Daf Yomi Shevuos Daf 3 by R’ Eli Stefansky

Good morning boys. Welcome. Welcome to all the guests. What's your name again? From Vancouver. That's right. Who else do we have here? What's your name? Sadik. David. David. From where? From here. From here. Anybody else? You You're new. What's your name? Sebastian. Oh, you're a son. You live over here. Okay. It's quiet day today. A I want to show you real quickly before I do anything. Yes. Last night, a 14-year-old, Daniel or Lar, it's your grandson. Uh-huh. New. Uh-huh. Uh-huh. Uh-huh. He donated the pizza, 17 pies of pizza last night, a 14-year-old. For the very, very first email of Mr. I would like to give that honor. I said a story over in sheir that I went to I knocked on somebody's door in Los Angeles then I knocked again and then there was a a very high powered attorney who was there also and he he got he he he took to heart what I said listen to this email subject from one of the most powerful lawyers in Los Angeles please inform that the story you told was not a story which Mayweather in LA is 100% true here. I'll put it on the screen except for the one of the most powerful lawyers in LA part. Then again image is everything in Hollywood so it doesn't hurt. I said to myself I would send an email when and if I completed them separately with you. I meant to send it after completing Sanhedrin but things got busy over Pas. So you finished Sanhedrin and Makus with us. Then court matters picked up and somehow we also finished Makus. The reason why you and MDY are so successful is because it's about the cause not the person. Your ambition, sincerity, and commitment to the cause is remarkable. You're a renaissance man. What? What does that mean? It doesn't matter. Let's hear. Let's hear. Bring it on. And I must admit, you did a pretty good job. Just the best you can say the word renaissance. Okay. And I must admit, you did a pretty good job of cross-examining me about why I wasn't learning the da. I plan on using it in my next trial. Thank you for making learning the da fun and exciting. We always enjoy how you weave in insightful stories and lessons to live by to spice things up when they get dry. Your team of art and graphics, Cameron Kling is award award-winning. So, keep teaching, keep inspiring, and most importantly, keep being Ellie Stfansky. L Shapiro, fine to share my name, attorney at law, certified specialist criminal law. And on the bottom, it says he was on Fox News just like the other day about the Doge and then Trump and Elon M. And then it also in his email says he has all the awards there. He's not a Kathle as we say. He's a Stark lawyer in high school. You are. Was he was he the top guy in class besides you? Years above me. Oh, you're also high school. Good guy. Veri. My 12-year-old son Benny signed up with their officials program to learn and was very excited about the free salami and the $250. I'm not sure which one was the bigger lure for him. After he signed up, my son Ari signed up as well. Manim good friend El Marus also signed up. Unfortunately, due to the hust and bust of my son forgot to post after day number four and was very upset. He asked if I can email official but I told him I spoken to official about the program just before PE and he mentioned that he's extremely strict with the rules and would not accept any excuses. Need to say my son was very disappointed. But imagine my surprise when he kept on learning every single day. I think the the the subject of this email is lashma. This kid is learning the you know knew he's not gonna get a salami and but imag Oh to make it even harder he had to watch his brother Ari post every single day. Benny's about to make his first gamaris without any award even though his brother and his friend will be getting the rewards. This is true learning the schma and wife and I are super proud of him. This all due to the people like official Yasi Klein Rosenberg Marazi Yiti Has and the countless others who involve themselves on a daily basis just to ensure that there's some learning in Israel. There's more learning Israel. What Benny has gained from this experience is far greater than a salami and $250. And we have rebellion MD. Thank you for that. Thank you so much for everything you that you do. As a good friend, I would advise you to give your son $300 and a salami. Two salamis. It's the best $300 you'll ever invest. That's my my two cents. Here's his son, Yaldic. When you learn the schma, then you get an award. Oh, it's that much better. Um, I'm going to skip a little bit around here. Oh, dear Rebellion MDY team. Dear official mitzvah motivated team, today we had five guys from Fanil school in Zurich, Switzerland celebrated our first team on a full Gar very young kids and I'm going to show you in a second. Thank you Rebell for your great which we even watched during pacific vacation. What a gishmach. Thank you for your generous incentive making us watchd write right down and sending comments every day for the entire mak. May you all be blessed in everything that you do and be able to keep up the great work. Attach is a short clip of our sem but switches in regards Benny Natan Yoni and Ronen aka Tamil Feril Zurich Switzerland MDY Zurai. Here they are sitting like good Swiss boys. la. To do the Dishm sorry this time it's not about you. I want to take a moment to highlight the incredible work and dedication of MDY ambassadors in Antworp. Yity Eisenthal Yity started and Noam was on top of the whole program says yes Yity started MDY Antwor group over two years ago it's renamed right MDY Europe but okay we're going to call it Antwor has been doing a fantastic job ever since every single day he sends out a WhatsApp reminder to keep us on track with the daff and shares important MDY updates thanks to his dedication we're about to celebrate our third season together this upcoming Monday that organized we begin our first se we began our first scene with just 18 to 20 participants and now as we finish with Mak we're proud to be over 40 strong that's what these groups are these retention groups are amazing consistent motivation leadership are what keep this group thriving tremendous to him maybe to continue inspiring us all in to learn the daff every day finish together on behalf of the entire MDY and family thank you to the best MDY ambassador and of course thank you rebell for being there warm regards Harry Pilp Belgium official said that the guy can get 250 for shis plus the salon Oh, so official is saying if you missed out and you could continue and that's even without a partnership. Wow. He's continuing at least for the guys that dropped out. So if you do, here's the thing. If you missed one day in Makus, all you need to do is a that's double as long as Makus and then you'll get the 250 and the salami. It's a great deal. I am Isaac Khan from the art school video. I just want to thank you again for changing my life. That guy, remember that kid, that reformed kid? I had no clue that the video would reach you, but I'm happy it did. Just want to thank you again. You're one of the best teachers I've ever had and so excited to start. Sincerely, Isaac Khan. Um, okay. Oh, I got to talk about this cuz I said yesterday we have a great connection with with um what is who? What? Benny is the kid that you just spoke to. Oh, Benny. Here he is. Everybody say hello to Benny Gald. Oh, the Paris is I have a picture. You know why he's wearing that hat? Check this out. He's making stuff for the whatever the get together the seum or whatever it is. Oh, it's a sem flapper seum. Here we go. Mosha Steinberg is speaking and look they have aender that says 8. This is bar park. Here we have a little all colors to be described. This is one. No. Between Switzerland and this the kids are wearing their shorts sing. What are you talking about? No, it's blue. This the Here we go. Staten Island seem arranged by Pyab and Silly Pes. It's unbelievable to all the guys that arranged and get involved. Muny seem arrangement of Krauss. Here we have all colors. Look who says kadesh. This guy's a str. This guy doesn't even have a hat. Join the global MDY movement in Jackson. Rao said their mam is pushing it. There's a morning, there's an evening. It's Galdic. 5:55 a.m. Monday through Friday. Galdic delut. What else? What was I in middle before I got distracted over here? Oh, here we go. Thank you, Harell. Thank you so much for my second. We now have nine guys doing the daff also does the DAFF. Well, he's doing it Benino. I'm not going to be in firesome. Nobody's going to hear this. Natanel Usher Sassin Danil Diaz Akiva Morris David Alic Alicious Mosa Silver Sim Fuches Matis Krauss Sammy Tyler is the one that wrote this. Thank you so much Rebelli and the whole team for making the do fun and easy to do. May they continue to motivate many to reach Tyra around the world. This year is not over yet. Sadik, we just get started. Okay, sponsors. Let's see how fast we could do this. The sponsor. We only have one. So this is fast. fora Jeff in Los Angeles Mosha Aron and Miriam Landy for that of all our children anonymous safe return of all the hostages that's our sponsor for today MDY kids monthly innovations art of the month rebelling the whole MD staff continue to make tires so joy for so many in honor of Marishi for all the work they do and that's the how long that wasn't so long. Wow. Yesterday was unbelievable. Okay, here we go. We have a very easy daff today. Especially if you did makers with us. It's a lot of makas and it really is easy really. But I have a question to see if the was paying attention to and whoever knows the answer is not allowed to answer. What lav whatever could you do and you do it a few times without in between you get malus for each and every one cannot answer I know that you're about to answer see what and you also you have no right to answer anybody anybody hint hint we learned to makus it's an aero you you do it once you do it twice Three times, four times you get malus on each and every one without astra in between. No, no. One one person one. One. What are you saying? For example, you do five with one. How about the the plucking of the hair? Oh, uh, it's similar, but okay, fine. Yeah. What do you say? Now stand up on your chair. Get up. Stand up on your chair for a second. Stand up. Raoai. Here. Zoom in on him, my friend. You know how to zoom in. What's your name? From where? Uh, from how come you're the only one here in the room that knows the answer. How old are you? I'm 15. 15. He's right. Shaving. Ellie Burke is his son. So, I took you skiing once. Yeah. Yeah. This is my grandfather. And that's your grandfather. And your father did not get bit by a shark ever, even though he goes there every week. That was his friend. No, he doesn't know that guy. He doesn't know the guy. Oh, okay. Ellie Burkowitz, the guy that arranges the the ski. Your father should be very proud of you. You're in a room full of adults, maybe 80 people, and you're the only person that knew Kavaldic. Shaving the beard. Shaving the beard. You on five. One, two, three, four, five. Even though there's no in between says the garlic. So the does this a lot and different. What's the connection between? We just finished. Why? What? What's the connection between? Why are we all of a sudden learning? Here's the picture. If you did makers with us, you know this. Not so great. We'll do there's to shave your pay is to make a straight line from the forehead to the ear. It's to be to round it off basically and it's to cut that area. Even without a razor, even with a machine, you're that if you do it on both sides, you're two. So this is one, which is two. It's one in the not to cut your pis. And if you do it twice, you get two. Two without in between. We here it is with the beard. You skipped the sponsor. Oh, I skipped the sponsors. Wow, that's really bad. Okay, so we're going to have to pause in a second. I was getting all excited with Mameish on a roll. Maybe it gives him a little bit more time to put I saw there was no sponsor for today. Like there was one sponsor. So, we'll see. Maybe maybe who knows here. Let's just finish this. The Zuck on the beard your on where the skull meets the jaw number one. And then below it, number two, there's a big shim. This is based on Rashi. The reant says it's like over here lower down two and number two are over here not over here like rashi the bottom line is that the says therefore you shouldn't shave anywhere somebody's telling me that the yakis that's why they have over here because they like shave in between there and now I'm there are people that say that on people would shave exactly where you're allowed to shave to show that they're keeping the beard there's a way to keep like keep their pis So you shave every but say listen we don't even know the one she is the chin and they have somebody else that says that this is the chin right over here on the Adam's apple so you shouldn't touch anything you shouldn't shave anything okay let's do the sponsors real quickly but what's the point of the point is since over here on the left you be five so it's one of which could be two and the for the z is one that you're five so That's the connection. Okay, just real quickly once we're here, show different things if you're new to the shear, the different problems that could happen if you use a uh not a razor blade, a haircut machine, and cut really close. And they like a lot of times you go to the barber and they like to to put the machine right over here. Very problematic. Um straightening out the pace on the side with the machine if you can't grab onto it. I don't know what the um the number is two or whatever it is. It's it's according to basic we passing is we did learn there's a that says you do the entire head but we don't pass like that we passing is fine here's the other one the red the yellow okay happens to be I mentioned the mak but we can mention here because there's a bunch of new people the asks right over here on this not in the mak I just brought in mak but this is where he asked the question what's the difference between chabas and pis in other words on chabasality use a comb, a brush that will that has potential of taking out two hairs even if you don't do it on purpose. You're not allowed to brush your hair with with a strong brush or comb because you'll pull out two hairs and you pis also if you pull out two hairs you so how come you're allowed to brush your pis and he say doesn't have an answer says I saw with my own eyes brushing their pis so it can't be that's a problem and what's the what's the difference so some say because it's a spec of how many years you have to pull out to be how to do it where to do it a bunch That's why matter just continues the we have to do this is a basic stuff that we do. Why is this here? Why is the first so? Uh let me see if I could find I didn't make this chart for here. Huh? You missed out. I missed I missed out a few words. Which ones? So that's why it says it starts off the because it mimics it's similar to the beard. So just as a these are the four different cases that we had in our Mishna two that are four and asks why now does bring all four yet when it comes to shabas the first mission in Shabas this is the first mission in Shabas all it mentions is that's how the mission starts doesn't mention doesn't mention doesn't mention why is it in our mission mentions all four. So says the guy we have these two in talks about talks about so those two things are brought down together. So in the Mishna we would also bring it together. So our Mishna is talking about so automatically we're going to talk about the whole the whole is called so we're talking about so we're going to bring once we bring we bring because it's right next to it. So now we have two. Oh, once we have two, we might as well just bring all four. And they're very similar because you bring this carbon called just to remind the new people. It's a carbon that depends how wealthy you are. If you're wealthy, you bring a sheep. If you're poor, you bring birds. And if you're super poor, you bring flour. I'm going to ask only you guys cuz you guys weren't here last night. So just for you guys, we had in this week's parachute, we had a yus and a both of them bring birds or or a carbon. Is that a carbon you three? No. Huh? It's not. No. Do you agree with him? No one says no one. I'm just telling you it's why not? Because depends on your status. It also depends over there. You can bring flour. One minute. One minute. One at a time. Stop answering the right answer. What are you saying? She can't bring flour. He says, "Very good. It's not. You don't have to come to shop. It's fine. You do, but for different reasons. You only have the two options." No, I'm pay attention over here. There's only two. There's a carbon and birds. You don't know the flower. It's not called a carbon or something else. So, I was at um Yseph Bilyak's bar mitzvah yesterday. not his BMA but his kids and the rabbi what's the guy rabby's name Fletcher Fletcher Fletcher he said his own vart it was a nice vart so I'm going to say it cuz if I hear something and it's he said why does a not bring flower he says cuz a woman who gives birth doesn't really answer so well birth she's shown gratitude we don't bring a couple little flower at least a bird you want to say thank you tom at least bring a bird I know you can't afford But at least a bird when it comes to sin says okay I'll take I'll take even the the flower it's not it's just a okay it's an ideal and have the same carbon and they're right next to each other in the we're going to put them together so we put them together therefore we brought those two in the so we bring the other two a trick first thing in that's the name of the and then we don't hear about for 20 days as long as the almost we don't hear about it we go into this that what happened we start with the word and all of a sudden all these are talking about says I love this I did this it's very few words it's only 20 days We say it and then we get rid of it. We're Rashi says a lion here. Let's get rid of it. It's a lion of like uh it's like you have a loan like a get rid done. I'm done. And now next to explain a little bit what you do sponsors. No, I'm going to go a different route. That everybody knows that used to call the seven do every day. He calls it I'm in fact he was once at his one of his kids' weddings and he says oh you have so someone came over to him you have let me let me pay let me help you out with the he says no because I had the I didn't do my seven daff yet I have the yeah because uh I was just going to throw it out there because I heard this many many times from young bakim they always say uh people ask me I'm sure they ask you as well do you love learning is it Gishmak He said, "Yeah." How come it's not for me? I don't I don't like it yet. Oh. So says, "I don't know if this is going to help for I'm going to try it on my son." Probably not. I have a feeling it's not going to help. He says a bak should view like a like you have to do it. You have to put on it's not to put on you put it on eventually once you learn a little bit then you learn how to learn then you getcome it becomes very enjoyable or whatever. You're not going to get that day one. Is it going to work? No, no, I didn't think so. Says the Oh, so sorry. Thear says since it's a few words, that's why I get rid of that. I get I'm done with there's only two proim for and then the rest of the proim another six pro have to do with is two which is four. Okay. So now we're just going to see these things that we did this what we did yesterday. Here we go. The Tyra says that the is in the future that I'm not going to eat something and he ate it or that I'm going to eat something and he didn't eat it. Which one of these is an action? Which one is of these is not an action. That I am going to eat something and he didn't eat it. He didn't take any action yet. You get malus for it. But we're not gonna this is just to what we're going to talk about in the later on in the d that two turns into four because I take those two and instead of just the future also in the past I say that I did not eat and that I ate it happened already. Either I ate or I didn't eat and one of them is a lie. Both of them could be a lie. If I say that I didn't eat and I ate. Yeah. I could just see because uh my my daughter hates mameish a sinner for liver sa for for herring. So I I hear her husband all the time coming back from shul. I did not eat herring. I did not eat sometimes even and I saw him at the kid there. No, I'm just kidding. That that's you know what I'm saying? You have people that have the you know like she said I can't be married to somebody what what he did over there what do you care no my wife always sneaks in the herring she if he's coming for shab she brings the hering like come here look let's refrigerate don't she's still sleeping right here's mouthwash okay anyway yeah he's allowed to make such thing for sure huh yeah exactly Okay, fine. These are all things we had. That's why I said it's easy. A lot of a lot of things that we had word for word. Huh? What are you saying? What's the guy forgot that he's tummy? That's step one. Step two, two, three, and four is that he forgot what he's doing. He forgot where he is over here. He forgot that he's taught me. He forgot that he's taught me. He went to the to that morning and he's passing by the kais. He said, "Why? I got to go to the base of Mikdash." And he goes in and he wow he comes out and he he realized what what did I do? I'm Tom. I I didn't wait seven days. How could I go to Bd or he's and he ate? He had a carb and he ate whatever it is. He ate he forgot that it's a B mikdash. Forgot that it's the same thing. same two made it that okay that's that one remembers this one this one the the first two the talks about going from into that's two that way and then the says going from Yeah. Do we have to do it again? We can do it slow. Here we go. The T says going from your tent to this. There's a private domain, a public domain. All the T talks about is going from the private to the public. So the arrows are pointing this way. Ley, where are you going? What is this? I have to go greet all the children. Let's go. Ah, good excuse. Here we go. That's that. So we're going to show it. It went from the house. The guy took it from the house and put it in the other way is sorry that the guy in the takes it he takes it and then he gives it. Those are the two. So when in this direction the direction of the arrows. Now we're going to do the other direction. It goes from he the guy in. What's the guy in called? He's the owner of the house. The guy in is called ai. So went from the balabay took it from the ani. Over here it goes real quick. The ani gave it to the but it's the same direction. So now we have two that are four. is two are when the guy in the house gives it to the guy in the turns into four because now it goes from to either the guy standing in the gives it to the guy in the house or the guy in the house takes it but it's in the same direction. It says in the I think not whatever I I put but the point is that what oh very good they're both white here let's just show this for a second here's a guy's arm and all of a sudden develops a taras though they're both called sea and beh the tada is a different shade of white. It looks like sid looks like lime or like the chrome of the beta. So it's two that are formed like the top it's a different shade of white. Great says the GMAR let's just look at these four. Oh, here's the problem. We'll say B. If one of these four cannot go like Rishal, let's say the bottom right is not going to go like Rishal cuz he doesn't hold this four. There's only two in that case. He doesn't hold that ashw that goes in reverse. It talks about the past is only so then all four can't be. If one is not then the whole mission is not. If left bottom bottom left cannot go like because he also says there's only two the top two not the bottom two. So it's not according to in that particular case of so all four can't be then the whole doesn't line up. So thear says this our four different cases cannot be cannot be can't be because the bottom right one and can't be because the bottom left one in let's blow it up it's only these two in not these two why because in the in the future future not in the past says how does he know that anybody oh because it says in the past or it's in the future means the negative and the positive I won't eat is I will eat is a positive but it's in the future can't be either because when it comes to tumar alim Top two good, bottom two no good. So I have two that are two, not two that are four. It doesn't make sense. The rest of the mission goes like so. Huh? Where you see that? Well, let me see. Oh, he doesn't know. Yeah, you're right. What? No, he's saying it's the the right and the left. Okay, we're good. No problem. Let's say that the entire thing goes according to So, what's the problem? I'm just going to say like this. Look at this. Where are we? Oh. Pay attention. Oh, the top. We're going to go like The whole mission is What did you ask me? That the that in you only have two cases, not four cases. No, I have four cases. They're not similar. One, two is not like three and four. One and two. Three and four. You're not It's a case doesn't like that. They have to be the same. But it's it's a nice try at least. We have four cases. Two of them are going to be two of them. And the same thing I could say when it comes to two of them and two of them. What are you saying? Why why would I say that two cases are? So if you go back to this chart all four cases should be similar. So let's take the top right corner that's the case of an ofas all four cases whether you have a say and or it doesn't matter what color it is all four colors all of them have the same they're identical all four are the same. So how you going to tell me then all four cases are not the same. Some are some that doesn't make sense. They all have to be uniform. And if one case we know is uniform that what they're all they're all you call them they're all they're all identical. All four 1 2 3 four are identical is going to look at and say okay get out leave the whatever it is. So then also 1 2 3 four have to have the same not you can't split them up. Where is that turning of the daff inovations in honor of our son's kl 12 nine for learning san and mak unbelievable nineyear-old making seem of two things 12-year-old it's all unbelievable global still experts in international financial services and by anonymous in honor of the sadic whose name we cannot say who shows us what it means to be a giver in a sadic Just want to make sure that Okay. So, where are we holding? Huh? Oh, you want to show some live cement? Where is this? Staten Island. Staten Island. Shalom. Staten Island. They don't hear us. They're excited. Maybe it's on a delay. Boy, if you hear us, raise your hands. 100 years away. No, they don't hear. What are they doing over there? Looks like Okay, what else do we have? Oh, these guys. These guys are live. This is flat push. What else? Hey, sit down you. What is this? Aiz. This is Monty. Hello. It should stay on the screen. Yes. He said yes. What else? I know that guy. Okay. Says again, who's our going to? We have all four cases. We have who does it go according to? We have a problem with why because he says there's only two cases, not four. And our is talking about two that are four. So he says, "What was your question?" Your question was that according to you don't have to bring a carbon. You're right. But you do get malus. So now we have all four cases that you're something. You're not you might not be the same thing. The top two you have to bring a carbon. The bottom two you get. I think it's much much worse to get malus than bring Okay, that's my own personal opinion. But something you don't get all free fits in but at the end of the day if the top is and the bottom is potter we had a big problem with that but everything is now great who says this says it oh so we are talking about a little bit about What's awes Okay, so look what a thing. This is a table. So what's the difference? A sheer but it's a sheer which is obvious. Oh says it's obvious. Take a look what Rashi says. I'm just blowing it up. This is what we have today in America. says he's changing something that's known. He says that a man is a woman. In other words, and Rash continues, he says this table is gold. This is a piece of gold. Everybody knows it's wood. It's not gold. That's why is that that not a sheer, it's a sheer. Oh, the answer is means for instance, I say I had a now that could be a sheer, but nobody knows. You don't know. You don't know this. Everybody knows. They see this is not gold. They see this guy is a guy, not a woman. It's obvious. You could scream as much as you want that it's a that's a woman, but it's not. So everybody knows it's a fact. Even if you that a table is a table, that's okay. That's mish. Yeah. For no reason, but everybody. Okay. So says, check it out. Look at here's the It says, "And what do you see all the way at the end of the It says the word twice. One of them is extra I can learn from this as follows. I'm talking about even the past. So two I'm gonna take this word which I don't need in this and I'm going to use it for something I don't need. That's if I have this word here that's not necessary. I have nothing to do with it. Let me put it somewhere else. And I'm going to say that what that you get Malcus for lying about the past. I'll call upon him here according to Rava you get malus for the past not just the future and that's what is gonna hold okay you're right you don't get you don't get a carbon you don't have to bring a carbon but you do get malus two are two are amaz it's a totally separate how can you compare them all other ones all four they have the same thing over here the only way that is if two are and two are amazing what is this he's saying it has to be in in a in a different scenario Okay. No. Yeah. No. No. Not too much. You're talking about Oh, yeah. He's talking about Yeah. Good answer. Good answer. All four of them are amazing. So, now we have to understand how how how does it work? How do you get malus in such a case? We have four cases, right? I ate and I didn't eat. I will eat and I'm not going to eat. The four cases, two in the future, two in the past. Like says why you get malus for the past. What happened happened and you get malus for it. You lied. You get malus. But I'm not going to eat. That's the third case. that what this is obvious. If you swear you're not going to eat and then you take a steak and you eat it, you took action. You took a physical action. You took it with your hand, you're chewing with your teeth. What's you get? Malcus is asking a simple question. If a person swears that he's going to eat a spinach, he tells his mom, "I promise you I'm going to eat the spinach. It's uh it's it's not taking action. He didn't do anything. He didn't he did not eat. How could you punish somebody for not doing something? Not doing your homework. Like I didn't do something. How do you get punished for not doing something? Malcus. So that I just want to remind we had a a uh video. This could explain the suga slightly. It also explains why I only later on like two weeks after I saw this video. the the the punch line in this thing. Only answer if you don't know, he says. Okay, here we go. It's older one, but it's it's good for today. Monty, not again. Every time you're hungry, you put the whole fridge in one sandwich, and in the end, you barely eat a quarter of it. This time, I'm really hungry. And you know what? I swear I'll eat it all by the end of the day today. You know, you'll get 39 malcus if you don't eat it by the end of the day. I don't want to be rude, but I think I'll be putter for one of two reasons. Does anyone know what the two reasons are? Now, only those who don't know the answer should answer. Yes. Only those who don't know what. Yeah. So what are the two reasons why because he holds oh we're going to introduce a new thing he like the says even if you didn't take action you can get malus on it no action zero by refraining from eating you swore you're going to eat the sandwich and you don't eat it you'll get malus for not eating it even though there's no action here. What does hold when it comes to on the one hand our Mishna says you get malus this right over here like our Mishna says all anonymous Mishnas that's and our Mishna anonymously says that on you get you get malus why because two actions on that are really four so even in the one case out of the four what's the pro problematic case that I will eat and I don't eat it's you get malus we said you have to get you have to get something either you bring a carbon you get malus you get malus like so so then he's forced to say that in the in that fourth case there's no action he just didn't eat he put his hands down didn't eat he's going to get malcus so you see he holds you get malcus the problem is that somewhere else it says ain't like you don't get malcus So let's see our I just did this literally at 7:05. I put this in. So really it should say not by if somebody says I swear that I'll eat this bread and the day went by and he didn't eat it. He doesn't get the reason why in the case of the video of that kid where he told his father I won't get malus the reason is because there's no action and if for no action you don't get malus if you don't get malus why there's something called what does mean so concept in it means first of all in order to get punished you have to be warned by two in the warning has to happen when does the warning have to happen you remember right before hold on a second yeah he was warning him like a father yeah of course not very good what says it has to be of the you see a guy about to shoot somebody say hey if you do that The two agents say if you do that you'll get killed in Bez and he goes pulls the trigger within two seconds dead we killed. The problem over here is that he says you must eat this loaf of bread. Now he has the whole day to eat it. There's no I don't know if he will eat it. I don't know if he won't eat it. How do I give him now? Now the only possibility is maybe he'll give 22 seconds before the end of the day. Well the problem is huh? Maybe it's a Toms who doesn't need. Maybe he's like you. Oh shame. Oh, so you're not like it. Why? Cuz I don't know when to give the and my not might not be effective. It's not and at the end of the day he might not have enough time to eat the bread. Maybe I gave it to him too early, too late. And therefore this is called and it doesn't work. So that's we're not going to we're talking about now over here says in the one hand here's the contradiction over here I don't know if you can change it let's just say oh noer right over here where it says kicker then it'll make more sense over there he says you don't get malus green and in our mishna says red you do get malcus says he has another Mishna and he he prefers the other Mishna over our Mishna and therefore it's not a contradiction. Which one? So today we're going to do try one. It's not going to work and tomorrow we're going to get another one. Which which other Mishna did he see that it says that you don't get malus for this? Everybody that did Makus remembers this and I'm going to show you. Here it is. Hold on. The green one. The on the top where it says Mishna, you put Let's see you do it. No, I No, I will. I will eat a And he doesn't. The is I think it's better like that. But anyway, let's keep on going. We We'll get there in a second. Here, check this out. Remember this case, this is a carbon pal is you have to eat every single piece of it. You can't leave a single. Now, what happens if you leave it over? That's called nicer. So, what do you do? Oh, there's a there's a remedy. There's a fix. And that is here. You see the sun go down, you take it and you burn it. So it says in the if you leave over some of the carbon pes in a good carbon pes it's a carbon and you break a bone one of the of you're not allowed to break any bones but you broke a bone of a non good carbon you don't get malus why if you break a bone of a nonbel you shouldn't break the bone of it because possible. That's in a good carbon, not in a carbon. But if you leave over some of your carbon, why don't you get it has to be says it is a lab that has no what happened? You left it over. You didn't eat it. You left it on the table. You get You don't get malus for leaving something on the table. That's not taking action. Not taking action. You don't get malus for it. ain't love. Oh. Oh, no. No, no. Cuz it has to say right. No, no. Under forget it. I'll do it later. No, it said you leave everything that said before. Just the top part should say instead of Let's go. You You can work on it. You see on the on the right side it says it's say under next here are the two actions that I'm going to eat. Sorry. Here says I'm going to eat and he doesn't eat. You don't get malus. There's two options. Either you could say it's because of it's a that you didn't take action. You don't get malus. If you don't take action, you get malus. If you do take action, the reverse that I won't eat and he did eat. He took action. You get malus. So we go like but it's very it's very possible to say that doesn't hold like hold like on the left it's another reason why you don't get malus why it's a say don't get nervous here these are the most simple things any is don't do that the gives you a remedy like don't steal and if you steal what should you do the ex return it you don't get malus on stealing if somebody steals a bike he doesn't get malus cuz he can return it What? How about what? Not talking about talking about ah good point. Yes. So in this case of noiser correct. This also we have to fix but not not now. Maybe I should have the fixibility here. How do I do this? Maybe I should could I do it? I need another I need a keyboard. Um who said, "No, just leave it. Leave it." Oh, this one. This one is done. Okay, good. Good. Now, this one we need to fix. But okay, a different time. Who told you it's on the right? Just ignore what it says in the top. Just It's the top. Just You know what? If you could erase real quickly, don't don't erase. Fair. Forget it. There's two things in it could either be the right and the left. Who told you to go with the right? Go with the left. Who says it should go like that you don't get malus for something that there's no action? Maybe go any says don't do something and immediately afterwards the says do something like by carbon p says don't leave over and if you do leave over you have a remedy burn it. lucky. So says don't leave over and if you do leave over burn it then the gave you a positive commandment after that's what we call in all of that case says that you don't get malus and that's not the reason it's not because anything We said a number of times already. So we have here why don't you get malus when you leave over either because it's a or so again we said why does say all the way in the beginning here says you don't get malus and we're going to prove it from carbon pes who told you to prove it from carbon pes in carbon pes you can say that the the reason is not on the right the reason on the left That's why you don't get malus. Who told you what the reason is? Hello. So, oh, we'll continue tomorrow. Have a wonderful day. Merit the of spreading Torah throughout the world. Sponsor Ashir today. mdysponsor.com or sponsor at mdyd.com.