Preparing video...
0:00 / 0:00
Coleman Hughes | The Deal w/ Nissim Black
2,758 views
Coleman Hughes is a writer, podcaster, and opinion columnist who specializes in issues related to race, public policy, and applied ethics. Coleman’s writing has been featured in the New York Times, the Wall Street Journal, National Review, Quillette, The City Journal, and The Spectator. He is the host of the podcast, Conversations With Coleman and is also a musician under the name ColdXman (pronounced “Cold Man”).
Featuring:Nissim Black
Categories:Music
Comments
Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
[Music]
hey coleman thank you so much for coming
on the show
such an honor to have you here on the
deal man i really appreciate it
it's my pleasure
no pleasure's all mine pleasure's all
mine so let's let's get into this really
really quickly um i i have to ask you
about this video because the video is
fire the video is fire right
um blasphemy i mean like i i i mean
quite honestly i got i got a whole lot a
lot of questions i got to ask you off
camera about this video anyway but first
off i want to ask you like what inspired
you to do this i mean there's obvious
things that you talk about that inspired
you to do it but there could have been
many other platforms as you're familiar
with but what made you want to do it in
the music video
well i it was 2019 when i first started
the song and i had just testified before
congress
and i was feeling the heat of a lot of
people that didn't like my opinion in
the room online
and
i was
uh
there was a kind of resentment of
feeling like
people were not taking uh my opinion in
good faith or or seriously and engaging
with it
and there was a kind of frustration that
i just felt i had to channel
and uh that that that was really the the
feeling that sparked the song so i made
that beat
and then it just the lyrics just kind of
came
this kind of flows i know all about
inspiration you know it's very
interesting they say artists usually
when they're going through something
uh makes the best music would you would
you agree that you know that had it not
happened you don't think you would have
been able to pull off a record like this
i think you you often have to have
strong emotions about something where
the where those emotions come from
is less important but yeah i mean it has
to be a strong emotion that is the
genesis of a moving piece of artwork
right right so you are let me get this
straight you are black and you're also
white you're mixed is that is that what
you i think i caught that line inside
the inside the song right
yeah that's a lot that's more of a
metaphorical line in the song i mean
okay
ethnically i i would
you would one would probably call me
half black half ethnically puerto rican
my mom was puerto rican
my dad okay he's black
okay okay got it so here's some of them
on my puerto rican side i'm also
racially mixed like my grandma is like
white puerto rican my other grandma was
black puerto rican so even that is like
you know i i do think at the end of the
day
almost every black person in america has
some quote unquote white in them
genetically for sure that's sure and a
lot of white people don't know they have
uh black in them so
it's kind of not metaphorical
no it's true i mean even if you look at
the african-american population or how
many people have native american in them
also too everybody's like
it's always been a thing for me anybody
that's that's black by the definition of
meaning that descendant of you know um
slave slavery in america and i'm gonna
say most of the people that came over
even a lot of them even um are not
100 african jeans you understand what i
mean it's not so this whole
you know
extra super pro black black everything
you're talking about the color of your
skin but ethnically a lot of people have
a lot of other other uh you know ethnic
groups you know mixed into the to the
gene pool for sure right for sure so i
want to ask you about this record so you
said a few things i want to quote a
couple of these lines that you that you
had so you said look at my attitude
after they called me a tom
and a ray called me a [ __ ] it's a 10.
you say well you said something else
it's a 10 but um
i keep it clean um i mean explain some
of these bars to me i'm saying don't
tell me who the fan losing a few of my
friends yeah i've been booted from
public events and it was almost and it
was over something i said
like
talk to me about some of these things
i'm just excited to hear about it i had
officer tatum earlier on on the show and
we discussed a few of these things but
i'm really like interested to pick your
brain on this side
well yeah so
the choice for me as a public figure as
a writer has been
to think for myself and to think what i
actually think
and risk being called names by people
being called uncle tom being called a
[ __ ] sometimes
right and
the choices between that and just
shutting up thinking what i'm supposed
to think not really thinking for myself
and
basically people pleasing
catering to the people that that wield
those kind of epithets as a way of
policing the boundaries of thought
so i've always chosen the first route
and
that's basically what that's about it's
like i'm not going to stop
thinking for myself because
someone is calling me a name i mean that
i think unfortunately those kind of
slurs do work on a lot of people
that don't want to that limit themselves
and what they'll think so so as to never
cross boundaries that will get them
called names by other black people
but i don't think that's that's just
not the the way to be an autonomous
uh self-driven individual
right right of course it's not a i mean
there's a few different things you know
i've struggled with a lot of these
things i myself i grew up in the hood i
was very very um
familiar with what that relationship
was like specifically
you know dealing with a few of the
things you you know you were talking
about in this record and things that
just been going on specifically the
relationship between the police and me
being a black man you know what i'm
saying in the hood growing up and and i
always tell people like i was way more
worried about the other guys i was
beefing with then i was with the police
you know i just didn't grow up with a
crazy fear my fear of the police is i
didn't want to go to jail but i didn't
grow up ever thinking like you know i'm
saying the police are going to shoot me
i know some people could argue that
we're living in different times but i
think we're just living you know what
i'm saying with different uh different
people on the news to be honest i think
i think you know it's been very very
hard
um to be able to have these tough
conversations because there's so much
noise in you being a public for being a
person that's a writer you understand
um the power of you know uh putting
articles out and different things like
that how strong do you think that the
influence has been from the media in
terms of uh being able to sway people in
the black community
on this issue in particular
that's a great question and i i think
the media
the one of the primary powers the media
has probably the most important power
is not necessarily
how they tell you something
it's
what they show and what they don't show
so
and i'm talking about national news i'm
talking about cnn msnbc fox
um the national news which is now what
everyone watches it used to be people
were more into local news but more and
more
it's become national and what happens is
every day in this country like a billion
different things happen
crazy things happen in different towns
and cities all across america and the
national news picks and choose chooses
you know two or three
to report
and the primary power they have to shape
our picture of what's going on in our
country
is to choose certain things and to not
choose others
so for example
um
obviously the killing of george floyd
was a huge story as it should have been
but three years before that tony timpa
who was a white man in dallas that was
killed in in a very similar way to
george floyd on camera
a knee on the back of his neck for 13
minutes and the cops making jokes as
they kill them right that just wasn't a
big news story
so
basically what happens is you show all
the examples of things happen to black
people
you show none of the examples of them
having to white peop happening to white
people and then people form the
impression that oh this kind of thing
only ever happens to black people
because of what are being shown and what
they're not being shown and that's the
primary power to shape shape the
narrative and it's i don't even think a
lot of people in the news are doing that
consciously or they they know what
they're doing right right um that that
has a real power to skew people's
perceptions about what's right that's a
great answer great answer i you know
what i you know i myself
you know it's very hard for me because
when i'm having these conversations even
with people that i grew up with or
different things like that like
the truth is is that
nobody ever really thought it out you
understand what i'm saying nobody ever
really thought about it themselves you
know i mean
i remember being a kid and there would
be this group of five percenter guys you
know what i'm saying i think they were
they you know obviously meant well so
they would take us out of the class
and they will pump us basically with
their ideologies of how important it was
as a black man to know that your god and
whatever the case is but it was like you
know
all these things happening to people you
know whether it's from the media whether
it's from you know these type of groups
or whether it's from what's happening
entertainment in our culture it's really
programming a person to think and and
not to think about things their actual
life experiences in other words like you
know i was put on the spot after the
george floyd thing and somebody was just
like you know what's it like being black
growing up you know in your neighborhood
like you know you know did you
experience racism what was that like how
did that feel and i'm gonna be you know
i have to be honest with people like i
didn't but but it had had had it not
been framed to me that way you
understand what i mean i would have
never i would have just been like yeah
it's hard out here uh you know what i'm
saying people are racist and all that
because
that's what i've been fed you understand
what i mean but when i think about
myself how many times did i actually
experience those things i grew up in
seattle seattle happens to be very very
liberal very very politically correct
there could be a lot of systemic things
that are wrong but to say that i
actually was experiencing racism or the
police did this and whatever yeah
the times i got jacked up by the police
it's like you know i was doing something
i shouldn't have been doing i looked
like i wasn't doing something i should
have been doing so uh
i guess my question is to you are you
thinking are you seeing the same thing
you know for yourself also today a lot
of people's opinions they don't even own
those opinions they're not really theirs
they really belong to what they've been
taught from other people
so what you're talking about has a name
uh it's been given a name by
by certain thinkers called the optimism
gap which is you ask someone the same
question in two different ways and they
will give you two different answers so
right if you ask someone how much racism
there is in in the us they will tell you
a lot there's a whole lot of racism how
much crime is there in the us there's a
lot you know whatever it is
if you ask them how much racism is there
in your neighborhood
how much crime is there in your specific
on your block the more concrete you make
it
so that they're actually thinking about
their day-to-day experience
the more people will say well actually
it's not as bad it's not as bad right
right
so
you know like if you ask everyone
has
have people been making economic
progress the past 50 years you've got a
lot of people saying no we're just as
poor as we ever were you ask people are
you doing better than your parents
most people will say well actually yeah
i am doing better than my parents so the
more concrete you make it the more you
get people to actually think about their
own lives rather than these big
narratives about the country that are
influenced by the media
the more optimistic people are about the
future and about how much progress has
been made
wow that's crazy it's funny because you
know
not to get in i don't care if you're
four or not i have to make that
disclaimer just because i know that the
you know whatever algorithms and whoever
is watching or whatever not saying pro
not saying against but the vaccine was a
major issue this this past year right so
i seen a video somebody has hit me of
someone going around on college campuses
and they were asking
all these girls how do you feel about
you know my body my choice everybody
obviously agreed they agreed that it's
okay to you know abort their child and
and whatever else because it's their
body their choice right so um and asked
several different girls
and finally
they they after they were done asking
you know certain amount of girls she
went back and asked all these same girls
how do you feel about a vaccine mandate
with you oh no i'm definitely four and
i'm definitely for it i'm definitely
fourth 100 percent you know for and and
then the question is well what does that
do with my body my choice and everybody
stumped oh i didn't i didn't think about
that you know almost i almost didn't
think about it so it seems like even in
the midst of all of this sometimes you
know it's just like
you know i mean i found that to be very
very hilarious but i think it's
sometimes it's just one of those things
where
um
you know i think people need to spend a
little bit more time alone away from the
rest of the world like and and and for
me that's how i'm able to formulate my
opinions i take time i go spend like you
know an hour every day just talking to
god trying to formulate what my life is
and and what i'm supposed to be doing
and why why was put here you know do you
have any practices or anything like that
that help you to stay focused on what
you're pat because you could be
indoctrinated also too on the right also
too right where the person's right or
they're left on the political spectrum
you can hold and own opinions that don't
really belong to you but as an
individual so my question is for you how
do you keep your opinions your own
that's a really good question um
well i try to always
i mean meditation helps i'm a big
meditator
and um
i guess the the way that helps is to
make me a little bit better at
not trusting my first reaction to
everything
so if i read something
and i feel in my body i just i think
it's [ __ ]
i don't always trust that i think okay
wait a minute i'm i'm being too reactive
to this
this is the kind of thing that's going
to lead me
to just confirm what i already believe
so let me actually give this a chance
let me give
let me really
uh
right this is so much of a chance as i
can and see see if there's anything
uh to be gleaned here because i know
that so i'm i'm
doing that a lot when i'm reading things
that i don't like i try to expose myself
to
things that i i wouldn't normally expose
myself to
and i think that helps me
not get too deep down any rabbit holes
that are
misleading or or wrong
and i try to also really detach my own
i try as much as i can to detach my ego
and identity from what i believe right
because
the moment i say
it's a core part of my identity that i
believe x y and z
that's the moment that i'm gonna start
believing things that aren't true
because i'm trying to protect my
identity
right so
i try to remain as flexible as possible
as open to new facts and new information
and new paradigms
um not wedded to any one particular
ideology because i think pretty much
every ideology gets something right and
something wrong
right
and um
so and i'm hardly perfect but i try my
best
right right right right
so let's let's get back to the music a
little bit since uh we're playing a
similar arena there so i want to know
what what drove you to start producing
and to start writing uh writing songs
well i've been
i've been obsessed with music since i
was like 12 years old it's my first
passion really
and
it's
um
you know like why does why does anyone
get into music it's like you know it's
the most beautiful thing in the world
and it's it's sort of self-explanatory
at that level but
getting into hip-hop i didn't really get
too deep into producing and
writing bars and that kind of thing
until i was 18.
and it was partly around the time my mom
was sick and eventually passed away
and i was really
using
hip hop to cope with that loss a lot
uh how old were you how were you when
you lost your mother
18. oh wow wow i was 19 when i lost my
mother well it's crazy hard to hear that
yeah
but i think you know
we were talking earlier about how
powerful emotions are usually the
genesis of art
and so that was a huge
formative powerful experience for me
that was
the genesis of my interest in in like
really writing full songs and
um so i dealt with a lot of the emotions
through that and ever since then i've
been i've been producing and and rapping
and trying to sing a little bit
sometimes you know
right right right yeah once you start
one thing you know it leads to another
you know
um so like music is obviously the most
powerful thing so usually there is
always some type of influence that that
sparks that who you who would you say
with your musical influences
and particularly in your type of
position and holding the views that you
do and even me i would say even becoming
more of a religious person um over the
years right so my musical influences
um
versus
versus the fact that i probably disagree
with them and and a political standpoint
but disagree with them as an individual
but like they're still dope you know
what i mean so like i want to know if
like you have to deal with that
dichotomy also
yeah sure i mean
i've always found i can listen to music
by people that disagree with my politics
um
a lot you know like i i can actually
listen to music by people who i think
have really
wrong and kind of hateful views
and if it's good music it's still it
still touches me the humanity of it can
still touch me a hundred percent
um i mean as far as influences i have so
many but
you know as far as rappers go
to narrow it down i mean i love
tyler the creator earl sweatshirt
i love
uh kanye
eminem mf doom kendrick lamar
childish gambino chancellor earlier
chance the rapper
you like rappers you're like real
rappers it's what you just j electronica
right
yeah i mean that's a good place to start
right right now so you mean to the into
the guys who i mean i would say kanye is
both from both you know kanye would
throw bars also too but he's just such a
creative but also tyler the creator just
very very creative out there type of
type of guys that would just do things
that you would never think on a record
right um here's my question right now in
terms of guys that are out that are
positive i don't know if you're very
familiar with this work
one of the guys i think that operate in
that space
and i think this is a problem that's
happened with hip-hop and it's sort of
some of the problems that we're
happening we're having
also in um
a lot of these
social issues that have now become
political
there's a guy by the name of nf you
familiar with nf
okay so enough is from detroit uh i
encourage you to look him up um in terms
of content-wise he's clean meaning that
he
um he doesn't curse
um he's he's almost like a clone of
eminem i was saying a little bit his
style's very similar he's also you know
young white kid from detroit uh but i
think he a guy like him is
he's super talented i think he's
talented than uh you know a good
majority of these guys that are out
right now that's my honest opinion
and i feel like even me being able to
ask you that you not know who he is
although he has millions and millions of
followers and and and broke hashem he's
he's had platinum records but i feel
like a guy like him in the way that the
industry is gone he'll never get
recognition because of the color of his
skin
is that ironic
it's interesting yeah
you know like obviously eminem
was a huge deal as the really like the
first white rapper
where
every great black rapper after him or
many of them at least were influenced by
him and respected him
on irritable terms with the greatest
black rappers
so he really did he broke the it sounds
crazy to say but he kind of broke the
color barrier
right for white rappers
and there have been others in the in the
meantime that i've really gotten a lot
of respect
in the world like mac miller
um right but yeah i mean it's an
interesting thing
i don't know going forward the more and
more
race conscious that we get in the
culture
and the more and more anti-whiteness is
sort of viewed as cool
in the culture
will
will white rappers and i mean like if
you're a young white rapper now i think
it's
in some ways it's easier to come up
because you've had eminem and and those
kind of people before you but in some
ways it's harder to come up because if
you say one wrong thing you make one
misstep people are more going to be
waiting to jump on you now than i think
they were 10 years ago
right right right and it's one of those
things also too where i think in this
particular case is sometimes that you'll
never get that credit for really being
that good because uh you know
it's just been so such a grab on like
you know this is our culture this is us
this is that you know what i mean so
almost feels like a person will never
even get a chance it's been bothering me
a little bit i just kind of i kind of
want to know what you thought about it
you know
so you were a guest on the on the bill
mayor show and you were there to debate
the police brutality and you even
testified in front of uh you know
congress and everything to voice your
opinion on slavery and reparations so
take me through that experience really i
really want to know like what that was
like what's it like to be a guest on the
on the bill mayor like tell me what that
tell me what that was like
well
they put me up in a
really really nice hotel
like way too nice
they treat all their guests the same and
they have people on there that are like
a-list celebrities
so they treat everyone like an a-list
celebrity pretty much by default which
was really cool besides that there's
actually nothing to say because it was
it was
during the height of covet restrictions
in in la
and wow la was extremely
extremely conservative and they're co
not conservative politically but like
risk-averse in their covert policy so we
i couldn't hang out with bill we
couldn't have a get-together we couldn't
have a party we couldn't talk i couldn't
talk to anyone it was mass the whole
time so it's just like straight to
business straight to the show straight
back home
there's really nothing um
i can say about it but it was i mean
it was an honor to be on that show i
really like bill's show i think he
um he's one of the
few voices on the left that really
said is not afraid to disagree with the
trend
and
you know says exactly what he feels
and i think that's really important and
that's why he's so recognized as far as
congress that was kind of a circus that
was much more it was way more
disorganized than i thought it was and
if you've seen the video of these
testimonies
it doesn't really capture the degree of
chaos that was actually in the room like
it felt like it could
almost turn into a riot at any moment
and like no one wanted to do like there
wasn't that much security it was kind of
disorganized it was like
a lot of government functions it's kind
of like half baked and like not that
tightly organized it's kind of kind of a
show
right so do you feel like your voice was
heard
that's my question like
you imagine with the circus is already
one thing but then it's almost something
like sometimes like you feel like you're
talking to
you know
what's your thought are you going there
trying to convince anybody are you are
you only saying like listen if i make a
few good points as long as this is
filmed then i'm going to capture people
out there but i'm not even thinking
about you know trying to change
anybody's mind up there
yeah i was trying to
communicate
as succinctly as possible
what i actually believed
and i was trying to persuade people
um
and it's such a hard format because you
know they they say they give you five
minutes and like an idiot i actually
took that seriously
so i made sure i could say everything in
five minutes and if you know for you
know like five minutes you can't even
say enough that would go into one op-ed
right a short op-ed that that would take
like 10 minutes to read so it's very
difficult to communicate anything subtle
right everyone else on the on the
panel went like 10 15 minutes and i was
like jesus i feel like an idiot i could
have taken my time a little bit more
um
but
at the end of the day i went up there i
said what i thought
and
uh let the chips fall where they may
right
so the biggest thing as long as you feel
you feel like you were successful in it
i mean i just i would never know
my biggest issue has been always with
you know especially these things that
got more poli political i would say
um
is that you know we have
i i call them ride factors what i mean
by ride factors like there are things
that i'm real willing to ride or die for
right
um
political opinions have never really
been something i could ride or die for
even though
over this last year makes a person
really feel like they have to but so
there's a few different ride factors
right ride for me means that ride or die
things right so for political opinions i
couldn't feel like i could ride or die
for it although i could see how you know
over this last
two years or whatever as things have
gotten crazy why people definitely feel
the way that they feel but god is my
thing like that you know so like if if
i'm going to
um you know have to ride about or die
about an opinion it's going to be
because it's my god opinion you know you
understand what i'm saying like for my
faith for me as my thing to where that's
one thing that we're we're not gonna
touch you know and i and i grew up like
i said in in you know in seattle
washington and it was a very politically
correct place and i didn't really know
that you know here we are in 2022
that a lot of the view views that i had
when i was working for the ywca which
was all about empowering women and
fighting systemic racism that when i'm
arguing with people you know at all
these workshops and different things
like that i didn't know that my
my social views would later on become
political views you understand what i
mean so there's a few different things
that i can ride or die for do you ever
get to a point where you feel like
it's just not worth it you know what i'm
saying it's only politics this is a very
small thing i don't know how religious
you are not religious you are whatever
what other thing could be taking you
um
into much more of a space of saying that
this means more important to me than
than politics right now but hopefully my
question was a question yeah
um
i guess
politics is important to me the culture
of the country is important to me the
direction of the culture
is important to me so
and and i do i feel like
if i say it's it's not worth it to weigh
in on something where i think weighing
in
is is useful
right it's kind of like uh
it leads to a vacuum that just other
people step in and push their point of
view right and it's like
it's a little bit like the argument for
why america should you know intervene in
foreign affairs sometimes it's like
we pull our troops out of there russia's
going to put their troops in there
china is going to take over right if we
stop influencing
it's just someone worse is gonna come in
right so it's not that we wanna be doing
that
it's that
someone's gonna do it so it might as
well be us and i think
a lot of times when i'm weighing in on
political issues
it's you know everyone's going to be
weighing in and i know
my perspective is
it's it's often not going to be the
dominant perspective
and so i feel like i don't say something
i'm letting i'm just letting other
people dominate the narrative more and
so
i want to do my part
right but um but yeah i mean at the end
of the day you have to pick your biggest
battles definitely right and
so not everything is is a ride or die
issue for me
um not everything is an issue that i'm
gonna stake my whole
reputation on
right
yeah you have to sort of yeah you have
to you have to pick your battles you
have to pick your battles okay so my
last but not least question i would say
also to on this
is sort of sticky so my understanding is
i ask you a man of faith but you you
consider yourself an atheist right i've
been a jew i've been a muslim been a
christian i've done my my fair share of
whatever were there at any point that
you were ever
a person of faith or anything like that
or you know how did it come come to be
about that you would
become an atheist
uh no there was no point at which i
believed in a literal god
no i've done
i've done meditation retreats i've done
psychedelics
i've
felt
i felt what you'd probably call
spiritual experiences
radical connectedness to
all people and
uh radical empathy for all
beings and and
i've had those kind of experiences i've
also had
you know strange experiences while
meditating
where my entire body felt like
it almost like i had taken some drug
and it was it was like tingling and
shining head to toe i've had
strange things happen and i so i tend to
believe
that people have
um
experienced the strange things they say
they experience
whether it's a spiritual experience a
religious experience and so forth
but i've never believed in a literal god
that can hear my prayers or that
um is is running things um from heaven
uh so i never had that belief to begin
with and i never
uh became persuaded with with any
particular religion so i've never i've
never developed that belief
really so it's like in the house you
were raised that way like your family
was that way or it was like i want to
know how
neither of my parents believed in god
so they didn't raise us to believe
um god
and and i never
went into any particular belief system
on my own
right
so has there ever been a moment it's not
my last question has it ever been a
moment where you hoped that god exists
um
it's a good question
thank you
[Laughter]
so at least one you have to think about
so
you know i don't
i think it's it's hard for me to even
[Music]
really entertain seriously the idea that
there is a god up there
um to even hope for it
i i'm not sure i can bring myself to
hope for it sincerely
right um
on the other hand i think
a lot of the attitude in life that would
come with a belief in god i think is
positive
you know like this idea of being
radically grateful for everything that
you're given all of your talents
all of your
um
like the idea of really meditating on
your blessings in life
i think is
it's like the healthiest thing an
individual can do is to look at
everything that's gone
well in their life and dwell on it
and
not really take credit for it understand
that you've been given gifts right
and to
walk through life humbly as a result of
that i think is
is the
like having that kind of attitude
if when that comes from religion or
belief in god i think it's a really
beautiful thing
um so i can't say that i've ever hoped
that god is real
you know call me back on my deathbed i
might have a very different attitude
i definitely thought that
uh
some of the attitudes that can come with
a belief in god are deeply healthy
deeply healthy amazing amazing okay
listen man i i want to tell you man i'm
definitely a uh
a a big fan of everything i've been
exposed to
obviously i'm on god's team but other
than that i i definitely want to tell
you no doubt about it that uh you know
just the the courage the amount of
courage that it takes
um to stand up and to fight even after
losing friends and being ridiculed and
and fighting for something that you
believe i think that we all share that
that is
that it's it's a uh
it's a it's something that
definitely during these times
we don't see a lot so that's why you
know people such as yourself anytime it
happens it's like it's so celebrated you
know um from people who who want to have
that courage but they don't necessarily
have it so i want to wish you you know a
blessing you should only go from
strength to strength and you should have
only success in every single thing you
do i thank you so much for coming on the
show
it's my pleasure
awesome thank you
[Music]
you