0:00 / 0:00
My Journey from the Mind to the Heart || Rabbi Russel Interviews Rabbi YY at Kesher Nafshi 2026
971 views
To sponsor or dedicate an upcoming class click here: https://www.theyeshiva.net/donate To watch more classes & to read Rabbi YY's articles visit: https://www.theyeshiva.net Follow Rabbi YY Jacobson: Youtube: https://www.youtube.com/c/RabbiYYJacobson Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/TheYeshiva Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/yyjacobson Twitter: https://twitter.com/YYJacobson Linkedin: https://www.linkedin.com/in/yyjacobson/ Telegram: https://t.me/RabbiYY
Categories:
Torah
Comments(0)
Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
the yeshiva.net.
>> Hi, good evening everyone. Good. Good
evening. We have a rather unusual
evening this evening.
I've been sat in the hot chair many
times by alier ye
my dear friend Rabi Wai
and uh we decided to get him back
in camp. the autopsy turret.
>> And as he did to me on numerous
occasions, he has not seen the questions
I'm about to ask him.
>> But we're going to dig deep tonight.
We're going to dig deep tonight.
So, I want to return the favor. I
remember sitting on a very cold winter's
day in the basement of Reverend
Jacobson's house.
when we did a uh a conversation, I
thought it was a conversation turned
into a grilling
and Robert Jacobson asked me a very
interesting question out of the gate. He
warned me that his wife had recommended
he should not ask this question.
But uh in his infinite wisdom, he
decided
guided by the an
that he would ask me the question. The
question was gavaldic. I actually
appreciated the question because in
Kesha
we get real.
So the question he had asked me then
which I think surprised everyone was uh
with a big smile on his face he said to
me Rabbi Russell he said you're
considered an important person in the
world of kinuk today. people respect you
and they you know they you they follow
your advice.
So perhaps you can comment on how it was
that you had six kids off the deck. This
was his opening question
live to the world. It went viral. There
was a 100,000 hits in three months of
this thrasher. So we get real in cash.
She said I want to return the favor my
dear friend.
I want to know if what did your wife had
to say about that?
>> I didn't tell him. I didn't tell her. I
didn't even ask her cuz she for sure
would have said no.
So I remember in 2020
we were at Kesha Nafi in the rally. I
think it was the first time we had met
properly. Was 2020 I'm pretty sure.
Although I'
>> before Corona
>> before Corona although I'd listened to
you and very much admired you and
but it was the first time we met and I
that Kesha was when I gave the three
foundational drushes I think we called
them going deeper about trauma
and I remember you sitting in the all
the way in the back on the left taking
copious notes.
I was so surprised. I thought you would
come in. You know, speakers, they're
busy. They got a rest. But you sat
through it. You sat through it. I was
very taken back. I was very surprised.
And you sat through and since then you
have entertained us Aesha with your
amazing version of Shiman Russell
speaking about the amygdala the amygdala
the the limbic the this that the
prefrontal cortex you've entertained us
with that many many times but I saw you
took it to heart I saw you took it to
heart and it became very real and
something I witnessed in the last six
years if I may a a transformation
in Rabbi Yby Jacobson. I saw something
shift, something changed. It was uh
remarkable to watch the man in 2026, in
2020, the man now is a different man.
Something changed. Something shift. And
uh and we've all been we have been the
beneficiaries of a shift.
We we've we've noticed. What can I tell
you, my friend? We've noticed.
And so I'm wondering what you could
share with us about that evolution. What
happened here for you Aesha Navi?
Something changed, something shifted.
And I wonder if you could comment on
that and share that with us. We've heard
you do it bits and pieces, but how you
would put it together? What can you tell
us of that?
It's good either mascul
say you have the right to be silent. You
have the right there's no rights here.
So
we could talk about this for six years I
think
but maybe to give uh just at least you
know one aspect of my own journey would
be
I grew up uh in a very very rich
intellectual environment. I should say
extremely rich intellectual environment.
Um and I took that to heart. I uh I
tried to study diligently to internalize
to understand to comprehend
ultimately to teach and uh I found with
God's grace with Hashem's help a lot of
success and in that
as my life was evolving things were not
adding up
what should have uh
been a very successful life and it
appeared to many I assume as a very
successful Very much so. Very much.
>> And it was successful in many ways.
>> Sure.
>> On an internal level,
>> a lot of cracks were showing up.
>> Not in the presentation, the PR world,
but in the internal world, the world
world of Pineus,
which as we know counts infinitely more
than the external world, even if nobody
knows it. And what I mean by that is in
terms of my own marriage,
in terms of uh my own children and in
terms of my relationship with myself.
I had inklings of it before because uh
you know what comes up are things that
are usually embedded in very deep places
but uh I didn't have the I would say the
courage or the bandwidth or even the
awareness to be able to know exactly
what was happening.
Today I could say it was a gift that so
many cracks, you know, when cracks show
up in the walls of the house, first you
ignore them. There's a leak here, there
leak there, you call the plumber, shine,
$50, $100, but then when the ceiling
caves in,
>> it's like, yes,
>> you have to wake up. So, uh, a lot of
things started to happen there and it
took me on a journey. It, uh, I always
tried in my life. I tried to be honest.
I tried to be earnest but frankly
I was suffering from I would say
unconscious trauma.
uh one of the profoundest forms of it
was I didn't know this today I know it
was uh almost complete disassociation
and what I mean by that is in my own
experience and as a coping mechanism
because God has given me a certain type
of brain and certain talents
I substituted experience with intellect
>> so if I can understand something and
appreciate it and share it with others
and really feel the beauty of it. That
for me meant experience. There were
certain wires inside of me that were cut
and uh the world of real visceral
emotional experience I didn't know
about. Not because I didn't want to know
about it. I simply didn't know about it.
And uh
I really be believed in a very deep
place that intellectual comprehension is
what an experience is. There was a whole
universe which is really the core of the
human experience that I wasn't aware of
and I could compensate for it because I
always had empathy. I understood certain
things in a very deep way. I even could
preach about trauma
>> very well. Very well. Right.
>> And it wasn't fake. I like I understood
it.
>> But I was It's fascinating to me how
much I did not know what I didn't know.
And there was no way I could find out
about it. It wasn't that I was trying to
be arrogant or or foolish or in denial.
I wasn't trying to be any of these. I
was actually I I like to know the truth.
But the the the our coping mechanisms or
my coping mechanisms are so powerful
that they do not tell us what we don't
know. So it's like I was living in a
reality that in many ways was very
blessed and rich but in many ways was
cursed. It was uh extremely extremely
shut down from experience and without
even knowing it. What I did see is that
the people around me who were supposed
to be closest to me were getting were
being pained by me that I saw. C can I I
so appreciate
what happened and your you know honesty
about this. I'm thinking about this
group and people listening to this, you
know, I like I say, you came here to
Kesha and something started happening
here. a process began here uh if I'm
correct and and and it's probably no
gaya to what you're saying right now to
an awful lot of people in this room and
I wonder if you could sort of broaden
that for them bring them into your
experience because I think something
happened if people say something happens
here that changes you know to tell a
person you're going to come for shabas
and after shabas you're going to walk
out a different person you're really
resonating with that idea that that's
what happened and and I wonder if you
could share that experience for yourself
that happened right here. It happened in
that experience here at least if I'm
correct that's what we witnessed.
>> It was certainly part of it.
>> Yeah.
>> Um it was a journey that was extremely I
went on a journey that was very very
vulnerable very deep. you were part of
that journey yourself because my wife
and I had the privilege of uh meeting
with you on an ongoing basis connected
to our children and I think in one of
our first sessions you looked at me and
you said that you have a stonewalled
face there's something about your face
that is not alive
um you said that there is uh you told me
that when you started to work with
Russian clients in Lakewood you thought
they all suffered from aspergus.
This is how a how a Stamford Hill gates
boy classifies the whole Russian Jewish
community asperers.
And then it took you some time to
realize that no, Russians don't have
asperers. I mean, some Russians, I'm
sure, have asperers. Some English or
Brits or Americans have asperers, but
Russians have something even more
powerful than asperers,
which is uh the Stalinist regime,
the Zarist regimes were so horrific that
millions of people were forced to shut
down emotionally. And under Stalin, it
was even worse because he turned
families against families. If you
informed on your mother or your brother,
your sister, you were elevated in the in
the program in the in the communist uh
party. So that was a tremendous
incentive. So you couldn't trust
anybody. So emotions
really were were were shut down and you
know you were asking me you know what's
the history of my family and so on and
so forth. So you know this started a
very profound journey. Um I need to give
tremendous tremendous credit to my wife
who you know
>> because of her uh
>> because really while to the world I was
a hero,
my wife
would not settle for anything but my
most authentic self.
>> Amazing. And that was a gift because
sometimes other spouses would settle for
a lot of blessings that I provided but
not my wife. She would settle for
nothing besides my most vulnerable
authentic self which I did not know
about.
>> Correct?
>> So that was a challenge but a infinite
gift and I say infinite because it's the
gift that you can only experience when
you're ready to crack open all your
defenses. You know there's a line I
think I'm not sure I once said it
perhaps here I forget where that one can
get to know oneself the most through the
most intimate relationship one can see
oneself
reflected back
>> and I think that's what you're saying
that
>> you saw yourself reflected back from her
>> and it wasn't something you wanted to
see
>> right
>> it's remarkable I mean just remarkable
what happened and I think really for all
of us here it's such an inspiration. I
can tell you for myself to some degree I
think my wife requires that of me too.
And if you notice how she conducts me
when I speak
>> she's sitting right here and watching
every word.
>> Yeah. Exactly. You know like
>> no drama. No she's my conductor.
And and if we can have that relationship
with each other where we can reflect
upon the best and bring out the best and
and push for authenticity. I mean I
think that's a word I've heard you speak
about again and again. It seems to
become the the central theme in your
life. I've heard it in your drushes. It
comes up almost every time you speak
this word authenticity
>> because in my own journey I never
realized how important it was for me. I
never knew
in fact I would have said about myself
that I was an inauthentic person because
there were a lot of parts of me that
were inauthentic cuz I was shut down for
myself. So even without trying I was
inauthentic. I wasn't trying to be
inauthentic. I was just inauthentic cuz
I was fragmented person. my outer life
and my inner life did not match up. I
wanted them to match up. I wasn't trying
to be a con artist,
>> but they just weren't matching up. And
uh I also realized the torturous
component in my presentations. There was
something I worked very hard on my
presentations. I built them. I
structured them. Um
I knew what a crowd needs to hear to be
able to be uplifted and inspired. And
people were touched and moved. But that
somehow that wasn't coming back to me.
Something was strange. It was almost
like when I finished a lecture, I was
often craving the feedback of the
audience terribly. I needed to hear from
people that it was life-changing, that
it was amazing, that it was incredible,
and I was seeking it. I would stick
around after lectures
>> to be able to get that feedback. And it
was still torturous. It was not doing
the trick. It took me a lot of years and
inner work to realize that a lot of
these lectures were actually driven by
trauma by a need for external validation
which could never be felt.
>> I can get a million views. I can get 7
billion views. 7 billion views. I know
at the moment there's no seven billion
people using the internet, but maybe
with AI, I don't know. We'll see.
and 7 billion views will not be able to
compensate
>> right
>> for the lack of internal authentic
connection
>> correct
>> and with internal authentic connection I
don't even need one compliment
>> that's right
>> so uh that really was uh was just an
eyeopening transformation for me to be
able to start feeling what is it to feel
my own energy
>> so let so let me give you a feedback
without you running off you don't have
to hang around. What you've done for us
here with your authenticity,
showing up the way you do in the
vulnerable way is simply and I I think I
speak for all of us is part
inspirational. It's partial
inspirational.
You're the best. You really are amazing.
Anyway, enough of grilling you.
Let's let's move on a bit. I actually
came.
>> Yeah.
>> There was some time ago at Kesha Navi.
>> Yeah.
>> You were sitting at one of my
presentations and you were shing a lot
of nas I saw
>> because uh I've done a lot we have done
me and my wife and I have sat with shin.
It was a zoom zoom for quite a few years
uh uh with a lot of different challenges
in our own lives. And uh you came over
to me afterwards and you said you did
it. You did it. you did it. Uh my wife
would come home from Keshani and would
always marvel about how uh authentic you
were and your wife was about your own
struggles. Um you know people there's a
lot of Jewish conventions let's face it
a lot of conventions and shabbatones and
retreats and a lot of speakers some of
them are better than others but uh many
of us have become so used to listening
to speeches that are just simply
inauthentic. And it's not that the
speakers are the speakers are fine
people. They're saying good good ver but
it's all vert
right very rarely do you have somebody
get up and speak about their breakdowns
their temptations their addictions their
insecurities their their failures in a
real way not just I have a yates thank
you you know not very vulnerable to say
I have a yates good morning you know
other marishians had a yates and even
like thank you and that was very in it
was more than inspirational it just it
it created a paradigm. I think you and
your wife and many others here just
created a paradigm of what it means to
live with authenticity
and that not only it's not a burden or
shameful but on the contrary it's the
only way to be free and you said I think
in Israel when we were in where were we
in Taria Kashani in Israel
>> I think you said then if I'm not
mistaken one of the times you said that
what is Kashani doing for you and you
said that if every time you peel away
another layer of shame. Another layer of
shame. Another layer of shame.
>> Correct.
>> Um, in many ways, I don't mean to dumb
it down, but what do you think, you
know, the gula is going to look like?
The gula is going to look like a basic
endless kesher navi conversation where
everybody No, I'm serious. Where
where if you're not being vulnerable and
authentic, just shut your mouth. like
>> it's and the truth is that I find that
the Jewish world is sick and tired of
any presentation that is not vulnerable
>> correct
>> and is not completely completely
authentic. We are done with ideas and
insights and perspectives. We did it
2,000 years. We did it well. I should
say 3,338
years we have mastered ideas. And I
think what everybody's searching for is
embodiment. Experiential embodiment.
>> That's correct.
>> That was a gamecher for me.
>> Amazing. Just amaz and and it's it's the
essence of what we hope everyone coming
for Shabas will peel off one of those
layers.
>> Yeah. Uh, I remember I I forget which
Keshani it was at where we did the piece
on shame and we actually I don't know if
I should do it now but maybe it's a
little risky but we had everyone just
take 30 seconds
and just think out loud just think to
yourself
about someone
important in your life
who you have not yet hold the truth
about your struggles.
And just take 30 seconds,
everybody, to think about someone who's
important and you were just too
embarrassed
and you haven't told them the truth yet.
I'm not going to do a show of hands,
although I should.
You could do it. You could.
>> I wonder if we should.
>> You could do it. Sure.
>> We're talking about vulnerability and
authenticity. So, let's uh
>> So, I wonder whether we can
just put your hand up when you're ready
to commit
that this week before next Shabas,
you're going to tell them.
You're going to tell that person. You're
going to share
something you haven't shared.
It's amazing. There are hands, major
hands going up on the men's side. But I
want to tell you, I want to tell you,
they're all want they decided to tell
their wife.
It's okay. We don't Thank you. We don't
have to. We But you understand the
concept. If we go home ready, listen to
what Rabbi W is telling us. Peeling off
those layers, becoming authentic.
is what we're all craving
>> at the core of our souls. And it's the
only thing that frees us. It's the only
thing that makes us free because what
are you worried about anymore? Someone's
going to say, "Russell, you got these
kids off the dare. Didn't you know?" I
said, "No, I had noticed. I don't really
I don't live at home anymore."
>> Exactly. My wife takes care of it. I
should also add one more thing and that
is in terms of our relationship with
Hashem as Jews who are grew up with Tyra
mitzvah everything is about our
relationship with Hashem and I have to
say that although I never had serious
doubts in God's existence I mean here
and there you know like I guess every
thinking Jew I mean once in a while but
it wasn't serious doubts in God's
existence but what I never knew was what
it means to experience the divine Right?
I didn't even know the concept. I did
not know what it is. And I grew up in an
environment where, you know, very very
avatured
with nister, with kabala, withidus,
which is all about experience. So I saw
the concepts, I like the concepts, but I
never knew what it is. I simply did not
know what it is. I could talk about it.
I it was inspirational but I never
actually experienced in my nervous
system the
and it wasn't even spoken about it
wasn't even an expectation it was all
about understanding understanding at
least the way I took it I'm not judging
or talking about other people
and only years later I'm 53 years old I
would say for for half a century my
entire Judaism was intellectual
>> um it was obviously some emotions you
know I'm not I'm not a so sociopath
psychopath
>> I would have told you
um it was this journey and maybe one of
the most important consequences was I
can't say constantly that wouldn't be
true but there are moments that in my
nervous system I can experience my
divinity my soul and anybody who
experiences knows that the bliss of that
moment surpasses any other joy in the
world. There's no vacation, there's no
trophy, there's no physical award that
even comes close as a fraction of a
fraction of a fraction of the
nervous system bliss of experiencing
Hashem even for a millisecond because
it's something that's transcendent of
time. Now, if I would have heard this a
few years ago, I would want to know what
drug this person is on or what
hallucinations they're having because
this didn't seem like normal language.
And now it's the only language that
actually is meaningful to me. Any other
language doesn't mean much to me because
I never knew that if Hashem is real, it
means it's real in my body, in my chest,
in my heart, in my bones, in my cells,
in my nervous system. real man is
somewhere in Gmorrah in
in mitzvah in higher worlds and and and
the whole purpose of creation is that
intimate intimate relationship and by
the way the moment I started to
experience it I realized that the focus
of my avoid hashem is not healing my
children it's not fixing my children
that's an escape of dealing with my own
relationship it's a good way of numbing
my guilt and making sure my kids become
perfect, beautiful Jews, whatever that
means for them.
>> This is this is so important what you're
touching into now
>> that we shift away from defining my
existence, my purpose by making sure I
fix my kids. You know, I mentioned the
rashi at the last conference. I was I
was nervous to even bring it up. the
Rashian
where the POS says that
told us
and Rashi tells us why does it interrupt
the heck have told us told us and
Zagashi in the second
not your kids. The ick told us of a
person is not his children. It's not a
mistake. It's not an interruption. It
comes first.
>> Yeah. I should say one of the very
impactful stories that I heard from you
at Kasha Nav and you said it publicly.
It left such an impact on me because I
asked a question to myself was when you
described in a very vulnerable moment
but to the public
>> a conversation that you had Friday
night.
>> Oh gosh. when you were leaving your
shabas table miserable because it was a
colossal failure of a shabas table. No
mirrors, no diva. What you call a
cataclysmic
failure. Shabas is the highlight of a
yiddish shahome for everybody, right?
Whichever group you're from, like
shabas, shabas, shabas.
>> Yeah.
>> And it's when your daughter said,
>> "Oh, I was so depressed. I couldn't even
I could barely mumble kittish out of my
mouth."
>> And the line that your daughter told you
was the way I remember it. He'll correct
me is Tati, how was this religion doing
for you?
>> Yeah.
>> The actual word she said that killed me,
changed my life, was it doesn't seem to
be that your Judaism is doing very well
for you, is it?
>> Yeah.
>> And what I took from that was you said
that that moment you became a bouva.
>> Yeah. Yeah.
>> Yeah. What that means was what she was
saying is if Shabas is real, if God is
real, even if nobody's around the table,
where is your relationship with Hashem?
Ah, your Shabas is fake. You just need
the image of the Russell family.
>> Yep.
>> Gracing the room, making you feel like a
success story.
>> Of course,
>> BMG 36 years, Tom or whatever it is.
Hearing that story put me on a path to
cha.
I'm still working on becoming a Bouva.
>> Yeah.
>> But it's it's it's such a powerful
message that comes only from these
culture.
>> Only from them,
>> right?
>> It's like so your Shabas is real or your
whole Shabas is just fake news as our
president likes to say, our president.
>> Yeah. We we actually my wife and I after
that my I'll give my wife credit. She's
amaz saw it.
And my wife so many times saw me in this
fake relationship. I'm not sure she
understood it. She never said it or
articulated that you're being fake, but
she knew it was wrong.
But she always gave me space to find
myself,
to work it out, to understand it. She
didn't mus me. She gave me the space to
to suffer and to cry and to think and to
work it out. There's something awfully
wrong. If I'm so depressed over Shabas,
then apparently, you know, you know,
that's where I first understood and we
talked about this many times about my
Shabas table. You know, it's not God's,
it's mine. What's he got to do with him?
It's mine. and you're going to behave at
my shabas table.
And it was, you know, we broke free of
that.
>> And I see that that's happened. It's
just remarkable.
>> I'm so grateful you're saying it.
>> There was a moment that was very
embarrassing for me. You know, Purim, a
lot of people come for Shalakas.
>> Yeah. And one of my children at the time
decided to remove his yamoka. And he
made sure that Purim day he would be on
the first floor as all the guests came
in to visit Rabbi Yway on Purim. And
this is the time as a rabbi you're
supposed to show off your merchandise,
right? Everybody comes, they're in a
good mood, they want to say, they give
you a hug, they give you a kiss, right?
the experts leave a check whatever it is
but everybody everybody's coming to to
you know be inspired
whatever all the good things and
suddenly it's like this man who's
talking around the whole world about
love love love love love love
and inspiring people and experiencing
our relationship with our children and
here we go this is the merchandise right
and uh I shared it with my wife simply
my shame, my embarrassment. I was smart
enough not to say a word but internally
it was very very painful
and uh somebody who I look up to was a
mentor of mine. He said something very
profound to me some time later. He said
actually your son is so spiritually
sensitive
that he is actually making a very
profound statement from what he has seen
in his life. He is like, "If this is
what the yamaka represents, I don't want
to have to do with it." Only when he
discovers a yiddish kite that is truly
divine and authentic, will he put on his
yamaka again. He is now actually taking
on
corruption that he is observing that he
does not want to have to do with it. So,
not only should you not be embarrassed,
you should actually be proud of him.
It was,
>> you know, if I can resonate to that, one
of our sons
who'd gone off for a few years was
struggling and then he found his way
back in a conversation with him. I'd
asked him, you know, like, "What was
that about for you?" And his words to me
were, "I needed to vomit up
>> wow
>> the Judaism of my childhood, of what I'd
seen and witnessed, not just with us,
but in the community, the schools, you
know, the whole experience. I needed to
vomit it out so I could drink in a new
one."
>> Wow.
>> You met him.
>> Yes. Yes. Well,
>> yes.
>> And he embodies it.
>> Yeah.
>> Yeah. And I should just add, you know,
it could come across to some like
there's some romantic experience.
There's a lot of pain in this. There's a
lot of shame. There's a lot of pain.
It's not like, you know, I'm talking
here and it's like, wow, I'm so cool and
chilled with all of it. There's a lot of
grief. There's a lot of pain. It's not
simple. It's not like a journey where
you let go of your ego forever. It's
important to acknowledge both sides.
There is pain. Of course, we pray and we
want our children to be mitzvah to be
filled with shamay to be filled with a
shamay to be able to observe and
celebrate the mitzvah and live with
anoid mulada
is not uh out the window. This is the
dream of a parent. But what we often
confuse it is with educating our
children for our own sake or educating
our children in a way that we fully show
up to the journey that they're on and
really can be here for them in the way
that they need it most so that they
could find their soul. So it's actually
allows us to show up with more love to
actually be with much more presence. So
actually the most loving
endowment we could give ever to our kids
is us living authentically with simra in
our own Jewish life
>> without saying a word to the kids. Not a
single word.
>> Just embodying simka
>> and authenticity in our own life. And I
think because of the trauma that many of
us have in a very deep way and many of
us unconscious of it and not just men
but also many women very unconscious of
their trauma. The reason I'm saying this
is because women are sadakus they're
namanis and they have miser and because
of the nephish of women sometimes it's
easier to cover up
blind spots. I'm saying this with a lot
of empathy. So all of us have to look at
our real blind spots.
And when we do, we could suddenly really
discover that our children were actually
a distraction. It was a way of avoiding
our own relationship with Hashem that we
were not dealing with. We never touched,
we never felt our heart. And we wanted
our kids to compensate for our own void.
I saw that within myself. And the moment
you really start having a relationship
with Hashem, you think you're better
than Dan Amel. You know what Davalik's
kids looked like? I mean, I don't know
if you're familiar with the story, but
you could read it. It was a disaster.
Never mind about, you know, some of the
big names in our tradition.
But what happened was they understood
that it all begins with their own
relationship. Like it's everything is
about their own relationship. And the
children feel it immediately. I mean
when our children sense the sim that
their mothers and fathers have with a
hashem and with each other it's a
gamecher. You don't even have to say a
word. You'll see in seconds the demeanor
of your children shift.
>> Expand upon that. That's so crucial.
>> I saw them I saw it in my own life. My
wife and I thought our job is to heal
our children, to change our children, to
fix our children. It was coming out of
love. It wasn't coming out of hate. It
wasn't coming out of maliciousness.
That's what good Jewish parents are
supposed to do, especially Yiddisha and
to a certain degree Yiddishatas, if
they're not out for lunch 24/7.
I was out for lunch a lot and for
breakfast and dinner. Uh
what what what we realize then is that
it's actually the other way around. Our
children's it's might might sound funny
but I heard this from my wife. Our
children's souls have taken upon
themselves
with miserious nephesh the task of
cracking open their parents because you
could look at something very stat you
could look at the statistics. This was I
think at an early keshi shabat.
Ask most mothers in this room and most
fathers. Which child went off the dak?
Is it the one who was least sensitive,
most brute, least intelligent, most
coarse, most careless, most
self-centered, or it was the most
sensitive, the most empathetic? The one
who Friday night when you were exhausted
at 12:30 a.m. was the only one who
stayed up in the kitchen and helped you
clean up. The one who came over to mommy
in the middle of the night and said, "I
love you." Because he knew or she knew
that's what you needed. And that's
somehow the person who at 17 years old
abandons the ship. So as I once wrote to
a mother, I think I sent you the email.
>> Yeah.
>> Do we really think that a gilgal of Dr.
Mangala
went into your daughter and she decided
to join the SS to destroy the family
forever? Cuz that's what the mother was
describing that her daughter is an evil
17-year-old shed who has a dbuk and
whatever. Is that really what happened?
that a Nazi soul somehow went into her.
Is that that what happened? Or maybe if
her whole life she was such a refined
person, there's actually something
deeper that we have to look at. And is
it possible that some of our children,
the holiest of the holy, the most
sensitive of the sensitive, have
undertaken a grueling task to usher in
our generation from gullis consciousness
into gula consciousness. That's what I
feel in my bones. I'm not a ni. I don't
have I'm not a reb I don't have any
information about this. I'm telling you
in my bones I feel that a lot of our
children I know from my children I know
some of your children I know some of
your children are very very holy people
very sensitive I told I told at the
kdish today I told the I was walking
through my kitchen
and I'll tell you what you hear from
your child in your kitchen you won't
hear 10 years in therapy and your
children do it for free your children do
it for free you don't have to spend
$25,000
They'll sit with you 4 hours from 12:00
to 4:00 and they'll tell you all your
issues and they won't even ask for a
dime. They'll do it the next night
again. They'll do it the next time. Ah,
they charge you, huh? They charge you.
Okay. Okay. They're smart. Yeah. I'm
just walking through the kitchen. I
think my child was cutting an apple or
maybe a piece of meat and he just looks
at me almost like Derek Hagav. He's
like, "By the way, Ta, when you'll start
embodying
what you teach, you won't have to use so
many words." Boom. Next.
Continues cutting the steak. Shine.
Tati want a piece of steak. I'm like,
"What?" He's like, "Yeah, when you start
embodying what you teach, you won't have
to use so many words. That's it. Next."
Right. How much does that cost now? Of
course, my animal trauma consciousness,
right? My prefrontal went offline at
that moment cuz this is an attack. He's
telling his father who's 53, 52 years
old, who supports him very nicely, the
I don't believe anything I say. I don't
embody. So, I wanted to say, well, how
dare you? What do you know? Let's call
my students. Let's see. That was my
infantile four-year-old that was just
wounded.
Um, thank God due to my own work, I
could watch that four-year-old go crazy.
I could give him a hug and say, "You're
safe. You're safe. Young Wa, you're
very, very safe. Nobody's asking why why
you were created." Nobody's asking that.
It's fine.
And my adult self or my more evolved
self or my divine self could actually
listen to my ch my my son and say, "Wow,
wow, that's powerful." When I start
embodying what I teach, I will use less
words. I can't say that that has been
fulfilled yet as some of you know.
Maybe by the next Kashi if I do a little
more chuva. If I do a little more chuva,
but the this is a precious insight and
this is not coming from a 60-year-old.
This is coming from a young young man.
Where did they get this information
from?
I would have even thought of telling
this to my parents. Not because
I didn't even know about this frequency.
Yeah. Last Kesha Navi Gdalya asked me to
speak to the teenage girls. So I went to
speak to them. I was with my wife and we
asked one of So I was telling the girls
was saying how her mother is a wreck, an
emotional wreck because of her brother
went off the derek and how much she's
suffering.
So my wife or I asked this this this
girl 16 years old at Kesher Navi in the
Raleigh where was Raleigh right last
time and I I asked or Estie asked a girl
do you share this with your mother did
you tell this to your mother how
difficult it is and she looks at me 16
years old and she's like what my mother
doesn't even have the bandwidth to deal
with her own emotions she doesn't even
know what she's feeling you want her to
deal with my emotions forget about it.
This is wisdom of a 16-year-old
who understands that her mother doesn't
even process her own emotions. Now, I
want her to burden her mother with her
emotions. Right? These children, the
last of the last is
so I don't know, there's something in me
that tells me that these children are
helping us all usher in a new era of
healing
in the Jewish world.
Unbelievable. Thank you. Thank you.
Thank you. Wow.
You know, I just just uh he reminded me
of a story that happened to us with our
eldest daughter when um you know, after
all the journey and the crazy she was
the first one and we went through such
craziness with her and uh and then she
got engaged and she got she engaged got
married to a guy she could have had they
both not gone off it would have been a
totally reasonable and and it ended up
that way anyway. and they found each
other. They were boyfriend, girlfriend.
There was a I mean, the stories are are
crazy what we went through.
But at the
she um
she bash and we got to the kasna
and uh I got a message that she didn't
want to go out to the cabalis pond
uh until she spoke to me. She had to
speak to me.
I thought she wanted to break it off. I
mean, I was in Pak.
I ran to the room and there she was.
Beautiful, beautiful 19year-old girl
leaning forward with two tissues and
mascara laden tears flowing down the
tissues. She's trying to avoid her gown.
And I come in and it's like I was
shocked to see it. I said, "You know
what? What? Leave it. What?
And she said to me, I mean, you talk
about the Hikite of these kids.
And she said to me, Tati, she said, I
can't go out until you m me everything I
did to you. That's what she said. This
sweet head and aes put the right words
in my head because you know this is
divine. Like you say, it just comes.
It's just there.
And when I looked to her and I told her
that you don't have to ask Mahila
because you gave me much more than you
took from me.
You gave me so much more than you ever
took from me. And and that's this. When
we open ourselves up
to our children,
they actually gift us. They take us to a
play. Look at us too. They took us to,
you know, we're both reasonably
successful people and we would have done
fine, I think, in life. No, at least you
would have for sure.
>> Paid the bills.
But it the kids our kids took us to a
place of of of
love of honesty, vulnerability,
of relationship with our kesh with
ourselves and with others that we simply
would never have got if not for where
our children took us.
>> Yeah. And I think that's the gift that's
this gift we have here. You know, to
people starting out here the first time,
that may seem almost bizarre.
Bizarre
>> and even non-empathetic. We should just
mention that.
>> Go ahead.
>> No, it's important to understand that it
doesn't take away from the fact that
often we can experience deep anger and
pain and let down. And I've heard from
mothers and fathers who were very honest
and very loving that there were moments
that they felt horrible things about
their children. There's even parents who
in desperation sometimes say things that
they're very embarrassed of. You know, I
say, "Father once told me, I wish my
child was dead."
>> I can tell you that there were occasions
when and it was because I couldn't reach
that particular child. It was not
because I I hated her. You understand? I
I felt so lost. I couldn't reach her.
And she was in so much pain.
>> I just I I kind of hoped an 18-wheeler
would come and just take her back and
give an Ashama to someone else cuz
clearly I'm failing.
>> Yeah.
>> Clearly I'm failing.
>> Yeah. And we have to acknowledge that.
>> And I had those feelings.
>> Yeah. It's important because if we deny
them, they will haunt us. They will come
back with a vengeance if we all become
sadikim now and like it's a gift. Let
all your kids leave you dishkite to give
you the gift. Even those who are from
throw them out into the streets. Get
them expelled from all the yeshivas.
Right. Bring your tattooist into the
house on chabas.
>> On chabas.
>> Yeah. And keep the keys in the car and
say go to the movies. Here's money for
the movies. Like
>> it's just
>> and a a a season's ticket to McDonald's.
Exactly. Exactly. And then a trip to the
Bahamas as a reward for giving us all
these gifts. Uh and it it's just
important to understand like when we're
not allowed to amputate any part of us.
This is so important. Like we need to
hold space for all our parts. Our
disappointments, our frustration, our
anger, our pain. Because if we repress
or suppress any of it, suppress means
consciously, repress unconsciously, it
comes back in a passive aggressive way.
And our anger towards our children will
come out in a clever sly way. When your
daughter comes down from the bedroom,
you will in a clever shrewd way
denigrate her. Not because you weren't
at Kashavi, because you didn't deal with
your anger. So we need to hold space for
all of our emotions including the ideas
that what you're hearing now is so
contrary to how you grew up like that's
not
somebody mentioned today a very wise
woman mentioned today at the kdesh she's
like are we being taught here at kasha
navi in her words to raise snowflakes
kids that are as fragile as snowflakes
shouldn't the goal be to inculcate
resilience it's a Great great question
and this is how so many of us have been
trained. A lot of our parents or
grandparents were Holocaust survivors.
Without resilience there would be
nothing left to qual. And how much did
they deal with their emotions? Let's
face it. How many of them dealt with
their emotions? Many of them had to
completely disassociate just to wake up
in the morning. We have to acknowledge
it and honor it and appreciate the fact
you told me right about a family that
told you that our shittita is we don't
show love to our kids right
>> and Rabbi Russell said you know you
don't have to turn the Holocaust into a
shittita like
it's basically crazy trouble not to
blame anybody but but people had to shut
down their emotions too much pain like
it's not their fault it's it's Hashem
Hashem did us all like we also have to
have a lot of compassion
and a lot of respect. It's very
important that when we go away from here
and I know I struggle with this, it's
very easy to become arrogant. It's
called enlightened arrogance.
Baser mentioned finemeckers.
We're the ones who discover the truth
about and that's another
just as one side of arrogara.
We all are humble servants of Hashem.
All of us and those of us who have had
the gift of opening oursel up to
Hashem's messages have a privilege to
share with others. But there's no room
for real judgmentalism because you
always have to ask yourself, I basically
dealt with my coping mechanisms and
others are dealing with their coping
mechanisms. And as my 14-year-old loves
to make fun of me whenever I'm stressed,
Tati, don't worry. You're doing the best
you can with the tools you have. Right.
And we have to remember that about all
of us. So it's just I think just
important you
doing the best you can with the tools
you have. You don't have to be anxious.
I'm like wow. These are 14y olds today.
Who thought like this? Amal who thought
like this? You had to have three PhDs to
say something as intelligent as that.
And even then if you went to Harvard
forget forget it. But even then such
wisdom such wisdom they are so evolved.
It's incredible. I talk to Bram
sometimes, right? And I'm very open with
them. The Rashivas are cringing, but the
boys are all like, "It's fascinating."
And all the ADHDs are the most
attentive. Yeah. One ADHD kid tells me,
he says, "Rabbi W, you could have spoken
for 12 hours." I'm like, "You? You're
like the poster boy for ADHD? I mean,
the medic the big farmer uses you should
use you as a poster boy, right?" And he
says, "No, no, people don't understand.
I'm ADHD if somebody is not hitting the
spot.
>> That's right.
>> If you hit the spot, I'll sit for 12
hours.
>> Yeah.
>> Right. So, you you talk today to 15y
olds real without any masks, they're
like,
"Wow, normal. It's it's it's a it's an
amazing gift to bless a generation." I'm
sorry for not being so pessimistic about
our kids. They're amazing people.
They're amazing people. So, so, so let's
let's just
>> They're not narcissistic. You know,
people say they're all narcissistic.
Really? Your kids are narcissistic? I
know you narcissism like I'm a frog.
I am a frog. You agree your kids are
narcissistic?
>> No. And their mother is also not
narcissistic. You know that. Don't make
like this. Your mother is not
narcissistic.
Take it in. Take it in. So, so just
let's tease this out just a little bit
more. What do you think?
>> It was a therapist who once told my wife
that I have narcissistic personality
disorder.
>> Really?
>> Yeah.
>> Wonder who that was.
I was testing the waters.
when you agreed with me, I knew you
weren't.
>> So, let's pull it out just a little bit
more because I love the direction of
this. What do you think that for us
here, let's start with us and then in
general, that most parents in this
generation, certainly us, most
misunderstand about our children? What
is it we misunderstand the most about
these kids of this gener because people
say all this rubbish you know I said
over the story with le you know how when
he say he said there's no such thing as
everyone went crazy I had gone in and
asked him
>> like the whole tuming you know we seebah
it doesn't make sense right and he said
to me two words
>> self-defense Wow.
>> It's not.
>> What do you think most of us in this
generation, us here, and in general
misunderstand about today's children? I
I I it's hard for me to give that broad
di diagnosis because I'm not you know
this is not my particular expertise but
just from my own experience
>> right you counseledled many many
>> I think my own experience and I think
many others is that there's a deep voice
in us that simply wants
our children to comply and we'll do
whatever it takes to comply just comply
like it's 8:30 just go to school just go
to school I don't care if you're in the
mood if you're not in the mood, if it's
a good day, just get out of this house.
Like somehow it makes us feel safer.
Like it's shabas. Like just do the right
thing. Just take a shower. Just go to
bed. Like everything. And it's not
anybody's fault cuz that's how we were
raised. Like show up externally
and that will prove to all of our
caretakers that were safe. Show up
externally.
And our kids are not doing that. And
it's driving us crazy. So we try to
bring them to professionals, whatever
that means, so that they could show up
again externally. And I think we all
need to take a deep breath and realize
that our kids are actually helping us
heal
and telling us, Tatia, mommy, you don't
have to show up externally anymore. You
know why? I want you to actually have an
integrated experiential
blissful encounter with the divine 247
and I'm going to show you how to do it
and I want you to learn from me. I mean
they're not doing this consciously but I
want you to learn from me and when we
can go in and like I don't need my kids
to show up externally.
I want to be able to heal me. I want to
show up authentically. And then you will
notice that your children are actually
very much alive inside.
And I think that changes the paradigm. I
still have to work on this every day
because my survival coping mechanism
instinctively like reacts like just
let's get this straight. Let's get this
straight. It's 9:00. You're not in
school. Okay, you need a snack. I'll
take you to Wesley Kosha. Let's get a
snack. Whatever it is, just let's keep
the chess board complete, organized,
safe, and somehow the world will feel
safe. And when our kids are not
responding to that, it drives some of us
crazy. And I think there's an internal
letting go that needs to happen, a very
deep sense of trust in Hashem and in our
children who are created in Hashem's
image. And really surrender almost
everything. Not almost. Surrender
everything
and really be fine.
Really be fine. Put on the music in your
kitchen and just start dancing. Dance
like a mishuga. Just dance. Dance with
your kids. Dance with your spouse and
celebrate. And I think we will notice
that our children have a very deep and
rich life that only that way we'll be
able to cultivate. That's what I feel.
>> What a beautiful answer. Thank you.
Thank you.
Let me let me throw one more at you if I
may. You've been here with us in this
you know the unfolding Kesha Navi
movement for many years and you know
that we put a constant doggish on you
know obviously we talk about attachment.
I mean you've made fun of it enough
times that you know you you know that
it's a central theme here.
>> I never knew that before. I never knew
that. What do you
>> I didn't know how much attachment I
need. I didn't know it. I did not know
it.
>> I did not know it. I think you knew it
growing up. How much attachment you
need? I did not.
>> Yeah, I did.
>> Um but due to my own circumstances, I
never knew that I needed attachment. I
thought that I need to learn, I need to
understand, I need to teach, I need to
explain things,
um I need to be a good person, I need to
be a moral person. But I never knew how
much emotional attachment I need. Today
I know and I feel that attachment is the
core of all of existence.
>> Explain.
>> It's the reason why Hashem created the
world.
>> Explain. Explain.
>> It's the DNA behind everything. It's the
backend program of the universe. It was
Hashem's yearning for attachment that
propelled everything. Yes. It all began.
Hashem is perfect but Hashem somehow
wanted attachment.
I want a relationship with you. That's
attachment.
It's not just psychology that realized
in the last few decades the value of
attachment. All of yusheskite is one
message. God craves attachment with each
and every single one of us. And that
matters more than anything else. So on
every strata of existence, attachment is
everything. We crave attachment. We need
attachment. One of my epiphies,
emotional epiphanies was when I looked
into myself and I'm like, "Oh my god,
all I want is attachment. I didn't know
that. I didn't know that." And then I
realized that my seeking validation was
a fake compensation for attachment. Cuz
if you could tell me after my speech,
you changed my life, that made me feel
that I had attachment. Of course, it was
fake. It was meaningless, but for a few
minutes, it felt good. In the absence of
real love,
I opted for validation. I think there
are a certain many of there are many of
us who do that. At a certain age when
our heart gets broken into 500 pieces,
we don't feel we can experience that
subconsciously. So we go to the second
best option, but it's a fake option and
that is get validation from people cuz
validation feels like love. It's not
like it.
>> So
I've learned that and then I realized
it's all about attachment. Like there's
nothing really else going on. There's
nothing else. I mean the BMPv nailed it
in everything when he said everything is
about dus. There's nothing that's not
about veas. Either you're attaching
yourself or you're detaching yourself.
Like I learned this in my marriage.
There's no such a thing as being neutral
in your marriage. There's no such a
thing. Every good morning, every good
night, every what's going on, we're
late, we're early. What are we doing?
Either I'm getting closer to my wife or
I'm detaching.
Means
I once heard from the becomes the word
In all of your ways, you can experience
intimacy with Hashem. Connection.
Everything is either connection or not
connection. It's all about attachment.
So, it's so liberating because it really
made me realize first of all how
vulnerable I am, how much I need
attachment, how much we all need
attachment. And everything is about
attachment. There's really nothing else
going on. And that was a gamecher. Wow.
I have to say that I to the point that
today and I actually saw this in in a
discourse from the Bal time but I never
I would never even begin to understand
and he maintains and he was quite an
intellectual that there's no such a
thing as an idea idea ideas are fake
things everything there is is only a
scythe and Hashem shows that certain
elements of infinity should be able to
be structured also intellectually but
don't detach it from infinity
>> don't allow that to detach It's all
experiencing the divine. Some things
Hashem allowed us to experience also
intellectually and that was it's
resonated so deeply. I don't believe
anymore that there are ideas. I don't
think there's such a thing as an idea.
There's something called truth and some
truth we can understand and it's
amazing. But it's all about truth and if
it's truth it's about Hashem and if it's
about Hashem it's about attachments.
>> Wow. That's that's just amazing.
Amazing. and and Nell is
>> so I really any conversation that's not
about attachment I have no interest
there right
>> I have no interest there I'm serious now
>> and it's such a liberating thing to say
>> I hate small talk I always did I'm not
very good at social stuff uh I have to
do but I I never liked it but
>> this is sophic
>> yeah yeah listen we come back to
aspberers but uh
no no I really I really feel that any
conversation that's not about real
attachment with each other or with
Hashem is just it's not worth having.
It's it's fake. It's superficial unless
it's a continuum of attachment.
The truth is as follows and this I could
say from experience. The only
conversation that is worth having in
life is a conversation about Hashem
and that means it's a conversation about
attachment. It could be a conversation
about our own relationship, but that's a
conversation about Hasha. It could be a
conversation about something you said
that hurt me, but that's a conversation
about attachment. It's a conversation
about Hasha. I think everything else is
just dumbing down our energy. And we
should we're too We're too grand for
that.
>> I don't know. I don't know if I can
reach high enough, but I'm going to try
and bring it down a little if you don't
mind and bring it back down to us here.
>> What did you put into Mahavdala tonight?
What do you have?
>> It's like the I have to reach high for
this, but let me let me slap it. Dear,
let me see if I can bring it down.
For us,
going home to our children.
>> For me, too.
>> For you. Exactly. We're all going to go
home to our Just Let's take it to this
place, you know, as we finish up for
tonight. This is just too amazing. But
um obviously I see well you've not just
embodied all that we've been trying to
talk about attachment from day one.
>> That's why I took notes. I I realized
you're describing the brain. I knew
>> something happened with you. I watched
it. Am I right or wrong?
>> It was crazy.
>> Well, I heard what you were saying. You
were describing the brain. Now, I happen
to love neuroscience.
I love I I happen to love to figure out
how we our systems work because I think
it's the most incredible divine imprint
in the world. Like what that brain looks
like. It's incredible. You were talking
about it. It was amazing information.
But I also felt I feel energy very
deeply and I felt it was true. I felt it
was true. I knew that you were
describing symptoms that I could
identify in myself. I just didn't
experience what you're talking about.
So, as far as I knew, you were just
preaching a foreign language, but in my
curious self, and I have to admit, when
I hear good information, I use it. I'm
in the recycling business.
There's nothing I ever heard that's good
that I don't use. If it's worth it, it's
I'm going to use it. So, if I'm hearing
good information, there's a real shalma
over there. It's like my trauma self was
what can I use from Rabbi Shiman
Russell's neuroscientific analysis that
will make my speeches interesting,
compelling, psychologically
uh intuitive and insightful. There was
that element there. I don't remember
exactly what my intention was but
right. So it was uh it's it's really so
so important you know to understand what
it means when we are completely
functioning
with our lower parts and we are we are
offline you know it's like I never knew
how to I never knew how angry I was to
be very honest I was so
I was so not in touch with my emotions
I remember I was once sitting at a
therapist's office in my a close friend
of mine later became a close friend of
mine. He was a the good therapist.
And uh he looked at me and he said these
words and they were life-changing. He
said to me,
"The response you gave a few minutes ago
either comes from somebody who's
completely stupid or who's very angry.
You don't seem completely stupid, which
means you're very very angry. Why are
you so angry?" And it was the first time
I looked into myself and I realized I
was angry.
Growing up, I wasn't allowed to feel my
anger. We weren't allowed to feel our
anger. We weren't allowed to. And we had
good words for it.
>> So, not feeling your anger means you're
not. The problem was I was angry. I was
I just wasn't acknowledging it. You know
what I mean? It's much worse. And
suddenly I realized I'm actually angry.
And that took me on a beautiful journey.
Why am I angry? Wow, somebody's getting
to me. I'm hurt. Oh, I need attachment.
There's an the wounded attachment. That
was a very very uh insightful journey
for me to be able just to open myself up
to these human experiences. So, so let's
let's frame as we end this, you know, we
can go on all night, but we have to end
somewhere. Let's frame the ending um
within the uh our understanding of
attachment and yourself embodying these
ideas of attachment and knowing you're
going to go home I don't know tonight
tomorrow you're going home back to your
children and we're all going to go back
to our children
and take these the theme of attachment
practically bringing it down from the
anai for a minute if that's Okay. And
and bringing it back into our kitchens
and our living rooms and our dining
rooms.
What do you like could you give
guidance, advice that you would use for
yourself?
>> Yeah.
>> As you as you re-enter the world, you
come out the bubble, Apollo, you know,
lands and they and they enter they exit
the spacecraft.
>> Right. Again, I'm going to speak from my
own experience and I hope it can
resonate and I'm going to try not to
speak in words of a scythe but in very
very practical words and that is I
realized at some point that for me
attachment was the most important thing
that means I could deny it from today
till tomorrow and I used to deny it
unconsciously but my attachment with my
wife my attachment with my children is
number one priority it's all really
based on my attachment with myself which
is my attachment with Hashem
You can't really be attached with your
wife and children or your husband and
children if you're not attached with
yourself which means you're not attached
with Hashem. And then I realized that
that is not just a priority but that is
the priority.
>> That means any thought, word or behavior
which will cause detachment between me
and my spouse and me and my children
will be a betrayal of my deepest
authentic self and desire. And that's a
choice I have to make 24/7. I may be
angry. I may be overwhelmed. I may be
stressed. I may be anxious. My children
may say something very disturbing. I may
encounter a very difficult moment. I may
disagree with my spouse. She may
disagree with me. But anything I say or
do or even dwell intellectually
on behaviors that will cause a rupture
in the relationship is actually the
deepest betrayal of self. that has
become for me I try I can't say I'm
always succeed but it has become a
guiding factor
the next comment and you you told this
to us you Shiman shared this with us
when we were working with him the next
comment you're going to make to your
child is it going to cause attachment or
is it going to cause a rupture you might
say beautiful things you might say
that's don't speak to me that way that's
not a bad thing to say right or this is
my house or you're shamay or there's
ganed and gehenn they may be beautiful
things the question is attachment or
detachment it doesn't mean I don't have
all these drives and motivations but
that's for me a very very guiding
principle because I know in my bones
I've learned I've experienced that
attachment is the priority and I can't
deny it anymore I used to deny it I used
to think I have other priorities I don't
it's a game it's a sham am rib shim from
day one I have to say and I always
marveled on that you never denied that
that's your most important need you
never denied it somehow you knew that I
>> I don't know your mother your father
somebody
>> my mother gave it to me I didn't realize
I had it until
I struggled with my kids and kind of
lost it and it was when I woke up to
realize together with my wife we woke up
to realize but then I you know I I I had
grown up with the gift of attachment and
it was relatively seamless to understand
that and feel that
>> it's powerful because your kids don't do
homework even in very innocent ways.
They're not saying at the Shabas table.
They're not sitting at the Shabas table.
The seder is not working out the way you
want to work it out. They're quitting
school
and your whole system wants to yell and
scream and beat them into shape verbally
or emotionally and stop, pause, breathe,
maybe do some push-ups and then ask
yourself, are the following comments
going to create attachment, trust, or is
it going to create a rupture? That's the
question. Ribshim has guided us with one
of our children who would come home,
come down in the middle of the night and
complain about the horrible parents that
this child has.
And he would say, "You're getting angry,
but don't go there. Smile.
Welcome them." And just ask yourself,
"What comment can I make that will
simply enhance attachment?" Even if it
won't be registered right there, the
child won't say, "Oh, Tati, you're an
amazing attached father. I dig your
attachment. Wow, I love attachment. We
all love attachment. Let's go for a
tensil. That not going to happen. But in
that child's psyche, this will be
registered.
And this accumulates in a very very
profound way. And I find that that's one
of the most incredible things we can do
constantly. Uh we once struggled with
one of our children and uh
Rib Shiman gave unforgettable advice
which was life-saving and he said and I
assume you've shared this with many
other parents as well. He said, "You're
right for wanting to end whatever you
want to end, but under these
circumstances, if it's going to create
a lack of attachment, the most important
healing medicine that your child has,
you're going to take away from them." At
a Kesha Navi conference, you once said,
and I think it was one of the most
important things said, and it should be
said with a 100 disclaimers, that this
is very sensitive information. So maybe
you'll want to add that, but I'm going
to already make these disclaimers. But
said something that I feel is critical
to understand what attachment really
means. The question that was raised was
if your child is addicted to a tablet or
a phone and they're not watching Rabbi
Ywise clips,
they're not even watching our sessions
on YouTube with a 100,000 or 200,000
views. They're not even watching Trump's
speeches on Iran. changing every few
hours, right? They're watching things
that you and I know are very
inappropriate and damaging,
porn, pornography, etc., etc. And the
question is, do you confiscate? Do you
confiscate this mazik, this malikov,
this sultan? And you would think it's a
no-brainer. Of course, you confiscate
it. And answered, and I remember it
almost verbatim, counterintuitive,
brilliant, authentic, and real.
He said, "There's nothing as damaging as
a teenager addicted to pornography, but
there's one thing more damaging than
that, and that is when they don't have
attachment." Because if there's going to
be healing for pornography, it's going
to be attachment. The antithesis of
addiction is not sobriety. The
antithesis of addiction is attachment.
All of our grandmothers had hip surgery
at 86. They were given cocaine for 3
weeks in the hospital. They didn't come
back full-blown addicts. At least not my
86-year-old grandmother. You know why?
Because they had attachment with around
49 grandchildren or in Satmar 129
grandchildren
who were jumping on her bed. Cuz the
antithesis of addiction is not
sobbriety. The antithesis of addiction
is attachment.
>> Beautiful.
>> That's the truth.
So, so if this 17-year-old girl or boy
are going to heal from pornography, it's
through attachment. It's through love.
It's through a real relationship with
their parents and ultimately their
siblings and ultimately themselves and
ultimately friends and and and Hashem
and all that. So said if by confiscating
that satska
you are depriving them from the only
chance of attachment cuz now Tati and
mommy are the enemy.
Unintentionally
you have secured the perpetual
horrors of pornography.
And that means that sometimes you have
to choose the lesser of two evils so
that that daughter or son knows they
have a father or mother who are attached
to that. That advice was incredibly
insightful cuz that was a real ev what
attachment means. Attachment doesn't
mean let's go out to a restaurant that's
great. Let's play Monopoly deal.
Amazing. Let's go on a hike of course.
Let's go skiing gavaldic. Of course it
means that too.
But what it really means is when you're
making a tough decision, a really tough
decision, something you don't like,
something you hate, something your soul
protests, something that's against
everything we believe in and everything
we want for our children. And yet you
know that sacrificing their relationship
with parents is depriving them from the
most important medicine. And therefore,
don't do that. Don't do that. That is
extremely extremely powerful advice,
>> Rabbi W. Why? Thank you. Thank you.
Thank you. What can I tell you?
>> You're I'll just make a disclaimer.
Rabbi Russell or Rabbi Jacobson, we're
not saying that it's a good thing that
people are addicted to XYZ.
That should be misconstrued that we're
making a new It's horrible. We know it's
horrible. It's against of course it's
against forget about it's not something
that healthy people do. They don't look
for pornography. They look for real
relationships. We know that we're
talking when there is this crisis. What
is the medicine you're going to give
them? Of course, we don't give
chemotherapy to a healthy kid. But when
a kid is suffering, the question is what
is the medicine you give and what is the
price of not giving that medicine?
because the medicine has damaging
damaging side effects. That's the
message. I just wanted to make that
because there are those who will often
misconstrue these messages. You thank
you for your authenticity. Thank you for
your vulnerability
and thank you for what you brought to
us.
Really proud of you.
>> Thank you. Thank you. And I want to I
want to specially thank besides Abdalia
of course and the whole team. I want to
thank
two spe two special families. One from
Cleveland and one from Pittsburgh. the
Calfman family from Cleveland and
and the Rosenfeld family from Pittsburgh
for allowing me this and all of us to be
able to celebrate here such an amazing
Shabas together. I just wanted to
express thanks to all of you. Thank you.
And of course, thank you to Rabbi and
Rabbit Russo and to everybody here.
It's great.
This class is brought to you by the
yeshiva.net.
Please help us continue the classes.
Make even a small contribution at
ww.theshiva.net/donate.