0:00 / 0:00
Noach - Invisible Unity
245 views
Why does the Torah leave out most of the story of generation of the dispersion without even giving details about their sin? Why does the Torah leave out the beginnings of Abraham and his philosophical war with the idolators of his generation? Why does Abraham begin his preaching by smashing the idols into pieces? Why is dispersion the appropriate punishment for that generation's rebellion against God? Find out in this week's parsha podcast.
Comments(0)
Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
You're listening to the weekly para
podcast recorded with Hashem's never-
ending assistance in Raish Israel 5776
2015. This week's para is
parasyak and I'm actually going to skip
the story of Noah and I'm going to go
straight to the end of the para because
I'd like to discuss the idea of the dora
the generation of the dispersion and the
introduction that the Torah gives us to
au to Abraham who would be the
progenitor of the Jewish people and in
looking at the description of our khazal
how our sages explain the dha and the
interaction of Ara of Abraham with this
generational dispersion. So the khazal
our sages fill in a lot of blanks. The
Torah is very unclear as to who exactly
was who were they? What was the problem?
What did they do wrong? Why was there a
dispersion? Why did God himself as it
were come down and say I don't like
what's going on here? I'm going to
disperse them throughout the land. The
Torah is almost silent on the story. The
Torah is almost silent on the the sin of
the the generation of the dispersion and
the midrashim have to fill in the holes,
fill in the gaps. So the first question
I'd like us to think about as we start
discussing who was or who were these
people, the first question I like to
think about and plant the seed inside of
your mind is why indeed is it? Why is it
that the Torah is quiet when it comes to
the dispersion in explaining their sin?
Doesn't speak about it and our need to
fill in the blanks. So, but why why is
it indeed that way? That's the first
question. The second question is so the
majam also talk about au as we said and
and his interaction with the generation
of the dispersion. It talks about him as
a Abraham the ivy the Hebrew as we refer
to it. So the word iry in Hebrew
actually means the one who's on the
other side. And hazel tell us that the
entire generation that entire time all
of the people who lived in the time of
Abraham they were all on one side and
Abraham alone stood on the other side
because they were all preaching the
concept of idolatry that there are many
gods. One should bow down heaven forbid
to the to the sun, the moon and the
stars. That was the idea that they were
proliferating. Aravino Abraham came
along and said this is not true. There's
one God who is above all of these
powers. Maybe that they do have some
powers but it's not powers that they
have on their own. The stars don't
control reality but rather they are the
vehicle through which God controls
reality. Now as his kdish that was the
novelty of Abraham the people fought
against him. Nimrod was the leader of
these people of the generation of the
dispersion and hopefully we'll soon see
exactly what was their sin what was the
thing that they had done wrong but
what's interesting here and the point
that I'd like to make is that au this
whole interaction that he has with these
people him being on one side everyone
else being on the other side and and the
story that comes out of it which I would
like to also share with you which has to
do with him breaking the idols and being
brought in front of Nimro thrown inside
of the kisha inside of the fire and
surviving that which is also only barely
hinted to in the Torah. That whole story
is something which we don't hear about.
We don't hear about it. The first thing
that we really hear about Arau is in
next week's paras in parl when God says
to him go leave where you are. Leave
your father's house. Leave everything
behind and go to Israel. That's
something that happens much later in his
life. We don't really hear the Torah is
not explicit. doesn't really tell us
about the beginnings of Arainu even
about what he teaches about the one God.
I mean, we we look at the stories as
they continue. You look in you look at
this at what happens to him as he gets
to Israel. It speaks about his his
kindness, his interactions with Aimelik
and and and the parro and they're trying
to steal his wife, etc., etc., etc.
Everybody knows he's a man of God, but
the Torah never really talks about what
he's preaching. The Torah never tells us
the shittita, the opinion and of Abraham
and what he stands for. It's it's almost
never mentioned. It mentions perhaps
that he he he called out there in the
name of God. But it doesn't actually say
what he was saying. Doesn't tell us that
he was the okay he he was the man of
God. He was the one who believed in the
one God and we know that. But it doesn't
speak about that at length. And it's
very interesting in these explanation.
Why indeed is it that the beginning of
of Arau's life the the shittita how he
became molded as a human being in his
philosophy and his belief in one God
that's something that's left out. It's
just left for our sages to fill in the
gaps on. Why indeed is it left out? And
why as the story continues do we only
hear about his actions, his goings, his
doings, his back and forth, even even
the the binding of Isaac. It's something
that hits there's movement there. But we
don't hear anything about his
philosophy, his teachings, that which as
as we understand Abraham and we
understand his place in history was the
center of who he was and what he was
teaching. How come the Torah is almost
silent on Abrau and his teachings of the
one God of the people of Israel. Now
before we move into trying to understand
this there's one more question one more
point I'd like to raise and that is that
in the description the way that the
measure speaks about the dha the dha
fluga the generation of the dispersion
it says that what they wish to do what
was their point what was their goal with
this tower that they built part of the
goal with the tower was that they wanted
to be able to climb up to heaven
classically this is how we hear it
described they wanted to climb up to
heaven and fight against God which of
course if we think about it doesn't
really make that much sense because if
we're talking about a god who's
spiritual, so you don't really need to
go anywhere if you if you actually want
to fight against God. All you need to do
is defy his will, right? But somehow by
building this tower, there was going to
be a great defiance of God.
Interestingly and beautifully, the
measure speaks about the fact that they
wanted to place an idolatry, an idol at
the top of this migdall, at the top of
this tower. And not only was there to be
one tower, there was supposed to be
multiple towers which would be built.
And indeed, they place this idol at the
top of the tower. And the measure says
something amazing. They were going to
use these towers to prevent a a further
mobble to prevent another flood from
occurring. They were trying to to be
able to protect themselves against the
wrath of God. that if God would want to
destroy them or punish them, that they
would be protected somehow through this
idolatry. Now, there's a few things that
are really difficult to understand when
we read this and we think about this.
First of all, I mean, do they believe in
God or not? Like, they're fighting
against God. If you if you're fighting
against God, that means that you believe
in God, but you're just not interested
in what God has to say. You're not
interested in being subservient or sub
to submit oneself to God. So, so here on
one hand they they believe in God and on
the other hand they don't believe in
God. They want to fight against God.
They don't believe in what God actually
represents. It's very interesting just
to to to notice that that they believe
in God and they don't believe in God. I
mean that's classic. And you think about
people who who say that they're atheists
very often it's because God did
something wrong or something was so bad
that it can't be that there's a God. So
they're fighting against there's like a
rebellion against God. It seems that
intrinsic innate in the human experience
is the belief of God. Okay, that's just
an important point to notice. But
another point here that's interesting is
that what was the result of this tower?
The result of this tower was that God
dispersed them at at the beginning as
the Torah describes there was one
language. Everyone spokeesh. They spoke
Hebrew. That was the language everyone
spoke and they used that language that
holy language against God who used the
holy language to create the world. So
because they had a because they had
unity they were united in purpose they
were united in language. So that unity
they used in order to somehow fight
against God to defy God to try to
prevent God from bringing any kind of
punishment on them if they would do
something wrong. What is the result? The
result is Hashem takes all of these
people, disperses them, creates 70
different languages for 70 different
nations. No longer would they have that
unity, not when it came to their
language, and not when it came to their
location. No longer would they be in one
place, but rather they were dispersed
throughout the land. That that that was
the tikun. Now, it's very interesting.
Why specifically was it this the the
dispersion? Why were they separated? The
languages had to be split up into 70
languages. What is the significance of
that being the punishment? How are we to
understand this on a deeper level? Also,
I'd like to share with you one more
medish. The medish says in speaking
about Arabino Abraham and the way that
he started to preach about the concept
of one God and the and the falsehood of
the idolatry that people were following.
So, the mag says like this, I'm going to
read it inside.
Aram's father. So he served idolatry and
not only did he serve idolatry, he made
the
idols. One time he left, he had to go
out of the
country. He asked Abraham to to sell in
his place to be the salesman of these
idols of the
idolatry. So a person would
come. They wanted to buy an idol.
So Abraham would say to the person who
was coming to purchase, he would say,
"How old are
you?" He would say, "I'm 50 years old.
I'm 60 years
old." So Abraham would respond and
say, he he would say to them, "Woe unto
the person who is 60 years old and he
wants to serve an idol which was just
created a day ago, which is one day
old." and the person would become
embarrassed and they would leave. Okay,
so that's the first story that Abraham
that we find about Abraham the way that
he started to preach. Second story,
these are classic stories, but it's
important to notice the details of these
stories. A woman came one
time. She had in her hands a basket full
of flour.
She said to him, "Take this and I want
you to bring this basket full of flour
as an offering in front of all of the
idols. Come." So Abraham got
up. He took an axe and he destroyed all
of the
idols. He left one idol standing which
was the biggest of them all. He placed
the axe in the hand of the biggest one.
Once his father came
back, he said, "Who did this? Who who
destroyed all these
idols?" He said, "What what can I do? I
can't I can't tell a
lie." This woman came in and she had a
basket full of
flour and she said to me, "Bring this as
an offering in front of
them. I brought it in front of them.
Each of the idols would they started
arguing and they said I want to be the
one who eats this offering. No, I'm the
one who wants to come in. So Abraham
told his father that this very large
idol got up which was in the middle
amongst
them. You see he has the axe in his
hand. He used that axe and destroyed all
the other
idols. He said to him his father said
what are you making a joke out of me?
What do they know? They know anything.
They they know what's happening. You're
giving them offerings.
Abraham says to his father, "Listen, did
you did you hear what you just said? Do
you understand what you just said?" And
the story continues. His father brings
him to Nimrod. Nimro was the leader, the
head idoltor. And there's a whole
conversation there. I don't want to get
into that conversation, but I do want to
focus in on the two different things
that Abraham did here. One was that he
he showed this woman or the person who
would enter into his store that you're
old. You've been here for a long time.
This is a brand new thing. Why are you
60-year-old bowing down to something
which is one day old? That was the first
thing. And they were embarrassed. Very
interesting to point this out. They were
embarrassed. It means that they knew the
truth. That's what embarrassment is. A
person who's humiliated means he's he's
caught by the truth. That's the first
point. The second point is that how did
he show up? How did he show up his
father that that these are fake that the
idols are false? The way he did it was
by destroying them, smashing them to
bits. Why did he choose to do it that
way? Why didn't he just, you know, throw
it in the river and say that the the
main one, the main honcho threw all the
ones in the river? There's lots of
different ways that he could have dealt
with the same exact issue. Why did he
specifically break them all? What's the
significance of them being broken into
pieces? So now to start to understand
this, I want to share with you one one
more medish. And the medish is very
powerful and it explains something deep
about what's going on here. The medish
says like
this when it came to the generation of
the
flood no one was left. There was only
Noah. When it came to the generation of
the
dispersion they all survived. What's the
difference?
Since the generation of the flood, they
they were busy stealing from each other.
They were separate from each
other. The verse in reference to the
generation of the flood talks about the
fact that they were they were constantly
moving around their borders. They were
stealing from each
other. That's why nothing was left of
them. There was no remnant of alu. But
the generation of the
dispersion of says um they had something
even though they were they were
rebelling against God even though they
were coming to fight with God as it were
they loved each other they were
united it says that the entire nation
the entire world at that time they were
all of one language they spoke the same
language meaning they all saw eye to eye
the
That's why they survived. Furthermore,
says the
message says the concept of peace is
incredible. Peace between men, between
people is so
powerful. Even if the Jewish people
serve
idolatry, but if there's peace amongst
them, God says as it were, I can't I
can't do anything to you. I can't
conquer you. I can't do anything to you
negative.
because of the fact there's peace
amongst them. We find this a verse in
Hosea 4:1
17 because the people of Ephraim who
were the classic the the representation
of the 10 tribes who ended up serving
idolatry since they're connected to each
other since they're they have that love
for each other leave them. leave them.
There's nothing I can
do. But when they start to fight with
each other, when they start to become
splintered, what does the verse
say? Now that their heart has been
splintered, has broken apart, they don't
agree with each other anymore. They
don't have that love for each other. Now
they will be found
guilty. This teaches
you how great is the concept of peace
amongst the Jewish people and how hated
is the concept of arguments.
measures us one more thing and this is
the key. This is the bottom line of
it. It refers to the fact that they were
all
one. The medish addresses the point
which we raised earlier which is why is
it that the dora m the description of
the Torah of the of the entire
generation of the flood and what
occurred and what what was happening
before what was happening afterwards
that story the Torah describes in full.
But when it comes to the madora flago,
when it came to the generations of
dispersion, the Torah does not explain
it. It's something that need to fill in.
Says an amazing thing. The reason that
the Torah didn't speak negatively about
this generation was because of their
aus. This is how the explains what the
measure is saying. Because they were
united. Even though they were united for
evil. Even though they were united to
fight against God, to build a a tower
which would protect them from the wrath
of God if they were doing evil.
Nevertheless, because they were united,
they wouldn't do anything to take
someone else's things to to try to get
something that belonged to someone else.
They saw themselves as a part of a
greater hole. Because of that, the Torah
didn't want to say anything negative
about them. Didn't want even talk about
it beish talk about it explicitly what
the story was and what they had done
wrong. It's an amazing thing, amazing
idea. And I think that what we see from
this is extremely powerful and it it
starts to explain why the beginnings of
the story of Aram of are also not
misparish. Why it's also not explicit
what happened at the beginning of Aram's
life. why his general shittita his his
his approach his his what he preached in
life the Torah doesn't explicitly say
and I think it's a very deep idea that
when it comes to aus when it comes to
unity whether it's unity amongst people
or whether it's seeing the broader
picture of how everything comes together
all the pieces of reality all the pieces
fit together and form a greater hole
when it comes to that concept when it
comes to the transcendent idea idea of
seeing things from that broader
perspective because we live in a
two-dimensional reality so to speak. We
are not see we can't see it from the
three-dimensional vantage point. The
Torah is speaking to us where we are.
It's speaking to us in our realm. And in
our realm, the concept of aus, of unity,
of of transcendent unity, of of being
able to see that bigger picture is
something that we can't see from this
vantage point. It's something that
requires more of a pirish. It's deeper.
It's it's it's sight. It's hidden. Yes,
our khaz can talk about our sages can
talk about it. But it's something that's
hidden. And that's true when it comes to
the aus comes to the generation of the
flood. And it's true when it comes to au
as well. Abraham the beginning of his
career, the beginning of of the whole
the whole story of Aram is not in his
parish. It's not explained. And I think
that the the reason is because it's
about a it's about Abraham has the
ability to see that all the pieces
everybody looks at the pieces the the id
the idols the the um the stars the sun
these are all the pieces that Hashem
used but Hashem is the broader unity
that encompasses all of these pieces.
Hashem works through all of these
pieces. To us, it seems like many
different, many different powers, which
is why we refer to God as Elohim, which
is plural, because he's
the God is behind all of those powers.
But when it comes to that idea, which is
the foundation of who Abraham is, it's
the foundation of
Judaism, that idea almost can't be
explicitly stated. We can't talk about
the beginning of Aram's life. We can't
even talk about what he preaches. It's
something that requires time. It's not
until we get into the guts of the story
of the Jewish people that we start to
hear about the unity of God. It's really
it's really what happens in Mitsim in
the depth of the darkness after all of
the difficulties the Jews have gone
through after they've been broken as a
people after they've been enslaved for
210 years. Only then do we start to get
this picture of God, the oneness of God,
the unity of God, God being above nature
of being beyond everything and also
being inside of reality. But the idea
here is that the unity that that
transcendent aspect the bigger picture
is something that it's much harder to
touch and to talk about and we see that
from the fact that we can't talk about
the doraflaga the generation of the
dispersion themselves. And now the depth
that comes out of here also is that the
punishment of the dha the the punishment
always whenever we have a punishment
it's always a tikun it's always a
rectification somehow it serves to to
bring the people who have done something
wrong back towards God back to seeing
the true reality when the dua these
people were united so when they're
united to do something wrong so that
unity is really false that unity is
really they're united against God The
concept of unity is really belongs to
God. So they're fighting against God
with their unity. So they're really in a
state of destruction, of separation.
It's not real unity. So what Hashem does
is it's an amazing thing that when
there's a a state of unity which is
negative, Hashem creates a state of
disunityity which is positive. He he
takes them out of their state of quote
unity and puts them into a deeper state
of quote disunityity. But by doing that,
by breaking it down more, what happens
is now becomes more possible to see the
truth. The truth is revealed as you see
the pieces for what they are, which is
false. So the the greatest example of
that is what Afraino does. Abraham takes
the Soom. He takes these idols and he
smashes them to pieces. It's not a
coincidence. He's smashing them to
pieces. And by doing that, that's how he
shows the truth of what they really are,
which is that they are pieces. They are
not the greater whole. God is the
greater whole. And and he's doing that
by showing the truth. He he speaks to
these people. He says, "You are 60 years
old. You've been through time. You've
touched all of the pieces of time."
Because just like in reality when you
have a distance from one place to
another and that that creates pieces so
to speak as as as what happened with the
dispersion. So too in time there are
pieces of time when I get from here now
to there later that all that in itself
is a dispersion so to speak. So he was
saying to them you have been living for
so long and and you're and you're
talking to something which hasn't gone
through that process and therefore
hasn't experienced the unity through
separation that we're speaking about. So
aam and and what what happened as a
result that they were humiliated they
were embarrassed by his words they
realized the truth the depth of what he
was saying and the depth was that here
when you go through the reality you see
the pieces for what they are which is
pieces all of a sudden what's revealed
is that there's a deeper unity which
binds all of the pieces and that is
something which you have to see for
yourself. It's not explicit. It's not
something that that anybody can really
tell you about. It's something that you
have to realize on your own and face off
with experientially. I want to bless you
and please bless me back. Hashem should
help us to be able to recognize the
unity which he is and realize that so
many times the experiences that we have,
the destructions that we experience in
our own lives, whether it's personally
on a national level, these experiences
also serve to break down the false
reality that we see so that we can
experience the deeper reality which is
the the reality of unity. Hashem should
help us to be able to see that
day where we see the broader view that
that transcendent view of the aus the
unity of all of reality and that day
when all of us join together as
one to serve Hashem all of us as one in
that place that unified
place the place which is whole where
there is true seeing of the unity of
God. Thank you so much for listening.
Have a wonderful
Shabas. This podcast was made possible
through the gracious donations of
listeners like you. For more podcasts
like this, please visit
www.rigoldwag.com or search on iTunes
Ari Goldwag.
[Music]