Nissuch Hamayim on Sukkos and Nissuch Hayayin everyday - How do they differ?

I want to begin this year the first day of to thank the powers the behind Hamberg as well as well ased that are two the two not only for but for all the learning programs last night learning over here Kipper I come even if I don't have how could you not come be part of such a beautiful mat the morning the night give them continuous in in today's Shear I would like to focus on a topic that's less discussed in a typical Shear before a young before usually you go to a be more over here the typical is either what are the Mitzvah coming up what are the Mitzvah coming up the mitz say the mitz so you could speak about each one of the the you could speak about the and then the the first night there's a lot to speak about out there's another Mitzvah a Mitzvah that's going to be coming up suus which unfortunately we do not have it because we don't have the BD a Mitzvah that's connected we're a little bit connected to the because we have and is a that was in the and the was for the is differently but that's not the discussion for we're a little bit connected so when you go to the if we're not to be and we're going to try to speak about it to go in a little bit into this Mitzvah what's this where where exactly is this Mitzvah we we're in the T so it's not one of the T mitzvas it's not one of thez as a matter of a fact the from the that lists thez doesn't bring it it's not it's not one of thez but the I'm gonna speak over here about the because where else should I speak about it so it's a that's not in the it's in the over here was another besides was was and he's going on what is talking about says that another so if it's not if it's not a mitvah from thez where then yes is the Mitzvah where do we find the mitzvah so the EM is that it's a says just to be clear these came with allb that's in wine UMAS and wine came with heavy carbon came with a carbonis that's a that's a par and that was every day of the year what we're talking about is unique separately that there was the the water the pouring water that was and that's the says how do you know so if you take a look in the I have a copy of it also that's the throughout the regular of every single day a couple of pages in The we you have over there the regular carbon T that we brought every T came with a with a and so because that was brought every single day of the year if you continue on there are three changes throughout throughout old in the second day at the end of the the says V instead of Ven it says ven these are extra end it's also we'll soon see but it's not V then if you continue on V it's on the next page but thear brings it extra the six day the six day of these are extra doesn't just say with a then on the seventh day usually it says it says so the says what are the three extra letters me is say and it's with these letters asks the following question asks the says what's RAB every morning when we brought the carb there was there was only one only one that we brought what is what is why does the say there's a like what the says you have the copy I don't understand it's not V it's V every carbon only came with one so bson the simple answer which he he answers that but he answers it with a which we'll get to in a second but the simple answer is we just saw the says these two of every single day of the year and so it's very good it's very good you could stop right here I was learning last night with my son we going over a little bit and he said it's very it's very good it's the T says and that's him you could stop right here however seeming L what was bothered is that laa it's not to if it would be this well soon see how he makes it two different but if it would be the same thing it still should have said it's it happens to be in the recipe of the these water these wine if you would need four different things in the you would need oil and you can't bring honey if you need all these type of things so is it different it's one thing it's one with water and wine it's it's different that's brought every single day to the that was brought on and as we'll see these three but it's it's what's the difference foll mean while it's clear that's brought every single day is a din in the carbon what carbon the carbon tomit the carbon Tom was supposed to come with wine with it's a of the carbon has nothing to do with the nothing to do with the it had to do with the was the days of was not to do with the carbon you see you see you see we're learning it you see we learning it out from the learning it out from the same reg so maybe you could say we're making making it of the but how do you see that very good beautiful what's your name R beautiful what you're asking and will soon see that it's not so simple what my we'll soon see his questionable let's see as we move along if the question is still a question but to to clear between the two when says that's connected to the carbon Tom and then there's another that is not connected to the carbon Tom like the says it's a long he says this everybody's going to agree the time to bring the we actually brought it together was with the carbon tomit don't mistake that even though it's nothing to do with the tomit but like he says his ele the was to bring it with the carbon but it's not so what we have over here so far with a chlorite is not like is a just like you brought a carbon you brought a carbon T then you brought a carbon mus and and carbonis yesterday and Kipper you brought carbon so there was another called it a carbon there was that was its own entity and with this says I understand why it says because these two types of if it would be both the same carbon so do you have to list out that the one is wine one is water it's all part of the carbon so it's two separate entities is so even if we stop the she right here and Su you want to talk about it's already a clor thing to speak about that is not just a part of the carb is its own entity to bring every day of what didn't bring it oh we'll get to that very good we'll get to that shortly if you don't have a carbon Tom that's a Chlor that's NA number four that we'll get soon brings but if brought it we'll start with that very clar what happens if you don't have a carbon tomit R if you don't have a carbon tomit could you bring you cannot bring the reason why you can't bring is only with the carbon tomed if you don't have the carbon tomed you can't bring the you can't bring you don't have a Tom but water you got water water you'll be able to bring one clearly if it's a not part of the carbon if you don't have a carbon you could still do the another three says they all bring it's all the same but it's plays out in three places could you bring the May or the Y before or the night before let's say the night before could you do or the night before or could you do it in the morning before you bring the carbon tomit what happens if you brought the carbon tomit and you didn't have a chance yet to bring the and it was so busy it was a busy day and said a day pass it's the next day if it's a of the carbon T the wine is a of the carbon T you cannot bring it before not the night before and even the morning before you can't bring it before the carbon Tom it's a of the carbon you can't bring it before afterwards the wine you didn't bring wine for the carbon T of Sunday morning today Sunday the week of and you didn't bring you didn't bring you didn't pour wine you could still bring it cuz it's still connected to the carbon Tom you could bring the night before because there nothing to do with the tomit like says the Min to bring it with the tomit even like said even if you don't have a tomit you could bring it the night before and you could also bring it in the morning before the carvon Ted there's nothing to do with it's afterward you can bring it the whole day but only off until the end of the day once you miss it over so here are three between of the carbon T that's brought every single day of the year is only brought only brought on suus it's not connected to the it's its own it's its own Mitzvah you gr brought at the time of the T says that is its own not connected to the carbon like is you have the copy over there it's like what we saw it's not connected the has to do with the day and it doesn't have to do with the carbon yes that's connected is not connected to the carbon the same is also the r the spells it out crystal clear that it's not connected to the carbon the ra doesn't say it as clear but the ra what the r says is the ra says if you bring the before the not only if you bring it in the morning before but even if you bring it the night before so that's that it's not connected to the carbon Tom if it's connected to the carbon Tom it's a the you have to bring the with the you bring just like you can't bring before the this also not so and the is like that what is going on a r and the riv argues the riv holds that is like it's connected to the carbon so what we had before that is owned then now we have the way how you're asking good I'm not 100% sure I learned it a few times the is arguing on that Riv it and and is it meish that the reason why Laya is no good is because it's before or maybe which car at least at least a understands like that at least a he's going on the he's going on a special carbon or it's part of the no no it doesn't doesn't have its own carbon it's brought at the time of the carbon T in the morning that had the sh is just the the of besides also have but you're right it's not the's never there's no other carbonis the water the only addition of is only the water no carbonis now the sh is do we plug in this into the carbon T in the morning to the wine that's connected is it another ingredient into the carbon tet or it's its own it's it's owned in and if it's owned in you can bring it already By Night the riv it says that if you bring it by night so and the argues so the B see and understands you know why by night it's not good the reason why by night it's not good is because you have to bring it with the T because first the last problem so has to be sandwi between that has anything to do with so I'm talking not sure that's what asked also needs more clarity at least to me in the when he brings the rivid when it says Lila is no good maybe you can't bring it by L and if you can't bring up that has nothing to do before right right the way argues on the it he doesn't he doesn't theid says he can't bring by night so if it's just algam in so what is the saying it's a din by itself okay but still you can't bring it by night it seems the reason why you can't bring it by night is because it's connected to the I argue it's not connected to the and therefore you can bring up by night but that's understands that connected or the is own is his own in say we're not done yet we is own entity then we saw the says then the in his goes on to say that it's what's the is the is the you have this copy over here also on the bottom brings this same suff with the na he brings the Naina that we mentioned before what happens if you don't have a carbon toid but Al in this sh says it's a what's the he says like this if you learn that is known from theen then it is connected is like it's connected to the the exact opposite of the says that if it would be the same type if would be the same you wouldn't be able to save in if you learn you look at the the Bim if you learn from V these two so then he says that it's the same it's the same or if you learn it with the we saw not connected to just the extra if you learn it from there then you could say it's a separate in so again there's one more piece to add on over here but just to make it CL there should be a very clear takeaway could either be like it's one it's one mitvah part of the of course he Mitzvah but it's another ingredient included into the carbon tomit or or you could say that actually it's a separate it's separate it happens to be we bring it at the time of carbon tomit but has nothing to do with the carbon tomit I made a copy you could look at in in the brisan stencil Claire's even if you say that is in carbon you could still cl to I'm going to leave it for now but I want to add one more nud over here and that's also in the cerer comes let's call it with a Twist that both are true both are true say and it's part of the carbon and to say that has its own and it depends it [Music] depends if Mo if if you bring the Y together with the carbon Tom then it's a of the carbon tomed if you bring it separately then it's not a both are true but it depends if you bring it to if you bring it together with the carbon thenes of the carbon if you don't bring it with the carbon thid then it's not the nain that we said before are still going to apply that has its own cuz if you bring it the night before you could bring it the night before and it's t not going to be part of the to so you could bring it the night before you could bring it the morning before but what's going to come out half is is that when you bring the T in the morning and you didn't do the you're not going to be able to bring it the next day cuz remember we said before another Nao besides before could you bring it 3 days later so he said if it's it's owned in I said it wrong you are going to be able to you are going to be able to bring it you are going to be able to bring it later you're not no back to what I said you're not going to be able to bring it afterwards because it's not connected to the tomed it's not connected you can't bring it two days later you're not going to be able to bring it so with a with a clite that both are true it's connected when you bring it with a carbon and if you don't bring it with the carbon it's not connected so just is it you had a shil before is it still you still have that Shila or what was your Shila before again one thing the DHA of May or the other DHA which which D the the May one so so the EMS is is now that you're saying really the says that if you learn from the of it's actually not one thing if you learn it from the other so it's that it's one thing not like the says it's still two things but the says that if it's it's the same thing is the same thing if you learn from so the Torah says the says it's a but it's it's but it's how is from the extra letters but the extra Letters by the way are not even from the word right the extra it's not connected to so just to conclude and to sum up the that's it's not one of thez is brought every day brought it's brought the preferable time is to be it's brought with the carbon and is it the same thing as or is it a separate thean when he speaks about this he has a long Chua you'll see it's in the copies the starts off and he says just like we say it's interesting the a sh if you say it elsewhere besides carbonis but this ISB so the says he wants to go in get involved in the to be have so if we're not and we're going to be still in so then we we went through a could speak about we could have we should that will be able to actually be have the of together with all the other like the