Daf Yomi Sanhedrin Daf 41 by R’ Eli Stefansky

[Music] good [Music] morning good morning good morning my name is Jakob aisen I wanted to show you what I've done as a he's an artist and this is his room good morning r [Music] what it says over there something like that [Music] um just want to make sure not this one okay High belly no words describe I I enjoy your Shear last night I'm 99% sure that you by mistake started the shear from five lines from the bottom the so yes we got a bunch of people light also cats light here somewhere in the room I saw before bunch of emails people picked up on it and we in fact yesterday we started the she from and then we skipped the hold off they came over to me in the K somebody's watching it says you made a mistake you started the wrong D I said no no we had to go back Daniel petl petl something like that thank you reell you are truly one of a kind and I appreciate the amount of effort you put into the spreading I used to not be able to learn that without feeling the feed 5 minutes in watching you Shar has changed more than just my learning has changed everything Deans I hope this email finds you well just wanted to take a moment to thank you for your incredible y your ability to break down complex suas with such Clarity humor has been a game changer my learning have made my daily learning something I actually look forward to I've been following since y 87 I wanted to let you know that on October 8th while learning Bas 105 this is from so he didn't write okay 105 you introduce us to a very memorable moment chart 10 with the guy in the bath house sporting six toes on his left foot I must admit I wasn't expecting such a footnote in my experience let me show you that picture not going to believe this so here he is this is you look over there on the bottom this is AI generated and so there's a lot of times they have issues with the toes six toes so he says interestingly enough my wife recently gave birth to adorable baby boy who like the man in your chart also has six toes on each foot turns out this is called It's both rare and fascinating so while I was trying to focus on inheritance laws I couldn't help but smile at the coincidence I suppose there's just another way that you keep me on my toes pun intended now I know it's a bit of a delay I'm not sure if to to blame the baby or difficult do but I want to finally thank you for all your hard work and for making thei both educational entertaining your humor insightful teaching style if this guy went to M like I did then this email is also AI 100% % your humor and insightful teaching style are constant source of inspiration it says kindly from a bunker in Upstate New York not giving the exact location afraid of mdy Monroe bunker Hunters Monroe bunker Hunters your humor Cal teaching style are a constant source of inspiration may you continue to brighten our days and help us navigate the da with both wisdom and smile I want to remind even if you're in America especially if you're in America this is the last day to win a laptop donated I forgot the guy's name anybody what's his name elzar what benra oh which also reminds me I didn't make a note of it but I tremendous to Yari from Manchester and Rabbi D shinski for putting out the spread that they did on Friday was very very nice it was high-end food and cakes and wine and all sorts of things they made um I showed it no the uh okay let me see if this's anything else that we have to it's a lot of stuff a lot of emails okay so we'll jump into the unfortunately I know that you guys want to hear more emails we'll just jump into it sponsor from his grateful family memory who started learning age 70 and Contin for 32 years until he was n the M for the unity of the Jewish people sponsored by Glenn esterson with love and gratitude from Wilmington North Carolina thank you for enriching my life with and tremend in honor of our oldest grandson May grow iner art of the month for forell and the whole MD staff to continue to make enjy so many and in honor of Y kin and markazi for all the work that they do here we go with seven lines from the bottom I think unless I don't remember okay as a public service announcement I don't it's not 100% uh locked in but I am flying to America tomorrow afternoon so if that's the case then tomorrow is the last year I'm saying this for the people also that are there's some people coming it's it's vacation now in America and they people have been asking if I'm going to be here so tomorrow is the last day and I I'm leaving Utah I'm leaving Utah Sunday I don't think I get back to every until like Tuesday it takes literally two days in each Direction once you get to America it's 5 hours to get there so like you take the next I'm getting to America like 9:00 at night I'm only getting I'm leaving New York the following morning so that takes up half a day you know how it goes anyway tomorrow is my last dat not ever for now yes will be from there or you'll have somebody else well we do always the same thing that we've been doing for the last six years huh Ah that's your dad light there where do you live ah very nice okay welcome welcome very good we have an interesting Su today one of the things we're going to be dealing with is let's say Adam come say that somebody a woman was maana let's say and they want if a woman's maana we have to kill her come to other and they do they say no you're lying now there's actually two components to what they T component number one is that she has to die she's a component number two is that let's say that falls through that whatever for whatever reason they can't kill her but she still becomes AER to her husband so the question is can they claim how could you kill us maybe we only came to say that she's us to her husband yes you're right at the end of the day the bezan is going to kill her but that's not what we meant what we meant is we wanted to kill we wanted her to be user in we don't want to kill her really we don't care yeah she dies she dies that that's not what we came for is it such a t in is such a says yes it's an excellenta and we're going to see so now the we're starting off with four sources for the idea actually we're not going to start off there let's until we get there it takes three lines one of the things that we ask these that come in to testify in do you know him you recognize him who is he do you know him did he kill don't worship now I've seen this a few times I saw this in New York and I saw this in Chicago I saw a guy waiting for a bus on Chavis s's hat the whole thing like as if it's like a Monday afternoon and I realized this guy wasn't Jewish he's wearing the hat everything whatever he stole from the sh uh a long reckle the Hat I'm serious s is coming out I looked a little closer no this guy's not Jewish but he could have in New York you have it all the time you have going around on they go around in shs they collect money how do you know just cuz he's wearing you have Arabs dressed up and like they put a safer in the the dash they come in they do they they kidnap like that how do you know this guy is is a how do you know he's how do you know he killed somebody that did you give him this is amazing we're going to learn some that I don't think anybody ever thought of this is one two things that are incredible about as when you warn somebody hey if you do if you do this if you're going to kill that guy you are going to die did he say okay what was his response he heard it he understood it did he accept it about himself did he say I know I'm going to die and I'm so upset at this guy I want to kill him I don't care if I die did he say that I'll give you a marshall what if a guy today today you tell a guy listen shabas I don't know he starts screaming at him he say listen if you do this and this Shas if Messiah comes tomorrow and I really hope he comes tomorrow if Messiah comes tomorrow they will kill you he says I don't care I don't care and Messiah comes tomorrow and they establish a ban you kill his guy you don't kill this guy that's nothing that's unbelievable what he just said is amazing I'm serious Elvis is tremendous elak anybody agree with him he said he doesn't really count on coming so the Shak says like GIS I mean what's what's he I don't like that the Shak doesn't say like GIS Shak says like who what's your name Elia Shak says like Elia like that the Shak and Elvis agree going to sayi said that Elvis is the sh whatever okay why because that's not he's not mamish accepting upon him the death penalty he knows that there's no B today what are the Chance is coming in his lifetime he doesn't really believe it so that's not H he knows everything he understood the whole thing he just the bottom is he's not other argue but that's what the says this is this is also incredible it literally it shouldn't be a a 3 second difference between the warning and the killing the warning and theas why because if there's more than a few seconds maybe he forgot what you told him it's unbelievable now the this guy okay what kind did he do the which one did he do what style did he do in that particular spill wine he what he do did he bow to it how do we know the whole idea of and the is going to bring four sources and in fact says all four sources are good we need all four of them we're talking about person marries his own sister he sees her does it have to do with seeing this has to do with doing not with seeing we're talking about saying that they showed him they explained to him the is and what he's going to get when a person is over in AR with his own sister he doesn't get's he gets he gets malus but he doesn't get Mis so since doesn't need to know what this guy knows and doesn't know he knows what's in his head so there's no there's no for you're not helping outm you don't warn the guy when it comes to cars to of Al we are into 40 days unbelievable so therefore we take this PA and we say that in order to get malus you have to have a I'm assuming based on this gar was very very difficult to give people malus very difficult to give people M bezan very difficult years because now I'm saying this whole idea not that there's no murderers there's a lot of murderers unfortunately but to be you're talking about enough to say whatever it is two three seconds and if you say it and the guy pauses with the knife and 5 seconds later kills it's not it's not as so if you look over here on the chart it's K to look at the chart because it's going to help us out in the so we just spoke about what's the punishment you get Mal have another source it doesn't say hazed hazed is in the past if the person was amazed he did it deliberately no he's doing it deliberately now it's a that he's doing it now huh he's doing it as he's doing it he is is amaz he's amazed as he's doing the the a oh so let's look at this now and that's referring to a murderer and a murder receives which is lowered down on the if if you have to choose AA this is the the easy one it's with a sword brings another source the very they found him Gathering the wood the famous M that got what is that that's and what kind of you get it goes together all I want is that no I don't have a choice the next one is it says he wasn't he didn't do it in the past he's doing it now he's M right now in other words the is there the warning is there great and that's Nas is an Engaged naira she's 12 years old between the age of 12 and 12 and a half and somebody comes and testifies that she was the the punishment is and it says over there Al what's what's the it's a it's a hint that you get the when there's speaking done here somebody spoke and somebody warned you a warning a verbal warning Al is a verbal warning says simple here we need all four so what do we have again we have which is Mal we have which is and we have which is and then we have which is we have four things it's going to be easy now when the says and why do you need two skas now we have in front of us we see there two skas say to understand this is what we understood yesterday it's very very simple the lighter the case the less the less warnings you need the less in other words let's go let's take the the extreme example the worst of the worst is a guy that tries to convince somebody else to do that's the worst guy ever him I would kill him without warning without without anything without starting with a all the all the that we made on a regular we try to get him out of it we drop all that and we try to kill this guy why because he's so severe in other words somebody that's on the opposite side let's say only gets malus it's not so severe so I would say you don't have to do a the T says you do have to do a there that's amazing you have to do a but that's only you have to we have to we we try to get her out of it we try to not give malus because it's lowered down on the on the on the on the severity so it's lowered down let's let's let's try to get her out of it how you have to do be but some that shot somebody in the head maybe kill him without you know everybody should understand on their own that you don't you don't kill another human being and he and he so you didn't give him a get rid of this guy he's a bad guy get rid of him in America there's no a anywhere there's no you get the death penalty in America without somebody kills another person you kill a cop whatever it is death no so that's why I need the also I think that the second is you don't get over there so that's why I need to say that you do need oh that's one misz that's very very easygoing you just chap off his head you're not it's not so severe like throwing a guy off a a two-story building and then then stoning him and then hanging him that's already very severe shows like hashm is not happy with this guy not happy maybe you got get a rid of him right away without so why in fact do I need two of these on the bottom one one one so if we go back to this thing according to you get which is you have to drink this hot lead that's the most severe so maybe the most severe you don't need a it's so severe you don't need a yes you need it's only it's not therefore I need another to tell me by the way you're right yesterday the guy that just walked in his aunti how you doing you're a little right you were right we're going to get there you asked me a good question yesterday I was wrong you were right remember question I know cuz there there was a bunch of them the good one no you ask me how come what if the guy uh the two a said it was in the middle of the month does the middle of the month have anything to do with it right says yes need a special to talk about you're right is more once I know that's most that certainly try to get the guy off the hook said yesterday something that you could learn sometimes the goes out of it way and mentions it anyways so just say the the most severe even they need certainly certainly [Music] malus you're right the could have just gotten away with saying one by and or one and we would learn everything but the T likes to repeat itself if it's something that you learn in the guy has to say I know all about this I went to yes I know I'm going to get I don't care how do you know you should kill the guy that's dead H he's dead already so if he's dead what are you killing obviously he's alive so what does mean it's talking about that he says he agrees to [Music] die here's the big says that when two ad them come along and they say this woman who's engaged engaged means she received money for Ain so she becomes a she's not married 100% yet she was never with her husband they haven't seen each other for almost a year but she's a she was m so we kill her the says what he do to the if we find out that the Adam are lying they were somewhere else we do to them exactly what they wanted to do to her what do they want to do to her they want to kill her so they come and they say no we didn't want to kill her that's not that wasn't Our intention Our intention was that she she should be user to her husband there are situations where you don't kill the woman you can't there was that wasn't good I don't know but we know that she was m so she's also to the husband that's all we wanted to do so says you can't kill them that's not means that you do what they intended to do Z that was their intent that wasn't their intent all we wanted to do is make her us husband says but they told her specifically going to die they gave her says didn't give so how in the world would she die if there's no you tell me a major what's your big even though she's going to die and therefore you think they should die because no but they didn't tell to kill her so therefore they don't die but they didn't even intend to kill her so then what's the of course they don't die you're telling me two that came they didn't even do as they didn't try to get they they didn't do anything so if they didn't do anything why why would they why would we have a half a minute that they die you need to tell me this any kid knows that a without let's say they come to this guy was was that no so what do you want so go home there's no you don't kill them of course you don't kill them there's no so it says the unbelievable they didn't give us but we're talking about the wife of and we learned in this doesn't according to only the whole purpose what's the purpose of according to to tell the person hey what you're doing if you're going to make tea on chab like this like this you're and you should know what you're doing is amazing you have to sometimes you have to explain to a person they don't know no no this is the wife of they say they love and the the came without a ring he forgot the ring at home instead of delaying the whole wedding for an hour they asked an audience they said is there a woman here that could just lend the ring we do take the ring don't worry we'll give it back to you after let's just let's get the show on the road so she gave the ring then came to said listen listen I thought about it it doesn't work why she didn't learn any she doesn't know anything about she wasn't she wasn't who's going to give every what woman is going to give away a ring like she there's no there's not take my wife's ring my wife is understands that's what he told her it's okay so oh so we're talking about the wife of doesn't need and these people could have killed her because since she doesn't need so they when they come to testify that she was m interesting she's not even married okay she's she's she knows she knows and uh so she should die even without but they could say no we didn't come to kill kill her we came to make her user on her husband here's a beautiful video there's one flaw in this video it's a great video just in the voting you'll see there's a little bit of a flaw let's see if you can pick it up here we go oh no not this one next one sorry sorry this guy the testimonies that Ruan desecrated the chabus have been received the courtroom now moves to vote wait but there was no warning the witnesses did not warn me that what I'm doing is forbidden on shabas unfortunately for you in this courtroom We Rule according to the ruling of RAB Yosi Ben RAB Yehuda who believes that a does not need a warning and you consider yourself a you make sure you get the third alah on shabas because you are a we have proof that you said I don't study because I'm a so of course you know the laws of shabus right and therefore the results guilty 11 isow no [Music] oh W I got to stop studying the doth in bed before I go to sleep very nice 1211 is is not the right thing you need you need in order to be you have to be up by two not one um Gra so first of all huh no the [Music] artist it reminded me when I saw I saw this video it reminded me of a very emotional time that all of us not all a lot of us had when we were is the first of the cycle so we made a big when we brought in the famous rash Kaplan that's rash and he gave a and there there wasn't a dry eye in the room his wife was just sfter literally a few months before that speech and described us how how hard is to take care of the kids and all the kids are are mourning and there there's a lot of SAR in the house and they had to feed them and bathe them the whole thing you take over her job and they they didn't go through a the of her being sick the whole thing very very draining and he even said some kids would sleeping with him in the bed they had they had trauma the whole He described the whole thing was it was bad it was I remember being very emotional when he speaking and then he described how he took upon himself to he doing that and one night with with with his last he's doing trying to do the da and and all of a sudden his daughter comes and wakes him up at 2: in the morning 2 in the morning she shakes him T and he wakes up and he's holding a gamar in his hand it's on his face she say you didn't do the da yet you didn't do the da yet was unbelievable so that's this guy with the um I I wanted to show you this video just happened yesterday I just thought it was interesting pun yesterday very to the politics these days this is the vice president if not on this vote the Y's are 50 and the Nays are 50 the Senate being equally divided the vice president votes in the affirmative and the nomination is confirmed yeah the Secretary of Defense yeah so it's notas maybe it is depends but they're not yeah but they're not kill they're not killing anybody they're not killing anybody so if you're up by one if you're up by one it's 50/50 and he he's the deciding vote everything is GED okay she is the no no she's married to this girl woman what does it say over what's saying she's 12 years old she's very okay right there's a lot of okay even a 12-year-old you grow up in a in in in a you're from from birth and you know these are shabas to make a fire you don't you don't need a for certain things it's it's obvious to you that this is AER he's saying that she herself she's not she's not the she's not a married woman she's not the the the wife of aover she's a she very good says means she herself is very knowledable in certain things B like like one of the one of the videos they made was that biting your lips and biting your skin off your lips and you see you don't even know certain things are is that people don't know if you bite your skin off your lips it could be person that's a sign the person does that kind of thing there usually because they mental no it's not me it's a bad hat it's bad habit I I have Al I'm mental I'm mental cuz once in a while I have DED Li we're all mental good thank you in public just called me a m you know what I at home I have even the certificate I can show you it's not it's not yeah but I'm saying people don't know they B the nails whatever they do it's a thing what do I don't understand what you're saying certain things people don't realize that this a shop so you have to tell them yeah to make a fire on CHAS to cook on CHAS most people know there are things that they don't know they don't know have know you know that on chabas on chabas I I saw my sons both of them washing their hands and I'm like I'm pretty sure that the the direction that you're putting the water on is hot water and by us we have one of those it's not like in America we don't have it's automatic hot automatic hot so as soon as you put it on the Hat the machine goes on the fire goes on right yeah it's show so the AR with me if that's the hot cold after Shas I went and I yeah it was the hot yeah I'm just saying that's but I'm just saying people don't know this is yeah we should turn it off we should it's one thing yeah but I don't do the I don't put the black on the thing I forgot to light the candles and shs you don't to turn it on the shs you're joking right I should do the normal thing what everybody does yeah I forgot to buy the food I had to go to thei hey you have a piece of fish yeah okay go away the shops okay should you heard what he said regular people turning it off regular people yeah okay we couldn't open up the refrigerator the shabas cuz we forgot to push you should if I remembered all the stuff that I was supposed to do yeah goes back to the certificate no it goes back busy you're busy next I'm saying this week I how much my wife does yeah yeah I have no idea where we okay 10 minutes wow remember that that that screen 10 minutes uh sorry oh oh it's still here the we like five lines from where becomes very wide say have you know this is like preparation for the next is that in order to to die if the don't die then she doesn't die why any testimony that you cannot bring the adom to the same punishment as the defendant it's not even forget it there's no you can't kill her you can't since you can't kill them you can't kill her say that's exactly what we're trying to say is just saying you should know that you cannot kill why our intent you have to read our mind you can't read our mind and we tried not to kill her but to get her user on her husband so therefore says yes therefore you can't kill her so like like says any woman who knows so according to how how's it possible that you kill an morasa they know they know the you don't have the master they the the a were going to claim that they only try to make her user on her husband since you can't kill them you can't kill her and the whole Parish of goes out out the window no no no they cannot claim that they came to make her user and her husband because she's alreadying her husband because there's another set of a that testifies she was M yesterday that part part the is part is done now we come so why are you coming again she's already you're coming again to say that she that anybody that's M with her she can never marry that person even if she gets divorced so all we came to to testify is that the second is also she was with the first guy twice time number one she becomes us her husband time number two makes her you cannot say that they're coming to say that she's on the happens to be your brother so what did they come to say but the question is this is a technical question why are we talking about a 12-year-old who's engaged just talk about a regular as it's the same exact story regular is come to say she was M they will say no we didn't want to kill her we wanted to say that she's her husband we coming to say a greater the greater is that even though they don't even know each other they haven't been they never live together they're just engaged time he gives her money whatever he gives her a ring and then they don't see each other for a year theen could still say we didn't come to kill her we came to say she's AER on this guy she never lived with so it's a bigger here we go um this is the mes oh I forgot to show these okay the mes hold on mes is the guy that's Gathering wood and his you see she's not even married she's very very smart says like this did it kill her did it kill the guy yeah we have a between the two two come and say we saw Ruben kill shim one guy says with the sword the other guy says with the axe we go says with a sword or with an IUN so just to to recap because we're going to please remember this we not going to need it need it but it's to remember how do you know where in the T does it say that you you ask seven questions you do seven where does it say in the T seven times how do you know you doas this a good good one anybody says it twice great so I'm just pointing out why the uses but we're going to need exactly what I said maybe B meaning it's not a good you have to you have to you have to be on the same page when it comes to the murder weapon you can't say oh the murder happened with a gun no it happened with a knife that's not that's not good testimony but the guy says oh he's guy he's wearing black no no he's a he's wearing white no that's a good AIS why because when it comes to the murder they're on the same page when it comes to side things exactly what jacket he was wearing the color of the car you asked the guy what car was it I think it was a Toyota the no it was was a Tesla okay that nobody makes that's that's a side point that's not what happened he drove away in that car they made they got they got confused on the type of the car but the murder weapon you have to know so says you're telling me that if they make a mistake in the clothing that's okay we we keep the testimony and now this is what we're looking for one says he's wearing a black black clothing white clothing a second ago he said it's good testimony now saying it's not good in other words they have to be on the same page when it comes to the clothing so if you want to be you could say that he killed him with a with let's say a scarf he choked him to death and and that's the murder weapon so he asked him what color was the murder weapon black or white that's exactly what the the same case as as a sword he had here here he's wearing a black suit a white suit uh what kind of shoes was he wearing so if if he says white one says black one says white he had those that have a spits you know those Corner things the here like this we have one we have a picture no it was over here oh this is a shoe something like that he killed him with the shoe saying you want to be oh it says in our Mish that Ben Zak he he asked how thick were the stems of the figs no so that's the side point obviously he didn't kill him with the stem of a fig it's not the murder weapon so what is it it's just it's something that was next to the murder scene do you notice the the the figs on the on the on the tree what size no no no we needed to know because that was how he's he didn't kill anybody he was so I want to know what what did the the fig look like nice try there was a murder scene it wasn't a check this out he took uh a branch here let me zoom in on this he made it nice and sharp and then he killed him with it it's not the Fig it's from the Fig Tree know we're not talking about a branch we're talking about the Fig itself do you need to see this picture you know what are here they're doc here Doc it's got whatever it is so you see that we're not talking about the tree itself we're talking about the the Fig the actual color was black the Fig was black it was white great you brought me a ride from that he has a question about figs and that's circumstan that's like the side point it's not the murder weapon he actually says that you have to be extremely careful with the have to be on the same page when just like you have to be on the same page with that's only nobody else now ask theak who is this person we know there's a famous person called the Mish calls him here benak is it the same person says yes then says benak was when he was not the person he was later on in his life he became he wasn't even in at the time lived 120 years he was a businessman 40 years he learned in 40 years he taught you hear what's going on here he was 40 years a businessman later on it seems like he did I don't know I don't want to say the tra but he went and he learned toyra for 40 years and only afterwards he went and became a big r who else in history was like that everybody's going to say now who else say who what other Tana what other Tana had the same thing the started when he was 40 he was a businessman his 40 learned t for 40 years and then taught t for 40 years what other the Tana this 10,000 10,000 points Bo say h h also started when he was 40 yeah yeah okay he was far from a businessman but he started when he's 40 it's unbelievable K says from here listen to this I think you can make the de yourself I noticed this also but he says much better than me says it says that he learned TI for 40 years that means he wasn't a r for those 40 years when you says when a person takes a Stella you should make sure he knows what he's doing that he's he's learning for 40 years he brings a r from says learned for many many years then afterwards when he was older then he came out and then he was he had the influence that he had was already learning before we don't know that do he was on the roof that was when he was 40 T so here we're trying to prove that H that that could not have been Ben Zaki why cuz look here we go this is the bottom part is right he 40 years he was doing business 40 years he learned t on the floor over there learning from a rebi sitting in a chair and then 40 years he was was was a Dy but guess what 40 lived after theb you see like a little bit after theban you see where it says he lived a tiny drop afterwards let's say 40 years before theban the blue backs on top they never did there was no Sanhedrin anymore the Sanhedrin went from the here check this out which is down here this little this room over here and they moved out to kanos a place called kanos so for 40 years they weren't they weren't even dealing they there's no capital punishment how's it possible that who lived after theb dealt with capital punishment that had to be at least 41 years before that at 41 years before that he was learning on the floor he wasn't a diet they didn't do they didn't do penalties of course they did how come they didn't do because too many murderers too many you hear this too many murders they they couldn't deal with it with after so may he couldn't have been in a in a in a time period when they were doing the now says it's somebody else it's not the author of The would put in his he call him call him that doesn't make sense it says the same story doesn't make sense to somebody else he checked with the stems of of a fig for a murderer case he was there you're right he was a tal in that period he said something good he said check the pit check the the thickness of the of the and they said and they named that that they named it after a tal and what was his name then then his name was says when he was learning his name was when heau then he was a rebi the M re called him that was his original name when the story happened if a story happened with kki when he was a b Ina they call him walked you don't say that you said kki when he was in you give him cover even though then he was only 17 years old the call him with his full name RAB but he's only a then no now his name is raban the bich family in honor ofd Champions uncle Freddy Mr gr and fearless leader and chief by the members of the Mony fire department and S films strategic video production so says that if two ad say we don't know what happened the this is good if8 says I don't know what happened I don't know what color his his jacket was it's good so the M says and even if two in other words if one says I don't know the color of his jacket so there's we're not going to even ask the other guy what color is his jacket because that's not testimony you need two a them to testify so if both of them don't know the color of the jacket of course it's okay of course it's good he says a big argues later says no we're trying to say a case that the is no good what happened check out this the most one of the most famous book it says every testimony is two so why does the Tor say three major to tell you that all three are in the same box if you get one of them to to prove you if you can prove that one of them is a liar or one of them does know Z kick all three out all three are no good ah I don't need three two is enough no they came together 100 come together you get one all 100 are gone according TOA and that's what the mishna is saying we have good a this good testimony he's wearing a blue jacket I don't know no so this we're talking about it's not jacket they asked him what day of the month was it they B two guys say it was on the 21st of the month and one guy says I don't know I don't know means you you failed the get out not only do you get out all three of you have to leave it's not like three you get one you get them all nice it's good not bad it's not canel it's good the same case but in the in the sorry is the same exact case but we don't pass if you get one out of the three says we don't pass know don't pass say story they were learning what's the first first thing somebody asks you when you learn in from tell me something from from and if we didn't learn by what we just learn from the art scroll even without RAB what do we need RAB for now at this point R could have been a little mean to them and he could have like ripped them apart he could have asked him questions they wouldn't know what's flying that's what's match from the G he went easy on thems Us's the differ one of the says I don't know if one of them says I don't know it's bottle is the one who says I don't know it's he asked him a question what's so how come how can you get off the hook if one of doesn't know how come he's okay so they told him great answer if you don't know what date you don't know the place so I can't do I can't do we said it's not but if I don't know the color of the car this the the size of the Fig the color of the Fig you could still do it by the way what's what's the there's a guest over there didn't say what's your name from where oh lately the Anan people are very star a few of them flew in for the S here they came for the shabas in America the regards says the way I thought it meant if you if you said this oh he probably said he said a lot of good stuff no then then he yeah Rashi says if this is what you're telling me then he said not good stuff a lot of stuff he must have said a lot of good things oh my so he gave him a compliment wow you must have learned a lot of a lot of things over there so they told him because you you went easy on us you acted like an onov you could have ripped us apart but because you nice to us we're able to articulate a nice had you been mean to us we wouldn't even be able to come up with one let's just do one this little Su here cuz that's what our new guest who lives here he asked me this question in the M says if one Aid says it happened the second day of the month and the other one says the third day of the month it's a good adus at what point of the month does a person not figure out and the reason is because maybe it was a 30-day month maybe was a 29 day month okay people don't know sometimes but at what point does a person realize that he made a mistake that the happened and this in this time most of the month until the 16th of the month let's say but once you make a mistake in one day after the 16th they this is no good I'll prove it to you but if they made a mistake in two days is no good maybe a person made a mistake he didn't realize that two months in a row he didn't realize was on the 30th he thought it's on the 29th so he made a mistake of two days now the whole where's this chart right over here I forgot where it is okay somewhere I I I passed it here this one so the point is that most people figure this thing out halfway through the month a little bit more than halfway through the month and by that time you shouldn't be making mistakes on the date of the month says no people do make mistake in other words from our miss you can't prove it and that's what I told our guest you from you can't prove it is like you that after the of the month you shouldn't be made but from not why person remembers theer blowing today foras if you notice we blow there there two Sirens before shabas one maybe you don't pay attention two not have a wonderful day tomorrow there will be a Shear here in the morning but not in the evening e