Mitteler Rebbe instructs Chasidim to make their own shul- Reb Shaul Alter of Ger: Right or Wrong? #1

everyone a good night of shabbos it's the weekend of tests and youth kiss live tazkis live is the yama lettuce the birthday and the yard site the day of passing of the rebbe the second khabab and followed by youth kislev which is the day when he was liberated from his imprisonment so it's appropriate to talk a little bit about the historical details of the midla reba and his relationship to khabab now what do i mean there is an interesting letter from the mithla rebbe where he encourages his khasiddhim to make their own shules their own stables because at the time although the alta rebel was vindicated on yutez kislev from the false conspiracy charges of him being an active participant in supporting the turkish government over the russian government nevertheless the khasidim muslim feud lingered on and linger on in many different states many little cities you know and when khabad khasid david they prayed in they were pressured in various ways or at least they felt pressured and it was very uncomfortable said the bitterness was the first one not the altered to say go for it make your own shoes and i think that's a very significant historical point there is a time and place when a person has to break away you know we talk about breakaway communities today we're dealing now with a breakaway within the world of the hasidic movement gare or gur and everyone around here is talking about it 10 000 people their shabbos or in a tent on 18th avenue and 53rd street or so and someone told me he tried to get in you couldn't get in it was dangerous you said there were so many people there's not that not so much room who was this rap show alter the rash of shiva of the of one of the gary yeshivas who was a kind of appointed and elected by a group of 250 people several years ago to start their own school and he's very very forthright and he is a great talmud i heard yesterday he's one of the six great greatest torah scholars in the world today and if you see and hear him talk he talks very flippantly you know like you and i can have a conversation they had a clip of him ending a certain talk that he gave here in muncie or somewhere and he says thank you for listening gets up and he leaves you know no fanfare that combined with his personality with his knowledge is only going to attract more and more yidden hasidan to him guaranteed whatever he has now in five to ten years it will be probably a hundred fold but it's a breakaway and i'm not taking sides who's right it was wrong it's a breakaway gare had one red until now now they have two figureheads call them arabic home rush shiva but someone who is an active leader in the movement is it right is it wrong the middle arabic teaches us that there is a time to break away when you cannot continue being in a situation because there is constant disruptions and more than disruptions there is humiliation and there is embarrassment and there is much like this divisiveness it's time to leave it's time to vacate and it's very hard to accept this we're saying it's a bitter pill but it's a but it's a necessary one and so historically the mittal rebbe saw that the barbecue see them are not won't be able to function the way they should and therefore he gave them the green light and he instructed them to make their own the middle arab also is known as the the the expansiveness of hasidis the bean of hasidis and just briefly the idea is that his father the altered would let's say say a mimer that was several paragraphs a page or two whatever and he would expand on it for 10 pages not only was it a quantitative difference it was a qualitative difference too because his hasidis is known among the deepest hasidic teachings in the world of hasidism the masculine the great intellectual minds called in khabad circles masculine compared to iv them the servants the masculine would learn and dwell on the mithril rebels hasidis in fact there's a saying i believe in titus shalom of the rebel ashab he says i must of course it of my father that happened i studied the zetas with the grandfathers considers now it doesn't mean that he didn't learn that his father's considers he did and he wrote hanukkah's and your explanations but mean to say that delving deeply into understanding the intricacies of god