Mishna Berura Daf Hashavua Siman 27 Seif 1 Can Someone Without a Lower Arm Put On Tefillin?

this Tower class is brought to you by torahanytime.com we're continuing in Mission abroad so I think we have a very short reading today we're doing the end of Sif aleph again the shita of the mahaber was that the villain that is put it on the left arm that is inclined slightly toward the goof should be no lower than where the flesh begins to ascend on the bicep the Rama then says you need to put it on the first part of the bone near the elbow but not in the upper half however the missionboro pointed out that the mahabir agrees to the Rama on that point that the upper half of the arm is not Kosher for tillen um and however the gra holds that the entire bicep discussion for twilin the preacher says that um and therefore says that it's best to get smaller to fill in because most of the time big filling are going to be below the area and uh if if you have to choose between too low or too high it's better to make this villain too high than to make the fill in too low because too high it's only it's only the Rama that say you're not saying as opposed to if it's too low everyone agrees with that you would say so you always yeah the the most important factor is the tone should not be Tula drama continues a son whose arm is cut off he his hand is cut off he doesn't have the Yad he only has this roya so what does that mean does he have the hand does he have the lower arm or only the upper arm he puts on phone without a bracha says the mission of burushen what does it mean doesn't have a hand it means to say the P the segment of his left arm with the entire Branch until the elbow is taken off okay now who's who's cheetah is this this seems to be the shita of um he the Ramos is your Potter so therefore you put it on without a bracha so it's the sheet of the arzarua that we're being concerned for Avalon if you have a little bit of the lower arms that's what I found in the newly published arzara so in other words if there's any amount of the lower arm than you could put on fill in so if you have a little if somebody has a little bit below the elbow then there's enough muck I'm to put on the fill in clearly the wrappings around the arm are not making right and we had that before we had that the shita of the is that after you wrap your fill in you don't make the seven wrappings you put on the show Rush right away because the seven wrappings might be a half sick because you don't have to do them so we hold they're not a half sick because it's part of the Mitzvah but it's not you don't need it you do not need seven wrappings in the kind in the midst of fill in forget the around the finger that's just also not me but even the seven wrappings so as long as you have a little bit of this part even an inch you can make put on tone with a bracha which would mean that if somebody has a wound and they have a cast um and there's a little bit of a space to put onto an even on the lower arm there's no issue you know so that's conclusion of the mission quickly um I don't know who that is the oh yeah rabba the hagra the chocolate gamkin many acquaintances what if now this interesting question what if somebody only has a little bit between half of the bone between the the uh in other words let's say you only have the upper ha part of the upper arm you could so you say well this has to be in the lower part of the upper arm no but the grass says it could be in the upper part of the of the upper arm the Hoshi so that mixes the grow would say even if somebody has the upper half of the upper arm you could put onto without a bracha uh so now but I'm putting on the cell rice and on the show Royce we know you could make two brothers right that if somebody didn't make sick between the shell yard and the shell rush you make two brothers now let's just review for a moment what did we come out if somebody talked out for um between the shellyad and the show Rush um so we said that the the mission of Brewer said if somebody let's say answered I mean rabba then you would have to make two brothers said that Posh does you make two brothers said that our meaning is like Rabino Tam that you would only make one bracha on the remember the snorkel I guess what what what how do we pass again if somebody was mouth sick for a daughter between the shalyad and the so Rush said you make two brothers but we we weren't going so far we weren't ready to say that you do what was the reason he said because it's a sex Sega namely maybe the is like Rashi that even if you talk out you don't make a bracha on phone was that the shita Rashi foreign but if it's a Dover sabikadusha then it seems like it's a machoist whether you make two brothers here saying that you definitely should make two brothers because number one you did not make any bracha on the shell on the shalyad so probably in other words here it's a different Factor you really perhaps should be making a bracha on the shalyad it's just you don't so you're it's like here definitely you can make two brothers okay the mission Bureau continues the Inland small Club someone doesn't have a left arm oh yeah or he doesn't have a bicep he does not put on fun on his arm we don't say well let him put on the right arm no he doesn't have to yeah and some say that he should put on the right arm foreign this is all if you became an amputee on his left arm now who's gonna put it on other people have to put it on for him can a woman put on fill in for you so the right that's a very common question can a woman put philan on a man somebody needs help so that goes to my minutes says that there's a famous sheet of time that anyone who's now in the Mitzvah can't do it I think the Zara says a story about a woman who is married to a cover and she would tie his villain she would just be Messiah but she can't do the kshira says well maybe tying is not making sure it's only some kind of assistance and even Robin would be masking says a woman could put the fill in on the man however the lady says only if no one else can and the rabba yashiv also says let's say can an aid somebody has an aid Revolution the aid should not put on this villain again this is cannot write the Mitzvah and cannot cannot let's say by lulav a woman cannot tie the lulav or by sukkah this is a woman cannot put up this again we're only foreign but let's say even those that's regarding creating there might be more room because they're not creating has already been created this is just assisting in the performance of the Mitzvah soman says you could be lenient by sukkah you're creating the woman creates the circle we don't allow that she can create the Lula she's not making the not of the villain she's tying this villain so there's room lahoka okay have a wonderful day we'll see everybody Monday put on you've just experienced another Torah class brought to you by toraanytime.com