Mishna Berura Daf Hashavua Siman 79 Seif 2-3 A Smell Emanating From Another Reshus

okay good morning friends we're continuing in we're learning Simon T we're middle of B the M said as follows M says if you're on a high spot or the soya is on a high spot or a low spot or that si in a different room with the doorway in between if you don't smell it it's not a problem according to the according to the it's a problem if you could see it and if it smells the says Zion that if it smells a haaka will not help now what about making a Suka in a place that it will smell so the says later on that if you have an alternative don't make it there but if you have nowhere to make it then you're but you can't make AA okay the is now going on the words of the that if there is a smell a does not help you need four from where the small stops some are that if you have a he it's enough just to go where it doesn't smell you don't have to go four away from where the smell stops look Z that you need fouras from where the smell stops this is the opinion of the the the lenient opinion who says as long as you don't smell it is the P the and and the in the is this is also interesting this is what ryak was asking me yesterday let's say it's covered and it smells do you need to go four away from where the smell stops or is it enough just not to smell it so there are different opinions like we wrote earlier in the hak by the way the deu brings regarding the the as long as you don't smell it and he asked the s that in Simon test the pagm is mic it seems like in a number of places if listen very important it seems like in most places the Mish brings that if soya is covered and you don't smell it you're okay you don't have to go for away away from where the smell stops which has tremendous na Caminos with dirty diapers let's say you have a kid you know he has a dirty diaper but you don't smell it you could tell it's nice and packed you know it looks like it's uh it's m vades in there but you don't smell it why cuz you know the diapers have some kind of barrier and uh the kid is wearing you know those the tights they put on the the boys NE and then and then pants on top of it and you don't smell it so it's a big Naina do you need to go four amus away from where the smell stops or is it enough to not just not smell it now I don't remember the deu was bringing that earlier in s i invol gim the primam says as long as you don't smell it and then he brings the prim and later on in simad he brings that you I don't remember what we said in the here let's take a look he says um in the H in sh this is on page 222 he says re he says the gr by the way is is Mare mean the question is covered that has in is and you always have to distance four from where the smell stops the question is what about covered is that or is that not it seems like it's a very big a big source of unclarity so what about daving and saying next to a baby who's wearing a diaper and you're not sure what's the mat so I mean I'm sure by now there there must be an app you know you know you scan the kid and then you you see what what his story is but let's say you're not sure so I would say ask the mother the mother knows so the sh says it's m you don't have to be concerned maybe there's but if there is then we and you have to go where the small stops also says that RB Yos says that Lisa you you could be and just go away that you don't smell it when it's covered but you shouldn't rely on this okay that's how should and also not bring babies into the shaw fine um someone D in the house he smells something he should interrupt and wait till the smell passes a guy who has a illness that he can't smell either he has covid or he has a psychological illness that he thinks that his Co makes him that he can't smell it could be you could be lenient even though we had yesterday didn't we have yesterday it's and Sim we had look in that he has to go four away from where the smell stops to someone who could smell that's talking about when there's sa behind you but now you have an additional Factor where it is I don't understand why you could be make her it sounds like with that additional Factor you could be make why look in the says in we said that H very good that if you're in and it's the night or you close your eyes then it would be okay according to the rash so because you don't see it so this also maybe it should be like it could be over there because we're combining the Das I thought for sure it's because we're combining the Dasa Rush the opinion of the rush is meaning it makes it AA okay I'm not sure I don't really understand why it would help if the persons can't smell let's say they took the but there's a smell but someone who can't smell he would be allowed to read again if it's what we call okay gim a small courtyard that broke in its fullness into a big one the big one is bigger than it on the sides you know what the case is I'm going to try to draw it here we [Music] go let's see you see this is Katana the entirety of it is open to okay very simple case this is we had this by I don't remember by what in Arab in all the time yeah no where we we had it we had it in do we have it we had it somewhere oh with a minion right very good okay so the small one is not a separate room since it's open in its fullness to the bigger one the bigger one it extends beyond the small one on both sides so this is not really an accurate drawing so just imagine for a moment the big one is extending on both sides if there's in the big one you can't say in the small one but there's in the small one I'm sorry also you have in the big one you can't read in the small one until you distance yourself for from where the the small stops the small one as long as now wait a second you have so in the small one you could read in the big one without distancing that would only work according to the rash but what about according to the Raj we'll see the from where the stops but if you have in the katana so if you have then the small one the small room is not considered a separate room you would have the distance for from where the smell stops but if there is in the you could read in the as long as the doesn't reach you now what about according to the rashba that if you see it it's an issue say he's being like the opinion of the rush that if and according to the Raj I would say he's not being he's just not getting into it of course according to the Raja would be a problem you make a the case say it's where you can't see it or is that yeah that's what I mean in other words he's not he's not getting involved he's not we all know according to the Raja if you could see it it's a problem so he just saying that the big one Vis the the small one is a different R but small one Vis the big one is not a different Ros what the laws of different Ros are you know it will depend we did have before yeah if you close your eyes whether that's going to do the job or not okay rabai have a great day C be well