Preparing video...
0:00 / 0:00
Author Tuvia Tenenbom Joins Nachum on Today's JM in the AM
157 views
Nachum Segal welcomed renowned author/journalist Tuvia Tenenbom back to JM in the AM this morning to discuss his storied career, his take on antisemitism based on his travels and work, his latest book "Careful , Beauties Ahead! My Year with the Ultra-Orthodox" and more.
Categories:Music
Comments
Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
Tobia Tan. My pleasure to welcome you to
JM in the AM.
>> Pleasure to be with you.
>> I appreciate that.
>> So you were born in Benet Brock.
>> I mean physically in Tel a Viv.
>> Ah
>> but my parents are from Nebra and
[clears throat] uh after the hospital
after I was born I was taken to but
[clears throat] my passport it says Tel
a Viv.
>> Right. But the reason I bring it up and
the reason I say it like that is because
and I always like to point this out. You
know the whole routine. In other words,
when you go and explore Maya Sharim
>> or or or you have an adventure that you
know involves our people, especially
those who are part of the religious and
ultra religious community. You're very
very familiar with it.
>> Uh yes and no. Yes, I was born into it.
But that has been some years. To remind
you I'm 21 years of age.
>> All right.
>> So obviously it took some years and uh
when I was there I was a very young boy
and I saw the world then from the
perspective of a young boy. Now I see I
got the chance to see the world to
replay my life decades later and to see
it from a perspective of a grownup which
is very interesting number one. Number
two, I didn't know anybody in me shar
you know by the by the time I came back
you know because most of the time was in
>> right
>> and so for the book I was in Merim I was
with my wife Izzy and we were there for
about a year and a half including also
some weeks in Ben boy break and to my
luck and I didn't know that this is my
best first surprise when I go into a
showroom I walk on the street and
everybody Not everybody but almost
everybody.
>> And how did they know you?
>> This is what surprised me. They read the
books.
They were they were from and at that
point
>> yeah in the book in your book because
catch the Jewish in Hebrew and they say
ini
>> on page 137
base
>> they give you these details huh
>> the five just go back
>> just go back
>> I get that but what just just go back
for a second you so you leave that whole
Ben arena. At what age? Like are you
gone from there as a very little kid or
as a teenager? When are you
>> I went as a teenager I left the ultra
orthodox world and I moved into the
orthodox world. I moved to
>> Oh wow.
>> And then when I was in America I saw
they don't know how to study. They don't
know Talmud because compared to what I
learned you know it was totally
different. I mean it's like you cannot
compare. There's no there's no
it was not it was not the way we studied
the Talmud you know it was totally
different not to mention
and all that thing and what you know
nothing I mean comparison you know and
in the world we we learned you know
And then
one second, one second, but you're
surprising me with this. In other words,
you go to America and what the the
spirit, the atmosphere is different when
it comes to Torah study.
>> They don't know how to study.
>> What does that mean?
>> It's like,
so it's an academic pursuit instead of
>> Yeah. kind of academic, you know.
>> What was it in Brock? It was what kind
of pursuit?
>> I told you. I told you.
So,
you know,
>> so it was more so it was more of a
spiritual uplifting experience.
>> Number one and number two. It was
compared.
Everything goes. Everything goes and are
you sitting on the chair or does the
chair sit under you?
>> Right.
>> So say to an average person from from
America and he thinks you lost your
mind. What do you mean you the chair
sits underneath you is you don't
understand. You don't understand these
things. You know, it's like
>> how they handle how they handle Brisco.
>> They don't even know.
[laughter]
They don't know. It's like, you know,
it's not and they don't have theidic
passion, you know. This is the
passion. You know,
they don't have it.
>> How long were you in the America Sarav
area? I was six months
>> and then
>> and then I decided okay this is not for
me and then I moved
um um I met up from Shapiro and we both
decided this is not for me.
>> Wow.
>> And then I moved to Edder
>> where
>> in Malot.
>> Wow. So I went to I was there and then
uh I immediately realized that in terms
of Talmud they have nothing to teach me
>> and I didn't even go to the classes
because I said this is a classes for
dumb people with low IQ.
>> Wow.
>> That's the way I saw it. You know
>> this was a Hezra Yeshiva and Malotra
Malot. So the Roshiva came to me and
said how come you don't come to classes
I study by Rosovski
and I
teach in the style of Rashmoski. said to
him listen and I studied
was the brother of and much more than
him I don't need you to teach me how to
study gam and he looked at me said you
study roofski I said yes of course said
okay you don't have to come to classes I
have nothing to give you
>> wow
>> but what but what it gave me is I served
in the I army
>> right
>> I was in the tank units
>> around what year
>> and I became a tank driver
>> around what year was this?
>> 77
78 something like that.
>> Post 7.
>> So I became a a tank driver. That's
where I learned how to drive. I did not
learn how to drive on a on bicycles, on
cars, you know, I came from a totally
different world. To this day, I don't
know how to drive a bicycle, you know.
Kill me. I don't know how to do it. I
don't know how to swim. I don't like
beaches. I don't know how to swim. Never
taught me how to swim. But it's funny
because you come off as such a
courageous and brave person. I would
think that the sense of adventure would
be very high and that these types of
activities would be
>> Of course I I of course I tried. I fell.
I went to the I went to even to a small
pool. I drowned.
>> So you gave up. [laughter and gasps]
>> It's like what's the point? You know, I
said, you know, I live I lived all my
life at that time without a bicycle and
without, you know,
>> but our Talmud does tell us the
importance of knowing how to swim.
>> I know, of course, but
they never say
they didn't that page I didn't study.
Put it this way.
>> When do you start the world of
journalism? Because I want to get to the
point where you're writing these books
and really investigating in your unique
way. When did you start doing that?
>> Um, one time it was in 2008 I think. I
was in u in uh Saudi Arabia in Riyad.
Are you
>> because I got a I got a an invitation
from President Bush at that time to join
the president on his Middle Eastern ride
and I
took from that part I took only the part
of Saudi Arabia because at that time a
Jew could not go into Saudi Arabia
especially a Jew was born in Israel and
ser in the Israeli army. I tried to take
a visa by the on the on the Saudi
website and two questions I couldn't
answer. Where were you born?
You have a list of countries. Israel did
not exist,
>> right?
>> What religion did you grow up in?
Judaism did not exist,
>> right?
>> But uh the White House, you know, I told
the White House, are you are you making
fun of me? I mean, it's like I cannot
get on my own. You know, you should have
known that I couldn't get on my own. I
said, don't worry. Send us a passport.
will get you the visa. So I sent him the
passport and three days later I had it
already with a stamp from the Saudi
government and it says on it that I am
in the delegation of the United States
presidents,
>> right?
>> Means I'm totally cautious
>> and and you were invited because you
were a journalist.
>> Yeah, because I wrote a few little
things, you know, it's like all my life
I studied journalism one of the things.
So I wrote in little papers here and
there and then I wrote an article um in
the Italian paper called Corera de laera
Ka de laera and they put it on front
page how does a Jew get along in Saudi
Arabia. It was very funny and then
somebody from the site from Germanite
you know uh called me up and said can
you write for us also about your
experiences in Saudi Arabia.
I wrote them and obviously the the
German audience loved the article and
they said, "Give us this man more and
more." You know, we forgot already what
Jewish humor is. We forgot already. One
of the letters, for example, said after
we killed the Jews, we don't even know
what Jewish humor is. And it's
>> so it was a humorous article.
>> Yeah. Yeah. So, by the end of the day, I
started writing for them. And I wrote
more and more and more. One time I even
wrote from
an old article about
>> How many languages do you know?
>> Um,
a little bit English.
>> Yeah, we got that.
>> A little bit English.
>> Yeah.
>> A little bit Hebrew.
>> Any others?
>> Little bit German and a little bit
Arabic.
>> All self-taught.
>> Yes.
>> Interesting. Um, Tovia Tanibam is with
us. Does that trip become part of your
first book?
>> So just a second now. So after I have
started writing for the for the site
which is one of the biggest papers in
Germany. It's like the New York Times of
Germany
>> only higher level of journalism.
>> Um so I started writing for them and
then one day I get a call from I got an
email from one of the publishing
companies in Germany. Would I mind? you
know the editor says I love your
articles and decided do you mind to
write for us a book come to Germany and
write a book for us. So I went there,
came to Germany together with my Asia
Kyle and we traveled around Germany for
a long time and then the book came out I
sleep in Italy
>> and and that title was why that title
>> why the title because I actually slept
in it
>> literally in his bedroom
>> literally yeah in in his room he had a
place as that he was in charge of
renewing it's called the the elephant
hotel. Today it's in Vimmer today and
during the after the Vimemer Republic
you know when he became the leader
>> he made it with a whatever with an
architect whatever
redid it and then he had one room one
suite that was is when he came to Vimma
you know to that place the German the
Germans were the people were gathering
in a square a big square in front of the
hotel and They were yelling and
screaming fear fear
uh get out of your elephant house you
know and then the fear would get out and
stand in the balcony do zig eye and the
audience would go crazy so that's what
uh
>> that's where you stayed
>> so I stayed there I went to the balcony
I saw like a bunch of Germans working on
the street and I did the guy I just
wanted to see as you'll do it the way
did They answered me back the guy. It
was very
>> Are you serious?
>> So is that the book where you where you
expose what what Europeans actually
think of Jews?
>> Yes, that's the first one and that
became a huge bestseller in Germany. It
was for months it was on the bestseller
list. It's like the New York Times
bestseller. But but I thought that their
desire is to is to try to uh is to try
to express, you know, that they've moved
on from World War II and that they can't
tolerate, you know, being referred to
the way they're referred to when it
comes, you know, to their attitude
toward Jews. But they
>> That's true. The publisher
and the publisher on the first publisher
when they got a copy, my editor loved
the book. She said, "Tuia, I cried and I
left." And then the publisher, the ad of
the publishing company read a book and
he sent me an email. He said, "I'm
sorry, I cannot publish it. You don't
know how to write."
>> And what he really meant was, "I can't
publish.
>> Can you teach me?" He said, "Yes,
>> what he really meant was that he can't
>> I will edit I will edit the book." So he
edited the book and said, "No, it's a
good book." And I looked at his editing.
If somebody said, "Uh, I can't stand the
Jews," it changes. I can't stand the
Israeli. If somebody said all the Jews
to die, you know, it changed at all.
There was a chapter about club 88, which
is 88 stands for HH, which is Iler, you
know, there was a chapter in the book
about a neo-Nazi club and he took this
all out. Basically, he made Germany look
much nicer than the book was. So, he had
a big fight and it became a big fight
also in the in the German media. He
broke the contract and
It all looked like doomed. But then
another publishing company So got along
and they published the book and it
became
>> a real the real manuscript. They
published the real manuscript.
>> Yeah. Yeah. The real one and
>> and that's the translation we have of
the real of the book you actually wrote.
>> Exactly. And that became a huge a huge
bestseller and that started them the the
book business. I never thought about
writing books.
>> Right.
>> And then the next book was about Catch
the Jew.
>> Right.
>> No. My editor said to me, you came to us
to Germany and you spend your month and
then you came out in a book with a book
claiming that 80% of us are
anti-semites. Okay. Now I challenge you
go to your country where you are born to
Israel stay there a few months and come
with a book see what you come up with a
book about you guys. So I I accepted it,
you know, we agreed on the prize,
whatever it is,
>> right?
>> And there we went to to Israel and then
the book uh catch the came out and it
became also a huge huge bestseller.
>> And in that in that book, you're you're
you're going around Israel as a German,
right? Nobody knows you're Jewish.
>> Yeah. At that time, nobody knew me.
>> And what do you discover? What's the
reaction?
>> What I discover? I discovered that
underneath the noses of the Israelis,
you know, you have all these peaceloving
Europeans with all their NOS's. And I
discovered that they are not peace
lovers. They are just simple
anti-semmites. So I became very
>> selfing Jews. Would that be the right
the right self-hating Jews?
>> That too. But many of them from the
European NOS's are not even Jews. They
just come there. And the idea what they
come that's why the name of the book is
to catch a Jew. That's the idea. So and
I became very friendly with Gibbl at the
time he was number two of the
Palestinian leadership of the PLO. We
became very very very good friendly. He
didn't know that I'm Jewish. Of course
he thought I am a Nazi German. And we
became very very friendly, very very
close. And he opened the doors for me to
anybody I wanted. and and I was walking
in Ramla in Janine I I was like a king
everybody knows that I'm a friend of
Gibbril you know and I everything all
the the the foundations the NOS's all my
friends because I was walking in the eye
classes of the Palestinian world and it
was amazing so one day we were in Israel
one day with the Palestinians for months
month and months and u and Gabriel told
me the truth what he thinks she told me
what the PL a lot of things, you know,
they just wanted the Jews to get out of
there forever, you know, and
nobody wanted peace and spoke really
badly about Jews. You know, the
Palestinian leadership like Iard the
worst thing about Jews and then and I
realized what the what the NOS's are
doing, what all the peace movements are
doing there. You know they are basically
running there to catch a Jew and if they
didn't catch a Jew doing something wrong
they try to make him do something wrong
you know whatever throw stones at him
and then nobody's set him up they try to
set him up set him up and the Jews throw
stone back you know that's when the
camera start so the whole thing and then
I also find that you know like one of
the which is the Jewish
>> right
>> you know very left um
>> he's
pistnics and I found out I mean talking
with their one of their biggest uh
activist over there the top activist and
he told me um
the holocaust is a lie never happened
you know
>> a bellum activist told me
>> activist yeah
>> and I recorded him and I have a video of
it you know of course you know of course
in the beginning but went crazy the
denied that happens. He denied that he
ever said it. They called me a liar.
They made a whole spiel with American
media. They tried to sell to American
media that I am a liar. So what did I
do? I took the the thing and I put it on
Facebook, you know, and then they didn't
have a choice.
>> Are you a are you a marked man? Are
there people who uh who would like to
come after you after doing all these
under this undercover work?
>> I don't think about in those terms. If I
thought in those terms, I wouldn't be
able to move. So you don't travel with
security?
>> No. God forbid. God forbid.
>> And and obviously the adventure you just
told us about catch the Jew, the that
resulted in the book Catch the Jew.
Obviously that was an undercover job.
How difficult is it to remain
undercover? How hard is it to maintain
that you know this whole charade?
>> You have to you have to understand the
mentality. You have to know how to speak
Arabic and you have to understand the
mentality that the Palestinian mentality
and the Middle Eastern mentality because
otherwise you are not going to make it
you know
>> I mean you if you say one they got you
>> of course if I say one they got me so
and sometimes they started talking to me
in Hebrew I would say excuse
what language is this is the language of
the docks I don't understand one word
you're saying you know stuff like that
so you always have to and they say a lie
you have to say a double I you have to
understand the the whole spill, you
know,
>> it takes training. It takes training.
No,
>> no, it takes it takes thinking. It takes
cop,
>> but you have to train yourself otherwise
[laughter] you can slip.
>> But it takes a brain to be, you know,
you have
>> Did you did you ever think of Ellie
Cohen when you were doing this?
>> No, I didn't think about that, you know,
because it's like I was totally
different, you know. I went to this on
the streets. I did whatever I wanted,
you know. It's like
>> you know people thought that I am the
the savior of Palestine.
>> It was it was like amazing.
>> No understood to tan.
>> You remember one day we were in the
house of Gibil Kajub and Gibil says to
me from this day because I called myself
Tommy Toby from Germany to minia. So he
says in front of these people he says
from this day on your name is not Toby
anymore. And I said oh god he knows
what's my name. Says from this day on
your name is Abu Ali. Abali gave you an
Arabic name
>> and all the people around me said to me,
you know, the commander, the commander,
the colonial
gave you, you know what it means? I
said, what does it mean? Abu Ali in
Arabic, it means the father of Ali. They
said, no, no, no. Abu Ali is an term of
endearment.
This is the highest respect we can give
to people like you, to white people, to
Europeans. And I found out that the
other European white man who got this
honor of being called Abraali was Adolf
Hitler. So they put me on the same level
as Adolf Hitler. I said to myself, "Wow,
what an honor."
>> Who gave Hitler the name?
>> The Palestinian at the time, you know,
the sheh, the MUI. I know who gave it to
>> the MU. I was trying to think of it. The
MUI, right? Um uh from this you went to
uh to check out some of the um uh
refugee camps in Germany, right?
>> No, that's after that. And then we did a
a journey in America.
>> Oh, you did America first?
>> Yeah. That's book is called uh
>> the lies they tell.
>> The lies they tell. And that's when I
discovered for the first time how
anti-semitic this country is.
>> Where what cities were you in?
>> Everywhere. 28 states including of
course New York, Washington.
>> Even in New York you found
anti-semitism.
>> Oh yeah. Oh yeah. And I recorded this
anti-semitism all over and it was
amazing. also recorded the the the
Jewish anti you know auto anti-semitism
self anti-semitism
>> you know it's like you go to temples you
know on Don Kipur and Raj Shana and you
hear the rabbis telling you that we have
to say to pray for the holy souls of
Gaza
>> which has been tortured by and killed by
by the Arabal Jews the Zionists you know
and it's like it was amazing so I heard
all these things it was like you know
recorded. I remember when the book came
out, people said to me, "What are you
talking? You are you are inventing
things." Now the people say, "Tuia,
sorry for saying that."
>> Yeah. Because [clears throat]
>> before us, I mean, I'm not an obia. I'm
not a prophet. I didn't do it.
>> People have been exposed.
>> Yeah.
>> Sitting in the car, turning the machine
on, driving and talking to people,
>> right?
>> From 28 states,
>> you know, plus Washington DC. I mean
it's like it was like amazing to see the
anti-semitism in this country. You know
people tell me they have nightmares just
thinking about Jews. I mean it was like
frightening to hear what I had and
>> imagine how much worse it is now.
>> It's the same thing. Now it's in public
now. You don't you don't you don't need
me to go there and tell you the things.
You don't
>> exposed now.
>> You just you just see it on the street.
>> Yeah. Understood. Um, yeah, someone once
said to me, someone in law enforcement
once said to me, "You have to remember
something. Everybody hates Jews."
>> And of course, that sounds like a very
harsh, you know, terrible summation,
irresponsible summation of the
situation.
>> But it's true.
>> I was going to say you could confirm
that that's the case.
>> Yeah. But the the more horrible thing is
I find out many of these NOS's and
foundations
that are anti-Jewish.
If you dig deep inside them, the person
who is like staring the pot is most
likely a Jew,
>> right?
>> And that's what's frightening.
>> Well, they taught you bra they taught
you bra about the av, didn't they?
This is I mean if it was just we will
not have so many NOS's you know and so
many Jews you know who are doing this
you know it's it's it's us times that we
look at oursel look at the mirror you
know then there was a book about Britain
you know um the taming of the Jew
>> the taming of the Jew about
>> and what the anti-semitic
>> first you did hello refugees
>> hello refugees that's about the the
Germans the the
>> refugee camps in Germany.
>> Refugees refugee camps in Germany, you
know, which was shocking to see the old
thing the machine operates
>> and then aiming of the Jews.
>> The funny thing the funny thing, you
know, during the the book about the the
refugees. So, we used to spend a lot of
time with the refugees and with the
German refugees, Germans, refugees,
Germans. I found out that the Germans
are much more anti-semitic than the than
the refugees. the ones from Syria, from
Lebanon, much more anti-semitic than
them. It's like I I didn't hear so much
anti-semitism. Nobody was like obsessed
with Jews, you know, from the refugees,
you know, the Syrians didn't care. Okay.
>> But the Europeans Yeah.
Yeah. [sighs and gasps]
The white men, they are the biggest
haters of Jews. More than more than the
Arabs, more than the Palestinians, more
than everyone, you know. It's like it
was like amazing. And then I go I try to
interview people from all these NOS's,
you know, solidarity with Palestine, you
know, all these things, you know, London
with Palestine, you know, all these
things. So I'm going to interview them
and I thought I'm going to meet
Palestinians. No, no, white people and
many times Jews.
>> Well, as as many people remind us, you
know, Jewish history with Christianity
was much more brutal than Jewish history
with Islam.
>> Of course. Of course. And it is to this
day. To this day, you cannot change the
>> the cultural history.
>> Unbelievable.
>> To this day,
>> all of this that we just described, this
list of your incredible works, all of
it's undercover, all of it with the
bravery and courageousness that I keep
pointing out and you're able to maintain
this facade in every one of these
situations.
>> Thank you. So, except for the of course
the the book about which was not under
any assumed thing. Everybody knew why he
was from the beginning.
>> Yeah. Let me just tell everybody the
latest book, Tovia's sixth book is
called Careful Beauties Ahead. It was
published in May of 2024. Again, it's
called Careful Beauties Ahead and it's
uh it's about Maya Sharim and And you
didn't have to go and you couldn't have
Right. You couldn't have gone under
cover because they knew you there as you
said.
>> Exactly. Exactly. So there was no point
of going on the cover but it's not just
I mean was the base but it's a book
about from A to Z in Israel you know
whatever you know. But what did you
learn about the Karedi community?
>> I learned uh
I learned that I personally might not be
religious but I am kared.
>> You have to explain that. You have to
explain that.
>> This is first of all I learned and it's
like you know it's like personal you
know because you are closest to yourself
you know. I learned I'm think like them.
I my sense of humor is
you know you can see me you know Friday
night we do like shabas thing the
theater and us we are doing inviting
people for shabas I I I have a table you
know that it's totally
>> you have a tish you make a tish
>> I have a dish it's like a you know
[laughter]
like a dish you know it's like all the
songs you know all the the msdk you know
[clears throat]
That's what you sing.
How ironic.
>> Nobody in the upper east side where we
live sing these songs.
>> But how ironic that is singing about
>> Seion. Of course. Of course. Remember
this is also the song about all the
people who got arrested by the Israeli
by the Israeli police. Correct.
>> So it's like but [laughter]
[gasps]
yeah I mean that's the first thing you
learn. I mean the food that you like the
most is the food you have in your food.
>> It was a very positive experience.
>> Amazingly positive. I mean it's like
from the time I open my eyes in the
morning till the time I went to sleep I
was laughing. These people make me
laugh.
They have such a healthy sense of humor
>> and their attitude and their attitude
toward Israel, toward other people who
are of the Jewish faith. Did that come
up? Was that an issue?
>> Of course, it came up, of course, 10,000
times. But you have to see the people
who are making the big spiel, you know,
the big anti- thing, the demonstrations.
First of all, is the group called
Pelleg.
>> Oh, they are they are the worst. And uh
their leader is
Marovich whom I know personally I was is
my family Rabbi Marovich and which I
never liked him and this is one of the
groups and but most of the times you
don't see that you don't see this sin is
you don't see that I remember I went I I
gave interviews to rabbis I interviewed
rabbis it was from my understanding the
first time rabbis agreed to be
interviewed you know so title What
>> inf of course so I interviewed the reb
of the sound you know the reb of the is
one of the biggest and you know
>> the ones who got the passing with the
>> gold may there may
so I go to the reb and the rebar and I
ask him a question and I ask him what
would happen if it's came to the what
will you do
means
nonreigious nonreligious in that lingo
>> right So the Reb says to me, if he came
to fight with us, what can I do? I have
not many choices. If he did not come to
fight with us,
what kind of question is
we are all Jews. I said this
anti-zionist, you know, [snorts]
the father of the mother of you know he
has more is you know than anybody I know
in Israeli politics than all the 120
members you know he has more where do
you see somebody even from
where do you see anybody talks like this
we are all Jews you know we have to
welcome everybody who says that
You know what you've taught me?
>> You know what you taught me, Tvia? You
can take you can take the man out of
Benet Brock, but you can't take Benet
Brock out of the man.
>> But yeah, [laughter]
but by the end of the day, that's I
mean, it was amazing. It was amazing.
And the food, I love the food.
>> How long were you there? How long did
you move in there for?
>> For about a year and a half.
>> What you were 18 months in Mayor Sher?
>> Yeah. And Ben.
>> Wow.
>> I spent time in May. Did you get into
the bianual rituals? that you enjoy pes
and sukus and may
>> of course
of course
>> and even though you've gone in a certain
direction you
>> sukus you know you go so I go to which
is the I got another extreme with
extreme it's a split from the from the
no more relation I walk in and I have my
telephone on me you know and immediately
I just walk in you know 20 kids you know
because they've never seen a man who
looks like me you know it's like they
come to see who is the animal so I if
you're talking to them in English.
So you like
all walls tumble down, you know, because
myish,
you know, and it was like totally and
then one of them says to me, "What is
this?" I said to him, "This is a
smartphone." And he said,
and I said to him, "What bother you?
I'll put it in the bucket if it bothers
you to look at it." So no, no, no.
If you want us to do you a favor,
give give us the phone and we'll break
it for you.
[laughter]
I said, I need this phone. It's it's
it's my job. It's it's my it's my
producer.
>> I make money out of this. And and all of
a sudden, an older man was standing by.
He said, "What is your producer? What is
your job?" I said, "I'm a shber. I'm a
writer." So he says to the kids, "Leave
him alone.
make right [laughter]
>> and that was and that was at the
simplest space of
>> Yes. Yeah.
>> Did you did you bake matzas in May?
>> Uh no,
>> you're not into that.
>> It's like you know I did it when I was
young young young young and and it is
not an exciting thing to do. So I didn't
this
and when I did it as a teenager you know
I got paid for it at least you know like
no I'm not going to do you know.
[gasps and laughter] So yeah, but it was
very interesting. Now we were like uh
the next books that comes out will come
out next year is about the the
settlements.
>> Where who did you spend time with there?
>> Oh, everybody I could. I mean it's like
God almost everybody. Um
>> of course you are ra no question about
>> Marzel. Of course,
it's it's it's we have to talk about
>> Of course. I know. I know. So, I spent
every we we moved from we spent like
every two three weeks we moved to
another settlements.
>> Give me a name. Give me some settlement
names.
the non-religious, you know, the
religious Emmanuel, you know, the I mean
it's like every time somewhere else,
you know, everything you can you can
imagine, you know,
>> were were you were you were you
>> were you as happily um did did you meet
Daniela Vice?
>> Of course. Are were you as happy and as
enthralled with the mitnim as you were
in May?
>> It's a totally different thing. First of
all, the mitnim don't have the sense of
humor,
>> right? They're serious people.
>> They're serious people. Number two,
their food habits, their eating habits
is very different. It's more like San
Francisco.
>> You know, you go shabas, you are
invited. Always invited. You know, it's
like we we lived.
>> So, it would be good. Salat
>> salad. Salad kinoa sal everything is ely
I said how can you live like this
>> you don't you have ch no god no it's not
it's not it's not it's not like I said
to me you know what I send you all to
San Francisco to to to California you
don't belong in this land you know it's
like you know I mean it's like it was
like amazing the food was arable
>> but you're not being fair I've had
plenty of good in you're not being fair
>> okay maybe you had good child in I did
not have good in asked for you. But I
did that. I lived in too, you know.
>> You lived in Baker for how long?
>> For three weeks or something.
>> Wow.
>> What are you talking about?
>> So you're a ser you're a serious
investigator. You you you
>> came to you can do a book about the
settlers and the settlements without
living there. I was like, I can't
believe it. You know, a professor in in
Bengalon University said to me, he's
very famous and she said to me, Tuvia,
you made history. I said what history?
She said look I did not read your book
yet but I can tell you you are the first
one who actually lived with the settlers
to write about them. Nobody has done it
>> right
>> you know maximum somebody would come for
two days for two hours.
>> When does that book
>> I have no idea who the settlers are. So
I learned the settlers they have a lot
of good things. Of course you know
>> when does that book come out?
>> In the middle of next year somewhere.
>> And have you been back to Malot since
Hezra Yeshiva or not? Of course
>> you have been.
>> Yeah.
>> As a kid my
>> it was a different Malot in my time was
Malot was like you know basically only
Moroccans and us you know Moroccan
immigrants you know Malot is now
different you know it's like
>> to me to me as a kid in my generation
Malot meant one thing one of the worst
terror attacks in Israel's history.
Yeah, of course.
>> That Friday night.
>> Of course, I mean,
you know, it's like 24 hours a day I had
the M16 on me,
>> right?
>> You know, for four years, you know,
>> other other areas of Israel have caught
up to the to the uh the the danger,
right? Lot lot of other areas of Israel
where people need to walk around.
>> I mean, the funny thing, especially
during the war, the the settlements were
the safest place to be,
>> right? you know, because because of the
rockets, you know, almost no rockets
fell in that area. Very few in that
area, you know.
>> But there's another reason.
>> Yeah.
>> And I wonder if you agree with this
because, you know, both the uh the quote
unquote settlement side, as much as I
don't like that word, and the Arab side,
uh Israel was showing its strength, its
power, and it it made the enemy rethink
whether they're going to uh embark on
wanting terror attacks. Is is that
theory does that theory hold any water
for you or not?
>> No, it doesn't hold any water.
>> Wow. And there are every day attempts
at terror attacks in all the area.
>> War or not war no matter what. war on to
this day there are all the times you
know it's like I interviewed so many
soldiers I mean
officers you know they constantly have
to go like in Elon M for example there
is not a day going by that the people
around in the area you know who are not
planning to infiltrate alon and kill the
people in many places like that I mean
it's like it's a constant constant
constant constant war and you cannot let
go. So the Israeli army is very good in
preventing it. Especially the Shabbach,
you know, the secret the Shabbach is
doing an amazing job. I mean, people
don't even know.
>> People on this side of the world will
never understand the neighborhood that
Israel is in, right? They'll never
>> No, no, no. And because the journalist
who are there to tell them the story,
how do people know about anything? You
know, they reading journalists, you
know, they read papers or they watch TV.
>> They're staying in a hotel and they're
and they're flying back.
>> They're not even staying in hotels. I
mean it's like they live most of the
time in in in in Yafo, you know, Jaffa,
you know, on there they go to
restaurants and they write on their
computers. They open the computers and
they write Gaza strip. They are not in
Gaza strips there in Yafa and and they
write as if they were in Gaza Strip or
as if they were in Kon or whatever. You
hardly see and I mean it's like I lived
with the settler so much I've seen
journalist they come for two hours
maximum,
>> right? And then they already create, you
know, they tell you what the settlers
are and what you know from them. The
settlers are not inhumans. They are
cannibals. You know, they kill
Palestinians for breakfast. I mean, it's
like you don't the journalists don't
know. They came with their anti-Jewish
ideas, anti-semitic ideas, and they come
here and they just exercise those ideas.
>> Toia, I can't thank you enough for all
this time. Everybody should check out
Tovia Tennbam's books. They're
available, they're available on Amazon.
They're available everywhere. All right.
And um and what was the worst when it
comes to the lies they tell about the
United States? What was the worst
episode you had? Where was it? What
city? Give me something of note that
happened which showed you the the
ferociousness of the anti-semitism in
this country.
>> Everywhere and anywhere. that uh the
most things that I will remember I'll
never forget is the self aid of the Jews
>> where
>> to go to Yamipur to go to a shul in
Colorado for example you know and the
rabbi talks about the horrible things we
do in Israel and national remember the
innocent people of Gaza
the innocent people of the West Bank
were nice people
and then she makes a prayer for the
Palestinians against the Jews.
You know the worst for me
>> the worst anti-semitism you saw in the
United States came from Jews.
>> Exactly.
>> Wow.
or to go to there was a conference of
Christian CFI whatever they call
Christian for Israel know in Washington
DC there was demonstration outside of
Jewish voice for peace the way they
talked about Jews you know in your
program I not even say the names and not
repeat those names because there are so
many explicits
you know and who that Jews
and who try to stop those Christian from
loving Jews the Jews themselves
zero fighting zero like amazingly arable
you know the way you talked about Jews
like Nazis
so if you ask me what is for me as a Jew
the worst of all the anti-semitism I saw
in the land is the selfhating of the
Jews and the fact is that none of us you
know not me of of course none of us of
the Jews you know the leadership of Jews
see don't open their mouths against it
you know it's like if he doesn't exist,
they don't want to see it. You know, I
only hear the voices from the Jewish
organizations saying, "Okay, what these
Jews are doing is armor." No, they don't
say, you know, I'm sorry to say, I mean,
J Street is is a garbage. I have been to
their conferences. What I hear J Street
people, rabbis tell me to the Germans,
you know, because you thought I a German
journalist. what I hear them telling me.
I bet the Jews are they admit it.
I mean, it's like,
you know what he does to you? It's like
you cannot forget it. So, of course, as
a German, I tell them, "Yeah, you're all
right. It's good that you came up with
it. Very good idea." And I'm just
listening to myself.
>> Very perceptive.
>> What's going on for it?
>> These are so If it wasn't so so sad, it
would be funny. Huh?
>> I know. It's actually funny. I mean,
funny.
>> Have a wonderful day.
>> You really do know your name.
>> Shabas.
>> Wait, wait a second. Is it a git chabas
or Shabbat shalom? Which one is it? I
need to know.
>> Shabas.
>> Shabas. Thank you,
>> Shabas. Everybody check out his books.
They're all available on um on Amazon.
on the most recent one, careful beauties
ahead, is the one he wrote after
spending all that time, a year and a
half in May Sharim. And next year, I
hope we'll have him back because he's
going to have his evaluation of who he
calls the settlers, the Mitnim, the ones
we call the amazing heroes of Uda and
Shamron, uh, and those areas of Israel.
Um, and we'll speak with him, please
God, about that once that book comes
out. Again, check out all his work
online. Sophia Tanbound Te-N.
More coming up. It's Thursday and you're
listening to JM in the A.M.