Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
No, but it's a double standard to say
like as an adult you're allowed to have
two or three friends.
But when you're a kid, you have to have
17 friends.
>> The ideal setting is the choice of high
schools should be 100% the parents.
>> All they see
is just their own selves. It's not being
selfish. It's not being um you know
narcissistic. They simply can't see
anything outside of their own view of
things.
>> Welcome to the Learning Curve podcast
brought to you by Mishpacha Magazine.
>> We're raising children in a changing and
challenging [music] world.
>> So let's tackle the important issues
facing families today.
>> I'm Rabbi Garfield, menahel of Yeshiva
[music] in Houston, and I love talking
about
>> I'm Rabbi Ari Shonfeld, menahel of
Yeshiva Manhattan,
[music]
Director of Camp Hach. I also love
talking
and of course a little bit of fishing.
>> Join us as we answer your questions and
discuss the topics that matter to
parents the most.
>> This episode of the Learning Curve is
sponsored by Clever Candy Fruit Jelly
Jewels.
and welcome back to another episode in
season four of the Learning Curve. Yes,
four
um which is quite remarkable. Um and if
the first two episodes,
you know, a little bit out of order in
terms of um you know timing the the
first one we did right after camp and uh
the second episode was as we know was
recorded during camp speaking to the
that are now in middle of this so
there's no way Rabbi they'll hear this
one probably until you know
the off
they're not going to hear this cuz
they're during this there's no way
they're listening to the Learning Curve
during this month.
>> Push it.
>> It's
Unless they have a certain MP3 players
that might let them, who knows. That's
their that their job, their job.
Um you know we have
>> or the regular one? Like
>> regular one or the special one?
>> I'm not you know this past summer in
camp we just had a camp episode
AB Rottenberg we had the
I would say the
come to camp and give us a surprise
It was it was a
emotional remarkable night in camp and
he sang a a song
like a takeoff little kite tell me
and he rewrote words little drone tell
me
and it was the
of a Yeshiva that had like the drone
following the boys around when they
leave Yeshiva.
It was very cute and at the end of the
day at end of the day I don't need a
drone cuz the boys you know are doing
great
>> He did a
version of his own song.
>> You know interesting
I actually once interviewed for AB
Rottenberg for a the
I want a little bit of history here the
the reason that we have a little bit of
a going down history lane people ask me
what were the origins of the learning
curve.
So do you know it Rabbi
other than me calling you and saying hey
>> I think you could do a much better job
sharing it than I could that's for sure.
>> So the the origin of the learning curve
was that I actually got a phone call
from 24/6
five years ago when they first started
about doing a podcast on
Jewish music and
Jewish
something like that they try to like
fuse the two.
So I interviewed two people I
interviewed
and I interviewed AB Rottenberg
and they were never aired I have those
on my phone I I felt really that and I
called up
the owner of 24/6 and said
Rabbi on this podcast it's not for me
there's not enough there's not enough
meat on the bone it's really about music
and I'm not a music you know
I I love music but I'm not I'm not
becoming a person who's doing a podcast
about music you need
I really want it and and I tasted a
little I said I want to talk about
and so that ended I got a sweatshirt and
that's about it
and then I called you when there was
once I got that little taste I knew you
a little bit then and I said hey I just
been dabbling in podcasts I don't want
the music but I wanted to that's the
background the reason why I say this
is because in my interview with Avi
Rotenberg then, which has never been
aired, some really cool stories that he
shared.
I think he said only one song he has
doesn't really like that they did.
And that is the second version. I
shouldn't say didn't like.
He said the song that he every song that
he did felt as a real tachlis and a
message, except for the the second
version of Ninth Man,
where they're all 45 and then then right
then they they're all working out and
they and then they flood. That was just,
you know, a spinoff. It took a late
sonus. It was cute. There was no message
and that song bothered.
That song bothered. Once I'm going at
ideas, here's the idea. I asked Avi
Rotenberg, is there a song that made it
that when you wrote it you didn't think
it would?
And he said, yes, I'll give you a song.
And it's a song that made it maybe on
his top 10. And that is the
Everyone sings everywhere in the world
the
He thought the high part didn't cannot
he he didn't think it would it would be
such a, you know, a bestseller.
Interesting. Fine. Anyway, so that was
that was the precursor.
>> I have to know, I've heard Avi Rotenberg
speak about music
and it really people don't realize, I
get some people might, but many people
don't realize how much effort
and focus he puts into each like it's an
avodah. That's not like, yeah, he just
put out a song, you know, like like some
say we do with the podcast. It's not
like that at all.
It's like each nuance is worked on and
thought each word choice, the rhythm,
it's like every word.
>> You know when I saw that a little
because I had Avi the summer in camp and
I've had plenty of singers down here in
camp.
He was the most particular, not in an
annoying way, in the setup, when are we
singing the song? How are we going to
like he cared more about his craft than
anyone we had.
>> Wow.
Really cool. I I do want to mention one
thing since you mentioned 24/6 that, you
know, people might remember from a
previous season that I brought up some
concerns and I've been so amazed about
how responsive they've been
to the I'm not saying they were
responsive to Garfield. You know, I
wasn't the only person,
you know, raising concerns. But over the
last year, they fixed almost every issue
that was raised. And it's pretty
impressive
for you know an organization to be so
responsive. They have now I think the
select which is the I don't know exactly
all all the things basically were
addressed.
And
I just think that deserves a lot of
respect from a community. How often is
it that we complain about something and
then it's addressed? You know, like very
rare in our world. So shout out to the
people there for doing that because
call a vote. I think it makes it even
more
>> We We never discussed I don't know if
that regard but we never discussed We
don't say names of organizations. We
never discussed
>> you mentioned it so I felt it was open
it was open. You opened that gate. I
jumped in it.
>> So I know you were you were part of that
article that you wrote so fine that was
yeah.
>> and they really they worked on it. It's
like on the spell really.
>> Beautiful.
All right.
>> All right. Let's get to it. So I'm going
to ask you question number one and here
we go. Let me open it up.
We're navigating high school
applications for our oldest daughter and
have an idea of which schools we'd like
to apply to.
Our daughter has her own ideas pretty
much entirely driven by where her
friends want to go, not necessarily
schools that will be the best academic
or
fit for her. And she's not really being
open-minded about it. How much should we
be giving our daughter a voice in this
process?
>> Wow.
>> Only you can answer this because in
Houston we have one
one choice.
Makes it much easier.
>> I guess for the boys
>> choice but one choice nonetheless.
>> I guess maybe for the boys in Houston
there's potentially more choices. So
you know
I get this
all the time this almost exact question.
I usually get it after the fact when
they're
now in a disagreement with their child
of where to go or struggling how much
you know I'm not going to rephrase the
question but the question that I get
asked often
um is how much should I push my child
to go to a Yeshiva, boy or a girl, where
I think this is where he or d she will
shtieg most, and she doesn't. Um,
and you know, as as you know, I was a
eighth grade rebbe for a while, so I I
dealt with this as an eighth grade
rebbe. I deal with this as a menahel.
And oddly enough, as a camp director, I
deal with it a lot in the summer. In the
summer is when you have those uh-oh, we
should switch or we want to switch or
we're still you know, you have certain
kids or or schools that are are are
should we take you know, transfers. I
get deal with that a lot over the
summer. Um,
I'm going to be a I'm going to pull a
Garfield.
Ready? Whoa, I'm going to pull a
Garfield.
>> not even sure what that means. What does
that mean? You're going to argue with
yourself?
>> Woo, going to pull a Garfield. Um,
it doesn't start in eighth grade. How's
that?
And that is it's a very
hard conversation to have with a parent.
I want my son to go to you this Yeshiva
and he wants to go to the other. I'm
like you know, how much should I give
him a voice? Well, how much does your
daughter trust you? And your
relationship with your child is what by
now? To just wake up now and and and and
want to have a certain relationship with
your daughter or son in eighth when
they're in eighth grade
we just do this all time in our podcast,
right? So much
of the answer is well, what's your
relationship with your child? And And
what I will say is that
in an ideal setting
in my opinion, the ideal setting is the
choice of high schools should be 100%
the parents. They are the ones that know
high schools much better than the child.
They are the ones that know the child
better than the child. They are the ones
that understand the the nuances of
hashkafa and the differences between all
the variables. They're your parents for
heaven's sakes. Right? And to quote a a
in venerable and veteran and very um you
know, well-known mechanic Rabbi Chaim
Pechter who has a mesifta. He told me
once that he interviewed a parents and a
child um and the parents wanted the
child to go and the parents I want my
child to go to your high school and your
mesifta. My son doesn't want to. What
should I do?
And he said to them the Torah is moshel
and he said to them if your son had an
ingrown toenail
would you let him choose the doctor?
And no, of course not.
So then how could you let him choose the
mesifta? That was his, that's the line.
How could you let him choose the
mesifta? So
in an ideal world, that's of course what
has to happen.
And and a healthy relationship, the
parents decide. Now,
of course, I would assume and hope that
the parents will decide taking into
account all the child's feelings and the
child's social life and the child's you
know, that I don't want to be with that
friend or I'm nervous that they they
have night sitter four nights a week and
I don't know if I want four nights a
week night sitter four nights a week or
a girl they're not going to let me have
a phone and I want a phone. All of those
variables that your child's concerns of
course matter. Of course your child has
a voice,
but it's your decision. You're the adult
in the room. And
what I tell parents and I the parents
ask me, how do I know how far to push?
Now I have four children
three boys and a girl and each one was
its own sugia and they're all four
incredibly amazing in their own way
and really
thriving where they are. And some of
them
got exactly where they wanted right
away. Others it was a process. Like I
I've been through this.
And when parents ask me but my son says
he really doesn't want to go my daughter
really doesn't want to go. How do I know
how far to push?
I think that as parents we are
so afraid
of our kids being
upset disappointed angry in the moment.
Just just like it's okay. They're
allowed to be really upset assuming they
get in obviously right? They're allowed
to be upset
and disappointed.
And it's
what's going to happen in a week from
now?
You're going to choose this high school.
Is your daughter going to accept it and
therefore do you know go in right now?
If you're going to tell me that your
daughter's going to fall apart
then
you're probably making the wrong choice
and to quote a bit Garfield there's
probably something else that happened
you know going on behind the scenes.
Don't be afraid to be bold as parents
and make the choice that you think is
right
after listening and understanding your
child.
That's my
feeling.
>> I I I disagree with a lot. And I know
it's not surprising necessarily, but I'm
a little scared to I have to be honest,
I'm a little scared because it could be
misunderstood and I don't want to I have
to be very cautious about how I express
this cuz this is a delicate thing.
I I would say in an ideal world You said
an ideal world, of course the parents
decide. So I would say in an ideal
world, of course your child should
decide. In an ideal world.
>> Oh my goodness gracious.
>> In an ideal world, your child should
>> a 13-year-old One second. In an ideal
world, I'd like you continue because I I
don't want people to misquote you. In an
ideal world, a 13-year-old boy or girl
should understand what's best for their
future?
>> In an ideal world, yes. Meaning if
you're Yeah, in an ideal world, your
child knows what they like. I'll tell
the parents, visit a few schools. Like
it's more relevant to boys here because
with the girls it Like I said, there's
only one school and generally that's
where they go.
But with boys, let's say a parent says I
want, you know, school A. So I say okay,
take your kid to three schools that are
in the orbit of what, you know, And And
let's see what your child Don't tell
them and much enforce. See what they
say. And I found in my experience that
kids
almost subconsciously sometimes, but
certainly if they're conscious about it,
they sort of know where they need to be.
It's sort of like an innate, you know,
an innate sense that they have.
>> go where the open house is better. They
go where where when they go to an open
house and different strands of
Yiddishkeit in different ways, but they
go where the food is better.
>> Okay, I said ideally. If you as a parent
feel that your kid is making it on
fickle basis, then maybe you're right.
But ideally ideally, you'd want a
situation where your child goes like we
send them to yeshivas and they come back
and they say, you know what, those kids
are my I felt like it was my kind of
kids that were there or I I really liked
the menahel. I really connected to him.
Like if they tell you that that place
fits their neshamah,
>> the menahel. I I as a parent, I know the
menahel. And he won't deal well with the
kid like you because even though he's
nice to you now, he's very rigid, he's
inflexible, or is the opposite like you
just don't know the big picture.
Don't let your child see a school that
you don't want him to go to because he's
just going to like it and then you're
stuck. So don't give him three choices
within the orbit because
>> say that one of those three choices
should be a place you absolutely don't
want. I agree.
But it doesn't necessarily have to be
the one choice that you do want. You
know, try to see, give him an
opportunity to experience it because in
the end of the day
maybe in ninth grade
>> He knows nothing. He's 13.
>> I've met I don't know what 13 year olds
live in the Upper West Side, so I can't
speak to the to your 13 year olds. But
the 13 year olds that I know
are many of them are very insightful and
do have a sense of success
>> No, no, they want to go where their
friends are going. And I tell the eighth
graders
I say guys, I hate to be harsh, but your
friends in eighth grade are not your
friends for life.
It's actually your camp friends and your
friends. Like your friends will change
and you won't have friends until the
first day. They want to go where their
friends are going. They want to go where
where their decision making is an
immature as expected 13 old now. Again,
of course you take their opinion. I'm
not saying ignore what your kid wants.
But you you know your child.
>> What do you mean? Why of course ignore
They know the opposite. You shouldn't
only ignore it. You should say you want
to go there? It must be the wrong place
for you.
>> I don't think I need to to respond to
that.
Um it's it's the parents and the rebbe
>> I said in the beginning
>> to help you. I'm trying to help you not
sound it. The parents and the rebbe and
the
who by the way have seen 100 eighth
graders go to those three yeshivas. Just
have the experience that your 14 year
old child just doesn't have.
>> I said in an ideal world. I I I'm not I
recognize that there are many situations
that are not ideal. But in an ideal
world, and I would say it happens often,
not always, but often, a kid has a sense
of of environment when he visits
some places have you come for Shabbos,
they walk away and they say, this is not
for me.
Or, they walk away and say, this is for
me. And when that happens, I think
that's very powerful.
>> I agree with you. How's that? Yes.
No, of course.
>> Of course that there are times that
parents will have a kid and they'll and
and together and the parents will see
the kid's reaction
and they'll see the kid's reaction
positive or negative, but it's not the
child should not be the driving force in
the decision. The child should be
trusting his parents.
>> That's I call that
that's exactly what I'm saying. You go
to three yeshivas and then you see
afterwards, how'd you feel? Did you Did
the guys seem like your kind of guys?
Did you feel like you And And a lot of
times I have
I have found I could I don't want to
name yeshivas because you know, it gets
a little sensitive, but I know certain
yeshivas you the kids go and they say,
this is not for me.
And other times they go and they say,
this is for me. And it it's
You know, I think that Now, is that the
parent being weak?
>> No.
>> I don't think that's weak at all. I
think you have You're You're I think
weak on the parent who doesn't take the
time to understand that dynamic. So,
>> Of course.
>> Okay, so we
>> But But what when you're at eight
But But the the decision has to be made
by the adults in the room because often
a child will want to go to yeshiva A and
it won't be that yeshiva is perfect,
that yeshiva is the worst. It will be in
between. And the child's like, I want to
go there. Why? Because my friends are
going, because they give off in the
summer and I want to go back to camp,
because right all these reasons. And the
parents know and the rebbe and the
menahel know sometimes much more than
the parents. I know your child. I've
seen 50 of them come through my yeshiva.
I know that mesifta.
You're making a mistake or it's a
reasonable risk or it's not. And there's
no perfect science. It's not a perfect
science.
>> that most of the time Maybe this is the
difference between us. Is your
experience that most of the time the
eighth graders are off?
Like they want to go to place A and they
really shouldn't? Is Is your experience?
Because in my experience, it's not. In
my experience, I would say 80% more,
more or more, the kids are right.
Or justified in their hargasha.
>> I don't think it's off. I will tell you
that
it's a real process that I've been
through
countless times
to
explain to the children the decisions
that their parents are making. And by
the way, I think it's important that the
children at the end of the day accept
it. That's a real challenge if they
don't, then you're in big trouble. But I
think very often
the children come to different
um you know, places of their parents on
on because of reasons that shouldn't
matter. Whether it's they're going to
make me wear a hat by that
>> Yeah, I I have not found that. So that's
the difference. Maybe it's not a Maybe
there's another layer here to explore.
But in my experience, parents and kids
usually are pretty much you know, the
kid is usually within reasonable svaras
and and and
>> within reasonable svar, but it but but
but in an ideal world, the parents
should be making the decision of whether
the son goes to
>> All right.
Okay.
Let's move on.
>> Oh boy.
That was a hope I hope this one goes
better.
Um
next question.
My 11-year-old daughter Two daughters in
this one. Wow, a daughter heavy
But of course, we face what we discussed
>> pivoted that first one to boys.
>> discussed
[laughter] My 11-year-old daughter is a
lot of fun. Oh, I have an 11-year-old
daughter. So let's see how this works.
Um
All right, I didn't write this, but
honey, I don't know. I didn't read this
question before, so let's see. My
11-year-old daughter is a lot of fun,
but she tends to focus on her core two,
three friends and won't be interested in
other classmates or neighbors who want
to play with her. Not my daughter. She
is the most popular kid and loves
everyone. So good. Whew.
I want her to be nice to everyone, but
she just says they aren't her friends
and she doesn't want to spend time with
them. Meanwhile,
the kid is standing at the door hoping
for someone to play with.
How do I navigate this? Great question.
>> Wow.
Well, I'm not a big fan of forcing
friendships. So I I don't think that's
necessarily something you can do.
And I don't it's so bad for someone to
have two or four friends because how
many adults do we know that have two or
three friends? I mean, that's so typical
of
you know, I don't want to like point
fingers to my wife or neighbors or
whatever, but a lot of people have a
have a smaller friend group that they
that they really spend their lives with.
I think that's typical, you know,
leaving family out of it.
>> But not in school so much. In school
it's usually your circle.
>> it's a double standard to say like as an
adult you're allowed to have two or
three friends,
but when you're a kid you have to have
17 friends. Like to me that sounds a
little funny. I like having two or three
friends.
>> Maybe you get to two or three friends by
experiencing 17 and then slowly
>> So if you moved into a new town, just
want to specify, and your wife was like,
I'm not sure how to do this. You're
like, I have an idea.
Try to meet 20 new friends and then
you'll pick two or three? No. You you
connect to the two or three they as they
happen, your neighbor, someone you're
connected to through work. It's it's
that's how it is. It's a natural
process. We don't force it.
That's not how people normally make
friends. So I'm just saying I don't
think it's so crazy for your kid
for a child to have two or three
friends. I don't think you're doing
anything wrong. It's not selfish, so
focused, evil, bad me those. I just want
to say that. That said, there is an
element of
meaning if that's what we're talking
about, where you feel there's a
for her to be nice. There's a kid who
needs you to be nice for some reason,
you know, whatever. So then you get into
encouraging
and
I think that's very healthy. I think
that's very healthy to have a
conversation with your child about and
say, listen, I know you only like these
two or three kids, but you know, there's
another girl who'd be nice once every
two weeks. Maybe include her. You know,
how can I make it comfortable for you
just in terms of teaching
But I would not be forcing your child to
like have more friends. I don't I don't
even think that's possible.
>> So so before we deal before we with the
neighbors at the front door, but you
don't see
an unhealthy dynamic or consequence of a
fifth grader
that just has two or three friends that
they spend, you know, their recess and
their lunch with that you know, that
click that you you're really this it's
this this woman or or man is describing
almost like
like a click type behavior. She tends to
focus on her core two three friends. I
will tell you that as a menahel, I do
not like that. When I see middle school
kids or whatever age kids is 11 year old
that there's a there's two or three
friends and when it comes to recess they
play their own game and not not that
they're being mean
but when you know by by lunch they're
always sitting together that's not
something that we
>> I agree. In school you have to know the
social etiquette. It's like it would be
like the equivalent of a of a mother who
has two or three good friends who goes
to a sister at event. She shouldn't sit
with her two three friends in a closed
circle in the corner. You're right. She
should sit at the table and be normal.
So you're right. I agree with that.
>> be interested in other classmates or
neighbors who want to play with her.
>> I assume it means outside of school
but
I again, you're right. If there's a
social norm
then you should certainly you know be be
the social norm.
But
you don't have to what what are your
what are you suggesting
that you force this person to have three
new friends? Like be their friend? Be
interested in them.
>> I think again a force I don't the word
force is a harsh word. I do think though
that I would speak to my child about the
importance of having a large circle of
friends, of not just always play with
the same two three girls and and you
could be selfish about it. It's not
going to help you in the long run
because if you had just have two or
three friends no one's going to want to
be friends with you.
Um that's A and B etiquette it's just
not appropriate. You're in an
environment
>> just want to be clear. I just want to be
clear.
>> you're in a neighborhood. There's the
the girls in the block are playing on
Shabbos afternoon. You shouldn't be only
playing two three friends. I had this
one of my sons one of my sons really
didn't he had one or two friends and he
did and and we pushed him to leave his
comfort zone and with with amazing
results of of like it's just not
healthy. It's not
>> Was he unhappy and then
>> Meaning
>> was unhappy
>> and he said, I need more friends? Or he
was happy?
>> Opposite. He was blissfully happy. Every
Shabbat afternoon, ignoring the tumult
down the block and playing just with his
two friends. And we were like, it's
snobbish. It's it's you love it. We
didn't. We thought it was
>> I don't understand. If he was a mother,
if let's say I told you there's a woman
here and he's a kid. I know I'm asking
you a question. Listen to my question.
>> Here you go again.
>> Mrs. Katz across the street from me,
she has two or three friends. She's more
of an introvert by nature. She has a
very busy life
and she's that's her nature. But she has
two or three friends and she's really
friends with them. She WhatsApps, they
share recipes.
She likes them. Do you have a problem
with that?
As I as an adult, you have a problem
with an adult having two or three
friends? You think that's being snobbish
and selfish?
>> No. I don't.
>> Okay. Just want to make it make clear
cuz like I don't know why you have a
double standard.
>> I I can't I can't believe that you're
comparing
raising a child to an adult whose life
is not defined by the social settings
and network that they're in.
A child in their life entire the entire
growth of a child and by and and it's
value and currency is the social
dynamic, social network, and social
standing. And when your child is
exclusive in that social setting, that
has negative consequence that it it
doesn't help the child learn other types
of people and it's it's not I do not
want my child
and I'm not an introvert who who has
hard time connecting. I have a difficult
kid who really just two or three
friends. This is who I like to play
with. I don't want to be friends with
the kids in the block. Again, I'm not
forcing him to have sleepovers with
them, but I am pushing him and and I of
course will add the element um to it.
But no, I I am pushing my child to leave
his comfort zone and to recognize
>> it's a function of anxiety or an area
that they're Okay, cuz that's different.
Then then maybe you need to help them.
>> No. No, I want my child to recognize the
value of other people that are not just
his or her best friends.
>> an adult need to recognize the value of
other people who are just not their two
friends? Why is different?
>> I I I can't believe you're comparing
children to adults.
Adults have a and a healthy adult has
already mastered that
and already learned all of that. And now
again, hopefully. And now the adult has
settled into life, which is a crazy busy
life, and the two or three friends is
either all he or she has time for or
those are the two or three people that
they connect at the end. There there's
adults are not children. We want our
children to have wrote wrote like for
example, I think typical children should
go to sleep away camp or or camp in the
summer. I don't think adults should. I
think it would be a disaster if they
did.
[laughter] I think children are not
adults, and I want my children to expand
their social setting if
>> what if you spend two years expanding it
and they say, okay, I'm now in eighth
grade. You pushed me for four years.
I've been meeting 17 kids. And you know
what? I did it. I mastered it. But now
I'm in eighth grade. I want two or three
friends. Then you're okay with it?
>> I don't think that's I don't think that
has happened.
>> No, but if it would, you'd be okay with
it. Like as long as they learned that
skill in third and fourth and fifth
grade, then you're okay with them having
two or three friends.
>> they're supposed to live with people and
learn how to have people in their circle
that aren't exactly like them.
>> So that when they're adults, they won't
do it.
>> When they're adults, whatever happens in
life happens in life. Two or three
friends you have or you have 10 friends.
>> Well, we're two for two.
>> Listen, I think we could agree that
extremes are always, you know, you can
always say, no, no, no, we're talking in
general, you know, obviously. I can
think of cases where you need to push
kids and you could probably think of
cases where you shouldn't be pushing
kids.
>> trying Am I Am I
These two questions, am I
set at the fact that we're partners? No.
No, I'm not I'm I'm not going back and
saying wow was the learning curve a
mistake. I just I disagree with you
strongly on these two topics.
>> All right. Well, it is what it is.
Listen, I will announce the numbers and
the email at the end. I don't have it in
front of me at the moment, but we would
love for our listeners to opine on these
discussions because they're they're
really important.
And but we're excited to welcome a
special guest to talk about social
stuff, social issues, and socialization
of children.
Right. So it's a perfect segue.
>> So it is now our pleasure to welcome to
the Learning Curve Mosher Trainer.
Mosher Trainer is a speech language
pathologist
um in Lakewood, New Jersey, um
specializes in the social skills um you
know part of speech and language. Um a
very very sought after therapist um who
grew up in in the Heimishe Yeshivas in
in Mir and BMG um and then you know
started his career with tremendous
um has a
um Think Tact is the name of Mosher
Trainer's
you know office and business. Um so
welcome. How are you?
>> Thank you very much. Pleasure being
here.
Thank you for having me on.
>> Yeah, so it's
>> We we just had a conversation about you
know social being social and the
importance of connecting. And as you
know because you this is your area, it's
such a critical thing for children
to have the tools and the ability to
connect socially and appropriately.
So it's a very important thing you do.
You know people think speech therapists
only do lisps and the like and uh
you know communication is a lot more
than pronunciation. That's for sure.
Articulation.
>> Every one of my clients when they meet
me at first
and they and I tell them that I'm a
speech therapist, they give this very
confused look. And they I don't speak
like I don't speak like this, so why am
I coming to you?
>> Right. Exactly.
>> Right. And I also you know when it comes
to language and social skills, you know
what's the most important thing is to
get a therapist that's good and
qualified. That being said, having a
Heimish
therapist that understands the social
demands that the boy or girl is
struggling in
is just I mean it's it's half the game.
It's tremendous. So obviously in
Lakewood um dealing with with you know
frum clientele um is your clientele
children, teenagers, adults, men, women,
where where does it go?
>> I only see the male species.
Um,
because I I have some colleagues that
are women, and so, you know, we'll we'll
kind of split it. If they have a a boy
or a man, they'll send to me. If I have
a girl or a woman, I'll send to them.
Um, I I really don't see anyone under
the age of 10.
Uh, just the the
that I use, the cognitive
uh skills that are necessary.
Younger children are not going to be
able to succeed in that regard. Uh, I
will send the younger children to one of
my women colleagues. Uh, they have a
much more young child-oriented kind of
approach to social skills, and they
often do it in groups as well.
Um, uh but I see up until and my oldest
client, I believe, ever was 63.
>> And his name is No, just joking.
[laughter]
Could you give us a a 90-second layman's
birds-eye view of what it exactly is
speech-language therapy that's not for
stutters and lisps?
>> Sure. So speech language is the key
there. Speech and language are two
separate components of communication.
Speech is the production of
communication. So if someone has a lisp
or can't say a proper r or stutters or
has a voice issue, that's all in his
production. So that is speech therapy.
Language therapy is the brain part of
communication of which there are many
components. There are many components of
the brain part of communication such as
word retrieval,
uh syntactical skills, which is putting
words in the right order in a sentence,
semantic skills, which is the
comprehension of what someone is saying.
And then there's something called
pragmatic language skills, and that is
kind of the social ability to be able to
use the communication in the most
effective way. The goal that I always
tell all my clients is my goal is is to
get you to be someone that can
communicate effectively with anyone that
you're communicating with and that
whoever you're communicating with walks
away feeling like, hey hey, I really
understood what he was saying. It made
sense to me. I got it. And B, it was a
really pleasant
it was a pleasant experience. I look
forward to having more of such kind of
communication with them.
>> On the the children who stutter, adults
who struggle with pragmatic language, is
that often related to
um autism spectrum disorder?
Or could a person who's otherwise, you
know, not autistic, not on the spectrum
also have pragmatic language issues?
>> Right. Just just like just uh to add I I
would my question was the same idea and
then so are are most of the people
coming into your office people that are
struggling to connect with others
through language, which is what we call
spectrum, you know, kind of, right? The
autism world. Is that
the the the arena?
>> So I really see two different types. I
certainly see the spectrumy type of um
boys, whether they're
actually were diagnosed on the spectrum
or whether they
could have or should have been diagnosed
on the spectrum. And I have to clarify
though, if I do see someone on the
spectrum, I'm really only seeing someone
that is on the very high end of the
spectrum.
Because if he's on the middle or lower
end on the spectrum, he needs a little
bit of a different kind of approach.
Again, I'm working with people that are
cognitively quite strong. Um as a matter
of fact, the typical spectrum kind of
client that comes to me is
anywhere between quite bright and
brilliant.
Um you know, Aspergerish type of
profile.
Um but then I also see a completely
different set of of clients who do not
belong and are not on the spectrum, but
for whatever reason,
as we can go through, they just haven't
kind of picked up
on the skills necessary to socialize
correctly. Sometimes it just means that
they get themselves into a lot of
trouble in Yeshiva. Sometimes it means
that they have a very hard time
uh getting along with their Rebbe and
Hula in the school. Sometimes it really
they were able to get through life all
the way,
but when they get to dating, it just
bombs on them. Some of them even make it
through the dating process, but then in
their marriage,
um where the nuances of social
communication is so important,
they they start busting.
>> I
>> just to to bring home one point, I'm I'm
fascinated by the fact that if you're
people that are struggling socially,
struggling to connect, right?
That they end up in your office, which
is almost
it's a pretty impressive self-diagnosis.
In other words, I would assume if
someone is in 10th grade, Yeshiva who's
getting in trouble in Yeshiva, who's not
having friends, he'll go to a therapist,
he'll go to a social worker, he'll go to
his Mashgiach.
He won't have the the wherewithal unless
he's to go to a speech language
pathologist that's able to tell him, no,
you're not struggling because of social
anxiety, you're struggling because of
language. How does someone Does it take
a long time till they land in your
office?
>> Usually not, actually. I'm not sure if
you guys are familiar, there's a there's
an
Igud Igud
Um,
and and the Igud
was really made I think specifically
more for
um around the country. Um, I have I have
presented uh I I give workshops a lot to
schools, Rebbeim, parents, therapists.
Uh, I have presented a few times in
front of them and I think that that has
really opened up their eyes to exactly
what would be a something that would
land in my office and what would be
something that wouldn't and would end up
by a social worker. And so uh for the
most part, most uh certainly in
Lakewood, the Rebbeim, the Menahelim,
they're all familiar
again, a lot a lot of from my workshop,
they're familiar with what I do and they
therefore know kind of who to send to
me.
>> Cool.
Uh, I mean, I think I would ask even
more fundamentally,
how do you know if it's for you or for a
psychologist?
I mean, a kid who's struggling socially
in 10th grade,
I I would probably first go to a
psychologist. I mean,
how would you distinguish when it's
appropriate [snorts] for you?
>> So ge generally the the
we could go into kind of what are the
underlying skills that are that are
lacking, but for the most part, the the
of someone coming to me is a lack of
awareness.
As a matter of fact, most of us, you and
I, for example, did we learn social
skills? We never went to a social skills
rebbe.
Gemara we had rebbeim teach us. You
know, math we had teachers teach us. But
social skills we never had anyone teach
us, but rather we naturally have it
built into our brain that we can observe
the society, observe the world and pick
up on it. As a matter of fact, um
studies have shown that children as
young as 18 months old are able to
really pick up on some of these very
basic uh skills necessary for for social
skills. It It's fascinating some of the
studies they've done at such young
children.
Um but the child that comes to me is
generally is just he doesn't have that
awareness. And if he doesn't have that
awareness, if you're lacking the
awareness, you're just not picking up on
the skills that everyone else is picking
up naturally. So if it's someone that is
more uh behavioral kind of child, he's
just being very
uh you know, oppositional to his
rebbeim, or he's just getting into
fights with the kids in his class
because he's just a you know,
hyperactive kind of bochur or something
like that, then he's going to go more to
a social worker or a psychiatrist or
psychologist. But if it's if the rebbeim
ascertain that it's more he's just not
getting it. We're explaining to him,
we're talking to him and he's just not
getting it,
that's when he'll end up more in my
office.
>> Just Just um just to end and then you'll
take the question. Five years ago, I had
a child in my school
who we
I don't want to say misdiagnosed. We had
an uh an understanding of this child
that he was just a
that he was just ignoring us. You tell
him to do one thing, he would do the
opposite. And we were like, this kid is
ODD, this kid is is all
and he's a liar.
And it took a lot
It actually took a language therapist
sitting in my office.
And he says to me that that this doctor
says to me, I I spoke to this kid. He's
like, he does not have he's not a liar.
He doesn't have ODD.
He has a speech language problem.
>> Mm.
>> And he went to speech language therapy.
And not overnight, but it was
it was it was such an eye-opening moment
that if the kid doesn't have that skill,
then everything that he's doing you're
mistranslating because he's just unaware
literally this point.
>> I I'll give you one of my favorite
stories. It was one of my first clients
that I ever worked with was a an eighth
grader who
Rebbe was complaining he keeps doing
Sudoku in the middle of class.
And Rebbe kept telling him you got to
stop. He would put it away and take it
back out again. Eventually Rebbe took
away his Sudoku book. He sits down and
he asks Rebbe when can I get it back,
which is a problem in itself. Um but
Rebbe says Friday.
Friday morning he meets Rebbe at the
door of the school building already. Can
I get my Sudoku book back?
And Rebbe tells him listen I'm going to
give it back to you, but you got to
promise me you're not going to take it
out during learning.
So
he says I promise.
The Rebbe tells me
three minutes into the first period the
Sudoku book is on his Gemara. The
Rebbe's about to explode. But Rebbe knew
that I had been working with him and he
realized. So Rebbe waited till the first
break
and Rebbe pulls him aside and says what
are you what are you doing? What are you
talking about?
And the Rebbe told me the kid's look on
his face you could see he had no idea
what Rebbe wanted from him.
It turned out see Rebbe had told him
that you can't take it out during
learning. He took it out when someone
was asking a question.
But this was real. He absolutely
followed Rebbe's instructions to the T.
>> Wow.
Wow.
Okay, that's quite a story. All right,
I'm going to ask you what we call our
spotlight question uh and it you know
opens up the conversation a little
further.
>> [music]
>> This episode of The Learning Curve is
sponsored by Clever Candy Fruit Jelly
Jewels.
Love the classic taste and nostalgic
appeal of Sunkist Fruit Gems?
Meet Clever Candy Fruit Jelly Jewels,
the delicious new alternative that
brings back the taste and texture candy
lovers remember. Each individually
wrapped features a soft jelly center
signature crisp sugar coating. The
twist, a refreshed flavor lineup.
Blueberry, cherry, orange, lemon,
grapefruit and lime.
No artificial colors or flavors.
Kosher certified from the the
Gluten free, perfect for bar and bat
mitzvahs and special celebrations.
Clever Candy Fruit Jelly Jewels. The
tradition continues. Clever Candy Fruit
Jelly Jewels are available now
nationwide at
economycandy.com
and select its sugar retail locations.
>> My son is in eighth grade.
He doesn't really have close friends.
He has a bit of a domineering
personality and doesn't notice or care
if that results in everyone getting
annoyed with him.
His younger brother on the other hand is
extremely socially savvy.
I used to chalk it up to personality
differences and maturity on the part of
my older son,
but the older he gets, the more worried
I am
that he won't just grow out of this.
What do you think I should What do you
think I should be doing for this
situation?
>> I guess and just to just to hone in, at
what point
does a parent say
this is not just immaturity. This is a
son who can't connect socially. He's
missing the social cues in life
>> Right.
>> and therefore I have to call the think
tank.
>> So so let me give a little background
here.
The the concept that someone is lacking
social skills
um is not is not a a learned thing.
It's not something that parents just
didn't teach their child or didn't model
it for their child. Um somewhere down
the road we're going to find it on a
gene somewhere. We haven't yet, but
we're going to find it somewhere. Um it
there's no question that it's it's it's
something in their DNA.
And and just like we have found many
things on the DNA, we'll probably find
this one day. But what's going on is is
again, as I said before,
naturally most of us
we we just
we we pick it up and we pick it up from
a very very young age.
Um,
there's a fascinating study they did.
I'll just share that very briefly where
they put in front of
uh
very young children, 18 months old, bowl
of broccoli and a bowl of crackers
and they tell the child you can have
whatever you want and every single child
is sitting and pressing the crackers
but then the researcher tells the child
takes a taste of the crackers. No, I
don't like crackers. Yo, I love
broccoli.
And they ask the child can you give me
some now?
And
you could see the 14 months old in the
study kept giving the the researcher the
crackers.
The 18 months old were giving the
broccoli.
In other words, they were able to
already understand that even though I
think crackers are delicious and
broccoli is horrible, but I can
understand that you think differently
and I'm going to be with you. I'm going
to I'm going to deal with you from your
way of thinking.
So children at very young age were able
to kind of pick up on that concept
already. It's called theory of mind.
>> We call that empathy?
>> We call it theory of mind. Theory of
mind means the ability to understand
that someone else could think
differently than me
and that when I deal with that person,
I'll deal with that person from his
perspective, from his way of thinking.
>> Mhm.
Wow.
>> Okay.
Um, so so what happens is these children
for whatever reason who come here they
for whatever reason their brain doesn't
pick up on it.
So
often it they seem if you don't have the
the understanding of the knowledge, they
seem to be domineering or aloof or
something like that. They're not really.
It's just I call it they're very very
narrow minded. All they see
is just their own selves. It's not being
selfish. It's not being um you know
narcissistic. They simply can't see
anything outside of their own view of
things. They just can't see it. So yes,
my son might seem like domineering
but you know if if I'm if I'm having a
conversation with him
and he still can't change or he can't
understand what I'm saying, then that
would tell me that he's lacking that.
>> Well, that sounds like autism
to me.
The inability to see perspectives
Isn't that autism?
>> The the most um
the most
important principle that people with
autism are lacking is theory of mind.
>> So but you could have that
problem without autism, like isolated?
>> Absolutely. Now, theory of mind has many
levels. So there are kind of lower
levels and higher levels. Um
people that have autism have almost no
theory of mind. So even very weak levels
um they'll struggle with you know the
the the who, for example, is
I I I had I had a recently who was very
into mountain biking and all he can talk
to his friends about is mountain biking
and nothing else.
And he complains when they talk about
other things because it's so boring.
So that that that's that's a spectrum
kind of thing. He's he's just it's a
very low level. But then you have you
know a a higher level where sometimes
you kind of get the basics of it, but in
the fine tuning of it you struggle. I
can give you an example uh just you know
a younger man who was married for a few
months
comes home and his wife is crying. And
it turns out his wife is crying because
it was her birthday.
Every single person in her life
basically
um wished called her wished her happy
birthday, but her own husband didn't.
Now, here's the background. The
background is it happens to be in his
family
birthdays are are a non-entity. It's not
a big deal. Like like you you didn't
accomplish anything. What did you do?
Nothing. You know what I'm saying? So by
the time they turn about 10 11 in his
family, he tells me I don't even know
where my siblings' birthdays are. You
know? So so so so if you understand his
perspective, you can understand why he
didn't say anything. But what I tell is
there's three types of responses you can
give.
One response would be
Are serious?
Your your birthday?
Are you are you eight?
Okay, that's not bad social skills.
That's bad
Okay. But what would be very common for
someone who comes to me who's not
spectrumy is where he would say
No,
let me explain. See, in my family it
happens to be
that we don't make a big deal about
birthdays. That's why I didn't.
And what I explained to them is all
you're doing is you're explaining to the
other person why according to your
perspective you shouldn't be upset.
But that's that's not good theory of
mind. Good theory of mind says you
handle with the other person from his
perspective. Oh my gosh, I can't believe
it. That's horrible. The whole world
called you on your own husband.
I I could just imagine that what that
would feel like. Later on you can tell
him what you think you have and you
everything. So that's that's kind of a
higher level of theory of mind and
that's not not spectruming people. But
just lacking that. I need to be taught
that.
>> And that's rooted in language?
>> It's a skill.
It's a it's a lack of understand being
able to read a situation within a
communication and operate it
efficiently.
Pragmatic language is the ability to be
efficient in your communication.
>> It's it's a much broader definition I
think than most of us are used to. Not
that it's not accurate.
I think most people like said before
limit speech and language
to certainly articulation issues which
we talked about, but even broader more
like specific to some kind of language
processing problem.
This is more just as we talked about
like the skills
which it's not like you can't learn this
from a psychologist either, you know,
that that is something that a a
therapist might talk about, but it's
also something that a speech and
language therapist might talk about.
>> Yeah. I I would actually add um when I
went to get my training uh
my more advanced training out in
California in this clinic called the
social thinking clinic, which is really
the primary methodology that I use in my
in my office. Um I actually went
together with a social worker as well
and we we get kind of trained together.
So, so there is there is certainly
overlap over there.
>> overlap, yeah.
>> I I would imagine that there's another
tremendous arena where especially boys
will struggle, girls also, and that is
academics. In other words, when you're
trying to understand, I mean, let's talk
the Gemara sounds frightening to this
child. When you're trying to understand
a
with a
of a Gemara, a Ramban, I mean, just it
sounds overwhelming to that child
or that that that struggles with
language,
you know, processing or it doesn't
understand the nuance of language, even
the pragmatics of language forget
socially. The academic piece
can it it sounds like like like a
a fiber line fire.
>> Right. So so I I I don't usually
directly address those skills. That's
more what Rabbi Garfield said before and
mentioned language processing. That's
more what I call the academic angle of
language skills. Um, there are some
other therapists that work on that.
My my challenge was, almost as you just
mentioned,
bringing that up to a level that someone
can be successful enough to be able to
dissect the
within the parameters of the language
therapy that we have knowledge of
is a bit of a challenge.
So so it you know, there are for
example, there are a number of very
successful
um people here in Lakewood that work
with language processing. They'll
Are you aware of the
Um,
>> Yeah, of course.
>> So I've had boys of my Yeshiva that have
been unbelievably successful in language
processing by using her that that using
that technique.
>> Yes, that's that's a very very well
researched and well accepted language
processing tool. Yeah.
>> Correct. Within academics.
>> Yes.
>> But that's not, right, but that's that
but
you tell me
>> That's not that's not going to bring you
anywhere near a
>> Can you explain that more?
The the the depth of understanding the
the depth of understanding that is
necessary for a piece of
The Linda Mood Bell is going to help you
speed up your processing
speed a bit. It'll help you be able to
hold threads together and and and
organize it. But the the the the the
there's so much depth that is necessary
for
to understand, which is why, for
example, you know, we don't teach it to
fifth graders.
A child has to go through so much
learning just to be able to get there.
So the the language skills alone can get
them to be able to, for example, do a
good
understanding of the
but
he really has to go through now seven
more years of learning to get to the
But if I'm getting a who's coming to me
is 18 years old and he's lacking those
skills and he's starting Linda Mood Bell
now,
you know, I I can get him to
but but
is a lot of lot of steps in between.
Now, if he sits in
and and then goes with that skill, you
know, maybe he can get there. But the
therapy alone wasn't really I I want to
share anecdotally. I just want to share
anecdotally. I had a a student
who went to Linda Mood Bell who
struggled tremendously as a young child.
He's maybe the biggest
and math and hard worker that I know.
And today is an absolute
in in in learning. And he went from a
boy that was really didn't belong in my
school almost with special ed. And today
he's absolute
Now,
the the dedication and the perseverance
of this boy is
But but no. So for parents that have a
child that's in the second, third,
fourth grade, now's the time, right? If
you can jump ahead, I've seen it
daily yearly
Linda Mood Bell and others, language
therapy that have un that have opened up
a new world to a child that would not
have existed. But but, you know, which
is different than what um
what you're doing. How how do you get
I was curious cuz the question was about
an eighth grader and you mentioned about
getting early intervention. I'm I'm
wondering to ask uh Mr. Trainer, what's
the age You know, I think a lot of
parents push off intervention cuz they
hope, you know, it'll be okay. But is
there an age that you think is the
window where children are most uh
receptive to this kind of help?
>> So uh it's actually a bit of a dilemma
because the problem is,
as we said, if the if the
of the deficit is a lack of awareness,
that means that the child who's coming
to me doesn't think that there's
anything wrong.
He doesn't think there's any issue at
all.
>> Right.
>> And so, you know,
it's a bit of a a challenge to be able
to kind of balance that. Um so the the
the big challenge for me often is is
that when someone's coming to me, often
it's the parents that are pushing them
to come.
Some boys will just enjoy my
personality and they're happy to get
away from school a little bit, so
they're happy to come. But some, you
know, give resistance. Um I'm in the
middle of dealing with now with uh
>> Right.
>> I'm sorry?
>> They say, what do I need this for? I'm
fine.
>> often my life is fine, you know? And
they don't really see the deficit. Um
what I I I have I I I've worked on
training um some other people into this
profession as well, into this specific
profession. And whenever I train them,
one of the first things I tell them is
the the most successful clients are the
ones that hop the social patch.
Um because
they they kind of saw it and they really
couldn't deny it. So they got kicked
kicked out of three yeshivas and no one
wants to take them anymore. Um they're
they're dating for three, four years and
they're getting rejected on their first
and second date every time. You know,
they got they got divorced or something
like that. Those people are generally
the most successful clients because
they're so motivated, they you kind of
saw it thrown in their face. But the
problem is I never want to have someone
come to that. So I would much much
rather work with someone as young as
possible to try to remediate this. Now
again I don't I I happen not to work
with younger than 10 because my
it doesn't work and I don't connect to
those children very well. But if someone
feels like their child is already you
know they can see that lack of awareness
I would tell them start when he's
really young. Yes the earlier you start
the more you're going to accomplish.
Having said that for the most part
the the the the the
bulk of my clientele is
that is the bulk of my clientele.
They're really in that in between.
>> Let me ask the question again. We asked
it before but I want I maybe I don't
have it clear enough so I want to get
it. If I am a parent of that child who's
a 10th grader who's struggling in
Yeshiva
I I'm going to make one phone call not
four. I'm not going to call nine
different arenas. I'm not going to call
a speech pathologist and a psychologist
and a psychiatrist and a you know and an
LMFT.
How do I My son is struggling in
Yeshiva. His didn't go to the
you know what's it called training. They
called me up and they said your son is
struggling socially. He's struggling
with friends.
I don't know what he's doing in
learning. Leave that aside.
Is there two or three things that if my
son or daughter are presenting with this
then I call think tact?
>> So yeah the
let me kind of name some of the main
skills that are necessary for social
success and if if your child is lacking
those skills then that's really what
you're going to see. Number one is what
we said theory of mind. If you
consistently have conversations with
your child and you see that no matter
how much you present the other side of
the coin he just doesn't seem to be able
to integrate that. Now it doesn't mean
doesn't mean that he has to agree to the
other side but he has to be able to
integrate that into the conversation but
if your child cannot he really just has
very much what we call that tunnel
thinking. He just only sees things his
way then then then that's that's a
that's a red flag that would bring him
to think tact. Um another very important
kind of deficit or skill that's
necessary is flexibility or the the the
opposite of that is rigidity.
Um we we generally describe four types
of rigidity that a parent already would
see.
The first one is that they have a very
hard time with change. Um and again you
can often see that in the spectrum world
change is murder for them to to shift
gears to to change plans or anything
like that is very very difficult for
them.
>> It's a it's a cognitive theory of mind,
right?
>> I'm sorry?
>> It's a cognitive theory of mind.
>> That's why it's all part of the social
skills paradigm. Yes. Yes, but it's it's
it's it's inability to shift. These are
people that are often just as an example
extremely picky eaters. They will
literally only eat like a very small
handful of foods because this is what I
like and I don't want to try other
things, you know. I just like to stay
with what I like.
Um you know this is the guy who who when
his father wants to go daven a different
shul on Shabbos just has a tantrum. He
he can't deal with it because
>> I'm that parent so if I'm a parent I
know there are parents listening to this
podcast right now and saying oh my gosh
my seventh grade daughter or son is a
wonderful I have no problems. He's the
pickiest eater in the world. Oh my gosh
does that mean he won't be able to get
married because he won't be able to date
well?
>> Yeah right. So so again I I I want to
name the skills. I'm just giving some
examples of the themes of that. Um but
you want to look at the whole panel of
the skills. But you know if your child
is a very picky eater but for example if
you tell them on
we're going to this and this park and
then you you wake up in the morning and
say oh you know what we're changing
that. We're going somewhere else and he
doesn't have a tantrum then it doesn't
really mean that he's that he has
trouble with change. But if he has a lot
of trouble with change, change routine,
change in schedule, change in people um
every new school year is terrifying for
him. Not
and you remind them but you remember
last year you also were scared about and
then you ended up liking your rebbe. No
no blah blah I'm used to my rebbe. I I
can't change all that. Then, you know,
if you're seeing that across many areas,
then he he's showing a lot of rigidity.
Um, the second type of rigidity is that
they they have a very hard time problem
solving. So, they get very stuck. I call
it stuck in the problem.
They can't think of solutions. They
can't think of ideas. Um, these are the
kids who, for example, are always
complaining at home, I'm bored.
Now, again, many kids complain they're
bored. You have to know how far it goes.
But but if someone's just he he never
could think of an idea of anything. He
can't generate his own ideas, then his
brain is quite is quite rigid.
Um, again, let me just go through them
first. The the third rigidity is really
directly theory of mind. It's he's rigid
and that he can only see his
perspective. He can't see someone else's
perspective. So, in other words, if
someone has weak very weak theory of
mind, he's being very rigid.
The fourth one is probably the most
common one that I hear in my office, and
that's black and white thinking.
All or nothing. So, you know, it's just
it's amazing or it's terrible. So, you
know, these are the guys who are always
negative and and and and my my my rebbe
is terrible. And you'll go over them,
you say, but but but don't you like
this? Yeah, but he's terrible. Um, you
know, very very black and white.
Everything has to be
Actually, very often that's linked to
rigid number two. I have a great
example. I have I had a boy who was
always complaining he was bored at home.
And his one day his mother had enough
and she sat him down with her pen and
paper and she said, listen, you got to
write me down ideas of what you could do
when you're bored. We're going to have
that list and then we'll be able to use
it.
So, he did.
Here are the items that he wrote on his
paper.
I Play America,
Six Flags, American Dream Water Park,
uh, and and and a few other things like
that. Those were the only things in his
mind that he would do when he's bored.
That's very black and white. It's very
black and white thinking. He can't It's
It's all or nothing. He has to have very
high level kind of excitement for him or
else it doesn't work. So, that's very
very very black and white thinking for
that.
Um, so those are those are things if
parents see a lot of that again, don't
just
see it one time and say, oh my gosh, my
child needs therapy. But if you're
seeing these kinds of deficits over many
different areas and over a period of
time, then yes, he's having trouble with
that. Another another deficit also just
to mention is um people that are very
literal.
That that we see a lot and you see that
a lot on the spectrum, but people that
are very literal um like if you tell
them I'm coming back in a minute and
they go crazy because it wasn't a
minute,
that's that's a deficit that they would
>> all of your examples I keep thinking
about the spectrum.
>> And yeah, and if they go to think tact,
can they be confident that you can
heal them just like that in two
sessions?
>> It took a long time to get to that
question.
>> Two sessions. Two sessions guaranteed.
>> Here here's the thing. I I and I tell
every single parent that enters my room
before I meet anyone, I always meet the
parents first. And one of the things I
tell them is we can't fix your child.
Because again, think about it. If it's
not natural, it's not natural. I'll give
you a perfect example. Take someone
who's extremely clumsy, very clumsy.
Um but like really bad clumsy.
You can do all the physical therapy in
the world. He's not going to become this
ballet dancer. It is just not because
it's not natural. Now, you could make
him become a lot less clumsy, but you
can't make it become natural.
If it's true as we said that this this
social skills deficits are something on
the DNA, it's it's just in their brain.
I can't I'm not a brain surgeon. I can't
change that.
So we can't really fix them, but what we
do is we make them
perform a lot better compared to where
they are. And that's what we really aim
for.
Having said that, a couple of kind of
disclaimers about that, if a boy comes
to me and he really isn't a spectrumy
kind of boy, he just for some reason
just didn't get some of this, then
sometimes we really could kind of fix
them because it really wasn't a true
deficit. They just didn't really get it.
And I have plenty of those clients and
they can do a lot better. Um and the
other disclaimer is even though we can't
fix them, um, we've brought them to
amazing places. I I just married a
bocher off a week ago that was deemed
unmarriageable. Um, and now we had to
walk through it. I had to speak to the
other side during the dating process
even. They had to kind of know what
they're getting into when the girl is
maybe not exactly perfect, but but we
can get them to a place where they can
get married, where they can be
successful in life, hold on to a job,
etc.
>> Amazing.
Well, this was great and we really
appreciate you coming on and really
sensitizing our listeners to some of
these issues and also, more importantly,
some of the solutions that there are
people out there like yourself
who are able to help in these type of
situations. So we're we're so
appreciative.
>> If I can for a minute just to give
parents even a little bit more, um, you
know, because parents ask me all the
time, what can I do at home?
>> Yeah.
>> You know, if my child does have this
deficit.
So one one of the things I always tell
them is
it's best if you, now that you
understand these skills, and by the way,
I
I always encourage a parent to sit in on
the session if their child can handle
that, because that way they're kind of
learning what exactly I'm teaching their
child.
But what I tell [clears throat] them is
model this at home, speak it out at
home. So let's say for example, um, you
know, you were you're going to go
somewhere and the and the Uber didn't
show up and now you have to run late
later at home, speak to your children
and say, you know, it was amazing how I
really had to adapt because originally I
was about to fall apart, but then I
realized, you know something,
falling apart is not going to work for
me. So what I did was I did this and
that to help me kind of adapt and
change.
If you speak that out to your child,
you're really kind of modeling for them
the thing that they don't naturally
have. And the more you model that kind
of thing for them, the more you can
really, you know, help.
A child gets in trouble with his menal,
you tell the child, I have your back
100% but but I would love for you to
hear, why do you think your menal feels
the way he feels? Let's just have a
discussion about that.
You You that's the kind of thing that
you could open up and expose your child
to this kind of thinking, which is very
helpful.
>> Amazing.
All right. Thank you so much. We really
appreciate you joining us.
>> Thank you. That was wonderful.
Absolutely wonderful.
That was wonderful, Rabbi Garfield. And
you know, as
as a menahel who has almost gone through
this process with children
in I don't want to say mislabeling,
misdiagnosing, or being becoming much
more aware
of the different types of challenges
that kids have
and knowing that there's different
lanes, right? There's the there's the
behavioral lane and then there is the
language lane.
Um I've seen tremendous success in my
own yeshiva with it and
you know, Moshe Trainer was
not just eloquent, not just passionate,
but but you know, I thought very
forceful and just explaining to parents
the different types of children that we
have
and um and being advocates for them, but
also getting them the right help, not
just any help.
>> 100% Yeah, it was great.
And he's not the only one. It's a whole
industry. So wherever you live, you
know,
um
>> And I was curious to hear that he
that that he mentioned that like we
said, are there people aware? And he
said, well, there's you know,
that there is you know, it's not spoken
about loudly, but I know Rabbi Elephant
in the mirror, he spoke to the to the
menahel about this when we had him on on
your leadership group about the fact
that he runs now this group of menahalim
in yeshivas to try to
give over the value, the importance, the
education of mental health and at least
yeshivas should know what to identify,
you know, who to call, things of that
nature.
>> 100%
>> he's on the front lines, Moshe Trainer,
and he was
um at the very insightful.
Um
>> Speaking of who to call,
what a transition. What a transition.
[snorts] So we always love to remind our
listeners, especially after today's
opening discussion,
to share their thoughts and written
comments. We appreciate people's
comments whether they call in, are they
right?
The number to in is 443
that's 4 436
>> Or if you're upset at you could call his
cell phone WHICH IS
>> [laughter]
>> 443
UM OR YOU CAN SEND AN email to the
learning curve at mishpacha.com that's
the learning curve at mishpacha.com
>> Enjoyable as always.
>> All right, all the best. Take care.
>> Take care.
>> [music]