Daf Yomi Pesachim Daf 84 by R’ Eli Stefansky

this might be the last week that ahenu benay england will be able to join as much of shabbos we try to delay it as much as possible for them but next week it's ready as far as i understand it's like 15 minutes every week we're not going to be able to delay it that much yeah toyota is important sponsored by moisture white rib harvard moisturize sponsored by two new yorkers that are not on right now anonymously by comment of the five towns in honor of my wife orlean my bachelorette and izzy connectoy on our ninth wedding anniversary is this supposed to be tonight i hope by ellie deichmann ninja mask handle miriam basswood mordechai david my wife's grandmother passed away yesterday not from kovid this is dove's brother remember dov the hazen from melbourne derebelli i'm writing to you from tel aviv iraqi dish we'll be happy to know there are also tire yidding who are enjoying your daf yamiche i was introduced to the ship by my brother dove in melbourne australia and thoroughly enjoy it i wish the specially thank you for your vote on the shirley which was credited as per attached you already popped it open it's my friend i gave gary a battle it was a mistake daryl is going to be drinking now wow that's right that's right it's other so uh if kai and fargo sent me the link to the youtube i don't know how to even say it maybe if you search on his name firecast so he said over the word he said it better than i said it over it's beautiful the way you set it over this is from david levy rebelli big fan of yushir i've been on board since early brachus mostly on the app i just went over a guy i said you know okay you guys started from bracha so you're four hundred dollars in the shout outs i went to a guy said you know since you didn't join us when i asked you to join you just missed a thousand ninety five daf because that was the three year anniversary one thousand if you were to join thousand daff you could join today so i don't have to come to you in three years from now and tell you that you missed another thousand dollars big fan of your share have been on board since early broca's mostly on the app would love to do zoom but it's too late early we live in woodmere davenets at that gouda in for i used to dive in there as a kid in that gouda across you from the white shield the six minute drive is perfect to listen to your pre-share announcements as long as this year is uploaded then i learned to share before the next minute begins perfect way to begin the day bar hashem we just married off our twin daughters who are living yerushalayim our sunni immersion plans and going to shiva and there's this troll soon and they want to join them and er to stroll can you recommend somebody to speak to besides benefice they can understand the prose cons of aliyah versus just going and living on a student visa i'm laughing because i didn't speak to never benefit i didn't do anything it was a two-week process from the time that we even thought about coming down the stroll to the time we moved was exactly 14 days grab the suitcases and ran if you start speaking after benefits it'll take you years square foot you do call tuv david i don't know i don't know i don't know anybody anybody know who to speak to we'll have to who donnie fine does real estate he's a zionist well he's not such a zionist but okay yeah danny fine but it's a good idea to start with donnie fine he does real estate there's a lot of guys in the that do real estate hillary abrams who else does real estate a bunch of guys all right rabboissa here we go today is that paid dalid uh ashila mashallah to think about before we get to it in the gemara is there a problem chewing on bones any sort of viscera could you think of any issue whatsoever people eat bones all the time no from the child from this from the chicken is there an issue we're going to see that according to schmulzovsky perhaps it's an issue huh we're going to see we're going to see soon not love this no not at all very very simple shiva of panovich but he's very so we're holding that pigment base like 12 lines from the bottom 10 lines from the bottom so what happened was we had in the mishnah that if you have neusar bones giden when do you burn it you burn it right after yantef because you can't burn on yontif so you burn it on the following day on shisha so now shisha also falls out on shabbos it doesn't push off shabbos so what do you do following just push off yanta why can you why can't you burn noise right all through the midst of burning it should overcome the issue of islam fire and yantev that's not latoya in case you don't want to look in the gemara you can look over here it's much more colorful so it says add a biker and then it says add biker a second time the same pasta now if you just look at the puzzle we're gonna use this for later as well velocity menu this is to leave the meat over into the morning and then what do you do with the noise have a nice time in menu at biker bay she sort of you burn it says the gemara but that biker is extra it could have just said if you left it at biker to tell you that here's an exception to the rule typically you have the tar is telling you no there's no essentialization here you're not going to push off yant of the burden you are going to wait that yantif doesn't get pushed off to burn it on my crow or last shabbos bishop we had this in the sect already that the torah tells us that there's only one exception to the rule what what do you burn on a shabbos an oil of shabbos the muslim that comes every shabbos gets burned on shabbos and that's it but not a weekday oil and certainly not a puzzle carbon that's what we're talking about something that's possible we're talking about noise if you can't even put an ila that you brought on friday it doesn't get pushed which by the way somebody was telling me that i said yesterday that uh i went back i didn't see it i didn't i remember pointing this i might have said if somebody heard that i might have said kachi kachin that is versus kachikalan i don't know maybe that's what happened i don't know somebody said i made a blooper went back minute 20 to 22. mamashima foolish i don't say okay i make bloopers all the time but that happens i don't like to be accused for bloopers and also i said if i if i make a blooper go to my wife you can't come directly to me it's not it's not right we said okay so we have the pasek the famous pasta we dealt with this pasta a number of times this is the pasta tells us that who [Music] for important things let's say for yantev for food but to make the pot you can't anjantiv so when you have to do a bris milo on shabbos you could push off shabbos for biz milo if the baby is born eight days earlier but if the baby is born nine days earlier rashi gives examples interesting examples if aguer or you were forced to whatever the reason is you didn't do the bris milo so you don't push off shots now why would i think that you push off shabbos so there's a cava climber it goes like this very simple if you want to start this way you could start from the end mila pushes off to rash that means if there's a taras on the brismilla you cut off the taras you now gotta cut off taras abrasmilo pushes off to ass tiras pushes off avoid that in other words if there's no question in the world and the one kind available has saras so it pushes off in other words you don't do that the tarasa is stronger than avada but avoida pushes off shabbos we know you do the perform that void in the basement dash on shabbos so mila which is stronger than saras which suras is stronger than avaya now now now now if i did stronger should certainly push off shabbos when it's shillai bismano bismana of course it pushes off but i'm saying this should be even on the 9th 10th day mila should push off shabbos commercial so it adds another essay what was your question you have an assay versus allah guess what it's actually saying against the na the mitzvah to burn the noise is not going to be stronger than the mitzvah and the and the less acid that saying of not doing for on says the mishna [Music] gado so what are we talking about here we're talking about a current pesach what is considered part of the the animal part of the sheep the goat that we can consider it as a piece as a cause is that you could go ahead and be part of the carbon right to be a manui i have 10 pieces of meat available thank you zai sim i have 10 people 11 the guy comes along he wants to be part of my carbon could i give him a bunch of sinews can i give him stuff whatever it is says the mishnah here's the rule call hane if it's edible in a big axe so all that stuff that's edible and an axe this there's a bunch of sinews a bunch of different stuff that you could eat then you could eat it it could be part of the goat viroshe kino fayem and goats in the time of the gemara had wings naps virus and are we gonna see the cartilage of the the the shoulder blades also some sort of cartilage says the gemara rabba rami tanaan this so this is a bryce who said in the mishnah sorry quran it seems like if it's not edible in the character in a big ox it's not part of the carbon they're not edible these things are not edible the cartilage of the of the ox is not edible the the shoulder blade not editable so wamp shot is actually so she the number one is that has to be one for one if you could eat it on the ox you could eat it on the goat it could be part of the carbon if not not and via and then comes shita number two and says not true rash shaking of five vasrusim are different if i could boil it up and soften it up and make it edible yeah so now i can just take it roast the d and it's considered edible umainen and what are we talking about russia okay so according to robin no macholik is the first sheet of this big kiddish take a take a a an ox you could sous-vide it for three days if you're able to get it to like a really soft edible thing then even if you don't do that suvi on um on a goat it's still kosher oh my gosh somebody said what's a souvenir you know the souvenirs right it's a cooking it's like uh it's that it's this heating device that keeps the temperature of the water at the same exact temperature so you could he knows what it is the chef knows what it is anytime you use it we used it on uh we had to see them that was like two years ago by nom and we bought these steaks from spain they're not as good as american steaks but we sous-vide it it was mom and butter butter you understand it's butter i haven't used it since but we have we have the souvenir at home anybody wants to borrow it you can try it out oh mine and the really soft sinews are just like meat so we have over here let's see if we have it first of all we have pictures we have a lot of pictures today excuses you want to see cartilage here we all recognize this from a chicken this white thing is skuses now um rashi says on the mishna that also applies to to the ribs that the sauces on the ribs so there's a there's an arrow right over here you can see this is all from colorado this white part over here here are the ribs they go this way and this white that's what's the opposite of perpendicular uh no parallel maybe it is perpendicular this is perpendicular okay fine perpendicular perpendicular to the ribs this white stuff okay then what do we have we have do we get the new it yet rashi says i think uh yeah rashes says so here's the heisen the cartilage in the in the ear of the goat there's a goat right over here oh now we have we're talking about gideon arakin the soft soft sinews here's a nice soft sinew this is this is part of the carbon peso so what is it in a month and a half from now a month and a half from now we're going to need this month's a month and a half no purim is in 15 days in a month after purim so it's one half 45 days this stuff i hope you don't get stuck with it but if you're in a group and they're they're really short of meat this works itmar inches says rashi we're talking about the neck the next sinews here they are these already pulled from the neck here's the neck they run along the neck this way and you yank them out but if the animal was older would be tough meat right now today is a very young goat he's just born eight days ago he's barely ready to use as a car in pesach now it's soft what's the halacha if you have something that's soft today but gonna harden up if he was alive if he was lucky enough to live that long it would harden up what do you do says the gemara it's no review they're edible today let's go with it you go by today today it's soft it is soft we're going to see at the end of the surgery takes it back he retracts this this this much like this really at the end of the day i go what's going to happen at the end of the day the only thing that's edible in a goat is what you have to take its counterpart in the ox and say okay is it edible or not everything is included but why is the mission to grab the the shoulder blades and other things and not these these sinews honey maitama what's the point what's the what's the savara behind it because i could boil it and soften it up so the bottom line is you have to you have to look at that what does it tell me it's not oh only these sinews these things that i could put in a pot boil it for a while and soften them up so anything that you can put in a pan and boil it up is kosher it's part of the carbon pesos all my larry behind me there will be oven it says rub your metabolism i need to ask you about a vote question for me is it true that eventually they're going to become hard today they are okay rubion says they're okay so it seems like your everything is going based on what we have right now as the gemara of aboriginal irish locations [Music] what about the the hide of a young calf right now mao shi taming can do we consider it food so that becomes tommy tomason right food can become tummy non-food object doesn't become tummy what is this soft skin on the head of a calf is it food or nafu today it's edible yeah but wait three months it becomes harder like a rack so what do you do is it makable [Music] what happens eventually eventually it's going to harden up so today it's also considered hard it's not food whoever asks you this question doesn't care about his flower about what he grinds in other words he stam talks he moves his mouth he's grinding stam he's asking questions that are not saying and he says it says in the mishnah that we treat the skin as an edible product and it's a stam mishna it's anonymous anonymous mishna means like that so says great but at the end of the day rebecca takes it back realized that the mishna is a is a das that's what he tells him she got him she says okay that mishna is if it's a one person cheetah so we don't pass it like that one against everybody else so you already took it back so in other words reverend holds attacking he says don't don't cheapen me why are you bothering me i already said that i take it back i regret it i retract and therefore i hold that it goes by what eventually is going to happen to the skin eventually the skin is going to become tough so today it's not food so so it's not food according to beautiful don't ask me cash here question this this sinew that's in a baby goat that's really soft today but had he lived another few months has become tough can it be part of the carbon pace of the answer is no it can't be part of the carbon basis here you have these these sinews that run across the neck that are soft and a baby goat but very tough in an older goat do not use this rabbis i'm warning you in a month and a half from do not use this in your current peso it is no good because eventually it's going to become tough what very interesting they see from this gemara nest rig how an asterisk what if i buy an s3 that's this year but during sukis inevitably it's going to become smaller that's what happens the next week they shrink slowly it's going to become slightly less than the shield is that okay or not you want to prove from here that it goes by the scythe at the end of the day it's going to be really small so today i have to consider it small and i can't use it as yesterday this is actually the ramos says that if your becomes dry over yantif you have you buy salad that's really nice you know like they start becoming these are falling into your soup and stuff rama says that's possible on the first day some say don't bring a writer from so bottom line is the terrorism says you cannot use such an asterisk but the hazard is a very interesting cop he says the whole point of a shear in the estring is not because there's a real shear it's just to tell us that this s-rig is mature so how do i know it's for sure it has a certain shear so i saw that it's mature so now that it's shrunk to a lesser shear it doesn't take away from its maturity mma i could use it says all right what's the menu one you're saying during the mitzvah during the midst is going to come i know but today today today is one day day one i have a perfect essay who cares that in three days from now during young tim i'm asking you it's during another but who cares but right now i was behind the mitzvah the rest of the day it's by the way there are bona whatever it is who cares i do care because right now i have to be miscash of according to these the sheets if i want to but you see how they schlep what today it's perfect today is perfect but tomorrow is not going to be good do i have to worry about tomorrow you see how they have these these from different sugars whatever okay very good [Music] if the carbon pasta was tar so he broke an atom that we had the pasuk this is the rice the break a bone and a carbon face up i raised the liquor bomb so you get some alcohol it says don't you do it malcus like any other love ava if you leave over meat from a perfectly good carbon pesach even though the tire says don't leave over there's a cereal manner we saw already did i put it back already hey vinnie not good okay that's right everybody tommy ain't no you like this everyone if you break a bone from a tummy carbon you don't get our body that we have we brought down this this mishna the other day what is the swara behind if we could go into kilo the the reasoning in the torah so the says that you're sitting there at the pace of the seder you shouldn't act like a peasant how does a king act a king doesn't sit there and break bones and start chewing bones it's not it's not proper for ben mellor you're ben miller act like a ben miller member says richard wilsowski that would apply to every shabbos then also you shouldn't sit there at the shop if they were going like this you're a bad male you're a yeshiva act like a ben miller just like the ram says that a ben mello talks a certain way he doesn't scream he walks a certain way this he doesn't chew a bone it's not that it's us or it's not like oh yeah you have malcus but act like a act like a act like a frumid for me it doesn't doesn't show it's interesting thing to think about if you're looking at the at the reasoning if you're doing tamiya missus goes into the thing so based on that he says we should also be careful all right i understand if somebody takes good a good carbon oh by the way i have to go back it's just a second because the rebecca nano says here there's an interesting lecture i want to point down to rebecca it's uh it's matsushavas we got a we have an extra second there when he says you're asking me a question on behalf you don't care about the flower so i see this lush in here he says if you look in rabbinical on the side everybody has it in there on the on the death of the king he says this guy's food everything all the pizza eats all the all the uh steaks he's eating is worthless interesting lotion in other words if you are a person that's avid hashem you learn torah so then whatever you eat goes into a body of personal person but you you say such i'm not talking to him but the real kind says person that doesn't learn karate then then the food that he eats the resources on in this world are not meant for him they're wasted wasted resources that's what he says interesting lotion okay anyway bish lima what's going on here look it says an apostle very simple what's life a second later it says this is giving you a positive commandment this is don't do it don't leave over and then all of a sudden says but no it's your menu what do you do with it you burn it it says this is called the lava nitric laser i have a loya and then i have a solution the turret tells me what to do just like stealing you steal do you get marcus for stealing no this is the solution give it back tyler tells you anytime the third tells you what you should do then there's no malcus why so it actually gives two reasons either the tires telling you specifically what to do and it's telling you melee you don't get the malkes fine or she says it's not similar to where we learn all of malcolm is from the love of hasima the love of muzzling the the animal okay fine i'll go upon him basically so right the the shadow rash the torii is telling you don't give this guy malcus give him a way out tell him what to do this is the way out i know you said obesity serve that's ruby hoodoo that's not the reason the heavenly lamb shamed by myself you don't give a person malchus when he didn't commit a crime what did he do he didn't eat the steak but he didn't do something to the steak he just refrained from eating it refraining from eating is not a cause to give a guy malcus obviously review the holds it is a reason when a person review the holds left shame by myself you do get malcus so he has to come on to another reason why you don't get marcus all right love shame by myself ain't like you know love hello schweiver about tommy minalon how do i know that if i break a bone from a tummy carbon paste i i don't get malcus tomacro that's so we must remember this very important we're doing something that's a record in chats perhaps i don't know again i might be making recording shots the edsel is boy what the boy tells me this is when it's kosher when the animals puzzle i'm not over this the animal's tummy not over this the kosher of a little apostle [Music] it's the same possible beforehand says tell me eat it something very similar but a little different he says it's not that it it's kosher impossible it's not real if i could eat it then i'm over on the average you know how to break the bone if i can't eat it not ask the gemara my binayo so what is the difference between the two so typically when a gemara asks such a question what is the difference the market is an uh something that there's a difference sometimes the guard gives two differences you know what kumar is going to do today eight differences it's very rare eight and each one is because the manda oma doesn't hold of the one before very simple gemara but it's eight should i show you real quickly what it looks like i don't know if this will help it's not going to help oh i can't even see gary are you still there do me a favor zoom in for a second because it's green and blue and it's i don't know if you i don't can see the question is what is atom where does it reply where's the isr we have one mandarin says kosher that the animal has to be kosher in order to be over and enslaved the other man says rebbe says rowey what we're gonna see is that rebbe is always always mako besides one according to one so seven out of the eight rebbe is the one that says there's no answer so real quickly just to run them down like stop so you know what we're heading to because it's it looks like in a goddess of the death it's one of these diamond looks but it's it's these eight reasons reverend review or not if there was a minute that it became that was kosher we went through a lot of these spheres before abaya says this nafcamino is in a case on the 14th but now the the easy thing is that rebbe is always saying that there's no problem of examination brew boy no problem so erviantev you break it you're not over according to rebbe rubble says if part of the limb goes out of your shalayim what's rabbi going to say not a problem raphael just says no it's not cooked well so according to rebbe if the animal is not cooked well you're not over i'm breaking the bone renault we're talking about the tail of the sheep according to rabbi you're not over i'm breaking the tail if you break a tag on that however ravashi says there's not a khazais on it and according to ravi it doesn't have a kazayas you know and ravina says there's not a cause is right there where you're breaking it but it's because it's on the next part lower down on the bone let's see inside we need a stickled drink for this says the gemara maybe two lines from the bottom of pedal um where the carbon pesa cloud throw his tummy again clyde stroll the river of claudius rose tommy what happens when clyde throws tommy you bring the carbon face look anyways lemando alma kosher now returning to daff he dialed on the base high apostle wow i mean we went through the suggest of tomato to mahutra but the gemara is telling us that if you hold the klysol's tama and you bring the carbon anyways at the end of the day this is a puzzle carbon okay it's tu matruyo i pushed it off i tell you to bring it anyways but you should know the carbon is possible do you eat it yes you eat it so if you eat it what's rebbe going to hold it's all about eating rabby says has to be right to eat the tanaka says it has to be kosher apostle so you have an animal it's possible if it's possible there's no issue to break a bone and rebbe says but it's edible it's possible it's edible so there is a issue to break a bone this is the one case out of the eight that rebbe is more machmer and the gemara says therefore i don't like it because reby is the maker over here that can't beep shot we just turned to pedal on the base sponsored by keshironamshi.org for the struggling kids in pain of claissero and for the future name of oh khalil israel especially from our mdy family please consider joining md white tehillan group at thehillin.8mindaf.com says gamora lomano royal akilo according to review it's edible interesting right it's too mature did you guys think about that the tomato the animal is apostle you think akashbab said bring the carbon so it's a kosher carb no it's possible bring it anyways and eat it anyway that's not true everybody even rebbe is going to agree that there's no this is the break of bone why because it's possible the rebbe like in rebbe sheeta is more mako than the tanaka he's going to say if the tanaka says it's breaking a bone he's going to say you know if i'm breaking your bone by apostle and this guy is apostle so we're in the second shot raviosa says the child is like this you did all the avoidance you did everything is great so there was a moment in time that you were able to eat this carbon peso how do you take a taken a bite out of it right after this rico yeah and then the carbon peso became tummy afterwards that's the napkin and omar kosher according to the tonic comet this is a kosher carbon if it's kosher kosher equals the issue to break a bone in it but according to rabby there's no way to break the bone because right now you can't eat it it's all about eating not about being kosher almo each one is going to say well the guy before me is wrong that's why there's eight that's not true everybody has to agree that this is not edible and it's not edible so it's kosher mai tai mashed meal puzzle at the end right now this this carbon is possible if this carbon is possible right now tanaka has to agree no ways to break the ball that's really says move by joey mickey ben ayo could you break the bounces abaya on the 14th le mando my kosher hakoshi this carbon pays that i checked it at 2 30 in the afternoon every peso is it a kosher carbon basically yes could i eat it no you have to wait until the saturday night so if i break the bone never face according to rebbe i'm i'm not over anything may sway red the oimer hits rabbit himself nine if you want to participate in the current visa you can use the brain of the animal name says why could you use the brain this is not bone marrow ovary it's a play on words it's the same word means marrow but it means brain we're talking about the brain of the animal not the marrow of the animal because i could get to the brain of the animal without breaking any bones i'll take a syringe whatever i'll schlep it out somehow with a stick i'll go through his nose as rashi without breaking anything i'll i'll extract the brain however the thigh bone there's a lot of meat in there so i could get a bunch of people to join my group but the only way to get to it unfortunately is breaking it you know how to break it first i could rather just describes how through the nose i could take the brain out without breaking it these okay that's very similar dummy but if you're telling me that breaking the bone irif pesach is okay coolest i mean today so you shuffle the carbon peso it's air pace of now i have zero issue to break a bone so what's the problem break the thigh bone reach extract the marrow from it and now i have more people i can join my carbon face off according to you also you should take a cold put it on top of the bone so what the saying here is you know how to break a bone you know i make a break you know how to make a hole so i take a little coal put it on top of the bone i'll create a hole in bone and i'll extract the marrow vanilla and then i could have more people in my group it's fine if you sorry about summers you allowed to make a hole in the bone is another you allowed there's no cutting sine is not cutting a bone the isr is cutting bones breaking bones but you're allowed to call it sinews the problem is if you're going to start making holes with coals you know what might happen or break the bone you're not going to make a perfect hole or make a crack in the bone that's awesome rub oh my mushroom has to touch him because at that day your coal might burn some of the bone marrow and that's also to come absolutely be a diet to let it to let it don't do anything to it that it becomes nice and then have to burn it that's one thing but to go ahead and put a coal on it and burn the bone marrow that's massively a dime that's doing it with your hand and that's us the fire was going to eat up and might have to do that he's going to eat off the marrow the same spot applies you asked me if you are right that you could break a bone why don't you break a boner of young but i'm concerned that if you do it before yantif you might do it after yante palmar he argues of the value called at the end of the day if you do what you're saying says abayo you you're breaking bones of yantiff yes everybody agrees it's not true or even my time lord today right now on the 14th you're right you can't eat it but if you wait a few hours it becomes a carbon that you you could eat so we may let's also do it right now hello so what's the shiloh baby the whole map like this is where are we holding here we're holding the chart right over there one two three four only four wow okay we got the purple one if you're asking why the x is yellow and the checks are blue that's because i try to do the x's in red that's what i have but it didn't work very well on this red guy so i change it up now i try to change the cancer the blue didn't work on blue now it works no no we start 10 minutes later the guys from manchester and london and all those guys could join us gary we this is the last maybe next week go back so that you could uh gary's very busy monster shabbos hello behave something the limb went out a little bit rabbi said i just want to tell you real quickly uh a story about protest it's the slightest of brothers but i saw it as yo what happened was i had i wanted to bring i went to the store i told you the story on friday i came and i said where's the bone i was very disappointed i couldn't find the bone i wanted to do show and tell with the bone here's a bone now why was i disappointed because i spent time on it i went to the butcher shop and there it is and i did and i made myself crazy to remember to bring the bone so what happened was sorry to tell you a story of his girlfriend reuben shade as i'm going to share reuben chad who edits the eight minute video he tells me do me a favor before you go to share come to my house give me the video that you recorded the night before i want to edit it instead of coming to share i want to edit it so i stopped in his of his house he lives two floors below me stopped there and i josh what's going on you don't like the miso it's during the month he takes breaks this is the first time since we started share three years ago a guy actually snored out loud and cheer this is this boring story anyway listen to this mice and josh listen this murray dick and myself the tire part you were wide awake right away it's not even such a great mindset i'm just saying it's in the mind in the minute part you could see a coachboard's hand so i go to this house i give him the video i come to share i don't have my bone what happened was i left the bone by his front door he said i came outside i found the bone in a bag and we're like would leave me a bloody boat in a bag so on the way back from shearer i climb up the stairs go to his house i grab the bone i go to my house now this is very important because i took the bone i didn't notice anything everything is good what i go put on my filling come down the stairs as i come down and say what's going on here there's blood everywhere ah the bone was leaking but i didn't realize that until i came back down there's a whole puddle of blood in front of uh of ruben's house so what i want to tell you and then i by the way when i gave him the video i said reuven i don't think you should do the video now you should come to share do the video don't worry about it do it later so you came to share my so i have it like this the first time ever that he asked me to stop by his house before shear and it didn't even do anything for him because at the end he came to shear and because i left the bone there i didn't my gemara is still i love my gemara i'm very very immaculate on my gemara i don't even have a single ear on the table had i brought the bone here i wouldn't have noticed just like i didn't notice when i came all the way home i was taking the go out of there and i had blood everywhere so myself he saved me but today we do have a bone i got to show you this is bone from chunked and this oyver is coming apart already it's not my chong somebody gave me a bone from this chunk if you look closely i don't want to open it but if you look closely this is the part that we're talking about this is the part that you could throw out and this marrow part that's what we're talking about this is edible he said it gets hard once it cools off okay here it is we're going to use it soon all right so you're right it came out a little bit here's the wall of your slime a little bit out a little bit in half the hand is outside of your july half the hand is inside your slime according to rashi madam kosher hakashiru we're looking at the part that's inside yerushalayim the hand doesn't say you shall aim is kosher meat mma live it's kosher what i cannot break the bone because if i break the bone it's going to break part that's kosher but according to my oma that says that it has to be edible rebbe it's not edible the part that's not out so this is the obvious question you're gonna go by the part that's outside and call it not edible if it's not edible it's not kosher you're gonna go according to the part that's inside so it's edible and it's kosher which one is it okay it doesn't really answer so a limb that goes out of your shalayim and you break it so you're not over on breaking a bone in other words small binocular goes according to rebbe who rebbe says that since it's not roy lahilla there's no problem of breaking it rashes almost i don't like your shot because everybody agrees that oh i forgot to show you i spoke about the yellow and the blue but i forgot to tell you what it does if you're going to be using this chart it's telling you that breaking the bone is not a problem or is a problem he rev papa for instance just says everybody agrees that what you just did here is okay it's not breaking your bone check everybody agrees that what you did over here is a problem that's why i put checks and and and x's so they're saying the guy in front of them the the the moyer in front of them is a problem it's not a problem sometimes it's a problem something that's not according to the check okay i just threw that in i said oh my god means it's not a problem you're not over it's a check you're not even breaking a bone the high aver apostolo this ever that came out is considered possible if it's not cooked that's the naf um right now since it is not cooked well it's not edible not edible i break its bone i'm not over reducing [Music] so what if it's not cooked throw it back into the grill it'll be cooked i'm going here in red i'm going with the tail he says the tail the number kosher hakoshi the animals hundreds and kosher the mother hilo a tail is not regular gila why can't they eat the tail it goes in them everybody agrees it goes into this bath that's not considered edible elijah the macholicus is on a very that doesn't have a causalis i need edible it's not edible i don't have a kazaas it's not edible not edible i could break the bone i'm not over rubbing omar and finally finally eight shot them later [Applause] by the way marrow's considered meat so it doesn't matter inside outside that we'll see here i don't know here's a picture i stole it from a different place but the bottom line is here the meat is over here the bone is over here and i break it over here am i over or not that's the shia la there is meat somewhere else a lot of meat look there's more than kazaas but it's somewhere else not where i'm breaking it the mandama kosher kosher who if it's kosher i know if i'm breaking the bone loma marilla but according to rebbe that it has to be something that that i'm eating edible vinaigrette butter it has to have the meat right where am i breaking it and i and over here it's not well let go says the gemara tanya ka arba minayo i have a bryce that says exactly like four out of the eight very very positive rebbe oymer this is rebbe bringing that passage again of atom boy right the same loy boy it says [Music] on kosher not puzzle what does it mean so he goes into the scribe let's see if you could cop which of which of one's which of the eight four out of the eight maybe even five out of eight right over here raviolis so it's in the braiser review it has to do with having a moment that you were able to eat it um [Music] who's that you need a shear that's right over here kazais now it could be both it could be ravino then it says kazais over here but not over there or because it's could be both of them so now really we have three that's that's a bonus we have five not four hey man who says rebbe says that if you could put it on the mizbeh it's not right for you it's right for them there's no breaking of bone now is right over here here you have a little bit of meat on this side but not on this side rib yakinoma so what is this shyla basically this is the same shiloh that we had before between ravin and ravashi do you need the kazayas to be in one place not in one place that's basically the mimicking this this is this this is the machines that we had already loved it's considered it doesn't matter even though there's no no meat where you're breaking it's still considered breaking a bone remember that's now what does it mean it does if it doesn't have meat it does have meat might love his eyes buster eliminated because i suppose a cloud it can't mean that there's zero meat on it right because if there's zero meat on a bone what are you allowed to do with the bone that has zero meat you throw in the garbage there's no problem with breaking it allah why not whether the meat is on the outside whether the meat is on the inside of the bone the marrow that's it i'm not allowed to break the bone even if there's zero meat on the outside but the meat is the marrow on the inside then you're also now a break so the bone that you're allowed to break there's a bone that doesn't have any matter on the inside and nothing no meat on the outside that's a bone that i'm allowed to break have a good divorce we'll see you tomorrow in 10 hours no share of malaysia shabbos why i have no idea because nakamura salsa is not here i love the bears what do you mean oh sir hold on hold on are you talking about during the week no it's also to eat the bone to let it break but the the eat it from it that's what you're saying no no no there's a week you lotto yeah yeah the smaller bones maybe even ribs i don't know i don't know those are some spokes [Music] sounds so familiar oh i know him now i know i know i know yeah yeah yeah that's right really i met him where did he say i just met him not just but yeah oh i think he was on he was on a mentor's mission or something he's a gevaltica guy he's like a very that's maybe that's where i knew him from okay now it's all coming together square to you you do it's supposedly it's very good supposedly it adds a lot of flavor yeah how are you doing ah you ready you you have uh you have uh shots what do you have you had corona got the certificates beautiful so you're gonna come you're gonna come every day you're gonna try to get my son to work to school whenever you can whenever you can