Mishna Berura Daf Hashavua Special - Should One Wear Rabbeinu Tam Tefillin?

this Tower class is brought to you by torahanytime.com okay good morning everyone before we go right there I just want to revisit um Halal Mesa regarding Rabino tomtillen the Macabre said in similarities unless one is renowned in his uh saintly practice they're really two ways of reading the Mahaba does Mahaba mean you should not wear Rabino town at all unless you're Muslim you should not wear them simultaneously unless you're most but even if you're not at least put it on after davening the mishna Brewer reads the mahadur that if someone is they should not even wear radhe after davening why not apparently it's arrogance and in fact says it's because it's looks like you're macrame on yourself even if uh on something that others are not annoying to be math because as we said the Minogue is like Rashi [Music] that's even if you want to put it on after davening even if you want to wear avenu tamtoon after davening still it's uh the Macabre saying not to do it which the maril interprets it's because of you ARA the question now is what if somebody wants to wear it privately because if you look in the mission of bura the mission of Brewer says that one should not uh the Mr World brings the Shiloh could somebody put on Rabino Tom villain the farthestia of so he quotes the bear hey Dave um Who quotes Maharaja Levi that it's and that's the opinion of the schwasyakov as well that even if some people do it it's maxi kiyuhara well what if it's not indicates that you should not put on Rabino Town's phone period whether it's public or even if it's in your closet period you shouldn't put it on the Shyla of the Mishra is uh right didn't say it's awesome he said not to do it the Mr Brewer is talking about when you do beforehetsia that's awesome that's is [Music] um is prohibited but even to do it privately um perhaps that's also prohibited so that's a very interesting Shiloh whether you are applies if you do something privately now let's say I want to be Macklemore without anybody knowing about it is there you Hara so there's a mission bura in Sim about how many holes your titsa should have and they're the mishabura brings the basically I saved that's something you should do two holes but you should you don't have to be cautious for this and if you're going to be machame element says the bath the talus cotton you can make two holes why because nobody sees it it's not Nera La coil so here it sounds like something that's not seen by everyone is now again that Macabre didn't really tell us the reason you shouldn't do it but it seems like the reason you shouldn't do his mission you are right he never said you could do it privately unless it's self-evident that you could do it privately Lamesa I saw abroad that it's not postured that you're allowed to do something that other people are not maharan even privately there may be you are even privately let me show you an example um an example would be in Simon gimmel the safer um the safer mayor eyes I have over here it says we know that in Simon gimbal the Macabre says that when you go to the bathroom you say yes please you know the the Malachi shows that a company a person they don't accompany you into the bathroom so uh you should sort of take leave of them and say in other words you you sort of take care you leave the malachem but the Mahaba says we don't do it because nobody's coming with you to the bathroom so if nobody's coming to the bathroom why can't I say yes it seems like there's an Indian of you Era even if nobody sees meaning guide us for yourself you think you're a best to Revenge because you do something I wear Rubino Tom filling to where I've been with Tom Stillen but your Movado Torah 90 of the day exactly no but nobody's looking nobody how about you you're you're looking so it's not push it again it's there the mission that there's no uh implies there may be you are okay now let's talk about the mission of shita for a moment I want to show you uh says right that Mr Brewer said that it would be you are aware of even if other people are wearing it I mean foreign so that's the opinion I will just point out that Mr Brewer disagrees Mr Brewhouse it is you Era Mr Brewer knows what's going on in the world it's the same time in the Arkham um again if you're if you're a fidish and uh then of course it's not you are that's the Minogue of your community but in general minog ashkenaz is fill in so if you're going to put it on again the mission Borough would say unless you're muksuk um but this is the opinion of brings down that um first let's see the grub now the beer has mashma to me that he's reading the mission he's reading the Macabre different than the Mishra the bira gross says yes I think the girl is saying don't wear two pairs of tone at the same time oh no excuse me meaning the bear Agra is reading the the uh the Macabre like the mishaburra it's going on the last year the last he is showing room is if you can't get them on simultaneously you should put them on after davening and on that the Macabre says as is well known the girl did not wear Ruben attempt felon and the casarocious oh now why didn't he wear Rabino Tam the answer is the grow words fill in all day see where's otun all day how could you take off rashi's filling and put on Rabino tab You're My Vato you hear this for the girl it was awesome he was wearing fun all day so he's gonna take off Rashi that we passed in like to wear a bit of time it says I I know where it's feeling all day um if you're going to want to fulfill all the opinions you're gonna have to put on 24 Pairs and therefore the gross said that uh you know you're not really accomplishing anything it's not like you're you'd say all the day ice um if one second yeah did I put this on the sheet yeah himself it's brought that um until the the world war one of Ukraine moved to the Ukraine so what are you gonna do he had to buy Rabino town [Music] that's why he started to put it on said that he didn't really go for that answer because you show me everybody knows is a forgery and himself knew it was a forgery anyway The Story Goes that in fact did put on Robin at the end of his life and he when he was asked why he said well Tam and within a time I learned Rabino time and I twice this all day and my van time's gonna ask you learn my Torah and you're not used to the midst of villain according to me again that's a story that is brought in uh the safer page 419 to 421 again I would not I would not get carried away with that story because as we saw up for the noise that's not a taina at all if Rabino Town we're going to ask why don't you wear my villain would not have a good answer for that because he's still not you I'd say it's they have to be horizontal so for that to be the reason why rabbino Tom put on to fill in they're they're not Kosher according to Urbana Town actually Rabino Tam would come to him and say that you weren't United Mitzvah and if you made a broadcast later on it's brought down probably put it on for kabbalistic reasons as we know the father'sheim was a um was a lawy maid to be Kabbalah Vietnamese this is also interesting and we'll just end with this um here we go this is something I saw today for the first time then he brings that there's not passing like him and unless don't do it so the author of The safer mayor always says he asksky foreign again I would not get carried away with this because somebody got the details wrong because it says time word for many many many years so obviously the details here are not exact um but to put on Rabino Thompson once in a lifetime it's filmed but to do so regularly unless you're uh in your closet why would you want to do that if nobody's going to see you doing anyway what do you know um that's uh you could ask your own local Orthodox Abby whether there's yuhara on a uh that nobody knows about other than yourself but the guy who goes around asking 90 rabbonim am I Allah in my closet that guy's thinking look if if my Show's not going to know about it at least let every rough in the world know that I'm doing it in my closet you know the guy who goes around asking you know when I put on Rabino tomt Phillip the guy posts he puts an ad on Yeshiva World when I was just wondering when I put on Robin in my closet you know what what kind of should I have okay rather say um how I guess we'll hold it over here okay have a good day everyone yeah it says he did put them on himself he said well he was your restaurant from his father he put them on in his house when he quoted it that's what it says he didn't say shimai in it he said tell him in it ah very interesting you've just experienced another Torah class brought to you by torahanytime.com