Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
okay good morning friends how are you
we're continuing in
uh we're
in the optimal time to
say is
before if you did not say it before NES
the earlier you could say it the
better um you know if you're daving with
a minion and they're going to make the
kishma I don't think there's an inion to
say it
before
CU I don't think so we didn't see that
in other words let's say is 8:00 and
you're ding with the minion that they're
going to
say 7:45 and you're up at 6:30 I don't
think there's anion to say
the your minion is going to make this
man it's talking about all things being
equal if you could say it earlier or
later say it
earlier but someone by but um one should
not say until after M but the M says
someone who's anos is allowed to say and
the already from yesterday we saw
from
that means even if someone who has to go
early to
work there's no greater onos than going
to work you're allow if you have to go
to work early you're allow to say
already
from let's continue in
in
giml okay we read the miml we're up
toat
yalid yalid is going
on let's say someone has extending C
circumstances so he has to get up early
in a place of wild animals and bandits
and he won't be able to stop in his
travels and say the first
paraa or even the first couple of sukim
and they're not going to wait for you at
all
says they're not going to wait for you
if you want to read the the
road we're also talking about where your
trip is going to take until the end of
the because if you're going to arrive at
a destination before the kishma then you
should wait until
after to be able to
say you could read it with
its and you could also say
the
and
um and and
daving you could say
it you could even put
on you hear this here's a guy he has to
get very early to travel he has to he's
going on a trip they're not going to
wait for him he's not only allowed to
say
sh he could even put on
but he just should not make
a until he
gets
soill in you could put on M but you
don't make
now what
if a person has a choice
they
with or they could wait
till
say without you hear the SH now you have
a choice of
saying with with or BisMan
withouta says could be it's better to
say
with
because
um I don't think I would have said
that I don't think I would have said
it's better to say sh
from with than to say it after m without
I would say I would have thought that
it's better to say
sh without and I'll tell you why because
the
of is
the the
fundamental um parameter of the Mitzvah
sh the Mitzvah sh needs to be
said is
wearing is not the parameter of shma
it's not a fundamental parameter of shma
it's an external Den that you should not
say sh without because it's like being
made but we had many times that if a
person's worried he's going to miss this
man or then he needs to say sh in other
words it's not in any way it doesn't in
any way undermine your fulfillment of
the mitvah of sh it's just a din that
you're not to say sh without
on Raa doesn't say it definitively he
says he
says I would have thought it's the other
way
okay we could think you
know that
um now let's see the end of the um the
if you're in extending circumstance
since
it's it is correctly
called and it's also called meaning you
might ask okay maybe it's when people
get up but it's not light outside so
maybe you
can't don't
say so early
until you
reach meaning this then that you could
say and you could say that's very good
it's called but it's not
called says you should not say
it and you can't make
a
so I don't this is a very this is a
tremendous curveball because here it is
we're saying yeah no problem you have to
go to
work yeah but you have to
skip and it doesn't sound like the M
brings down other opinions I mean the is
another opinion the says you could
say I mean bottom line is I don't think
you'd be able to say Y what do people
do people skip
y I don't think
so I think people D before mishak are
saying Y
no that's very
interesting the finishes
off if you're not in a place of Bandits
and Wild
animals where the people are not in such
a
rush even if you left
after
still you know how to read the until the
time
comes so this is only in Mish
extenuating
circumstances uh um let's go a little
further if you did say
after and you did not have extending
circumstances in we learned that if you
have extenuating circumstances you're
allow to say sh but what if you didn't
have extenuating circumstance and you
still said
sh
if you said without
the you should say it again in
with let's do
one when
is some say is a little bit before the
Eastern Horizon is
illuminated some say is when the Eastern
Horizon is
illuminated this is
[Applause]
before what we going to do we'll try to
take a look at the
tomorrow okay and we're going to hold it
over
here recording stopped
