Mishna Berura DH Siman 60 Seif 4 Do Mitzvos Need Kavana? Do I Have To Do Them Again If I Didn't

okay good morning everyone welcome we're continuing in we are learning Sim is a epic C some say do not require what does that mean some say that even if you're not to do this act as a Mitzvah you just say sh you don't think why you're saying sh you don't think I'm saying sh to fulfill a Mitzvah you just say it some say that's good enough who are these some they hold don't some say to be by performing that Mitzvah and similarly that's the so some say MIT don't need and some say mitos need says the and who's Theos need the and the rash and the third of rash and that's the the is MIT require kavana says the Miss now it's interesting the that need now um the need is it's not a reib requirement wres and that's what the the in says that implies they argue about now the says that which is like eating a k or K in the the opinion of the later on in is even if you're not meaning the is when it comes to eating everyone agrees even there now [Music] um now the says a that if you look in the it's that according to that if they call you up for Alia and you take a Talis you take your own Talis or the Talis of the kahal so you're not to be you're if you throw a Talis on you to get Aliah you're over why because you're not wearing the yeah but I am no you're not the mitzah is not to put for um the mitzah to the mitz TI and you're not says the he says it could be their reason is that since they don't want to wear the Talis then and they're not wearing it only because of this is not a wearing that requires cus so what should you do um he says you should follow the sh that we learned earlier inim in the beer um which is you should take a borrow Talis whenever you get Aliyah better to take a borrow Talis this way you don't violate a nothing to do with checking it has to do with being if you're not for the Mitzvah you might be now this is um this is very interesting so then it would come out RAB say two things it would come out that if you take your own Talis and let's say a guy puts on his talus in the morning and he doesn't explicitly think I'm being the not only is he not being in the of he's he's over a why he's wearing a bagot of do conf without situs not without situs without being you hear this it comes out if you're not besides not being you're over an you're over of wearing a this now what would be if somebody ate in a and he wasn't then perhaps you're of eating outside of a Suka the only thing is that the started when it comes to that's the that's the redeeming uh Factor over here now the First on this says some say don't need says whether you do it yourself and you're not or let's say you heard M or and you were not or anyah that's if you say and you didn't stop and think I have to you might be a good Jew you might do other good deeds you were not m in the midst of sh or if you bench Hello friends you ever hear there's something called benching if you don't think before you bench explicitly you are not it's not you're not that's how we Pas but isn't situs and Suka different in other words you might not be over the mitah but you're not over sitting in have on it there's no mitah the to have of the is to be M the Mitzvah so if you're not M the Mitzvah you're over the is that's that's what the uh that is what the beer says yeah you could have you could have made the case not like that you could have argued that I'm not I have tius on my four cornered garment I'm I'm not eating out of this I'm in a Suka but the way understands it is there is no inion of having strings on the corner of the baged the is tovah by putting strings but if you're not you're not M the you're not that's it's but that's what says places shows only we'll see according to there's no such we'll see Monday there's such a if you're notah by it comes out every morning if you don't think before you put on your Talis or then I'm by the way then it would come out you ready for this here's a bigger I don't think people do this a married person doesn't even make a they just throw it on in the morning according to the Mish if you're you're you're it's not it's ver it's not ver to put on the Tas because you're not me the mitzvah if you're not makah so it comes out when you're in the morning you should think I'm also having in mind on my titas now the question is yeah but what about the 45 minutes that you wore the titas before you did that so you should make ay now that every time you put on right think right now whenever I put on my tius I want it to be Mitzvah now it might not help that you're you get the Mitzvah but maybe at least you don't get now you're only wear so why else I'm not we it's not a show that I'm putting on this garment to wear I'm putting it on for I'm putting on no you're doing it not to be embarrassed you don't you don't look like that you're going up for you're for you're just doing it right that's for B yeah so when I'm putting on so my regular Ts that I'm putting on for doming I'm putting why else am I putting on this TS not it's not a garment that I wear all day it's a garment that I wear for good good but the says that that's not good enough not good enough that why else am I doing it there's a Dinda you have have to explicitly think you're doing it that's the of now the says another important factor that is um something that only has AA according to everyone you need kavana now now if you're then even would say you're not for example guy's you know fooling around with a and he and he's practicing even i' say another thing if you didn't even know that you were in the Mitzvah let's say a guy is picking up aul on the first day of rash of suus and he thinks it's AR suus so even the you're not okay so these are a few factors let's see the there are two needed number one one is kav for the Mitzvah itself for example to to think I'm now saying here CLA Isel Hashem is our God Hashem is one we're not talking about that we're not talking about here when we say we're not talking about an understanding and an awareness of the meaning of the Mitzvah we're talking specifically about a specific kav the second commanded we're not talking about here not spacing out we're not talking about thinking about what you're saying getting distracted that according to everyone you should have not except for the first what we're talking about is what we're talking about is a specific thought I am now being and if you don't you're not I what else am I doing why else did I wake up an hour earlier T you know Frank came to work at 9:00 he got up at 8:45 I got to work at 9 o00 and I got up at 6 cuz I went to sh guess what you didn't do anything more than Frank you spent the whole morning in SCH and you did nothing you didn't say sh you didn't say you didn't say sh nothing you didn't do anything you didn't put on a Talis and you didn't wearin because you didn't think before you did the Mitzvah H now let's just let's say what MIT are there in the morning number one we'll have to talk before you say which is you have to have in mind I'm being number two number three number four number five those are the five that you do another one a sixth in those are six that you do if you don't have in mind that you bring M you could be a nice guy you lost two hours of sleep maybe you showed you're a good-hearted person you wanted to serve God but it's like you know I always say let's say a woman comes to sh she puts a doily on her hat on her head she covering her here no she's paying homage to the ancient custom of the Hebrews where women cover their hair so people come to show in the morning and they put on Talis and they put Onin and they do mitz and they don't think before each Mitzvah being this Mitzvah they're paying homage to the ancient custom of the Hebrews who used to do mitv you're not yet on the level to do actually do them but at least you know you respect the practice of the ancient Hebrew okay that's that's how we pass in yeah that's if you say it but what if you hold like you're not to say it so then you still have to think it I don't say doesn't bring down does bring down um the Mal says that it's already become widespread to say it but still says you're right if you say it listen if you say it you have an advantage but I'll tell you another thing if you say it you have absolutely no idea what it means then you didn't do anything either because the objective is to think before you do the Mitzvah that you're being the mitzah when you rattle off like you'd be saying you know an ancient um incantation to on like a a stew then uh that's also you're not going to be fulfill the MIT the inion of uh okay now do you have to do the Mitzvah again of course you do you do if you know right now right now hello if this morning when you put on fillan you didn't think I'm being right after this year you have to put on your again not a you have to do it if you didn't think it when you put on your Titus you don't have to put on again because you're wearing it so just think it now okay you the we and you got to do it again now we'll see Monday There's AA here that says that you could rely on the fact that um why else are you doing it we'll see when that applies again that's very it's it's not so when you get upstairs they say they might say hey what are you doing here you didn't do any mitv and you have to find the page in the Misha where there might be a Kola I'm telling you you don't want to have to come on to that you want to get right in you want you know you want to you want quick entry now now um even the like like we find in do MIT for the one who created you for the the one who commanded you critici that your fear of me is by if you were not to be you're not you got to do it again what if you say hey I'm not sure this morning when I put on my if I was or I said I'm not sure if I was if I had in mind specifically that guess what it's a you also have to do it again even if you're not sure if you had you have to do it again don't make a why because even if you definitely didn't have there are opinions that you don't make another let's start the next of you have to have to practice let's say you're teaching kids had a bench you also you forgot for [Applause] yourself now it's interesting why does the Mish say you know an example of not having someone who is blowing to practice or someone who's benching with Kim what about a guy who is spacing out and he just didn't think to I think the reason is because of the next thing that the Taz holds that if you're if you're blowing to practice or teaching kids you're not even according to because it's like having a mind not to be but granted if you don't explicitly think you're also not and another reason why the says this case is because in this case you won't be able to rely on the Kula we'll learn about on Monday that why else am I doing it so you don't have that so let you think about the following question a guy Disturbed you in middle of daving and you gave him a dollar but you didn't think I'm so now what now now I don't get a I also wasted my money let's say a guy gave and he wasn't does he have to give another 10% the answer is no does not require does not require does not apply why because your friend doesn't care what you're thinking he just wants the money what is your friend care what you're thinking you're Mahana your friend the Mitzvah is not the act the Mitzvah is the result so therefore by let's say by Mila is the Mitzvah the act or is the mitzah the result if the Mitzvah is the result also mil might not need kabana CU he's gal so the mar ask so why Wason Ben punished that he did for his own covet who cares is not important and then the mar says that it's not true that he doesn't agree with this that you you would need so it's not so P it's not so p r have a great day