Preparing video...
0:00 / 0:00

Daf Yomi Shabbos Daf 5 by R’ Eli Stefansky

2,828 views
Mercaz Daf Yomi by R' Eli Stefansky avatar
Mercaz Daf Yomi by R' Eli Stefansky

Transcript

Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.

all right you ready we got to go okay all right boys I hope pack day today sheer sponsor Louie Louie Sh Monsieur Obon are you late Chava consumption and Ally is sponsored by the le watt family of New Jersey multi in and bet Shemesh oh I didn't speak into it Lili nish my co yo Ben are you late oh yeah that we can take off yeah we have a very very special guest speaker today thirty to forty second speech na thum is looking at me like crazy this is one of the world's most popular children we have here in pajamas we have over 18 schools happy birthday to who Mandy Mandy [Music] so we're gonna get to use it Noah Miller Wow we got one for Noah Miller also here we go all right anyways going back to in ramappa challenge we have I think over 18 boys schools anyways this thousands of children one of the most popular kids in Rome a patch a mesh is Rea cami on ski and yesterday as I was leaving show he had a big bag --is-- off him on us and he comes running over to me and he says here's a shot from honest for you I said for me he says yeah I love you I love you and he went on saying something and I asked if you could tell to them I hope he hope he says the same thing here tell everybody what you told me you don't get coronavirus why is that why don't you get coronavirus if you learnt yeah who did I save my dad rabbi okay let me seltzer okay so I saved two people you should go yeah thank you are you a give all day all right yeah no he came spontaneous I'm not kidding him over he said you he said you saved my dad from Corona like what the good news is the good news is that javi decided yesterday that he's not going to America he's gonna go America but this is with the 14 day quarantine he said he was gonna go and now he's not going I'm real quickly we have what we'll see the rabbi Stefanski Mazel Tov on finishing Broca's I just wanted to take this opportunity to thank you for the wonderful summaries of the Deaf they provide a great way to do cleanser after each Dave laughs I really appreciate the effort that you must put into the preparing this your cold tub and much of lava from selfish Chavez and the rest of shots get on Moscow all the way from Melbourne Australia and then McCart Ellicott sir we have a guy from our BSA I'm not sure why he's not here but it hi been listening and watching the full deaf for all the Broca's give Val dick how did I start I live in our base for 20 years two cycles ago I learned I've younger the rubbish mold cats also give out the and I never finished the entire cycle about a year and a half ago Hill Abrams got me hooked Belova which means I received a lop dates when a new video came out the kids are he subscribed YouTube I can't watch the sheer okay one year ago full stroke fully recovered so this had do you want to make a change in his life oh it's pretty long so I'm just keeping around there they made a version anyways well why not start with the rest of the world so I haven't missed an online chair for the entire bravas all the way to then give valve ik here's a guide that did every single share online here are a few notes that come to mind I wanted to share with you from the Maseca I'm gonna skip them that's for me private it has to do with hearts and palm and popcorn and Nagumo thank you very much for making consistent learning going me easily accessible I'm with you every day whether you know it or not even though I'm only a few minutes away from the new da VI me Center thanks I plan on continuing with Shabbos David block RBSA I'm sure he has reasons for not being gear so you sure kya and with that as Nokia okay we are holding back to David block okay you know him okay doctor give Alec valid all mode Bay's we are a middle of a sucio it's a long story it's ending on deaf hey I'm at Aleph I told you the end of the Suki yesterday I cheated a little bit the gamora's question is if honey I know everybody said yesterday was a little noisy but that was poor and we let it go today let's get it together and let the item here if a person Sean if a person a nominee we call Minami because he's standing interest arab him he takes an object and he transfers it to a different domain into saying how could places it on an usher develop ices hand the Bala base is passive he's just standing like this he's like a shelf he places it on his hand the unnie was over an Akira and the Hanako and he skive for malakas height so the question is why and my hand is only five inches wide by five inches or so unless he Shaquille O'Neal 9 inches by 11 and she's fine but you're still not at Fort him you need to be at Fort welcome to be a mocking for she say often why is he over mm-hmm different attempts multiple attempts yesterday we said maybe through makeva who says you don't need four words for him we went away with that now we're gonna go to El Amin of Yosef where it becomes wide ha Manny Rebbe he it goes according to Rebbe now there's a couple of options hey Rebbe which one he's a male Rebbe the Sanyo Zaraki no a Gabi's is we're talking about a person in racial Sir Robin and we're talking about according to actually a transfer of four amis in versus a rabbit he threw something in rhesus Arab in Wanaka Gabi's is culture it landed on top of a branch doesn't have to be four hours Rabelais hi EV the haha meatboy dream Rebbe says you hive and for America hominem say your Potter Oh says the Gemara Hossam kid the beam on LeMay Meyer they come on kid a bio over there so you see that you don't need for it for him because it says call shoe it landed on culture even uh Nicole shoes okay sitting tomorrow no you can't say goes according to this Rebbe could abide on my Rebbe Huckabee lon how a Mythbusters are Yahud Vannoy a no delicious Arab him it's a very specific case of a tree that's inertia say of it and its branches come out interest you surround him with zorag Wanaka know if I and it landed on its branches the Rebbe sovereign renown should they know if I was in Cairo it's a different I walk over there it's a la ha whether we consider the trunk of the tree which is for 12 m and an extension to that trunk would be a branch that goes into Sir Robin so in fact yes it landed on a branch it's very narrow but we don't view the branch as a narrow branch we view the branch is a very thick trunk robot inside really I mean should they know people see choroid so it's not important to us that Rebbe it can't be that Rebbe ilaaha Rebbe this annual Zoroaster surround mr. Robin Bruce alabanza worst case of what we had yesterday yesterday we had a case of Russia sailors do good they were playing ball between their houses now they're playing ball from one Street to another Street and there was a backyard in between yeah I don't know think about an example oh I actually come out I want to print it I thought about an exam I forgot to print it there's a guy in China who insisted I'm not moving his home I guess they don't have eminent domain over there I know what the thing was and they made a crazy highway around his house three lanes he has his house I don't know how he gets in and out he probably doesn't he but he uses action that would been a beautiful picture so they're throwing from the three lane highway over his house into another three lane highway what who was that Hills on it we're gonna get it Ivy's on it we'll get the picture in a second it's a crazy picture there's one in England also another miss Choe gonna visit Sugarman England - okay by the way that guy in Chinese the one that started the whole Corona thing starting tomorrow that's what happens he went from it's just her rap into her saucer album he was throwing a ball over the guy's house and what what what why no publishers around so much no no soccer is all the way to all the way up which this Rams up until ten which we're gonna discuss in a sec that's too small I need a big picture okay he got it here we go oh it's a nice it's a nice it's a nice picture we need a bigger picture that's that's a during construction show it afterwards yeah I don't know they have the absolute they have the picture fine let me shine it we got the picture though this time he's arguments around juice around with elements ready math I have found poetry maybe says you've hired a home say Pato Barbuda much more the higher-value rubbish type act as muhammad saw but a Kozma who know so what Tate saw remember in the mission we learned that some means from Russia say yahud Teresa rabbit and fromage schuster rabbim should say yeah that is called Han awesome so now he started out in which mr. rabbit he threw the ball over the house and we should say okay and it landed which is around so first of all he didn't know so he went from Russia Sir Robin taursus I ahead we're gonna be learning like we learned yesterday the concept of clue talking from Konami oh that's where we keep us the concert danube Akiva that what whose cake is who I'm confused it the life cakes going on there who's Baracus also who'd look at me show Nicole as it was passing over there was just a rocket it landed how logically was just say Akkad excuse me what did it land on did it have for two of them to land on no it just landed on the ear the ear is not for him so you see the concept of rebbe that you don't need for its tool and then it also took off from its just say your head oh my gosh this is a beautiful picture otters I okay here you go here we go and for the viewers crazy picture okay so anyway yeah why but that's the we said that yesterday there's no doubt amis the sold out for him it flew how big is this thing this thing is a few inches and it and it was Nick lot in the air where's the doubt there's no doubt for him in the air no on a piece of ground it's not doesn't mention anything about that Atmos you don't know where it is first of all the air caught it and so we have to learn I was I was also wondering the same thing maybe how logically it is a Ford Falcon but it's a lot of concepts without a physical force Wacom so hmm but it also took off from Azusa Yahud to Shuster rabbim that's why ready says you have two times your high freud so for taking something from mr saye from that crazy house the middle and putting it on the other side versus a rabbit yeah but I'll cope on him what no it's two different shoes look one is northbound the one a southbound to diverges oh no you're doing around forget talking about lanes going this way lanes northbound southbound whatever you went from here to here now so I kept on him you see the aside with that going into great detail you see that he's sorry that you don't need fort welcome according to revi because he's doing a hell of a landing halakhah take off without any fort welcome Emily by Akira Blair no huggably mocking my Bible says the Gemara that's not a good writer poet Mara law Rabbi Shmuel diameter value Lima hi Robbie L versus hi me Clara we're talking matters she say your head that has a ceiling Damron on basic command the mallard ami I had a few years ago had the opportunity I went to visit one of my properties and the property manager she said you have to see this apartment we gotta go see this apartment I said work it's gonna be surprised Wow was it a surprise we knock on the door and a man in his 70s opens up the door like other Mauritian before the head some like them no problem right there she says this is Ellie he would like to see your apartment oh no problem come in you walk in he's a hoarder in other words there was only one foot path in the entire house you walk in there's pile to the ceiling everything newspapers soaps deodorants everything you walk in what he couldn't find his clothes I'm assuming I don't know he walked in and it was a bedroom there I'll never forget it's a bedroom that the door there was only junk up to the door but the top of the door is about six seven inches and there's a cat looking at me from the top of the six seven inches and I went into the bathroom he had four hundred toothpastes four hundred toothbrushes it was the most incredible and I'm thinking myself I should just raise this guy's rent he's no he can't move it's a math law I mean then the story was that two weeks later she told me that he killed himself in that apartment and when they emptied all the stuff out they found 70 guns with each one had a laser scope on it his son came and donated it all to the police whatever that was that I'm only saying this because the Gemara says that when you have a roof what it happens to be legal to have somebody like that you have to it's it's a hazard and the fire department doesn't allow anything like it's a big problem these people anyway now as I'm thinking like it's Kamali Adame mamak Mallard ami I'm visually visualizing a house that there's no room wherever you put something on it you are you're it's a shelf wherever you put it it's there canal you dummy that's what it says beso that has a roof Kim the Mallee Adhamiya there is no ear in a private domain it's all full so no matter where you put it it's as if it's on something mmm so may may law so it doesn't apply to us he Rabi says it's only talking about it should say y'all could make her oh then it has a ceiling there Mena basically madam madam avishay a no mackerel oi now okay she asking so what what's our case our case is talking matter is just a yakitori should surround them portions around Thursday Yahoo this is the Ani standing in which is Arab him he transferred it into the the the Bala bases hand and we're asking why is why is the Bala basis hand considered fourth welcome so this whole case that that uh that Rebbe says that you don't need you don't need fort for him because it's as if we're talking about that it's it's a say okay that has a ceiling on it it has their ceiling that's why there's a special offer or for talking because it's full so no matter where you put it it's full you put it on for talking but by us but he came I'll Konami bit McCoy are you gonna say maybe in our mission we're talking about ceilings everywhere okay enough we should say okay ed McLaren okay or should say I forget have a ceiling Canaveral which is a rabid McCormick hired but you can't put a roof on it was just a rabbit once you put a roof on which was a rabid murmur of shmoop are you though I'm already a mere baap I would have one arm around I'm advocating desirable species are having a rope at door if there's a ceiling which is Arab you Balter why we may live ashamed diamond of the dig layer miss Bart everything has to be exact like it was in the mid part all our malakas we learned from Delevigne from the mid but from the Michigan and in the Michigan in the mid birth there's no ceilings obviously when Clara brought their stuff through the Michigan they went from Rosario clitoris Arab him or vice versa there's no ceilings there so you cannot say that there was a ceiling mistress around their tents had ceilings but the reserves arrived and then never ceiling Elham Arabi zero so now we have to go to another attempt what is going on here in the mission of a guy put play something in somebody's hand which is less than sports bottom why is he trying how many I've hired me this hanging up here ammonium ormaybe my Maliki Bell high of a carbon crime of akeeba Potter beautiful you playing catch with somebody we're all familiar with this you're throwing it 50 feet and the guy the guy catches it so who's hired who did that keeper who did I know her the person that threw the ball he did that kiriakos he threw it he also did that naka because his throw is designed to land in a hundred feet in the guy's glove but if the guy is running towards you he runs towards you since your throw was designed to go 100 feet and the guy ran towards you 20 feet that's not where you wanted to land so who caused the landing the catcher so he caught it now what happens if you throw if you do in a key row and somebody else does I know huh your partner yeah it's awesome the rabona but your partner militarize you're playing football now yeah you threw a pass as a short pass and the guy comes towards you you thought you should come to know you through it that just go 100 feet you threw it on two feet but is it you by mistake threw it short or whatever or he won it doesn't matter by mistake yes he is design they said it was designed to go a hundred feet but he decided to catch it early well it was intercepted exactly it was intercepted beautiful the doc who came up with the frisbee knows a high pass it was a high pass but the guy jumped 14 feet in the air and intercepted it was the low pass the guy died then he caught it he went to the what do you mean it can't be over 1012 no it could go through and welcome to and then land in a multiple even still be five I think there's a let it go through the mother again not Hummel for those who didn't understand the guy through he was a picture he was throwing it to the mound and the catcher for whatever reason and decided to be miss sugar was poor him he ran out of his spot and ran towards the pitcher and quarter middle now the pitcher didn't want that the pitcher wanted to go all the way to the to the plate to the batting backs and the catcher decided to do something else so the catcher ruined it for him the catcher made his own hand aha two people that do one melaka art Potter long did Akira one did I knock about it's gonna get more interesting or bus it's amazing stuff I'm happy McCoy might be ki belt-high of oh but if he if the catcher sat here where he's supposed to sit in the batting box he's hired hobby you know and I know if I got a mocha my ball but like y'all but his mitt is only one foot it's not for talking says the Gemara Elish mom you know they begin the mocking my ball you don't need you don't need for so this is not fair we're not there yet we're gonna push this off also I still Mario do not know who delay be you know what here a beam on from here you owe me see you don't need to land on Fort welcome you don't see that you need forth but you don't need Fort welcome for the Akira it's interesting because yesterday when we asked the same question of Akiva over there we had a really good Raya that that's the case because over there we said where we keep it it wasn't my hive two times when he threw it in the air we said there wasn't a take off otherwise if there was a take off you should be fired twice that's Araya that even a hero you know anyway the Kumar just ask the question since you see there is a difference in rebut kiva between a knock-knock hero that pinaki need for him a kiri you don't need a fourth problem so maybe this town also believes that this is thirteen enough anak Kira fine and I know hanami another question Dilma deposit time Vicky blow who told you that he caught it in his hand maybe he had a very large talus and he went like this he made a tent and that's how he caught it which is a little bit of like the Konami Anoka O'Meara babo must nice inky going she keep low but rascal beanie I forgot my tricycle the Konami I know how it's talking about yeah we had a basket had a basket when the unnie puts it in it's not it's not his little hand it's a fourth basket nope oh boy yo DK Tony doesn't say anything about a bask in the mission it says a hand today rascal should be all done look we don't we're kind of stuck now tomorrow says we tried different different ways we said maybe you don't need for its box and maybe it's this is that we don't have a good shot so maybe the shot is there's a basket and you're asking me why does it say in the Mishnah so yeah so if you want to stick in the word basket fine what a nut Rancic was just say yo kid well Transco be shoots Arab him should be ceramic should say Yahoo do you can't have a basket or just Arab and that turns it into a socket and that would be a problem labeled Alegre be a superb you to the sign you're busy you the white man a boy sigh everything is in the Gemara even my favorite game which happens to be basketball it's me forcing the Gemara that they used to play it it says here like this not scorn abuse a rabbit they put a basketball pole in riches a rabbit uber rush or a scow on top they put a basket this is all rock and they threw into the basket right why is it called basketball because here I prove it to you I have in here this is what it is this is manage the Gemara they put a corner in the floor and they put a basket they forgotten those days they didn't clap they put up lad and every time a guy scored a basket they went up on top and took the ball out until some genius said wait a minute we don't need a bottom we could just make it this it's called the basketball if you look closely here's the Israeli guy giving this guy an elbow and this guy is shooting like yo whatever anyway listen it why have thank you okay this is just joking Noah right over here I heard he's still playing what oh sorry is the basket on top of the thing this backward came later oh all right so no it's called retribution Rosie Trask girls are given a hug a ball and the ball landed on top kai of the game is reviewed or possible by city of the hoods we know something here the Chelonia might have mr. suhaka does Rosario had come a pig according to Herbie I see that this is considered we should say Yahud even though they're playing basketball in the middle in the middle of the highway this is Rosario could why because you have a basket but our society needs tent welcome so here we're gonna just mention briefly that there's a concert called good a kazoo kids though we have that in sucker and that's you pretend that the walls go downwards that's why I have these arrows here you pretend that the basket extends 10th welcome down but we have a major problem here that it's pretty obvious that like mr. Pfeffer keeps on saying or like even documentary before it has to be under 10 fathom because it was just Arab and once you go above 10 12 times 9 which is arriving anymore and that's pretty much what the guitars gonna answer but it's pretty obvious fine a field theories review the homeland mallow-blaster Oaxaca LaMotta mass or so this is difference between above 10 him it's an yeah 10 him and that makes it a safer dr. Lamott oh my sorrow if you're a nurse Arab him and you below 10 him see still a rucious Arab him casually Larry Bevo Mikoto neat rascal should be other again this hope chat doesn't make sense it says that he has a the only put into a hand it's sort of you should have said something about our basket well you're the guy Tony along river vogue you're going to show you're the new shot Oh loop shot why don't they need for him in my hand keep going to shill shell Yoda lomatin especially kilo we're talking about the concept of love would by the way yesterday one of the best lines was you saw me guy comes to my house for money because I'm gonna give you a corona Sholem Aleichem love what is it good enough as he said love I like to know cuz he he was sensitive to because the other guys they couldn't care less they're like licking the hand and I saw Malaika I'm kind of thing this guy anyways love it what's love owed anything within treats for him is considered what about the you shout me that comes right into like he's like breathing over here my thing I hope he doesn't have Corona I really am what I gonna say get back on ski yeah okay this is the the further away you are for me the more you gonna get I promise you but I'm feeling okay I think yeah but ain't no ain't no publish matter as me wish I assumed I could save you guys I can't say myself okay guys just so y'all gonna mataman slice of a qiblah something about the concept of love are you asking him his hair doesn't have fort him his hand is the ground the ground has a lot of talking to it since my hand is within 3,000 we all know love it is from suka you have an opening that's lesson sweet welcome you just close it i logically my hand is as if it's on the ground mike the ground is for him not a problem so the guar goes through a series of big deluxe nobody likes no hugs well i remade Kotani it says it says before she the guy was standing so how in the world if he's standing how in the world especially Shaquille O'Neal how does your hand 312 him from the ground doesn't make sense be by saying uh vaca Thani I meant the Shia easily he could bend over he's doing made them be by say ma big umma he himself is in a pit Minmei law his nose is on by the ground level so he sticks his hand out like this oh so he doesn't have to bend down he's actually standing yeah he's standing in a pit you boys say more bananas we're talking about a banana sorry bananas it's not part of any important I think but if it's porcelain today one is support Mitchell I'm with we're talking about a vertically challenged human being I mean Maine law he has no issue of putting his hand close to the ground three spot it already is three time I just copped now he doesn't have to bend his hands at three twelve from the ground fine oh my over each boat panel Ashman on kahani Rashi explains it beautifully the Mishna tells me yaaayyy so what the missions should have said is that each then did is beg it says Rashi you want you want to get me to fort for him you don't have to come up with crazy ideas the guy was vertically challenged he's he was bending over he did see that just say he extended his garment like this he made a tent with his talent with his towels cotton whatever it is and he has for talking so you tell me the word y'all die and you tell me that you have to come on to all sorts of also obviously from the Mishna says Yoda it means that your hand is enough l Amaravati shall Adam this is the final final shot and this is what we we understand your thou shalt Adam Superboy valid a Dalek hello ha a human hand has a logic has Shiva's of 4:12 my for him some people say because a hand could grab very large objects that are for him it has the ability to do so you have a thumb your fingers or in the Mishkan they would they would do that they would use their hand as a 4x4 it has a high Shiva's a hand as a Casillas as 4x4 well thank you all so Robin over at Alicia Lanka Superboy she'd Aled i'll darlin and that's the end of the so you finished you're asking me how could I place an object in somebody's hand when it's not for him it is for him it's a force I look for welcome my small hand how logically is force for him just like any other force bottom shelf all Melvin are very loyal and not battlefield it shall have a row if I have listen to this this is a beautiful Schuyler if I throw a ball into my friends hand I am kyuf by throwing it I did in a Kyra buy-in landing in his hand I the thrower did ha ha ha because that's what I intended it to do try it Micro masculine the other enchilada has sugar Lloyd get dolla dolla dolla well I'm telling you he'll share that my friends hand by him catching it it's considered 4x4 by Mario be little called the Zin though he already said it Mao the same Mahanama later the action of a Julio day that's because as a pitcher I want the catcher to catch it and consider it Kruschev and I want him to catch him I may look I established that hand that I'm looking at as a fourth hand a belated election bully all day hey Maloney maybe in this case I didn't think I just threw the ball and he caught it maybe I wasn't much of it as for commercial on no matter what every human hand has shiva's of 4x4 America venerable ireland almighty McCoy I'm a big key Bell higher if the catcher did it move one inch huh what is the case that is the case the one they discuss it they do look inside you'll see well I'm Cory we keep a higher oh come in come at the key bail Potter in case that we had before if the catcher comes towards you listen this reverses give Alec if the catcher comes towards you the throwers Potter why because he intended it to land somewhere else the guy that decided to get up a middle and run towards you and catch it earlier he's the one that did that not that he ruined your hand off her you wanted to land on your feet from you and now landed only 50 feet from you the both put them in there right so because there's no Akira nothing for one person Tania Nami tiny okay I've here in my room oh it could be the keeper high above come carbecue but that's what we had before barbie is a nun listen this give out get cash or Zorich aphids vinegar memo because of the key blame ow what happens if you threw a ball and then you stow it in one place you went like this like in the cartoons and you ran ahead and you caught the ball or like his case you threw a frisbee let's say you intended it to go on your feet and it was like traveling real slow so you know what I could catch myself and you ran and caught it in the middle wasn't this cash it's unbelievable you intended to throw the frisbee on your feet and then you decided afterwards to intercept your own throw and catch it after 50 feet but you're not supposed to be a hundred feet from there but you intercepted your own throat you did that hero and the Hanako maybe you should be higher but maybe you ruined your own enough cuz you're never supposed to be 100 feet and you made the 50 feet what do you do with such a question it's an amazing question anything now well first of all you mark it all so always apply stuff to different things that's the whole thing good-morrow you take something you learned over here you apply two different things aren't you present but it's give out leg because yet that but yet really truly understand this fara over here is the shot when somebody else you because it's another human being intercepting and that so causes it or it's because it's another place that I was intercepted and that's what it ruins it maybe because it's one human that did both back here in an alcohol you should be tired I understand the other child better even it's not where was supposed to land who supposed to land a hundred feet from here and then landed 50 feet from here mr. Pfeffer Federer and me the net government Koval causa the Keyblade mouth maximum brother over a bad ever have a snake like this bottom become a ballet since he did both things back here and an alcohol Snake Eyes about the method called him fo da me the higher V should be higher or do mawkish neighbor named Adam dummy he now just intercepted his own pass he should be you should be like another person here who Potter there's no there's no real resolution to this take Oh fine so do you more remember whenever your Kanaan pitchman co-leader cats are very weak people make shaman Boyd see this beautiful sparse here today a guy sticks his hand into his friend's backyard and receives rain is that in akhira my boy sighs that in akhira I took rain from my friends it was raining I went like this and then I brought through sir rabbie is that in that Kiran I know huh nobody's answer me nobody noticed was that hero what I mean here I have two pounds of rain in my hand why is that ear a lot of rain a latter rain a reveals of rain for a visa rain what was that hero yeah but I didn't pick it up yeah it's a trick I did pick it up it went into my hand it went into my hand I put my hand to catch it but that's how often it's not my hero Akira means I have to lift up the lift up no I didn't oh it's as if Tony put it in there what's inside she didn't lift your hand oh no Barry became a make Charmin buoyancy and he went from Azusa Yahud - she's Arab him kind of muscular zero malli you know have a Roy I'm a Latina so my aim our first mission says that if for you Omni has to lift it up if somebody no forget that we had the other case I have forgot to bring the picture the guy drew it from a guy who was a guy they loaded him up with fruit right it Tina Sherman what's the difference you have to do an interior you have to lift the object off the ground it's not enough that somebody puts it in your hand it's not good if somebody puts it around evenly over that Kiro he didn't do that Kira says the Gemara you're right now the camera tries the Gemara knows the answer look marta is okay there hug Amara we can go through different things to see why they don't work like that Makeba ellicott Oh first attempt is he went like this for the raid here's his hand he goes like this he's paddling it so maybe by paddling the rain into your hand that's an act hero yes if you go like this that's not on that hero because it just happened to fall on your hand and you have lift it up and you didn't have to grab the rain somehow so the first attempt is he went like this this is how he grabbed it no a touch pass it's called in basketball have all but you know knock here amalga be mocking my rebuff alekhya wait a minute going like this is nothing you need for him going like that is now for its welcome armed rebel cabaret their Abu Nick you going to call that my god be a coil attempt number three or two is that the rain is coming down a wall a wall is fort welcome it's a vertical wall but it's moving the rain is moving down the wall and I see you stick your hand and you start catching rain off a wall I got a question I'm evil I know it never rested it's in constant movement motion constant motion Kodama Rob because I'm a super ok so now the gamer goes in but this what this multi could all these these Farzin apply all over to anything in the world and chasse and in life your honor angle so angle slows it down right we know that vertical is gonna be much quicker than our angle so you slowed it down somewhat haha I mean because I'm a super it's a little bit uneven but hey kid with the Robo where does it say oh this is not that family base for your query bit safer I scoop all here I brought a safer with me says ratchets a megillah' very interesting so he's reading from the safer and it goes like this it falls out of his hand and I'm the school for the school for is a car Milus because he's in front of his house he's not in his house he's on the stoop of his house it's more than 312 above the ground Benny's gal de laatste from the other you know sometimes that when that happens with the soil vapor just rolls and rolls you don't know what to do it and it land somewhere and then you have to start rolling it back up that's not that funny goodness Gaga we all know you go last like so what do you like to do you let us start rolling it back up you go like this roll back up why this is a kind of building good to be other I'm still holding on to it since as if it's in my hand la Hill actually yeah the swords welcome go ahead so if you didn't get the tents of all came away from the ground you bring it to yourself Misha Gill I saw its ballgame - I like South you go like this here's the beautiful crab it's not a real Magilla and you don't want people to see this because it's not nice it's a bazillion on Shabbos to lay like that for ten hours you flip it over like this you go like this now we're good nobody sees what's going on here and it's not a design to the Megillah to the safer in those days by the way everything was written like this right oh come on all restrain him whatever was is written on clap on its grow Vivino bone we asked a question am i hope i like salve holy no he never rested anywhere but Miraval because I'm a supe what does it mean it's tent bottom it's dangling pen thumb above the ground so never rested so still in your hand and it's like this big deal no it's not like this it's actually on Honor on a pitched roof what oh that's what ignores gonna ask so the safe air is on a pitched roof just motionless right it's a safer half is in my hand the rest is spread out on a roof well rather than quite some soup that's the Gemara what's the connection to our sugi a madama reverb is safer that doesn't move at all Dobby denied Miami gravity 19 but water on an angle is going to continue moving so never had a point of resting so you just grabbed water without doing enough here oh you never looked at something up that was not a motion lifting something up that same motion is not a nikiro el amarillo volume shot you're going to call out my Gabby Gumo he took water from a puddle he took the top portion of the water this is ignore Google cheat oh yes and obvious he just took water that's not in motion now the same on Miami Gabby mine Lavin oh ho ho commercial on so Luke shot and so hitters how did we view water water that's resting on an ocean floor this ocean it goes a thousand feet down so is the water stationary or moving it constantly goes like this what is this because the water is laying on something salad we view it as laying on something salad why because water is water and it's laying on water that goes all the way down to the ocean floor and the water in ocean floor is on something salad so since it's one one item it's all water it's all the same so the water that I just put down or the water that I just raised even though it's moving it's as if my hand is also moving but the bottom of my hand is on something stationary so it may load the whole water is one piece that's how we have to say that that's the chap Lamine F kameena what if you put another type of item on it what have you put oil on top what if you put a ball on top of the water it's floating and happen the water it's moving that's not 1:1 in the same with the water as the Robert I'm a drummer over Mayim I gotta be my aim high no annek awesome that's considered placing down Edgar I gotta be my aim love hina on across sony says rubber but if i put a nut a floating nut on top of water there's no one alpha it never rested because it's constantly moving and a nut and water are two different items you can't view it as one Bhairav oh here's a very interesting question edgar is Beakley you put on a nut you put a ball let's say in a little boat a little play boat now compared to the boat it's not moving but the boat is moving with the water how do we view that you have what no no no you have let's say a bottle full of soda the battle is moving on the water but the soda is not you know I'm saying it's like it's 10 seconds its threat for life but there's a high enough hot in the battle and the battle is in the water it's one that once removed from the water eglee's be clean and cleats I forgot my Buster excess linen do we view it we do we look at the nut the walnut Vaseline on vinayak and it's resting because it's resting on top of another piece of something or Duma Buster please lean on play naive deny it but the vessels constantly moving has no it has no rest take oh nope shot no no resolution chemin should suffer gabion oil naturally for that but why McCoy distribution on the new river a Bonin mug is it is now chairman safar Gabi I mean not that foolish a man we have chemin of true moe that's floating on top of wine but fool you're the person who's Tommy he went to the mikveh that day but he can't touch true MA until nightfall but he's it in between Tommy because he really did go to the mikveh but he's not under center yet and then he touched this chemin how do we view it it's two separate products you have oil on top one on the bottom I touched the liquid on top did my finger touch everything all the way to the bottom of the vessel which includes the wine or just touched one product called oil like Parcells chemin bad don't you have a menorah imesh name a kibarim zoella's e the both connected so my Melo what Oh so if hold on a second so according to your banner menorah that they're both connected so when I place something on top of it it's like the it's like the the oil which is not part of the the wine is connected to the ground so the walnut that I put on top of the water should also be connected to the ground the two items why is a walnut different than oil oil so what the way is also moving which is moving on top of wine but they're all the same we say wine and oil are considered the same even though this is what to keep products what's the difference if I put a walnut on top of water the two products and they're both moving they should be the same according to your inventory court the Cohanim not should we stop right over here unfortunately how about one more minute Oh Marvin remember Larry Bittman hyeon a Halima masculine states of color in cooler a guy this is an amazing thing we have to understand there's a gay I didn't have any intention to do Anna Kira I know you want to walk in his house and then it's a big sodium it's a big figure we're gonna stop here forget it well after I'll have to start tomorrow