Daf Yomi Sanhedrin Daf 45 by R’ Eli Stefansky

[Music] good morning live from Park City from my daughter's home for my son-in-law's home which happens to be the Park City Jewish Collective headquarters you hear that Park City Jewish Collective headquarters I want to say uh tremendous to the MD a bunch of guys got together and got us this amazing amazing tray of here I even have a picture not only that um yeah yeah I'm getting there hold on oh here we go here's the picture of the meat board let me zoom in a little bit the meat you can see the meat it came cold and fresh it's unbelievable here even have the has all the names here of all the guys that D it beautiful like this this is how it came in the mail in a box with the ice oh in a box okay so thank you so much um what else do we have here today first of all I got to do the good morning RAB from the slopes you guys are Pros so you're not going to be impressed but there are other people that live through me vicariously is that that something like that so here we go um do you have sound I'm putting on sound mark good morning boys it's unbelievable unreal this this is great [Laughter] unreal so Ruben Harrison renewed for $1,500 a month Salomon Marano $500 a month shim Brun increased to 180 shimy Bron ah I wanted to show a video from him maybe I have it in there m Schwarz 101 Elliot Shalom 52 maim Stein 36 Jonathan TK 36 David Joseph 36 SCH gml 18 Sean saxs 18 Gabby grin 18an clet 18 James E wolf 10 and we have with us yonah bookin who's also that's where I recognize the name he's here with us today as well and he's on the MDM monthly.com giving to all the hundreds of people that are on it literally hundreds so it's a big watched the shear together on Zoom with a pre- sheer here you guys could see this over here this mon is shabas uh par boy at 11 PM I think because the shear here I think is nine o'clock so is that okay 11:00 in New York is :00 here that works out perfect they don't have to stay up till 12:1 whatever they do over there usually B me monich whatever however you pronounce it the did not like the way I said it last time manrich 1301 East 27 okay gal that's the I don't know if they do weekly maybe yeah maybe not I don't remember anymore uh a new talmid good evening rebell I'm not the type to write in but I felt compelled I started the D with m the started hedin what is that 44 da and I'm in shocked that I'm still here 42 da I never would have thought it's possible I've been trying to get on the dam B for many years now but to no avail if you would have told me two months ago that I started the da get up an hour early every day to watch the sheer live and still be doing it 42 days in or da in I wouldn't I wouldn't have believed you I find it extremely difficult to stick to any to to daily routine stay disciplined with with these sorts of commitments especially getting up early part I'm proud to say they not just hanging in there fighting stick with it and not to lose interest quite the contrary has become the highlight of my day I find myself looking forward with anticipation for tomorrow's da to borrow the Shor of your famous line I came for the da and I stayed for the Yi I owe a great great you hear that I came for the da and I stayed for the Yi I think I heard that line before I owe seriously I owe a great deal of gratitude to you for all you do thank You On a related but more technical topic one thing that does bother me is the fact that I find myself constantly unblocking blocking than unblocking apps like YouTube and Spotify to watch a share although I generally watch it live on zoom in the morning there are days where my wife needs an extra hand with the kids in the morning and I need to put off watching it until an hour or two after the live stream is ended for some reason the shear is uploaded very quickly the Spotify it takes much longer on other koser platforms but kiter this guy is one of the managers manager customer support for 246 it's the kosher Spotify he wants to know how we could get the oh and he says like this I'm might because the it's only on audio now the shear is on 246 but it's only audio in my opinion doing the da with MD Audio Only is kind of like eating haing without a cracker or kle The Taste is there but it just doesn't feel right I think I would have to say differently it's like eating the cracker without the Herring not eating the Herring without the cracker it's garnish without not garnish but it's it's like the main thing is the the visuals and everything else but okay there are a lot of people there's a lot of they just listen to it and I I talk about these chars and they have no clue what's fly I was speaking with to my friend kid it's a very long thing but bottom line is I apologize for the criminally long email great should B you with's amount of children gr and peace of mind to spreading to amongst with much gratitude and appreciation mha from that's an here's uh it's an email in Hebrew but basically this guy is on a plane and he just started the with Sanhedrin and thanks for adding so much to learning and you can't imagine how this whole y thing he came back from from and he lured 30 D on the plane because of the shear he was inspired by this idea that talking about people learning on the plane he learned 30 and you that's you know the famous song [Music] about what else do we have also let me just do it this larger from his grateful family Larry started learning age 70 32 years until he was you still there you hanging in there you need AAR I have a I have an iPad hold on when we say his name we're all gonna clap right for the unity of the Jewish people Glenn erson with love and gratitude from Wilmington North I love this one Wilmington North Carolina Wilmington North thank you for ening my life with and of the week do Eisenberg in honor of the Burgen War the mon firefighters had their turn family loving memory of we have to have two of the brothers in our big they sit there um mainly no one is in the no they're both in the English one they both speak perfect Hebrew but they're both in the English here and part Gans in honor of my father-in-law Daniel benedict for turning me on to mdy with her belly I didn't see this before wow can I say I get on the phone yesterday with Daniel Benedict because his son in-law Gans and his grandson what's your first name Ariel Ariel came for three and they flew in he tells me he flew in special just to to see the sheer live and to do a little skiing of course but that that's a side thing but he really came for for the and he says you got to speak to my father-in-law so I speak to him the guy tells me I've never heard anything like this he learned in ponich and he learned in TI those are two places I learned in he does Real Estate which I do he flies a single engine plane which I used to do and I own the small plane and he owns a plane I think right owns a plane he scuba Dives he skis and and and safaris the kids are uh yeah I've never heard of so many similarities he says but I don't give a Shear okay but he's a great guy and he turned his son-in-law to the DA and now his grandson to the DA what enter the Yeshiva he might be the first guy in the new Yeshiva no no no no is not watching now he's in America he's he's actually on a Safar or something I don't know what Ben and Dan Kaufman in memory of from her two sons enjoy doing the D with mdy should have an Al by Leon Welter for the Speedy release of Aron Ben Hilo eser G Rosenfeld from je and a participant of MD who's been incarcerated in prison for too long yeah take him out art of the month for forelli and the whole MD staff to continue to make toy so enjoyable for so many out of the month in honor of Yi Klein and Kazi for all the work they do Bo was starting a brand new Mish if you recall yesterday as they taking this guy that's they take him to the to the place where they throw him off the uh the roof the 10as away they say okay do TR now we're four armas away which is a 8T away they remove his clothing so there's a very way to show that let me show you it's very oh yeah turn this around here we go enjoy here you go the pill is clothing off so there's one issue that there's AA we don't want to see an AA so by a man it's enough just to cover from the front because that's the only place where it's visible from the front to make sure that the covered completely it's necessary to cover from the back as well don't worry about it only a man is Nal you do skila perform skila without clothing that doesn't even apply to a woman she wears her clothing says for this scarf for the the liquor drank his tonight so I can say whatever I want this is the name of his organization he a big goes around it's a great name should have a lot and a lot of people should send you money back it's all they say not necessary to cover a woman because she's already cover she's wearing her clothing where did they get this from just say what's we know we're talking about this individual that he has to we have to perform SK what's it's extra word so typically if I ask you why does say is z so say it means only perform skon not in a but that's not true says the we know for a fact that if a woman does the same a she she's not immune to skila she'll get SK as well it comes to exclude women woman gets he you remove his clothing but a woman no this this uh idea of removing that what does mean it should be him against the stone there shouldn't be anything um cushioning the blow from the stone so it's without any garment so that makes no difference between a man and a woman a woman also no clothing says very interesting thing here perhaps the reason why Ron say that a woman should be wearing a clothing is because we're concerned for illicit thoughts people that are there might have a Ruru so I was puzzled by this until I saw Rashi what do you mean are learning this from AP they're not making this up him not her so it's a so nothing to do with it's it's not it's not dependent on what think in regards to it's dependent on how they learn the P so Rashi sticks in a thing here that yes you're right women don't have to take off their clothing but shouldn't we make that they should take off the clothing while it's better for them not to have clothing because they'll die quicker the 5c 10c difference makes a big difference we're going to see the gamar by the way I have two questions here we'll ask we'll ask one if somebody and he decides to make a run for it he runs he grab he grabs on the helicopter and scoots out of there one of has a gun he all to shoot him as he's escaping he's could I kill him with a gun why not you know the say everybody agrees with the own so we're going to see B no you could kill him with a gun kill him with a gun just for that was worth coming but I do have a question a serious question here I feel like there'll be different uh people think hello are you part of the she are you going doing something what are you doing over there yeah hey come sit sit with us what are you doing says here that he's not relying on the person really yeah okay but we go with Rashi it's yeah so um um what I wanted to ask is as follows personally what would you say personally not not a gar or anything what would you prefer to be paraded around without clothing but to die 20 seconds quicker or have your clothing your dignity and it's going to you'll have suffering for 20 seconds but you'll have more dignity or you don't care I don't care go to mikah I don't care what do you guys say anybody want to take a what do you say Doc what you want dignity dignity what do you say I would say just the no not unclothed unclothed that's why I wanted to ask I want to see here's two people sitting across from each other saying the opposite things and it's interesting because he's younger so you think maybe the opposite he's you're older okay what do you say same as him dignity y rather not situation but yeah that's not the question you're in the situation you know what somebody lied to ad sheer said said as fast as possible as fast as possible so you don't care about dignity now so the gar says like you and I I was thinking like them like I'm I was more into the dignity me 20 seconds suff you're going to die anyway so 20 seconds but at least you die with that's what I thought anyway doesn't agree with me the agrees with you guys fine so says maybe it seems like from here the here doesn't care but we heard the opposite so just to um what is this okay let me just show you because we have I forgot his name already what's his name the first guy from the mdel Ariel so let me just show you real quickly this a bunch of people didn't see this even though we show it often because there's a lot a lot of alas here this is the of sa so basically sa is a husband is concerned that his wife is talking to somebody else and he warns her not to seclude her herself with this other man and she doesn't listen and there two Aden that see that they go into a place and they seclude themselves so this is sped up a little bit I hope here's the other guy and she goes in there to a him witness that she comes back then they take her they have to take her to the B mikdash and they they uh they give her the K gives her water to drink talking about water at a certain point point here they remove her clothing they bring it to this thing that thing so at a certain point the K grabs her clothing right over here and rips it down if he can this is not important this the the whole thing okay we're not going to go through the whole thing now but thear says like this when he tears her bed so it could be a nice tear it could it could be no tear if it's very strong nothing or it just falls apart so says like this this not so over here again over here care about they care about her and Ruda does not care about her but when it comes to the site that's exactly it's exactly the opposite cares about here and R don't care what happens he grabs onto the her shirt if it tears tears it rips apart into shreds we don't care until he reveals her heart he removes whatever covering she has plus he undo the braids that she has if her heart is attractive then we don't he doesn't do this why because R is concerned of hearer by us he's not concerned of heer it's a contradiction and if she has attractive here then he doesn't undo it so it's here say we're not concerned and says we are concerned so it's a contradiction seems like so now we're coming to answer that when it comes to we're talking about a woman who could she could 50/50 if she was mat herself she was M with that guy she will die she'll blow up she's not coming back home but there's a possibility that she wasn't M possibility she's coming back home now these young were there in the and they saw her revealed so now they might go and seduce her and she say that's the problem he's now it's interesting even though she came home Zaki she didn't do anything wrong but she still deserves this this embarrassment why does K rip it because she deserves even though she was Not Innocent but she's she I'm sorry even though she's innocent She's Not Innocent because she did go and seclude herself with that man and she shouldn't have done that so for that alone says Rashi she deserves littleit Biz so ha but over here in our case so let's say they kill her without clothing what's the big deal says I'm not concerned about the woman's dead they're not going to go after her she's dead wait a minute but if those the people there The Spectators they see her without clothing now they'll have a TI in their head and they go after another woman says something very interesting is the person that they saw without clothing that's where they they'll attack that's what they go after you just answer you forgot to answer the question that we have around Buton the same exact question but in Reverse right in one place it seems like ra are not by us they're not concerned of hearer and by S they are concerned so which one is [Music] it just explains the big difference between a woman who might go home and they they saw her unclothed where a woman who's not going home she's dying no matter where she's gonna die by the side that says that there's a we have an idea we want other women to be faithful to their husbands and we we warn them how by making an example out of this woman when they see that we embarrass her we rip her shirt like that they might think twice before they go a ahead and they they have relations with another man it's not necessary to to take off her clothing why all other women and men whoever sees that she was over in aaria look she's dying this woman it doesn't get any worse than death so okay you add a little bit more the clothing no no we don't need to come on to that it's we have enough here okay so kill her and take off the clothing we have a to love our fellow like we love ourselves so give that person a death that doesn't include embarrassment this might be the easiest in the world what why this oh so that the gor is gonna talk about that I I told you that it's faster and you know that's s but right now at this point that there you could do death with embarrassment without embarrassment do it without without embarrassment so this idea that so you want to tell me that whether or not we care about that that re says that you take off her clothing he doesn't care about one of the things I saw today uh in my video that I did for the Hebrew shair because I did a video in English on the slopes so yesterday Aaron Cutler did the video but without the microphone like we switch phones think so the sound came out great but you heard the skiers flying by you heard the carving today he's not zero like you see them fly by but you don't hear them at all cuz the microphone picks up so I'm hoping I'm just saying because I I hear the vacuum cleaner upstairs I'm hoping that uh maybe Ki are you able to tell her like to slow down on the vacuum or text text Mommy um okay brother yeah no everybody agrees with we should always pick the the the the quickest uh death possible or the the nicest death I should say what does a person this is what you were asking what does a person perform more prefer more a little but die quicker and the other one says no it's better to to uh in other words the is or pain which one is more reminds me of the famous with the Tas they're sitting on the M on the de you know everybody's looking at them thousands of people so takes a little water he's drinking the other guy just digs in he starts eating and eating so the other guy's like he looks at him he's like you're not you're not like embarrassed Fring like a pig so the guy says listen I gave into my big Ty of food I gave in and you you gave into your big T of coved we're both the same we both gave into what's the difference okay so it's a sh there always like a it's a given take a little biz no pain not less pain a lot of pain no Biz you got to pick says the the house was the height of two humans so human beings approximately three alas let's call it six feet so two times that 12et what is learned that it means on his side I like theat that it's on his back personally and I think it's more than like the Mish it's like like more like maybe so basically I didn't know this really maybe I did because I learned this m once before but you take this guy and you put put him on the edge of the roof but his face is not facing the sidewalk his back is facing the sidewalk his face is facing you so he has much less of a chance to catch himself basically his head is g to hit the concrete and then Boop it's over that's what it says here or you could Lear the other is that it's on his side okay let's go with theat that he falls on his back the this is like one of the most famous jokes in Israel I hope I don't batch it like it's the you know pre1 a first grade joke but why not what's the difference when a person falls from the first floor from the 10th floor person falls from the from from the first floor it goes like this boom ah but when you fall from the 10th floor it's ah boom that's anyway I don't know what this is 12T new I don't know which one it's in between let's say he somehow flips in midair and he lands on his stomach so you flip him over on his back or like the other on the side and if he dies from the fall you don't have to continue with with what the P says you know Stone him you don't have to Stone him you don't have to you don't have to do that I could see the brisk no I wasn't I have to do does that stone have a Shear whatever we're gonna get into it in a second it seems like very he places it nicely no no no no you take a stone and you throw it on his heart and we G see this Stone weighs a lot let's let's call it 150 pounds boom right on his chest it's over if that did the job great if he didn't die everybody throws Stones is going to tell us that never happened he always died on the first shot first do it it's important to remember this we're going to mention it later on y the hand of the witnesses they're there first what if a doesn't have a hand doesn't have a hand it says in the the hand of the Adam they should push him they should throw the stones what if a person doesn't have a hand then what what do you say so you can say well the is okay so we'll see so we have where is that here we go yeah you got it you have his height plus two more floors or whatever so his head is basically three stories above the ground why do you need such a great height we learned that a pit you dig out a pit and an animal falls into it he dies it's it's enough to kill an animal how much is that this tall what do you need to go 18 feet or whatever it is a question that I was very bothered you probably also very bothered by it t my my grandchild could jump off T and survive so what's the what's so bothered i wna i i w to I want to do a me so that the guy's gonna die so I make sure 10 feet 18 feet what do you yeah okay an animal could die so says something very important and I think you could see it in tysus also says the difference if a person's walking down the street you know you have some of these videos I think I showed it once a woman mind you know she's texting in Brooklyn you know in Brooklyn how they open up the sidewalk they have the piece of metal and the side you go into the to the basement on 13th avue it's all you know she's walking and they forgot to to put up the metal she walking one Falls in a person can die from that even if you fall three four feet if you if you don't if you don't realize it's happening and you don't catch yourself it could cause death so it says the's question was since you give that person wine and together his brain you know it's gonna it's going to mess him up somehow like you know whatever it does to to the person so it's as if he's not paying attention so he's not going to catch himself he won't be able to so even at a a small amount T whatever that is we have a doctor in the house over here he says no you're not really dying from that you don't see it you can snap your neck on it backwards backwards unlikely from 10 F to snap your neck and die okay so says the I hear but but then you go with the stone you get him with the stone I checking out his grandson he talking about that M I hate to say but that that grandson got hit by a piece of marble in the head one of the he had a marble table and the the marble hit him okay Z does anybody know what this is I have no idea what this is Yoshi stuck to sin after this year and I didn't have a chance what is this no looks like s there's a sword over there I have no idea and he's going to tell me oh I can't believe I didn't okay we have to make sure this guy dies and he dies quickly 10 enough so why you doing 18 feet do 50 feet throw them off the the 10th floor why the third floor no he's not even wearing clothing who knows what's going to happen to his body what's going to explode what's going to break and it's going to be ail to the body you don't want to you don't want to disgrace the body like that learn one of the aam actually pushes him off here whoever didn't see this we could do I can get there or was it no I guess not not today okay so how do you know that one of pushes him it's ation of push and how do you know that you Stone the person you st do know you do both of them why does say double te us that you do both how do you know that it's enough that he dies by pushing you don't have to Stone him after he's dead it's extra so this was said by if you go close to the mountain this is what's going to happen to you how do you know this for generations to come turn you ready in honor kovc in honor ofman and ficial and this is for me this a first time in many years AKA was one of the first people to be inir from the 10 first guys of I think we have pictures of him there I don't even know how old he was no This was um seven years ago approximately seven years ago so how old were you seven years ago 15 15 16 so let me say this and and thank you to re Global experts in International Financial Services Anonymous says the one a grabs a stone and he if he doesn't die from the fall then that second a picks up a stone and kills him there was a stone right there ready to go but two men had to pick it up was very heavy he now all of a sudden singular puts it on his heart he dies great seems first it says it's two people and says one person takes it no the way it works is two people lift up the stone and one person throws the stone like Maneuvers it so two people lift it up and one guy like pushes it on him I'm going to tell you a secret here that I've have never said and uh I just figured out today this is a major secret you're hearing this here first have you ever been to a wedding where the two mothers of the and the kala they take a a plate and they try to break it on the chair and it doesn't break all the time all the time all the time but but it's a plate if by mistake it slips out of your hand it breaks but two people go like this I'll tell you the secret it's POS it's because one woman is going upwards and the other one is going downwards one is negating the power from the other take a look at it do it in slow motion you like it's like uncoordinated that's what the gar is saying over here when two people are going to throw the stone on the guy it's not going to come out good this guy's going to go this way he's one guy does the throat two guys lift but now that it's up in the air one guy is the one that does the motion and that's the secret to Breaking the plates at the I was a caterer I can't believe what is going on here just break the plate what's the problem and again and again it's like they're like scared to the they might break in their hand so they one pulls back you know what I mean it's like okays that it should come with a good Force next it says if he doesn't die from that one stone so then the rest of the community The Spectators they throw stones nobody ever needed to throw another Stone I say that it happened if in the future it's necessary then you should know everybody can throw there was a stone there ready to go any murder weapon well it's not the weapon it's the tool that they use to kill this person in the B like the stone like the the sword here I don't want to show this on this but we got a sud going here it's perfect this is uh they choke the guy with this so if they choke they put the guy to death with this what's it's this it's perfect you bury it with interesting you know that today also if something kills somebody like a weapon you have to put it away you have to bury it so for instance if you find a a rope that the Nazis hung Jews with you have to bury it so what about a gun do you bury a gun you find the L happens unfortunately all the time an Arab comes shoots a Jew now what you find the gun does the gun have to be buried so they say no but the bullets have to be buried what about a guy takes a car and Rams the Jews with it and he kills a Jew happened you have to bury the car so they say no why because a car is not a it's not a weapon although I don't know if that's so accurate it it has been a a pretty bad weapon kills it's like the number one cause of death or number two cause of death you're a doctor you should know well heart disease yeah it can't be the number one cause that's that's exaggerated because 500 people died in a from car accidents this year 500 it's a lot so it's not really a weapon it's not designed to be a weapon okay I get it so you don't have to do that but different things if somebody kills someone with a knife then the knife has to it has to be buried a there's a famous I don't know exactly who's they say about they say about this one that one you know each but the the story goes as follows the lesson is true that a very wealthy person calls his family he's dying he says listen I have two things to tell you number one I'm writing a will I'm writing a do not open it until after I'm buried okay okay number two I demand that I want to be buried with my socks just socks everybody knows the story but it's to say so they go say no way we're not bearing with socks so they go to the local Rob the says I can't come up with the he they go to another nobody can come with the he so they don't bear him with socks so then after okay now let's open up the they open up and it says the front the first line it says you see even with the socks they wouldn't let me be buried you can't bring anything with you nothing zero only you can bring with you is the sword or whatever and that that also the says doesn't work can't bring anything with you the only thing you bring with you what can you bring with you the that you make the the the the the CH that you create in this world all these things that you can bring says or like that Chinese guy I showed just recently maybe a couple months ago that he was buried demanded to be buried with his car he loved his car so much they put it in in the grave okay you have sugar here and there of China allow says oh so what's the's question so this stone that they killed the guy with should be buried what are you telling me there's a stone there like a designated Stone it's not designated every time the stone says I skip anything ansers it doesn't say that's there all the time as a designated Stone no there's a stone there ready to go every single time they bury one then they bring another one and it's ready to go again how could you say that it's buried with him you don't bury anything with the person in the Cav not even the socks you could bury him within you bury the the the this weapon or whatever you want to call the tool within four amas of the grave amazing if the Aid's hand is chopped off Potter the guy doesn't get the death penalty it says the that the hand of the witness pushes him or throws a stone at him so now we have a listen to this it's a it's called called do we always forc the exact wording of the T to take place are you going to be like what's the word I don't want to use that word it must be a better word um okay are got to be exact to every word literal is a better word okay you know the word I didn't want to say right do you have to be literal it says that the hand okay not the hand so so he blows on him and he pushes him off with his foot no so if a guy doesn't have a hand no a guy who doesn't have hands that's how he's born or was chopped off beforeand what he can't be Aid say no he could but the difference is means what whatever you witnessed it with that's where you come so if a guy is born without hands he has a little stub or whatever that's his hand for for the time being but this Aid had a full hand and now it's chapped off he's no good anymore K says I read the Pu literally so I just thought to myself very interesting with that story that we had with shim where they killed shim's son with a lie he didn't deserve to die but aen they want to take revenge so they killed him so have a great way out of it you know what you do you chop the guy's hand off you chop the Aid's hand off you're a false witness you want to kill me I have no problem chopping your hand off now if I kill you I might go to prison for the rest of my life so that's a prow but have a great chop the what's the worst they'll put me in prison for three years is better than dying no how many how many years of prison could a person get for chopping hand off it can't be too bad murders go to prison for 5 10 years so chopping your hand off no I'm just saying it's a great idea according to you heard here first and you're lad I would I think you if you ask the say sure chop the guy's hand off he's a liar he tried to put you to death for no reason he deserves his hand chopped off so what happened was there was a murder case let's say in New York and the guy they said okay we gotta kill him and he ran away to Park City so now they find him here in Park City and it they two witnesses come and say we witnessed that he was sentenced to death Ruben and shim from Brooklyn you kill him here in Park City Utah but the question is it says y the the witnesses that saw the the death they're the ones that kill him not you guys here in Utah no the two a in ut are the same aen that witnessed it over there it's very difficult in the because it says we we witnessed it doesn't say pl we are the plainy it says those two guys are the it should have said we are the okay says No in fact it must be according to me that you have to translate the PK literally so it's the two a that witnessed everything they in New York they're here in Utah today and they're the ones that going to perform the so this idea I don't know if I'll remember but you'll remember it for me are we literal with so here's a few examples you kill the [Music] murderer what does it say you kill a murderer with a sword what if he don't have a sword he ran away he's running you can kill with a gun it's a double kill the kill the murderer even with a gun as he's running away or like the there says he's on a boat you could sink the boat you don't have to you don't have to do don't be bring a r from a killer over there says you can kill him any way you want it's not literal but nevertheless you see the thir is not so literal so if it's not literal learn for the rest of the that you don't have to be literal we have that when when the T says in one place you can learn it to every place but if the T repeats itself twice then you can't learn it to another place because the Tora is saying listen only in these two places had I want you to learn it to the rest of the Torah I would have said it once why am I saying it twice to tell you only in these two places so when I see that the to is not literal in two places then it's only these two places that it's not being literal but the rest of the T very literal that's what the is goingon to say here where else is when somebody kills someone then you have it today by the Arabs by the Muslims it works like that you kill so so you know the relative comes and kills you back and whole War have in Mexico I had a guy that works for me had to run away from Mexico because he killed somebody and uh the family is going to kill him there's no when you don't have you know authorities then it's the wild west so the is that the go could come and kill what if the guy doesn't have a go so check this out this is where we pause for a couple seconds and we do some uh uh humor here we go you ready AK the court has ruled that you did not intentionally kill the old man you tried to Rob so you must go to an ear mlot if you choose not to go the relatives of the deceased are allowed to kill you I'm terrified really he was a 90-year-old man with no children he does not have a blood Redeemer if I don't go to a City of Refuge there's no one here to kill me the Torah has already thought of that in such a case the court appoints a goel hadam please let him in [Music] that was a great idea to use that inflatable go Adam what what that's a good one excellent in the Yesa the guys are going to make their own stuff and they're gonna come up with their own humor you'll help CL okay you don't have to be literal the Torah says that the relative kills it doesn't have to be relative the B can appoint anybody to go kill the guy what are the two things relative kills with the Rel doesn't have any reliv what's the word appoints okay so we have two places that it's not literal what you're saying that you don't have to be literal in the about the the uh the son the Ben right is a kid that's going in the wrong path he's stealing meat wine this whole thing we see that he's going to turn out no good so his parents bring him to B I don't think it ever happened but because there's a very very strict criteria the parents have to be the same height they have to have the same voice but that's not what the is talking about it says over here like this if one of the parents doesn't have a hand is mute or can't walk blind the boy is not killed you have to grab him they don't have hands one of them doesn't have a hand and they take him out to the they can't be somebody that that doesn't have feet or Lim and they say meaning can be people that don't can't speak here this son I don't know where he is I can't see no good he doesn't hear our voice because being literal in the we're taking every word literally enra we learn from each word what about is a city that every most of the city does and it says in the POS has Street what if it doesn't have a street we take it literally it has to have a street you build a street in other words both agree that it has to have a street we're taking this POS literally you needed a street that was there beforeand okay to build a street now you see that everybody holds that you have to take the POS literally says oh I was going to take some ketchup and show you okay forget the ketchup now no ketchup on right of the in the process of the so we sh an animal and we we dip his finger his thumb in blood in the right ear in Blood and his right big toe in blood what if he doesn't have a right thumb what he do do you have to be literal or not so it's the same question again doesn't have one of these things nothing to do he's going to a for the rest of his life you take whatever there was a thumb right over here so he put the blood right over here where the thumb used to be put on the on the left thumb we have are we gonna be literal and say listen the guy is never going to be tar or no don't be you don't have to be so literal you can put on the place where you used to be you put on the left you don't have to be it says you can do it on small also you don't have to be so literal so we have a here we're just going to do the M today and we're going to finish holds that anybody that is stoned to death you hang the body afterwards just a person who curses the and somebody that worships Idols The Spectators get to see his face a man a woman you flip her around so that she's facing the tree and The Spectators don't get to see who it is you don't even hang a woman crazy story that we had the other day Ariel that's the name how many witch witches did shim kill 80 perfect 80 got it you got it okay 80 so says he did hang them he hung these witches he killed 80 everything was interesting over there sh was in a big rush he had to kill them all before they started doing sorcery to get out of it and their husbands would come and the whole thing he killed them all even though you shouldn't have killed them all in one day and he hung them you can't bring any proof from what happened with but a regular woman say we don't hang thank you for coming have a wonderful day