Daf Yomi Sanhedrin Daf 80 by R’ Eli Stefansky

[Music] good morning [Music] ra this Sunday I have a special special announcement probably one of the biggest announcements I've ever made so get ready teas it's a teaser get ready dear belly my name is C hefter and I'm 12 years old from Baltimore I joined MD wife for San hedin after joining your official grosses mdy initiative I'm proud to say that I've never missed a day even when I had the flu I also got my several several boys from my class into mdy and they also watch the she special mention to Yakov Pano zevy Minkin Ellie Kastner and others from my class who have joined this year in school whenever my rebi comes into the classroom in the morning my whole class says good morning rebi at the end of the day we say Reby have a wonderful day of course we also say meni V when things get sidetracked during class and Ashi approves when we want to do something which the school doesn't necessarily approve of email this kid thank you for making to and gar interesting and something I can understand and be able to discuss with my father have a wonderful thank youmo should we do it again whenever my rebi leaves in the morning the whole class says rebi have a wonderful day of course we also say meny V when things get Sid TR v v v and a she approves when we want to do something which the school doesn't necessarily approve of De that makes sure that we have your jokes and humor are so much appreciated as a dentist gives me an opportunity to crack a joke from time to time with patience thanks for the material I thought this might be interesting to you and the MD audience I just read an article about a procedure that some doctors are able to do in order to restore Vision to restore Vision a tooth is extracted from the patient who can see in this case they use the Kine which is appropriately named the eye tooth as it generally sits just straight below the eye they drill a hole into it and put a lens into it and then buried in the cheek for several months where muscle type fibers wrap around it and then it is removed and sewn into the eye socket allowing a patient to see and some patients they have clear enough Vision to be allowed to drive yesterday we mentioned the T concept of shen but I think in this case we can truly say it's a here's the link to the article wishing cousin penny a continue Alex Gilden Penny Gilden should have a big surprise here in this is during the other night some people get a little bored [Music] okay here's ABY Slayton in a ski resort somewhere in the world don't don't exactly [Applause] [Music] knoww oh this is uh let me just read it in Hebrew thank you for making it up so interesting I started three times I started uh with you and bastro and and I do a shabas one day I was giving the shear and I I was surprised to hear my one and a half-year-old scream out ah so we started saying in middle of the day even my wife says in the middle of the day now so the kids I like this kid this is unique check out how he finishes One of a Kind oops I don't know if a kid should be saying that in front of his mother he [Laughter] says rebell I was thinking to myself why does a frisbee appear larger the closer it gets then it hit me [Music] I noticed today also actually noticed this I read recently to is the of who that's why they brought a a keyboard here they brought birth the get very nervous when they dive in a because we say they get very they walk out it's a whole they do a whole thing it's like the Democrats in the convention they pick up they have signs they walk out they do all sorts of stuff reading I noticed that so somebody sent on the group a nice he thought it was a nice V I thought it was nice too that why is it called carbon Ted because you do it every single day you have a consistency so why is it called Ted because when you do something consistently then it's a Ted then it's kyi you're not doing it all day it's not t Okay anyway I thought it was a nice connection thinking thank thank you for changing my life Benny Maslin Mig B identity crisis have caught up from broas B he caught up but he's really only from Milla now he doesn't know what to do cruise no Cruise ps picture attached from man to see him my wife jokes that I haven't washed my left hand since this picture was taken uh me wsbg if you remember 720 you got the thing fixed over there because we heard there was a stickle issue you scream out before something I don't know no okay yeah okay yeah yeah of course it's going to happen with h one day I'm going to meet him he's working on a meeting another point you mentioned this phenomenon about many times before someone they get better for a bit it's not let them go he makes it harder for the the addresses this point all the best me wbg Toronto this is me wber those of you that's why I like the pictures I get to remember sure I definitely remember now I for sure remember boy said this is not we call him he comes to the Hebrew she he's in Baltimore and he found in Baltimore their Greatful family ANM started learning at AG 70 and continued for 32 years until he n Anonymous for the unity of the Jewish people Glenn esterson with love and gratitude from wilington North thank you for enriching my life with monthly sponsors sponsor the daily sponsors and so happy didn't know that was also born on my uncle on a second y the seventh of the of is today by bur my great grandfather Asar the two suits made suits yum Goodman best actuary ever have to run the numbers on that of the month reell the STA to make so many and in honor of maraz for all the work they do question we're holding B kind started the [Music] gar there who which kind of person who doesn't have he's and you don't have to give him okay so therefore you can't answer you anything within 20 years no but yeah but there's there's a new one after says then huh kills in front of bzen kill him front of said no we said yesterday it's a problem we said no there's a problem you can't kill him because [Music] G [Music] [Applause] [Music] h [Music] [Applause] [Music] [Applause] [Music] [Applause] [Music] those of you who don't know Robert Earle married off his son last night and after what I think was a very very long mitv he's here early in the morning tremendous as he's done in the past tremendous tremendous you think you feel guilty that's why okay that's sometimes yish is about the guilt there's a lot of guilt in yish it's okay that's what I do I'm good at it I'm trying to guilt everybody into coming after their kids weddings if Robert could do it you could do it so the question is what person doesn't require so you said what anybody else huh very good according to one cover what else what about it you have to say it better what is it called who who theis the guy that causes other people to do have there's more no yeah very good the question what else yesterday that's the trick I thought you have a good memory you don't have to doar I'm kidding I'm kidding all right um this one if you know this one this is this is worth a lot of points especially if you didn't do this stff yesterday who was rud's father ABA is true that is true you got to well and who is his brother who are who was his rebi rud ra and and raud okay so we're going to see his father is very interesting story towards the end of the D um so the mishna says that if there's a murderer who was mixed in with other people you let them all all off the says what kind of people are we talking about we're talking about regular innocent people so why would Ruda argue and say that you put them into a a closed area and you let them all die you feed them barley and they die what they're innocent how could it be that he argues on something like that so one shot was that they're all murderers they all had aarin but our murderer didn't have AAR and he got mixed in with the rest so they anyway they all deserve to die we have whether you let them loose it's not really let them loose there's a rambam that says you don't let them loose you put them in jail forever it just means they're not in the keepa kipa is a little bit tighter and there you feed them this barley that their stomachs explode okay I don't see it in Rashi I don't see other I don't see an argument but that's what the ra says then we have another seven lines from the bottom certainly when it comes to human people to humans everybody agrees that you can't just because one guy that's a murderer get mixing with the rest they all go out even even if they are murderers that but he didn't have AAR how could you can't murder one of them or any of them because one of them didn't have a there's no verdict there's no final verdict so so we would have to say according to the ra they would all be in jail not they don't go Scot free but they don't get the death penalty over here we're not even talking about human beings there's a certain pen that in the pen they put all the Bulls that killed people and had a verdict and this one bull over here he killed somebody in the middle of the deliberations and he got mixed in with them we have the famous the puts together the bull and his owner so you have to make a comparison the way we kill the odor that's how we kill the actual bull you can't you can't kill someone without uh having a a with with the defendant in front of you so too you need a bull in front of you they're all Potter all the Bulls are Potter however what's the they're all Potter now let's take the rambam you don't even need the Raab here it's already everybody so what do you do you let them you let them all loose you can't let them loose they're also why are they also because some of them had a if this and what about the one that's also why because a living creature cannot be he's a barrier so that's it they're all we're going to see more of it soon no we don't just let them do not you put them in a special pen and you don't feed them you feed them whatever and they die on their own it's more of like a grma cause them to die they're all Potter says they're all Potter says even if my father the God was one of the people they all they're all Potter what does that mean here's depiction you have a bunch of hams you have one G one Rabbi they're all Potter so first of [Laughter] all wow wow the hate man hey mail that I'm going to get no I'm md.com please not me don't I have nothing to do with this I have to rethink some stuff here he's out before he started what's your name g Goldenberg pal Alta California pal Alta California wow gar Goldenberg wow and what's your name you're you Gladstone glad from curst and what okay awesome anyway what do you see from this picture what do you see from from he's talking about human beings even if my father is part of them what does it mean even obviously not talking about bulls is saying we're not talking about human beings we're talking about bulls on this exact thing comes along now the other thing is even though he's a so we're not talking about it's a question on on both that we said the one that we said yes the one we're saying today even if they're human beings but we said they're all they're all murderers most of them had this particular one didn't have a but he's sticking in a sadic over here it has to be still a sadic otherwise he wouldn't say even my father if his father killed let's he was the gadar and he killed I'm just saying rash y over he's gar and killed then he's no longer gadar he's a rash so then he also wears one of those vests so we had a guy once I just I just thought about it some of you will remember I had a we had a see him on my porch when when the she was still small one of the guy gets up he says he wants to say over his story his life story there used to be a Harley-Davidson guy and he does and it went on and on it was over a 40-minute speech in the beginning was interesting and then it's like and I had this that and fire the do the do changed my life okay anyway so we had one of those guys so obviously we're not talking about that everybody is a murderer and we're not talking about that they're all Bulls something something's going something's offir by saying even if my father is one of them are you allowed to say are you allowed to say let's say your father's name is MOA my father MOA my father MOA says is that a normal thing to say let's say K son is he allowed to say my father is that how you speak no no no his name was his name was so over here they want to prove that if you add a title ABA you say that the title then you're allowed some people say some some want to say that he never said he he said AB the adds that his name was if that's the case then you can't prove anything from here then then there you can't say your father's name with a title his name yeah what do you mean exactly his name was and he and as a son says so says no what was talking about something else if a gun went off between two people one of them is AB obviously AB did not shoot anyone he's a g he's not shooting people and a guy there's a murder that happened right here and it's either AB or the guy with the funny vest and the and the earrings and everything but it can't be it's the can't be but you don't kill somebody based on a can't be based on a whatever you don't kill people like that and that's what he's saying huh they say I don't know it's you have to look it up they say that by when they when they hung him so there were two Israelis that pushed the the button to to let the floor out because they didn't want any one of the two to like have a post trauma so they both they both did it so now neither one of them knows who did it nobody could take well it's not it's one just the other one two people are standing there you don't know which one did it huh say cleans some oh oh here no no no no no R the for sure agrees in this case 100% he agrees you don't kill them and then thear continues so what happened by us oh what happened was there's one bad guy he got mixed in with a bunch of Good Good Fellows here we have a picture of it here there we go check this out no you missed it you missed it you missed it you m sheing you missed the whole thing this guy got mixed in with the rest now there's all types in here if you look closely there's all of them but there's some very innocent accountants and this and that what do you do you must kill this entire group over here I looked it up today there's a place in America called King Ranch it's 850,000 Acres meaning it's 1290 square miles there's a place in Australia called Anna Creek it's larg Ana Creek Station larger than this the entire area you in in America King Ranch has over 35,000 cattle 35,000 cattle so I was thinking to myself if you really don't like the guy you take a wble one cow that's after the and you helicopter him in the middle and you run they have to kill all 35,000 cattle there's nothing you can do they're all why you're not bottled there's no B on AO it's one cattle doesn't have Australian accent King Ranch King Ranch look it up crazy 850,000 one guy one guy owned it rules yeah of course you can't identify you yeah oh now it okay yeah you're right he faked the brand he took the brand off and put it on the other one I don't know why you're talking about a branding branding some of them having in the ear yeah I got it now let's think about this for a second let's say you have 100 cows which are very expensive each one is about two $3,000 they're expensive you have hundred couple $1,000 you take one cow that's M you put in between you have to what does it mean take each and every one and stone it to death it's a lot of work now you have to hire more people in bezon and do it why because one of them is so in order to perform the Mitzvah of on that one you have to do it to all but why kill them the answer is because you can't benefit from from any of them either way you're not allow to benefit they're all because there's one of them draining around over there and you don't know which one it is so if you can't benefit from them you might as well kill them and if you might as well kill them you might as well kill them with the skila I disagree it's too much work that you going to have to hire 25 people for for four weeks stoning and stoning and pushing off until you bring a a bull each one is a m it's a half hour it's too much yeah yeah yeah yeah exactly exactly Financial no that's what I'm saying unfortunately when I when I I was a little kid I was 10 or 11 years old I was in in in and they I don't even know maybe today they still have it they have tens of of chickens and this animal called AIA I still don't know what it is exactly what is it amongus amongus got his way into the pen thousands of chickens and killed five of them and the Rabon had to come down remember as a kid there was a whole thing I think we have to pass we have to tra everything because we don't know which one of these chickens the mang was attacked and if attacked it it becomes a trade fund we you can't really see you can't necessarily see the signs the outer signs you went crazy you know eat one after another just kill kill kill it was was a game for him overnight they wake up in the morning now Financial loss Financial loss what are you going to do what happens if you have a mad mad cow disease you got to get rid of everything you have a thousand you get rid of them all you two them but it's only two three you don't that's how it works somebody has what is it called the those viruses in inside the salmonella whatever it is Calli next you don't you don't ask questions so now the says something very similar these two sheas that we have whether you take all the animals and stone them whether you take them all and you put them in a place and just let them all die by themselves but and we have a similar a similar place that what it says so just to the bottom of the and the is going to explain exactly what's going on it's very simple and it's a fascinating question you have a pregnant animal who killed a human being and we know we have to kill the human being what involvement what did I say oh okay I have no idea what they said I have to go back you have a cow that killed the human being you have to kill the cow now what involvement did the cow did the the the fetus have in The Killing have any involvement is it part of it not part of it could you let could you allow this baby this calf to live so the it says like this she killed somebody then she gave birth there's a birth before the verdict you to benefit from the fetus from the calf but if she gave birth afterwards this is a concept in the entire in the to the the fetus is actually like the the how do you say the hip the a limb whatever it's one of it's part of part and partial so if the mother killed somebody you don't say oh but the heart you can benefit from the heart the the fetus the the Uber is like the mother Yosi did a phenomenal job here I like it a lot I hope you do too that the fetus is one part with the mother boys say take a look it's part of the it's part of the mother it says in the sign over there it said and it says on the sign okay this this is a real shil I mean if you I had this of my father waking the entire family up at 4 in the morning we're going to we had to go to we go to 770 would go cuz they they had karus early in the morning sometimes you went to the other places and if what happens if the woman is pregnant do you have to purchase two chickens maybe she has twins three maybe she has triples four kids a whole NE what if the baby what if what she's carrying a boy so you need for her a female chicken and a male chicken but maybe it's a girl so female K it's very expensive the vill says but people I think are on two chickens the the says one chicken fine so says the how exactly it happened you can look in t but but let's just say that the groups got mixed in there's a big mix up here sorry this exactly what we learned before who she does this they put them all in a and let them die by themselves that's it's just reverse the are reverse first is then the you bring them to bz each and every one if you're in that King Ranch in Texas 35,000 cattle it'll take you about 35 years but you'll get it done fine now we're going to go through it just to explain I think we have a little bit of a chart here let me just see if I there's three there's three times here when the when the mother if there AAR and then she gave birth then the Uber if she got pregnant and gave birth between when she killed and the then the Uber is M because the Uber was I thought it was cool also how it pops out maybe it's for later I don't know even though when she yeah yeah I think though it's later I I messed it up fine we'll use it later when she gored she was pregnant how could that be that if you have a uh bull that gored and she gave birth let's say there's one Aid or the owner even says my bull gourd killed somebody also you're not allow to use this baby you're use this calf for a carbon so you see that rub holds that if the cow was pregnant during theault the calf has the same as the mother you can't use it not like what you just said why saying here not so much maybe it's different than it's as if she was part of this she added Mass she added weight to the mother she's part of the of the salt and therefore she's AER if a human being had relations with an animal then the animal becomes AER he we look at it as if this pregnant cow the the the the Vlad inside the cow also had the is done to it and that Vlad is also a ask what seems like a here it's going to shock you for the first second you think about you might even have a terrce or a se you think you have a teret if that's true that a human that has relations with an animal it's as if he had relations with the with the Vlad with the calf and the calf is a so comes out you're not allow to have relations with a wife that's pregnant because then you are having relations with your a mother and a daughter at the same time later on the talks about it's part of the mother it's not it's not it's not an entity on its own okay you can't kill the because you're going to kill you can't kill them both in the same day when you can't so okay you don't do yeah that's something else that's a that's a of eating and maybe kill it as is you don't have to wait until she gives birth you mean in the case where she gave birth so he says like this if that that's this this thing on the chart now we introduce this this new if she got pregnant and gave birth in between the two what is it what I want to call them the two uments events thank you that's the word I was looking for the two events there's an event of a where she killed a human being there's an event of verdict in between those those nine months she I don't know how many we say five months for maybe it's nine months for I don't remember it's four five for small animal n six I don't remember the name okay let's call it nine months just to be safe there's nine months in between she got pregnant and gave birth then the Vlad is 100% M why because the Vlad did not participate in the murder the Vlad was not present at the verdict but if she gave she got pregnant and gave birth after the verdict then this is a birth of is now let me ask you a question why is the vad who's the father the father is a kosher guy so you have 50% kosher 50% an animal that had a bad verdict against it okay but it's only 50% why kill the baby so the says if you have two parts to one you have one Vlad That's created by a z in a cave and that Z in this case is kosher also still even though it's only 50% it's still also great I understand why you have to kill the blood if you have 50% and that's the that if the father is a good guy he's an accountant then the Vlad even though the mother is a big Russian she's the Vlad is M as wasow over let's do the Turning of The Da turning of The Da sponsored by Adar Global experts in International Financial Services by Dr Allan and Barbara l in memory of my dear Father Joseph on his 45th Y in honor entire y family I think I said this in the Hebrew share I don't know if I said it in the English share hold on Benny I want to I want you if you could stick around okay forget it I changed the gar a little bit not I didn't change thear I changed the years I don't know if I said I'll say it real quickly one of the sponsors today was watching on Zoom which he watches for years already he's watching in zoom and he noticed that one of the boys that watching in Zoom he had a leak in a ceiling he said the story lot but it just show I said in English too I said English okay galic hello now now the hint is getting closer and closer because you know now could take off some of the sponsors and this not dailies okay but whatever there still a lot of monthlies andas and all stuff says let me change it around a little bit if before the verdict she got pregnant and gave birth then now what he does is he's splitting the pregnancy started before the verdict why what then how do we view it the parents let's look at the parents of this cow the Z is certainly a kosher guy what about the mother kosher because no verdict so you have two kosher parents okay then there was a there was a verdict and the verdict was also on her pregnant calf the fetus that's bad yes the pregnancy it's a joke they say it about a human being but the pregnancy was M two both parents both cows they had a they had a it was a good it was a good union but when she gave birth she was already the mother why because of the famous doesn't make it retroactively that was already a bad go so the V should have been bad from the time of right no let me ask you something let's say let's sayar did and you benefited from the milk yesterday so you going to have to go pay and you did is because retroactively you benefited from the milk the milk was koser then the vad kosher up until the verdict the verdict it's not it's not think from now on it's we said in the mishna you have two people one shabas one is a murderer one gets skila for shabas the other one is supposed to get S for murdering and they got mixed up they look similar and they got mixed up so what do we say you give them the the least the the the lesser the one that's instead of SK is the most according to says we have there's a question in in if you could do something like that let's say somebody deserves Skil could you give him can you give him could you give him another he's going to get the most the highest can you give him something less is it included or not came and said by the way if you are M shabis we're going to give you Skil and then because of this reason because they got mixed in we we'll give you instead is that okay is from you'll say look he supposed to get the worst of the worst and now it's going to be a less painful death it's going to be quick maybe yes maybe it's not why doesn't have an answer over here we have an answer that if I give you for the more severe one it's included in that why because both of them are death it's a death Penal just how do I kill you I kill you with a less severe one okay it's within it it's not no I can't prove from here anything I want to prove that it works but you can't prove why because there's no on the type of we talking about that he didn't say what what's if you you're going to die he didn't say skila he he didn't mention the word skila is that good enough or not so Revol I think I heard this I think it's R Who says but it's a good for parents and don't ever give an empty threat don't ever tell a kid if you do that you don't know what I'm going to do to you it's going to be the worst punishment you ever had in your life you have to be specific you have to say exactly what it is I'm going to take this game away from you going to put you in the corner for 5 minutes I'm going to make you write your name 100 times but you have to I'm not going to let you go to D to the DA tonight so that's what some parents do yeah yeah the younger kids it's a treat treat so but empty threats are nothing we had a kid here we had such a zic kid he's like a 10-year-old last night he says when my rebi says I'll give the worst worst punishment we all laugh it's nothing if he says I'm going to not let you go to recess that's a bad one but don't use T as a threat don't use T as a threat why maybe maybe it's a good thing he's showing the so so I don't know I hear I hear what he's saying says you need this look it's a new one this is 23 all you need 23 show the face M like drone Fage it's crazy okay you need but check this out read these words carefully and also they have to notify him that there's going to be a Mis over here but it doesn't notice that it doesn't say which one going to be death and that's enough no it's not enough you have to notify him that it's going to be so to went and what I do with the with the person huh what you say they look similar to the bad guys so the truth is the whole Tyra is is uh is but the M he was and over there obviously they didn't tell him by the they didn't say what death he's going to get cuz they didn't know look you don't have to tell him what death don't bring that was a once in A- lifetime thing that's why there was no but Rashi says over there's no as on what death and Rashi reminds us it says in the that part of that is you have to tell the bad guy you are going to die he says I don't care I want to die like he's matter he allows himself to die so but that he knows what death he's going to get Story the father of this is the answer was the father of he told R's brother his name was Ry here so I did a a little chart this is not Yoshi style this is uh stansky style but it's going to have to do today O then the colors are off oh I used the wrong thing okay so green you'll have to get you saw this blue and red and then it turns into green for some reason I don't know if maybe if you could turn off the go into the slide and turn off the animation and then they'll just stay it says like this in our mission if you notice it says the bottom one it's important we have the top and the bottom look Hebrew would say this got mixed in that the that is much more than the this the is scull the one guy let's call him in the many in the if it would say the reverse would say it would be the few in the many of in our it actually says it says the bottom one but when rud's father was teaching it to R's brother he he reversed it didn't like it he says sorry what are the many does it make a difference says says to review the yes does everybody get skila in this case the top case top case a guy that deserves got mixed in with the skila why does he get skila because was more Hummer I can't give him the harder one so give them skila says no the reason is in that case because there's many against one you have to go with the r and skila is the r you have to give him skila you missed the point then I'm trying to say that you go with the lesser the Lesser this less severe uh Misa and over here you didn't make your point over here I'm going with the that's not the point he told him very sharp don't teach him like that is GNA say how do you talk to a father like that you tell your father don't teach him like that the reason why the Top Line you give everybody SK because they're the maybe I should have put two stick people two stick figures so it's because it's it's more and it's rough fins okay fine but you get the point what do you want me to say I want to say like the bottom line deserves thank you much better to me now I could see it not green thank you g the the the RO is but because so severe I'm going to give everybody now makes sense so he asks him I thought about that but how do you explain you start off nice but how you going to explain the end in this case you should get that's not true why you getting straf in the bottom case because the isra not because do you have the same question you asked me on the top I'll ask on the bottom you're right it's a good but who started the conversation started the conversation why I'm telling you no isud so the re tells rud I asked in the beginning who's Rab's Reb R and after R was then became his Reb so he says don't talk like that Shar he always call him Shar how do you say like that to your father how do you talk like that to your father if you see your father being what is the worst thing that could happen to a human being I thought about it this morning I came up with when your daughter returns from Seminary and she starts telling you I learned in seminary that you're big Russia which one did you go to had to get you back to and then the father is secretly thinking to himself I can't wait until she goes off the D until she calms down she cools down you know it takes a few months T you didn't do this well that's not you say KES you have to wear your hat during benching we learned this we learned that out no you have no idea what I'm talking about you know about these fmer girls that come back and they try to make that's what's going on there so what do you say you don't say you did it so it says isn't that the same thing says in the what you're doing is wrong says in the here's the you say you say it nicely in our case should have told his father the Mish says I'm sorry and then you're supposed to figure out that I reversed it to the son by yourself you figured out have a wonderful day shabas shabas quarter to nine