Daf Yomi Succah Daf 47 by R’ Eli Stefansky

[Applause] today's share is being sponsored the is over 8 23 from his uncle michael menachem grandsons made today's learning vias for him for good health that may have estrogen he also wears indiana jones head in good health avi herschel and the unofficial official mdy youth baseball team in honor of having the pleasure of meeting ben schwartz in the ritual on our way from los angeles to our week-long tournament in cooperstone cooperstown by akiva sokovic sulkowitz so yesterday i had a bit of confusion i i met somebody that david zlatnick brought to this year f202 and yesterday akiva wrote an email and he said that he's that's all guy but i didn't recognize his face so in fact here it clears it up in a sponsorship he is f94 in honor of rebellio for teaching us the daf and david zlatnick f200 for getting me to do the daf also in honor of f202 and k303 nrl 97 als advanced life support and rl 137 which is rockaway lawrence and l83 what's l your voice i'm here with knock on cells is amazing you know fix in the gyansa alum we're back we're back in business ella's lakewood what's k canarsie [Music] now these all these guys for doing the daf strong every day keep it up in this picture you shall see josefitskowitz guersten and aaron hirsch sponsoring in honor of a dear friend who never gave up on me rejoining learning the dive daily i would remind every few days it's never too late to start thank you this is i guess right over here because this is it's and desire hershey huh that's what i just said he got aaron to join and it's a big it's a big thing for us he's a big macaron the honorary president rabbi mr ellie trapper very good here's a picture of us at our cousin's bar mitzvah i'll be going to sleep afterwards while ellie trapper the mass mid stays up for the live zoom share here he is i had a picture of my son and ellie trapper that will be a different time all right voice i what time is it what's the clock very good yakko he's back israel adler their values did i miss your simcha in [Music] as a matter of fact on the day of your son's wedding i went to the scene of the riven praying for your son and family the main thing is you should be blessed with caffeine all right talmud adler and this one is from yitzhak isaac friedman my name is freeman i did that for every day thanks to sheer i always had my trouble doing the dive i can only learn with hebrew english so that's a big deal everybody knows ever since i started with yuma thanks to the free gemara i have not stopped since i also did this commitment as definitely shelley marowski who is nifty right before covet getting hit by a car walking home from my riven teeneck so should have been a leader he's definitely smiling in heaven for my learning in his house mazel tov especially to rabbi jay nathanson big guy he wrote a nice article the other day irabi above for their encouraging words and my daft journey all the best it's like freeman base water new york voice i here we go wow thank you it's great to be back somebody uh one of the shortest emails i ever got yesterday was very belly do you have a dog because at the end of this year some clown decided to knock on the door woke the dog up or walked the whole family up yes so if you're not aware my son was in the yeshiva two years ago and the reshiva had many many meetings with us discussing one thing that we have to get a dog for akiva simcha we have to get a dog and i told him that i said but he's going to go off to yeshiva and we're going to be stuck with the dog it doesn't matter so now he's in america and we are stuck ooh that's a good but guess what sussman is in america also he's also an american when he comes back don't be great i'll just bring him the dog unbelievable yes halloween i might have to be there also with him since my wife is a little bit attached to that dog all right so here we go so yesterday we had a macholicas if somebody sets aside where is it let's see 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 15 lines from the bottom if somebody uses his s-word on the final day of sukis is the mitzvah over or not does he could he use the mitzvah to use the s-rig or is the mega disk once it becomes moxie for the mitzvah it's moxie for the rest of the day so we looked at the rebellion version we have a similar macholic it's like that interesting words here other if a person set aside seven destroyed him for seven days somebody sent me a video or primeknivsky shaking the lulu of an s rig i'm talking about 50 estradium at least it's one like give it to him and he doesn't it just goes like this boom boom just just the s-ring not the little because a little if you can see that is kosher you see the tumors is this you see that that it's just the the estrogen this is on this sound so 50 of them hey foreign so there's another guy set aside seven destroyed him each day he wants to be macbeth shouldn't have any brown that's from just holding it seventh day so now that the same shia law when he's done with that estuary oh doctor malaysians great to see you so when you're done with that s rig are you done could you eat it or no it doesn't matter like we had yesterday if the pit breaks off on day number one it's it's awesome to use the entire seven days so here's the machines again rav says once a minute is over like your schlock is finished you could go and use it right away you could eat it oh my [Music] it's only you only set it aside designated for the mids once the mitzvah is over it's over my soul could you even get so no i designate for that entire day once the day is over i can use it after that day so if i have answering just for the third day hallelujah excuse me so once that day is over then i could use the estuary because i designated only for one day it's not like the first case so i designated for seven days and it broke the pit and broke in day one over here i designated for one whole day but the whole day you cannot eat it even though i'm done with the mitzvah in the morning yeah that's not the problem it's a it's a different problem unresolved [Music] take a look at this it's a little different than the other calendar ignore that other calendar i made this is more accurate because it's the month of tishrei so this is hutzlarz okay this is blue is there it's throw let's say blue and red is hudsolards average richard dish over here aleph which is the 30th day of ello then yanta falls out on tesla i love the way it all lines up here nicely fine if this is like an irish troll you do rosh hashanah right over here then sukis falls out right over here on the 15th and then hoshanah rabbah falls out over here okay sorry ishan and rabbit falls out over here simcha storus miniatures falls out over here so again rosh hashanah first day of yantev and shimini at ceres and we shana rabbo which is the seventh day so i did it very nicely here this is day one two three four five six seven the seventh day of suk is called a shadow rabba the eighth day is called shimini at series and that sookie that we're going to learn today it's it's own yantiff however if you're in america and you did two days of rosh hashanah well we do also two days rosh hashanah but you have a spake in the ima you don't know if your traditional that over here over here but we do an artist role for just for actos of clay israel fine so then when is the first day of circus it's the first day of circus over here or in the red over here and therefore in hotels they keep these two days of yantef now once you fast forward to the end of the yanta you have the same exact problem is shimini same thing right sheminates the it's a weekday and everybody's on the buses and driving around so that's that's the suggest is but first we have to talk about the esrik omar abbayo what do you do about the s-rig right over here can you eat your s right on sylvester is yandev over or not all right bye ishmini suffolk sv ossrig on shmini you see this look down here it says eight this is the eighth day from the beginning of yant of one two three eight so this is shimini but suffolk perhaps is the seventh day from the red if you're in hutzlar's in england and you thought that this is we think we have to be mesopotamia maybe this is the first day of yandere so if you count seven days from the red it's right over here and they so this this is called this blue box is called shimini suffix v it's eight days from the blue seven days from the red it's eight days from when you know for sure energy stroll it's the eighth day mma it's schmidty at saras it's impressive what is the subject maybe it's the seventh day in hutzlarz so that's what would be awesome why because as we're going to see you have to sit in the sukkah what happens on this day very interesting this day and this is today's big sugya a very controversial halacha there you don't shake a little of an asterisk on this day but you do sit in the sukkah that's that luck in the gemara use mesa you sit in the sukkah we're going to discuss why the hasidim don't or others but the gemara says you sit in the sukkah but there's no willow okay so if there's no but you you sit in the sukkah so mela that's why you cannot eat the s-ring it's still part of yante if you're sitting in the sukkah shi savak shimini mutter what about this they're right over here nine you see over here the pack says nine so it's the ninth day from the beginning of yantev inertis it's a weak day but in hutzler it's still a suffolk maybe it's yantif maybe it's somehow that's when they celebrate you're allowed to eat the esri why because there's nothing to do with sukkahs you're not sitting in the sukkah at all even over here even in khuslar you're not saying this it's nothing to do with the sukkah so maybe the mitzvah of the estuary is over and done with and you could eat the esri mama rafi minis says even in this blue box where it's the eighth day inertis roll eighth day to the first day of yantef and the suffolk of the seventh day you're still out of it astrid why because yes you're right you're sitting in the sukkah we're not making a rock on the lulu of an estuary so there's no midsole of estrogen that day if there's no midst of estrogen that there you could eat that's right okay visual abdomen raymar they said it's multitasker on the in the blue circle rough shady shibuya the river should be writer of italy and that it's awesome to eat the esrig on shmini which is sofikshvi in other words the first day of yantev schmidty had serious inertias from [Music] and here we go the big famous sugyo what what why is that like that because you have to sit in the sukkah no it's all it's all the same the the mitsubishi i'm that's once far but the other smart is it's it's still suffocating it's something that the reason why we don't i'm going to go into why we don't check the little vanessa but but we're saying that it's a day of success perhaps it's a suffolk on that side it's still part of the mitzvah you shouldn't shake it if you want to know the real i'll skip ahead the reason why you shouldn't shake it is because of this or about tyson because it's knicker that you're you're shaking it for for the mitzvah of lulu whereas i don't want to skip ahead i want to go into the deep a little bit because of this a little bit of a controversy oh sorry let's go again all right [Music] this day right over here the fir shmini had serious inertia's role which is the eighth day it's the day after sukkah so to speak she meant terrace but still a sufficient maybe it's the seventh day in slaughterheads what's that sri lanka you have to sit in the circle ushmini libra what does that mean you make the brach of series like a contradiction you're you're dancing into hasanas you're doing a jantav called shimini at ceres but you're sitting in the circle you you're acting as if it's but you're saying that it's not circus and you you don't make any mention of success you say so now the governor on the first attempt says mase of kuli amalui pagini everybody agrees that you sit in the sukkah do you make a brother type of memz according to rav who says that this day is considered for so it's considered you make a bracha not only you go into this this day right over here has a hello of eight you see down here it says eight it's the eighth day for everything you don't make a bra okay but you do sit in the sukkot according to this also beyonce not yet because even right now the kumar says you sit in the sukkah you just don't make a break listen to the story it's an incredible story needs a lot of explanation imagine in your mind who the god ladder is they happened to come to asuka on the eighth day shemini which is only a suffolk that may be in hustlers the seven but in inertia straw they're dancing with the torah and somehow story of the whole thing may say baby they sat in the sukkah they didn't make a brah so here's a raya that you sit in the sookie don't make a broca like the first day of sukkah because it's one long mitzvah since you have to eat and sleep in the sukkah consecutive there's no break at all so he says you make one breath in the beginning you yield to that and then we brought it right from finland that even go to the bathroom you do make the fine but according maybe they held they already made a broken the first day of young that's why they didn't make it says the gemara incredible listen to this according to rashi kimiri the mahapharasa they came from the dirt meaning the entire yantef these daily adar were shepherds they didn't have a soca mamas it's so hard to understand how how how would a god ladder shepherd his animals and not make a little sucker next to his animals one shot that i heard and nobody says it besides i don't remember was the the mashallah like one of these that maybe it was in the time of the xero and they weren't allowed to stay in a sukkah so the eighth day they could it's not mentioned it seems like they were busy working they were working people in those days no kailua nobody supported them every tana every america had a job but they were they were busy thinking and learning and they weren't worried about them in sukkah and now they came they finally oh they happen right they were able to do the sugar for the very first time of all of sukkahs and they didn't make a brahmana but they sat in this sukkot unbelievable another chat is everybody agrees no mach like is that on the on the eighth day of media series [Music] he's the one that said over ubisoft himself didn't even sit in the sukkah okay i'm sorry who's the one that said it over in the name of rav rav is the one that says you should sit this ravi and review themselves didn't listen to rap he did like rebecca they didn't send this says listen to this video this i think everybody knows this line it's a very very famous line mesa you see there's a on here in the aleph you sit in the sukkah you eat in the sukkah but you don't make a bracha so when i first got married my very first sukkas was in chicago and my sweater was invited out to some family and uh they started like they made kiddush or something and then they all went into the house like what's going on here what are you doing she says what do you mean you're not allowed to eat in the sukkah where i go open up this mushroom it's there's no mention in the shiburu the misha brewer brings brings this supposed to sit in the sukkah and you don't make a broccoli he's supposed to sit in the sukkah what are you talking about i was all confused so i decided me and my wife we sat in the sukkah by ourselves they started serving us and that was it then i learned not to go out with my share what is going on here so bar hashem now i had some time i'm looking to so you know so it goes like this there there is no there's no mention in the mission there's a safer did i bring it yeah you saw those be careful not to me shiva's a whole somebody wrote a whole conscience not to sit in the sukkah the village in my sarab he says that he was the most macbeth to sit in the sukkah to eat in the sugar and to sleep in the sugar why because he said it's a it's under a bottom if you're over in there he says whoever doesn't sit in the sukkah and it says miso the thighs in the mug bring this minute of not to sit in the sukkah and they they they go they they they go wild it's us how can you do this so what what's takapsha so in the max of victory richard he brings this inion of that the reason why we don't shake a lullaby talks about it why don't you shake a lullaby on that thing if it's so important to send the sukkah fill the gang that's it so why don't you shake a loaf the answer is because places says that alola is mukta so why are you taking a little of now because obviously you hold it sukkas today so that's the problem about this if you're sitting in a sukkah and relaxing and eating it doesn't maybe it's not about that maybe you want to stop anyways sometimes you go outside to your backyard and eat right now you you eat outside you have meals over there you soak up fine but it brings ribeyose mckinnon that didn't sit in the sukkah so that's early in the time they reshared him already there were those who weren't sitting in the sukkah you don't sleep he makes enough talks about it what yeah right the fear of all this so the mordechai and the maril they talk about not sleeping in the sukkah because of the but when eating it doesn't look like you're about to but sleeping if you go out of your bedroom into the sukkah then it's obvious that you're doing this for sukkah and that's a problem about taisuf and then aleph morgan brings that allah didn't sit in the sukkah the gross slept in the sukkah because he passed cannot like the mortified like the rashbow the other restaurant i'm i'm bringing i'm bringing the ones that say i'm trying to be malama 100 percent one minute i'm getting there i'm i'm gonna explain the hasidim the best i can i'm trying to no i found it interesting doesn't even mention like you should say yes or whatever he doesn't even mention them he ignores it completely i was like what's going on here i told my harushi yesterday he didn't know there's such a minute he didn't know a little back in arizona doesn't know about it you have to be in an america in a casino environment to even know that such a thing he didn't know he says it's impossible he starts looking you couldn't find anything i'm just telling you whatever fine so the magazine is rich they they used to do this thing that may shred them make kiddush eat messiness and leave and they said in accordance that you also do like that a little bit of uh you have uh yeah you have a hamish thing and they say that the bashamtv also the they say didn't eat in the sukkah fine so what's going on here so here's here's a great a grape shot great limousine and the carbonisano they say a similar thing that this idea that when we don't take a little of why because of baltic it's obvious that you're you're doing it for circus not for no other reason a normal person on a wednesday afternoon let's take a look but when you're sitting you're soaking you're having a bar you're enjoying yourself great but in america in europe when it's freezing cold it's 20 below zero who's going to sit in the sukkah so obviously you're seeing the sugar for the mitzvah sukkah so comes out then inertia straw or in florida in los angeles where the weather is nice you'll have a major problem and in fact somebody wrote me a rabbi grossof grosskopf from london he said he when he was learned by pickers scheinberg repeatedly sharpened said that this doesn't apply narcissism he locked the doors to the kitchen he said if you can see this you have to eat in the sukkah you know so you have to it's interesting because you know a lot of times you say these minhagem come from okay so you say in europe's like this and then people forget why the minix started it's only because there's a problem baptism but the shogunate says you shouldn't eat in the sukkah so it doesn't imply when on a day that's boiling hot in america it wouldn't apply so you have to once the minute we're in it but it's it's to be like or something it's like it says so [Laughter] i miss you abby i miss you all right let's go right there i have no idea what time it is but it was it was candidate to talk about it because it's a big it's a big sign at least people should know that there's a big thing here look into yourself fine i know i'm not going to change anybody's mind everybody has a thing in them but know why you're doing it nobody's ever called me i was like oh uh i'm the babbage and i started sleeping in the sucker because of you that's the one oh oh we're really but not to sleep fine by itself however the seventh day of pesach is different than the eighth day of sukkos vomit believing what's the difference i'll tell you the big difference it's very different in three different things you don't sit in review the argument two things says rashi first of all you don't need three look you need only one look but the point is he says you do pour the water on the eighth day so the eighth day of sukkos or nanasukes but the eighth day from the beginning of it is not different in okay fine at least it's different you don't have to eat matzo on the seventh you could eat non comments you don't have to you never the first night the following morning you can eat the macaroons you do whatever you want so it's not even the difference between the seventh day of pesach and the in the first day it's different from the entire pesach so why would you say [Music] fine you're talking about the eighth day is different than the seventh day over here he's saying that the seventh day of pesach is different than the first day of pesach he's going way way back so why would you say or papa siv so this is very important raboisei if you want to remember very very simple onso the number is 14 14. so for instance the final final day of sukis you bring seven cows plus seven days of circus equals fourteen the first day of soak is you bring thirteen cows and it's the first day of circus so one plus thirteen equals fourteen it always equals fourteen and you keep on going down thirteen 12 to the final day so what should be on chamini and series six cows plus eight days equals fourteen but what does the posix say that one so you see vermeer that it's a different yanta of it's younger before it's its own uh a cumulative halachus over here all of a sudden it says it should have been red meaning it's its own little entity the eighth day it's a it's a it's a day before it's not uber it's not a continuation of the seventh it's bayonne it's by itself another ride that it's its own larry lay how do i know i'll bring you right there you say this on the eighth day right so all these are bringing let's say seven cows on this day plus two to two rams and fourteen sheep every day two and fourteen magma says that what if you have only thirteen cheap you don't bring them i think it means all of them not understand i saw show him fine but if you have you're missing one you don't bring any review pardon me magazine says but the cows have differences review though if you're if you don't have seven you only have six bring the six why sharing smart involved him every day he keeps on going down you see the tacos broccoli didn't really mind interesting sarah he started with 13 then he went to twelve yeah so you don't today don't have semi f6 no armor equivalent what do you mean but at the eighth day it's completely different it's one ram and seven and seven uh sheep oh my god when they asked me okay it's its own don't bring me right from there it's its own entity oh what's so different about it every single day you have to bring its own carbon different carbons this year and you talk about rashid says you talk about the poor people da nim and the the shirsha yoim of shimini doesn't talk about the poor people he says i don't even know what you say exactly i'm not so sure but it's not about poor people we're going to see what bracha means velina so lino as we learned about this lina is any time you bring a carbon to the base amigdas it says in the morning you go home you do not go home at night you must stay in a hotel in yerushalayim lina ashwini so too shimini had serious it's a younger by itself tone carbon you have to bring its own kirbanis this year it gets its own uh you make its own that's the whole point of the gemara now what that means velino you have to sleep over there turning them zairon bays my love aren't we talking about what is brahmin like we do today by the way right women when they live from los angeles and honorably's wife for sacrificing her life in order for ellie to be fair share it's the first time you heard it huh we're not talking about don't bring a writer from here that you're supposed to say you're supposed to say a brothel doesn't say his man it says brother what brother you desire on your own no this other box by the way every day but you don't say brock every day you only say once in the beginning says well that's not great proof holy cassio oh now the the rest of your mother's gonna tell us that's not good proof mar the price is only telling us what do you have the option to say if you forgot it but what do you mean you have to say no you can't say what are you going to walk in the street and say you have to hold maybe it's a good writer of lachman and this is how we pass it you could just say shakiano style without a cup of wine that was being closed because it's called eco where's he going to find it do medically closed not a good writer then today somebody gave a couple wine it's not a big deal to find a cup of wine in hallmark this solver by the way right boys i'm getting all excited because we're we still have to start preparing we do these beautiful shiurim kalama sukkas in the morning in the sukkah with with the with eggs and omelettes and pancakes and wine wine we have wine even though we have wine on the table i'm getting saying you know why because i was thinking about it this year i'm not going to be lazy i'm going to build a giant silk on my porch the entire porch to house and why because of the squishmaker to make it to build the sook i'm going to build the sugar i'm going to hey yeshua's going to build most of it i'm going to put the last matter out of the shook down has been increased i'll climb on the ladder and pretend it's so hard to put this one piece what you have to sleep in your shalayim it's not we're going off now on a tangent you have to sleep in your shallow on on the eighth day on series if somebody who's tommy the first person he brings his carbon pays on the second peso he does not sleep in your shallow that night so shouldn't she at serious be similar to the peso shady why should it be similar right this this is possible that if it's a giant yante with seven days then you sleep over your slime if it's a one day yantef like lakshmi net series what else is one day anthony schwarz you don't sleep in us [Music] isn't also coming a one-day yanta bushmi natsares something that's exactly like pesach but it's called place of shaini that's the time you don't sleep in your slide but you do sleeping beautiful bikurim is this week's pirate show the beginning of the paris show you have new fruit the new crab you bring uh a basket full of fruit to the basa amigdos and i don't know if deuteronomy knows this to unim carbon not only do you bring your fruit you have to bring ashlan vishy and you say special shir called hashem the whole thing with nufa and you shake it like a lulu if you pick up the basket and you go like this all i don't know again i'm not going to go into it and make fun of us fire it again you go this way you go all the way around that's damn lift you got it this is where we took it from like this in the basement velina and you sleep over there manchester united who's the one that holds you have to shake it they call my tuna lino so even though bikurim how many days is this bikurim one day so here you see the idea that even if it's a one day uh exclusion or whatever the word excursion i mean excursion two you're lying you'll you still do lino still sleep over you can't do it in and out what is it called when you have that quick surgery um yeah but this is a bit outpatient and out boom boom there's no such thing once you go to slime you stay there this is already placed it down he already put it down so then why puzzle you doesn't say and then and the israel says this whole long thing hashem what's going on here there's two hanajos you put it down twice by the misbehave maybe the word literally in hebrew means to put it down who told you means to wave it around because i already said a positive dialogue with the word venus that you put it down so what does it mean that he put it down again this is possible i learned the idea of waving now so you see that it's review that says this so review the halls that you need leno one day says with dilma river there's another one that says that you have to waive it from this learns that you have to wave the bikurim the whole basket the river lets me agree my time and then realize where did he get it from him again it says the word yoda [Music] so we go back and forth just like over here by bikurim it's calling so over there by shlomim the cayenne here i have a picture this is a beautiful picture why the cayenne here's the coin he puts his hands underneath the basket and the throw holds the basket by the by the room why because tyson points out this picture is very medullary not like the gemara says you should put your hands under the hands like it would seem like them literally this is that's a that's kazitsa then the kind is not touching the basket he needs to do it move into the basket so it may look like in the picture they're holding in two different places fine but they're doing it at the same exact time very interesting how they do back i'm not exactly sure maybe it's like literally like your time can have kind of a little bit you don't have to like just like swing the guy over your shoulder kind of thing all right do you say one shaykh on the seventh day of pesach absolutely not no that that was our only the eighth day of sukkah is a new yorker and that's why he says we learn [Music] what's the first one pay stands for pie is lifting asthma so goes like this all days of yontif you have all these curb bonus every kind you want to be zygote to check the carbon to be microcarbon and you have to be in the basement so they divide it up very nicely between the 24 mesh marios every mishma got a chance to be makarov but when it came to shriniat series which is it didn't go with the mishmarus it went with a with a raffle raffle you bring a different type of carbon you drop it down completely to one one one power instead of the thirteen seven or whatever it is that has its own type because every day of yontav really has its own chiro but like rashi explains the shira during yantev of sukkos is about giving matanistani like a chicape these kind of matanzas and on it has nothing to do with that it's a different topic it's a different thing than all other seven days you say have a wonderful day [Music] ah [Music] you