Preparing video...
0:00 / 0:00

Daf Yomi Menachos Daf 88 by R’ Eli Stefansky

45 views
Mercaz Daf Yomi by R' Eli Stefansky avatar
Mercaz Daf Yomi by R' Eli Stefansky

Transcript

Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.

hey chess are you enjoying PFS pack Shimon today we're gonna start from the Camaro design with bass basically we're gonna repeat the Mishnah but the amar says is a big difference in how you read the Mishnah do you read the mission of from the smallest measuring cup up or these star from the largest measuring cup and go down and the gamers can explain the difference Bernard bonnel Sheva me this shelah flava me touch through seven measuring devices for liquids in Ibiza meters starting from the smallest one reveals look that's the famous reveals that we're familiar with it's a quarter of a look the haughty look and a half a load the loin and a one full load we release a hint a hen we said is 12 look reveals a hint a quarter of that Alicia saying the hottie in him did baby who those who view the says we start from the smallest measurement and we work our way up may I marry it starts Hin so in the Mishnah it started from hint the hat seein like remain remain mere hit the hat see him whose dishes are here in Reverse a hint and then the measurements of the log below catalogue of a slow fine no big traditionally the gamers can explain everything is gonna explain why be shimmy Romero hire some him so this again and we hadn't it says we don't need a hit became a yo-yo in Misha Misha there was no measurement needed for the hidden it was only one time by Chanukah Sameach gone as mia vita table so what do I bring instead of the hint a llama desertion like a toy shop there was another measuring device that was a log and a half boy are you more than happy to go and go that was the right measurement for the middle of the condado logo maps of a biker with a mess of Inara by him was the exact measurement which was needed for the well every morning and afternoon Oh Malloy haughty logos - um why do you need a special measuring device let him use the half a book three times Wester the shower vacati look Oh Marla hey my falooda break I'm Patsy Lloyd but legally yeah so what do you need a half a book and a full of rubies Isis um if you don't mind measuring a lot so use the Revere's the little better that we have and just from there keep on filling up if you have to do 20 times 20 times did obviously we need larger devices to measure larger measurements hello Zack Lowry by Mick dodge it was a rule cliche miss Amish me the zoo animal Shama Schmidt out Harris so if there was a particular measurement we had Ackley for that measurement now you could use that cleave for different things that have the same measurement but every measurement if there was three different men office they had a look so we used one click called a look for those three manavas if there's another minica that had a look and a half so we had another nuclei looking awfully so every measurement had its own clean maybe less other guy mention not so he's how you buy him again something that was on the Mishnah that it was one device called a hidden and in that measuring cup there were lines in it Schomberg pointed out the lines were inside the clean not on the outside cause it wasn't see-through wasn't glass so you you look inside and you saw okay up to this line is a Revere's up to this line is a haughty look and just kept on going up like the picture in Rashi now the picture of Rashi is very difficult because between the reveals her log in the hats you log it's like very it's it's almost a nothing if you're talking about a giant jug the size of a gallon and the reveals is on the bad and bad is one line and right above that there's another line and how you gonna measure with you right now according to tysonis that works out beautifully twice's says that's not one colleague called the hin that had four lines rather there was one click old him and that was only for hints so there was a reveal is she she's a in cannot see a hint and a Hindus for those four measurements in that hand let's say three lines and the full hint you have a full in gallon whatever it is almost a gallon and then you have on the bottom you have a reveals a hint then you have Ashley she's saying you have oxy or and a cotton you have three lines in addition to that one Klee says typhus you had three other calum for a look you have the reverse Klee something this size and then you had the the solution of the hot seat lug and alone so total of four Calum yet three Luke Calum and one Hinckley that had that had they given me a look as if I didn't read it well okay no bubas nice tonight electronic noises of a pilot that's not out there learning it it says before somewhere I don't know where I saw it Sheva medidas look at Tyson show me details on a vessel mandala I buy me - Allah for you face versus Arba me - Allah there's four kingdom of Lanna and and one was a hin and three war for the law that's how I understood it how do you understand our women she laughs [Music] no no exertion tyson's that's a good thing Raschi held its 1-click hold him anti-system hooligan he says there's at least an additional include according to him as to how many K I'm going to you according to me this for what about hints what about the right that you don't need like but you need a review saying Patsy and you're saying but it will see a book look and hit all-in-one clean the six lines according to Rashi one reveal Oh Patsy look full log and then you have the the hint the four measurements of in welcome Jeff Gordon the able to avoid it's interesting if you look at this picture of you look at look at this look at this picture in raschi it seems like there was a measurements for him also even though the clues are him it was above the him I don't know how that works with what we're gonna learn how it was no there's only six lines here what's missing in Clapton River him like Hudson River I think we're missing Ashley she's yeah this is a hint is missing from the from my picture at least I don't know you have seven line okay so I'm just missing it was a mistake of my guy okay you have says the Gemara up we need a picture in that everybody sign Oh so should we get stuff he didn't go to sleep yet okay so now that you Mars asking the question that everybody had my eco baby mailer Buda what is the difference yeah this to really Wow okay so oh come on I was in Mitchell by Morales okay thanks SEZ SEZ SEZ thing tomorrow mieka been remember you the who cares how you how you read it you could start from the largest measurement working way down you start from lowes much your way up but the measurements are identical so what's the difference how you write it says the Gemara is a big difference Amira be open on Beirut say me do you mean I would see me do is meaning similar to what we learned yesterday like we had yesterday the Russian called goddess beauty mythos is the the article translated over broom I think the it goes over the top of the rim the heap okay heap would be like your salads and ovary would be for various indices we're talking about liquids now now seems like in raschi depends which Rashi read but I think they both say the same thing that very simple if you go from a very large Klee that has a over brim into a small clay it's gonna fall on the floor the the extra the top you can't get a very a big pale that's over and trying to get into a cup it's gonna spill all over the place right that makes sense if you go both of them the top and the bottom both say but the one on top says a little bit better he says it my hair you have to do it quickly and and the one at the bottom you could you could read a little differently I poop on him the point is if you have a lot if you have an over bream on a small little cup and you try to pour it into a large pail you can get it all inside in one shot it's not a problem to go spill it quickly and get it all into the pail so so then the shot would be like this if you start from the bottom from the smallest year you starting from the top so then that includes the over brim is well and the over brim is cottage because who's Berkeley called my shrub and would start from over here and let's work at your way up so when maila everything is included but if you're starting from the largest CLE you cannot get the over brim into the smaller CLE therefore the over brim is not included in this year and if you start from the smaller CLE then you please actually bigger because once you're adding all these over brims let's say to get you start from the Revere's but to get to a half hour vyas you need to two cups each Cup has the over brim so now you're dealing with two over brooms so you're half a Revere's is actually more than a half a Revere's it's two over brooms more than a review than a ver it is versus if you go the other way if you start from the top and it's exactly reverse with no louver brim so it's a different shear a slightly different shear in the cup right yesterday right that was this way with my my coffee cup one bigger one right but in liquids is different because also that we were saying how we designed the cup the first time yeah when you need a larger cleat let's see inside the mando Mary Matalin mallow of cassava beauty I mean it's nice catch you release your their coalition wasn't this mr. Kornbluth it says over here I'm just following up on what you're saying coach Bart who gave my shrub a new or a vyas and said figure it out yourself from that point now he had to make it clear that contained the reveals with the over brim you understand is different than what we said yesterday with the solids that it's used you have a clean that's the smallest Lea that has the over brim fine over broom I'm asking to you that over broom is a smaller clean but if you creating your your uh your uh Klee Smith I don't know what it's called you you make Calum and you start from all you have or cuz one gave you is this little Klee and said go figure out a hint from this so the way you figure out a hand is with the over brim so then you're CLE that you end up with is a larger Klee because you're filling up these Revere's into another clay and you're measuring it with the over brim and you have to add a little bit understand like if you take my half a coffee cup that I had yesterday and you do a heap and then you take that new poured into another plane say okay now that is your hats Revere's so then would have to raise you would have to raise the cup and then you have to do two times to get the Hat see so it's two burps and then that would have to be you know then you get to the next year the full look is four of those four over brooms so it's a largely clean no no buts moisture I've been to dinner one time that's it finished that was the clean we knew what the key was but when he created the clean base it off of that if you would have to use a few times there's a separate key you can take one key do once and no no no because he created a clique called Patsy a half of oh how did he create the clique Caldecott see logs with to reveal slugs but once he had the Hat see look now I'm only gonna use the half a look it was a one-time creation he's not using it three and he didn't use it three times to get to a full load we gotta use it three times four times and to get to handy how to use it twelve times twelve times the log by Lomond alma mater the matter kesava bharati me this way nice catch you if you work your way up from the largest CLE from the Hin which is 12 look downwards then it does not include the be routine me does not include the over brim because it's impossible without spilling so that occurs bajo didn't mean the overgrowth within your layer of manila moisture vomit leisure baja the kunafa Gilbertson so I was one who gave him the him he said start with the hand here's the the largest CLE working break it down until you get to reveal some look but it did not include the be roots him i buy all my data coolly all my booty on me this EULA Mae - catcher because I'm a melodious catcher that's not that's not the point whether we came cause you're not the haha the Malayan camilla gate right everybody knows the position yeah Emily right it it has to be mother what does Molly mean soilless Molly it has to be full so the question is is does the word full mean a minimum like up to here or or at but it could be more or it means exactly to that level not more not less well double n commando mamela mallalieu Matt Apuzzo Varma laying low has officially a sir it has to be exactly mondo Omar Mamata la mala Malay Emsley hazard of a you sir Malaya Marina Bay you can go even higher so depends how you read it how you learn it it's interesting it seems like from Rashi especially in the urban of garam he says the word cats I think the word of you might be that also as well rash is learning it's a practical thing that when you pour from a small clay into a bigger place and now from a middle of the matter you can go from a big liter small plea would be exact but if you go from a small Clete the big thing you do fast from a bit Cletus mocha you have to go really slow so you don't spill so if you go really slow you don't have foam but if you go from a small clue typically you go fast and it it foams up and that extra you have to count for that extra foam that's that's one shot and raschi here twice's says that it's not a practical thing it's a simin it's like the idea behind it not literally that's gonna foam up but when the tire says you go from small to big that means you can add you could you could go bit you could go more the tire is telling you but when you go from big to small that are showing you keep to within your limits don't go don't go larger go exact that's how they just learn as if you want to see it touch dimmer maskel Amanda Omar voyage the ferris Raimondo mamela Matt Elam a live is simin commotion ahoy little mice if Kathy ah hello hi sir I be rooted it's a simin it's just a the idea behind what's going on but not practical like Raschi saying like literally it's gonna blow up it's gonna be more of a shear if you go from small to big says the car on my mark maybe shimmy Romero Harry Shum him shot become a little ribbing opponent why in the world I need our measurement end it was a one-time deal bio exam is bad my son Lucas at Mishka so what do I need what so what do I need to basically this why didn't he carried around with me what I need to worry about it what I need on the show ok rabona on have a hint of emotion is Gemini Mishka the ceviche means ice in Mars of Arc even little doors I have it sorry Luffy showed of their weakness this is like your clanking of skis favorite word bigness they got rid of it there is no need for it if there's no only for it if there's no need for it you got rid of it the dog even the have a half of our and this is what Mandy was saying no it was a one-time thing there's no reason to get rid of it it was a nice golden clean keep it on my Merapi me no matter what eruption in sailor Harry Shum Hin sorry that's me avi tapped of Sir Simeon said okay since they got rid of it akina's so I need to bring something instead of it says the game or lease a given Michael and why did it what was pushing him to get another measuring cup so you have six not seven what's the big deal Kodama rivinoja Miri stays smooth wais bit cheaper it says in the Torah twice am i shocked by parent over by the soil Azazel that's by a communal carbon only twice maybe we should do it in other carbon eyes know we have a lot of emotion to see not only these two it limits to those two so to says the Gemara it's interesting like the Gemara have done this as an example of all aloha machine to see nice maybe because it's like a number two or no more so over here it's seven and no less we have a la cocina open ami give me the Sheva media Shalako buy me those end of the story after seven and one of them was buried we have to come up with another one so we come up with another one which is one and a half look for the cavity yeah I'm saying in the local machine I over there was not more not less I know it's not less because the tyre tells me to so what I use the same idea Ravi al ahzab rabbits how the climate losses how you buy him the Leslie Sheva media is so according to velocity there's only one CLE the size of a hint one measuring cup and it had seven lines in it or six lines less leg he doesn't hold that there was seven cups he says the morrow Leslie he doesn't hold it anybody say my chef Ameera shut d-does he asked he holds that a local machinist ed said that there's seven measurements doesn't it several measuring cups the seven lines says the Mishnah release my high so Misha measures what do they do with that famous reviews says the game Mario says the Mishnah reveals my limits are the roots our like it says in the puzzle that the Shaka that C power half has a clitoris well you you check the one one of the birds and the blood goes into the water and then you take the water and the mankind it says o mankind you should shift it in the blood to go on water that came from a spring so how much water do I need I need a rubies rubies chemin de nos zero and it also measured the oil for the bread of the nozzle Patsey look my Amish what'd he do they have a log that's look man Messiah I take the I take the the Taira the the parish off of the soy de and I have to put it in water how much water half a look of water so for that I need a measuring device the tactical chemin the toy though and a half a local shaman for the three brands that we have right there kick in the mats of the palace and the ravu club below if I get a common office for every sorrowing that you bring for a min ha I need one look chemin so that that had a lot of use I feel little middle-class shells she should be so nice in the ocean like like we had yesterday if you're gonna bring a min ha of 60 Sarang you have to measure 60 times with the e sorry measuring cup so - you would have to measure 60 times the chemin with the measuring of they didn't have a larger that was before yes that was the wash the water was the wash you'll see we're going to talk about watching soon serious washing in the Manoa there was the Washington had that sponges they had bad things to wash you mean the oil the water you measure the oil the water you have together so we had that once we once discussed that I remember where it was left over we had something about the leftover sticking around says the Commissioner Rabbi Eliezer Ben Yaakov Oh Murphy no mukou sashimi sorry lol Lugo Shan Mei Lee Min Ho be like shaman there's a positive one like chemin for the Minho she showed up our says the Mishnah you take six look chemin for up for the fur cow how much is six log a half a him because a hen is 12 look very ball my eye oh how much is our ball don't be Ashley she's saying would be a third of n4 look who's fleshly cabinets and three look would be a revision / Olmec Solomon RL and then you take three and a half look for the malaria why that's it local cold Nair if you have seven candles seven works so you need three and a half look for the monoi oil eat half a look for each candle you also ready Bickle casually let me out of cash ruby is llama named Johan so we go back to the Mishnah what is the mission to say why do I need a rubies two reasons MIT sorrow and an Aussie er says Rabi from why in the world do I need to be me Khadija why do I need to put in a clitoris emits all your what suits not maybe something that happens outside vino si La Casa de Mesquita silo the cottage you have to wait anyways until you chef the the RAM and then it all becomes cottage anyways the bread right we had all suger when the bread becomes luck in college college through the schita so what I need the clean or malaria meal you're right you don't need it for those two Shabbat how you murdered the Kavita Kohen Gadol since he was 12 breads and was three lugash a man divided to twelve breads you needed a reveal shammiracle Halawa Kahlo came out to one Revere's for each bread para la merits madhawk he came from poverty strong ish at saucy he's the man that gives that gives me good advice tremendous compliment catty look man how you Machado so what does it say in the mist now fatty Lord was for the satyr and for the toy de los the Rebbe even casually same question has aluminum shaft what do I needed Esau ok cool alluded sweetly kaduche a you think the water is is regular water from the sink manga Dacians if it comes from the key are a toy doll laughing meet Idris cutest I do de cachi it becomes cottage through the Chiquito so I don't need a CLE over there machine me be ready somebody else told him Shibuya mahalik hot see look Sherman oh that's right his own son let me see me be ready she boy have a hearty look chemin they call Nevin air this is how this is how they got the Hat see Luke chemin from each candle on my lord Nerys raw cacao so Texas points out the obvious I don't know if it's obvious I says that he called his son this he gave him this government twice and both of them had to do with lights and now our studio is the bathroom in notice they called Mary strong and also on the sucio of kids ahoy - whispers light oh my reveal cannot on my rebbe Nair Shakur so yeah I love her if you have a minute and the light goes out approaching Hanukkah not so Nikita's magic Hobson me - in Hashemi need a schnapps Allah I think the way you understand it is that once it goes out you have to view the oil and the wick as if they're not there as if they're ashes so what do you do kids in oyster meat eve of a noise sample chemin America you have to clean it out and then you start over you put in oil and you light it is Rako become a ballet shoe noise about chemin how much oil do you put in let's say you filled it up with a half a log and it burned a half a look and then I went out in the other night half at the half a look so now you have a reveal slug leftover so what do you do how much do you fill it up that you put in a full half a log where he just put out whatever was missing a reveal of let's a comedian Shinar I can my Sahasra or like which is missing so how do you read this just simple tight hafstrom means if you just read it as as is it doesn't make any sense do you do you put in as much as that that was burnt Sahasra means whatever is burnt right so you have to obviously what oh but if you really Bhima Dyke in the if you want to touch it up exactly so a big commotion hofstra would mean like what you throwing down into the garbage now in other words whatever is leftover you have a reverse look leftover and your Mahathir you take that out and you put it away throw it into garbage that's what you have to refill it okay fine it's just how can it go how you read it commercial call it should say commotion can be commotion ish are not commercial cause that's what that should be the no no no because the oil that's leftover we say is garbage it's it becomes like ashes just like the wick is garbage you have to throw out the wick you can't use this way you say oh it's still good it looks pretty neat you know like the second night of Hanukkah we use our works again can't do that take it throw it in the garbage because once it's burns burn so all the leftover oil is also garbage get rid of it put it into the true based edition somewhere and you have to put more oil in but what do you how much oil they put in you go all the way to the top of the cup or whatever what's the show the Raschi says Roger says that's in at night you notice that at night Chinaman's night they when it happened but Rashi says a night she did the coin comes they said there was big wind or something was gone so he runs cleans it out real quickly gets rid of all the oil what's the exact oil that was that was left in there whatever is left till the next day that's what he puts in there oh so the motors gonna say that's exactly why the gamers bring this Gemara this this thing yeah all my Ribeira Mia she told the comedian's show you know obviously you have to start from the beginning so you have to put a cot see look Nika Muckelroy cuz if it's what I was left over you know you denied my visa how is he gonna figure it out what is left over the heat name of the Shire lang so you'll say okay he poured it out until clean and he put put a marker then he said okay this is how much it is okay and Cheramie toys why you tell me there's only seven notion to me this to them then I cook every single time that a candle burns out you have to make a new mark and a new mark means a new especially according to the sheet of that there's only one clean that had marks in it so now you made a new mark a new mark is that 8th CLE the next days of the 9th police so you have hundreds of Calum and there's only allowed to be 7 clean Halen so obviously we never measured it you can't measure it you put in a cocky look and that's it the following day when there's too much oil you just you put it out you throwing you take it out no the mushaira means measure we're talking about measuring the key thing entirely you take what how do you know how much is left over okay this is this is this is the CLE this is how much oil was left over start out from here win here how do you know you have to pour it out you have to pour it out how do you know much as leftovers you have to make a mark you can't just look at and say okay this looks like I have to make a mark that mark is awesome because there's a local mission is you know you can do more than seven marks since the kymaro Coryell a bad Orca slap your splendor gives you the hats lava-rock about very mess you're riding on the truth because you bad vengo vengo today because another an MS that's why how you got to this grapeshot it's Minami America Vote American on the amarelo I'm Arab a bow so now we have a price that says mommy shower we had a question it says the answer in the words oh honey no Rabi there should constantly - in Hashem international Silla a candle that went out you have to view it as if it's all ashes it's a toy so what do you do Mick Tebow of the noise of a chemin Kim Midori Shinar it's asthma for SH the bracer as much oil as when you started out I have a will go mad Rico oh my god on over there ever use all of our obsessions never should I make the whole show program a ver very interesting yeah every day I make a shake it from shake with a blender and I found out very quickly if I want to clean out that container it's very difficult to clean it out in the in the sink right you you clean out your cleaning out the dirt and the dirt you have to be able to flip it over and I spray water like this you schmuck it comes out clean in second the same thing with the malaria how you gonna clean out all the soil it's it's upright you're looking at me like yeah for that you have to do it over there by the way the other day there was a thumbs down now you know why the people that woman in Brazil Hey okay I'm upon him you have to put it in through submission and you put and yes and that's a submission probably the pile that's the pile of garbage that's not so very sad he clean it says the Gemara unbeliever prata Marva it almost seemed like it had joints the gold was so beautiful so pure they able to bend it downwards and gravity would help you out clean it you flip it over yeah the candle the candle part you go like this you bend it down I was don't try it at home yeah you bend it over clean it down up sit down everything drops and then you put it back to where it belongs Kesava kick save key karo make sure I'm in know your oven air sexy so the the word key car is going only on the menorah and the candles even the my boy at tava since you need to clean it out you love the program how about if not if it wasn't flexible we have him a title a it wouldn't clean out makes me okay said though so it says in the in the bright so miss out contamination boil you you are this is you disassemble it you take the top part off the candles you put it in there and not so it says no forest you could it comes apart well mechanical misfire you take a sponge and you clean it down the noise chemin I'm at legal and then then you you fill it up at the oil you put it back together again since the Gomorrah Russia ashes who says that it's flexible who the are Marquis height Anna he hold the sang is a harmonium is easy I used some time the candle would never move from its spot MacLeod Sigma as a question they wouldn't move it from meaning McLeod the embody lay the boy lay like Susana Martinez's lay it seems like you could move it they just didn't la mother Isis is awesome in crime I never moved from its spot so our appreciation sobs and never moved in fact close it could have moved from its spot the only thing you could do is flex it downwards oh man - maravilloso design your blazer Brent Celek white man came in tassels of Halle acaba Schumer Tebow here I have a picture I stole this from the missus nah it's not quite the size and these colors is she nervous you know because this is Gold's how to do a yellow so basically there's um this is also gold this round thing is a tassel dog Rashi points out it has a little cutout in the middle and they would pour the oil through it now when they wanted to clean out the menorah they would push it in the direction of the arrow towards the narrow because you see it looks like a little boat over here here's the flame the wicker the wick they would push it towards there and then this part would be open they would flip it downwards and all the oil would pour out and then they would push it back so this is the normal position fill it out from the hole so when they cleaned it out says the Gemara they would push it in direction of the blue arrows that way okay you noise sample chemin de caca clapping Roy Shaw we may plucked or Donita noe the Sangamon Ebenezer boy's been a key card vein Malcolm hey I'm after sermon a key card it says in the postal cue card kicker soft are ya sir you saw the monarda came from one key car from one like a fifteen hundred ounce piece of gold so the question is does that include was included as include the candles on top and does it include you know like by the fireplace you know the fancy home they had the families and have those like a shovel and a brush the middle also has a couple tools called a milk I am and am a place the one who was a tongue to take the wick out and one was like a scooper like a what in my house in Chicago yeah we have family I found it in the straw house and I put it in my house hey Malcolm Thurmond a seminar Kiko its globe but it doesn't come from this kicker the 1500 ounces or the 1,800 ounces of gold which by the way in today's price is about two million dollars of gold it does not include the Calum it's yeah $1,200 per ounce times 1500 1800 is like two million dollars fine so the malko claim is not part of it rubbing the hemorrhoid mayor now pay attention this is room Nathaniel here remember you're a merman know your ID tsubame naki car the menorah came from the key core Vilonia t-cell he says me foolish and not the part that you light the wicks from we malko Hellmuth yourself and of course not the tools boy you see monocular and they don't come from the keyboard but might come if Louie what's my focus bhai Crowe the Sonia kickers of Tory I saw I saw LeMond denominator shoe bomber Akiko benignly Robbie's nearest cell how do I know that includes the Narrows now all of a sudden the prices says it does include the nares a second ago we said Renee Fleming says it doesn't contain errors the composer's gonna dress this helmet mark he's called Kayla more inland you see in red is Carla Kayla Mellie comes to include the neighbors who says this y'all for Shannon my base Marco thermos t-cell maybe it should also include the tools that Malloy Mart or he saw in blue livery ribbon if mu so this is a big problem cashew before we go anywhere casually retire in cameo he started off saying that it thought it does include the nares now doesn't include the nares what is it trait I know I believe there is I'm fine okay we have to obviously it's too strong of a question to answer we have to say that's too annoying their water from the time you said maybe sure I've been caught 5 min Minori Obama naki core very Michael clever them after seven or so bomb in a key core vellum on a Mac I am a scholar kala Merri what do I do with the Escala Kellerman either how you Kahlan shows up that the tools were made I dissolve as the Gemara resolve a epic super I don't need a spark here the Marilla when it's more fortunate I oversee Sisneros an evil presence ever has Alaric whenever I come home after sales or pirates as my portion the Taira should be at a go my mentor Clara the pig narrows it's talking about this part of the menorah all the way up here maybe this part right over here this little part I think shouldn't be out of gold there's no point for it to be at a goal when every night you're burning it it becomes black so good night and I mean oil peanuts our story mass here become black I thought of course of my mother she's strong but I've adsorbed coal do and make it out of whatever why does it have to be from this key car from the purest of the pure calm a smile on that even the entire menorah is made out of pure gold the key what do you say