Daf Yomi Succah Daf 33 by R’ Eli Stefansky

[Applause] wow we are live in teaneck it's new jersey right right teaneck new jersey unbelievable what an islam thanks for hosting thanks to the rabbi thanks to joel mizrahi padner is that you no that's not you not bad no no no what's your name moving off that rubin off oh that rumor if you have yours i know grandmother's yard side today okay scrap all the food the chinese and everything beautiful stuff it's unbelievable go from place to place wherever i go i see the same people mark ashkenazi yossi klein avi sherman it's unbelievable it's beautiful beautiful turnout hey you know what let me turn this youtube around just to show the islam whoever wants to see what's going on there so we got ushi over there michael clark michael cohen i mean stefanski okay thanks um did i put it back normal messed it up a little bit very interesting just a cute little story yesterday um i didn't have my emails printed out so i decided i went on on my email there's like i don't know 40 emails that are received between friday and monster chavez and i said okay whatever i pick that's the one i'm going to release i picked one and it turns out that the one that i picked it was from uh what was his name peretz uh rappaport paris report and as i finished reading the email he walked into the room i thought it was very interesting from all the people different people from different parts of the world sent the emails and he just happened to walk into the room in barbara nice coincidence if he doesn't finish shots with us he's in big trouble i mean it's a big sign from hashem so lila nish massimo only five sponsors today today's shir sponsored shmuel miller ben pesach in honor of the medical team at greenwich hospital last summer who made my reform so comfortable and rebellion this year for helping me in my recovery anonymously for a forced lima for gold about miriam by dan rubinoff here he is dan grandmother miriam leia bass of romaro and grandfather yaakov and by the way dan rubinoff i should really know his name inside out but i'm terrible with names he's been you've been like in every single city from mary's distraught from my pajamas the cote d'alessio where else for rockaway miami he's been he was in the share of miami you're a stalker but kids are just a stalker um i think i just okay here we go by the rapport family in honor of the outside of esther kaya bass parrots paris by michael bemela in memory of i say but michael in memory of his mother and father and in merit to make it to uma rosh hashanah this year rabbi michael bemela had a fire in his home and his home is gone i believe sounded like i have to speak to him i didn't speak to him yet i want to give him a call uh there's actually a gofundme page it's a it's not a it's not a good matzah over there so it's very we're talking about mega man we didn't realize by wednesday already there was a big thing all right fifth sponsor who's the fifth sponsor ah the kessler family before schlema eliza tova bass esther grona daughter sister cancer patient now diagnosed with cover should have or okay real quickly dear belly felt like a real surprise for me and my wife tyler and attending the chair brokers thank you for sharing to all of us thank you for meeting all of us offered pictures of each and every one that came to introduce ourselves this is supposed to see so many of his hosts i'm not making this up here says aaron mark who was in my class in a certain yeshiva to name a few i see every day on tour anytime youtube to be able to see in person which means the person who was a very cross of a a highlight for me when i was dancing schmack to learn the daf it's taken me on baltimore you know the guy you see with him okay reuben thank you inspired me to learn the daf i enjoy the sheer this clementis i wrapped my lulu here we go we have a couple of uh suggestions i wrapped my lulu in a squeezed out paper towel and it doesn't get moldy a regular towel is too wet also i believe the pronunciation is a baggy too bad this is how we did in yeshiva that's how it is here in manchester uk this works very well for me i don't know how well it would work and i just rolled because i think a plastic bag just shorted basically in a rubber bag and i put one inch of water in the bottom he sent me a picture but i didn't have time to print it out put the whole basket a little bit off and adapt together in the bag making sure the ends of the stems are in the water this way i've managed every year to keep homegrown i rather fresh toast shana rabble okay i like the paper towel one better water if it falls down it gets everywhere don't put the adacim in a wet paper towel put them just in the tin foil and sprinkle here and there in the drops of water and then put them in the fridge you see what's going on here one guy says put in a paper towel and this guy says put in a towel the other guy says put in water this guy says don't put it in it just so now we're confused okay that's like a typical gemara we have four sheathes here you do it every day except of course in shop it's all the best you the herzog the guy who started listening to you for the free gemara to start soaking continues to listen to this really bornstein as well as i have been for the last year and a half despite what some of your crew thinks that truly is a competition you're both highly complementary to each other in my humble opinion otherwise here's a good one and i owe this person or at least his brother a tremendous accuracy he set up a lot with uh the chevy brachas so this is srila yitzkowitz a good high dish it's the long ones i have to skip around there we're late uh it's great to see so many people at the chevy block they've been receiving eight minutes my brother yarchanan that's the guy i have to say thank you to right he helped a lot for the with the chevy brackets he started going all your hoshua erin price on me should i say it again my brother yochanan started going all yahushua erin price on me it's uh it's in the dictionary now you sure impressed me and got me to join mdy after joining the live launch and sharing the five times i immediately felt that i've been part of the hebrew from the start the love and non-judgmental respect everyone shares is nothing short of inspirational story one arab shabbos i was by my in-laws this week and i was showing them pictures of that in zimmer hall and a huge crowd my mother-in-law was so impressed that she turned to my father and said yes you're joining the daff minutes later he's on what's up group story two chavez mourinho and i were in simon zelman see when they made himself sumo for his father's second yard side explained to the lunch guests that was going to the kiddish the kitser by the time they got to the kids she already committed to do the daf this kabu is the most amazing pyramid scheme i've ever seen but unlike a regular pyramid scheme that only generates profits for the new members i will from the new members i believe this one generates profits from old and new alike oh my gosh i can't read this one he says that just like a coin god all khan god all is every day gevalde okay guys ready oh yeah tomorrow you're all invited to the cookie corner in lakewood live share in lakewood that is the place that i was born in i have to go back it's been 48 years i need to go back to lakewood i was not born in the cookie corner but my mother had a cookie from the cookie corner before she went to the hospital she said what time tomorrow 9 30 in lakewood in the cook in the cookie corner free cookies for those who come we got late on him over here all right gevalvic everybody's with a fresh sense of humor wow look at the oil standing room only i should turn around the video look at this it's crazy unbelievable what's going on there in the corner okay very good guys ready so yesterday we're talking about the adas mitri i actually mentioned that i had this hadas mitri and the art says that if most of that das falls apart four out of the seven but you left the three on each level it's good now by the way i received the email of a guy by the name of aaron sitner and he says that he happened to be he a very nice story he wanted to see him khan kanewski so he went on a bus at 1am he got to benebrak and he slept the entire night in the shoal letterman then he snuck into the minion he's a cayenne so he happened to be right next to the reptile cadence and he pulled out his flip phone and this is the picture that he took over kaikanivsky and as you can see in the picture he has a smith tree this hadas right over here is fully loaded seven on each level so what's interesting in this picture is that he's holding he actually is not holding these are hands of two different people i i just covered it with this email massive answering which we learned was not the best in the world what if a fall whatever i guess he held this as other it's like it was a little bit of an issue the kumar says it's okay but it seemed like there was somewhat of an issue what if you have to switch hands it might fall okay but that's not that smith street all right bio three lines down from llama with alef from here you see it's kosher here's a great picture a close-up of adas mistry seven on one level here once again this is the level you put a string here it's all on one level sheeta it has an additional name it's not just called hadas it's called mitzray to shot him rashi does it come from israeli or another but the bottom line is that it has the extra name it has a shim levite and maybe it's not kosher come on now twice points out right away what what do you mean commercial interesting i saw because i ran out of paper very good i ran out of papers i printed rohan kennedy's vision on another but what's on the back i just noticed it now it's this hadas the gemara thought that this should be a hadas a drifa what is it called hirodov and iguara says it's a good hadas because the leaves actually cover the entire branch the reason why we don't use this is because it's poison you don't have anything in the torah that that we use as poison is used for mitzvah so that's tyson but it's called heredif here though if it's hashem levi that's another name and the marta had no problem with that so you see that uh hashem is not a problem why all of a sudden now are we saying that hashem advised the problem like what is the big hydrochastis that we can use hadas mitsuri that has the extra name yesterday it wasn't a problem why is it a problem today okay latoya says it's meaning it doesn't even say a name doesn't say hadas that we have from tradition but we know it fits everything if all the different qualifications that are needed for hadas fit into these words therefore it's a good hadas obvious means it's completely covered it's it's adas so any type of hadas even adas mitri tanura banan yafshu roiv olav most of okay this is the picture of four out of the seven leaves fell off most of the leaves out of the three adasam so it says rashi you have three adasam it looks like this most of the leaves became dried up they were dried up then the shower boy by the island and there are three nice leaves then it's kosher but has to be on the top like in the picture but if it's in the center like this no good by the way i don't know if if i recall correctly it just seems like the top usually goes bad before the bottom no it'll be hard to have everything because the very thin the top are smaller easier to go that's what i recall i might be wrong nicktime roshoi if the top of the hadas is cut off tonight on examination by tomorrow caution what if the top is cut off and then some sort of grape grows on the top basically it repairs itself is that a problem because the problem with nicktom really showed that it's not hudder it's not nice it's not a beautiful hadas it's cut but now repaired itself now if you look at this picture he says that in our days we don't really have um you know like a grape growing on the top it's more of a repair of the branch so you can see it's a little interesting here's the nice hadas and all of a sudden there's a repair that's okay it's kosher it's not a problem of hodder boy we're going to be talking about the concept of for the rest of the almond basically sodium simon came in i think from edges rove unbelievable gevaldic he's the guy that brought four bottles of castell 2003 2004 2005-2006. he's the guy never tasted it but i believe it's okay i think it's gonna be good at the right time all right uh wrong picture goes like this means something is rejected so typically i just pulled this out from a different place drew back in the day when we're learning about the hui you have an animal that's owned by two people partnership and one of the two ruvain designated his part his yellow part as a carbon it's not a good carbon then he goes ahead and step three and he buys his partner's part off of him and he decides to designate his partner's part also he thought he's gonna he's going to fix the problem so he makes the whole thing hectic it's not a carbon why because it was rejected was pushed off at a given moment at this point right over here when he designated his half as a carbon you can't designate half as a carbon so the carbon the half was rejected once it's rejected it's rejected for life another example let's say the the mizbayach that you put the carbon on is missing a tiny stone a little it's not smooth this bath is possible so if you have a carbon that's ready to go into the mizbeach at that moment it's possible it can't you can't you can't be macro because it's known as bear so if you go and you fix them as bail it's too late that carbon that you should throw in the garbage it's pushed off forever ask the gemara do we say this concept by a mitzvah you have a mitzvah that was pushed off for a moment is it pushed off forever can i use that mitzvah after i fix the issue i fixed the problem is it like a carbon here the shiloh that's what we're going to be discussing now is there a dehui in a mitzvah could you push off a mitzvah forever now there's two types of dehui we're going to see both of them one is that it's it was never available and it just became available that's the lighter one that's the easier one this is one that's even worse it was a good mitzvah it was it was pushed off it was a good mitzvah then pushed off and then now it's good good bad good that's the that's worse than the first case where it's just bad it was born bad you made it good now let's see inside but hear me nick time roycho if this hadas had a boo-boo in it it was cut off on the top also by tomorrow bianthus somehow it repaired itself on yantef in other words mao the mitzvah was pushed off as soon as it was the top was cut now you want to repair it and you want to take away the problem do we say the same idea of that we say by a carbon do we say by a mitzvah as well bicarbonate for sure we say we say this idea this concept by mitzvah says gemara what's your question i have a different ray a different suggyo it's not kiso venezuela a bird after you shack the bird or a kaya a deer you have to cover its blood you don't have to cover a cow's blood or a sheep's blood but you have to cover a high knife so if you do caparis a lot of people are yield to the mitzvah then they give them a little dirt and they say the bracha they do kiss here i have a picture of a guy doing kisi hadam in case you want to know what it looks like i guess it's a bigger it's probably a bigger mitzvah to do the kiss down than do kaparas although you'll ask people and they'll say no kapar is much bigger but this is a mitzvah so what happens if you cover the blood kisov in his gala and became uncovered you don't have to recover it you covered it you guys are finished but if the wind came and covered it threw some dirt on it and we're going to see in a second in the millisecond it's talking about that it became uncovered you don't have to cover something that's covered when do you have to recover something that the wind covered when it became uncovered again so the wind covered the blood then the wind came or whatever happened and it became uncovered now you you have to cover it is if it didn't become uncovered you don't have to win this enough when it became uncovered again why do you have to cover it with dirty there's no mister for you look at this blood when the wind comes and covers it at that moment you are potter from covering it so your mitzvah went away now your mitzvah re-emerged when when it became uncovered it's too late that's the bemidjis your mitzvah was rejected you don't have achieve you cannot invent a nuchi of afterwards what do you see from this that you could invent that by a mitzvah once the mitzvot comes back again you could do it there's no rejection by mitzvahs so asking why you why are you asking questions about a hadas that got cut off and then every it it healed itself i said that allah by blood there's no reason to bring any conscious fraud says no you can't prove anything from blood well like the republic didn't know himself he wasn't sure we don't know him did he say a clear cut halacha that there's no rejection by mises at all even by blood in other words you could go ahead and do it sorry by legenda over here by lulav let me just look at rashi real quickly and not and certainly by the blood you would have to even the humor the hormone means that you would have to go ahead and cover the blood likula i could use uh uh that's like that yeah so likula means i have an adas that for a minute it wasn't really for a mitzvah i couldn't use it and then all of a sudden it grew a little bit and it covered up the cut now i can use it the fact that i can use it i don't have to go to the store buy another hadas what is that a homura kula that's a cooler i could use that das even though it was pushed off and rejected so the question is can i use this idea of indirections even likula even to use that das or maybe it's only the karma that i'm high to cover the blood for a second time to be mahm is not a big kuns but to be mako is a much bigger thing if i could if i use this idea this concept there's no rejection by misses at all no matter what a mix is never rejected so i could use hadas that healed itself even though it's a coulomb or perhaps rappapa says that you use this is only the hormone only where it doesn't hurt us to do it so you'll cover the blood again not a big deal but the cooler in it i can't i can't use this hadas taku interesting that the word taku over here is not 100 accurate usually take a means we have to wait until mashiach comes in fact we're going to see that the gemara is poisoned at least half of the question anonymous base says perhaps this is it says that if you have a bunch of berries on your hadas you could remove them and make your rosenbergs from muncie all the way i understand the island comes to comes to restaurants all the time from us yeah true not true so we had these berries on the hadas there's no chairs no chairs so come sit next to me okay wow joel what do you think this is you think this is chicago 20 people going to show up anyway so you have verizon adas you cannot use the hadas it's not harder so what do you do you take the berries off but if it's already on tv and i'll take the berries off why can't you take the berries off the tacoma you're not going to fix the clay so what happens if you took the berries off aniantov apostle so i try to make it a little simpler it's not a heart so yeah very very simple actually but what we're going to see is there are three things going on here and if you take away any one of these three things then you're gonna come up with one idea if you have all three in line then it's okay what do we have we have the idea that we're talking about yes is it can a mitzvah be rejected then we have another thing this is the only picture i whatever do you have to bundle up the three minimum the lulu of hadassah and the third idea is the idea of task of elimination you already recall that it's a sir to be meaning create a cavity in a haystack because what you're doing you're not putting this on this was there before you actually created the cavity that's where is that halaqa said by asuka because it says so that that's where we learned allah the question is do we compare al-lulev and adassim the whole thing to asuka can we learn this idea of tassavalemena by alulov now if i remove one of these things if i say that i do not learn from asuka then this whole pyramid falls down and if i say that alola doesn't need an egg it then the whole thing falls down and if i say that you don't need egghead the the so let's see inside that's the whole sugar really the gemara is going to start off saying perhaps this is the machis says no this is the bucklages or you know what this is the macholicas i can't prove that this top guy is the macholicus because there's other ways to learn the machlaics maybe not like it says do i need an egg at all or maybe look like it says do i learn from from a sukkah so i don't have a proof that this is the makha the mauryan wants to say layman the first words les makitanoi perhaps this idea that we're discussing now whether misses are rejected forever or not i think we're going to say no we could be titled something completely different maybe that is this or maybe they'll call you this says possible okay so you have this much like is if you went ahead and you pulled off the berries on yante can you use that hadas says this middle guy everybody agrees you don't have to bundle them up vincent's anybody say everybody agrees you have to finish then i don't learn from sukko over here only by sokka says that's lemonade not by lola so i don't learn my lab so then what is the macholic is if i don't have these two things the man the puzzle is the one that says that you cannot use this hadas even though you pulled off the berries but when you pull them off too late because as young came in the minute uh ski or whatever it takes whatever you want to call it that minute your address was possible because it had a bunch of berries then on yount if you went ahead and you pulled the berries off yesterday it was already rejected you cannot fix a mitzvah that was already rejected maybe that's the mach like and the one that says that it's kosher this and that's even though you pulled the berries off on chapels is that such a thing when it comes to the mitzvah there's no so so what if it came in the chambers came young came and there were berries i fixed it on chavez says perhaps always perhaps i don't know but maybe i'm going to be done maybe everybody says came in and there's a berry it's not a big deal i can fix it so what is the machine though is down here do i compare a little of to a goddess the idea of taj luminosity why because now you have to say like this very positive very nice rashi points out when do i make the bundle i have to make i have to i have to do egg it i have to tie my adacement rubbers together when do i do that i must do it before yantiff why because i can't make a knot on yantev you have to make knots we're going to see in a second you have to make two nice knots so i have to do it before you octave i'll do it before yantev so now i have a hadas inside my knot which is puzzle and then i took off the berries is just like making a cavity after i have this already on top i'm taking off the berries and all of a sudden i create a new hadas yeah you're holding some of you would give me this look what is going on here it's complicated stuff not complicated easy you have a dash that's puzzled inside the egg it's already tied up so it's already too late to do anything now i'm making the hadas kosher by removing the berries it's too late it's already in the egghead that's what we're talking about it says do you compare hadas to soka that's exactly the question that is the question exactly what you're saying even though it doesn't say that do i compare hadassem to asuka if i compare it then it's a problem if i don't compare it it's not a brown that's exactly what i guess you hold like the other mandala giveaway why i don't know that i think the opposite has been also should be by everything not just by sokka and we say it by titties we say by a lot of things that's when also goes into the whole time you can't we learn by sentences you can't just snip it afterwards and say oh it's a you have to create we had all suggest we had all the fight i don't know i don't remember what i think that everywhere but i could be wrong as usual you see the words that is exactly the question a different question not the third thing but the middle thing do you have to make a good what's the difference because if you don't have to bundle it so even though you bundled it and it still has grapes you can remove the grapes on yantef you're not creating anything because the bundle is nothing you don't have to do a bundle the bundle is time for for for beauty and it's says you don't have to bundle it review this is the one that says you must bundle it my time with the review though why does review say you have to bundle it you see this this is a bundle of azov this is what you brought on the first carbon pace so this is what you brought together with the carbon peso and it says over there except just like this in the picture you see it's a bundle it's tied together i'm kind of good so too you have to tie the hadas to the lord hold of this or somebody doesn't hold the xero shava the the simple explanation is because xero shava comes by tradition and they did not have that tradition they cannot just make up exercise because somebody else said so if you view the holds like there is this thing maybe he learned it from israeli we did not hear from our rebbe we cannot say it allah we had this exact a word for word so if so what does it mean the surprise that says there's a mitzvah to to to tie up your lulav together with us either it's a or you don't have to what does it mean it's a mitzvah so it's zero by tying it you don't accomplish a thing um there's a mitzvah and we have to take this to heart there's a mitzvah in the torah to beautify all your mitzvahs all your mitzvahs your little love your esrig your sukkah your shabbos meal and i want to say i don't know if it's true you're tara you're def yo me beautify daffy me how do you beautify that you me you go to a good cheer no you do hazara you do hazara you add another one here give me this give me this the bomb okay hey michael come here come here mike mike come here i wanna get him here michael but the bar machado safer is here come come michael no look there's a lot of work there's a lot of work has pictures everything how long have you been with us since broadcast beautiful and oh you want to see a real safer he's much harbor this is his father's father was the most giache in tells cleveland tremendous tremendous goddess and they just came out with a safer destroyer for the present anyway by the way michael i was by my sister-in-law's house and i had uh my brother's house and i had your book in the car so and i saw my sister-in-law outside i said listen take this book inside and run inside say rafael rafael look what i found in the bookstore so she comes running in she goes rafael you're not gonna believe it she played the game was beautiful and he's like what i'm scrolling guys what is going on here and this is the greatest book ever it took him five minutes and he's reading every word he first he flipped it over it's unbelievable then all of a sudden he says okay anyway it worked great says oh now i just want to point out something that i was a little shocked to see this i have to do more research i'm just telling it to you to throw a wrench into everything that you guys know we're talking about if it's a mitzvah to be again not mentioned so um like the mordechai do we show them talk about this that you have to make two knots so the big question is that i never thought about until today what about akashika how's that a not you put ya ravi and it comes right out so some actually say it's no good the misha brewer brings that it's okay but it seemed like that it's not the the best no i i never thought it's even an issue though everybody in the world use the kaiser claw inspire them don't use it ah very nice because fire them go according to they have to tie too they they don't use it at all it's puzzle beautiful oh i'm in a spidey show now so now i know you know maybe i'll say because mr says okay but it doesn't seem like it's the best idea another thing that i saw and this i really want to look up more is that it's brought down that even if you use the kaiser claw you should make sure that the bottom stems of the robust nadas and touch each other and the lulav they shouldn't be they shouldn't be a hatsitsa a complete catizo so that means my beautiful kajuk i was talking about is probably garbage i don't think any it doesn't touch on the bottom but anyways you should make sure it touches as i state look i'm not a rav i'm not passing i'm just telling you something that i saw today it says you should make sure that everybody agrees you have to make sure that the bottom stems at least touch each other the lula of the adas and the ravas because the khashoggi itself is fine next no you take off the the nuts those are those those the nuts this is i found this gemara very interesting because refrigerator says something in the name of rav rabino god rashi says it means rav the famous rav again rav the first these these are grapes these um what are they called berries these berries that are growing on the hadas the the only time that we have a problem is that if they're in one place but if they're all over the place like this two three different places kosher you hear what refrista says a whole statement that the gemara says never existed i find that very hard to understand to me it's hard to understand this is what rav rabbin agatha said hashem should help him the problem is if the berries are in one place like this but if the berries are in two places like this no problem oh my lair of uh so son-in-law rafa says that i'm on base what happened it's like a leopard it's all spotted it's ugly it's worse if it's in one place it's great in three four places that should be a problem we have to flip it we have to say something completely different it's such a bomb question that it can't be the wrath said it of apostle um he didn't mention black at all all of a sudden his statement was about black berries if they're black no good avalanche of iroquois it's one of the i don't know if we have other places like this in shots that it's like it didn't even start it's not even the same sentence not in the same topic somewhat in the topic of berries but not what he said okay now we're not talking about mccoy mice we're talking about color now if they're green berries it blends in then it's kosher i don't know guys that's who the culture now we just turned to let me go on base sponsored by them the white helm group for all those who need shidduchim refuse and yeshua's please join tehillan.8mindaff.com omrap yep yeah yeah it is other that that is the issue it's not beautiful but if it's green it's beautiful or yeah it doesn't take away from the beauty omara papa a moisky is damion red berries like these guys are like black hi damn shahor odom it says that there are five types of blood one of them is black because black indeed is red it's just something happened to it so you see it's from the same family red and black is the same family melo red grapes or red berries are like the blackberries and they are possible in miata if you remove the berries then the hadas kosher the matino emas when did this happen they if it happened before you put it together you you bundled it up shito what is the dish of course it doesn't have berries anymore hello it happened afterwards if it happened after you did the egghead so this is dokham khara it never had a chance it never it wasn't a moment in this hadas life that it was kosher it was always and then you fixed it which is as i explained all in the beginning a better step than if it was available it was good mitzvah bad good good bad good is worse than never available for the mincem like in this case here you have a case where that's grew with berries so it was never available for the mitzvah and then you put it into an egghead you tied it up to your lulu and then you remove the berries so it's so if so tiffs and you see it's okay it's okay we said we went through the whole heisman if he didn't put it in a bundle then what's the problem if he put it he already tied it it's still good why is it good you have a case of dokham khara you have a hadas that was never kosher you already put it you ready tied it to the lulav and it's kosher if you remove the if you remove the berries so you see from here clear cut that off it doesn't push it off forever no it happened after you tied it and before jantef before you entered because of it take it together it's nothing you didn't do a mitzvah you were preparing for a mitzvah preparing for a mitzvah didn't do anything you didn't you didn't say the so you didn't start the mitzvah yet so then i could remove the berries and once synthetic comes in that's when the mitzvah starts but just because i tied it before your aunt doesn't do anything matami and you cannot remove the berries what if you do remove the berries caution that is postured in the words it says do not remove the berries you shouldn't remove the berries onion why what's the reason you can't remove berries take a monaco thicken clay so so it's a clay what is it what does thick and clean mean i'm not going to remove the berry because i've removed the berry then i have got a dust which is a good clea but it's a good idea because if it's not a good address then i would be able to remove the berry because i didn't do anything yeah i could i'm not going to fix a click that means it's a click that means that if i did fix it it remains a cli that i could use because if i can't use it then i didn't fix anything so however licked on my caution obviously it's caution so then the ashraemas when exactly did these berries become black elimination metamol if they were black before dokhmekaru then it never had it never stood a chance when you have to came in it was already puzzled so tip should mean i can prove from here you see that i'm allowed to i'm not allowed to but if i pull the berries off it becomes kosher even though from as the other came in it was already black it was there ain't no good el dash will be no what happened was the berries became black aniantis so then nero it was a good hadas venitra then became bad it became apostle hadas why because it became a blackberry shema near one of the two things we're going to be able to prove here and that's what the gemara says you're right we're able to prove one of the two either we're going to be able to prove dokgami cara that the berries were black before yantif and i'm allowed to not allowed to it's us but if i do i fix this hadas or i'm going to prove even worse i'm going to prove that the barrier became black onyantif in other words it was a good at das erviantev as the end of came in i'm sorry aziz came he was good at that so it was nero it was good nitro it became black it became puzzle and then i fixed it illegally but i fixed it so it's nira nitranira it's good there's no even in the worst case for me cara they became black aviantiff so at least okay so if you came black and young then i'm gonna be able to prove one one thing so i'm going to be able to prove the easier case at least one i'm going to be able to prove that if this hadas was never ready to be had because it was always black before and i fixed it by removing it which i shouldn't have but i did anyways i fixed it so if so what it says that i don't know the answer i only don't know one thing i don't know if nira nitronira by mitzvos remains pushed off forever reject whatever but i do prove from this braiser that when it comes to mitzvah i don't push off a mitzvah if it was never available if the hadas was black the berries were black so this hadas was never really further mitzvah it was [Music] throughout its entire life when young came in i and i fix it then it's a good fixing it's considered you don't push it off in that case the other case that was it was a good hadas it went bad and then you made it good near and it's gonna that that i don't have proof for so one thing you see that a mix is a little different than a carbon we started off saying the sugya that when it comes to carbon once the carbon is pushed off it's pushed off for life but when it comes to mitzvah it's not pushed off for life okay the im miatan culture no we said this because smack in the middle of the page almost maybe a couple lines below the middle how could you remove a berry on yonder when you're fixing the clay according he picked the berries because he wanted to eat them he was desperate and rebel ezra shimon this is the famous rival elizabeth shimon and his father is the famous rip shipment in mr chavez famous throughout chad's between them where's that picture every time what what's the picture anybody know the pictures who said bench the bench if you want to move a bench from point a to point b and you might create a groove in the ground rimship says it's okay why because you don't intend to make grooves in the ground you're not a farmer you're just trying to move a bench and it's heavy so it's davar miscavin something i don't have intended for is okay on shabbos so over here also i don't have intent to fix that dash i have intent to eat berries i'm just picking berries you want to pick a grape off a cluster of grapes so i'm picking grapes grapes and all of a sudden i'm left with this uh whatever it's called okay and that that happens to be a mitzvah that's fine that's double sheamus calvin ask the gemara about bible diamond to a lot of people get nervous when they hear this very very simple secretary almost means the way you read it is secretia if i'm going to cut chop off an animal's head the almost he's not going to die 100 is going to die so if i pluck the berries off one hundred percent maya is going to become kosher so i cannot say that rip shipment says in that case that it's milter you can't say oh dove shaming scavenge i had no intent what do you mean you had no intent 100 you're going to have a kosher attack then it's also if 100 percent this this kid is going to create a furrow in the ground he's going to dig then it's awesome so the gemara says here unbelievable svara unbelievable if you create a furrow you create a cli on chavez you create a cup so there's no way out of it you created this i didn't but i didn't have intent i didn't have intent i just pushed the button in the factory and i wanted to to scrape my finger and push the button and now came a cup but but you you knew that if you push the button this is gonna come out it's awesome hadas is different kumar says here very very interesting thing hadas is only a cli when i need it hadas by itself if i don't need it that's the sheet of rashi tells us argues if i don't need it then it's not a clique it's just a bunch of leaves it happens to be i have enough in my in my lulu i don't need this at all all i need are the grapes we're talking about a mitzvah here hadas is not it's not a physical thing it's not a clear not a klee you can't tell me you you ask an anju is this a khalil laugh at you well it was a bunch of leaves it's not clique oh my you need it for your lulu so if you need it for your lulu if it became you you fix something but if you don't need it for your little you can fix anything it's it's hard to understand i understand it's it's a it's a deep lumberjack thing twice says but at the end of the day you fix it for somebody else somebody else could grab i don't know what fight that's what the gamora says there think about this far as a very interesting spark here this picture happens sometimes to us what do you do this became undone now we said according to this fight you have to do two nuts what are you going to do you just like a gyarado like a house it doesn't wraps it around and then sticks it in sticks one end in right that's enough that's a good show eric van what's the problem let him make a bow like a shoe like tie your shoes comes out easy a lot of time your shoes in chapters why it's it's much stronger than just putting in one end and it's not a real it's not a question it comes out easy the reason i can't do that is because it goes to contribute you see that it's not motor to make an aniva you wouldn't be able to tell you should contribute though because that's considered a regular knot as the gemara can't be reviewed according to yehuda it's not enough just to wrap around review that says it you need to tie a lulu together with that and that's what he said it's reviewed and it says this so how's it enough to just do a good of a yarek which is nothing but and he doesn't know like review though he holds that lulu so you don't need a real egg you don't need a real tight knot but he holds um [Music] right he holds like a view though that that nodding it the reason why he says just do it like a yaric and don't make a bow because he holds like ruby huda that a bow is a real knot and it's also doing chops but it doesn't hold that you need a negan you don't need to you don't he just doesn't want his uh his aurovision and then it doesn't fly apart so just wrap it around and stick it in nicely should we do the mission let's do the mission arabic zulu of vegeta we know these already because they learned it twice already we learned it once by lulav and once by adas same exact allah by arova if it's stolen or dry it's possible they worshipped it or the whole city or 51 of the city does have a desire you have to burn everything so we have a problem you're missing them this year how many does rob have to be three talking you don't have three talking because it has to be burned nick damn russia if the top part of now rashi just points out the obvious why does the mishnah repeat the same exact thing that we said by same thing by lulu the answer is because each one has allah you don't have by the other so they had to repeat you're right the first few allahs are the same but then afterwards we come into nifty to allow that we had if the i bet you we have pictures of this digimon says we should make a bow tie arabi aveisha sula we know what that looks like it's maya rova every year nick damn roy shawi this you have a lot they sell this in the store they have to be careful that it shouldn't look like this that the top part shouldn't be snipped off you make sure that there's a nice little leaf growing there a little red bud whatever it is but not just snipped okay very important very positive some of the leaves are missing okay safa looks something like this he says okay posh it's not it's not a sulu camusha if it's slightly dried out like this like so vishnu should mix this a lot some of the leaves fell off we shall we're going to see what the kamaru says what about is shero here we go just a few of the the official mishna was sponsored by official reforce name of four okay fine we'll stop over here have a wonderful day rabbi say thanks for joining it's been such a pleasure mama thanks for the physique seriously you