Mishna Berura Daf Hashavua Siman 74 Seif 1-2 Using Water as a Covering For Ervah

morning okay good morning everyone we're continuing in Miss and it's good to know that we are on schedule we are up to the right correct place okay we're finishing up Sim we're finishing up Al theama said that not only if your heart could see your own ARA is it a problem but also if your heart could see it's a problem what does that mean there's no interposition between your heart and the and Thea of your friend for example they're both lying down unclothed and they're covered in one Talis and they're far from each other so basically two people lying in a under a blanket unclothed and they're facing each other the person himself Ru has a he between his heart and his his heart is still directly opposite Thea of his friend or for example they're both in the water why he has a garment under his heart but he sees the era of his friend that's not covered so I don't understand this because but his eyes see the ARA of his friend isn't that a bigger problem says no even though your eyes are out of the water but your heart that's in the water could see the era of your friend so there are a few stipulations that are needed you cannot be able to see someone else's AA your heart cannot see some your AA your heart cannot see someone else's erva and your era cannot be uncovered seeing your own AA Isa your AA being uncovered Isa your heart seeing your is the okay one who is bathing undressed in Clear Water and he wants to drink I don't know if he wants to drink the water he's bathing in but he wants to drink he wants to have a peach Snapple so what are the different issues could he see his own AA I mean the water is clear he could see his own AA even though we just saw in the M brua maybe it's not considered seeing his AA because his AA is covered could is his AA uncovered I don't know is water consider a covering so these are different issues we have to deal with so the first thing is he should cover with the Garment under his heart so that his heart is not seeing Thea when he's making a okay so he puts a beged under his heart so that his heart doesn't see the ARA only in a garment with with his hands it's not considered a the same thing would be if he's covering his head with his hands it's not considered so here we have encountered two a hand is not considered a cover to get around the issue of and a hand is not considered AA in other words if if your yamaka blows off and you want to make a you can't put your hand on your head your hand is not considered a cover okay let's see the miss you cover your heart with your with a garment the water even though it's clear wow we learned before that there's an issue that your erva cannot be uncovered if your erva is in water it's considered as if your AA is covered now in that case if my era is covered what about the fact that I could see Thea provided that you stick your head out of the water St up you're not looking at the since the water is clear and you'll be able to see it so there three issues you got to deal with number one being in the water takes care of that number two looking at the stick your head out of the water and don't look but what about I don't understand this if the way you get around seeing youra sticking your head out of the water then stick your heart out of the water also he's not standing he's floating there he's what he's floating so I have a good idea pal stand mean it's it's it's uh that's not a very complicated procedure so here's what I just maybe you could say that when it comes to seeing the AA don't look but you can't tell your heart not to look what are you going to say heart close your eyes you see when it comes to looking I look up but if you're even if your your let's say your waist is above the water in other words let's say the water goes up to your waist it's still because your heart is looking do you only have an A of not looking with eyes maybe you don't have an A of not looking with a I'm not sure you have to put a garment below your heart so that there's a separation between your heart and likewise if you interpose with a on your heart [Music] um now yeah I I mean I think you have to say what I'm saying that there's no putting your heart out of the water is not going to help sticking your head out you have the ability of but with a heart maybe you don't have that ability okay write it down someone okay write down the um you also have to cover your head I'm surprised that they haven't invented yet you know you have the kosher toothbrush and the kosher brush and the kosher lamp they should have like the kosher Gart you know for if you're in the water or the kosher heart covering the kosher head covering this is you get good business ideas here also okay um but hands whether you put your hand on your heart unless you hug with your arms we're going to see in that you could be meaning to go like to go like this doesn't work but to go like this that's already that works even though but sounds like the the bear hug the personal self self bear hug that works why does that work the says people don't usually do that yeah that's true people usually don't hug themselves and there so in other words a person would put their hand on their head so therefore or their hand on their body but not to to hug oneself fine that would work um the M continues someone else's hand that would be permitted fine on the head is not called if the water was okay the continues so now you're getting around Gila you're getting around but what about now that also you took care of you your heart can see Thea depends why the water is not clear if the water is dirty then and it smells bad you can't say oh so I was not right if your heart is not in the water but above the water then it's permitted so that that that refutes what I said right in other words here the r says clearly that another way to get around is have the heart above the water I the heart is always looking apparently that's not correct the heart the heart is not always looking what a different R it's a different r i but it's a r that it could see because the water is clear there your head probably looking the what cuz the eyes could see eyes can't be looking that direction the heart that can't see is enough to be in different R saying the heart doesn't really see it's only it's only that's how we envision it as if it is so since it's in a different R it works okay sounds good [Music] um by the way is the raama arguing in other words not but I'm just pointing out that the M didn't say this right the said or or the Miss BR said um on your heart but the the M never said this this is the Rama adding by the way who does that where did the Rama get it from he made it up this is so that he's not arguing on the but I'm not sure by the way thank you very much the pr argues on the r the pr says that it doesn't help says it does not help to stick the LA out of Thea so I would humbly read the I would say of course I would say we read the correctly the holds that this doesn't work and in fact many in other words the this doesn't work why didn't the say it cuz M doesn't hold of it a house by a window yeah sck his head and his out out of the window right so he said there's a separate issue oh did we did you did you have to stick your La out of the window also no we said there was a separate issue there of AR right we said right right like it doesn't sound like an issue of okay good oh he did separate issue no no I'm saying you're right there he said the way you get around you cover the right so he's saying what if another way would be to stick your your uh La out of the window again the problem is if you stick your head out of the window and your La out of the window in no time your R will be out of the window on the floor like Humpty Dumpty so you know I don't know how I'm not sure how practical that is okay but I'm very excited look in the says um on Zion that if it helps to stick your La out of the water um look in the maybe he's saying what raber said you have to stick your head out of the water okay that's the qu sort of the reason why we thought it doesn't help to have the LA out of the water is the's question why is it that if your eye is seeing the AA in the water it's a problem but if your heart is seeing the AA in the water it's not a problem so he says it must be we're more by seeing so says because A heart doesn't really see it's just in the again says it does not work what does hold I think the M holds it doesn't work why doesn't the because didn't say explicitly but you know what is let's finish this up um if I'm sorry if the water is clear you could dirty with your feet it's only if you're bathing something that has ground but not if it's uh you're bathing in a bathtub where there's no dust and there's no dirt even if you're bathing in a barrel there's maybe sediment that you could kick up the water is considered a between your heart and Thea the sh cha says that the B size with the against the in other words the water is a heick between your heart and Thea I but your heart could see the arva that's what we ask not better than GL okay say let's hold it over here see everybody tomorrow