Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
[Music]
Good
[Music]
morning live from Park City,
Utah. The final shar from Park City,
Utah of this season and the final shear
for today. This is shared number four
for a tremendous tremendous marshazi who
is with me for all four 2 in the morning
2 in the
evening. The idea is to have shirim
ready for the three-day yv so
that the new guys that come in for ais
they shouldn't fall behind on day one.
They should have enough shim to go
through yont. You should be able to
watch
it. There's only two days left to the
only two
days. And uh I know some of you haven't
brought anybody. You you hear about it.
You think about it. Come on, get out of
your comfort zone. Get off your chair.
Pick up the phone. Go get somebody.
Goapido.
So far many, many new guys are joining
and you could be part of this. It's a
revolution. It's bringing people to
Tyra. I want to show you something. This
is something you don't see in America.
Only in Israel, one of a kind. Check out
this
picture. I have to explain
it. If you look closely, you'll see
there's a green walking sign. In other
words, this delivery guy is at a red
light and he decided to use his time at
the red light
wisely and he's watching the shear. Let
me show you. Somebody saw him. He's
watching his the shear at the stoplight.
Incredible
picture. The delivery guy. Okay, that's
one. Very
interesting.
Today after giving
two I went to meet my family. They all
went out to the to ski and I have to
think three days I went skiing and no
injuries, no falls,
no my legs held out, my bad knee, my bad
hip.
Hashem didn't feel a thing.
Give I see a guy, a yeshiva guy sitting
there with a yamama. So I said hello to
him. He says rebell. Yeah. He says
you're not going to believe it. And here
he is. He says over the story on video,
check this out. Mark, we have some
volume over here. The voice say, look
who I met over here. What's your name?
Cindy Klein Sha. What did you say? I
said I listened to the daff by Ellie for
the first time today on the plane. First
time ever. First time ever. It was
special. It's a It's a kiss from Hashem.
And all of a sudden now I meet him. I
said hello. I see a guy with a Yamaka
sitting around. I see you. You ski
already. I didn't ski up here. What are
you doing? Why don't you go skiing? I I
have to get my stuff. You know, you
learned you learned what did you learn.
Du. Wow. Cool. All right. So he's
learning with Duo
Araven and hold it. Uh well, we got to
show the next
one. And
um so he decided to watch MDY. Today was
the first time he ever watched it on the
plane and he bumps in to me. I think
it's a very interesting thing. The
sader. Next one. This guy
Ah, Maddy's the ah moment. Revolutionary
care straight to your couch. Servicing
Bar Park, Crown Heights, Williamsburg,
upstate New York, and now starting a
numa sector
[Music]
my
voice in Toronto mdy
toronto.com and uh you can find your
local at
mdycm.com. All the in Monty in
Brooklyn and Toronto and everywhere else
in the world should be on
mdy.com
mdycm.com. Let's see what do we have
here. Oh, I think it's to speak about
this again. It's been a while since I've
written this. Today marks the second
yard of
our and I felt compelled to reach out.
As you know, was truly a remarkable
person, humble, sincere, and deeply
connected to Torah. What most people
including yourself only discovered after
his passing was just how much he quietly
supported MDY. His love for Tyra and his
appreciation for what you have built was
genuine and sincere. I wanted to share
the backstory of how Manim became
connected to MDY. I was in Israel over
Thanksgiving weekend about two and a
half years ago and had arranged with my
friend Ellie churns to attend your shar
live to your live shar when overheard us
he expressed interest in coming to the
live shar. The next morning he came
early to pick him up from his hotel but
he couldn't find his time was running
out and he urged us not to wait for him
but we told him if you're not coming
we're not going a few minutes later
found them and off we went we made it
just in time. He absolutely loved
Yushir. What he didn't tell us then or
even really or ever really was that he
would go on to sponsor hundreds of
gumaras. He never sought recognition or
honor. That simply wasn't who he was. He
was a nister in the truest sense. Ellie
and I don't share this to take any
credit did it all. But like you always
say, if you bring one person to the
daff, you never know what could come
from it. You hear that? If you bring one
person to the da, the one that I can
remember is Benny Rudlick. One person to
the daff, but you never know. It might
be the Klene. It might be the
marshanazi. Yeshua Empire brought
marshazi to the daff. You never know.
And Yona Rothman
brought Tapar
province was that person because his
deep love of for Tyra countless others
have learned grown and connected to.
This is just one facet of what made so
special. His presence is missed every
single day and his memory remained so
vivid for all who knew him. May
the have an aliyah from all the that
continues to be learned in his from the
lives he touched so quietly and so
powerfully. Well, it's amazing. I'm
going to say this again. He gave
hundreds of gumaras without
having that kind of money when he was
lifter. It was known later that he
didn't have all that. But he gave he
gave and he gave because he wanted to
give.
did Rothman. He is myid. I know him
since my days in Berlin. We played
basketball a lot together in Camp Mars.
You remember those nights at 1 2 in the
morning with the lights and barely
seeing this dirt and would slip over
there? Mica
times. Um, let's go. We'll jump into it.
Why
not? Uh, okay. Oh, I have to do the
sponsors. Jumping into it is not going
to work right now.
say these are the last days for these
sponsors. I'm curious to know who's
sponsoring by the grateful family
anonymous for
the Larry Cohen in memory
of who started learning at age 17 for 32
years until he was lifted. Anonymous for
the unity of the Jewish people. Glenn
Esterson with love and gratitude from
Wilmington, North Carolina. Thank you
for enriching my life with the monthly
sponsors by
actualize
and for the Thank you to Elli's wife and
kids for the great sacrifices they make
allowing him to spread to the masses.
Thank you. Daily sponsors Edward Gster
in loving memory of
Basaki Frank Rubin wishing Alicia Rubin
on his new business. Reuben legacy
financial mids monthly
innovations and Mrs.
Art of the
month for the staff to continue to
make and in honor of Kle and Marazi for
all the work they
do. Here we
go. Here's the question. We're
holding
question. Two people are about to walk
into there's only room for one person to
fit through the door. Who goes first?
the guy wearing on his head and on his
arm or the guy holding a bag. There
is who should go first?
First thought comes to mind. The guy
that's wearing the fillain on his
head guy wearing fill on his head. He's
like more kadesh. He has more. He should
go in first. Let's say somebody's
holding a satire. He should go in before
a person without a
satire. But the BI says not like that.
He proves it from our
sug. So let's see. We have some super
interesting suggest
about this idea of fill in not I mean
we're taking it out from this whole
business but many other as well.
We are in the midst of the
ofas is a city that the majority of the
inhabitants of the city 51% let's call
them worship of they have a special they
all die with a sword which is not as bad
as dying with skiila that if an
individual would do it you die with skil
however what's bad about it is that all
their belongings go up in flames we burn
it all. The Mishna told us that in order
for this to happen, you need somebody to
convince the entire city and that
someone has to be from the city and from
the same What
if nobody convinced them? They just
convince themselves seems like from the
Mishna they wouldn't be but they asked
the
question what if they convinced
themselves to worship didn't have
anybody to
be somebody convinced them to do
wrong and not if it happened by
themselves perhaps even if they convince
themselves that they're also
considered we could prove
It says the mission that if women or
children are the ones that con did the
convincing. It's not it's not counted as
anything. Just pretend they don't exist
at all. And then it's as if they
convince
themselves and you see from here they've
convinced yourself it's nothing. Says
no. When women and children convince
it's worse. Why?
When a person convinces himself, he's
sticking to it. He's much stronger in it
and
therefore he should
be. But the other people they were
convinced by women and children. So
their conviction to is less. So perhaps
they're not considered.
We saw in the Mishna it's a sug after
small and stuff. We saw that in order to
be you have to have the majority of the
city should be doing
says how exactly does this work? You
come into the city there'sund 100,000
people 51,000 people are doing. So you
grab one, you bring it to
Bezin and what? He's an individual. He's
not a He's not a full city. He's not a
majority of the city. So, so what do you
do? So you have to do bring all 51,000
people to be in the same day. It's
almost impossible. So you this over a
few weeks. So now you gave this guy
judgment and now he has to wait with his
judgment until he gets the penalty. It
could be a few weeks, a few months.
That's not fair. That's giving him extra
pain. We learned in this if you you
judge somebody to the death penalty, you
kill them right
away. You judge the person, you put them
in jail. Judge another person until you
have 51,000 people in jail, then you
take them all, you kill
them. Comes out, they torturing these
people for a long time. They know that
they're going to die. They're on death
row and they're not dead. They they need
to be killed right away. So what's
advice?
We you treat each individual as an
individual and the individual that
does he
gets notif which the gets
skil until you get to a point where you
killed the majority of the city you
killed 51,000 people with skiila then
51,0001 that guy is part of
And he
gets agrees to
this has another idea. Let's put you
51,000 people. So bring
150,000 make
50,000 and you could judge all them in
one
shot. That's impossible.
You should remove that person, that
woman, that child, that that that man,
that
woman. You only take one individual to
the gates of your city. And what do we
have in the gates of the city? A peasant
of
23. But when you're dealing
with, then you don't bring them to this
to the city gate. You have to bring them
to your to the where you have a
Sanhedrin of 71. So what are you telling
me? You're going to bring 150,000 and
you're going to make crazy amount of no
you need one and it's called the 71 they
have to deal with it. So
then then we have the same question. How
are you going to how are you going to
judge so many people with one of
71? If you judge one at a time then
you're being you're causing them a lot
of torture.
says you get a lot of and they they look
at it they they they see what what
should we do over here and then
afterwards then once they know what to
do they bring everybody to the
71 we even have a picture that I don't
know if you remember that but everybody
moved down the line was stuff let me
See, then that whole row moves over, but
I don't think we have it here. Okay.
It says in the Mishna that if you don't
have a majority of people that do have a
desire but then a bunch of camel drivers
came into the city and they stayed
there, they slept there, they become
part of the city and they could have
influenced the majority either to say
the majority does have a des drivers are
people that don't do have a
desert that the majority of the city
does not do have a des nobody die. It's
not. You have these people on on camels
on donkeys. They go from place to
place. If they slept in the city and
they did have a desire with the
city, if they were in the city for 30
days, then they
become everybody gets the sword and you
burn all their belongings. But if it's
less than 30
days, then we treat them as individuals,
which is their
is and their
belongings survived. They don't get the
burning penalty. You don't burn it. Ask
the you telling me it's 30 days. I have
another source that tells me it's 12
months. Where
in how long do you have to stay in a
city to to be
uh to have to pay the local taxes and
everything else that the city
pays? Is 12
months. So how can we say it's 30 days
when says in order to be part of the
city you have to be there for 12
months. No, it's
not. Check out the
says you have to be a dweller in the
city. You don't have to be a citizen of
the city. You have to be a dweller of
the
city. You come to a place like uh Park
City, Utah, and you sit here for three,
four days in a hotel. You're not
a for 30 days then you're a you live
here permanently you become a citizen of
the city that's 12 months then you
become a citizen so for certain things
all you need is a and certain things you
need to
be you want to be a citizen then you
have to spend 12 months
there you know it reminds me like people
that run away from New York to Florida
for taxes so the certain amount of days
they have to be in Florida in order to
be considered a citizen of Florida. You
can't just show up there in the summer
for three days or yeshiva week and say,
"Oh, I live in Florida." They check your
they check your flights. They check your
credit cards and they know what they're
doing. You got to be careful. People
that do this, they tell me, "No, I can't
I can't come to the bar because I have
to be a certain amount of days in Bokeh
or whatever it is that these people live
in to save the taxes." So says and taxes
here. We're talking about taxes here.
But if you want to live
there just to be
a to be a
citizen you just want to live there
living is is 30
days. So
the the in the city so when he starts
off the pes he starts off right
away the money that you're supposed to
give the poor people for pes and he says
when are you obligated to give? He says
if you live in a city for 12 months then
you're obligated to give. And when are
you
uh eligible to receive if you're you're
poor and you want to receive
the you have to live in the city for 12
months. You can't just show up to a
wealthy city and say oh I'm a resident
of the city. You come from you come to
my you say I'm a resident. No you you
just got off the plane to live there for
12 months.
However, there's there's an interesting
if a person purchases a house in a city
then it starts immediately then you
become part of the city
then the first day and if you purchase a
house and you're poor you could also
receive the right away the says that one
should be even 30 days based on this
gimar I guess the is also basing on the
gamar here 12 months 30 days the says
but let's be mak on 30 days if you're in
a city for 30 days you should start
paying up the
localisk
fund and I'll prove to you have to read
it. This is not a question. This is an
answer. This is a not an answer but a a
proof to exactly what we said. This is
the difference between 12 months and 30
days. Somebody says I will not benefit.
I make a nether. I won't benefit from
anybody that lives in
If a person lives in for 12 months, this
individual who said he's from that city
can't benefit from but the guy lived in
less than 12
months he could benefit from him. But if
he that's because he
[Music]
said city dweller that's 12 months but
if he says
of similar to the P that we have over
here that's
only difference between 12 months and 30
days depending if you're talking about
av then then the is 30
is this just reminds me that I was in a
certain country and I didn't want to
tell people where I was and I was
drinking the water bottle and it was a
funny label and they took the label and
they figured out that I was in Africa
something like that.
If you have a who lives in the he
doesn't do and he has possessions
outside of the city they don't get
burned but all the possessions that are
inside the city is car is washing
machine everything gets burned. How do
we know this
from everything that's in the city but
not stuff that's outside the city? What
about the Russia did have a stuff
outside the city that we'll see that is
burnt
but everything that's inside has to get
burnt even though it's the belongings of
why he didn't do thear is going to
explain that that we saw that anything
that's
that's something like that all these
things that you don't That's we'll have
a about
that means even if a
Russia and he has stuff outside of the
city you have to burn that as
well says this is the
famous time of the today it's very in to
try to understand the mitzvah why did he
say this mitzvah say that mitzvah
People come up with all sorts of weird
stuff. But says, "Look, certain things I
could understand. Why did the say that
it's sadik's belongings have to be
burnt? I'll tell you
why. Why is it sadic living in
this? He went to the to get a to get a
job to get money to was he was driven by
money. driven by money. So the money is
going to get
burnt. He said that belongings of the
Russia that are outside the
city those get
burned provided that you could gather it
quickly and easily and bring it into the
city.
In other words, if the das is in
America, well, it has to be in Israel,
but okay, let's say it's in. It's next
to and the guy's belongings are in
Africa. So, we don't say, "Oh, go to
Africa, bring the stuff, and let's burn
it." If it's next door in you take it
and you bring
it deposits what what does a deposit
have? Now depends whose deposit it is.
So nothing is going to discuss if the
receive deposits. Let's say they're a
bank and they receive deposit. It's not
their money. They're holding on to
somebody else's money. So why should it
be burnt? But let's say gave deposits to
another city. Shouldn't that be burnt?
As long as it's we just said provided
that it's close to the city, it's not in
Africa, it's close by. Why shouldn't it
be burned? So that's exactly what the is
going to
say there, you don't have to burn it.
What's the
case? They received received a deposit
from another city.
It's not their money to be burnt.
They're just doing somebody a favor.
Whatever. They're holding on to somebody
else's money. It's not theirs to be
burnt. They do. But you're going to say,
"No, this is
money." And they deposited in another
city. Maybe they're smart. They didn't
want it to be burnt. They put it in
another
city. if it could easily be brought into
the
should and if
not we already said
this we're talking about another city
put money into the ask them to hold on
to
it they had a special what is it called
FDIC they guarantee everything if
something is stolen and lost they will
guarantee it
It's interesting because this is also in
if a non-Jew
deposits he says hold on to these 10
pies of pizza for me and the Jew takes
responsibility says if it's stolen I
will pay for it. So it's considered the
Jews pizza and he's
on
on same thing over here. I would think
that the they took a responsibility on
this deposit and they're saying look if
something happens to it I will pay for
it. So then it's as if it's theirs. If
it's theirs they should they should have
to you should have to burn
it. It's literally like as if it's owned
by fascinating stuff coming up here.
If you have an animal, let's say uh two
people own a car rental place and in the
car rental place they rent the local you
know whatever they had in those days
they used to rent animals. So they own
an animal as
partners. One guy is you're an person
and everything that he owns has to be
burnt and one guy is a regular nice
guy. This animal is you can't do
anything with it.
Esau. Let's say two partners own a
matzah
bakery. One guy is guy and one guy is
brought. What do you do with the
dough? The only half of it is going to
be the half the kosher half
is. So this is very deep says Rashi in
order to eat an animal in order to make
an animal kosher you have to
sh but you if you have to kill this
animal so the is not
a on that half it's not a that half it's
killing it so you didn't sh this animal
you only shed half the animal you can't
eat a half animal this halfed halfed
animal that's what learns it
However, but when it comes to dough in a
matzah
bakery, why can't you divide the dough
5050? I don't have to something. You
can't have half. You have to go through
the
completely. But by I could say this
half, the right half is the half and the
left half is the good guys half. But how
could I do that? It's all mixed in
together. So for that we have to come on
to the famous concept called bra
retroactive
clarification which tells us that when I
divide the dough 50/50 the right part
goes to the left part goes to to the
good guy that's how it was established
that's what the the the
uh
the breakup maybe is the word that's
what the division happened from day one
when the you mix the dough that's what
it was now that I break it in
I retroactively understand that that's
exactly what the partnership
was
says another
question. Okay. So before we start the
sh we have to understand this is very
important. If an animal drops dead, a
cow drops dead or is shot in the head is
killed, killed by a car, then its body
emits a tuma. If you touch it, you
become tummy. If you shed an animal and
it's dead obviously after you shed it,
it does not emit a tuma. It doesn't have
tumas.
If it dies on its
own very interesting question this
animal which is destined to die you have
to burn it. You have to kill it with a
with a sword. What if you don't kill it
with a sword? What if you it could that
remove the tuma of the neo? You're
right. You can't eat it. That we
establish you can't eat it. But perhaps
it's good enough to take away
the does remove the
toe. Doesn't the says to kill it with a
sword. So what's the difference if you
kill it with a sword and its heart or
it's its neck? You killed it. If you
kill it, it's considered a dead animal
and it should have
tum it's it helps that there's no
tum. I don't know. I don't have an
answer to the
cascism. A lot of people are going to
love the
When you
have you have a woman who is doesn't do
she lives in do I have to burn her hair
right off her
head or what you have to burn hair off a
woman who does that makes no
sense. Why doesn't it make
sense? You should gather things and burn
them. There's two steps. Gather and
burn. But this has three steps. Cut to
here. Gather and
burn. We're talking about
[Music]
a Wow. So says that women used to wear
shhatals. Rashi explains you take
somebody else's hair and you add it to
your hair fills up the hair. Maybe
they're not talking about covering here
completely, but there's an idea of
pay of a wig that's from somebody else's
hair. Says, "How does this wig look
like?" Not how does it look like, but
what is it? What's going on here? If
this woman is wearing it, then it's like
she's wearing clothing. You don't ask a
woman to take the clothing and burn
them, whatever is on her is safe. So if
she's wearing a safe, you don't have to
burn
it. Then why would you have to burn it?
Says
The Yeah. Is that the word? I can't read
it. She's not wearing the on a head on a
peg
somewhere. Do we consider it like any
other belonging of a that's inside? And
you must burn
it. I live in a this is something that
she constantly takes on and off on and
off on and off. So therefore it's as if
it's on her even though it's on a
peg. So I don't know. So going back to
the question I asked before what hap who
has more person that's wearing fillin he
should go into first or a person that's
holding fillin's bed over here it seems
like says the bi that a person who's
wearing fillin it's like part of your
body just like you don't burn clothes
off a person's body you don't burn a oh
I forgot to show you this
picture you don't burn a shaitan
off their head so fill in on somebody's
head is part of their body. So he
doesn't have this person but fill him in
a bag does have
interesting. This is a with her and this
is a with
her or her hair.
There's a story that I said over and
after I said the story Do Fineberg said
I know this woman my she's best friends
with my wife and the story is a little
different and I forgot how he corrected
the story. I'm just going to say the way
maybe this is the corrected version I
don't know there's a woman who was
minding her own business in a bank and
there was a bank robbery and they pushed
the button and the cop showed up and the
guy panicked the bank robbery panicked
and he grabs this from
lady and
He put a gun to her head and he
threatened the cops. He's going to kill
her, etc.,
etc.
And he grabs her and he's like trying to
get her into the car and he grabs her by
her hair and he puts her in the car. So
she ducked. Basically her shaitle was
stayed in the guy's hand and she kind of
moved and he he shocked and that was
basically his last thought because as
soon as he like paused for a second, the
cop shot him
up. I guess his thought was how in the
world did her hair stay in my hand and
her head is somewhere else.
But this is
a says
the what if the city doesn't have a
square and there's nowhere to put all
the stuff that we're talking
about says this can no longer
be if there's no town
square here. Take a look at what the
town square looks
like.
Oops. Put everything in the center and
you burn
it. And what remains from
it? Boom.
Okay. So what's the source
of says that the center of the city
means that it was there before the whole
thing
started says no as long as you make one
afterwards as long when you burn it. You
made a you made a center. Great bay bay.
And that is sponsored by We have a new
sponsor. I heard turning of the
D. Oh, I see the new sponsor on the
bottom. Adar Global Onetop shop for all
your financial needs. Kovations LLC in
honor of our sons Kalmo 12 and Israel 9
for learning Sanhedrin with Rebelli. So
proud of you. in honor of Adar Global
Incations true role models of how to
support the DA and learning. I'm curious
to know which put this new
um
sponsorship on
top. I'm going to go a few words in so
that you can't skip around over here.
Oh, so now they said those two
words. Don't forget to bring your friend
to convince somebody to join the DA. It
will change your life. By you convincing
him, your life will
change. Why is when you get somebody to
do better with his life, you feel better
about yourself and Hashem feels better
about you and everything is great.
What if in the city of the there's a few
animals ready to go to
the there's no choice but you have to
let them die. You can't put them on a
misbehd. So what do you do?
So
is let them
die. But if it's designated for the
upkeep of the mdash, you redeem it with
money.
And if somebody designated some fruit
for the gave it to the it must
spoil and the 10% that you give to
yourself in years 1 2 4 5 they have to
be buried and
so when the Torah says you should burn
all the animals it means not the
firstborn animal that you give to the
and not
What's my beh? So, you take all your
animals, you put them in a pen and you
count one, two, three, until 10 come
out. Number 10, you take that
paintbrush, whatever you have in your
hand that's full of red dye, and you
slap it on the back of the sheep or the
goat or whatever animal it is. And oh,
here it is. Boom.
And that guy
is the word you take all the loot from
your but not money that belongs to the
mikdash and money that you redeemed your
mi all your fruit that you can't carry
up to the mikdash because it's too heavy
for you. You you trade it in for cash
that you don't burn.
if it belongs to the it should die.
So this is the question now for a bit
until well not so long just 10 lines or
so ask the why should it die I have a
better idea there's a concept called
giru you let an animal graze on its own
you don't take any care of it and you
hope that it trips one day breaks its
leg it becomes a bum and then you're
able to redeem it because up until that
point it belongs to the he can't redeem
it what's the big deal let that befall
am and then you take the money and
becomes money for the becomes. So we
have a number of reasons
here. Even the money that you get off of
selling this damaged animal is still
abomination. The money itself is gross.
Some some yeshivists won't take money
from certain individuals, certain
organizations or we won't say on YouTube
what it is, you
know, money, you know, comes from
different I'm not saying it's
abomination.
No. The reason
why you you can't the reason why you let
it die is because it's considered the
the the money the money that's owned by
the the
owner and we're talking about these are
that a person says I am dedicating this
animal to the and you took
responsibility. If something happens to
it, you are responsible to replace
it. And this goes according to which the
Gar is going to ask in a second. It
can't be because the continuation is so
this part is certainly
not says that that's considered the
money that's owned by the
owner. But that can't be because later
on it says from here on out is meaning
the first part is
[Music]
not. Okay. So noob shot
accordum there are two categories when
it comes to carbonas this is the heavy
duty kurbanus like a katas
asham and there's the lighter
ones asham the is part of you can only
eat inside the b you can't eat at
all but when it comes
two we have we
have. So these are lighter the lighter
category throughout all of
your says these
lighter that's considered yours. It's
yours. We got to get rid of
it. Why? because you're part
of but you're telling me that if it's
the severe the heavy
category you should redeem it don't let
it die if that's the case so now we have
a distinction if
it's if
it's
okay but that's not what it
says we say if it's kal
sorry and if it's for
the we jump to something completely
different taking care of the mid why
don't you focus on carbanas there's two
types of theum make a distinction within
themselves why you jump into another
category
of if it's for the upkeep of the you
should redeem
You should talk about themselves and
make a distinction
within when do you let it
die. But if it's the heavy category, you
should redeem it. Says, "No, you can't
do that." Why? Because it's not a it's
not a one rule fits all. If you can say
one
rule is you should redeem, great. That
includes everything. The problem is that
when it comes to you cannot redeem it.
Why? Oh, because here the famous five
and if you want to remember all five the
word first one
is and here the center one is what we're
talking
about. If a person let's say was mal
shabas and he designated an animal to be
but he didn't go to he's waiting to you
know for pes he's gonna go with his
whole family he'll bring the carbon then
what happened
was he was ner he
died
so is that his that he set aside and
designated it must die it's it's a it's
a very sad thing you take the katus you
put it in a room you don't feed it until
it
dies
So since he's part of any he's a dead
man a dead
man's must die. So you cannot give me
one rule fits all that if it's kachim
you should redeem it. No here's one
kachi kachim called which you don't
redeem it must die. So it's not a good
that's why I'm going to jump to another
category of and not talk
about says
It's said because it's an abomination.
So the reason
why it's a it's an abomination and that
includes
everything even the money that you
everything's abomination according
to I don't understand why has to go on
to another reason just it's a beautiful
reason it's abomination to bring
anything that's why it must die you
can't redeem it.
Nope. I disagree. He says, "You know why
it's
not? Because you you you switched it to
money. This animal is an abomination.
This animal came from. But if you take
this animal and you switch it out to
money, there's no connection anymore.
It's something
else. It's no longer an animal. It's
money.
So it's
different. You want to show me over
there.
Oh, let's see if there's anything else
interesting here. No.
Okay, one more piece and that's it for
today.
says the word in the should kill all
animals that does not include should not
kill the firstborn and the 10th one that
came out of the
gate. If these animals are
whole and therefore you can bring them
to the
mdash then you don't even own it then
it's owned by and you cannot of course
you can't kill it. Why do you need a
special? So you're talking about a bard
that has a little bit of
a then it's considered
completely the the belongings
of we're talking about that it has
[Music]
a what do you burn an animal that's
called an
These are different. First of all, their
name is different. Nobody calls this an
animal. Everybody calls them a miser
etc. They also have
different you can't sell in a
marketplace. You can't weigh it with a
lit. It's different.
Ma. Okay. So, we're talking
about it does have
a and it's not included
in and this argues
on. So he says a line that we have to
understand everything is brought on the
misbeh and everything is redeemed. What
does that
mean? Any animal that you could bring
onto the when it's without a m without a
blemish. However, if it does have a
blemish, it has a m you could redeem
it. So we say that says you don't burn
you don't kill this animal in the why
because it says the
word it's not the
animal but any type of animal that you
could bring onto the when it doesn't
have a blemish but if it has a
blemish you cannot redeem at
all what's a good exampleer
Then then I learned from the word in
other words according to only a which is
unblenmished you don't burn but a
blemished animal you would burn
according to raven
even a blemished animal you don't
burnai have a wonderful Hey,