0:00 / 0:00
Nasa Na 1931 #7 - what is proper praise? no eulogies in Chabad- why? Stories Abt this
37 views
Comments(0)
Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
so we're in the middle of the mimer nasa
no alias
which is the passage in malachim 2
chapter 4
uh with the issue of tsunamis
who
sees this uh
person who passes her house very often
and she says to her husband this is a
special man
ish
he's a godly man he's holy or even elena
utamid he's can't we he's constantly
passing by
and therefore let's make for him a room
and put in the room uh uh a bed uh a
table a chair and a menorah
this is um
a
that not only is it a a actual story in
recorded tanakh which that itself is
already special
but it has much significance as
documented in the zeira kurdish in the
holy zoa
with desire impartials i believe the
true mode that's having
volume 2 of desire page 133
the zayar comments that these
four items
are ways of being messaging correcting
the sheena because the shrina
is in golos and we need to correct the
shrine
and desire says that the way to do it is
using these four items comes along the
free the cab
based on discourses that his ancestors
already said
years before
and he elaborates on this idea and he
says that this refers to
the aveda of the evening the evening
service and the morning service
evening we know to be my river in the
morning we know to be shocked
but here in this miner that ebba has
explained and we've learned most of it
that the evening service in particular
we refer not just to my river but more
importantly to krishna
and as i said in the past urim
the pair's classes that this is not so
common
commonly discussed in jewish writing
and especially not in you know the
talmud and places like that so
there's added significance
to all of this
what did he say is the idea of krishna
mita he said to make a hajj you have to
make an account
and he said the account has to consist
of two things
what should my day have looked like
and what did my day look like
so in mentioning what it should have
looked like
what it what it should have looked like
it says it should have looked like that
when you get up in the morning you jump
out of your bed you say no don't leave
me first you jump out of your bed you
wake up like like a lion he doesn't say
that here but that's the concept
and then you say
psalms some songs miss maori to hillary
and then he says you learn some torah he
says
everyone based on their ability
following that you're dabbing with a
minion and that literally means
dominating with a minion if you're able
to we're talking about the situation as
a normal situation where you can go out
of your house
and you don't
say
hey you know
i'm dominating with
gathering my ten coco nephesh my ten
soul powers together you have to be a
very special holy person
and refined person to really feel that
but you go to a show where nine other
jews are davening and you're diving with
them shimon nestle together otherwise
you're not david with a minion just for
the record
you could be in a shul for hours upon
hours and if you don't end up dropping
smallness with dominion you haven't
governed that morning with a minion
so you die
yes
so if you come late to school and
they're and they're starting with
monastery
can you just start with monastery no go
back to them no
you cannot no you cannot do that halal
is something called
you could say certain parts of sukhitis
krishna
and then
you cannot just start necessary and get
credit no the answer is no
but even the halachic way of piracy
that we that i just mentioned is not the
recommended way and definitely not the
hasidic way definitely not the chabad
way i never in my life have done that
not once and i never believe that they
will do that because according to the
kabbalah
tv is a ladder
and if you and if you're on the last
rung and you try to go up to the top
rung you're going to fall and break your
feet and hurt yourself
spiritually if you're just starting to
daven and you need to involve yourself
in the abode of hashem
which is a certain mindset and and and
avodah
you're not prepared to go into the
chamber with god in this monastery and
all it'll do is just mess you up
spiritually
so therefore according to kabbalistic
writings it is not a recommended thing
again according to
if you want to follow that script
technically there is a way of jumping
around
but uh it's not the recommended way
so the bottom line is practically
speaking
sometimes you gotta wait between one and
two million
i like in the morning now in order to
make the shear now
i get up earlier i go to the first
minion which i don't dabble with
because they dive in before the nights
before uh sunrise
but i hear all the creoles all the
predation and creosote and everything
then i go downstairs and i dive in with
the nate's minion
so i've got him with the minion and then
after an s-ray i try to say tachnon
evolution and i take my chilling off and
i come home
so i've already heard all the
foundations from before and i got the
credit for dabbing with the minion
because i died and i ended up dabbing
although at the first minion i was there
the entire time i didn't i didn't put
two on that thousand trillion on so you
have to know that the technicalities how
to
how to get around and how to
navigate
the chart of halakha when it comes to
minion but let's get to the yes yes hilo
uh since you're on that subject um
and when do you uh put on rebecca tom
the villain
i i like now i'm going to put it on
after the sheer because i have to this
year is i'm teaching torah robin has
more importance if if i wasn't if i
didn't have this obligation i would i
would do it in in ensure
but but technically you should know that
you could put on
roberto
so you want the bracha from rashi to go
on the rabbino times too see it's better
not to make an interruption so it's
better to to put them on one of after
the other but in a situation like this
this takes precedence uh halfway because
it's
the rabbit
i i noticed
is this like a khabad thing that they
put on a lot of times uh romano tom
after monastery like you know by the
time like ashrae valencian no
it's not khabar on the contrary it's not
khabar it's the other has to do that
in khabad we're very we're very careful
not to put regular times till after we
say till him after a late
if the only hasidic group that says to
heal him with a with a minion
should say taylor with a minion
is is because the previous never said
that is khabad everyone else does what
you say they take their trillion off
during khazar's shots and they put on
rabbit times and they say they have a
source for it
yes hilo
the um
uh
so when you um you consider making
or having uh eating something a hashtag
between the filling
look again how logically the answer is
no
the answer is no because rapeno thomas
is not the each of the trillion
it's right the nikkor film is rashi
so you put on rashi you yield to the
mitzvah
however there are some people that will
not make a hepc but i i i i haven't you
know
there are people that will do that
because they want to
keep the bracha from rashi to roberto
tom and in fact they won't make an
interruption even speaking so these are
all but that's not halloween you could
you could do it you're right
you know yes i i mean i i once saw a
teaching i think it was from baruch
measurements yeah um
because who had a whole prac practice of
you know
making a half-sick daca eating something
and having a cup of coffee between the
film okay
a very different mahala okay you know i
i don't know i mean who who follows that
today i mean who who specifically does
that that would be interesting to know
next time
next time you're in tone the country
find out because i i i never heard of
anyone specifically doing that that's
very that's new to me but it could be
you know there's
yeah anyway let's go back so
so the rabbit speaks about this so the
third thing is philippe sebor
then he says followed by going to work
and here too it must be mentioned it
doesn't say it's optional after you dive
and you go to work one person is writing
for one person it's it's true it's
drawing for another person it's it's
being a doctor and everyone in their own
way whatever their work is and he says
you go to work and you're careful not to
have a from a vac or no
it's interesting that the rebbe uses
these words avaca no means the dust
of deception how logically you're not
allowed to receive someone more than i
think a sixth
it's called
um
a bach means that the the edges the dust
you know you're not ripping them off
you're not ripping them off
but you just
you know you're just not saying the
entire truth it says but ever
that after to healing and learning and
diving with a minion when you go to work
you got to be careful not to do a vocal
no two and number five
is he says
while you're working
you should think about what can i do as
a camilla's reset for someone else
because then you show that the work is
not just about putting cash in your
pocket and even to your own family but
you're thinking about someone else
says that but this is the way it should
be
however then you say to yourself now i
make 100 how was my day
i got up in the morning i took the
garbage out i cleaned the house i
checked the internet
i did sarcas first i did all the things
for my house okay
not great i gotta serve a chef first the
next thing is i sometimes don't go to
download the minion
then he says even if you go down with a
minion
you don't know what you're saying
because you go
you know and you know you have no idea
what you're saying it comes out it's
it's it's disgusting
so that's that's the way i dive in this
morning it was just by road right
and then he says you go to work
and you deceive people
you rip people off you say lies you make
up stories
and finally you're only thinking about
yourself how you can make more money or
you couldn't have more partners and all
that about
your friend you're the other you don't
think at all and guess what he says you
don't even think about your neshama
you don't think about what's better for
my soul to work harder to work
to work more hours or less hours all of
this is the
part of the hash but you have to make
at night
and that ever said that when you do all
this
you he said a line that's worth
repeating he says
you'll have less heartache
and you'll be healthier and he means
that literally uh velvet
because we all know stress kills and
stress causes heart attack and all of
that
so when you
are into your work and business and all
that and you're running for the deal you
make yourself crazy you're running all
around think you'll make an extra buck
and all that it causes heartache and
stress and it makes you sick
says that ever be smart
be focused don't lose sight of what the
goal is
right and then you'll be healthier and
this is all part of the discussion and
it's worth each one of you should
re-learn this and really memorize it i
reviewed this my murray school shabbos i
had a birthday this week as you know so
i said a bible shabbos and shul in honor
of it and i just took the this first
section of christian shalom and i added
a little bit at the end and i
you know shared it with with with the
people in shu
the and it to me this is so therapeutic
and so uh refreshing even though i've
learned this many many times from when
i'm a 16 70 year old boy a teenager okay
but each time i learn it i see new
things in it and especially gives me uh
more opportunity for improving myself so
let's continue now we're on page
just just something it's very apropos
today you were talking about the stress
aspect and everything yeah you see how
this today's stress is off the charts so
uh you know i don't know if he was
predicting you know such hard times like
difficult times but it it really
contributes i'm sure that the stress
contributes to all the issues that today
that you know that we're
that we're seeing today right right
right yoni i want to say something you
know
you know people make themselves stressed
too
someone will want to travel somewhere i
said to them now is not the time to
travel
stay home stay home
there's so many cancellations and
there's so many rules you don't know if
you can end up staying or coming and
they'll let you come back
you know last week there was a couple
with some children who came for a
wedding i know that she used to be a
teacher for me in a seminary that had
their shallow 15 years ago anyway
excellent teacher bestiacal
knowledgeable fine person so they came
her parents live here around the corner
and they came for a family sim club but
they didn't bring all the children's
they left some of their children back in
jerusalem
they announced you know uh during that
week that they're closing the borders
and they're not letting closing the
flights that was last week right
so they had to leave the wedding
before 12 to make the flight so that
they the deadline of the next flight
they wouldn't be able
now i'm asking you i'm just saying here
they came for a sim club
and unannounced
this is what this was what took place
now i'm not saying they were wrong for
wanting to come to sim club
but you know
it's like i i repeat always what i told
you is before what this ben brafman this
famous criminal lawyer
he said to the borough partnership to 2
000 of them
before
a tissue above one year i was there
they had all these these these borough
park is there and he says guys
i have a son that learns in co little
tunisia and here he is clean-shaven you
know
modern or what looks like modern
orthodox
and he's talking to this hussein
and he says my son is in yerushalayim
but guess what the f
after he he learns for a half a day he
goes and works and earns a living
and then he said and he had a hasidic
rabbit sitting next to him i don't want
to say which one
who he and his god by were accused of
different things i don't want to get
into that either
but as a plea bargain probably he told
them you sit next to me it'll be good
for presenting your case for the judge
and he says
there are certain times that certain
things the government is looking
at you from with 20 eyes
and you don't do it you stay away at
that time
there are other times they don't care
about it i'll give you an example we're
a basket
the time that the whole bastion fiasco
took place
the the government you remember was
going crazy about illegal immigration
and that was one of the accusations was
he legally i'm not saying right or wrong
but the timing was couldn't be any worse
the other issue at the time was unions
and the whole issue up there with with
the bosch complaint was involved unions
fighting the unions
i remind myself of another in los
angeles years ago
a very bright rabbi a supper
talented accomplished
they caught him
he was talking to an undercover agent
with money laundering
and they came down on him they locked
them up
because at that time they were looking
for rabbis and
priests clergy they wanted to show that
clergy you can't get away with money
laundering or anything like that
point this or ben brother said you have
to smell the situation out there so when
you mention now the stress
the situation is the way it is it's out
of out of control
we're not going to change what the cdc
says and what this governor says and
what this guy says
it's a okay it's not happening these
people have their agendas and they do
whatever they want with us
unfortunately that's the way it is and
you see when when trump and company
tried to to to force themselves it
caused the res that you know
you see on january 6 what took place and
it's still reeling and it's still
you know and to me the timing was the
worst timing you could have done any
other time but here he knows he's
leaving office and
again
i'm not saying that he was
behind it 100 even though some say that
and could be
but
but the timing was wrong so when you say
stress
it says the wise man
his eyes are in his cup his head
who is wise horrendous and ireland who
sees the future
the future now is that right now we're
in the situation so just
sit back
yeah so maybe you can't go so you can't
go
but least you won't have that stress
it's fair look stress i know what you're
saying it's confronting stress really
but
there are ways of mitigating the stress
and that is up to the individual
it is us who has the free will to decide
whether we should involve ourselves in
certain situations and then have more
stress or say no i'm not getting
involved
because right now i can't make a change
and if i'll get involved i'll be more
upset my family are upset my community
and it'll be a bigger mess
and this is an ongoing issue you know
how do you balance the idea of standing
up for what's right
and lay and sitting back and laying back
and it's an ongoing issue and this is
where you have to be thoughtful
you have to think it over
you have to discuss it with some people
intelligent people
and and then usually
you'll have less stress let's get back
to the binder
page 132.
we're here at the bottom of the mimer
where the rabbit talks about the
difference between
maidani
seemingly maidani means i give thanks to
god
and hashem means i give thanks to god
what's the difference
so he says briefly that her might on
these when you rot when you when you
open up your eyes
at that point you didn't study yet you
didn't learn
it's the simple faith and
acknowledgement
god you gave me back my neshama you
returned
my
picado you're interested in what's a
picado like you said last week
but my deposit i got it
my deposit
i see i don't forget what you tell when
you tell us your honest and i remember i
tried to at least
so i i i you returned the deposit
my nasham is here
no
i'm thankful and then you start
when you get to hoydu
you've already said brachas
you've already said car bonus
you've already dressed yourself
you've already began to
to evolve
here
it's not just hondura in the sense of
acknowledgements the rabbit says here
it's
in the sense of acknowledgement and
praise
and that's why
in reading the haidu that that chapter
of tillet i hope you've done this
you've translated it and you'll see
that haidu
la shem kirivashmi talks about the
mountains and the rivers and the seas
in other words we are already
talking about
development
and when we see this development how god
creates the world we're mashable we lord
and praise god
in order to praise you have to be fully
developed you have to be mindful
acknowledgement
is not praise
that's the point he makes it briefly and
i want to just elaborate acknowledgement
means thank you
thank you doesn't require
knowledge
thank you is thank you
praise
how can you praise someone if you praise
someone and you don't know anything
about them you are a charlatan you're a
faker you're a phony you're a fraud and
we have plenty of that too
you have to know a person
to praise the person
you know i make these clips sometimes
about people obituaries about people and
i would like to make him up more people
but i didn't know them well
so what what am i going to do make up
stories
if i had over my lifetime a relationship
with them and i saw them and i spoke to
them and etc i could speak about them in
a way that's meaningful
because i could praise them based on my
own experiences
if i just read about them and have no
connection
i feel i'm just repeating what others
said and again there is a place for
repetition but not when you want to make
a meaningful obituary at least i don't
feel that way you know
so so
praise
is knowing the person you praise your
children
we talk about praising your children
you need to know your children
because praising them without knowing
them
is fake
and guess what they're gonna they're
gonna they're gonna they're gonna tell
you you don't mean it you don't know you
don't know what i'm going through how
could you praise me
oh i was told that the recipe for a good
family dynamic is praise
well that's you know that's very uh
superficial
get to know them
then you can praise them
and and guess what when you get to know
someone you get to know their
deficiencies too right so when you
praise them you praise that aspect
that's good
and you won't
lie
and praise something that's no good and
that's by the way one of the reasons why
in chabad we don't make has paid him
you know we don't make eulogies
even for the greatest person the
greatest hussain
rabbi raichiko will show them
the previous
los angeles he was so careful to tell
i'm talking about schmool david right
the father
not the one who passed away now rabbi
shimon raichi
he was so careful he went he went uh to
a um
he went to someone's leviah and it
stopped off in the yeshiva in the
khabari shiva los angeles
and this person was a good friend of
mine but i already lived here
and all they did was they set off you
know they put the the r and the casket
down in front the dharan kaidish and the
yeshiva buffalo were there and and the
shiva someone said a few words about him
rabbi raichik went over to the son who
just passed on shim and he said
basically when i when it's my time to go
i don't want a word said about me
and they didn't overdo it at the at
my father-in-law was that way too he he
you know he left instructions he doesn't
want anyone to talk about it
and it was very hard because we made a
slash him
and we called up a few people and some
of them weren't chabad
and they you know spoke about what type
of person he was they knew him
so
slation is different by the way than
than at levaya the the the paid
the the particular
um
non-uh speaking about someone that
chabad doesn't do
as a eulogy
is primarily at the time of the
leviathan you know understand not
legislation
why
why because if you say something
and it's not true
it's damaging for the person's soul
lying about a person at the time when
the person's the shaman returns to
hashem it's very bad it's a very very
bad stain it's not good
so khabad says just keep quiet
don't say anything
in the lichfish in the lit world
and in the hasidic world they
they pour it on they shower it up
and again that's there
tell you a story i'm telling you a lot
of stories today
one of the
preeminent khabad khasid
was a rav in tel aviv his name was
islam
he was he was he learned in the early
years in the in the babaji yeshiva in
russia
in the night
1899 and
1900 in those years 1901
and he was known as shobein
shah bed and he was a muslim he was a
great he knew gemara hallach
he was like in every in every field he
was gifted
he passes on in 64.
and
rabbi yaakov landau the the
the rabbi chief rabbi of bernay brock
was a friend of his and he was in charge
of like the the funeral in a way
and he and you know
rabbi haskell sarna of
came from came from europe when he came
over
comes to the levia because since they
were both
you know from russia and rabbanim you
know that like i'm writing about now you
know if
a certain period were very intertwined
you know and and they they grew up
together in the communities
so
now comes to the levia
and he goes over to rabbi yaakov landau
who we knew and he says
you know he doesn't say you know i want
to speak
but he alludes to him that
he's prepared a eulogy
we don't make any
now you understand he's talking now to
rabbi sarnath
who was
a big talented
shiva you know
and robert landau who was older than him
i believe
uh he didn't budge he said this is the
way it's going to be there are no
eulogies this isn't absolute bear
yes he was the rav in tel aviv
but
he is lubavitch in its pristine
state this is real the babbage from the
rashad
you know you know you're talking he
doesn't say all that but
so
okay he doesn't so rabies aren't quiet
when the casket was about to be put down
over the in the earth absurd in castle
in in ludwig
who was a student
of
rabbi sharon bear sisling
in one of the cities nearby into the
babaji shiva
he went over to the casket
and he
said rebbe whenever he called them that
when you go to heaven
remind the rabbi
that means they're ashab
that we are a succeeded
and this is a an age-old
blessing that le baba hasidim would say
to someone who they knew who was passed
on
parenthetically
when reflected kaaba passed away
zalman schechter his good friend
went over to the casket of slimer
and he said to him
remind the rebel that we are his cousin
can you say that again it was choppy i
didn't hear it
okay but take off
and they said yeah but take off take off
he said
the the
i don't know if you're talking to me
abby but if you're talking to me
as alma shafter said to slay mcconnell
as he's laying in his casket over there
he's talking to a box
and he says to him
this was a standard and i'm still i
don't know what standard this was done
by some of the babaji qasid
at the time when accossed passed away
so rafale mccain
did this to his rebbe
raphael bears island
rabbi haskell sarna we're standing right
there and he's a hardcore lit
and he says i i heard this was someone
who was there
he says
i didn't know that in heaven they're
also playing the game of rebbie and
hussit
in other words
nick was it was a lit so to him the
whole idea of hasidim and a rapper was
like a game that was his that's where he
came from
so he said i could i i i i saw i knew
that playing this game while people are
alive
but after the death they're still
playing that game
so
the idea of eulogies
the idea of eulogies is something not to
be toyed with and played with be very
very careful and again
nili khabad is not to be eulogized okay
at the time of the quran for sure
meaning that day
at the schleischen there's a little more
room for it you know
so what why why am i talking about this
because we're talking here about praise
when i when i learned this part of the
mimer or learning this part that
hashem
is not only thankful giving
acknowledgement
but it's also
it's also praise
praise is a loaded gun
because praise has to be emis
praise is not stupidity there's a big
mistake people make
they they they shower praise and it's
bubble mices lies false that's not
praise
that's scary that's lies
praise has to be emma's so therefore
when you've already started said maidani
and you've said bruce and you got
dressed and you said car bonus and you
put on your towers and fill in you're
already in the ballpark once because
you've been thinking about god you've
been making a hundred when you make a
bra how you're feeling you think about
what you're saying
well you know take a look tomorrow
morning there's instructions what you're
supposed to think about
before you make the broken thousand
philly
it's not just written instructions that
means every morning
we have to think about this before we
put on the towers and make the broker
and the throne and it's in the center
look it up
when you do that
you say hey
not only am i giving thanks hashem but
i'm calling in his name mean to say i'm
calling in his name with praise as it
says and it's enumerated of great detail
in the heidel that's the i believe the
last part that we learned last week now
let's go let's go to the bottom of 132
and um
one two three four five six lines from
the bottom in middle towards the the
last five words on the page
afterwards you start organizing the
praise
omar
so we start saying if the heider what do
we do moshe we do borrow mark this is
up and then we do
verses of praise
he name is
um
at this point one's
understanding and comprehension of
hashem
has been expanded and greatened
realizing how the godly energy
enlivens all of creation
this comprehension
has now been comprehended velveo
by the human mind
to the extent
that even the the the
the mindset of the animal drive of the
yet saharan africa bomb is
can also comprehend this
we'll conclude here but the point being
the point being
that what
what hap where are we at as far as
we're at a point where our self our
nephesh obama's our yate sahara
starts hearing
some sense that it can relate to you see
when we come into davening
of rum every morning
who is the we
the we is the physical the drive the
indulgence the nathan obama's the yates
of horror
it's not interested in praying it's not
interested in god it's not equal to
spirituality
so we have to
soften it up loosen it up
work on it that's the that's the order
of tefila it's a it's a it's a it's a
progression
where we go from being not interested at
all to be interested a little bit to
being more interested and filing being
transformed that's the four runs of
trilo
and shmonesri
are four ways in which we climb and
elevate and refine the nephesh obama so
that ebba says here
when we say baruch
and we read you know about creation and
who is the creator and the purpose of
creation as i said it says there and he
says and then we go to the
hallelujahs praising god for creating
the rivers and the earth and then and
the the mountains and all of that
what this this talks to the fish obama's
like i i got quality what rabbi hadin
schneizel said
evan i mean
would say if a brengan is a good party
the nephew obama says a party i'll come
to
i'm not coming to a shirt
but a party you have food you have vodka
you have you have singing you have
camaraderie you have talking
i'll be there you tell me when and where
yes
uh is this um
the fulfillment of the
admonition in the tanya to to um
contemplate the godless of hashem
it's not the fulfillment a little bit
it's not the fulfillment it's it's part
of it
and and you know when you when you say
the the the greatness of hashem there's
the awesome part and there is the loving
part so davenink
full dabbing incorporates all of it yes
okay any questions by anyone on what we
learned today
my shirt it seemed like you want to say
something
well it's good it's it's it's it's
it's it's
not very good yeah okay kevin we'll see
everyone tomorrow have a great day beam
up sleep take care
bye-bye