Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
okay good morning
everyone we're continuing in we're
learning we're in middle
of B where the is talking about
saying uh the Mish said the reason is
because we're praising Hashem that he
lives above in the seven also the M
later says it's because we're escorting
the upward
also we there's a p we
say yeah so that's something that's
repeated uh two times and then the Rama
says you should also be careful not to
answer aain
twice to
one two
times
says because saying aain twice looks
like two
domains look in the he's lenient about
the
matter that you could say twice to
one that it's again the is
lenient that you could answer a twice to
one
but
let's say you say
to to
one look at the he
writes there are two types
of one is that I believe and I verify
that this is a truth
another is like a
request that the matters should come
true and our our desire should be
fulfilled and if
so that has
two
so the
has that since could have two meanings
one is that you verify that is
the and one is
your should
be so you could say twice because your
is a your verifying that Hashem indeed
has that ability and B that you would
like that to be but let's say if it's
just a regular
um it's just a statement of Praise then
you could only
say one time so it depends on
the if it happens your way to answer for
two
things that one will work for this and
for
that in other words let's say you hear
one guy making an and one guy
making it could be that one will work
for
both if you could say that's
better now it's interesting here the
Miss does not say that if you have two
things to answer aain to you should
say but
rather later
on the Miss writes in Sim
that if it happens that someone's going
has the opportunity to answer a for two
things he should
say and he should be for each what he is
answering but it's better to say I guess
over here they're they're happening
simultaneous so if the two things are
happening simultaneous then it could be
there is no option of saying aain aain
because the first aain will be he to the
second you're you're answering to two
simultaneous so the option is either one
or there it's you're hearing BR back to
back so either you say or even
better we had the shades people saying
kades um said the you say one both um
and if there but if there are more than
we would say two a we didn't say
there okay very good so the dings like M
said
Kadesh we said if a bunch of people
saying and one is a little bit one ised
and one is
so so if they
finish answer with the first one or with
the last one and it works for
everyone see there everyone's doing the
same thing so since everyone's doing the
same thing the question is how do when
when should I answer either to the first
or to the
last so therefore if you hear a lot of
people making the same bra together says
follow what the
saides that if they're finishing within
then either answer to the first or
answer to the last I think we had a sh
we learned by kades what if it's two
different parts ofes so far behind so
far ahead yeah so that would be like
over here so either if they're finishing
simultaneous it's one main or
and if there it's if it's not
simultaneous
then then it's
or
okay now we
have it's this week's let's see who
could figure out how
okay after you need to say the six
words quietly
says what if you didn't
say so apparently there's a whether if
you completely omit whether or not right
that's interesting you would think it's
for sure but the here does not
definitively say that now it's
interesting
in he writes that if you're
not you need to say it again because
it's part of the
first that is before you
begin however once you already began the
says that you don't go
back maybe we should see this
[Music]
um let's finish the this and then we'll
we'll we'll try to do the
okay called out his
children he wanted to reveal the end he
wanted to reveal when M would
come now these this this m is mad in the
ram that the source of is the story
of let's see what the
says I'm going to let you know what will
happen to you in the end of
days depart
from and it didn't allow him to reveal
it said to his
children maybe there's among you someone
who's not
fit they all began and they
said
responded theab said what should we do
if we're going to say
ITA didn't say
it what do you
mean mha didn't say there a lot of
things M didn't mha didn't say as either
M didn't say m m didn't say it mha
didn't
say so talk of that you know but there
are a lot of things didn't say
but well who so who cares didn't say it
so
says the cap is not to be middle of
thata wrote with something that he
didn't
say and by the way says the reason why
oner some people
say out loud is it's not so you could
say it out
loud so asks on
theud if the reason why we don't say it
out loud is so that should be a HEI so
then how does it help if you say it
quietly you're not to be M
quietly soash says a completely
different rationale when the gar says
sh is that when we say it out loud we're
making ourselves like we'd be on a
higher level than
mha mha didn't say it he didn't
understand it yob said it he understood
it so we say it qu
quietly okay it's a it's a vast topic
the bottom line is why is uh why is the
mishab quoting this why does the ra give
this whole
history again let's just finish up the
says
they they enacted to say it quietly as a
recognition it's not what it's not from
the par that's written in
the just said
it
when you say quietly the writes in the
name of the you need to be able to hear
it with your ears but you don't say it
out loud like the rest
ofish what about when you're saying
it says you could say it out loud the
only get jealous when when you say
it that should not be a factor because
that's not the only reason we say it
quietly that theu asks but
I think we do say it quietly if you
say the reason that the brings applies
the reason is that we can't say it
because didn't say it but the bottom
line is is it to say let's make an
attempt here on this it starts on the
page
before what would be if you didn't say
it didn't really say
what
you don't go
back says you do go
back that he agrees with the that you go
back which means you go back to the
beginning of sh doesn't mean you go back
to the slot between sh and have you have
to start
again at the very least
says in my opinion if you didn't say you
don't go
back go
back they should have protested like
other things they protested
about furthermore we go on to the next
page where brings another very
powerful the in the beginning of the
second that says that someone who
reading in
the what do you mean but you didn't
say you hear the r
somebody's reading the T and he was so
what do you mean he didn't
say it's all fine and good if
Me Maybe it means had a mind to be and
then therefore you said whatever you
needed to say
means to read the words properly like
the gar says in the answer then
definitely you didn't
say then the there's a
here
then brings
the brings
from again the is trying to
say
the
unless you're afraid that they might
kill
you so what do we see that ordin that in
general you do have to
say like the
first says in his opinion it's not a r
because we also agree is a great indan
but it's not a r that if you skipped it
you have to go
back bottom line is there's
a
whether the and the say it's
not says it
is personally is lenient and he sides
with the opinions that if you didn't say
it okay have a great day
everyone
because I
said
iOS is a
BHA I don't think is a
BHA it's
a okay what about the other then the
other bras also you're right all the 13
middle bras you this
PR that you could say you could
say twice we don't do it but it's to to
be when you answer to the middle that um
basically right it's true and you misf
follow that it should
be
okay
okay everyone have a great day
everyone's invited to join us for an
amazing share tonight on the Tyra of
amam Tas amam amram amam oh I want to
ask you something yeah
amam