Noach : Torah on the Internet and Teaching Torah to Non Jews

this Tower class is brought to you by torahanytime.com hey good evening everyone thank you everyone for coming I'd like to welcome all of our tour anytime viewers tonight's year is sponsored by a number of very generous individuals firstly by uh mishpachas um patakov and shaolov in memory of their grandmother that passed away yesterday Leia Luba bass this year and uh she should be a militia for home by Oran Shelley or if Stephen Weissman by robitsi liskar and by Rivera's agaya so we're moving for all of the sponsors they should be uh the bunchems should bless them with good health okay listen I want you to come I want you to go ahead and take save the world you have to save all of the animals but not all right not all animals are created equal right we know that not all animals are created equal so therefore Hashem tells her Nayak I want you to go to the kosher animals you take seven pairs of kosher animals and two non-cosher animals the plastic says so here's the question I was not supposed to know which animals are Kosher which animals are not cutting how's he supposed to know that's not like he had a Jewish grandmother I was not supposed to know which animals are cautious so Rashi immediately tells us Israel it means the animals that are destined to be kosher ah so what do we see from here La Magnus we learn from here that Naya learned Torah you know what else did he do in his spare time besides building the ark nothing Taya okay beautiful what's the problem the problem is and a guy is not allowed to learn Tyra in fact for a guy to learn tyrants considered such a severe prohibition that a guy who learns Tyra is actually high of Misa liable to the death penalty right you see a guy in the back of you know some room somewhere huddled up with the art scroll crisis yeah he's learning about what he is you know what he's respect what he's liable for he's kind of Misa the gamara tells us a guy that learns terrorist Hive me so how do we know because the Torah says commanded us to Tara has an inheritance it's our inheritance it's not there inheritance okay so the guy may not learn Cyrus the question is if a guy camera Tyra then they're more than zioners can still can't murder can't commit adultery and can learn that should be a new one right goyam can't go through the Duffy I mean says why don't we count it Sigma says we do count either if you're gonna say the reason why they can't learn a tire is because it's our inheritance and it's not their inheritance it's gazella it's stealing so if it's stealing gazella's ready on the list or if you want to read the plastic legumar tells us that one is not permitted to learn Torah in the presence of an alma RS why not because every Jew is considered married to the Torah is an arusa to the Torah so if you learn right so we're all married to the Torah if you learn the Tyra then you consummate the marriage right you're completing the deal so if you learn Tire on the presence of an MRS says it's like it's like living with somebody's engaging it's like living with someone's fiancee every Jew is engaged to the tire but if you don't actually learn it you've never consummated the marriage so therefore there are those who read the passage Tyra Siva Lano Maisha Myra noticed so the Torah is our wife so for a guy to learn Tyra you know what that's called it's called adultery it's called adultery so if you want to know why one of the why we don't count the guy learning cards it's counted a guy cannot commit adultery and included in adultery is Guy learning time right because it says and we know it doesn't say only kohanam could learn only the VM could learn only says Adam so the gamer says yeah a guy could learn tired but only the Tyra of the Zion so if a guy wants to spend like a whole year clearing you know you know with all the websham he's allowed to do that but that's right if he wants declare what exactly is Arias he could spend you know set we'll learn all the Yeshiva shatara and arayas or cursing Hashem if he wants to know what exactly it means to curse Hashem is it a voice curse is it a mice you know he could clear all the kakiras but when it comes to the rest of the Torah he is not allowed to learn that's the conclusion a guy that learns Tyra is high of Misa so what's the question so what was Nayak doing learning Tyra a guy that learns Tyra Isa okay so this is the question of what we call the super commentaries on Rashi right the super commentary is a commentary on a commentary Rashi is a commentary is a guy yeah he wasn't a Jew well you could either you're a guy you're a Jew it's one or the other you can't be in between right there's no such thing as a Jew right well abramovina was the first too so a knife came before avramovino I know it was a guy right now close the guy if knife would have kept Shabbos he would've been tired of Misa black was a good guy he may have been a tummin he may have been a Sadiq but he was uh he was a guy and if Nayak was a guy how was he allowed to learn to so this question is raised by the gorarie the mara the morale ass how can Rath learn Torah a guy that learns tyros kaiveness comes along the safer little voice one of the early acronym wrote a commentary on Rashi called The Voice now remember being being that his name was Mordecai his favorite Posse was um that's why he named all of his commentaries after that all of his commentaries come from that but he also has a commentary on Rashi called and he asks how is allowed to learn Torah he was a guy a guy that learns tairas it's a big problem so what's that it's not such a problem you know why because tomim what does it mean to be Tommy Tommy means you have no blemish and Arla a foreskin is a planet that means Nayak was born already gamelt he was already circumcised so since he was very circumcised he's already you know like gager so he can learn Tyra a little bit of a difficult answer I mean just because he's born circumcised he never converted there's nothing to convert to there's no Judaism I mean the reason a guy can't learn a tiger it doesn't matter if he has a Milo it doesn't have a meal but that's what the hero says and he says what are we gonna do with avrah mavino because we know avrah mavino learned Tyra before he had Amela and what are we going to do with Yeshiva Shiva Eva right there was a great Yeshiva called yeshu Hashem right it lasted for hundreds of years what did they do there they learned Zion Mitzvahs for 400 years I know some yeshivas they learned four blood above the seal holds the mind right but for 400 years I mean that's you know that's even slower I'm not gonna say that right but for 400 years they learned Zion miss this thing I asked I mean you want to have a cycle every year they learn a different one 400 years so therefore the bush Ira says you have to say there's some kind of side some kind of secret going on why they're able to learn Tyra but then he says those who understand understand and those who don't understand don't understand so I guess we're among those who don't understand right but he doesn't really give a full answer how these people were allowed to learn Tyler comes along to my route says what's the problem why is the guy not allowed to learn Tyra because either it's stealing or it's adultery why is it stealing because God gave us the Torah why is it adultery because we marry the Torah when did God give us the Torah when did we marry the Torah and arsena before the title was given it was an hour yerusha yet it wasn't our marriage partner yet and therefore says the morale there is no prohibition to learn for a guy to learn Tyra before the Tyra was given the thought of which doesn't like that because Allah says that when it comes to banae Nayak there is no difference between before the tarah was given an F do we say goyem are now at a kill only after the turret was given him before the time was given they're allowed to right if a guy curses Hashem he wasn't like because even before the time was given a guy that kept Shabbos was kind of me so even before the tire was given so why when it comes to learning Tyra would we say it was only prohibited for goyam to learn Tyra after the time was gone okay so what would we like to do is to try to explore a new possibility how Nayak was allowed to learn Tyra and uh maybe we'll explain everyone got the text today right the topic of this year was Torah on the internet right is that permitted are you allowed to make Torah accessible to gayam is that motor is that user is that permitted is that permitted so there are two independent questions is a guy allowed to learn Tyra and number two are you allowed to teach a guy okay so let's see the random if I would ask you at this point in this year what's the reason why you guys know how to learn Tyra would say because he's taking our our treasure he's taking our belong let's look at the Rama the ramam says a guy who on a Tuesday says I am serving my God by resting on Tuesday Misa so I mean certainly if he makes a whole festival out of that day he's kind of miso so religions that create a day of rest because they believe that God wants them to rest on that day not only are they not doing anything admirable they're actually incurring of Nissan okay why so we would say you know why you guys now learned Tyra what do we say because it's stealing the rambam injects a new rationale to the Smith so take a look at the Ramones here's the root of the matter here's the rule we don't allow goyam to innovate a new religion the lasso Smith and to do mitzvos on their own you know why not learned Tyra because they're inventing a new religion says there are only two religions in the world who knows what they are there's Judaism and the Noah kite religion that's it there's Judaism you want to be a Jew you have to keep all 630 missiles you want to be a non-jew you keep seven Mitzvahs but what do you want to do you want to be a non-jew and keep Southern missiles plus Shabbos or plus Torah that's called inventing a new religion can't invent a new religion so the random look what the problem is either be a righteous conversation accept all the missiles or keep your Tyra Villa Joseph or you keep Shabbos or you innovate anything in the religion we snack you yeah we smack you the ancient Isa we punish you um we let you know that you're high of Misa avalino but we won't kill you which is also something we have to discuss I don't understand either so what is around them say but we don't kill you I mean what does that mean but the random is giving us a tremendous insight into why we don't allow goyan to learn Torah Ramen doesn't say one word about if the guy learns tar he's stealing our possession the rambam says for a guy to learn Tyra he's innovating a new religion because if he's supposed to be keeping the seven midsos and he wants to add a new religious practice called learning Torah that's an innovation that's not allowed look at how lucky you had then the rambam says a guy that wants to perform a different message because he wants to get reward a minor noise we don't stop him what was that if a guy wants to keep a Mitzvah we tell him he's high of Misa and we smack him and we hit him and we punish him and then just says the exact opposite that if a guy wants to do a mitza yeah we don't stop him we don't stop him we just didn't have like a test we Whack Him we smack him we hit him we basically threaten we threaten we're gonna kill him and we just stopped short of not killing him and then what does he say no if a guy wants to do a Mitzvah no problem you know chill out let him do it how do I know they're at the mom contradicts himself says a guy that wants to learn Tyra what do we do we smack him we Whack Him and then says we don't stop him thank you too so comes along he's safer or avram bye rubber Brown gorowitz and the aura from says like this look at number nine for a minute said and he wants to advance a tremendous a very novel idea and remember from goreless wants to say that if a guy wants to learn Tyra because he thinks Hashem commanded him to learn Tyra foreign but what if a guy says I don't want to learn Tyra because I think Hashem commanded me I know God never commanded me to learn Tyra but if God commanded Jews to learn Tyra then obviously it's a worthwhile Endeavor obviously it's an admirable type of activity so I want to do it because I want to get reward for it but I don't want to be rewarded like someone who's obligated to learn Tyra I want to be rewarded like someone who's not obligated to learn Tyra says rabba from gorowitz in that situation it should be permitted for a guy to learn Tyra and that's the difference between a guy who wants to learn Tyra why because he feels that God commanded him to learn Tyra ah a guy who feels God commanded him to learn Torah he's innovating a new religion that's an Innovative religion God never commanded him to learn Terror a guy who wants to learn Tyra because God commanded him to learn Torah Isa but what if a guy says I know God never commanded me to learn Tara but I'm gonna learn anyway you know why because I think it's a worthwhile religious type of activity then we allow such a guy to learn time that's Allah that's the difference between Allah and halaka test we're talking about who want to learn Tyra because they think they're commanded that's innovating a new religion God never commanded guidance but what if a guy wants to learn Tyra because he thinks it's admirable he thinks he's going to be rewarded we'll let him do it so therefore we could say you know how Nayak was allowed to learn Tyra because he didn't learn because he thought he was commanded to live he learned because he thought it was a good idea um Nayak learned around them the roundabout seems to say that if a guy wants to do a Mitzvah in order to receive reward not because he's commanded we don't stop him that's where rubber from gorowitz learns the rambam which the mahilaski think he's making a mistake because that's clearly not what the round number saying because if you look carefully at the ram in the beginning of Allah the round arm starts off like this mitzvah the rambam says if a guy wants to learn do amitsa from the other midsos what are the other missiles what does he mean by that the other midsos he means besides learning Tyra and besides keeping Shabbos what if a guy wants to do one of the other Mitzvahs in the Tyra so then it depends if the guy says I'm gonna put on to fill in I'm gonna send the sukkah because I'm commanded too we don't let him if the guy says I'm gonna put on filling I'm gonna send this Hook off because I think it's a good thing to do even though I'm not commanded to that's where the random says he's allowed to do it but when it comes to Tyra when it comes to Shabbos even if the guy thinks that he's not commanded to do it but it's a good thing to do romance is very clearly he's high of Nisa no question about it the Ramba makes a distinction between Shabbos Torah and other missiles is talking about other missiles when it comes to other missiles if the guy does it because he thinks he's gonna get reward so then we don't stop him if he thinks he's commanded we do stop him is talking specifically about Torah when it comes to Tyra when it comes to Shabbos then we don't let a guy keep learn Tyro or keep Shadows under any circumstance even if he thinks he's not commanded we don't let him do that and rather he said this is not how I read the rambam the heart's Feast says very clearly if you look at number 13 you can look on your own the heart sees so it's very clear when the random says Sharma means besides Torah and besides Shabbos you know why because other mid slice you know they don't necessarily represent the special bonds we have between us and Hashem commanded us so if a guy says that he's commanded then he's a robber then he's stealing if he just says you know it's a good thing to do we're not going to stop him but Shabbos which is the ice between us and when it comes to Torah which is the bridge between Hashem and Israel it doesn't matter what the guy has in mind that he's commanded he's not commanded it would be prohibited for a guy to learn time I believe that's that's very clear what the rambam is saying not sure what from gorowitz is trying to uh be mahadish but nevertheless the random is very cool let's just go with the round number is saying this is a simple explanation of the random when it comes to Shabbos when it comes to Tyra a guy I don't care what he's thinking he could be thinking God commanded him to do it he could be thinking God didn't command him to do it if he thinks he is serving Hashem in any shape or form by learning Tara keeping Shadow by other missiles the random says that if the guy thinks that he's not abandoned but he wants to do it because it's a good thing to do we're not going to stop it so therefore we're still stuck how was Nayak allowed to learn Tyra so comes along Weinberg that attacked the three-day age three days was one of the uh very great contemporary play skin who was Innovative in providing certain Ways and Means for Jewish people in the modern era to deal with the challenges of society the Swedish gives us one opening to understand how we're going to learn Tyra and this is similar to what river ramgurus was saying but I think this fits into the round that much better again the rambam added what we call an editorial comment when the rambam brought down the ram man provided a rationale what's the rationale that if a guy is going to learn Tyra that's an Innovative religion right the random didn't have to say anything we would have understood on our own why it goes not a lot of time he's stealing the random says now for a guide to learn Tyra he's he's innovating a religion it doesn't matter if he thinks he was commanded it doesn't matter if he thinks even if he wasn't Commander if he thinks this is a noble religious activity even though he's not obligated to do it that's an innovation of religion be close for a guy to learn Tyra it is not a noble religious activity says the Swedish if the whole reason is because it's an innovation and religion what if you have a guy a guy he wants to learn gemara because he feels it's going to sharpen his mind it's intellectually stimulating he wants to learn about ancient Jewish civilization right recently um South Korea sent a delegation to a Yeshiva called Lakewood and they came in with their cameras and they took pictures how the students analyzed the gemara the shackle of the taiwi because they want to bring it back and put it into the curriculum in South Korea right because they also want to be smart like Jews right they so for the South Koreans to learn gemara because they feel it sharpens their mind not because they feel it's a noble religious activity they learn it for what rabiakov Weinberg calls he says they learn about talmudic jurisputans they learn about the ancient Aztec culture they learn about how the Incas built their I don't know what right that's part of a middle eastern culture so that's not a problem or they want to understand Jews better water it's permitted you know why because the rambam says the reason glaim are not allowed to learn Tyra is because it's Das it's an innovation in religion but if they're not trying to innovate anything in religion if it's merely intellectual gymnastics smarter ah so with this we could come and answer this is kasha okay look at number 10. number 10 um you can teach yeah you wanna you meet a guy in the street the guy is you know is in the RL the guy's a guy you know you know you're friendly with him you schmooze with him you say why aren't you calling my house on Monday nights we'll learn you know learn gamara together you can't do that you can't teach Tyrone how do we know the plastic says yeah comes Tyson Tyson says what do we need to remind me for remind me could have stayed home that day we need to remind me to tell me you can't he's tired of going I have a question for you is the guy allowed to eat every minute no I can't eat the right the living thing are you allowed to pass a a live animal to a guy if you know he's gonna eat it no why listen to Eva let's see okay no so you can cause a blind person to stumble you can't cause someone to sin so ask tices if a guy is not allowed to learn Torah anyway like the gamar says in Sanhedrin a guy that learns tairas hayamisa so of course you can't teach him Tyra you know why foreign could you give another a bottle of wine no no could you cause anyone are you allowed to tell someone Russian heart or something either so ask tices if any way a guy is not allowed to learn what do we need without me to teach me that you're not a teacher guy Tyler of course you can't teach a guy Tyra it's listening and says the Swedish but if a guy is permitted to learn Tyra out of intellectual curiosity so then not every instance is a guy not allowed to learn Torah some cases he's a lot of our entire comes without me and ravami says even in situations where a guy is allowed to learn Tyra you can't teach it to him so now it would come out of tremendous finish let's say you know the instituted a talmud class in college and it's uh in some place where there no yiddin in the class and they want to hire you know some Rabbi to give the course and you know he's comparing the salary that he gets in the Yeshiva to the salary he would get into college and he wants to take the job but the only thing is the gamar says he can't teach Tiger but what do you mean the three they said but if God is allowed to learn tight out of intellectual curiosity no no no no no he's allowed to learn but you can't teach a thing he wants to buy the article gemara and Harvard on it on his own no problem you can't be his rabbit under any circumstance so basically it comes out a guy can't learn Tyra the three days says that a God is learning time for intellectual stimulation May learn but you can't teach a thing okay you can't teach him the time so here's the question so how could anybody ever convert how could any guy ever convert right while he's a guy he's now to learn so who's going to teach him the time what yes internet who's going to teach it to him so comes along the bereshava was will be soccer bear Island Berg one of the earlier when he was born in 1550 he was a talmud of the lavish we mentioned the levo shoes and he was a ready of someone we mentioned the night of Shmi Ataris rabazaria Figo the binolita and the bear Shabba wants to know like this he looked through the entire and it's not brought down anywhere in Chicago you can't teach tairat he looked through the entire rambam the rambam does not say anywhere you can't teach Terraria why not so says the bear shadow you know why because we don't pass in like with Yami rabami's opinion was you can't teach Terror to guide him but obviously we don't agree with rabiyami how do we know we don't agree with aviani so he brings a few riots I'll tell you one of them says the bear Shava I'll bring you a riot from Shahs you're allowed to teacher now listen to what he says he sees class serving the eagle what does he do with the Lucas he breaks them what does Hashem say yeah did it on his own and God gave his huskama a guy who doesn't have a breastmila could he eat the carbon pesach no no he can't eat it right he's he's a mumma so if you can someone who's a Mumma can't even do one Mitzvah so certainly someone who's a mummer for the whole Tyra can't keep any of the midsole so now that I learn Tyra so the information and he broke it says asked Isis okay that's a beautiful why are we saying Masha acted on his own is not a independent logic it's a Torah logic this should be what Hashem wanted him to do why are we saying Masha acted on his own and Hashem gave him this should be called Maisha acted based on the will of Hashem says Tysons this is not a good combo crime there you know why because there's a special thing but when it comes to learning Tyra maybe a Mumma could learn Tyra says the darsheva if you could teach Torah to a Jew who's a mummar then you could teach Torah to a guy because they're all the same guy we're not making any distinctions between them and therefore if well if ptosis is coming out you could teach Kyra to a Israel mumar it must be you could teach Taira to a guy okay this Raya is not simple We're not gonna get into it but the beersheba's conclusion is even though the gemara says that you're now to teach Terror to a guy guess what we don't pass it like nakamara that Kamara is not a Libra we pass in you're allowed to teach territory so now the question we have to ask ourselves is do we poskin like the bear Sheva basheva says we don't pass because the random doesn't bring it down doesn't bring it down question is do we pass him like the bear shadow so comes along one of the great contemporary play skin the shaven halavi who's the Shaving our lady of the neighbor one of the great contemporary place that was alive today when the place and he receives the following question and the question was the question came to him from Lutheran where is that Switzerland and in Switzerland they were having all these uh conferences with rabbis and Priests where they were getting together to learn in this under the same uh auspices where they would learn from priests the Christian Theology and they would bring in rabbis to lecture about talmud to the Jews and and the Christians and they're asking robustner what does he have to say about this you know this Academy so first of all rev Wesner says like this besides the fact this is a tremendous little Hashem for Jews and goyam to learn together don't do that you want to learn it on your own you don't learn Tyra together with non-jews not not Prophets and we'll talk about that but he quotes he quotes from a safer cadmon by the name of hayasha mckendy okay then the downfall of Italian jury was because the great talmudic Scholars of Italy learned together with Valium says to shaved our lady anyone who knows anything about Jewish history will know the greatest obstacle the greatest Pitfall in our history is when we get together with to study together okay but says to shave it a lady the gamara tells us listen carefully sent two officials to learn Tyra that's what the gemara tells us and they learned the third time and tysus asks how are the allowed to teach them Torah but the gamara tells us and suicisis it must be that their lives were on the line it must be it was dangerous for their lives not to teach them it must be these officials came with guns and they said if you don't teach us we're gonna put a bullet through your head that's how they taught them Tyra so what do you see from this Isis that what if goem come and say teach us Torah let's make peace and Harmony are you allowed to teach them no what does the game say it will be good for public relations I know how to teach them it's Usher the only Hector to teach gaim Tyra is what if they're gonna kill you but if they're not gonna kill you you're not allowed to some Tyra and the martial says we see from here hello maisa it is prohibited to teach I the Beersheba says we don't pass in that way says the Shiva Levy we don't pass disagree with him there's not even one place sake that agrees with the barishana and therefore hello one may not teach a guy Torah and we pointed out even in situations where the guy is allowed to learn himself because he's intellectually stimulated and he's challenged and he wants to sharpen his mind and you know Sunday he does the jigsaw puzzle Monday does you know trivia and Tuesday he doesra you can't teach him you can't teach him foreign yeah you don't have to give up your life not to teach him but you're now how to teach him the bear Shadow we don't hold like the bear shadow ah we just skip for a moment the rabbitsby Hoffman brings down that the saferno or the value of one of the great recent him learn together with goyam and by the way this is the classic argument why can't I do this didn't the rom-bomb do this right didn't the ramban right people like to invoke things that good island did right 1500 years a thousand years ago first of all so as adults you have and the fact that the sparno Learned Tyra together with guardians he did it to save Claudius round and then he says and the other Godzilla of his era screened out that he was wrong so was he allowed to do it of course he was much greater than we are we can't investigate and challenge what he did but that does mean we're allowed to do that you can't learn Taira in company okay so here's the problem if you can teach a guy Tyra so how is a guy gonna ever convert who's going to teach him who's going to teach him a guy who learned Shas because he was intellectually stimulated but he's still I mean who's going to teach him so we have a famous Commandments after Shabbos tells us about a guy he was uh passing by and he overheard that a Korean the the eighth garments of the kalingada right the special hat the Haisha and the a fight the male and he says who gets to wear this can I tell him so he comes he says I want to be a uh again I want to be righteous convert so he comes to shamai shamai smacks him up right says right he took the two by four and he whacked him hello hello sir no problem you want to convert because you want to be the kind God oh no problem here's the thing though you need to know if you want to be a kind dog you got to learn the Halal how to act like a kangala you need to learn all the details so he went and he learned and he gets up to the plastic that says what that if a non-coin enters and then he decided he's going to be a righteous convert comes along to my shop very important listen to this martial ass on this camera wait wait a second what's going on over here this is a number 70. thank you so martial asks what happened first did Hillel convert him the pillow just met a guy right a guy comes in line and says hello I want to convert on condition I should be the kind Garden that's like a guy coming you know a guy an illegal alien right he comes right off the truck from Mexico right through the desert he jumps out of the truck and he you know he see he hears there's something called the debate there's something called the president of the United States he says I will be a citizen of the United States on condition that I will be the next president right uh even Obama wouldn't let him become a citizen right right there so what what's going on how could hello convert this guy on condition he would be the kind God all but that's converting for an ulterior motive you can convert um for ulterior motives so therefore the martial says it must be what that hello converted him later on first Hillel taught him Tyra and then Hillel understood he was a sincere convert and then hello converted him if Hillel converted him only after he learned Torah how was Hillary allowed to teach him Tyra that even though you're now the teacher guy Tyra is going to convert Yolanda teach him Tyra what's the logic of that very simple I mean why is a guy now to learn Tyra because he's stealing are you rush he's stealing our inheritance but if tomorrow morning you have to wake up in the morning and watch Nagel Vassar and what's he supposed to do learn you know the second he wakes up the second he jumps out of the Mikvah he's supposed to learn kala tarakua he's not stealing our inheritance about learning the title beforehand he needs to learn to know what to do so the PAD as you also said that's also why no it was allowed alone Terror because since Nayak knew that God was going to command him to bring the carbonis so he needed to know how to listen to Hashem because if Mike is not going to bring the correct quranos so Benoist that doesn't fulfill what Hashem commands so the same way the martial says that a convert is allowed to learn even before he converts so Mac was allowed to learn in order to keep the Divine Hashem yep feels like old learning Yeah by going is the lowest from above this one no no they can't we don't want them to bother smell we don't want that we say go fly a kite go keep your seven oh hi laws we don't want converts we're not we don't we just we uh discourage them does everyone agree with this martial that a person who's converting your latitude no No Malice he got a letter from his son-in-law listen to this his son-in-law said somebody came to me he wants me to convert them he wants me to convert him but the only thing is it's against the law in the Locale where the son-in-laweger lived it was against the law to convert people to Judaism so we can figure says so then don't convert him you know how to break the law do you have to listen to the king we don't break the if the king says we don't convert we have to listen to him so then his son-in-law asks okay I'm not going to convert him but it's legal to move to a different Locale and convert over there so am I allowed to teach him Torah here so that he could then move to a different Locale and learn and convert over there says Roberta the Marshall will tell you what yes but the key beggar said when I learned that my shop I argued on that Marsha because if you look in masecta yvonis Tyson asks how could Hillel accept this convert and toy Smith says that Hillel was sure that if this counter would convert eventually he would become sincere so what Hilla did was not like the Marsha that first he taught him and then he converted says tysus first he converted and then he totem Tire Cesar Vicky Vega according to tices the martial is incorrect according to Texas you may not teach a guy Tyra even if he wants to convert so you'll ask according to remember how is the guy supposed to convert I don't know that's his issue but we're now to teach himager concludes you're not allowed to teach a guy Taira even if he's going to convert sincerely he wants to learn about Torah he has to do it on his own you can't teach him I don't think we passed in that way I think we rely on the Marsha but nevertheless it is not unanimous not everyone says Okay so let's give me a couple more minutes another possible reason why knife was allowed to learn Tyra is remember the language of the rambam the rambam says a guy who learns Misa but we don't kill him what does that means but we don't kill him does anybody know what is that symptomatic of in Israel there are a Serial button it could be higher missile for but best then will not kill you for it says it's clear from the Rama the ramam understands that the Easter for a guy to learn Tara is only midrandana if that's the case lived before rabbana will I have lived before the rabbana put a restriction on goyam from learning Tyra another reason how Nayak was allowed to learn okay so let's talk about the following question this is very interesting somebody comes to have most of fountains that attack of rock and he says unfortunately I have a brother-in-law that married a woman she converted through reform what do we call a woman who converts through reform conversion right that's what we call him she's not Jewish Cesar of Maisha what are you supposed to tell the guy your magleaf to tell him he's married to a Gaya to tell him he should divorce his wife and even if you know he's not gonna listen at least he won't trick his future Generations very interesting Elisha says that you should tell him straight out the militia says you want to see what he says it's a number 23 the Malaysia says if you know someone who married someone with the reform conversion he says foreign if you could convince the guy to leave her you have that obligation and even if you can't you still should tell him so that he should not trick himself and the rest of the family okay but in any event but here the guy says I'm coming to my house for pesach and I want to stay over the Haggadah to my parents and I'm going to say over Avada darshan I'm gonna say all over all the Sam ciphers and who's going to be sitting listening there to all my dressers this woman who converted with reform conversion and I'm going to be teaching her Tyra am I allowed to talk and teach the hagoda in her presence thrivmeister says a very important that the answer of teaching tired to go in is only if your Cabana is to specifically teach to them but if your kavan is to teach to Jews and it happens to be there's going to be a non-jew presence you don't have to avoid her you don't have to whisper you could speak you could tell it you could tell it to whoever you need to and the fact that there's a guy over there that is irrelevant because you're not giving it over to her she just happens to be there and with this this really helps in a lot of very interesting cases the Milam in La Jolla and number 24 of David C Hoffman talks about a case where you have there was another individual in Europe who is married to a non-jewish woman and he had a boy now the boy what's the boy well there's a guy the only thing is it was in a nice detail all they had there was and the father what's he going to teach the kid to be you know akashurah Christian he wants the kid to learn you know Kamara so he sends them to the case now the principal doesn't know what to do what am I going to do to tell the father you know we don't want to teach the kid she's gonna get upset he's gonna get into a fight he's gonna create a whole stir oh so according to the the voice but uh it's not gonna help because he's still not Jewish according to the bush that Nayak had a breast and everything was like oh maybe right but that's also it's a very difficult answer so what are you gonna do so the Milan of the Ohio says very a number of very interesting things he says first of all Glam you're allowed to teach them why because by teaching them they're going to hear that one day mashiach is going to come and the Jews are going to reign supreme it's good for going to know that okay then he says that's that's very interesting go and we can teach them soon then he says you can't teach them the Mitzvahs but tell them about what happened to them at sriim when they harmed Us in the Triumph let know that when you harm Jews you get big boils yeah and all your water turns to blood and wild animals attack you that's a good thing for Graham to know that's awesome so you could teach them the Vmax to them you can teach them the stories of the Hamish and when it comes to Gomorrah you know send the kid out for recess or something and explain to the father what do you want obviously this father is not a sheimer Shabbos so you want the kid to learn that his father doesn't keep Shabbos the kid's gonna who knows what he's gonna do to father if he learns that right so therefore take the kid out of the class for gamara but says what if you're not able to take the kid out of the class for the gemara you can't teach the rest of the class now what would our moisture say well I should say you could do it right as long as your Cabanas to teach the hidden the fact that there's a guy there that's not a problem and then finally the very interesting question that robyakov isila Weinberg was asked from a rabbi in Elizabeth New Jersey who was the first person to put Torah on media right he gave a famous on the radio and he wanted to know this was a big issue is he allowed to teach gamara on the radio after all they're going to be gayam tuned in right so yeah right here here's the point you can have a good but there's nothing better to do with his life than listen to gamara and Yiddish right yes but nevertheless you say she could do it you're coming to teach Turtle the fact that some guy is going to be interested in hearing a gamara Sharon Yiddish you know that's not your problem however the 3D Ace again he says it would be permitted based on the rationale that the guy who's listening to the gamara share he's probably doing it for intellectual stimulation and that would be permitted so the same thing probably applies to putting Torah on other media sources if it's made specifically if it's catered to the Jewish people the fact that people are listening to shirimonyom kippura they're probably not Jewish that's how you're not having that the shroom should be for those people but again this is a they're going back to Naya right Rashi says so either you could say like the gorarios before the Tara was given or you could say like he had a Mila or you could say like River from gorowitz that he learned as an animal device or you could say like the three-day age that he did it for intellectual stimulus or you could say like the martial that he did it to be able to fulfill the Russian Hashem or you could say that it's only Mr jabone and this was before the rabbis came along all in all Nayak probably had a very good header for learning a wonderful evening you've just experienced another Torah class brought to you by torahanytime.com