Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
morning in progress okay good morning
everyone Shalom
Alim welcome back to
M we're
learning we're middle
of by the way if you want to join us
we're going to uh be visiting the city
of Cal in the Ramos Kev
for uh L upcoming about 2 weeks so you
could join us for that the
said and there's excrement in
the in the
house even if
the is behind him in the
house you have to be quiet he has to be
silent until it's removed
because he's
being we
in it would be it's inevitable
impossible that someone in the is not
within four cubits of the so you got the
case he's being
everyone and what
happens the situation is there's on the
sh so he's got to stop until it so is
removed why
because it's impossible that there isn't
someone within four cubits of
the
says let's see
the yesterday we
saw if the had a wait the amount of time
it would take to complete the whole
thing and it was not within his for he
does not have to go back to the
beginning
the since he's being them with
their
because now it's as if each one is doing
by
themsel what does that mean it seems
like that if there's
soya in the house it's going to cut
off one of the people in the house or
it's going to cut off everyone and it's
going to be considered like everyone's
doing thems so you say well what what's
wrong with that everyone nowadays does
doen
thems even though we are uh custom that
everyone davens
thems each has to
answer there can't be in front of
him I don't understand if everyone's
ding themsel then of course you have to
remove the soya because a guy who's
daving hasya in his
it seems like let's say it's not a
situation where everyone let's say the
is being everyone but if there's going
to be in somebody's he will not be able
to
answer if the is involved is is right
now up to
he's not being
anyone he could
continue as long as he's outside of for
from where the small stops meaning in
the first case we're talking about where
he's being let's say where they have to
answer but if he's up to zra where he's
not really being M anyone so as long as
he's good to go he could continue who
if he's within four cubits of the has to
be
silent even if he delayed to finish the
whole
thing he only has to go back to the
place where it's stopped where he
stopped the same thing would be in
the so this is whether he's in or in the
but
or one who delays to finish the whole
thing was in
the goes back to the
beginning and you evaluate it based on
the reader himself
the ra said it's impossible that there's
not someone
within if it happened that nobody's
within the is interrupting meaning is
the problem that somebody's within the
or even or somehow the creates a barrier
so Mishu is going to say
even though the is between
them they could turn
around so the is not in front of
them
because in the ey shot of uh some of
somebody who's in its
presence we did have earlier that even
if you can
see could create a
barrier by the way we also if there's
a a or an idolator in
between it would be an
issue so this is very
interesting inim let's take a look back
for a
moment there there was another factor
that the Mishu here is not really
working with namely here we're talking
about are you within four of but the
question is does the
create um a barrier and
in
brings is the
name that you you can't have
any in
between because
by the way the Taz says therefore you
should not have a uh an aara on the roof
of a sh because it will prevent the TOs
from going
up the you know what if what if what if
a sh on top of the roof has a you know
has a has a satellite you know for uh
for improper media
uh connection so then what the Taz would
say that might be an issue anyway this
is a it doesn't sound like we have a
definitive about this
fine t
it's impossible that nobody's within for
and wear the
small if a child
urinated should wait until you pour
water
cover if the was outside
of could be on the lenient opinion that
you don't really have to tell him
nevertheless the should distance or
cover or put
water you will not be able to
answer let's do uh let's start
B let's say you are in a high
place
or or if
you were in one
house and the was in another
house even if the doorway is open you're
sitting on the
side if there is no
smell
why according to the rush if it's
outside of your there's no inion of
the issue
is so it's permitted according to the
rash again we saw that it could be would
still
be but here the m is saying that
according to the rush it's okay because
according to the rush the only issue
that
governs this is a different it's in a
different bias it's in a different
room it's there's an issue here of what
of
remember we learned that
the applies to seeing and therefore
that's only it's only
okay only if you don't see
it if it has a
smell then even according to the Raj
it's a problem this inter this he is not
going to work it's not going to
accomplish
anything the different domain is not
going to do
anything just like
helps for the
itself it will likewise help for the bad
smell we will hold it over here we will
continue with
the
tomorrow this week we're going to get
together
Friday just to uh so we don't fall
behind Okay but right now we're on
schedule so after Friday we'll be ahead
of schedule call to everyone have a
great day call to
bye-bye recording stop St
