Daf Yomi Succah Daf 07 by R’ Eli Stefansky

the boy says the old side of the ish foreign for my wife undergoing knee surgery by michael bemela you're going to love this even scream louder than that in memory of his mother figure bastion and father from spring valley new york dear belly there are no words to explain to the schmuck you're putting into the shears for a litvak they have such a smack like a horse i want to warn you in advance so you don't see any cold cure against the shear you didn't succeed i was waiting i'm waiting for that you know that's michelle from your automotive listens and learns that torah anytime for quite a few months now it's really adler i thought this is a tremendous yoga practice tell me what you think good good morning rebelli i already feel connection although we never met my mother grew up on 6548 st louis avenue in lincoln with illinois so first of all that's a couple of houses down from my cheverus house what's amazing is i got this email yesterday and we we basically bought a house in lincolnwood directly directly across the street from that house 65 53 this is 65 48. the cop what's going on here okay i'm just just throwing it out there her maiden name is schnell her father's jack chanel curious if you knew them my uncles are david and tanishnell where's where is he show yeshua you hear this david and tony schnell vada the very very famous in chicago i've been trying to keep up with kabura but it's not easy when you don't have an actual shyness of the magazine but ever since i listened to your interview with yaakov everything changed you're trying to give him tiago blanket to join but he said he's doing kingdom secretary myself i'm doing it but as i'm doing sokka i figured it's a perfect time to join i didn't even wait i started on yuma like you said don't wait until the mistake is finished start now thanks for sending me the art scroll i'm still trying to figure out when to listen to shirt it's 12 15. it's a little late thank you rebel he's not in chicago he's from clifton new jersey thank you rebellion for making learning fun again a viktor weiss wow from aaron sidner shalom aleichem if you have something to say come over here and say it i don't know what you're screaming over there what are you saying what is he saying do you have any in there no i didn't think so somebody's started definitely okay rebecca you should all know somebody that started what i have no idea okay show me later rebelli i want to share a story with you that happened with my review of from clint kaufman he told us that he found the safer yeshiva and he had a cache on some point and wrote it into the margin a few days later he sees a response to his casual written under the note this correspondence goes on a few times he never saw who was writing the answers one night he gets a call that the shiva farak way it's the shiva faraqui alarm went off at 2 am so he went to investigate he found your father riding in the safer he was the anonymous writer that is my dad yeah what are you saying you have an announcement to make what so why are you screaming over there come here say say your announcement well oh you said he loves me okay thank you appreciate it wow i'm touched straight for screaming out from the back though um i'm sure if he was the machop of the savior he's a lot of time here this is from a broomy lightman he's a speech pathology pathology in lakewood pathologist i wanted to express my of course the toy for wonderful that you give and i truly feel that would be very difficult to go with the grind of the daily death if i did it any other way my 13 year old daughter sees me many times watching a shirt in the evening and she says that ellie stefanski is your new bestie teen lingo for best friend i also wanted to give thanks again to the sponsors my yuma gumbara i have to say that your motto of catch up later was right on target for me i finished himself a few days late the only problem is that in my case hoyte niskar because i get to make a scene in the nine days i believe that some say this is one more we still have time revoir one more okay first of all i want to thank you so much for inviting cheer this must take hours to prepare it's extremely low spending clarity excluding pictures perhaps as i i was curious if one may or should answer oh man to the break of shahakal do you make on your water while watching the sheer zooming you know that i'm not a rough i don't know anyway it's time to get to the daf ah shimmery hex brooklyn new york and then i got another one yesterday rebellion on occasion i see you drink water without a broccoli and something's with why come on sometimes i drink without a broker shall be saying oh man when it's just seeing you making more the answer is that because people don't know if they say brokenness i try to make the bracket before shear starts that's why you see me drink without a broccoli i don't know i'm not a rob i i do i'm about boss that does that for me i don't know anything about anybody want pens oh okay boys i you probably are wondering what goes on up there in that booth over there i've never been up there until last night you're not gonna believe it this is what goes on in the booth up there it's pretty intense here's the audio board here's that new uh joystick the thousand dollar joystick it's amazing piece and they're operating two cameras and you have to know how to my kids are they they feel cool when they push the buttons it's like on tv you push camera one camera two or going to karen he has this mouthpiece over here and he's talking to the guy that's sitting right next to him it's unbelievable and and if you look closely right in this box right over here you could see my cabrusa aravidikramer who's also on the screen but this is what they see this is how they see me hi guys doing up there it's unbelievable all right great oh we didn't do a good morning rabbi's side from from the kaiser do we have that sounds not good oh that one yeah i know so what but it's good to do anyways this is the picture of the queso sem one of them it's a beautiful beautiful gathering okay today also happens to be one of the records i don't know there's over 20 different pictures here that i had to print out so hold on tight says the gemara we're holding on that volume on the base all the way in the bottom three lines from the bottom where do you put this step up so we have a big macho i guess here you don't really need the pictures you can just look in the side of your yamaha you have it pretty much all cleared up on my wrap my middle canelyte so picture number one is you take this stuff out this brown piecing just put it by one wall so it creates a third wall and this is how we understand everything is beautiful oh my lay rav khanoveravassi lerav the two of them told rav top of that so you can see in the picture in rashi or you can look over here it's in color i just put the blue line here if you put a little bit on the angle it creates a triangle and it closes up your wall if you just put it out straight then it's not closing anything it's pretending to close one wall over here it closes it off creates a triangle which is not a problem there are some that say you shouldn't really make a suck out a triangle but of course you have here at least the zion zion or that whatever the shears with inside over here and it closes it off another shot that's just on one of the two walls but straight it's ki-elu it's a third wall but it's only one tefl this it's bent in on an angle creating a line here this one is bent to meet the other corner like it's uh in line with this blue line that i threw on here that's that's connected roy star the other one is that it's bent this way it's it's in a straight line pretend here this red line over here that's what it's following that's the first shot similar but not right not really but shasi grav according to wamp shot he didn't like what they were saying at all excuse me he ignored them another challenge tar over here is put it in a place that it's not touching anything and it could close off the two gaps an imaginary line so to speak hilariously or whatever going from here to this you put it right in the corner that's not touching anything that's another shot according to the maram excuse me in rashi in rashi i don't i don't think so don't think so he certainly didn't have those straight straight lines like that he was his side was a little cr next round it was made the levee okay like the first shot we had in modern bay mid russia and that's how they pass in there we don't pass it like that but that's how many american pasches you do put it attached to one wall in the not as a triangle but as a square i'm simon i'm holding this up for the next chat don't don't worry representative invite show up so this is a regular and there's a laughing tough out which means slightly the fingers don't touch each other like somebody that smiles and laughs and it's a larger tether so you take a larger teva um and you place it three twelve away from the wall so what do you have total you have a three a little bit less than three gap and that is closed in with allah beloved plus one tapax so we have fort falcon is the majority of a seventh you're supposed to have a seventh wall now you have the majority of it and that's how we use the one you want to know how to use the one tava you don't take that one to have i can put it on the wall you take the one and you maximize its its ability that one to have i could create a fourth have a huawei why not do that some of the difference is an alleyway that i don't have the picture here we had it the other day in those days used to go into the alleyway basically according to rashi not according to this according to rashi it's a mavimo foolish it's open on both ends so this is the alleyway and you drive through here you walk through here so the point is it's a sukkah that has two walls very good walls but they're not touching each other they're not on right angles it's not a l shape it's just two walls that are separated it's kosher but you still need one tafak what do you do with it he has four options here he could put it on any one of the four sides and here in this place you put it right over here on this use the tavern over here so you have one wall and a tava and opposite it you have another wall the kiddush that this works i don't think so where you don't have the two walls touching each other and it looks something like this you make a nice serious four teva piece of whatever would in this case and you distance it three away from the corner a little tight drop less than three so now we have a total of seven four plus the gap a three is seven in the melo we have a full-fledged wall in the case of a mother this is not a case of a regular sucker that has two walls and we're trying to figure out what to do with the tava this is specifically for the case that you have two walls that are not touching each other um away from the wall all of a sudden now we need a serious piece of wood that sports wide something funny over there where the two walls are l-shaped they're touching each other so it's enough to use one tava haka the luggage needs what happens what would you think we're saying we're talking about so what if you have a sukkah and in the sookie you have your nice candelabra it costs a thousand dollars two thousand whatever silver costed it and sitting there in your sukkah and it's open it has only two walls and a tether and you're in the middle of 13th avenue as soon as you turn around so he's going to and walk away is that a kosher sukkah because perhaps a sukkah that somebody could just grab your stuff and leave that's not a good sukkah i'll give you a hint this is that says there's a mordechai region who says that if you have a sucker that's open like that and you you're scared to sleep you're in middle of a street and people are going to walk by and poke you in the middle of the night they're going to do stuff to you so it's not kosher the sukkah is not caution so what about a sukkah that you can steal from so there was that said it's the same halacha there's no connection when you're sleeping you're really scared so it ruins your sleep it's not a good it's not a good schluff and if you can't sleep it's not a good sukkot any sugar you can't sleep in is not a good took even for eating but over here you worry that somebody might take so stay you'll stay there that's not a reason to say that a sukkah is possible that's what the ramos says okay [Music] says you know what you do with that fact you make a doorway out of the out of the tv you take the tafak you split it in half like a half and a half let's see if i have a good picture of it have it have a hover here have it level over here and you make a tsurasa pesach like this the entire wall okay forget this part over here i don't know if i have a better picture sure so you take the again what do you do with the tether he says you put it over here he says you you put a three comes up and says no take the tie back cut it in half take a saw cut the different half now you have a half a device over there have it over put something on top you make a whole frame there's nothing like a source of when we were learning aravind surisa passa was the strongest way to make it in arabic it's a lot better than allah a lot better than cairo et cetera okay so betsan we have three shitais in rava what did rava really mean the only way this this could be motors if you do at sura omarov and some say in his name vinnie maybe teresa not only do you use one tefl if you want you don't you don't have a tefl piece of wood it's hard to come by wood is expensive you have two half it's i have eights for you either you could use your type of piece of wood or you use two half and create a surprise out of it you have a choice in the third cheeto what does that mean you need both let's see if i have here so you can now meet tourist peso you take a tour of pesach and you take in addition to the tourism pacific and you put it three away so they have four two plaza tsuru now you're golden yeah fourth welcome over here plus it source a peso of three trojan or whatever and now you have a serious wall you're combining a tava with the tourism the that takes up here we go by the way i said it already twice since the beginning of september because it's that results the art one two and a little bit here that's a hug the results will save on his yard side i saw an answer because you know we're learning so now we're learning about walls although he said how do you stick in a little bit of a smarter thing for the nine days says he says what are we dabbing for bonnie three things she says when you dive in there's a difference between these three things you have bottom children high life and missionaries paranasal he says when you dive in make sure you dive in for your children and health schneider qasim those have to be kimo sarah the shlishas with the messiahs don't worry about it because brocco will take care of you don't don't bother and if the sahara comes along and says listen i need paralysis and i'm not doing well what are we going to do he says then you have to make it sure to remind you that we're going from this world to that world we're only here temporarily it's not a big deal copper and learn tire make sure you have children make sure you have help and then i was remember reminded i spoke to rabbi schoenberg last night it was a murder story this is for the nine days to cover the nine days in 1190 there were 150 jews that were trapped in a palace in york in england here in this palace right over here the clifford palace 1190 still here still exists the guys were chasing them and they they they made a deal with the guy over here with the the head and they he let them in and then he turned on them a whole night so they kicked him out but everybody's screaming outside we got to kill the jews kill the jews and they realize and they said if you come out and you baptize we'll let you live otherwise forget about it you know what they did they made a bracha al-qaeda and they shifted each other they all committed suicide 150 hidden in 1190 it's documented story nobody sleeps in the the town york you will not sleep there if you live in england right or something no i have to fight it's like the creme de la berry after 500 years it passes new so you're marrying another woman really oh you don't even step into york the island doesn't go to new york fine you don't even show that picture okay the earth says so he yields it with the torah of the al-shafa okay beautiful ravashi ashkekher he did two things interesting you know people took this uh seriously i guess the wood was expensive whatever to make a whole a whole uh wall was difficult so you use the tafak and the tsuru pesa or maybe he stopped he wanted to show his children in addition you do a little bit of a tourism bam you have a a kosher sukkah which really consists of two walls [Music] there's a there's a whole there's a three-way machine that's what robert said i hold like the lashing that says you need a tava and the suspects okay two walls that are seven falcon and one wall that's a tefl for a total of three walls on my rover the shabbos this is an amazing amazing allah on shabbos this job is coming up if you carry from your house into a room that consists of two walls and which is the middle of just a rabbit you're over it's a raisa you're carrying from rishi yahood international two walls and a tabak don't do anything for you on chalice but if it's shabbos sukkas one time a year this shabbos in the middle of sukkah it is a good rush you believe it if it's a sukkah and it's a room and i'm telling you you could be your to mr sukko with this room for you so all of a sudden it flips into shabbos even though all other 51 weeks of the year it's not a russian amazing it's a wild allah vaccine since we consider this a full-fledged wall have a different lining it dictates that it's a true wall so if it's a true it's a wall for shabbos only the shabbos of the year i'll prove to you the opposite success so it goes like this this wall works if there's less than a three theft gap between each piece of wood now question when shabbos is a halacha they can't have porous meruba you can't have the open space be more square footage than the standing space so is this kosher on travis yes why oh not maybe that is the shot because it's leveled lovehood bridges the gap this is considered completely closed and the mela it works [Music] now another allah the same thing we learned this in ireland it doesn't matter what way you go you see this a lot people have these kind of circus today they sell them a little bit like you know you put these ropes because of the halacha that the wall can't sway so they they sell you this tight string and that doesn't move at all you put it every less than three going this way [Music] okay so here it goes look at this sucker right over here so they did a very nice job i don't know if you can see the the red everything in red obviously is closed off everything in yellow is open if you do the math here because this wall is completely open there are 18 ammo that are open and 16 armor that are closed so this is a good example of a parrot's meruba alaimen there's more open area than closed area on shabbos this sukkah is not a good makita this is not a rush on sukis it is so what should the be that on shabbos sukkas this should work this should be a good sucker why because since it's a good sukkah on every other day so it should be a good sukkah and chavez you're right that on a typical shabbos it doesn't work but on the shabbos of sukkos it should work but that it doesn't say that here what does it say my love says you say rashaba is the sukko asuka that's what it says here it says that there's a bigger human chavez than sukkos and that this sukkot does not work on the shabbos in the middle of the yacht of sukkahs why because it's part of its miraculous empires does not work on shabbos you can't say miguel according to rava we should say miguel since this is a perfect sukkah for all other days of the week in the weekdays so this should be a good sukkah on chavez koitesh in the middle of sukkah and it says the hurry it's not lo you didn't know the stamp shot says robert backed up it's not true you're right the shabbos of sukkos this does work all the brides was saying is that a typical shabbos this week shabbos that this wouldn't be a good machita but sukkos it is a good mechanism so you see that there's a difference in shabbos let's do the reverse if you have two walls just two walls what do you have to do in order to make the cigar crusher you have to add one tava not just the fat okay and what if you have two walls on shabbos how do you carry in that place it's called the mavoi what do you do to make a mavi mutter you put a lucky how big is the lucky a mashup there's no shirt so now you see that chavis is more cal than sukko so why don't we say that should also add that as not only are we going to take the the coolest of sukkah but we're also going to take the coolest of shabbos we took the cooler of sukkah saying that you could also use a hearths mirabella we took the kula of sukkah yeah so let's take the cool of shabbos and say that all you need is a lucky mashup you don't need a tvx you don't need a full fist you can do a little tiny sliver of wood and that should also work so here's the picture here's an open movie and he puts rock on top all you need to do even though these two walls are not touching each other all you need to do is put a tiny little piece of wood right over here called the lucky you don't need a full fledge so what's the question the question is so why don't you put it in the bryce say if i'm going to use a kula of sukko ancha bis sukkas in other words i have a wide open sukkot it has air everywhere it's 51 percent here and 49 percent wall typically on shabbos that's not a good room that's not but because that chavez fell out in the middle of the antivirus it's a good it's a good wall so that's cool number one number two if i create a sukkah min out of two walls instead of typically having to use a full tava i can use a sliver of wood that's barely noticeable it's called the lachin that works since it works on a regular shabbos in the middle of the year for people to carry in the modeling it also works on sukhos says the gemara you're not going to like the terror so much i don't like you're 100 right but there's no need to to write it why hashtag if shabbos if you're over on shabbos you get misa skela there's nothing worse than getting stoned to death sukkah snow he didn't eat in the sukkah i ate outside of the sukkah they're not going to give me uh miso for that so it's much more hummus shabbos and i'm willing to take the big homura shabbos and say that typically you can you can't use this as a as a mojito because it has too much air but it's on circus the cow makes it into a good majitsa so certainly killed the cold gain then of course if it's a good lucky the lucky works in shabbos of course it's going to work on sukkos there's no need for me to say it unbelievable i know you're not going to like it huh shaking his head it doesn't like it okay can't win them all what are you saying so that suk is more hammer is the one that was then yeah i saw what he did there gary i saw i like it it's not bad you're getting better at it he zoomed in at the alarm zoomed he showed the oil and then he went but it's hard you have to control i'll tell you how it works this uh this joystick has a zoom in the stick as you turn it and you you move it forward and backwards so you could you have to it's like that's what they said they asked me how come you're not talking you're not good at this i was pretty sure you have to you have to be coordinated you have to like zoom in he's playing with it and at the same time okay that's where they get paid the big bucks up there goof oh my rava now returning to the zion of the bays sponsored by the md white hill group for all those who need shidduchim refusing yeshua's please join tehillim.amindaf.com oh so we just finished talking about this case there's two walls and he puts this hawk on top of the two walls there's no connecting walls here all he does is puts a little tiny piece of wood i don't even know gary could you zoom oh look at that right over here is a piece of wood that's called wow wow gary you're getting really good at it fine by the way i have to say i forgot to mention i have to say tremendous disguise who took the picture of me kaim snow heim snow is a videographer who came in from a fraud he spent hours and now he just got back from america it's been hours to to adjust the coloring you know we have new equipment then everything has to be adjusted the audio that this goes by the way here islam i i don't know if we skipped this already this is a great picture to show how asuka that this idea of parts this sukkah is missing two walls so right there is 50 50. in addition to the two walls that are missing he created a door has a window so obviously the open space the open area is a lot more than what's closed and this is 100 customer on circus this on chavez would be problematic it's shabazuka it is good okay here's a good example because you're allowed to have windows you like to have that kind of stuff now these are i just i brought this picture because the picture i'm about to show you doesn't really show the l shape so i wanted to show you the l shape first again you're a middle of versus arabim or a caramelist but it's much better to say your middle verse just a raven full-fledged russian sarabindi raiser you're permitted to make dium also called pasibi rice these are made out of one alma by one alma l-shapes and logically we bridge the gap 13 am or whatever it is and we create a rush because this well is there it's ten deep fourth white so it'd be awesome for you to draw water from here in chaves and we're concerned about the earlier golem kaham said this works every single time this works every shabbos of the year hanukkah also ham said don't use it we we restrict you to use it only by aaliyah regal okay fine that's the restriction but midair i said this is motor this works perfectly so now i took this and i made this you see what i'm saying you don't really see the l-shape here i tried a little bit to draw over here and whatever i don't know i don't know why but you don't see it so now you take on top of the l shape you put so now bats and we have three alas we just learned two of them on top of this page now what that if you have above two walls you're allowed to put on top provided you put a little lucky we have these funny walls they're not really walls i don't know what you could call them these are l-shaped brackets i put on top and we're great and then we have the we spoke about before although in the beginning of this year in the whole day actually the whole ahmad is that one what do you do he says all three are big meaning when we're talking about a model so the question is why do i need these two and the answer is this this guy has beautiful walls look how tall they are they're massive they're just not touching each other so the kiddush in this one is that they're not touching each other the criticism this one is that they might be touching but they're very small they're only one armored by one ammo nothing this is also so that's what the kumar is saying each one has its own little radish they are made of instrumentation so you have two perfect walls avogadro passive heroics the lakers need finance value so you only have an ammo how much is in ammo six so you have six by six welcome you don't have a single wall that consists of a seventh half wall it shouldn't work vias mean to be rice and if it only said this case of four one animal walls mushroom shame ridiculous shame arbitrage you have at the end of the day you have four walls yes not they're not seven twelve but they're four i was like over here in this case you only have two walls they're massive but they're only two hey we and if i said these two cases i'm going from shabbos to sukkos shabbos is homo because it's miso sukkos is that if you have two walls and a little tepha typically that does not work for shabbos why it's not considered at all but since it's a good sukkah says rav it's also a good rush i wouldn't know to go that direction to take a halacha that works in sukkahs and use it for shabbos that's a bigger enough shade and if there's more sun coming in than shade the sukkah puzzle that's the first mission what if there's windows in the in the sukkah and a lot of sun comes in it's burning you up says the tanaka it's not a problem because we are only concerned about what this does what's the icker sukkah sukha i need to make sure that i have the proper amount of scrap if i put sun directly on top of my sukkot does it create shade or does it not create shade i don't care whether the sun is coming in from the walls or not that's not my problem says no i must be concerned about the walls so you said before that this kind of sukkah even though it's part of his mirabella let me find that picture let me ask you if you're going to change your mind here you also said this norm if you have a sukko that's made out of strings a bunch of lovers we all know what it looks like but let's get the picture forget it i give up okay you know what it looks like let's say you have a wall made out of glass your sukkah your whole sock is made out of glass it's a kosher wall but some comes directly in or worst case your stick is made out of strings every two and a half does a string string string we said that works even though it's partisan right it works you said because it's love with love according to your vieitia kosher or not kosher it's kash you know cause unluckily it's closed but physically the sun comes in what do you say rabbi not kosher why he's right this aleph says that it's not kosher tiny little twice is the middle shallower that according to ryoshiya this sukkah would be puzzled made out of glass sugar made out of love with not kosher we don't passing like that according to yoshi would be proud of remember we're talking about the capoeiras now we're talking about the parents not to be confused i didn't have a better picture for lack of picture here's the parifus it's a curtain this is where the orange used to be this is the evan shasia where we do the the tires it says in the passage that this parikhas which is a standing wall creates shade so you see that standing walls have to create for our sukkah it's interesting but they're going to say that on top of this parifus there's the overhang it actually created shade from the top not from the side that's what it means very very easy suggyo abbay says there are eight not seven at six eight tanoim that hold that asuka has to be adiras keva that asuka has to be a permanent structure can't be a flimsy temporary structure with all these tanaan we don't pass like it at all all right now another thing we have to understand is yes these in theory they have the same theory but they don't agree with each other in other words you're going to see rebbe says the sun has to be four amis which i may say it has to be seventh but they don't agree with each other um and now we go one by one very very simple rabby this sanji rabio makos has to be a permanent structure has to have four by four like a men she lived like a man you don't live in a little little garbage can you live in a a four by four really show that we just said that if the sun comes through the walls it's not a goddira you wouldn't either live like that you want sun shining into your face no so it has to be a permanent destruction review of this the famous reviewed in our first mishna if it's above 20 i'm the mission says it's possible but comes along with you though if you don't match you why because it could be a permanent structure it could be a 20 i'm a structure foreign why one of the reasons we said all the way at the end missouri deposit says it should protect you from all the elements no that's a permanent structure like your house protects you from the rain remnant of design you know this is fine i printed it you guys know what it looks like but i printed why not there's beautiful pictures might as well show it if you make yourself a like khabad on top of your pickup truck or on your boat remember leo poison kiva max here so we're gonna says this apostle why on the boat too in venice wow according to this puzzle because it could blow off in the wind it's not this it's not it keeps on moving whatever the reason it has to be permanent structure so this is a completely different sheet of the review that says that you need four almonds but the point is i need to provide this bishop a table why table what's the table because it has to be like yes you have to have furniture you have to live like a mensch permanent structure baby this nano is causing its riff here a thrift like this little teepee hut whatever it is it doesn't have a nice surah people don't like living in a roundish like oh here here's a guy from the coil who's telling me yesterday rebel jockey is here he's running away imagine if your my brother had a situation like this he had rooms in the attic and you have a bathroom just picture a bathroom shower in the you can't live like that it's very very difficult nobody wants to live like that you want to live in straight walls you wanna this is not this is temporary this is for whatever i'm not gonna say that fine like this once again like in the houses over here i actually have it here we're trying really hard to raise the roof we have a second floor on the top the rooms go like this it's difficult you don't want to live like that [Music] and finally and this is all we're doing for today we're going to go into tomorrow if the sukkah is round it's like a chicken coop sula the fish endless of videos imagine living in a round straw everything is round wherever you go there's no wall there's no end there's no beginning people don't like living like that it has to be permanent here's the eight cheetahs that are so has suggestive permanent have a wonderful day you