Noach’s Korbanos (2)

going back to what we started yesterday and that is a little bit of regarding the carbon and the of so we mentioned that emerges from the what's the first move that What's the first thing that he does? He builds a and he takes all the kosher animals, all the kosher birds. He brings them as carbon on the smelled. The incredible smell, the emerged from these carbonoids. whatever was trying to accomplish with these carbonas. He accomplished. We mentioned the third raid bite yesterday that asks and that is it sounds like from the from all the kosher animals from all the kosher birds. We know not all behemoth and not all are allowed to go on the as it relates to we just talked about this in the as it relates to it's how could have taken from all the kosher animals and brought carbon with them you're not allowed to bring carbon from even all kosher animals these very specific animals that prescribes as being kosher to be brought as said something classic. He said he said the med says that tells that really you should have had a mitzvah to take from all the animals and bring them as carbon. However, it would have been a big it would have been very dangerous. You'd have to become hunters. You'd have to start fending and fighting for all these animals. says it's for that reason when I gave the Tory I said I want you to take from the three animals that are the most by you take the take the take the a every farm has an axe every farm has a sheep every farm has a goat take these three animals and bring them as carbonas to go ahead and to try to find all these carbonas I want you to take the carbonas from the things that are most readily available says YOU SEE IS REALLY ALL CULTURAL ANIMALS are to it says I'm not being it's going to be hard to find the other animals therefore only bring a carbon from said that's true once the yidden were all over the place living in however was emerging from the ta he had all the animals literally with him being that he had access to all the animals so the time of the of Why was not applicable for that reason was able to do what would make sense and that is which was written by the scher a very but it's a very very it's and that is that this mesh at first glance would seem to be the issur is the brings a and the talks about what the carbon was says as follows before the Mishkan was erected one was allowed to bring a carbon on a bomb and the one was not, it was the And you were allowed to take any animal and put it on the bring it as a just had to make sure that the animal was kosher. If the animal wasn't kosher, it wasn't going to be okay. All the carbon were he didn't have all these different types of carbon. Everything was and the last line of the price is that they follow that same guideline that's laid out in that price. So the price says was done on it was done by and you were allowed to take any animal you wanted and put it on the only condition is the animal had to be a kosher animal. So I'm skipping to the bottom of the You're allowed to take any animal, albeit a kosher animal, and put on the say take from all the animals from the it has to be what is doing that he's taking from all the that you allowed to take any kosher animals built the and emerged from the and built them. So it's as long as the animal was kosher that in of itself was going to be okay. So freightinger had gives with this I'm so troubled by it said something beautiful. a classic but it's already ask to be the truth is your brings that in office also asks me and he too says not the terret but truth is doesn't mention this but the and this is in the also asks the and he who says a terret again a different terret but he says a ter is he also asks this kasha and he says a ter and the kasha is what's going on over here it's a says that no was allowed to bring from all kosher animals because it was you come to the table you say you say a rape bite it all sounds good but it would seem to be dead on arrival it's at first glance it seems to says very glot, very simple and very em and that is brings as long as it's going to be a says that the to this is that from the fact that and he brought from all the kosher animals, you see that when it comes to you're allowed to bring any animal that you want. But this right here presupposes clearly that when built his he built a bum and when brought carbon the carbon that he brought followed the of how you're supposed to bring carbonas on a bum. Oh, when it comes to bringing a carbon on a bumbo, you can bring from any carbon. That's why no was able to bring from every carbon. And by the way, that is even the you can bring from any kosher animal from the fact that that's what but it's not so posh. It says that was just an ordinary bomber. The medish in this is inv says you want to know where built his he built it on because it's there that went and brought his carbon was where it was by the godel line. So first things first, it was a line. And second things second it was not just a but it was the it's also is just to read one excerpt emerges from the he sat down and he started darling in his heart saved me from the he also took me out of this 12 month incarceration of being in I don't have an obligation to be to bring immediately and he took from the men of this is interesting. We're going to make believe we didn't just read that. We need the next line. And he built them. And he went ahead and he built a misbeh like was popular the day and go ahead and bring carbonas. It was the misbeh of that's the of the of that's the and the was brought in Jerusalem that we spoke about yesterday where says The ram brings these he brings the bracel he brings the again since says that when noyak went ahead and noyak built his msbayak not his ta his msbayak he wasn't just building an ordinary msbayak But rather the that was going and that was building was a misbehan and it was in that one day the misbeh would be and the way the ram says it was in the place of kadusha in other words says according to these The was literally in the moto it's said to say that if built his in the moto that it could be the governed the of was not the of but rather it was the of the making such a big deal about the fact that this is the then it's not it's a leap of faith right just have to be a little briskish here it's not but it's very very and it seems very reasonable that if that's the and that's the of the then the would govern this would have to be that as well and if that's the case said ruling it sounds a little bit like there's a tan. It sounds like this taco. What was what was the misbehav that says you're allowed to bring from all different types of kosher animals and ra said what's the mar the is well if that's the case so what emerges is if this par is the melanade to so obviously that's obviously what it And if that's the case then the govern whereas in the braces and the ways that hold it was said there already and it was governed not by the laws of bas rather It's mis stubborn. You're talking that it was governed instead by the laws of the way a carbon is supposed to be brought in the B mikdash. If it's governed by the way it's supposed to be brought in the BTS, well then again then you have a then you have then you have then you have the then you HAVE WHAT HAPPENED to you going TO TELL ME IT'S true for everyone but this is LIKE THIS IS DIFFERENT. THIS IS THE AND IF THAT'S THE CASE, IT HAS TO be if it has to be what's going on over HERE and but the bottom line is you have to say that saw here in terms of determining and trying to figure out exactly what was going on and it's based on the other. You're right. It doesn't stem with but it stems with and it stems with its and all that raid is going on that side that this isn't just any ordinary bum and any ordinary but rather this is and as a result leap of faith again it's not m but leap of faith it's been governed by the laws of mikt and if it's been governed by the laws of mikdash ma it's very mab that this is the way that this all played itself out. There's a safer called I believe it's only out on but it's written by a tremendous and of the but in the on this so he brings this piece from and then he says that I want to be mo of one maybe you can be mo of something very beautiful and that is there's a a medish and this medish is in paramedish over there says well there's a medish and this medish is in par the says as follows this is a third interesting said in the name of when he left the a lion came and he broke his he injured him and as a result when it came time to bring the carbonas he couldn't bring the carbonas the reason he couldn't bring the carbonas is because he was the shame so instead of him bringing the carbonas his son shame right he goes ahead and he's the one that does the so the med says in parak that because he was famously injured by the so he couldn't do the himself. Instead of him doing the his son Shame ends up doing the fre's another mag this one isn't going to read the mag I'll prove to you that the were the ones that used to do the before go back to the beginning of time was the of the world the carbani as soon B is carbon. He wore the big day. They were big and used to wear these big day. When died, he gave it over to his son. And then got up and he brought a carbon guide then and only then the carbon was the one that brought the carbon and only AFTERWARDS AND BEFORE DIED SO ONE of his last things he did in his final will and testament he tells shame that even though the you're going to be the you're going to be the one that's going to go ahead and do the but in this who's doing the it's or when is bringing it it's doing the right these two incious parak is about because of his encounter with the lion and as a result he can't even bring the carbonus and you know who brought the carbonus our it's that brought the carbonas. Yet over here is the one he put on these big AND HE DOES AND AFTERWARDS HE GIVES IT tom is the one that's going to stop bringing carbonas we have that according to what said it's almost that way that you have these two approaches that took in terms of understanding what govern this and this of it's if you hold that carbon We're carbonos. So then the fact that was not going to be a problem. You know why? Because we know that was able to be brought on the buck. It's that same bryceman that we just mentioned. Now to be clear, the bry says that you were allowed to take an animal that was and put on the it doesn't say that if the one doing the was it would be okay. But all the speak out that were mach and c. And if the kur could be a balm, then the mak could also be a bum. Say if it was of then even though he's it would be okay. You would have to say that no wasn't a when it was but as long as he wasn't a even though he's about it's going to be okay. Whereas the says that was not able to do the he had to give it over to shame. Why? because he was about that's going that's going so holds like who holds like rebel is all the rebel they all hold the same thing that the was of mikdash why because it was on the mak and it was in Jerusalem it was on the misbeh of kind of everything is going to be okay. The bottom line is where are telling us is that in as much as that there seems to be a bummer and the reason he was able to bring me is based on the fact that because on you can bring me but really not everybody agrees this way. We have the bencious rabb. We have the we have who says that was and as a result he couldn't do the this is of who cares that he's that doesn't seem to be an issue must be they hold it was if it's now we're ready now why was able to bring from all the different it's the that's in They were all asking it according to says after you hear this I think it's to read this again inside it's just every word it's incredible let's read it says what's this on the bottom footnote one starts with We use that word five times. It was a simple word. I plagiarized it. It's not but it's that it had a den of and it's for that reason even though for you don't need to build in HE THE AND THE over says that the concept of did not exist when was brought on BUT the says answering two GREAT doesn't have to be and it's THE SAYS WHAT'S GOING ON OVER AND YOU KNOW THIS IS FOOTNOTE number four. What does it say? It says that was a but so you see that on some level according to that he was a coin that's why says it says for that you need a how come it doesn't say gave the over to someone else maybe his kids did it he didn't have to do it is bizarre but it's that requires and that's why the Torah emphasizes the says that where did this take place in and that's why there was a and that's why this and that's why saying right just to bring out the point a little bit better on used to do the it was in the she had to be a coin that's I'll say because his that was being done was being done and that's why the emphasizes why it's because the only thing that needs him is the it's that part of the carbon that requires cut now that I gave you a whole that what's going on over here is is so why did he from all the inract he's going according to that he's going according to that according to the built was in the mik it went with the mik. If it went with the straight at THE END OF THE IS AFTER HE MAKES EVERYTHING WORKS and now he says I one problem it doesn't make sense how you could bring the ISUNASHA yeah is going that was there's no is asking on the he didn't start with he starts is why you think of course the catch Kasha doesn't start the kasha is a choice it's a terrible terrible choice the kasha the kash is according to the rabi you have to know how to ask the kasha how to say over at the very least we should say it the way says it either way this is the rest of the story to this will revisit That's