Mishna Berura DH Siman 60 Seif 2-3 Repeating Shema When It Was Already Said Before Davening B'zmana

this Torah class is brought to you by Torah anytime.com in progress okay good morning everyone we're continuing in we're starting we're beginning uh actually up to S ice b b Sim s b let's say you said sh without a you fulfill the obligation ofish so the then what do you do then you go back and you say the without opinion it would seem that it's better to go back and say kishma with the so the first time he said kishma without the he has to go back and say the he's not required to say kishma this is the opinion of the Riff um the D that you do not have to go back and sayma is the and the Raj but the M himself says it's better to repeat the kishma when you're saying the says meaning to say that means to say even though the are even though you didn't make the at all you didn't you were not because there's a there's so you said the but you didn't make the and you'd be able to be without were not enacted you're not saying they're not dka on kishma by the way the the said earlier that the kishma is not the end of the third hour like is the of kishma itself it's the end of the fourth hour which is the of why because even though they to before they're not the you don't say that's why M also wrote the men is to be before the shots and to answer aain and it's not considered a he why because um it's not considered a now it's interesting um if we could review for a moment what is the correct procedure regarding answering at the end of so M said not to because it's a he right the of the m is that it's a a he um but the said no look in that is not to do that the is to be before and to answer and the reason is because is not so the we're pointing out the M it's it's a little bit of an inconsistency because the of the is that there is an element when it comes to that's why the said that not to answer after I mean think about it it's a little bit of a the is don't answer after because you don't want to be ma between the and the Mitzvah so then how is that consistent with what the uh with the with what we're learning over here that and here the explains why because it's not a the answer is no it's the listen to this that's why the says the that's why the says in my opinion it would be better to repeat the sh so I don't think we're able to do this but but according to what we just said we would be arguing with the Mish why because the Mish says what's that you should say again says um the Mish in order to be this Krish is like reading the Tah that perhaps there's a different reason why you should say sh because the of the is that and right you're not supposed to answer me between and because it's so the should have said well the reason why you should say sh again is because you need to say um the on the now the answer is could have said that because you're still not going to be saying the on the because you ready were theah so it's not a reason to say sh again to say the you ready although the points out that later on in later on in the says the reason to repeat sh is mean the are not being said and their right in their proper TI in other words that that might be more uh in line with the that are in a certain sense but we do we we we should point out the of the is that you are allowed to answer after and you don't say and therefore you answer and all the follow that if you finish you are required to answer it's better to um be together with you hear this let's review this if you say the words and the didn't say it yet you must answer that's the who says that everybody all the that's what the way the M comes out it's better to um to finish in unison with the Ken but if you didn't you're required to answer a if you did not you would be required to answer aain ah then here's another thing not only that if you already said sh before the daving remember this so now it's for sure not a then you're required not to finish together with the and to answer people are not aware of this you hear this nor okay if you were not yet the you should finish the un with the in Defence to if you forgot to you're required to answer if it's a shabas morning and you're ready then why should you finish in before the it's for sure not you should not finish before the should um you should excuse me finish before the in order to answer a um to his okay says the [Music] okay what if somebody is saying sh and if he would say Shama another time he's going to like this let's say like this you're ding in a sh in America shabas morning theyd D at 9:00 so you said sh earlier you get to sh and their mom is skipping their they they go They're speeding through the daving if you're going to say sh another time you're not going to make with says skip sh don't say sh why it's more important to what's the only reason you're repeating again only should be so that's the only reason well that's not more important than ding with the I would humbly think that the is differently because we just quoted from the the that later on the Miss says that uh to say without sh is not it's not to say without sh so even though this so the sh is more than being but rather the the is in order that the so he brings that also saysi says don't don't skip sh very interesting question very it's actually pretty relevant you know anyway if you flip the around you first said and then you said um you flip it around okay says the uh let's say you said before you did three before one after or he said all the after or even aftering at least you get credit for the that you made by the way the P says let's say you're right before this man and there's not enough time to say both bras before so just say one of them just say one of them and um let's see quickly that if you made only one of them and the second one you didn't make at all then you're to that one that theas are not of the not like they're definitely not of each other but even according to who says the that's only to not okay say let's hold it over here raber for giving the Monday and Tuesday good to see everyone well we'll see you tomorrow tomorrow is big day yeah everyone you've just experienced another Torah class brought to you by tor anytime.com