Daf Yomi Succah Daf 43 by R’ Eli Stefansky

who was tragically taken from us yesterday in front of his yeshiva in denver i mean today's learning is christmas inshallah thank you beautiful here's an email from first of all i wanted to show you this unbelievable picture according to mark ashkenazi this was the most shocking of all the shirin we had this was matsushabus almost the last minute kind of thing i think friday we weren't even sure where how when and over a hundred people showed up in the five towns for a share unbelievable yeah i think it was one of the big highlights that and lakewood like was a big shocker i'm not putting anything else down but in terms of shocking that was a big shocker miami was a little bit of a shock because sir um here's the genius a guy that's marsha i love these here's about kitchen i just wanted to point out that this that you forgot your phone in america is such a mustard lesson for all of us because in today's world people are so attracted to the phones that if there's one thing that they won't forget is their phone but by you forgetting it shows where your icker focus is which is torah gevaldic i didn't think of it involved i got my phone back my voice don't worry about it i got it back for hashem it's back it's i was relieved i didn't have to do anything i didn't have to speak to anybody it's unbelievable give vodka vacation so excited to finish the parrot with you today mrs hashem my first full one since i started with you shikaya salomon thank you simcha it says over here i've been meaning to reach out to you for a little bit it just hasn't worked my name is evan i'm 25 years old currently learning in asia torah in rochelle in baltimore from westchester new york got a whole story but not for this email i listened to meaningful people podcasts having no clue who you are along with having seen an advertisement on yeshiva news coinciding right around the time my grandfather passed away i decided to start up sukkah in his honor during the daf kept me in consistency they were back in new york we've been as many and have really come to appreciate all the amazing work that you do it is remarkable to see how much torah you love learning guys seeing all different backgrounds with all different exposures and feelings towards gemara i appreciate being able to be part of what feels like the jewish world hearing all the different communities though i've been exposed to very few hashem aligned so much to make this in the seth i started learning the deaf as i mentioned fathers passed away right around start of my sector on top of my father passed away from ellis a few weeks after sukkos 2018. that was his grandfather's father that year was my second year celebrating sukis bikitsu if his father was not observant but his last mitzvah that he did was shaking the little of an asterisk with his help i'm grateful to have been part of this journey with the khabar it's very special i feel the warmth of who you are and every so often when an email sponsorship can get you a little emotional and it's powerful things don't really care okay now that your sheep is back in the grind this is the sad part rabbi sai somebody needs to reach out to him now that yeshiva is back in the grind i don't think i'll be continuing with the sheer after sukkah time wise just makes me have to rush and the learning doesn't feel strong enough on my side so this seal my plan to celebrate with a full heart for my father and for my grandfather thank you for helping me make it possible i look forward to finishing up the masekta with all of you you should be blessed and continue to grow to share bring the beauty of gemara and learning to all jews all over the world you and your wife and your kids who i'm sure have to sacrifice to make this all possible should be blessed with a healthy physical and spiritual life on may to continue to grow in developing an authentic relationship with hashem and all your prayers should be heard and answered would love to comfort shabbos evan hendell is evan absolutely just reach out to burma all those seminary people and and bakarim there's there's um we have room we have in shabbat and we have bachrom with shops backhand it's only 14 days to the seam 14 days two weeks paso shem thursday i believe is the same wednesday thursday something like that wednesday i think wednesday is the same i'm not even sure so here we are daffman based on the base on the bottom so the question is we don't bring a little of the soul we don't check why not we're talking about mukhtar here mukta a stone something that has no value something that's not a cli a piece of wood what's a lulav a little of doesn't have much value i rava in terms if it was in the middle of a regular shabbos during the year it's nothing it's not a klee so it's only muktu velitri shabbas how could a israel muktin the rabbanaan push off the eraser of a lullab omarabha the famous concept zero shimmery taleno it lenovo yellow bokeh so the concern is that somebody especially if you dive into this expired here's a riot and it's expired it's so complicated you have to go ask a rabbi how to do it so you go ask how to make a bracha how to shake the lulu of all the all the things like i mentioned once i'll mention again maybe i didn't mention it correctly i looked in the mission brewer again so maybe i said it wrong as you go forward at the end you go like this a shake come back shake you do this three times shake over there shake over here it's funny that's weird says be careful don't shake like a madman because you're going to break the tumors be careful that you shake okay so you do a little shake a little shake but there's a you might go ask somebody via vireno dal damas so the concern is you're going to walk four hours or strava or you're going to take it from to from your house into surrounding which is not as common as rashi for atmosphere time of decipher that's the exact reason why we don't blow a soifer on rosh hashanah that falls out on chess it's important to mention the nays last year during kovid so we were concerned we made a small tiny minion in mdy 10 people 11 people and we needed about cairo we needed a baltic air so nobody could blow i said well i once blew an elo uh for ludavish ameri once in my life so uh okay i became the official baltico and believe it or not i mean the menachem says who said that it's true but i did not make a single mistake as far as i know like it could be the whole thing was a mistake but the kids came out the truth was everything straight from beginning to end it was literally a nasty niggle if i tried it again it would never happen okay shaipha show if you don't blow on chops the high no time of the megillah and that's why we don't line the megillah on purim that falls out on shabbos there's a beautiful shiloh here what happens if a person goes ahead and shakes a lullaby chavez he doesn't care about takana was he aita did uproot the mitzvah completely or they say you shouldn't do it what's an afghan mina do you make a brock on the second day could he say if they uprooted the mitzvah completely he wasn't yay at all if he was yaita then he shouldn't make a bracha the second day so believe it or not a lot of players can say that he was yota and it's a whole nice needling why because as we're going to see there's a major question here that actually brings up how could him say don't do a mitzvah that's in the torah tyler says you should shake a lullaby on chavez and then no you don't don't shake a lullaby chavez because you might come to walk and resist raven they could they could be like her amidst her iso they could uproot a mitzvah so rashi answers like the gemara says the gem already asked this question the answer is because just said don't do the mitzvah they didn't upload them in so they didn't say do something against the title you said just sit at home don't don't take a look oh so don't have the right to uproot the mitzvah so so a lot of players can say they didn't uproot the mitzvah so if you did the mitzvah you're making the mitzvah so then you don't have to do it the next day you don't have to say the broker the next day but others point out the tysons that we mentioned in this maserta that is that if a person sits in a small sukkah and his table is inside the house the gemara says we have to be geyser he shouldn't sit like that and if he sits he's not yet to the mitzvah says dice versus he's not yoita at all so over there you see that they uprooted him it's okay there's a whole beautiful knee then over here says so let's uproot let's say they should not shake a lullaby on the first day of yante the first day of yonder falls out on shabbos we do shake a lilif why is that well not us we're gonna go to get to us and what happens in our days if you look at the end of the mishnah yesterday the last last words we said yesterday there's a big fight oh i was i had a lot of karate because i found a great picture i found it because i actually made it myself here in the basement the imams went to war with the love and became dangerous became dangerous that was the end of the mishnah so they said you know what you you're putting yourself in sakana just go ahead and shake it at home don't even bring it to sean so there's no concern that people are going to schlep their little of outside into the into the surrounding for amis they know they have a sign here stay at home okay that was later on a different generation when they made it what happened all the years beforehand where they used to shake a little of anchovies in the basement what happened then how come we're not concerned they're going to walk four hours michael lemay ella re-showing the isa minatoya big villain so the shot is like this you hear a boy reshoot the first day is so harsh and so hummer it's so important why because it pushes off even outside of yerushalayim outside of the misamigdas but the other days that is not minna toyo outside of your slime so rabona meredix today how come lulaf doesn't push off shabbos if it's so hush it's so humber that you that that you're supposed to do it everywhere says so going back a step since we saw hummer rabona with glazer even in the base hamikdos fine and that's where rashi comes and says this whole thing how could it be okay or something direct anyway so we're going to mention this a few times a couple of times i should say very very simple here's a calendar i just grabbed a random month in the time of the bassamigdas they didn't have a calendar so they would make rosh based on aiden on testimony when they saw the moon the new moon so a month ello could either be 29 days and if they see the moon here this becomes rich height is the blue or the month the previous month could be 30 days and if they see the moon over here they testify and rashford becomes aleph the issue is and this explains we're going to understand a lot better today why it is that my wife wants to live in aaron destro her main reason is because you don't have two days yanta if you're energy strong for that alone it's worth for it to live here for 365 days in a 2 000 square foot home instead of a 12. it's not to not to have two days yantif okay great so that's what she says if you live in bubble you live in iraq you don't have a cell phone you don't have a tractor you don't have a 4x4 vehicle how long it does it take to get for a human being to travel traverse from israel to iraq on a donkey it takes more than 15 days so the people in baval they weren't sure israel in the blue circle or is in the red circle it could only be one of these two because they knew they knew what the previous month was because it took less than 30 days but they didn't know what the coming month is and if rosh is in the red circle here so yantif on the test valve falls out over here but if it's quite in the blue circle over here so yanta falls out on your dialed over here so which day is the ante we don't know so you have to keep two days yanteff so anan in bavel in bavel they didn't know where where is scheiders inu so therefore they can't push off because maybe maybe you're not doing the first day of yantef today is shabbos so if today's shabbos the toyota says it's sheikholu of chavez but maybe today's shabbos is the second day of yantev maybe hunter happened in the blue and now you're on a random day you're not you're not on you're not on it's not the first day of yantef today you don't know so you can't push off shabbos as the gemara you know the other people they are but we live in artistro we know when when the moon when they saw the moon to get from yerushalayim to every place in arizona is a few days and everybody enters this troll knows when yonte is going to be by tesla by the 15th of the month everybody knows already you're right so it does push off the tony hall though and i'll prove it to you because yesterday we had in our they had a bus stop they had an overhang they had a bench higher back and we learned that fm alex just won that ago the base hackness everybody would bring the lulu to the show what's the difference because amigos basically why the different language the answer is that says about a show is because we're talking about there's nobody english and even though there's nobody this but whenever it's just roll it pushes off shabbos even though there's nobody no so in there's this role we push all shabbos for now this is what we're doing understands now that i'll tell you that if you don't live in their destroy we do not shake a lullaby in chalice but over here the mother says we do we have two missionaries that say there's a difference between uh even bismarck outside of the west amigos this is the original chart i used a few days ago i was thinking to myself how do i get five drushes in there hashem great idea well here we go very nice this hay is a lima by itself so mars is like this and every individual has to bring a little of it's not one lula for all of christopher everybody brings a lot cannot be stolen it cannot be borrowed it has to be yours we discuss this it doesn't say what day any day even on shabbos ha ha is an exclusion the first day means only the first day of yantev pushes off shabbos re-showing here we are right here this is what we want to know re-shine gulen outside of yerushalayim also has the same says to exclude a borrowed and a stolen lulu of big tadic he steals a lula to do a mitzvah nope says rashi it's extra the green word is extra why because it says it should say on the first day of this comes to teach us that you shake a little of even on shabbos re-showing the word region is not action afidou just it doesn't say region doesn't say where where where where do you take the lord it doesn't say the the place anywhere even outside of the base of english and now this is not a reboot like is extra over here this is a meal this is an exclusion the only day that it is that if shabbos falls out here i made this for a little later we'll use it now why not oh valdicus stuff if shabbos falls out on the first day of yonte you take your lulu if shabbos falls out in the second third fourth day you do not it's only when shabbos falls out on one on day one that's when that's what the puzzle over here says huh your division the first day of sukkah that falls out of chavez you push off shabbos and you shake a loaf but you do not push off shop is a color my head [Applause] oh my god everybody my favorite shabbos yeah so we just said oh my my we just said we said it's actual word you're supposed to shake a little of you in shocks for that you need apostol what is the issue we're talking about mukta mukta is the rabbana comes later so it's the mystery tilto you think wrote in his torah a extra word to tell you that in later generations make xavier and they say you shouldn't carry you shouldn't touch moksha mukta i'm coming to to undo what are doing in a thousand years can't be um amazing [Music] we have the same idea uh by by bruce mila when the torah says perform a mitzvah and you don't have to worry about shabbos you go ahead and you shake a little van chavez did the torah say that he could also cut the lulavan chavez that he could you can make a saw to cut the low pajamas to what what point mitzvah anything that's isn't there isa you know how to cut a lullaby on champions on a regular shabbos it's a director you know how to tie and bundle up your lulu with the aurovision nadas it's the racer it's tying on chavez to tie something to make it not in javascript so even the mashiri mitzvah even the side things that help the mitzvah are also mother where do we have this same rebellion in mila could you make a knife for the bismillah could you do other things perform other things that are mature not the actual cutting of the bris but bringing the knife to the shop it goes according to that one of the sheriff not just shaking the lull of but everything that that's around and around the little of making the knot for the love is also what the divi rebellion my time of the rebellion what's the swara macro by philo bashars in other words why is the torah saying you could shake a lullaby chavez you hear this rabbi very gevaldic it can't be that the torah is saying that you could shake a lullaby there's no a history the only says that they're abundant of mukta it's not a director so why would the torah want to undo it's the the rabbana obviously the third is not saying that you should shake a lullaby chavez that they are saying you should make a knot on chavez you should cut the tree you should cut the little of itself off the tree on java that's what the tire is saying that's why this extra word but that there is oh yeah rabban on that say that it's us to do makshirim right they arguably they say that it's usur to cut the lulu of itself on yantev on chavez is the one that learns from bayonne that you could cut a little of a child but they say you're not so then what do they do with the extra word when do you shake a little of during the daytime you don't a little there's no mids with the shake it at night once it's nighttime it's too late and how does he know that you shake a little of only during the daytime save you the crowd from the end of the possible remember this this is very important because it says in other places in the torah it says by sokka it says seven days yam days that's almost the shiva although it is similar over there with the yama so it says during the day that's when us is referring to the simcha of bringing a little of an asterisk and it says during only time on guess what there's another puzzle that has the same exact words shivas yamim basuko station so learn from sukko and ge and sukka applies to the nighttime you're supposed to sleep in a sukkah knight yeah it has the same words learn from it you sleep during the night time also talk about a sugar station when you eat you want to eat you have to eat in the sook even if it's after shiki the now we have a problem you can learn sukkah you learn sukkah from lula and lulav is during the day or you could learn from yeah from here it's it's all day and all night so make it easy to learn sukkah from alulav and say that it's only during the day time perhaps learn sukkah from elohim that's also nighttime says gemara well the typical classic gemara if you have an option you could learn sukkah either from lulav or from elohim so you have to see what suk is more similar to let's take a look nir limited who is it similar to don in davos as we mentioned yesterday when you pick up an asterisk for a moment for a second you yield to that's it the mitzvah lasts for one second yes we go to show and we shake a lot then we do hoidoo and oh no that's all that's she already misses so to speak those are the extra stuff that are not part of the mitzvah the mitzvah is that one second and that's why we flip that right upside down we have in mind not to be it's but the minister only lasts for a second so mela suka is a lot more similar to me which is 24 7 or at least 12 hours compared to a little that's one second or perhaps no there's something else that is more similar to lulav than to me lasts forever all the generations have to bring a little so sukkah should be learned out from a love whereas milo it was a one-time deal take a look it says over here taisho in green that's the million but it says the word taisho and it says so the two greens are shava which we don't make up it's comes from sinha and mushroom received it on our sina and therefore i compare asuka to me and literally 24 hours 7 days sponsored by the md whitetail group for all those who need him refusing yeshua's please join film.com and by lazarian from la in honor of rebellious wife fagi for the sacrifice for sacrificing her life in order for her belly to prepare this year i showed it to my wife she enjoyed it very much and yesterday oh so first of all we're talking about simkas mazeltov huge mazeltov to leon welcher leon welcher made hassan last night so tremendous mazel tov uh leon welch have a lot of to akarsa i was two years ago literally a little over two years ago i was sitting in south africa in a restaurant and he walked over to me and he said so malayka and what do you do i said a little real estate but i do this thing called eight minute dab he says perfect i have an app that i developed for usher weiss and i want to give it to you for free i want to develop for you he worked on it for months he has a tech guy worked on it and he gave me gifted me this app that many many people use so you should after him and i have a tremendous accuracy there's a client you'll see clyde in new york person after person after person i started sukkah started soca i got a free gemara and start it was his idea his initiative he pushed it he paid for a lot of it so tremendous sakuras are taught and tonight his son yantif is having a bar mitzvah and it should be to be just as great as his father and more arava shiva keita oh so now going back we had this beautiful midsole you know it's interesting i bet you i didn't take uh a poll or anything i bet you fifty percent of the people that haven't learned soca before in their life never even knew there's a concept of a rava in the basa mikdash that they used to walk around the mizbaya and do a conference of the mizbeh now yeah you think to yourself why do we do hoshanas every day in sukkos well to commemorate this but here's the mitzvot arava shiva keita how does it work that you have an arava you bring it even on shabbos so the mission says you bring it on shabbos when you have to find that geovaldica chart that'll let i know from this chart where is it i see it but i can't get to it here it is this is what the mission says the arava pushes off shabbos only if shabbos falls out on the seventh day of sukkos if shabbos falls out on six fifth four four even the first you do not touch an arova on shabbos whereas the lulav it's only if shabbos falls out on day number one but if shabbos falls out on day number seven you do not touch your lulu it doesn't push off shots so now the gemara wants to understand what's going on here why why is alulah different than us what's going on here aro shivokait arowa lulav the reason why we said lulav pushes off shabbos because it's so humber remember we said lulav is special it's also outside of your slide but around is not outside of your shaline arab is only inside the base i made those in one spot in the basement so it's not so hammer so if it's not so hammer it doesn't have what the gemara said aloe if that that's why it pushes off shabbos so then gemma is asking so then why does a arava push off shabbos if it doesn't have that special aspect that it's also outside of your slime [Music] people don't know that it exists this idea you'll tell somebody to zairava in the base amigda she'll say i don't know what you're talking about i never learned taffy i mean and you're going to tell them that it's at their eyes what are you out of your mind what does it say in the torah they have to take an arava and walk around them is bear well i'm telling you that's their iso and not only is it the rise of pushes off shabbos typically you can't hold the naira van chabas i'm telling you you should do it on chapis why lift fire sing you have to advertise the fact that there's a mitzvah called arova because it's not foolish in the torah for a thousand points does anybody remember and it wasn't so long ago it was less than two weeks ago i believe what that was it that's gimmel you can look it up for a thousand points how do we know that you bring an aurova in the base of english so what we had was that we're going to talk about them later on not today is that it says in the past are they plural remember arvei the mitzvah to get a rava from the creek from the river that a lot of you are going to do this year the special muncie arova is from the water whatever the but the other mandarin says ayurvey is two there's two types are office one goes in yellow one is around them is bear so the iso and the others but the bottom line is to go around in this because is pushes off shabbos in order to advertise the fact that they left is also not exactly we're not sure that it's all seven days you could say raj explains which we discussed many times we had yesterday even maybe it's referring to eating meat for seven days who said it means shaking a little over seven days it's not a before so it's if it's not some of us maybe we have to advertise the fact says zero lula of zero mushroom daraba we said in aleph we're concerned that if you say you could shake a little van chavez he's going to go outside in rochester and walk four atmospheres rebbe to ask him how to do this but ira also maybe he's going to go ask his rabbi what kind of broccoli what do you do nah don't worry about it arava is taken care of from the besan in the bay san miguel they're they're they know what they're doing you have the kahanam only kahanam could could go around be making the mizbayach why only a cayenne because israel is not allowed in there so only they can hand him go around in his back like that so the concern is more for lulu that the the entire nation brings they're going to mess up the best in the base of english won't mess up they'll bring their over before shabbos they know what they're doing the qurayan are the ones don't worry about it says if there's zero concern that somebody's going to walk on shabbos for amis with an arava right even look at these pictures you have these massive aromas i know that's real but it's not like one little aroma the gemara says soon we're going to see it was bigger of us so only the vessen does this only the basin does it so what's the concern so why is it that tyrava only pushes off this final shabbos day if shabbos falls out on seven then it pulls it off if shabbos falls out on six you don't bring in our oven based on this why not there's no concern that you're gonna go to the rabbi and walk four hours says people are going to say look at this arava you pushes off shabbos on any day of the week on any day of the yantav any day of yandere sixth day of younger falls out of jabba's you bring in our own faith only on day number one verses of shabbos so what are people going to say you're going to say the lulav is a weak mitzvah it's not as strong as aroma okay now by the way in our days so we don't we don't push off shabbos for hoshanahs so do you say hoshanah as a commemoration to the besan mikdos and the fact that they walked around on chavez or maybe not so it's a massive massive from all over the place says that you say you just say the words hoshanah i think that's what we do today a lot of us says not to say anything the villain and a lot of times the ball italian the guy and say the same thing the villain explains he says in the base i make the shifter they didn't have aarova they didn't just say words so why would we just say words if we don't have that rather we're not let a whole die rubble okay anyways it's a massive machole because you just know that there's a lot of monogamy in this fight okay you only want to give it one shabbos one day to commemorate darava because you don't want it to be better than the lulu so why don't you put this arova together with lullaby and say only when shabbos falls out on the first day of yandere could you take dharava why do you push him off to the seventh day of yanta says nobody's gonna realize that you're doing something special for aurova you want to advertise the fact that i rub as a direct that they walked around in this bear in the torah they said it says it well if you do it together with a little they're going to say ah you're pushing it off pushing shabbos off because you want to do a little it just happens to be that you're just taking another arrow over with you also so you want to make a special shabbos that only dairova is being shabbos so to speak and say look the reason why you push off javas is because this is the right rights so then then have you want to do a different day than will of great so do what if shabbos falls out on the fourth day of yanta so push that off white after seven when you get the number seven says gemara keep in the comments oh we wanted to set a special day seven and one one and seven we don't want to say oh whenever shabbos falls out special yeah now how come in our day today we don't do a rava we should push off why says we don't know about should we do this again we can't push off we can't push off for our rava in our days because we have no idea when janta started maybe on the starter on this day right over here i mean rashford is on the stage so therefore is over here or orange was over here and yonder starts over here therefore we cannot push off oh shots we don't know when the seven fell out maybe seven is not seven maybe it's eight but energy straw where they became in the calendar or not to the beginning of the calendar sorry the bikini they know when rosh happens because they live in their soil they're right there where it happened even if they're a few a few hours away a few kilometers away they'll figure it out in a day or two but they know when you'll start says the gamora they should push it off so i want to point out something here a very important thing a lot of people ask why is it that in america in hudson and england all these places in australia i see someone in australia here why is it robert driving around where is he robert i don't know but anyway why is that we keep two days we have a calendar we know exactly when young tiff starts begins ends the whole thing so there's a question from the resigner it says in gemara bazaar which basically we're about to start in two weeks it says over there that today we are bucking in a calendar we know well here it says we don't know in in bava we don't know when the calendar so the answer is that the gemaran bates is going according to those days after hillel was misaki in the calendar he figured out the calendar he said this is it and where it says by us that we don't know when gantf starts or when rosh says therefore we don't know so we didn't have the calendar so then the question is but if we have a calendar then why do we do two days yante everybody's question this is the study right here the answer is we'll probably see it again debates and all that the answer is because when hillel made the calendar he did it on condition that we don't change anything that we keep the two days he was worried that we're not going to have a calendar whatever the reason is whatever his reasoning was he said i'm going to teach you a trick i know how to figure out the calendar i'm going to tell you the calendar but i want you to keep the same humorous that you had before in ghostlars of the two-day yoga that's what the ritz explains by the way another very interesting shia la oh we don't have time for this so we got to go right there but i'll just say bikitsu nimrods a lot in eritrea's role which is not in the borders of arizona is it considered like hutzle arts or not so if somebody goes there for yante for for any antis does he keep one day two days and even if we say that's within eric's row is another problem because the adam never got there adam always went to say testimony we know where they went they went to tsvat they went here but they never went to a lot so maybe even if it's within the borders of various roles considered to the i never heard of anybody doing two day yanta over there but it seems like there are a lot of acharyan while they have to do two today in eli i'll just tell you that will never go to allah because he won't leave marriage israel and for other reasons also let shabbos fall out on the seventh day of yantef because of this reason we don't want people to start getting confused and saying does pushover doesn't push off look there is no arava the whole point is the show so bisman is that we don't allow it that's about to fall out they'll do they'll add another date to the to the calendar they'll add another and make sure that shabbos never falls out on seven and robin when he came and all those who left her strong went down to bravo and the roshanim say that that's when there's a lot of confusion in torah and that's why there's a lot of mahlika ikla it's not true it does fall out the seventh day does fall out on shabbos and you do not bring in our rover velocasio why why not why is that rubbing is we have to advertise the fact today is it alright so man lemon along the road have been the tilo who told you what they did in the basement perhaps who said that this picture is right that they let's see if the picture no even in this picture you see that they weren't holding the iron that rubber was just up against them as back maybe that's what happened and if that's what happened then you're not commemorating it today by holding why should you hold the we don't have a miss bear eh so there's nothing to lean it up against there's no chemical and to hold it is not what they did in the middle so that doesn't push your shabbos it says that a little of an aroma could be six or seven days my love killula so puts it together lululeve and arava beneti love since the two words go together it's the same action so just like glue love you're holding it so too arova you're holding maybe and it seems like in the basement they did hold up me the area who told you such a thing okay so okay this is not true lulu if they held i rather didn't know who told you it's not a proof okay i'll give you another proof says it says one time seven times what does times mean if you're leaning around in it's not a time it's not one time it's not two times it's obviously we're talking about hakophas like on seven times going around my lab okay no raya because we're talking about um oh but what about robert malay it says that every day of the six days of yantef they would go around them one time in the final day of yontav seventh day beyond the evening seven times like we do in rabb it's with the love it could be that's why you would ask yourself a question so how come we do akafes and in shanna so we don't hold the arava we should do like a shana rabbo it should hold a bunch of the answer is maybe because of this gemara balulu the richard i'm not exactly clear seems from rashi that's what they the from this it was bill lulov and that's why today we commemorate below love we'll stop over here boys i have a wonderful day [Applause] oh [Music] i'll leave it on for a minute thank you thank you so much where you from from england how you doing your first time on zoom your first time on zoom every day wow i'm out of it i'm pushing out of it sorry mark you you recognize uh kantorovich absolutely i'm a fool okay sorry when did you start yeah like once a month you have to stay home and give the from home so you can see who's here when you're in the basement who's this guy dvr nedwin is he new [Music] tell me that he's new i don't recognize him nathan how are you doing mark how am i with natan did i get that right or no i think so oh okay ruby lebowitz is on for three years i'm not kidding he's on three years i don't know about zoom but on youtube he's out for three years oh gevaldic oh he looks familiar yeah nah just kidding what's his first name did he take a picture remind me who is he what is he what do you say he said you said he's at barry salah is on many years oh got it yeah yeah how are you jack yeah i see you all the time yeah i don't notice you all the time [Music] i got the new camera i got everything everything is good parker shaman's here and i just roll with the lens with the one 100 400 sony lens is that the science kind it's kind snow his father is the famous robin bar park the science you're talking about is my uncle right right did you hear the story you heard the beautiful story from israel goldstein and the lens so the 100 400 lens is at a stack for six weeks so he calls up he calls up b h he says listen uh i have uh this guy i go to shear he he just ordered the lens it's on six week four to six weeks do me a favor make sure it happens so the guy says what's your market sharer's name he says ellie stefanski he says ellie stefanski sathya murkhausen i do this here also next day next day the lens was in my house the next day hello because you can't you can't say it hello you can't say you want to ruin the you want to ruin the surprise on youtube you