Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
[music]
Did you know that the forgotten founder
of Zionism went on to play a leading
role in Agura Israel or that Rakhalky
[music] was responsible for the
continued presence of the Muslim wack on
Harabayas? It turns out that the margins
of history tell the real story. Behind
the Times dives into the big concepts
and overlooked moments that carry vast
meaning all through the lens of Torah
and rabbitic thought. Join me, Gdalia
Gutag, as I go behind the times to
explore the forgotten history,
remarkable personalities, and
transformative moments that shape
current events and explain how we got
here. Behind the Times with Gdalia
Gutenag.
On July the 26th, 1956,
the Egyptian ruler Gaml Abdul Nasser
gave a speech that set off a regional
war that reverberates till today. In a
speech that he gave in Alexandria in
front of a big crowd. So this is the
Egyptian strongman, dictator, very very
uh um charismatic personality. He told
the crowd about a meeting that he'd had
with an American banker named Eugene
Black. Black was the head of the IMF,
the the International Monetary Fund in
Washington, which is like a global bank
meant to help out economies in in need.
And he described how he's gone capinand
to the IMF to request uh money, a large
loan for a mega project that was going
to do something big things for Egypt's
economy, the building of the Azwan Dam.
Now, the Azwan Dam stands today and it's
a hydroelectric project. It provides uh
it it provides electricity for Egyptian
uh uh consumption. And NASA tells the
crowd in Alexandria the following
things. I began to look at Mr. Black
sitting there in his chair. The Egyptian
leader told this big crowd in Alexandria
and I imagined that I was sitting there
in front of Ferdinand Dlesps. Now as
both the as both NASA and his crowd knew
this dileence was a was a bad
associations for Egyptians because he
was the French diplomat who had said who
had first pro promoted the idea of a
sewers canal but essentially became a
French and British project that was that
that was a symbol of colonial
humiliation for for Egyptians. That was
what the crowd in uh in Alexandria were
hearing that comparison. But but
actually what was what in those repeated
mentions of dleseps, there was something
going on because while the crowds in
Alexandria heard one thing, it would in
fact was broadcast and NASA was using it
as a code word because miles away an
Egyptian team of officials stormed
essentially the headquarters of the
canal uh management uh in near in near
the Swiss canal and it took it over.
They were there to nationalize the Swiss
canal just months before the British had
withdrawn their troops. It was a British
colonial uh project and they had
withdrawn their troops as they felt
under pressure from NASA and now NASA
had completed the coup because in the
middle of his speech um he had uh the
code word had gone out the t and the
troops and the and the officials had
gone in and taken over the canal. In
fact during the speech uh NASA is
updated that it's happened. He then
tells the crowd during his speech that
we've taken over nationalized the Sewish
Canal and in fact he said remember the
Azwan dam he said we're going to finance
it ourselves that 35 million that we
that that goes toward that that in fees
that transit transiting uh ships
transiting the Egyptian uh the sewers
canal make uh provide every year and
we're instead going to the to the
British and French governments. It's now
going to go to us and we will finance
our own dam. In fact, it was I think the
the the Russians who stepped in and
financed some of it as well. But anyway,
this is what he told the crowd. That
act, that speech, the act of as Britain
and France saw it as an a belligerent
act was something that triggered months
later the sewers crisis because months
later together with Israel, together
with the young IDF, the British and the
French put their forces into Egypt and
they want to topple NASA. They want to
take back the canal topple NASA in a
secret behind the-scenes plot and that
in turn uh reverberates till today
because the failure of that of that plan
Britain and France uh to cut a long
story short under American pressure were
forced to withdraw their troops from the
S canal from Egypt. Israel was forced to
withdraw back give back this the Senai
desert and Gaza that produced what has
gone down in British polit particularly
in British history as the ultimate in
humiliations known as a sewers moment
which is when a world power um is
exposed his powers is exposed as being
far less than was thought and fast
forward 70 years with America in what
looks like retreat over the straits of
Hormuz the failure to capture the
streets for has has um raised obviously
it's a very neat uh you know yacht site
70 years but it actually has raised the
genuine spectre the American uh failure
to to to keep this to keep the hummus
straits open and Iran's ability to to
inflict economic pain on the on on on
America and the world has raised the
question 70 years after the sewers
crisis as it's known in Britain are we
now witnessing sing an American sewers
[music]
to get into the kishkas of what actually
happened there in the sewers crisis.
Let's go into a place called Sea which
is a place just out par outside Paris
October the 22nd 1956 when three badly
disguised Israelis arrive in a villa.
Inside the villa are the top um uh
really the top three figures in in in on
French politics. the prime minister, the
foreign and defense ministers are
gathered around there and they're joined
by three Israelis in in in is in comic
opera disguised. There's there's a
there's a there's a man with a shock of
white hair who who's who's wearing some
type of wig to disguise it, the fact
that he's really David McGurian. There's
a man with an eye patch who's wearing a
uh who's wearing a pair of sunglasses to
disguise the fact that he's actually
Mosha Dian. And there's a much younger
man, 33y old then who is who is Shimon
Perez who despite his youth is far from
call because he is the director general
of the Israeli defense ministry. A very
very senior position then uh back then
as well. And so these three badly
disguised Israelis are there in town to
do one thing. They're there in town to
parlay and convene in secret with the
French and the British. What is the
motivations for everyone around the
table? This is the most incredibly it's
incredible to think of this scene really
besides besides the bizarre detail of
the of the of the bad disguise.
But the French the French have secretly
flown these Israelis in on a French
military plane and they've had to go was
it would took them 17 hours to get
there. It's an Ask they've got there
through the back way the back alleys and
their interest to be around the table is
very simple. They hate NASA. The
Israelis fear NASA. He's then NASA is
then in his pump in his he's there he's
united the Arab world under him um as a
as with his dream of of secular
panarabism nationalism um in which he
says we can throw off the yoke of the
oppressor by kicking the British and the
French and the Americans and everyone
and their imperial lackey and lap dogs
out of the out of the Middle East and
part of the plan is obviously to kick to
throw the Jews into the sea. NASA is
then at that point arming fedí which is
gangs of terrorists basically like Hamas
Nukba terrorists who cross the border
from from Sinai and from and
particularly from the Gaza Strip and
murder and maim Israelis across the
south. So the Israelis fear the fedí
they want to take a knock knock Nassa a
peg a peg or two down. Um they also want
to unseat him because he's he's
inflicted he's he's he's blockaded the
streets of Tyran which lead to the which
lead to a latin Israel cannot um uh
cannot uh therefore engage in foreign
trade. So, Israel is is in the market
for anyone with a campaign and it's
going to be the first outing the the the
first the first proof of the military
prowess and the development of the IDF
into a regional power regional military
power and that's going to be one aspect
of it. But what are the French and the
British doing around that table? Well,
the French are another story. They must
remember after the second world war
tried to rebuild their colonial
possessions, their their their empire
and they have troops in um in al in
Algeria. Now the algerians don't like it
at all. They don't like the settler
colonialism. They don't like who are
called the settler French uh European
settlers there in are known as Penoir uh
black feet. They want to kick them out
and there is an insurgency. Now the
insurgency is funded and armed by NASA.
The insurgency is the LN and the the
front for liberation of national you
know f that's what it means in French n
national liberation front is funded by
NASA the French therefore are delighted
to bring NASA down what are the British
doing over there so the British very
simple the British it's hard to imagine
now with little England failing you know
failing to get uh to to to to exert any
power whatsoever the British in 1956 are
still a a world power they are still
They're crumbling world power, but
they're still a world power. It's only
in 1971 the British are going to leave
the Middle East, leave the Gulf States,
create the Gulf States um uh from at
that stage is still known as the
Truchial States. And and Britain has
very extensive interests in the area. By
interest, we mean money. The British had
a huge a large part part of their of
their foreign reserves come from the
stake that they own in for example Anglo
Iranian oil company. The Iranian
national oil company is providing some
25% of its profits to the British
excheer, the British treasury. The
Britain needs cheap oil for its economy
to keep the lights on, but it also needs
foreign exchange. And this is what is
being threatened because at that point
NASA has Britain by the throat because
this narrow waterway of the of the
sewers canal is what is is long is
providing British oil and it's providing
British foreign currency um is providing
income for the UK uh treasury excheer
and Britain cannot afford to let this go
on. this fact that 3 months before this
meeting um NASA has seized and
nationalized the sewers canal which
gives him control effectively over
Europe's oil supplies that is what has
brought these three actors around the
table
[music]
now it's fair to say that between that
that whilst the shik between um the
Israelis and the French is a good one at
that stage it's it's for for the next
decade France is their is the only uh
power that is uh providing modern
weapons to Israel. There's an there's a
there's an British military embargo.
There's an is an American military
embargo, but they're receiving fighter
planes and tanks from the Israelis. The
IDF is getting fighter planes and tanks
from the French. So that's fine. They
get on well together. But Britain and
Israel, this is not a good shock. This
is not a good shock. Remember, it's only
8 years since Britain effectively fought
the Israelis, fought the IDF by proxy.
Literally, they had British officers
were and and equipment were going to the
Jordanian Arab Legion fighting. The
British were in effect British officers
were killing Jews in in in in Israel.
It's incredible to think. And it's
remains incredible to think that that um
that only eight years later, Britain and
Israel were sitting around that table
together. Israel did not trust Britain
as far as it could throw it. Um, it did
not trust Brit, they they were
suspicious of what the French would do
and the British would do. They suspected
that if that what that what could happen
is that they were going to embark on a
campaign together and that Britain and
France would then abandon uh Israel and
let it take the would let it take the
blame. um uh the international blame and
international con condemnation and
therefore the isolation diplomatic
isolation that would come as a result
and and and uh so that what these
Israelis around the table Bengurian um
Dian and Shimon Perez demanded they say
we want this in writing we want this in
writing you are going to sign we're
going to keep it secret but you are
going to sign you the French and the
British are going to sign on the dotted
line that you agree to this and that is
in fact what they get they get a a plan
and the plan is going to be as follows
very simple very simple but you're going
to see slightly farical aspects as well
or less than believable let's call it
because the plan is for Israel to do
most of the fighting to storm towards
the sewers canal um right through Sai
Gaza and Sai take it over and and then
the Egyptians are going to obviously
fight back and then the British and the
French are going to say hey hey you
can't fight over an internationally
sensitive strategic waterway we have to
separate the two sides we're going to
come in as the as the responsible
world's uh responsible policeman
separate the two sides and we're going
to have our and in order to separate the
two sides we're going to control the S
canal very conveniently it was a plan as
far as plans go but what it hadn't
foreseen was that that the plan might
fall apart when it made contact with
reality
[music]
on the afternoon of October the 29th
1956 which is just days after the
meeting in Paris and just months After
NASA's speech, the plan went into action
and in fact it went into action with is
with the first stage was Israel an
Israeli attack. Israel airborne the
paratroopers hundreds of paratroopers
dropped off um jumped off over the
Mitler pass with Mabar Mitla um the
Mitla pass which is ver which is
approaching the canal deep into um deep
into the started a ferocious battle.
This was the first real ma um um action
of the IDF as a modern army under with
with jets and with and with tanks they
pushed their way around the the passes
the passes that go through the center of
the Sinai uh peninsula and they push
towards the canal and and like clockwork
the very next day the the British say
that's it. The British and the French
come as as was planned. They said we
cannot have this threat to an
international waterway. They gave an
ultimatum both to Egypt, to Nasa and to
Benguran saying both Israel and Egypt
need to withdraw their forces. In fact,
in other in other words, the Egyptians
effectively need to leave the Sur Canal
otherwise we will step in. Well,
obviously NASA having just kicked the
British out of Egypt, he's in no mood to
compromise. He says, "No way. We're
going to fight." And the British say,
the British and the French say, "Okay."
and they drop their paratroopers in
around the canal and they start sending
their naval forces then as well. They
bomb the Egyptian air force from bases
in Cyprus and and elsewhere and they
start a campaign and the Egyptian
military is not doing well. But then
what happens is the thing starts falling
apart because NASA it turns out has a
weapon. What is his weapon? His weapon
is blocking the Sewish Canal. He takes
some ships, he sinks them in the Sewish
Canal. The markets all over the world go
wild. What's clear is that the that the
S canal is now blocked and that it is
going to be that oil is now cut off from
from Europe um and that Britain and
France are in trouble. What are they
going to do? Well, things would have
things were in a bad bad state. But then
what really it puts this seals the whole
fiasco become turns it into a fiasco as
far as Britain and France are concerned
is what America does. Because Britain
and France had been relying on the fact
that America in some way is going to you
know stand back from it all. America
says no way and no dollars and the
mighty dollar it turns out is what sinks
the plans of Britain and France.
Now what was America's problem?
America's problem was was that number
one President Eisenhower did not like
British British and French colonialism
imperialism. The Americans viewed the
British and French attempts to reassert
the empire their imperial past as really
suddenly belonging to a different age as
suddenly belonging to morally wrong
belong to the Victorian age. They said
the age of empire is over. But it it's
ironic because America was then building
an empire itself bases all over the seas
economic relationships. But America saw
always has seen itself as as exceptional
as being morally different and on a on a
superior plane. So the main thing is
that Britain was weak and America was
strong because whilst Britain was still
a military power, France was still a
military power, Britain was not an
economic power. The the issue here was
simply the dollar because Britain did
not have the foreign currency that it
needed. The British economy in order to
stay afloat. This was this was still the
years of after the first second world
war. It took many many years for the
British economy to recover. You had
places like Germany being rebuilt. front
Japan was Japan and Germany the the the
losers in in the in the second world war
were booming the economies were booming
by that point by the mid1 1950s whereas
Britain was way behind and one of its
problems was it needed to have foreign
foreign currency it its currency the the
sterling was still pound sterling was
still used as an international currency
but if there was ever a run on sterling
if enough people lost enough foreign
investors um who held sterling went to
the bank of England and they said we
don't have confidence in Sterling and we
think we fear you're going to devalue
the pound. Um um uh therefore give us
dollars instead or give us a foreign
currency instead. Britain is not enough
dollars and foreign currency to to
support the pound. And if there was a
run on the pound that would make the
that would tank the British economy. The
British economy would go under. That was
clear. And what in fact happened when
when NASA blocks the Swiss canal is that
the British prime prime minister and
it's it's you know British officials go
to the IMF the international monetary
fund in which is effectively meant to
act as a lender of last resorts to
countries. He said please can we borrow
over we're going to need over a billion
dollars in order to guarantee and to
restore confidence in the British
economy in in in the in pound in the
pound sterling. And you know what
happens? Eisenhower
and the and the American administration
say no. They say if you want that money,
if you want your economy to survive,
you're going to pull your troops out
back from the canal. You're going to
leave. It's a stunning humiliation for
Britain. It's a stunning humiliation.
Forces a climb down because there's no
way they can put they've got the
military power. They do not have the
economic power to sustain that military
power. America was ambivalent about
British power. It knew America did not
want at that stage to put its troops in
the Middle East, right? The the idea of
of American bases in the in Qatar and
all these things was way off way off
decades decades in the future. America
did not necessarily want Britain kicked
out of the Middle East. But there was
there was another thing to to remember
that America was tremendously
embarrassed. America was trying to tell
the world, "No, we're America is trying
to tell Asia and African countries we're
postimperialism."
and in fact he's trying to win the cold
the battle for hearts and minds in the
cold war because at the very time they
were trying to say we're better than the
Soviets but yet what was happening at
the same time as the sewers crisis and
this we mentioned on a previous podcast
was that at the very very same time
within those very days the Soviets
invaded Hungary and so America wanted to
tell the world we are not like the
Soviets invading if they were there to
back up the British in the Middle East
they would be seen uh the the Americans
said we'll be seen a laughingtock
exactly the same as the Soviets,
imperialists just like that, just like
them. And so what they decided to do was
to employ the dollar as a weapon
[music] that produced what has gone down
in British history as the sewers crisis,
sewers humiliation, a seue moment. The
sewers moment is when it becomes clear
to the world that a power that a great
power is no longer actually a great
power that it doesn't have the military
or economic might to sustain its
previous commitments. That is what
happened over there. The Swiss moment
was triggered by the by the US stepping
in to to press the pressure points of
Britain, the economic pressure points
using the dollar. What actually happened
there was that um it caused it political
repercussions were immediate. The
British government of Anthony Eden fell
basically within within a short time. Um
the French government also was was was
was changed um eventually to go rise to
power again.
But actually France and Britain very
France, Britain and Israel all drew very
different lessons from this. Israel out
of all three emerged victorious because
whilst Israel needed to withdraw, give
back Sinai and give back the uh the Gaza
Strip essentially they had a decade
almost of quiet. Then they'd proven they
were a military force to be reckoned
with. But what had actually happened
also besides that is that for France it
wasn't quite as bad. They got a it
wasn't quite the humiliation that that
that happened to Britain. Britain was
thoroughly humiliated
and Britain and France drew different
lessons. France drew the lesson that you
cannot let the United States have any
leverage over you. Economic, military,
political, that's it. Under the Gaul,
who was the the president of the Gaul,
he returns to power as he was the
victorious, you know, he was seen as a
war hero. War hero. The French build
their own nuclear deterrent. They build
a totally independent. They withdrew
withdraw their forces from NATO. They
pursue an independent military and
political path from the rest of liberal
democracies. They say we cannot be
dependent on Washington. Britain
interestingly draws exactly the opposite
um lesson. It says we can no longer
afford to act on our own. Henceforth we
will never act on our own in opposition
to Washington. In other words, if you're
going to summarize this, the sewers
crisis and the humiliation of su sewers
changed the world in one way. It was
effectively sounded the death nail for
the British Empire.
Almost any fool could have told you a
year ago that if you're going to attack
Iran, you better make sure you had a
policy for the Strait of Hormuz. This
was no great discovery. Iran had said
for decades if you attack us we will
close the straight. What did that mean?
This is an internationally sensitive
waterway through which much of the
world's oil goes the world's oil prices
depend on the free flow of shipping over
there and Iran sits a stride that
straight. All they had to do and this
was well known in advance was they had
to deploy what is known as an asymmetric
strategy. Iran knew that conventionally
there's no way that you can tackle uh
the US Navy, the US Air Force or
whatever it is. But they said we don't
need to. All we need to do is have
mines, fast attack boats, to have to
have drones, to have ballistic missiles.
With that, with the weapons of the weak
and the poor, we can we can hold America
to account. We can in fact close the
streets of of of Humuz. And that is in
fact what happened. And that actually
incredibly is what happened over here.
America went into a fight with Iran
without a clear plan to keep the street
of hummus opened. And that is what a an
observer like Liam Liam Petta who was
President Obama's CIA director told
Mishbakha our magazine told Mishbahha
this week. He said that there was seems
to have been no plan. There was they
they had they knew the threat. They knew
the threat was there. Now why in fact
did this happen? It wasn't that they had
no plan. It's that the US military had
allowed itself to fall a generation
behind. They had no answer for these for
these asymmetric one-sided weapons that
could effectively these weapons of the
weak like the drone and the and and and
uh and ballistic missiles which could
effectively uh make it too costly for
America to intervene. America has fallen
behind in military terms. Having failed
to keep the straight open that created a
pressure a lever um gave Iran leverage
uh o over over Trump because effectively
it threatened to wipe him out
politically during the midterms. And in
fact that's what happens over here. And
so so much so that Liam Petta said we
have to do whatever it takes to open
those straits again. if it's called
boots on the ground to do the
unthinkable of of invading Iran, we have
to do it because otherwise you hand Iran
a clear victory. What he could have said
he didn't say but what he could have
said in other words is in that we in
danger if we don't do anything if
America does not do anything to seize
back control of the straits and subdue
Iran effectively you have an American
sewers.
So is this actually an American sewers
moment? Well, I think in one way there's
a clear difference between uh Britain in
1956 and uh America of 2026. Britain
1956 was a an economic and its
military strength and its residual, you
know, its vast array of global bases was
masking a a sharp decline. America is is
is far stronger. It's not the economic
power that it once was, but in effect it
still is a major economic power and it
itself is a much stronger pos seems to
be in a much stronger position than
Britain in 1956. But if you look at the
two ca compare the two cases, there's
one thing which America which should
give America pause which is that what
forced Britain back in 1956 was the
economy. It did not have the economic
might to maintain its military power and
effectively defy America. Well, look
what's happened over here. No, the
American economy is not about to
collapse. Trump is right. The American
economy is stronger. But politically, it
is what one of the major factors that
led to the devastating Republican losses
in the midterms. And that has taught
Trump and has taught the world that
America, whether it has the economic or
military strength or not, it doesn't
have the political and national will.
And that is a crucial point over here
because whether a nation can't act or it
won't act, it faces humiliation either
way.
And there's also a lesson for Israel
over here. 1956, Israel learned the
lesson that while it could act
militarily, it could not it could not
implement its will against the United
States. There was a clear message. That
is a message that Netanyahu has been
uncomfortably aware of since October the
7th. Every step needs to be get the
American. Okay. And this is the question
now. If America is retreating, where
does that leave Israel? Is Israel does
Israel have to finish? Will Israel be
allowed to finish the job on its own?
It's a crucial dilemma for Israel and
for its leaders as there's talk now of
of Bby using the interregnum of of as he
perhaps loses power over here. uh the
talk again of his him attacking Iran, he
must be aware that it's almost
impossible for an Israeli leader to
attack without American support. That's
Bibby Netanyahu's calculation. Donald
Trump on his side is is is aware that
the only thing left for him to do over
the next two years in in office as a
lame duck president is foreign policy
and his legacy. He has staked his legacy
on on clearing the debt on on restoring
American power. As Britain learned 70
years ago, if even if you have the e the
military power, if your economic power
is not enough to sustain it, you is the
end of your world power. And that is the
dilemma confronting America today. If if
US is is willing to bear the economic
pain, it has the power to inflict its
will on Iran still today. The question
is, does it have the political and
national will? If it does, that's one
story. If not, then 70 years [music]
after the sewers crisis and the sewers
moment, this will be America's sewers.
Thank you very much.
[music]