Preparing video...
0:00 / 0:00

Double Edged | Rabbi Ari Kahn

225 views
OU Israel Shiurim avatar
OU Israel Shiurim

Transcript

Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.

is sponsored by Rabbi Michael and Jerry Laxmeter for the Fruchelemer. >> No. >> No? We changed it. What do we have now? So you have to send me the you have to send me the text now. >> Okay. >> They wrote it. They wrote it. Okay. Okay. Okay. Okay. Sorry. In loving memory of Jerry's parents, Shechter and Rabbi by Rabbi Michael and Jerry Laxmeter. So this is correct? >> Yes. >> It would be nice if they sent it to me. [cough] Okay. Over the years I've been pretty consistent in Parsha Toldot, which means yeah, I keep on saying the same things. Although that's not completely that's not completely fair. What I noticed is that there was a particular approach which I I know okay, a particular topic which I'd noticed having again, I don't want to be too forthcoming right now so that we can understand what it is. There is a particular issue which I'd noticed and then there was a second issue which I had noticed and I dealt with each one of those independently. And it occurred to me at some point, I don't know, this week that no, those are not necessarily independent issues and we really need to look at them together. The second thing is at some point along the way we're going to kind of float from an attempt to understand Pshat to something else. I I I don't know what that something else is. I don't know if we should call it Remez or call it Midrash or call it Kabbalistic or Machshava. But it's so ingrained over here because of these multiple applications that I I hesitate simply to push it aside as a completely secondary consideration. So with that completely unclear introduction, let us let us begin. >> [snorts] >> So we will ignore the superfluous uh aspects over there. One thing which I warn you throughout this week's parsha is the dual statements and the asymmetry of those dual statements. Which means they sound like we're saying the same thing, but we're not. Just compare the presentation of Abraham and Yitzhak and then the presentation of Betuel and Rivka, you'll see that they're not equal. I mean just for example, Lavan is thrown into it, right? That's not true on the other side. The the the double So why is that being mentioned over here? The second thing and by the way, the other thing that you need to be careful about the lack of symmetry or the asymmetry of the information is that Rashi notices this and then he kind of convinces you that it's not there. So if you know Rashi, I'll just give you a simple example. We, okay, assuming that we know Chumash and Rashi I don't know if I ever told you this. I learned Chumash and Rashi fairly well in high school. We were responsible. We had a test on Sunday morning to this part and then like till Shani the first year, till like Shlishi the second year, till Revi the the next year until at the end of I think the next so like I I became familiar with it. When I was around 19 I decided to learn I decided to learn and and just to pay attention, what did the Torah actually say? Because we're we're we're it's so ingrained in in us that we don't see things. So again, just for example, we all have this image of this childless couple, Rivka and Yitzhak. And we have this image of the two of them praying, right? She's on one side of the room, he's on the other side of the room. God answers him because he's a tzadik ben tzadik. God doesn't answer her. You know, all that is very nice except for one problem. She doesn't pray. It's again, that's the asymmetry. So rather than identify the asymmetry, we make believe that it's not there. So if you read the next pasuk, she doesn't pray. So again, you can insist that she does. You can say that Rashi says that she does, but I'm going to say it again. Rashi is solving a problem because he's making believe that it is symmetrical. By the way, that Sorry, God responds to him. She will pray to God very very soon. And Rashi is going to complicate that as well. And she then says By the way, that that sounds like desperation. On the one hand, we can say that when somebody is suffering from infertility, the Gemara goes so far as to say that someone without children is if they're dead, which is really a very very strong statement, but now that she's pregnant, she says which is an unclear articulation. I think she says a very similar thing later on in the parsha. Do you know where? >> Go to the counselor. >> Yeah. If you look at the very end of source number three, the last pasuk So I wonder if that is in fact similar to this what it should say here So by the way is stronger like my life. And again, it's interesting because again, the the child the child is being childless itself has its problems. Her pregnancy presents another problem. And why is she going so extreme over here? That isn't I'm saying like why why am I even alive? And and again, why am I interpreting that way? Because of the other usage, which is She's so lucky your wife isn't here, right? [laughter] And Rivka is a quite interesting individual. But but but it's stronger than that because the very next thing it says Sorry, sorry, sorry. And I would I I don't think means movement in terms of distance. She turns to pray to God, which is really interesting. Should we should we unpack this a little more? >> Yes. >> Not her. It didn't say she prayed. >> Let's let let let's unpack this a little more. If it says that she is that means that she cannot have children. She does not pray for the impossible cuz she can't have children. I don't know physiologically what her situation is. I am not trained to understand what the situation is. But there are articulations like that among various rabbinic sources going back akara. That's it. Doesn't have a womb. Doesn't She can't She can't have children. So she doesn't pray for the impossible. But let's As I said, let's unpack this a little bit. Yitzchak has the ability of praying for the impossible because he's an impossible child. Not not impossible in the way that sometimes we say that's an impossible child. But he is a child of a mother who could not have children. So therefore, Yitzchak can pray for the impossible because he is the evidence of this. And she is on the other hand saying, how can you pray for such a thing? So I'm just saying is that their own personal perspectives may be a little different. but this does not necessarily indicate a lack of God consciousness on her part, because now immediately what do we find? And again, this is the the symmetry within the asymmetrical. And that is before only he prayed, but now she does pray. And he doesn't, by the way. Now she prays and says and she then reaches out to seek God. And then And God speaks to her. Even though again Rashi is going to somehow change that, which is as I said far less interesting to me right now. The words themselves That's what I'm going to That's why you say it just keeps on happening within this section of this The There is a duality, but then there is this lack of absolute duality and there's this always this interesting twist. And just pay attention as you read it because each one of these tells us something. Um the other is going to be that when she gives birth, they are in fact twins. When Esau comes out, it says I don't know if any of you printed in color, but but I Okay. I did I You know what? I forgot I did that. My My My printer's not color. What? Yeah. But But the color is very good here. All right. We put in color in red. Notice both parents call him Esau. And And And he calls his name Jacob. So I'm going to say It It's like almost every single turn there's going to be something which looks like it's symmetrical, but it's not. And every one of these things needs to be unpacked, it needs to be understood but understood, but that's not what we're doing today. I'm just giving you the building blocks and the pieces that you need to understand. But as I said, I'm much more focused on a particular point. So who are troubled by So are they still or are they no longer So leave that. And and some of you may have heard me speak about before. Okay, by the way, the other thing which is asymmetrical here, we're told how old was. How old was Rivka? We don't know. If you know Rashi, so Rivka Rivka is 3 years old, which which I hope at least some of you realize is somewhat difficult, but I'll explain it. I'll explain it. The the searching out for the bride is a replay of the [clears throat] And the Leave your house, leave your birthplace, leave your father's house. And according to Chazal, Abraham has his first awakening at the age of three. So it now and Abraham is full of Rivka becomes the Abraham [clears throat] what do you want to call it? The again, interesting inverse because she is replacing but she's much more like Abraham and she has the same the same experience. So therefore, to suggest that she's 3 years old and I'm going to I'm going to again just to be clear, the suggestion that she's really three is based on that immediately after the Abraham is told about her birth, but he's also told the birth of her mother. So no one's going to say, oh, her mother was also born right then and therefore lots of years go by, but it somehow juxtaposes the with his birth, but we don't know how old which is my stronger point. How is he described at the as a How is she described during the whole scene as a So how in the world are you going to tell me that in one case is describing a year old and in another case is a 3 year old and that that's the point which doesn't really work. So let's admit something. The Torah never tells us anything about Rifka's age. We don't know how old she is when the Eved meets her. We don't know how old she is when they get married. We know that 20 years go by of infertility and you know what? If you're infertile between 3 and 13 it's probably not such a yeah. That much I do know. I said I don't know that that much. But the 20 it's also very tender that Yitzchak is there praying for the impossible in front of his wife and and the Yitzchak the sorry the Yaakov scene where Rachel says why don't you pray for me? You have to hear this scene as well to see you know how that scene is being played out. And I would rather say that in both cases means around the same thing. I'm just going to throw out a number. I'll say 15. I'll say Yitzchak is 15 you can ask me why I picked 15 and the answer is By the way this next scene that we're going to have according to Chazal is when when he's making anybody can be making this week for you going to make it? I mean as far as I goes make ribs and for obvious reasons. I I was thinking about the I I like with the beets that's really red much more than Anyway we have to we have to think about this. So in that scene according to Chazal right? It's the day that Avram Avinu died. That's why he's making something which is reminiscent of mourning. That's what Chazal say. So if you do the math, it's very simple. Avram dies at 175, which means Yitzhak is 75. Their He's 60 when they're born, which means they're 15. So, therefore, I have and they're 15 years old, so I'm very comfortable saying that she was 15 years old, he was 15 years old by the she's 15 years old when the Eved finds her, and therefore she goes from the age of 15 till 35 without having children. So, that that that again makes a little bit more sense just in terms of the narrative. And if anybody tries to insist, no, she's 3 years old and that's It it is so far from that and and it it stretches. It Okay. By the way By the way, if I did have to justify a little bit, a little bit, even into the 20th century, you have cases of people getting married in extremely young age, including famous cases, Rav Kapach and his wife, right? One of the few couples that both won the Him for his Torah, her for her One [snorts] of the great things that we did, and I won't say somebody is a parent, was that my daughter in preparation for her Bat Mitzvah volunteered and did some with Rav and that was you know, really really something which was impactful. And I think she was 9 years old when they got married and there was a problem with with him being drafted and only married people couldn't and married a cousin, distant cousin, exactly. But And And she told it. She was We weren't intimate till many many years later till it was appropriate. But people did get married, but it doesn't mean complete marriage. So, slow down and you're the property claims because again, there may be certain cultural issues that maybe we're not we're not sensitive to. So, let's let's let's leave it at that, but you already heard that I am sympathetic, so let's continue. It's not just I'm sympathetic. I I I I think I exploded it, so I think I think what I suggested is much more reasonable. So, what we up to? So now, the 15. So now make up your mind, which one is it? So, this is one of the things that we're going to focus on, the which means what exactly is or who exactly is Esau? So, I think the first element that he is a hunter gets a little bit more credit than he is a hunter. What is the duality? What is the repetition? He is is is it two ways of saying the same thing or these two different things? The two different things, then what do they mean? But I'm going to point out again, he is so he only has one on the Jacob side. So, once again, we have another example where everything sounds like, right? That there's a facade here that everything sounds like. It's saying two sides of the same thing and every single one of them are not. Every single one of them is like this slight element that makes a difference. And and and do I have to keep on repeating this? Those differences are the things that we should be paying attention to. And then again, what is the meaning of these two sides? And then the question is how much ahead of ourselves we should get right now. The the thing which is most disturbing, so we ended up spending the time on that is Isaac loves Esau because he provides him with food. That's what it sounds like. for no reason given. So, I'm going to say it again. Lack of symmetry, almost the same thing, but not. So, when you realize this, you're going to notice it's every single verse. We're having something which sounds like it's the same, but it's not the same. And because it's not the same, then you have to start asking yourself, so so what in the world is going on over here? Because it is trying to lead us to this point of it sounds, but But it's not. And the thing which always dominates everything else, which I'm not going to go to, is to try to understand why is it that Yitzchak loves Esau? But he doesn't love Esau. He loves Esau whatever that means. We don't We're not as troubled why Rivka loves Jacob, although we are somewhat troubled. Is this because of the prophecy that she receives? Is this self-fulfilling prophecy? You know, I don't know how many of you I've asked this question many times to many to many different groups. If you're the kind of people who want to read the end of a book before you start a book, you want to know which one of your kids is going to be successful, to know which one to be nice to. I mean, is that Is that really By the way, this is one of the reasons that prophecy is sometimes called It's a burden. It's a burden to know too much. I don't I don't know if you've ever felt that way where you just hear too much about something and it becomes a burden. You don't want to know all of this. You You just don't want all of that information. And over here, we do have to question this. Okay. [snorts] And then we have this whole scene with selling of the which Esau doesn't want anyway. Again, we have We have another Again, those of you who have read on your sources see another example of red over here regarding It's regarding him and then regarding the food and And we're not exactly sure and he's called He's also called So, that perhaps we'll try to get back to. But what was it the one thing that I've raised so far that I have not engaged at all? And that is the double description of Esau as both [clears throat] So, let's pause that for a moment and we're just going to leave it as a uh question. In a of verses later, we do note that it says Esau comes from the and that's surprising cuz it should have been It should have been Right? So what is the over here? And and over here there's all kinds of that fill in this space. Okay. I I put in source number two and then I questioned myself multiple times why I did it. So I'll just say this that Esau, again, you want symmetrical asymmetrical, he's just like his father. He's 40 years old, he gets married. And he gets married. So therefore we have this repetition and you know, Esau honors his parents. It's not true, but he honors his parents, at least we think so. And but it says So he does a double compounded problem. One is if you remember a little bit about and the insistence of Abraham not to marry somebody local, he goes marries two local girls. The other thing about marrying two people is that essentially it's sexist. I hope you understand that because it sees women in terms of utility, not in terms of going back to early Right? This is I mean that that that is not a a wonderful description. when it talks about the first person who did this, which was And it says that married two women, one to bring children, but one to be this this young attractive woman on his arms and uh therefore he saw each one in terms of utility. One is to take out, and the other one is to stay home. So when in my cynical days I used to say that we don't do that anymore today. Today we do it sequentially, not at the same time, right? Rav Breuer, whom my wife studied with for many years, he he he uh he used to speak about this, about somebody who leaves the you would quote the verse, leaves the wife of his youth, and he thought it was the most terrible thing uh imaginable, that there is a covenant between people and the crying and so on and so forth. But you realize the superficiality of Esau. Again, he looks like he's completely developed. He has the hair. He's born that way. But he does just like his father. And a later stage we're told that he realizes that his uh that his parents don't Sorry. That his father doesn't like this. He doesn't care about his mother. And then it says instead of getting rid of them and changing, it says then he takes a third wife. So he takes a third Now again utility. So when he goes visits his dad, now he has a wife that that's okay for him. So again it goes back to this, you know, really strange looking at the world. Okay. In source number three we move over to again this dramatic scene. It is what Yitzchak is older. We don't know how old. His eyesight is going or gone. He calls Esau. Notice he doesn't call him my He calls him He's described as Whether he is still a or not is interesting. And he says I don't know when I'm going to die. By the way, if you go back to Again, we may have heard that in Rivka before, but if you go back to Esau, who is a young man at that point when he asks for the food, just you know let your eyes wander to the previous source where it says in I'm going to die. What do you mean you're going to die? You're you're you're a young man. Again, read into this that this day that Avram died and essentially he becomes a nihilist at this point. He just gives up and everyone's going to die. What difference does anything make? Why bother being moral? And it's Avram's death that sets him off on his downward spiral. Yitzchak says go bring back in source three go get your your bow and arrow. So again, I want to stress the So what is this doing here? And and the simple point would be is this somehow connected to Esav or is this a different So now let me just pause here for a moment and remind you of of something else and then we'll try to put this together as much as we can. If you look at for a moment at source number eight sorry, if you look yeah, in source number eight, but at the very end of source number eight that's the long dating scene. It says and Yitzchak goes out to pray in a field. So Yitzchak is connected to a I think more so than we sometimes realize. The other part of this that we kind of skip over because the the things about Yaakov and Esav are so much more interesting, but in source number nine Again, is plants this is working in the field. The cynics again will say this is the last time that someone worked in but right and so on. So so Yitzchak is a man of the field. Yitzchak is involved in in agriculture. >> In source 13 the Gamara says Avram is described as a mountain So he has his revelation up on a mountain And Yitzhak is known as a which means there's something about which is both Yitzhak's vocation and his revelation It's where he prays It's where he comes back from the field There's also something which which again I don't know if you ever noted this if you go back again and look at that verse again we are in source number eight So this is where Hazal understand that Yitzhak he's the one who institutionalizes Minha Now he was not the first one to pray this time of day Who did before him So the same chapter In [snorts] source number eight from the beginning now The gets to this hometown of Rivka He gets there in the evening and then he says Before the sun even sets make sure this happened Then what happens And then he looks up And then he looks up before he finishes speaking But now you notice Yitzhak goes to to pray It's it is just a complete parallel situation and I would suggest that the who is on a mission from Abraham, but the mission is for Yitzhak. He therefore channels some of Yitzhak's spiritual identity and I'm going to daven for Yitzhak for a shidduch. I need to take Yitzhak's spirituality and he prays at the time that Yitzhak would pray, but as I said, both the prayer and the response seems to be incredibly similar in this description. So I never noticed that before this year either. So and now you say hold it, that's that's like like yeah. Okay. [snorts] So Yitzhak's identity. So can I now say what I was saying in the first two minutes of the introduction? It's Esau's identity is wrapped up in this sadeh and Yitzhak's identity is wrapped up in this sadeh and are we essentially dealing with two completely separate phenomena or is there some connection or they at least concentric concentric circles? Is there overlap between the two or what is the dynamic? So so that really becomes the the question. If we now return back to source number three because he tells him to go to the field. So another point which we've said many times is that if Esau does honor his father, it's because his father tells him to do something that he likes to do. I mean Yitzhak is the is the genius here because Yitzhak tells his son who's a hunter go and hunt for me. So he just turned the hunt into a mitzvah. Hunting is generally not a mitzvah, but when your father asks you to hunt, so I'm saying that itself is really interesting and we do have to wonder now because Yitzhak's spiritual identity and I I keep coming I'm going to keep coming back to this now is connected to the field. So what does he say to him? So when we read earlier that he's an over here that is echoed by this verse where Yitzchak tells him to go to the sadeh and to go to hunt. And now I think you understand my my question because with Yitzchak we see it very clearly. Yitzchak works in the sadeh, plants in the sadeh, he prays in the sadeh. Esau hunts in the sadeh. Now that's not the same. When you think about Esau you think about death. You think about Yitzchak you think about life. Right? Things that are growing. There there is an enormous difference between the two and I think that's one of the reasons that our minds never let us wander to that point and say hold it. Why is there sadeh prominent in both of these descriptions but nonetheless it's not only the sadeh was prominent. It's it's that both elements are standing at us. It's the it is the tzayid together with the sadeh and that's and that's essentially exactly what it is that Yitzchak is asking for. Um he then tells him to bring all these things and I'll bless you before I die. And and by the way the other thing is that death is all over here as well. I'm going to die, right? Rivka articulates this, Esau articulates. By the way the only one who doesn't is Yaakov. He's the only one over here. So you say that she's a drama king. They're all they're they're all involved in the same drama but and I'll say it again except for Yaakov. Yaakov does not articulate that. And Rivka overhears this and she tells it over and blesses before he dies and so on and so forth. My son listen and she says and he says bring two goats. And do you all understand now where we just now went with the bringing of the two goats? So so we're going to enter into the world of midrash now but I don't know I don't know how much it's midrash and how much it's a biblical narrative which then feeds a later reality. Yom Kippur, the service is going to be to take two goats. The two goats, by the way, should look very similar. The mission tells us they should look almost the same. And the way that some articulate this, they should be twins. Twins is very interesting in this particular context. Which Pirkei Lezer spells it out and says one represents the world of Jacob and one represents the world of Esau. And Esau is called So therefore, but which one is it? That's the one which is the right? What's So is hell. So I'm going to ask you again, is this a total rabbinic imagination or does this become the prototypical scene whereby Yom Kippur is going to be born from this scene? Now, what I'm saying is not simple. What I'm saying is perhaps even a little bit daring. And the thing which is daring about it is is again, you know I do this time after time. I convince myself that something completely imaginable or unimaginable or totally his imagination is actually in the text and is our wonderful elusive word because none of us know what So the two are really interesting. If we continue this, there's another element. Again, Yitzhak had commanded Esau and therefore turned the hunting into the mitzvah. On the other hand, the word that Rivka uses is listen to my command. There's also the word used over there. So now he is commanded to do what she had said to do. And then this is our impossible dynamic of this family, which is obviously completely dysfunctional and there's a lack of communication. But and and he's afraid. [snorts] So, as we continue in there is another element added to this and that is that his fears that even though they may look alike, they may look more like than we ever imagined, but nonetheless, there's a difference. Again, there is this asymmetrical between the twins and he says, but he is hairy and I'm not. Again, and the twins which again the difference is interesting. And now we have one more element to add into our mix and that is the clothing. Okay. When he comes in and and again we're not going to play out right now these other elements. Does Yitzchak know who it is? Does he not know who it is? He know it's his son. He doesn't know which one of his son is his. He may have his suspicions. Um it does not sound like he thinks it's Esau. But I'm not going to go step by step over here. I'm just going to tell you read read it carefully. But then something else gets introduced. And after the course examination, he says most likely it is not a reflection of the tone of voice which is used, but rather the content of what was said because when he arrives, Yitzchak asks him, how did you get here so quickly? Your God helped me. Esau does not ever speak about God. Jacob speaks about God. And therefore, by the way, there's two possibilities at this point. One possibility is that Esau found God, which by the way, I I believe that Yitzchak would be overjoyed. Remember, the field that he sends him to is a field that Yitzchak prays in. And now he sends him to a field, and if he in fact found God in that field, and therefore he accomplished what he needed to accomplish very quickly, and he had bracha in the field, and I'll say it again, Yitzchak prays in the field and has divine response in the field. So if Esau now has divine response, therefore God is there. But there's still two possibilities. One possibility is that Yitzchak has now succeeded by bringing God into Esau's mouth and perhaps mind and heart and life. And the other possibility is that it's Jacob dressed up as Esau. Okay? Which itself is really interesting, but both possibilities have to be going through his mind because he just keeps on questioning. Even after he says it says He still asks him. And he won't answer directly. I am. But but that that's I mean, you you realize that Yitzchak is not as convinced as I think maybe you think. Again, bring the goats over here. By the way, he brings him wine also. So now the clothing which kind of God introduced as a side point along the way just now got introduced on another level. And it's at this point we're not sure what this is. So one thing that just happened is there's blessing. There's blessing in the field, and the blessing in the field is somehow reflected by the clothing. So it's at this point we have our goat and we have the clothing and we have the field and and that's what I'm going to keep asking you. So this blessed field, what is taking place? It's not just it's not a subtext. That that's really what I wanted to say. It's not a subtext. It's the text. It's what's taking place here. It's the text in terms of who Esau is and it's the text in terms of who Yitzchak is. And and we still don't know exactly as of this point how we're supposed to nuance all of this or how we're supposed to unpack it. But I'm just that's what I was trying to say is that there is a reflection between the Yitzchak life and the Esau life. And now we know that it's staring at us and now we have to understand this a little bit better. I I do want to note the pasuk we just now read, right? Is pasuk was it pasuk Yes. Okay, this is where the blessing comes out from. Okay? If you look at source 17, but I'm going to spare you, look at source 18 instead because it's the same source in Hebrew rather than Aramaic. It's the Targum Yonatan on the pasuk. So he just now said what maybe you were thinking, maybe it occurred to you. He just now said, do you know what he's doing? He's smelling something. What is he smelling? He's smelling the Which means if we're already talking about Yom Kippur, we've been missing one thing in the on Yom Kippur. And what's that? That when the Kohen Gadol goes into he goes into the inner sanctum, he takes with him the and the then Torah is something which smells. And that again, that's the magical thing which brings about the forgiveness of the Jewish people. It is the Yes, you have this and now you start to realize that that hold a second. Whoever said the may perhaps somehow connected to Yom Kippur and this this scene of going into to Yitzhak is somehow analogous to what's going to happen later on in the future when are going to go into By the way, that itself is fascinating because instead of God saying, well, that was a bad thing to do, Rivka was wrong. By the way, Targum Onkelos says when he says, oh, God, you know, I'm going to get cursed, and she says, she responds, no, I was told prophetically that this is what you need to do. So she's speaking from her Again, is the same prophecy from all the in the beginning is it a second prophecy? But again, I could have said that Jacob does something wrong and if he did something wrong, then how in the world does him doing something wrong somehow down the line get turned into the of Yom Kippur? And again, this is what I was saying that I was difficulty with. Am I imagining? Is Is Is this a question of total Midrash or total Remez or something which isn't there? But the point is it's the and the point is, okay, you got the two goats. So the two goats is suggestive. And then you have the clothing. Shall I remind you of something? When the goes in, he got the big day he has to put on particular clothing in order to walk in. But these clothing is clothing. Again, this is where this disconnect is still happening. And nonetheless, then you have the and then you get the blessing. Which means he smells it and then he blesses him. The blessing is from the And now you have this whole thing unpacked by the Targum Yonatan by saying, yeah, this is not that it will be. This is the of the going into the And it's at this point that you look and say, okay, so so essentially, how did how did we get here? You know how we got here. I I don't know if you can repeat everything I said, but you you you saw exactly how we got here. And the starting point truly was the So, let's try one more time. He then gives him a blessing And notice that the whole blessing has to do with from the field. It's things from the field. The other thing is is interesting. Um when Esau comes in, he says Who are you? Now, that's not necessarily really true. Because if he sold And let's remember something. According to at least some articulations of The idea of being the was who's going to be the And then the irony is that Esau, who doesn't mind killing, gets all kinds of queasy when it comes to killing animals to serve God with those animals. That's something he's not interested in. He's not interested in bringing a He's not interested and Jacob takes that responsibility instead. But nonetheless, here he describes himself I I am Again, I would have I would argue that when Jacob says I am and if if if you would have questioned how can you say that you're Jacob, he goes, but I purchased it. I took that responsibility. Esau was not interested, which means who really is the who can make the claim of being the And again, if now you ask me, how did I get to Well, that's what's going on over here. So, who's the one who's going to get that blessing and and he is absolutely shook from this. And he says no. He's blessed and he'll remain blessed. And afterwards, he questions Esau questions is that the only that you have? And he gives him another and he says to him, I blessed the field for him. One second. And he offers him that you will live and maybe die by the sword. Which goes back to Esau in the field uses a sword, uses a knife, uses a bow and arrow, and is involved in death. Yitzchak in the field is involved in life. But there's this other aspect of of the two. I I think that we'll skip four, which is but it's actually he's citing a which is source number five. He [snorts] was frightened twice. One time when he was lying on top of right? Again, with a scene, with a sword and near death. And one when Esau went in. You don't know which one is more intense. That means that that Yitzchak is more frightened right now when Esau came in than he was laying on the altar. But the other thing which is really interesting is the juxtaposition between those two events. One is the One is the place that the is going to go in and do the And the other one is this What do you want to call it? This this preparation for the the foundation of the But nonetheless, again, I'm going to keep on saying this, there's something which is interesting. I mean, the other thing, if you look at source number six, this is and I remember is the life now of of Esau who brings death. When the sword of Abraham comes down to the neck of Yitzchak his soul kind of left him. He came back to life. Then he stood up and it says I want to read the second version in verse seven. Isaac understood this is how one day take place. He experienced By the way, the reason why this is interesting is because the first of the is The second one is connected to The other thing that you may or may not know is that we noticed the word a couple of times here. The word is connected to Okay, if you didn't know that, I have to at least give you one source that says this. Look at source number 24. So much so that when is always found connected either midrashically or more And even when we say in the second That sentence goes together. By the way, it's interesting there's a whole whether it's the middle of the sentence or the end of the sentence. There's no It's with a It's the end of the sentence. It's It's not Okay. Isaac the one who represents but by the way, this goes right back to the idea of him being a farmer. Essentially, a farmer is takes something which is dead, puts it in the ground, and it comes back to life. Which means Isaac's spiritual identity is all wrapped up with thinking things coming back to life. And therefore, Isaac's identity is based his which you can say starts up on the mountain. He comes back to life, and now he goes to the field and things come back to life. And Isaac is a field. He's connected to the field. He prays in the field. He's answered in the field. On the other hand, Esau goes to the field, and he's not involved in bringing things back to life. He's involved in bringing things to death. So now we have to work a little bit harder and to ask ourselves, so what is Isaac trying to do? Isaac is somehow trying to fix I don't know, you use the word or use a different word. He's trying to do something with Esau. Again, first of all, he turns the hunting into a which itself is interesting because he turns something which is a total death experience into something which can bring life, right? Somebody who does it says But but but nonetheless, Esau is somebody who's connected to death. So let's again see how much further we can get with with some of this and Rashi says in source 19, and I think we remember or understand part of this. We're going to have to try to get to two parts of it. Same verse, the smell. The smell of goats is terrible, right? It's terrible. But somehow came in with him. So what is the that was blessed by God? So a couple of things. So the first question is is what is a That's the first question. I I remember hearing all kinds of people tell me that there's no that there's there were apples by the way in the Middle East. If anybody's interested, I I checked up on this I was trying to figure out why we not only that, I want to know who was the first person who ate a and why they chose a There is a very strong rabbinic undertone that is a citrus and that specifically But there were apples in the Middle East, but those apples were probably much smaller and they were probably much more like crab apples and they probably weren't as exciting to eat. One of the things that is just interesting in terms of eating an apple in anybody interested, I can send you something on this is that by the same time that we started eating apples was also the same time that in Christian art they started to depict the apple as the fruit that was eaten in the Garden of Eden. According to one of the candidates for the fruit was an So hold it. Hold on to that for a second. It could be a little bit, no pun intended, cross pollination of ideas that if there is this recognition that the fruit which was used was an apple, let's on take an apple and turn it into life because that was something which had caused quote unquote an original sin. As I said, there's something interesting about the apple being used as part of one of the The idea of is mentioned in the but the apple is only mentioned during the time of the Okay? So now let let me try this again. So what is this So essentially the claim is going to be that this is the because again, that's what understand this is being. And [clears throat] and means that somehow this clothing is not what we think it is. Now, those of you, I'm not going to >> Say that again. >> Okay. I'm going to I'm going to It's not what you think it is. Those of you who remember, there's a Gemara and there's Midrashim and various commentary cite this that the clothing that Esau had was clothing that he stole. He He He killed the Nimrod and he got Nimrod's clothing. Nimrod had taken it because he had killed someone else and then he stole it, which means this clothing according to Chazal is the clothing of Adam HaRishon. Now, can we recognize something? [snorts] I'm not sure exactly how uh how we we're going to phrase this. The word clothing, especially with the use of the word beged, is reminiscent of the word begida, which means that there's some kind of a uh rebellion taking place, which is why is Adam wearing clothing? And the answer is because he sinned. And now what they're telling us is that this clothing actually had the smell of Gan Eden and the fruit of Gan Eden, but that 's the sin. So now I have to try harder again. If somehow And I And again, this is all, you know, midrashic undertone, if the clothing that Esau has is the clothing which he stole and it's all involved sin and and he involves death and Yitzchak wants to somehow take this and use this for the avodah. By the way, our idea use avodah could be for Yom Kippur, but Yaakov is exempt doing it. By the way, Yaakov may or may not be guilty right now. Yaakov he also needs some kind of uh He He's wearing clothing which isn't his. By the way, Adam attainment of the clothing is also based upon problematic situation where he ate where he stole something which wasn't his, right? And that's And that's the fruit. So let's just put it like this. Some of you remember that I've citing many many times the who tells us that in the of the Garden of Eden, every single every single sense was involved in the sin. She hears the words of the she sees the tree, she touches the tree, she eats the tree. The one sense which is not mentioned is the sense of smell. So essentially from the place that was never corrupted is how healing takes place and therefore the becomes the thing which can bring about some real interesting healing. Now all of that's interesting when we go back to the scene over here where he insists let me smell the the big and again, the word it it has to be stronger than we reckon it. Big the big the rebellion which has taken place which means is it only who needs something to be fixed or perhaps throughout the generations will need things to be fixed as well. I'm I'm going to either fortunately or unfortunately have to wind up today because I I think I've already showed you all the elements. I I didn't dot every eye or cross every t or tie everything with a very pretty bow but what we take away from all of this is that again, at least according to the this will be good for you and be good for your descendants. Why? The two goats are something which you're going to need to do. Why? Because we are sometimes involved in sin as well which means when walks in, it's the smell of hell. When walks in, it's a smell of Now whenever we have heard this prior to today, we've always think the smell of that's great. But what's the smell of Oh, it's the smell of the What's the That's the tree. How do they get the tree? They stole from that tree which means that's the sin that took place using the And and where is the smell? Now the smell is on the clothing, but why do they have clothing? The clothes they're real as are naked. Real as are naked because they ate from the tree which means that both the tree, the the fruit and the smell are representing something which is really interesting because this is part of where is going to bless which means represents coming back to life. represents What is if not is using his spiritual power and he is trying to connect it to field. Can bless from the field or not? Jacob does. Jacob can't say the word of God at any point over here. He can't speak in that way. He does do what his father asked to do. He does bring the hunt but the blessing is not there. The the by the way he's lost. The smell isn't there and all that you have is right you want to say over here Don't you realize that these are two expressions of the same thing. So I'm going to say this one more time. I left you by the way a lot more sources over here. Esau is somebody who's involved in death. is involved in coming back to life. Jacob was described as an It's already been noted and you can look on the pages here if you want to see some people who say it. The is the inverse of mate. Jacob is somebody who does inherit from his father the ability to come back to life. Jacob is somebody who despite the disappointment of all the anti-Semites through history is that survive forever. We we we we are the eternal witnesses and God sent us to be those who will teach humanity for eternity and and again despite their disappointment of trying their best to get rid of us Esau has a dance with death and his dance of death takes place in the field. in the field brings things back to life. Esau tries to take Esau to that field. Esau it's a it's a field of death. Jacob is able to go and Jacob is able to go and to somehow bring the smell of Gan Eden which again more complex than we realized. The smell of the clothing more complex than we realized. All of this is connected. And again, we saw that All of this is ultimately connected to Yom Kippur, to the And what happens in Yom Kippur? People who may have had a bad year, people who may have been deserving of something worse. Two goats. They look like twins. One is Enter into the Holy of Holies, take that smell, take by the way, it works. Take a really bad smell, cover it up with something good, and somehow that brings about forgiveness for the entire people, and that becomes the realm of Jacob. Jacob bought the which means to be the from Esau, and therefore Jacob ends up walking in in front of and performing as a on that day, and that's going to be inherited by his children later on.