Daf Yomi Shabbos Daf 58 by R’ Eli Stefansky

we are unlive all right robust are we ready to go we are live on YouTube everybody please mute is Gary on Oh nephew number two where's Neffe number one we got here's a riddle I got a riddle for the eylem who's the uncle of the shear I see I see that there's a Neffe over there smiling laughing there's the nephew anybody nobody that's the uncle of the let's try this - uncle o this year any uncle that instead of taking their kids to restaurants well he did that also but he shoved them in a taxi woke them up fourth 4:30 in the morning tied them up threw them in a taxi and brought them to the shear a week in a row that's the uncle of the year so anyway a boy say it's a tremendous pleasures to let happy birthday to Joey happy birthday wasn't this this is unbelievable what does a nephew get his uncle it doesn't buy him a Gucci Gucci [Music] all right no boys sigh that's that's that's a true uncle you have an uncle that goes and gets Kashmir's what what is nephews learn from this our uncle wants tired uh let's support IRA but listen nephews don't don't get too excited this is nice it was a beautiful move but next year there's gonna be a dedication in the building maybe all the stones $50,000 worth of the outside stone something like that you know are you gonna give me a little piece of paper balloons for Joey this is the uncle of the year or a by side you gotta wait okay listen I'm not gonna get go too hard on you but next year you have a whole year to prepare for this today is the 24th day of the Eimer and yesterday sponsor was shingle bats of for Shane low bass Nachman from Andrew Fuchs we'll keep it on for today as well and a friend of the shear needs a big reform Oh or a mayor Ben you hood this get old or foolish lame-o put that up here a lot of people in this year know him oren kaplan roof foolish lame-o what we got here oh hi red bellied scribe for sending this to me 20 minutes before she starts on the worst day of this week on Sunday after I give sheer what's his Shabbos and hardly have time to prepare but here it goes its saw Joey leave his brother I know it's super late to be kind of you for something morning shadow but I'm a guy who doesn't give up without a try it takes the message that even a DA blah blah blah today this is Uncle Joe's birthday you're just talking and shot at staying on what to get Uncle Joe for his birthday the boys around the table were saying whether there's something special because in Joe's so good to us he buys his breakfast he may 6th child he brings us the sheer he throws us in the taxi 4:30 in the morning the best uncle in the world yeah when he's not gonna go Joey we have we have a bunch of people that including official all these guys that when they were in air just row every single morning without fail bring a taxi to America's not failure I mean do the Daffy get back in the taxi and go home every single day I think Joey was there like a week in a row every day slepping different nephews different things will have a mouth go with pizza french fries let's go son blah blah blah a brainstorm of an idea popped into our heads Joey never misses the daph and something he doesn't stop talking about he loves you he loves to share nothing we're making more happy than put a big smile on his face if he gets surprised of the shout out please we're all sponsoring this moisture in honor of uncle Jonah's birthday this from all his nephews including as you from Lakewood who's driving a special his uncle's birthday the nephews all staying up and we're making the usual we'll have a Malka in our backyard yes they're social businesses of course yeah I've had this social distancing yeah I saw that I saw the pictures already Shavua Tov Thank You Saul in all the nephews all right do we have any more time Joey with the cigar I love it all right uncle Joey I was wondering where you are all right look boy going revelry hosts the fancy street Oh guys guys okay whatever Benoist show Moreno how going I'm meet the Italica going the blanket ashleeta I love it le is just fine now he knows why I'm a grown egg cause I really owe your father sleep there's a real chronic you would make a broker reading McGillis yeah I guess he he knows us I not exactly sure this is he'd make a broker reading you'll see him come I did when he landed from a sitter I think that this virus is because of you hmm you have started such a tremendous increase in learning loving enjoying Tyra that the something went nuts and try to stop it with this MacGyver but Barca shame because of you and this be a Tabora he's not succeeding keep up you tremendous how about satire you're giving your mother today cos give a leg and a physician man besides your teaching staff you're giving over the schmuck attire of a high rev nor does this kind of tie rash refer you mentioned the other day about Aaron's brother I'm his husband he asked for the 8-minute Daffy okay he says to keep that yeah that why when I was saying over that story that he asked me enough I was a little vague I spoke about him two weeks before and he said more and then I couldn't say anymore we'll talk about it at a different time all right please don't mention my name thank you all right let's get into the DAF I have a good friend here social distancing avi Kaminski we usually pipes up on the screen now he's live so he won't be able to pipe up in it well he could you have a be my what happened was this morning my phone I got up too early didn't sleep enough I grabbed my phone and went flying out of my hand hit the floor it's done so no YouTube so I asked him to come over the cover that tire he came over so thank you very much I need a new phone here's my phone it's got a badge it's not even my phone it was Gary's phone lent to me because my other one is garbage says the Gemara we're holding da from tests after nyah Amidala I literally like every day I look at this and I can't believe we just started myself the Shabbos we're all in enough fifty-eight crazy time flies we could do this we could get through Shabbos we get through aver a ribbon and then it's smooth sailing through shyness alright so yesterday were discussing cavalo what scuffle Koval the Gemara said must be the hat that a woman wears and that's one shot says small no cuz we had a whole Schuyler how does a woman take off her hat if she takes off her hat she'll expose her here she won't want to take off her hat but since this hat is underneath the svaha it's like underneath the snood so she could like rip it off and it's not such a big deal by the way we have our usual Sunday morning guests from New York the ones who stay up matzo Shabbos we have let me climb Elia dick meters here every every document is here every single day anyway but it's Larry Klein especially he's a big he's a big star because he made a complete recovery from Corona and he sent his pictures with the oxygen and everything what's his shy he works all night but must've shot as he gets to be with us says the Gemara Welsh moolah Mar have lo the avid earth nut so I didn't have time unfortunately to make a nice chart for this I just want to give you a little bit outliner what's gonna what we're gonna see today Evan hasn't has a Kabul did two very very different things a Kabul that the woman has that the governor said yesterday with the missions talking about a woman's Kabul that's like a wool yarmulke that fits underneath the snow Schmauss is not we're talking about a slave even a ship huh because we're talking about women can't go out men could go out so there's like this Oh a slave they had a little Evelyn that said on it slave whatever it said everybody knew this guy is a slave it's to put him down to embarrass him to show that he belongs to somebody else yeah that's why I said yes like a Jewish start I don't know if I didn't want to make such a comparison you could get you know anything you say that has to do with that area you get into trouble but I did say it last night but anyway it's some sort of emblem they put over here now another way to wear it there's two ways you could put it on your clothing and you can put it on your neck and there are two types one is made out of metal and what is made out of clay so basically just if we want to go through everything and so that has some sort of float if it's made out of metal a slave or we're talking about a woman slave can never go out with it why because if it falls down it has a lot of value she'll pick it up and bring it in with just a rabbit that's a problem if it's made out of clay so there's these two types one is made by the master and one is made by the slave himself and there's the one made by the slave around his neck or on his baggage so if it's made by the master around his neck is motor why nobody's gonna remove that no slave in his right mind is gonna want to remove something that his master told him to wear to show ladies a slave people his slave was going to give it to him he'll punish him so you won't take it off so you're a lot of walk with that in which is surrounded and if it falls off there's nothing worried about its it's a piece of klaris it's nothing he's not gonna schlep it now if the the Bala boys put it on his clothing that's a problem why because if you put on the clothing look you could just take off his jacket fold it up pretend that he's too hot from the heat and he's gonna want to take off his jacket so nobody sees that he's a slave he wants to fit in you know a lot of people they go outside they're you know in America they take off the young they think nobody knows they have they look there the pay is a flying area they think of the young or whatever the slave also he'll take off his thing he'll fold it up nobody knows I'm a slave okay I you look like a slit okay but I'm not wearing the em on says slave but that's if it's on the clothing if it's on his neck he's not gonna do it what could he do he's not gonna get away if his master sees him with a folded coat he might not get that upset at him oh he's hot but if he has this thing around his neck that says slave what's his excuse why are you holding slave in your hand so I'll never take that off but if it's made by the slave not by the master says the kymaro then it's always awesome for him to walk out with it or for her to walk out with it because then she'll remove it the master didn't give it to her to wear to say hey you're a slave I'm doing it on my own now I don't feel comfortable wearing it in public so I'll take it off that's basically the Sonia let's see it inside you Omar have the davit oh we're talking about not a tipple a snood we're talking about up the emblem of a slave when we Amish mafia Amish war it's a bit behind some should serve our oi have a logo facing shipping sue Sonny Shmuel himself who's saying that this we're talking about this emblem of a slave says specifically that a slave could go out with the emblem on his neck just not on his Beckett like a Sheehan holdover they rob a holdover lady even enough she so what we do dig mark comes up with the distinction is different who made it and who didn't make it if the master makes it he's not gonna you know he's not gonna deer take it off the master said put it on you put it on if the master - daran you in trouble I guess these to beat them whatever they the master has his ways to punish his slave won't give him food put him in a cage who knows what he won't do it hot dog I didn't I'm Shay so if he does it for himself he has a way it's possible that he might try to take it off as he walks him which is robbing therefore he's not allowed to go out of his route the man who came to LA - mother overlay rebus he told me that by us in our mission were talking about the master made the crisis used to say I might like so how come if it's in his garment is different what's the difference he's not gonna take off his coat do mom if sarcomere to us who make happily or mostly a cafe maybe he will fall off and he's scared of his master so fold it up he'll follow up his clothing and he'll carries clothing as if pretending as if he's hot so he won't get in trouble from his master boys of the room easily I see every other night mm Capella's your ladder wear clothing it was just a rabbit that's one of the things you want to wear it for protection even for jewelry for yeah but you can't carry clothing in your hand if you do so you put even if you put it on your shoulders and you have some sort of retention still I have caught this is the rights of its up who cares if it's clothing clothing is meant to be worn not to be carried and that's what we're concerned we're concerned the difference between clothing and the neck is that clothing you get away with it he could pretend his hat the neck there's no way to get away with it so different I'll never remove it therefore you could walk with it on Chavez the Theo dominates mother of Keenan about Sheila we see something similar he told him cooler I bought in the Bay Ridge School this is very interesting first of all from this so you just see the kinds of shallow assigning of him you say every morning shall are you sorry I'm so Lisa imagine your Evan you have to walk around with the emblem I'm a slave disgusting who wants to do that here's something very funny or interesting the Reg goal is like we discussed them many times Marco was the rush colors different red bells the head of clients roll if you were subordinate to the Reg gamos you're from a certain group of it all of clay is from you had a walk around the street with that emblem stating the fact that you're the huset of the Reg godless and if not the rich girls had his guys all these gamers you see through our chance he had his cops and if they caught you not wearing the Emma did you up silly obvious looking at me like wow it's good thing you don't aware I'm Ken AFC kind of thing put your mask on he has his gloves mask don't thing you know what you know see them watching careful what you say hold on here's a V hold on if you guys want to know what he looks like okay he's a big fan of us see them oh it's fine zoom guys know what you look like forgets I see them imagine with crime cameo do all these look facts the classroom clang can you have ski we'd have to wear or plan like let's say we had grass wouldn't say can I ask you see how girly reply him on the thing you walk around but all kites well there's one rose girls for everybody everybody's no there's no different groups and this everybody can see them little axe smart him miss nag name everybody see join em oh all the hectic for guys all the whatever where are they yeah these guys they would all have to wear the same thing it's it's a funny thing to think about you all had to wear it so he told him oh it's very weird I lose it already she's looking really cool rap barn the base vegetables elliptic orbits are bullies I see me you know how to walk out with that clothing the barman of the Licata hello because if it falls off you're scared you're gonna have to carry it you know to do something with it cuz then the rich girl says cops are gonna come and give it to you they used to punish people a few goomar's they hit them they did whatever they did stuff to them but you we told them you bar Sheila is okay to like app download the barrage blue so someone should have learned that it's like a sign that they pay the taxes whatever but the point is you you're very close to rich dollars know that if you don't wear that emblem it's not because you're not you know you're not subordinate to him you're not miss buff to him it's because whatever happened it fell off so that's not round but other people have to be careful not to not to go out like that goof off as small you haven't the president should serve all right have a live version week suicide so he learned who - from oil a slave goes out with emblem on his neck that he won't take off but not with the one on his garment tiny a mahaki go to have a because of itself all right you learnt the same thing okay very me know the problem is it says li eight seven behind shirts I've already the lied bhai since reach suicide says before ish he cannot go out with the one on his neck you just said you could go out with an emblem on your neck you're not gonna remove that over it says low Yates a hydrogen so far a contradiction now so that's the question well keep on going busy busy as ever Amy column to mow then I'm a Kabul Tomo why is it emblem that macabre Tomo well depending on what material it is but emblem is not Ackley in order for her to be in Kabul Toma has to be a vessel has to be clean it's not a clean right it's an emblem it's not no it's not an ornament nobody's proud to wear it it's disgusting it's the opposite of an ornament so also not McHale Tomo and it's not a bed it doesn't help you it doesn't protect you from the elements so it's not McHale Tova doesn't have the three things that are necessary that could be one of them not all three but you need one of these things it needs to be either a CLE or a baguette or no neither of those the ladies look ship itself alright ah again another beautiful thing that slaves had they had a little bell ding dong wherever he walks he has a belt of the yet - who so you can't walk out with that yo-yo - bouzouki fixer sewing the bell on his garment is an ornament and therefore he could go out with it Zeb Isaiah McCallum Toma so both both of these things are Mikado Toma why because it's an ornament it's macabre Toma Villa Tate's of a malleable - Shiva tattva row and the same thing for an animal cannot go out with an emblem on its neck relationship you saw and if an animal has like some sort of blanket or dog clothes whatever some people are crazy enough to go look how cute I'm not gonna talk about people in my Mustafa if you buy clothing for your animal and it has an emblem in it can now go out with it but ladies look shipping Susa and not with a bell in its garment Villa Abhisek ship itself Varro why not sera she said it's very interesting that she says another reason why people we had this before the a bell is something you do you put on an animal when you want to sell it we had this the Wingo remember finger and I said pingas Moroccan and I got a email from a Moroccan who said it was so funny that I thought of King Pina and the finger the same thing because it's a market kinga is market so it's also to bring so basically the mission guru brings down that we have an Easter to put something on an animal because of the marketplace we also have the isser because of a mastery it's a load and also an animal what if you put something on an animal that might fall off then I'm all we had you might come to carry it mr. Brewer talks about all three hold on all three things and want each thing in a different case there I see Michael Cohen is the hog look at that dog that's a cute dog actually all right I thought you had a Maltese that looks like a baby pitbull actually looks like a pitbull to me alright whatever is it that of people no not a bit boats there's a nice cute dog okay whatever I need a mission for each there are times that then it's not a load the animals that you don't bring until marketplace you're not gonna sell a cat in a marketplace so the issue of a cat even a dog maybe dog I don't know whatever whatever animals go to marketplace they have the is sort of a bell the ones that don't have is sir of of maybe I'll come to carry it you know on a dog on a cat maybe their Bell fall off and then you'll carry those up so each animal has a different reason that's why I have three different reasons doesn't drew are you saying AVI nothing okay writer so is there a McCallum Tomo dynamic Kabul Tomo likely namikawa Tomo since the kymaro perhaps lame aha let's use the same distinction that we made before hard overly rub a whole dollar deal deny shake this contradiction that it says light say a bit behind some you cannot go out with the emblem on the neck and we were learning the whole time he could go out the emblem in the night maybe let's make a distinction what is made by the master that whole fear to take off and therefore you're allowed to go out of users around with it the other one is talking about who's made by himself so he's doing his master a favor he wants to show there's a good slave look at me even I wear an emblem but if I take it off my masters not gonna kill me for it the master can't beat him up for taking off an emblem that he himself imposed on himself so maybe that's a good answer lie I prefer not to go to that answer says the Gemara I prefer to say that everything is uniform we're talking about the master and not something that the slave did himself in DVDs over the Red Bay and what we're talking about of course something on the neck not we're talking about the neck right the question is neck to neck and on the one hand says we're not worried about the neck and taking it off his ladder Walker was just arrived another one says you're now allowed the conditional metaphase you consult it so now the Gemara says oh there's enough convenor between meadow and clay okay the RAV nachman or Moraga Volvo donor map it'll arrive early in your it's in boy metal is a valuable resource if it falls off you're not just gonna leave it Emile the street in those days metals metal so if it falls off you're gonna pick it up and bring it back back home and gonna be over on Heights on Shabbos no metal that's it so that's why I started off saying if it's made out of metal you can never wear it that's always a problem but if it's made out of clay falls on the floor and breaks you leave it there nobody's gonna schlep home broken pieces of clay love our Shane Mack middle of yachting boy if it's something like clay not a problem okay now mr. burr and I can prove with you humor has an amazing proof hear me dick Tommy's name is a McConnell tumor we're talking about tumor clay is not Makabe toma so it can't be talking about clay must be talking about metal and once we're talking about metal we can make that distinction yeah mr. Sherman Sherman tech as any Hollywood let me carry tumor okay pneumococcal a tumor so it's saying look this particular ornament an emblem that goes on the guys neck is not a couple tumor why because it's not Ackley it's not a no it's not anything but a regular clean made out of metal is McCobb Altima and oh yeah I'm a special tip now and if you're talking about clay so what are you telling you Sam a couple tumor clay is never ever macabre Tomo honey would let me cover tomorrow what sometimes it isn't it autumn it's never macabre Tomo forget about that it's made for a slave if you make a CLE ahead of clay it's emerald Oh what time y'all this is like one of my favorite vessels next I know next nexium this is what IV and now I'm we're gonna get me play a fun name a vessel made out of stone or plague lowly a vessel made out of excrements dung my boy sighs is what they used to do in those days they took some dung and they made a clear don't get yourself any crazy eight minute coffee mug dung hair together deceive no no Clegg eulalee Oakley Adama a macadam tumor believe it or not dynamical DOMA all the stuff earthenware stones dung and earth a Mikado let me tell you let me t researcher not even me the ROM Baro so doesn't make any sense to say oh by the way if a slave makes an emblem made out of clay it's not macabre Toma it's never macabre Toma even if you make a real full-fledged dish out of it is not Mikado yeah I mean also my taxes right now obviously we're talking about metal and if we're talking about metal that's the concern that you're gonna pick it up and slap it and loose around him oh my Mac the law position itself alright see what's going on there IV see how quiet it is here it's like impassable that's why it's good that you interfere sometimes good at the very okay so you'll fix it a little bit where's no I'm why does it what no I know he's here I seen but why don't you talking on what's going on with you well here he is yeah that's why I that's why I said I know how you guys think I prefer the the Sheep although you never gave me the meat that that chief what happened to it slowly and freezer okay we said we're gonna use it for the sium Recep the Shabbos better some sheep whoever there's no in middle of the sea ohm we were sitting down we're making aciem in norms house all of a sudden they said they wanted to give me a gift also they come in with a live sheep literally allied sheep into the thing and a psychic comes along chef did it and they chopped it up showed us the meat and they said okay this meat is gonna be for the sium since then a couple seemed and went by and I didn't get the meat he still says it's in his freezer we'll see all right and then he's gonna buy like a 2 kilo of me from the store said this is your meat I stopped I thought all right let me Zeus a Ferrari you can add go out with a bell on his neck I'll be right to a bezoar she big suicide I don't want it I don't want you I don't know I believe you I believe you I promise you go back home see he's here he's a real everything she said Mario su bazooka make Susie you better not drop it off I'll drop it right back Zook ships have are at my light why can't you go out with a bell around your neck Dilma missing muscle I see it might fall off and you'll carry it should be tsunami what's the difference between one around your neck and the one on your garment if you're worried about falling off or fall off your clothing if you're not worried about falling off so you could go out with the one on your neck what's the difference listen my music muscle I ca how come my skin under my Cobain mom call what's going on here is that a professional put it together a professional sewed it and if a professional shows that it's not gonna fall off who could you have won a Brit unless you have my professional that sells my stuff okay there Ivana braids that have you sure Dahmer have won a braids are you sure cultural Arab like Gazoo remember yesterday I told you to remember this this one line the guimard is now using the same line we said yesterday and a completely different context yesterday we said I don't with that picture hold on a second this is how it works it's back in the book here you guys remember this picture from yesterday koichi clock I said coach o'clock whatever I said yesterday so anyway that thing Ramona says that it's Arab it's woven and if it's woven there's no hats Itza over here we were using the same words for a different thing completely and he's saying since its woven in you could carry it nothing to do with water and cut Itza you get Gary that says he said it he said those words and he meant to include everything whole shoe or ugh like Gazoo anything that's woven and sewn in like that there's no zero that the Bell is gonna fall off but if it's on your neck it can fall off and if it falls off you might carry it on my merit five lines from the bottom Lee takes it bahama Lloyd bajos Navarro but like the hoisin should be soo saw the lye bezoar should serve ro the law position su so an animal cannot go out with the emblem not on its neck not on its garment on its blanket like we explained really big sheep it's a Varro and now with a bell on its neck Valera music she looks sooo so ok the Duke service everybody knows in Switzerland they those cows walk around with the bells not every cow was every twenty cows whatever it is but it everybody nowhere where they are vis-a-vis a a McCallum Toma by the way the bell of a cow is that Ackley what is that how do you view a bell of a cow it's on a cow what is it for what purpose does it serve so it serves the purpose of you knowing where the cow is so what is that believe it or not Rashi says that is considered a vessel for a human being it's not a vessel for account it's on the cow to serve the owner to know where his cow is so it's actually a CLE for all of them and that's why it's Makabe Tomo Oh but it says like this visit a McCallum toma sama kabul Tomo this Zook the Bahama a macadam - ma we're gonna see this grant I just jumped ahead to ration our normal days the zoo today made me come to MA why does a bell why is an amicable tumor very me no Zuko Bahama timaya yeah you don't read a babe at Smail it's not a non-kosher the the bell of an animal is Tommy if we stop right here we have a question you just said that a bell is not Makabe Tomo and over here it says Zuko Bahama Tamayo it isn't a capital o okay now we turn the page that will cause some debates we're gonna go through a whole bunch of different uh lavas we have to remember the question the question is that a bell of an animal is Nick Altima this is like this Michelle Delos the Huayra a door knocker they don't have them in Israel that much but in America everybody has it right that little a bell on the door it start why because a door is not macabre Toma why is it door down McHale Toma because it's part of the ground it's attached to the house which is attached to the ground which is not macabre Toma so the bell on the door is also part of that navigable Toma now so that less don't don't lose focus to the question the question is why is the bell of an animal why are you telling me it's not Tommy and over it says it is stomach we're just gonna say other our losses she'll tell us versus Alabama if you remove the knocker off your door and you put it on an animal so you took something that's not macabre Toma and you put it on an animal that has potential to be macabre to mirth was made directly initially for the animal Tamayo why because in my mind I made a tummy so I can make something from not Tommy - Tommy for instance if I am creating a bell so in my brain I could say right now at this moment I'm done with the bell I'm not gonna I'm not gonna send it anymore I'm not gonna take it I'm done I'm gonna sell it as is so in my mind I made it Tommy not Tommy McDouble - Toma right now could be me Kabul Toma so same thing if I have a bell that's on an animal I say you know what on a door I don't want it on my door anymore I want it in my mind I'm saying I wanted in my hat on my animal so now once I say it in my mind I wanted for my animal it's susceptible to capital mo so bahama buzzerella Della's now if I take an animal bell which is Makabe tumor could be Mikado tumor verse all at Delos and now I want to make it not susceptible to be in Kabul Tomo that you can't do in your mind anymore I have a piece of Hebrew Liddell Asik for MS Miriam even though he's screwed in as tight as you can into the door or bend it with nails Tommy it's still macabre tomo why she call like Halen yard with a - muscle mass Java then elimidate' - Muslim L - inna myself the famous line in Chasse that any anything that is not macabre Toma and I wanted to be susceptible in Kabul - I could do so in my mind but the reverse I cannot do my mind if it's acceptable to be in Kabul Toma - take it out of that category I cannot do it with my mind only if I change it now by putting it on the door and fastening it with the screw did I change it no well I did it is I took a bell and screwed it to the door nothing in the Bell changed the bells the same exact bill as it was a minute ago it's just attached to something okay that's not changing there's a fascinating tie sir son Amidala I don't kind summoned out of it it belongs to this to these lines right over here that Isis says an amazing thing if a woman takes her garment and donates it to a safer Tyra just from now on I want my tickle whatever she wraps her head with I wanted for a say photographer so they take it and they wrap the secretary with it did anything change in that garment absolutely not nothing zero it's the same garment it was a minute before and a minute before it was susceptible to mass measures of a woman his thesis now it's not susceptible to Toma because something did change since Isis you know what changed now it's a sabaha no that's a change in the actual garment of the same photographer it went from not being a certain in Ana - ah Savannah that's a physical change since Isis it's amazing clap it's a it's a very interesting cancer for all of shots you didn't change anything there's nothing under a microscope there's both they're both the same exact environment but how logically you made one into a macabre into ah Savannah and that is a real change in terms of tumor and that's why it's not macabre to him anymore all right says the kymaro yeah I mean change the halacha [Music] right you change the purpose of the clue you went from a woman's garment to a safest area and therefore changed neurologically in a Savannah and therefore it's a physical change anyway so back to the original question on the one hand we said that a bell on an animal is susceptible to come a little and now we're saying it's not or vice versa so the Gemara ha it's like in ball ha the last they Leslie in Bowl what's an in bow yeah this thing right over here you all know what it is but we need a picture today that guy this is a bell yeah the ding dong ger the thing that makes the sound that's the in bill in bells in the bell very nice oh that's a good Rav keep to those artists it's in Bell what's inside the valve that makes the noise give out it so if it like a show The Isley in Bell if it has it then it's me Kabul Tomo if it doesn't have it now the Capitol dome afraid to give our amount of shower now the Gemara understands right now that this Bell no I'm still laughing from your joke the commode understands that this Bell is an re it's a tack shed it's an ornament so who hears if it has the in Bella doesn't have the in Bell how does it help my taxes it's a beautiful piece look it's very nice even without it it's still attached alright because I have this little guy that makes it more of a tack Manav Shah Iman who if it's a CLE it's not a fabulously endo alive mono in Burma shabbily mana well just because it has that little ding dong in it makes it a clean in yes it does they move enough mainly on my river his song really son we're not talking about attack we're not talking about an ornament jewelry for that we're talking about that actually makes noise and it becomes a clay becomes a valuable vessel of noise when I Animesh Mirko Berkley my talking shoot or Mary how do we know that if a CLE makes noise it's susceptible to tow machine Emma called over mer learns from this world of Arts extra lovers like deep are like talking called over CEO of ABH severe beige I feel ooh deeper yellow beige even something that all it does is makes a sound if that's its purpose then that is a CLE MMA law its Makabe último the my Kindle but the last in bow you're telling me that if it doesn't have a ringer the sailmaker then it's not a couple two more mmhc awesome so let's talk about the milk case of a slave says by his slave the Lobos itself are a slave cannot go out with a bell on his neck remember we spoke about a slave with a bell on his neck I mean I'd say music should be suicide but on the one on his clothing we made a distinction it was made by professional it was sown in not Sonnen miss Arizona cattlemen two more in the bottom table to heed the Lesley in Bell Capilouto but if it doesn't have the ringer so why isn't gobble to murder me no voices economic tensions Valeri saw Oh in the base hammock - they had bells they made sounds when they did the Qataris Shack call yo Phillip summon the sound was good for them something so they had a bell Valeri saw and they put on the baby's crib they put bells so when the baby woke up it would move the crib it would make a sound put him back to sleep Lilith Muharram interesting round she says the Rebbe had a shlep his Tyra you're right and those days was made out of parchment so you had bells on it and every day you take it home and when he would go to school in the morning he would walk by the houses and the art rabi's going to school and all the kids would run out and go to school yeah sure I'm embarrassed harm what and those days was simple they didn't have recess they went from morning to night and they stayed there and they didn't complain they didn't have anything no snacks the little device teenagers and a bid by the way yesterday I forgot to mention this how to remember that thing that chokes a woman that's actually a bib I forgot to mention that that it's a key word it's a bit if you looked at the picture of yoni it goes all the way down on the top it had a choker it was really a bib now she says anyway so the babies had these bids the kids had the bibs and they had bells on it yes lemon belts ma'am yeah really you saying that online it says something about chokers having to do with double chins not having double chin it's an old trick from those days but it actually is relevant today okay now what if you wear a choker you do ever it's so-so don't have a double chin don't wear a choker don't worry charlie bit on that okay so but in those days they wanted a chin a double chin so they wore a choker very good anyway it says like this yes lemon belts me a lime in belter Hyrum its ESMA forage that if it doesn't have the dingdong ger then it start but you're telling me that by a slave if it doesn't have the thingy it stomach so that's the question is from this line a lamb inbuilt are you now Niccolo emblem a tiny muscle Mullane if you have a bell and you remove the in Bell from it it still susceptible to Tomo since the Gemara so we have to answer we have a question if it doesn't happen in boats as it start on the other hand you say that if a slave has it wears it without in boats Tommy what is it Hanuman Liberty Noack says who are these two types of bells the maitre to do is for the teen Ike and that's for sound why does a child have one to sound to put him to sleep to bring it to either whatever the reason but it's sound he's not wearing it to look good they call a vidi the same thing with a cow I need the sound I don't need him to look beautiful I have a god dog but a slave tack shadow casually like I've got lastly in ball why does a slave wear it not to know where the slave is but did for him to look good Oh so therefore he doesn't need the in ball he doesn't need the sound what he needs is the outside the exterior oh my man it will a Medina terminal I am even if you remove the what does it called in English the in bone how do you say in balloon English in Bell is uh no the thing that makes noise you don't have a you don't have a thing okay here look it up over here a clapper very good okay a clapper I would never know that a clapper hmm you think okay it's one thing to another one piece of mail that other is a clapper okay makes sense so if you don't have the clapper you remove the clapper oh yeah exactly because either you're limited the three things were sure that doors are lame Kozue okay but it doesn't have a clapper the thing that turns off the lights the clapper but what are you gonna do with it so what you have the exterior part but it's not a CLE it's like the Gemara understands it's a broken clean right we all know that love if you have an oven and it's tumba you want to get rid of the tool what are you doing give it a good zet it breaks in pieces and that it's not time anymore so if I have a if I have a bill and I remove the clapper I remove the in bow it's not time anymore it's broken clean oh my bio-oil share had y'all have zero one answer is a value and he says no it's not considered broken because any person in the street could just take it and hang it in the Bell and you're back you're back in business that's one answer Robin's answer we're gonna see is because you could take the bell without the clapper and bang it on a piece of whatever and it's gonna make some sort of noise and that's also good massive Rawal so Rob asked the question has argh valuable keyboard so we had this we had a very similar so key before I'm gonna see it literally word for word when you have two calum connected remember we had the we're gonna have it soon this that comes apart doesn't come apart if it's a consider won't clear or not right so the clapper and the actual Bell is considered connected if Toma touches the outside Toma touches over here the clapper becomes Tom eight Toma touches over here the Bell becomes Tommy its people the heat a Malky kottmeier oh so you see what do you see from here that if you don't think you understand if one is dependent on the other not like a biased says Oh since I could put it together if they're not together then they're not they're not a bell you need them to be together it's they're so dependent on each other that if Tomer touches one part it's as if the other part became Tommy so if they're not together then they're broken the heat a Mohican African village I became an the Mojave dummy perhaps you'll say oh no it's so easy to put the Heather again then it's considered macabre it's considered connected McMahon has a bomb question on this force on you know my spy Rochelle paraca and this guy this scissors that comes apart right it's Cutco you can get by you're sure Aaron brace yourselves Cocteau a foreshadow okay look at this that lock is will say about that that law says this is considered connected only when I'm using it but as soon as I put it down it's not even considered connected college gambit but I should have a higher if it's if it's apart it's not connected so how can you tell me that if a bell since I could connect it easily and this also look how easy it is to put together it now it's back together again if I could put it together it's considered connected it's not considered connected even if it's connected it's not connected either about maybe they're right sir even our scissors that could come apart but if I'm not in middle of using it it's not it's not connected so if it's really not connected the two pieces are part apart then certainly it's not connected so what are you telling me all because I could put it together easily it's considered how logically connected that's not true have another Macario Macario me the time my spiritual profit these missouri hit me you guys remember this we have this that signal welled up Memphis manage these things you have the Carpenters plane and in here you have this blade that goes in so they can they considered connected when he bore the tumor if you touch one part or the part is thought maybe he realized off but to sprinkle dashes of the peridot you have to sprinkle both parts we said that then it's look warm raw I mean I'm out of shop and we asked the question if he were who if they're considered connected I feel Eliza then it should work even when you sprinkle me like he brew I feel to Minami like my mother Sean I'm a rabbit very of shots philosophy Bobby no to Vanessa so we answered back then and after Memphis meteorites is considered a he bore regardless for sprinkling for Toma it's always a fever but it has to be bitch-ass Malacca while you're working it she loved your channel aha a nuclear alert over those up what if it's sitting on the shelf it's not connected at all they're not considered connected the gods are Alma smellavision Toshiba shots melaka they made it zero always look camera so when it goes the tumor we always say they're considered connected everything becomes Tommy and when it comes to a soul which the homer is the opposite we don't want it to become tar so we say everything's considered not connected by other assumptions about whether you're working it not working why is made Lahoma the bottom line is that you see that when it's not being worked let's say the scissors you're not working it it's considered disconnected so certainly a bell that's physically disconnected should be considered disconnected and not Mahavir LOL moreover so going back to the original question what's the question if the bell doesn't have a clapper it says it's Makabe toma but why why what purpose does this serve without a clapper that's the most question I bagged you says ok because I could put it back together easily oh my Raffaello mirov ohio variety show garbage Terrace it serves a great purpose it's still a bell if I want to call my kids I want to say that recess is over I think this and I bang it against the table and it makes us down now it's not gonna make the beautiful sound of a bell but nevertheless is to sound so Raschi says very interesting we had a similar thing if guy has a basket and has a big hole in it it's still Makabe coma why because it could still hold pomegranates up to a hole the size of a pomegranate in other words it's not the greatest basket in the world but it serves some sort of purpose so to this belt it's not even the greatest Bell in the world but it serves the purpose of making some sort of sound it's Miami American you know hope it ready like he talked about her ass or Roberto my whole butt really got mad baby mine Latino I can use the clapper the the bell and flip it over and use it as a cup to give water to a child no I'm take it away please you know