Mishna Berura Daf Hashavua Siman 34 Seif 2 How Did the Machloes Rashi & Rabbeinu Tam Develop

this Tower class is brought to you by torahanytime.com okay good morning everyone we're continuing in similar download Sif phase you were discussing the Michael and Rubino time regarding the order of the parishes in the villain Rashi reads it was asked yesterday first of all what is my focus Rashid based on says foreign ER from the right side of the reader the reader should read and encounter khandesh on the right followed by and then and therefore and he's reading it kasidran he's reading it in the order that it's written in the Torah Kadesh but it's on the left side of the reader in other words um let's bring this up here it's on the left side of the reader so so Kadesh is on the right side of the on in the vantage point of the koir the one who reads it he sees Kadesh on the on the right side but the wearer has actually Kadesh on the left side again this is now this is the way Rashi reads the sugya that the hakare kasidran has one simple question why does the Bryce break it up Kate said the sidron Kardashian s smile since it should say kadesha Kadesh then everything else the fact that it breaks it up into two says indicates that Shema is a smile barashi is um Rashi is compelled by the language of the Bryce of the gemara bachore kasidran according to the gemara says the one who reads it reads it in order the reader the one who sees the tone is not actually encountering it in order so that's uh basically where the what the maholic is based on yesterday it was also asked how did the mahoikas develop after Jews have been wearing fill in for thousands of years and where did this macalicus come from how was there how's their maholicus how to Finland should be made ifino came down from marcina he told you so how to make villain and the next day hundreds of thousands of Jews made villain and then their children also made fun so how exactly do we have a Mac like us there are three basic approaches brings something very interesting he brings in uh Simon tough Sadi gimmel that there was an ERA on Jewish history where very few Jews were to fill in during that era it developed like a confusion as to what is the correct uh manner to put on fill in because so few Jews were wearing clothes by the way the smug talks about how he went around and he darshaned to be magazic Jews in the wearing of Thailand which also perhaps indicates that there was an ERA in history where you could look in the smug and mitzvah gimmel darashti begolius okay but then uh it's hard to imagine that that so few Jews were fun that it became forgotten the correct manner of producing phone so they're basically two schools of thought they're um and the uh we'll call it so the hasidim say like this hasidim say and uh the closenberg is brought in the hatama of his haskama to the safer DeVille Israel that the the difference held that there was always there were always two pairs of villain that even when he brought us through the midvar they were already Rabino tabbed full in this is the approach from the kubolam and they attach very great significance to having no time to fill in look in uh Sternberg that means there are always two pairs of villain one was primary one was secondary and then it became forgotten which one was primary which is also hard to imagine wasn't saying his were Primary in rashi's secondary he was saying rashi's filling our puzzle so this is a hard approach because it's a it's it sounds nice but this is not what the we shine them are arguing on not arguing which is primary which is secondary Rabino Tom says don't wear ashitam Ravena tan holds rashita on our apostle anyway um the other approach this is the approach of the we'll call them the halaches as opposed to the makubalum is that cloudy Soul always wore Rashid fill in they got it wrong how could I be no time do that after many generations has the authority based on kind of tyrosite to say that the earlier Generations did not do it correctly that's basically what the that's basically what we hold by the way I'm saying this is the Hub we don't most uh Jews do not put on Robin so what's up Sean because we hope there'll be no time change the custom of many many generations but it shows that incredible Godless according to ashkenazim was he said we point out yesterday because uh you're putting them have to be horizontally so it doesn't even help to put on Rabino town if it's if it's not vertical if it's vertical then how's it from the right and from the left he holds the other way right yeah so the gamara the very quoted with that all Bryce says not me a minimis small okay of how it said how they're supposed to be lined up um it's from a different vantage point or something yeah as the yeah I'm not sure but but by the way Roberto Thomas says the same thing about mezuzah okay by the way that just goes to show that Robin are not because of Rabino Tam if you look in toy systems that that look that way okay so let's see Civ days again say uh the Rashi zikr and the girl also says Rashi is occur which is interesting by the way because Rashi wasn't a place sake usually usually we don't pass him like Rashi I mean there's there's even a math like if Rashi learns shot in a sugya is Rashi saying it usually we say not he's not right she's not even saying a lot she's being fairies but it's interesting here we passed in like Rashi the one that is according to him and the rest are just like straps inspirational States villain there's enough room on there there's enough room for everyone there's enough room on the head to put on two pairs okay let's see the Mr bro Vianney you should put on both of them sounds like both of them at the same time yeah you should first save the first put on Rashi and put them toward the shoulder meaning here let's see in the picture okay I have the picture here basically you're gonna put on Rashi higher up um both are going to be on the bicep viennia Mata by the head it's the opposite by the head you're putting Rashi lower down [Music] okay let's villain they're both in a place that our fit for him Tam who will will be covered under the straps of Rashi 's Galu rock with Swiss tarashi you should only see the straps of Rashi uh so it sounds like you're putting on the suicide why isn't it I don't know not sure why it's not a hamster mean demeanor very dangerous to me to put on two pairs of fun at the same time also you're gonna put on the Rashi higher up also very dangerous you know if you're putting it in the top half of your arm or until somebody so you're not even you'd say no no it's still on the muscle no again there's a machlikis um weather on the muscle in the upper half of the arm is the Markham of hanakast villain that's true it's normal upper parts of the arm though to the right parts this place for two yeah but that's uh you can have the very small to fill in the sized film that we have there's not enough room on the arm for tooth filling and even if there is you put a pot on yeah people who put on their ears if only if you're gonna be lenient regarding the upper half of the arm but there's not really enough room from where the bicep starts until the Midway point of the arm for too small you're going to have to rely on the lenient opinion that you could do it on the bicep above the upper half of the arm um what if you put on tones I mean according to anyone you should only make a bracha on the one that's written according to our minha rambam so in other words if you have one Rabino Tam and one Rashi make the bracha on the one that's risen like Rashi them out if you have a show right you first put on the show right when you're going to take it off then you take off the sheliad first why should you take off the show yard first sounds like because the icker is that philantha rush because the functions that you have was written according to sitas Rashi snehem both of them together on the hand vivares you're going to tie them simultaneously and likewise so that the places are near the bracha the oisan and you have in mind that with the one that I'm going to say with the one which is foreign again this is not does not sound like a kabbalistic approach over here where they both have some kind of significance seems like the Macabre holds that there's a Indian to have both of them because there's a halacha concern but then there's also a halachic problem namely baltus so you're having that your only yojse with the one that's alibi Paradise will continue over here tomorrow have a great day everyone welcome you've just experienced another Torah class brought to you by torahanytime.com