Daf Yomi Sanhedrin Daf 37 by R’ Eli Stefansky

[Music] good morning r [Applause] [Laughter] [Applause] okay [Music] okay to Gary on his [Music] okay okay okay okay Ma to my sonin-law mayor Jacobs and his wife my daughter who had a baby girl so I'm going in for The KES which is immediately after it snows a couple of inches yeah B I don't know I have to look at some of the tickets gal um delli from udas Zigler you know what I'll do this first because maybe where's Yona he's on his way how far four minutes okay so I'm going to do everything else besides this here we go Froman hello rabi here we are out again louder volume please hello rebell here we are out in Coachella California on yiva week and the boys you with a lot of other families have like little movie time together we got we got Rabbi stansky time [Music] together I just started over a month ago I'm 50 years old and travel frequently a few weeks ago I had a flight from North America to Budapest with a short stop over Munich start from learning on the plane while crossing the Atlantic on it's the first time for me I felt it was important to learn in Munich [Music] Germany that please see the attached picture here it is him learning in the lounge in Munich on the same trip at 11:30 p.m. after the whole day of visiting I felt so bad that I didn't have time to open myar that I forced myself to do an despite having a 2:30 a.m. alarm to catch my return flight home see that's that's a change has had such a profound impact on my life my kavana during ding has improved I never enjoyed learning as much as I do now I'm learning in places I've never done before Planes Trains and automobile smiley face and lots of airports and malls which is good for shom you go to the mall with you now offer to take your wife to the mall cuz you know you can learn you have a couple of hours of downtime I'm proud to discuss the daily do with my friends rebell can't thank you enough for the guidance and support your wisdom and encouragement have been and will continue to be invaluable to me you're talid please keep this Anonymous I want to say tremendous shalom to my wife's cousin my cousin RAB Shields all the way from like Baltimore not M Baltimore what is it called over there only only o it's like only but it's confusing only did I know that you live there like well you moved when ah you moved 21 years ago how come you didn't tell me no I thought like Springfield you know whatever your sons used to do the da still do the da some of them do the d a little bit here and there Valic for coming oh here he's in the lounge this I thought this is interesting uh learning in the morning after ding in pukana what's that pukana anybody yeah in Mexico somewhere I don't remember when I started listening to yesir but I've been doing it since BR rep Dominican Republic okay if you don't know something my father he did a man who never went to yes but upon retirement he decided to join a learn he started every day by waking up extra early to say her B it's exactly what we spoke about yesterday every morning without fail this is very interesting let's see if anybody recognizes this name I am now also learning the for brother that's right very good how you that so you do listen to the email the the the sponsors the sponsors also make Contin thisp us all with and jokes Yeshua Yash Jacobson I was yesterday at the I met somebody and uh I hope he shows up soon he told me he's coming to the Shar today I I was I was never so excited to have a guest come as this guy I don't know he's just like maybe if he comes I'll tell you a little bit about him um but I'm going to go through the sponsors and if he comes then I'll I'll hit another email says the oh I was rudely interrupted with that nigan that's why from his grateful family started learning 7 and for 32 years until theor for the unity of the Jewish people sponsor Glenn esterson with love and gratitude from Wilmington North Carolina thank you from for enriching my life with of them children in tremendous and thank you to in honor of our oldest grandson may he grow inid we saved you a seat get over here right over here mother-in-law and so again and both them who flew in from for the shabat tone which was a tremendous thing for me gave me a lot of two guys I didn't expect them there they they uh made sure that they were there and here they are sponsoring Yin of Heidi's grandmother for healthy and easy pregnancy by and N thanking for the complete and unconditional presidential pardon for my brother I guess he maybe with the the yeah in the what do you call the capital I'm assuming I said already in honor of the person who pulled a rebell should be for this whole for his whole family to have all brought his answer quickly for the good what is this what's something like that in other pull the rebell okay Mari toell and ransy on the birth of their new granddaughter all the bras that might have been a little bit too long that and next time please make it shorter that's an inside joke for my dear friend y Grant him someone who gets he's theel he can do whatever he wants he gets the whole page over and over for Bell to have in mind okay I'm not going to say that out loud for for the whole St to to make so many in the art of the honor Mar for all the work that they do last night after I was speaking to rabona over here by the way the Mina in the that sponsor his brother brother-in-law came out of Pard first cin oh really ah you see it's kiss from we call it kiss from hasem so I got this email when was this no not this one hold on I put in an email special for you I got it at 910 I spoke to you last night at what time at um 8:30 8:30 5 so 910 I got an email a heartwarming it's not dear belly I wanted to share a beautiful moment of I'll put on the screen you can read it with me that happened during this year yesterday I've recently joined the at the beginning of San and it's been transformative for me before this I had an open up a gamar in almost 30 years when I joined on the first da and saw a massive crowd of people saying the loud ah which you missed this morning I had a profound it had a profound effect on me for the first time in a long while I felt spiritually connected to so many people in such a powerful way yesterday you read an email from sh Corman from Melbourne Australia and showed the video of his son Yi saying the good morning boy say ah what made it so extraordinary for me that I also happened to be Yan's grandfather my son had no idea that I started learning the D so hearing his email and seeing the video during the year was an incredibly heartwarming moment brought together my family and toy in a way I can never have expected thank you for all that you do to bring D to life and to inspire so many of us your has brought so many to light Joy meaning to life and I'm forever grateful to be on this journey with you warm regards igler all right what what you say nothing we're holding by a brand says the Sanhedrin used to sit like this like you see this picture right over here in a half a circle why because so everybody in the circle the semicircle could see each other from all it's interesting if you move back Ashi and all you guys move back a little bit everybody everybody in the table move back good good move back this table is one of a kind I don't know if there's any table like this in the entire world it was designed specifically for mdy it's has that purpose it goes like this you can't see it on camera but if you look from another angle maybe you'll see that it's like almost like a V it's very wide over here and very narrow over there and the purpose of the table the reason why it's made like that is that the people that are sitting at the end should be able to see over here everybody should have a view it was designed by no it was no fix his idea basically I don't know where he is today he maybe danced too hard at the last night so now you can move back you can move back re you can move back in nice and tight now that you move back in oh now we can see the V oh there were two I don't know in English it's called stenographers whatever they call like two people that write down everything that here in America they have a Shand you know they have different tricks to write it quickly but they used to write down what what the had to say one was on the right side one was on the left each one would write down the and the Z to say that he's guilty you're not guilty why the what every D said he said because of this and this he should be Z there were three secretaries one was specifically just to write that all the people that say that he's not guilty one and one to say that they are just in case there's a mistake and want to figure out where the mistake is so a third one would write down everything and hopefully between the two of them we figure things out what's your name by the way I know you from few days ago from a few days ago where do you live not Five Towns Five Towns Shalom welcome any other guests here have to say sh too real quick no no okay we got the shields over there from only only listen you're going to see something beautiful here piece of art you have a bz of 23 let's say this 23 now what happens if one of the doesn't know how to pass he doesn't know he's he's stuck he can't figure it out so what do we do we have to add now we have to add how much do how many do we add two we had two what if they don't know what if there's a stale made between the two one says yes no what if we do now you had another two two until what until you get to 71 so what we do is check this out it's a beautiful piece what he did there he worked many hours on this uh after the Hebrew Shear not last night two nights ago he stayed up afterwards for another two hours to make the corrections that I asked him to do so it's amazing Yos did a fantastic job here the three rows that you see on the bottom these are replacement di these are people that are potential di if there's there's alternates so as the m is going to say this might be more for the the next part the no not really how much does each row have the same exact amount of people that we have on the main Row the main row we have how many 23 so we have another 69 now the question is why do you need so many what you really need is another 48 cuz the max you can get to is to 7 1 23 + 48 but the problem is each row could only have 23 you can't have larger rows than the actual bz that's not good and you you can either you can't have smaller rows than the actual bz so M you do three rows even though you don't really need that many so you're only you're the overage is only two right you have 23 + 23 is 46 and you need 48 so for the extra two you have to make a whole new row of 23 now this is not the art that I'm talking about in a second hold on here it goes everybody knows where they belong and the Miss is going to explain what that means we'll see exactly what that means if we need to do on one of the what happened change of case one of the goes up goes bye-bye now that's different than the case we said before before the guy was deadlocked he didn't know what to do so you add two when a guy goes bye-bye you only add one now where do you take that one you have all these guys in front of you have 23 plus 23 plus 23 where do you take you take from the first row because the first row is the most the second row is second third row exactly the opposite of what they taught us in over here we we're all professionals we know exactly who's and who's not and in the row itself we know who's more than the other how does it work the guy all the way on the right is the most the guy next to him is right under him inash we do a IQ test and a shast test and a this test we decide okay he's the most he's second now check this out what out of the three rows the middle one the middle one is also less and also the the one all the way in the right is the most of that Row the third row the guy way on the right is the most that roow now take a look at what happens Bo it's incredible stuff here that guy goes five so what do we do everybody on that row has to move over now why cuz we're going to take we're going to take a guy from the first row but we can't place him in seat number five he's not as of as number five he belongs in seat number one he's the least of the he was no it can't be that he wouldn't be there he's younger okay that's how it is check it out watch watch watch you're going to miss no qu no talking now check this out everybody moves over the guy from the right goes that way everybody moves this way the guy all the way the right goes that way everybody moves over now and now where do we get a new guy from the audience boomi it's unbelievable I don't know if it's true I heard that in the miror the miror in Poland the most used to sit on the left side and like you couldn't sit there if you w that's how it was where they sit and where would they sit were four classes no and they they made it known that's not nice that's okay not into that so much okay so let's see it inside they had to give one of them they take from the first row row number one the the the what is it called the floor seats the the seats that are all the way in the front by the way all these three rows are on the floor the DI are raised up on chairs these guys are sitting on the floor Courtside that's that's the that's the word I was looking for courtside seats they take from the right now a guy from the second row jumps up to the first row and a guy from the third row comes to the second row now if you read it I don't know if You' see it as visual is this now we know what it's talking about here when it says the the guy from the third row goes to the second row now we know exactly where he comes from and where he went to he went all the way from the left to the right then we take a guy from the audience and so nobody everybody sits in their exact same place where they need to sit they don't sit let's say the guy from the first row doesn't jump into the seat of the dying that died that's what the says now doesn't take over his seat so maybe you're right if he's he would sit in that seat or maybe You' even push he's more than the head of the what but maybe maybe picked up and learning later on I don't know say this is called we're doing easy stuff and we got to move we really got to move how do we know this it says in the what do these words mean means the naval it's the center the center of the world is the center of the world the and the in the naval in the belly button of the world a what's aan here's an aan means like a basin of some sort say rash it's made out of marble such as this when you have truth and and real real real then you have it saves the world it protects the world means the moon why is it called the moon because of not this this uh this this looks like a like a moon Mo when the moon is you know Crest and the Half Moon don't have any it shouldn't be less than mus so in the time of thear we know they had very very strong wine they they loot the wine with 2/3 water if one of the 23 day had to go somewhere let's he had a had to go to Utah he would make sure that 23 you missed it y you missed the whole thing they sang for me I had a after I spoke to you my daughter gave birth to a girl so I'm going to UT I'm just trying to fill you in so you don't feel like left out over here he doesn't live in ut he just wants to go vacation that listen somebody scared me today he said they closed on the SLO okay forget I'm not going to visit the no KES ah it's just a joke okay fine I'm going if there's 23 left you go out why because check this out what's 23 23 is a third of 71 the main s00 71 so you have to have the third the main the ior the wine part there's two parts water one part wine make sure is always the wine don't have less than the of the it says in the your stomach is like a pile of wheat everybody benefits from wheat you have Donuts you have pizza you have bread everybody benefits from the sanedrin in the time of the sanedrin if you think about it any shil you ever had can you wear such a sh can you do such a thing what whatever Sanhedrin said boom that was it there's no argument no this said that this say that say like this but the there's no such thing San that that's it sh what's here a picture you have a fence made out of roses it's not a really strong fence anybody could just break right through it but if kel has a fence a simple fence for they're not going to break it for instance came to ra started up with him and he said say we know that you to have with her a husband is allowed to be with her he tells him what you think that there's there's a fire and there's a bunch of uh particles of you know dust particles and small pieces of wood it's not going to it's not going to burn you're telling me people are not the testifies about us that we have no issue with that all we need is a little GA we're not going to have issue you make a little a little a little GA says I don't understand so how how do we in fact have with what's the answer somebody come up with an answer oh I like that better what you past Sally what does it mean yeah okay but what you're saying is the next Point hold on I'll get to what you're saying says since it's that will become so we're not concerned but however if a person was never with her then he has a problem and then he shouldn't be say says I learned from this check this beautiful I love this this is a m of beauty you see this no you don't see it hold on look at this look if you look closely each each pit of the REM it's like the like a piece of a pomegranate ra what does mean learns the word like means in Hebrew it means empty the empty guys in full of we know the famous smelled y's clothing that he was pretending to be as and it smelled weird don't read clothing the traitors those who who are bued you what is that mean so real quickly the RAB tells us who are these them two stories crazy stories that when the came the Romans they came into the they wanted to take the C of the these golden vessels the him who are they so they were scared to go in so they said we need to get a Jew to go in for us let him be the scapegoat so they said whoever goes in to get a CLE he could keep it so yes runs in he was over he ran in and he took the Mana most beautiful thing you have a nice Mana it's nicer than any giant Mana you can buy in the airport whatever so they said no no no that's that's too big for you that's too large this one we're going to keep you go back in and get that the messing with him so he said I'm not going in so he said you don't go in we're going to start we're going to kill you so he said okay so he started cutting his body in pieces and he kept on screaming what was the Lo over there I deserve this because I made my my Creator upset and he died saying these words so his so so yeah so that's B that's that the other one is y he was the nephew of the famous YZ who's dying they were taking him away and he started laughing at his Uncle he says look at you you're doing mitz that's why they're killing you H they had a hold back and forth and he says I'm dying and look at you and he realized that he's making a mistake after he made fun of his uncle he realized he's a buot he's a traitor and then he said okay he did something incredible he he killed himself with the four M bezan other words he jumped off a roof on top of a sword that cut off his head would burned him at the same whatever he did some trick all four B so his uncle said oh he was mocked me he got to G in one minute before me okay so these that b them these are the traitors even though they're traitors they still they still have MIT the tough guys the mafia that lived in's neighborhood he [Music] did they should do yeah my son-in-law the mayor he went to Utah to do to be M people that's what he's doing there no minion they reopen the SL huh they reopen the SL it's open for a while I'm following every minute don't worry I go on Like You on the ni I go on to see if it's snow that day don't worry about it I'm I'm I'm On Top Rabon were not happy it was almost like R grman right R grman used to go into the discos be M People Rabon were not happy with him until later on they oh so he went to be what are you going to be M these people they're bad guys what are you doing so these bad guys said what are we going to do so this is very interesting we learned was called he was short and with burnt feet why because every 30 days he would check to see if gim is going to get him so he'd go into an oven and it wouldn't burn him and then one time they had some iron heart or something ra looked at he went and he burnt his feet so they they called him the shorty the shorty with the burnt feet he's no longer going to D in for us what are we going to [Music] do so who's going to ask for forgiveness ask that they thought about it in their hearts they so you see at the end it does work out you go to these places and they become this is we already saw everybody in this room all 92 people are moving everybody moves well not all 92 maybe the guys I'm thinking the DI that are sitting to the left of the main guy in the center they don't move any not any Dy from from the guy from the Dy that was nter to his left doesn't move yeah those guys don't move okay fine but everybody moves [Music] says the guy whoa I was the first one on my row I'm top of the top of my row you're going to put me by by the tail I'm going to sit on the left I was the I was the the left guy on my row now you're going to put me on the right side of your Ro doesn't work the famous saying better to be the taale of a lion you go to to that are that are better than you go to to place that's better a community that's better than you although the say I think they say in the name of that when it comes to a Yeshiva boy it's better that he should be the top of his class and the top of his Yeshiva than the worst of his Yeshiva for for self-esteem purposes and stuff like that so if you put him in a a lower level Yesa but he's the top guy then he's he's flourishing that's better that's what they say that's not true huh that's not true good compared to the to the guys Inon okay I got you I know what you're saying I knew you're going to say something like that but Rashi says something interesting here so I only know about basketball so excuse me if it's a bad muscle and football and this and that but there's always that bench warmer you know that guy that doesn't get to play he sits on the on the bench most of the time and he feels bad to himself he's like what am I a loser what am I doing here so you have to understand says Rashi you look around you look at the stadium you're better than 100,000 people here you happen to be on the bench you're the last guy on the bench there better you're the the sh but you're still better than all the spectators I mean inass there's only 550 people in in the league or something 560 whatever it is so that means you're better than it's one per million almost or more in the if you're talking about the world but even in America you this you're better than at least a million people okay it's also don't don't look at the bad you look at the good you're you're top you're top guy just happened to be the lowest of the top guys okay it's also so they didn't show up and we threaten them we scare them a little bit how do we do this for people that coming in for murder they're trying to to testify they they saw a murder they bring them in and they would say maybe you didn't really see it it happened to me once I I saw an accident and then 10 seconds later I was thinking did I see the accident or I heard the accident I spun my head and then I saw the smoke and I thought I saw I wasn't sure like literally like 10 seconds later like what did I see like because I guess the the adrenaline and everything you don't hop exactly but they say did you see it or you're trying to use logic here the mission is going to tell us the going to say exactly what happened sometimes you see a guy running after somebody with a gun and you run after after him you see a guy that just got shot by a bullet blood is coming out of his head and he's jumping around and you see a guy running away you know it's him but did you see the murder circumstantial evidence that's exactly what it is circumstantial evidence that's what it is and it doesn't work in the T it doesn't work that's not considered testimony maybe you heard from somebody maybe you heard it from a very good guy from a very from your own R your R told you he saw the murder now you're coming to testify that doesn't work either here say you should know that we are going to we're going to find out the truth here because we're going to interrogate you till the end we're going to do AA we're going to do so real quickly here they have a little piece for today um here we go let's stickle value maybe here are the witnesses who claim to have seen Ruan desecrate the shabas we saw moment we need to threaten you threaten you can only testify to what you saw yourself not something you merely thought you saw or heard and know that we will interrogate you and check carefully whether your virgins match and D neous is not like d morus if The Condemned person is killed then not only are you killing him but also his sons and his sons Sons until the end of all generations if you are lying then you are mass murderers anyone who kills one soul is as if he killed an entire F second thought may maybe you cannot turn back if you saw and you did not testify then you are violating a Prohibition from the toone they they continue you should know beautiful everybody know [Applause] yeah you should know that this is different this is actually [Music] approved when it comes to a monetary case you lied you stole from somebody you give the money back end of the story you know by murder what are you taking away you're taking away the guy's potential he could have had a child he could have 10 children those 10 children would have another 10 children you see the first murder in history he killed his brother doesn't say the blood of your brother says the Bloods of your brothers not of your brothers of your the Bloods of your brother are screaming yeah okay at least that word I got means that you you you're taking responsibility for any potential that could have came out of this person just as a side is not what we tell the but this you should know between me and you he's blood was everywhere on this on the on the trees and on the stones the is going explain you should know that man the was born by himself only by himself for a number of reasons imagine somebody would have killed adish if a lion would have came and killed him he would have destroyed the billions of people that we have today how many n billion 7 billion I don't even know what we have today eight and a half we're closing in a 9 billion just in this generation alone that's what you took away from the world that that one NE is all this m if you save one individual you were M the entire world when I met y last night I I told I for a long time I didn't I didn't I was much excited that you're going to come today so I I asked him I said you look like he says yeah that's how much do you learn whatever we're not going to go into it hasn't learn gar in a long time it learns every day but not so I told him I said this is it says in this the guy that saves a guy that's drowning guy that has a heart attack you m the whole world but if you MIM you have to you have to save your own soul it's one thing of saving you have to save yourself and save your M by learning to every day every single day you learn gar every day you save yourself you save his soul and that's why I'm going toaz this over a thousand times I'm never going to stop Le another when you see somebody drowning and every single one of us knows this guy in sh that hasn't opened up a safeer in 30 years every sh has this guy and many of them so just like don't be like that New Yorker that sees a guy on the floor of the subway which I saw with my own eyes a guy having a heart attack and people literally stepped over him around him walked just kept them going don't be that guy we are doing that in a r way we see people that that s they really want to learn they really but they don't know how they don't know where to start what to do we have a to go over them and help them out sound and when you do that because I myself yesterday spoke to six people about joining the six I happened to be in the my wife is not here so I had to go shopping six people at the also one out of the six came and that's enough for me sorry for being Vue like that but okay you know the says that in other words if a guy's dying right here and you could learn t if you're the only guy obviously you have to take care of him but if there's another guy which MIT you do or take let him take the call you're doing the now you got to Lear Okay the reason why created the world with one person because to make peace in in in in kindergarten my father is greater than you he's stronger than your father check this out say also a nice littleti that he did over here oh you know you know my my grandfather is he's the ml he was 337 and a half for he says yeah but my my grandfather is the he's like not your grandfather's nothing compared to my grandfather so the the the the Torah tells us said you know what our grandfathers are the exact same person we have the same we all come all humans come from the same exact individual we all have the same DNA at the end of the day different that you could say and say that there's two there's two no only one Man was created that means one when you have a mint to mint coins every coin is identical I have a very good friend in Chicago one of the glennard I'm not going to say exactly which one maybe doesn't want me to say his name has a collection of quarters the the the biggest collection in the world of quarters quarters 25 cents some of his quarters are worth over $300,000 and more why because there was a little defect in the mint like the when they were minting the coin in 1796 whatever year was it was a little off you explained that you take a magnify this because that little thing and if it's a perfect addition $300,000 that but that's a rarity that's why it's worth so much every coin is the same everybody is with the same mint of not a single human being that looks like his friend every human being looks different it's unbelievable you think there's n billion different looking different people it's crazy therefore each and every one has to say the world was created for me what does that mean says Rashi so we threatened the a you have a guy here that's about to murder somebody for no reason he's about to say this guy is and he's lying so you tell him instead of saying oh you're going to go and you're going to get you're going be the worst guy of this you tell him no you build up his self-esteem you say you know that the whole world was supposed to be created just for you and it's true every yid the world could have been created just for him and what what am I going to I'm going to because of one silly a I'm going to pull myself out of this world that was created just for me no I don't want to I don't want to say well I'm going to go get myself now go uh go to court and they're going to ask me all these crazy questions and ruin my [Music] day what's the next words you get a bigger if you don't go testify well be a nice guy what I'm because of me this guy's going to die why should I kill him what no I'll be not alive no no no yeah but why should I I don't want to get involved yeah I'll be americanish no it's not exactly but why should this guy die I'll be when you get rid of it's It's a happy time what do we have here we have to do this no here we go turning the D by the bichi family in honor of MD da Champions Leo uncle Freddy Mr our fearless leader and Chief and this is this was the guy in the email by the members of the Mony fire department we have 19 guys in Mony fire department that do the D it's an incredible thing fil films strategic video production here's the story they tell maybe you saw a guy running into some ruins and you ran after him you see you see a bloody sword in the in the in the this guy's hand there's not a guy that died a day ago or an hour ago the the the dead guy is still moving around if that's the murder that you saw that's only circumstantial evidence you need to see it with your own eyes the same exact story happened to me literally what you're saying happened to me it's missing the word because it's like a a nice way of saying a not nice thing I should see I literally saw the story I saw a guy running after someone else and they ran after him I saw a sword in his hand it's dripping blood fire and I told him who killed him there's only two options here it's either me or you and I know it's not me I can't kill you the says it's two who could who knows your thoughts he's going to get rid of you they said they didn't move from there a snake came and kill this guy so when when somebody kills somebody when somebody kills somebody what M bz does he get he get they take his head off with his sword a snake bite is what M it's burning it's the burning of the the blood is burning so as thear this guy deserves to die by a snake he deserves to die by his head being chopped off somehow from the day that was destroyed even though we don't have aan anymore but we still kill people with the four we know that we don't kill [Music] people the idea behind is not B that what if somebody did let say somebody and he didn't do he's gonna get something similar to falling off a roof now I don't want anybody here thinking oh yeah I know that guy he fell off the roof oh he's stop being like that he has some fire dies in a fire or a snake bites him if he needs to get the sword or he'll get punished by the death penalty of the king or List here we have everything in a thing here we go not this there's something better [Music] there if let's say so you fall off a roof here we go let's say let's say s they take you away the court the the government or you get held up let's say you have to choke so you the hanging so you either drown or you choke on a piece of food or something also you have this this is what skila looks like skila they take you up to something that's two floors tall and they push you off and if you don't die from that the person doesn't die then they um they Stone him and after they Stone him they uh hang him it's very tough to hang a potato there's no like no neck says not only this is not only something that happens after the was destroyed but this also happened during the time of the in other words in the time of when there's no nobody warned the guy there's no a him let's say somebody murdered somebody he's still going to get he's going to get the same idea that saying he'll get he'll get some sometime during his life will take care of him so the question is why does this guy get a snake B he should have gotten something that's similar to he had another a that he did that he deserved now is considered more than her so and [Music] says two different things he will get the more in other words he'll get instead of it says that when it comes to when it comes to a capital case when you want to kill somebody no circumstantial evidence seems like from the mishna you just make a simple infer inference in inference forget it forget the word doesn't work today you make a simple di that's in a capital case but in a manitary case you could you could testify with circumstantial evidence who does this go like let's you have a camel that's mating and he goes a little muga and he and he he kicks another camel he kills another camel now you didn't really see it you see a foam coming out of his mouth look at this guy he has foam literally foam his white you see his face is white that's all foam from from his he's in a rage and all of a sudden you see another camel dead but you didn't see the actual killing you have to pay for it you the owner of this crazy camel has to pay the other guy for the camel but you didn't see the death it's obvious that he's going to kill him but guess what you just made a deal because the Miss is talking about only but it seems like you could do circumstantial evidence but there's another case that's only in he paid I can't testify the M says when it comes to capital punishment from another Aid I heard from another Aid what oh I could testify that you owe a million dollars because I heard it from another person of course not I need to see it with my own eyes it says in the Mna happens to me all the time doesn't happen to normal people but people come you know you owe me $1,000 okay fine they know I don't have a good memory so they could tell me things like that or the place that everybody's familiar with told me that he ow money now you remember the you remember this if you tell me that you owe money to him we don't believe you why would you say that you owe money you remember cuz he wants to pretend that he is poor okay now you can go you have to witness the saying to the Mala the saying to the lender in front of me both of them were in front of me and they he admitted him that he owes him $200 it was said in the M only by even though this case applies to circumstantial evidence also you cannot base your testimony on circumstantial evidence not only in but also in M why is it not said in the Mish because the Mish speaking about not about don't make any here says let me just remind you what it says in the Mish so you don't have to turn to the other page this is what it says in the M it says in the that the blood of your brother is screaming so he says what's there so much blood there was so much blood because there was so many wounds blood was oozing out of him was like the worst death ever for some reason he knew that you could kill a human being hasem said I'm going to you're going to die no he didn't know from where but he knew that you could kill a person nobody ever died before nobody ever died he knew there something called Death it's interesting and he started to whacking him everywhere here this is the gamar this is what we learned in this is what we learned in kindergarten right here he stabbed him everywhere so blood was coming out from everywhere didn't know how to kill someone and killed him when he got his neck when the earth opened up its mouth and took the blood of never happened again the Earth never open up its mouth what's the on this when did the earth open up its mouth again from the edge of the Earth the Earth never opened its mouth I didn't say never open I meant it never opened it for the good to cover somebody else's blood but to kill them yes when a person has sins so going in is how do I know because it says in the two words after went we dropped the word not so half of his his sin went away if you stay in the city you'll die from either sword famine or a plague if you leave then you live so you see will save your life happens to be that the vill says the vill was very big into gos I was just thinking a thought I don't know I hope this is the right thing to say but I think most people in this room made alah right right most people made Aliah so if you think about it it's very very difficult I'm not I'm saying Aliyah is unbelievable I also but the language is different the pizza tastes different to open up a bank account takes 6 weeks it's a very difficult thing so basically it's like we're going to go not only but also you going through the the terrible pain and aggravation of of G and that's like nothing else thear says over I'm not saying it's G I'm saying the the of G of going to another country picking your whole family up from their friends from your family everything and picking everything up and going that's G but it's not g don't say that I said it's G he's not going to have children did I skip no no no we're not to okay so you don't want let's stop over here cuz it's late Rai have a wonderful day