Daf Yomi Menachos Daf 61 by R' Eli Stefansky

Good morning Rabbi boys. HI. I HAD A TREMENDOUS COURSE LAST NIGHT to be in Shalavim. Spoke to the boys there for an hour and 40 minutes. It was a big matzah. Big, big matzah. I went to a lot of Yeshivas. That was like the matzah of all these they sang a lot before. They wouldn't let me speak until they like had three funny niggunim. What's the niggun I really like? >> [music] [singing] >> Right. I found out. I found out real quickly. Um Once in a generation opportunity Rabbi boys have be a part of MDY Gemara Legacy Maseches Chullin new sponsors today the dappim Moses Markovich, Ariel Kaimov Kaimov Dov Meir Balcony Balcony Kobi Leifer. You want you just read this. Avi Ka- Kami Onsky. >> [laughter] >> Perfect. Avi Shkoyach. Rabbi Avi Kaminsky is well done. Uh somebody just sent this I'm seri- I don't know where my father is. Have you seen my father? So somebody sends me this video. On on him playing he pulls out his little Sefer Torah that he carries with him all the time. All right. So um Not this one. All right. This Hagoyner Landau following Home Front Command guidelines is the eraser. Is the eraser. Here it is. Here's the video. Isn't that what I said all of them in the matter of safety? Oh. Common sense wins every time. When yesterday. This is not yesterday. How do you know this kid is from MDY? Cuz he's wearing a helmet. He cares about safety. I thought about it today. Um I'll show you this video. He's a He's a good kid. Very good kid. He's a 15-years-old. But how many people when you go on a plane and they tell you how to put the seat belt on? How many people on the plane out of 4-500 people, how many people don't know how to put on a seat belt? Zero. So, why do they say it? You could ask the pilots in the room. We have two three pilots here. When you when you They teach you the first thing they teach you is you have to do the same thing. Repeat the same safety steps. There's certain things that make zero sense. You I used to take a sample of fuel from the plane. Five samples every time to see drain out the water, but there's no water. There's never ever any water. I've never found. Maybe you found. And um you do these things that >> [clears throat] >> But guess what? You do the same You say You say You say the same thing. Your voice says you have to put your seat belt like this. You have to do that. It gives you a sense of there are no cutting There's no There's no changing the rules. These are the rules. These are the things. These are the guidelines. There's a checklist if they read from here. Check. Four. Yeah. Um I I know of a guy My my My instructor's instructor was a guy in in flying. And uh he was flying jets and he's flying this. So, when he flew a small plane, he didn't do the checklist. And uh they found him in a tree at the end of the runway because one of the things in checklist is to pull out the safety pin from the yoke. The yoke. This is, you know, the steering wheel. This thing that goes up and down. This when you take off, you have to pull it towards you. And there's a little pin that goes in there. But he didn't do the checklist cuz he's too khashuv to do the checklist. So, he forgot to pull the pin out. So, when he came to the end of the runway, he's pulling the yoke and it didn't go anywhere and he got and he slammed the tree. It's because he's too good. When you're too when you have too much confidence and so you say the same thing. You say the same thing. The boys are putting on your seatbelt and you go like that and to unclick you go like this. And the same dumb thing over and over. But it keeps That's why bar Hashem in America the safety record is In other countries like, "Yeah, that's still some Everybody knows that and we're going to do it." It brings a certain So, what I'm trying to say is it leads to other things. When you when you say when you relax, okay, you don't have to do the I'm not going to be this nerd that runs to the Okay, but then but then your kid sees it. And then he doesn't wear the helmet. And then and then your wife sees it, so she talks on the phone as she crosses the street. And she's texting. You know these people? It's nar viam. Anyways, it's fine. I said my thing. I go by there. I just I just How are How come they talk about the safety belt? Because one leads to the other. Anyway, fine. Think about it. No, is that is that shat? Something like that. You know me, Liber. Everyone. Yeah. Side of there? I just have to show You mean? No. Yeah. Um Our home is there. >> comes down and And then I come to the dash. Okay. Okay. Yeah. As I need Actually I can tell when I need money. Yeah. Tell me what you want to do the show. I need to say it's me about to tell her. I would have to say what I do. I don't know what you say to have her. I don't know what to seven year old lady. The call you on the way to go in the city. Call you on. No matter what you mean. I know I need what is it by English. How about you what is it by English? Yeah. I would have to say I'm a good boy. What is it by English? I see you too. My name is the opening. Tell me what you want to open the line. Tell me. What do you mean? I don't know what to do. I don't know what to call her when I go home. Okay, tell me. 20 of them. I don't know what to do. I don't know what to do. I don't know what to Call me to see how I got to be a match. I don't know what to do. I don't know what to do. I don't know what to do. I don't know what to do. I don't know what to do. I don't know what to do. I don't know what to I don't know what to do. I don't know what to do. I don't know what to do. I don't know what to do. I don't know what to do. I don't know what to do. I don't know what to do. I don't know what I don't know what to do. I don't know what to do. I don't know what to do. I don't know what to do. I don't know what to do. I don't know what to do. I don't know what to do. I don't know what to do. I don't know what to do. I don't know what to do. I don't know what to do. I don't know what to do. I don't know what to do. I don't know what to do. Yeah. I don't know what to do. I don't know what to do. I don't know what to I don't know what to do. I don't know what to do. I don't know what to do. I don't know what to do. I don't know what to do. I don't know what to do. I don't know what to do. I don't know what to do. I don't know what to do. I don't know what to do. I don't know what to do. I don't know what to do. I don't know what to do. I don't know what to do. I don't know what to do. I don't know what to do. I don't know what to do. I don't know what to do. I don't know what to do. I don't know what to do. I don't know what to do. I don't know what to do. I don't know what to do. I don't know what to do. I don't know what to do. I don't know what to do. I don't know what to do. and left to left us British to man the fort. How times have changed. We all want to go home. No shaikh is like, "Oh, you get a free flight home." Tati, I need to go home. I'm scared. Okay, come back. If you're in touch with Avi Katz and Buchler, please give them a yeah. I'm not in touch with them, but he reached out to Itzy Scharf. So, you should go out. This is um Check this out. The email is Zevy does the daf at whatever. I just took that part out. Dear Reb Eli and MDY Mishpacha, I just looked at my calendar and realized something incredible. Today's my 500th day learning with MDY. When I started, I was not sure I'd make it past the first week of Maseches Bava Basra, but your clarity, humor, and passion for the daf kept me going even on days when my motivation was shaking. Okay, I'll admit I didn't always do chazarah, but in fact, I'm still here says everything about how much your shiur means to me. This daily commute has changed my relationship with Torah, says this very mature person. Every day learning something new. I'm so grateful to be part of the Mishpacha. Most of all, I'm grateful to you, Reb Eli, for making the daf feel alive and relevant every single day. So, today I just want to say thank you for your tireless dedication. Whether you're in Chicago, Boro Park, Utah, you're always there with your warmth and smile. Thank you for being Reb Eli, who made 500 days fly by. Stay safe. Lots of bracha. Zevy brother 15 years old. 15 years old. Since Bava Basra daf kuf kuf hey. How come you're not asking me for this email? Okay. >> [laughter] >> Fine. Um I guess there's there's a lot there's a lot Let's go right there. Well, I'll show these be there some other time. Kivaldik. You know what? Let me just show this show this one. This is from Shalom Rand's status. Shalom Rand is a famous status guy. Hey, I feel like I need to share this with you. I know you speak with Reb Eli. I'm sure he hears things like this often, but I I want to tell you. He's telling Shalom Rand. I struggle with davening and learning for about 20 years. Recently things were really hard financially. My wife couldn't find a job. Lots of things going on. Wrong. Wrong. Right before the Shabbatone, I came across this status and decided to start doing the daf. Since then, I haven't missed a day. I kept telling my wife that our life would change if I kept at it. As I continued learning, I started to feel closer to Hashem and felt ready to take the next step. My wife and I took upon ourselves some kabbalahs, and I kid you not, the very next day she was offered a job. Reb Yisrael uh oh, we have sponsors. Official edition of the White Shas was accepted by the Iranian Levy families, Shmuel and Ahuva Shuster, in honor of my parents, Yitzchak Naftali ben Yitzchak Aryeh Shuster shlita, Shmuel and Ahuva Shuster. David Solomon, dedicated memory of Avraham ben Mordechai ben Baruch ben Chaim ben Dovid ben Yisrael ben Avraham. By Joel Gedaliah ben Yisrael ben Moshe ben Pinchas ben Gedaliah ben Yisrael ben Avraham ben Yisrael ben Gedaliah ben Pinchas ben Yisrael ben Gedaliah ben Yisrael ben Avraham ben Yisrael ben Pinchas ben Yisrael ben Gedaliah ben Yisrael ben Avraham ben Yisrael ben Pinchas ben Yisrael ben Gedaliah ben Yisrael ben Avraham ben Yisrael ben Yisrael ben Yisrael ben Pinchas ben Yisrael ben Avraham ben Yisrael ben Pinchas ben Yisrael ben Avraham ben Yisrael ben Pinchas ben Yisrael ben Avraham ben Yisrael ben Pinchas ben Yisrael ben Avraham ben Yisrael ben Pinchas ben Yisrael ben Avraham ben Yisrael ben Pinchas ben Yisrael ben Avraham ben Yisrael ben Pinchas ben Yisrael ben Avraham ben Yisrael ben Pinchas Monthly sponsors, Ari Simon ben Yisrael ben Avraham ben Mordechai ben Baruch ben Miriam, Jamie Azulay ben Yisrael ben Avraham ben Yisrael ben Avraham ben Yisrael ben Avraham ben Yisrael ben Avraham ben Yisrael ben Avraham ben Yisrael ben Avraham ben Yisrael ben Avraham ben Yisrael ben Avraham ben Yisrael ben Avraham ben Yisrael ben Avraham ben Yisrael ben Avraham ben Yisrael ben Avraham ben Yisrael ben Avraham ben Yisrael ben Avraham ben Yisrael ben Avraham ben Yisrael ben Avraham ben Yisrael ben Avraham ben Yisrael ben Avraham ben Yisrael ben Avraham Anonymous ben Yisrael ben Avraham ben Yisrael ben Avraham ben Yisrael ben Avraham ben Yisrael ben Avraham ben Yisrael ben Avraham ben Yisrael ben Avraham ben Yisrael ben Avraham ben Yisrael ben Avraham ben Yisrael ben Avraham ben Yisrael ben Avraham ben Yisrael ben Avraham ben Yisrael ben Avraham ben Yisrael ben Avraham ben Yisrael ben Avraham ben Yisrael ben Avraham ben Yisrael ben Avraham ben Yisrael ben Avraham Anonymous ben Yisrael ben Avraham ben Yisrael ben Avraham ben Yisrael ben Avraham ben Yisrael ben All of our Sherman is your site. Yossi Robbins with gratitude and appreciation to Reb Eli on his favorite of somehow of Stefansky Eli. Eli Berkowitz whose brother was just nifter. Young man with young children. Yitzchak ben Eliezer, Reb Simcha Lauer. Steve Kobrinsky thanks to Reb Eli for inspirational muscle shear at my son Zack's Yeshiva Shalavim. In the audience was a kid and he tells his name is Kobrinsky. Ah, Kobrinsky. So I brought him to the front and I told him over the story how right after the seder Pesach night there was a knock on my door and I didn't eventually I opened the door and I looked around and I don't see anyone and I looked down and I see a baby in a little basket. And I'm like, "Was ist das?" Oh, no. They dropped off a baby here and I need to take him in. This whole thing goes through my mind and how I'm going to grow him up. Is he And I look at him to see if he's alive. I thought maybe it's a prank. The kid is alive and well. He's like looking at me. He's blinking the whole like what am I going to do with this kid? I I I don't carry. I don't use the Chicago. Although my wife Hi Eli. So I'm like, "How you doing?" I'm with you Menachem Eskam and the whole family as Shamir Acham. How old was he? 37. >> Oy oy oy, 37 years old. Wow. Wow, wow, wow. Sorry to cloud your show. The kids are I'm like, "What do I do?" This that and all of a sudden this this kid comes jumping out of a bush. He says, "Ha, I pranked you." Little seder 1:00 in the morning he pranks me. So that was that was the twin. The guy in Shalavim is the twin of the of the baby in the basket. That's how long ago it was. Um but he he uh he verified the story and then he goes, "Just for that it was worth it. I never believed the story." and here's the kid. >> [clears throat] >> Daily sponsors Calvin Family, Mendy and Avi both came to this year. Uh Avi's a luminary of Shalom Bayis. So, unbelievably Yeshiva Bais Medrash, like these are quality bachrum. These are good, top top guys, but also but middos, like you know, like you see the Your son is going Your son went there? My son just finished there. Wow. Wow. What? So, they interview the parents also? >> [laughter] >> Calvin Family must be here for many years and hello Tainus. Yossi They didn't interview you. Tell me they didn't interview you. You You did? They were able to like look past that. These guys are amazing. Who does interviews? Reb Cohen? He He talked to a Christian. Is he Christian? Despite Calvin Family hello Tainus Dof Chovov Calvin Family and Moshe Michel Zaideh That's how you say it? Zaideh? Tainus Chovov. What is this? What's going on here? Hold on. Both say Tainus Dof Chovov. Something is Oh. Hersh ben Eliezer No, it's not. Same family. It's a different person. But they both say Tainus Chovov. What Who What's Tainus Chovov? The person that Calvin Family? Not the person that died? Okay, I'm confused a little bit. We're going to get a We're going to get a a Anonymous l'illui nishmas Reb Dovid Avrohom ben Reb Shloime Steigmann or Stigman? Stigman alav hashalom on his yahrtzeit. Yoni Jordana Gorelick in memory of Mayor Ben Yitzchok whose first yard side is today Levi Machkin Mach Machkin Mochkin in celebration of the 30th birthday of Levi Ben Chanan Nachman for Chabad of Geneseo Geneseo The boys, if you ever go to Geneseo, there's a Chabad over there. Yossi Fischer L'zecher Naftali Lederer L'tinokes Rochel Leah bas Rochel Leah Shlema bas Rochel Leah b'korov mamash. Amen. Moshe Shulga L'zecher Naftali Lederer Chaim Mendel ben Rivka Menachem Mendel ben Rivka. Amen. Everywhere? It's in New York. I always said I have to talk to him all the time. >> [sighs] >> Refuah Shleima Yonatan ben Esther ben Esther ben Esther Refuah Shleima Mordechai ben Esther Refuah Shleima Daniel ben Esther ben Esther The boys, I we are holding a einai like 12 lines from the bottom of daf samecha mem beis. Here's a question for those of you who didn't see the daf yet. This question is worth 10,000 points. One guy, one Israeli guy knew the answer. I have a feeling we're going to have more people. How many women do a t'nufa when they bring when they bring a korban? What do you say? sotahs sotahs sotahs Oh. Anybody else? That's it. You You didn't say it the right way. Say it the right way. Say it the right way. b'tzitzis a Mishnah Kiddushin Yeah, yeah, yeah, he said he said he said, he got it. Very good. You have to be in your late 80s with that kind of experience. Huh? Not late. Where are Where are you? Let's hear. Early. Early. Oh, 84. >> over 60. Remember. But we know her. What? Be quiet. Let's see. Let's see. Something tomorrow. You ate no wheat. Yesterday we had the word the "ve'eisa". "Ve'eisa". And we said according to Reb Shimon Reb Yochanan, remember? What does Reb Shimon Reb Yochanan say? Reb Shimon goes together with "lakba". The "omer". "Ve'eisa" comes from "omer". And Rebbi Yehuda says it comes from "sota". Oh, you ate no wheat yesterday morning. Maybe the word "ve'eisa" you know "omer" "ve'eisa" "el she yochid". It's like "ve'eisa" you shall bring as an individual. "El she yochid" is not that or maybe "mincha acheres chutz me'eileh she be'inyan". That when an individual brings a "mincha" perhaps he is able to bring it from barley. Typically speaking, he brings it from wheat. Perhaps this word "ve'eisa" comes to tell us that he could bring it from barley. "Chutz me'eileh she be'inyan". "Vedinun". Now, there are those that you do bring barley, but besides the ones in barley, just a "minchas nedava". "Vedinun". Perhaps you can learn it from logic. "Tzibbur" maybe "mincha minachos chova" maybe "mincha minchas tzibbur". When the community brings "minachos" they could bring it from two types. They bring from wheat, the "shtei halechem" on "Shavuos". Or maybe "mincha minchas omer". They bring the "omer". The "omer" is also barley. "Af yochid she maybe "mincha minchas acheres" "nedava" "yochid" "mincha minchas omer" "nedava". he could also bring it from both. It could only be these. Now, therefore, I can't think for a second that an individual could bring barley, and therefore it goes back what do I do with the the the vasa? I'm not going to learn a third thing from it. It's either going to be to teach me that either omer or sita they need to do hagasha. What's hagasha off? Maybe there's a bunch of uh Shalvim boys that just joined, hopefully. Hagasha is when you take the mincha or carbon, whatever it is, bikurim, and you bring it and you touch it right here on the mizbeach on the southwest corner of the mizbeach right here. Touches the wall. That's hagasha. Actually, a kid in uh Shalvim knew the answer. I asked him what a hagasha is. He said, "We're learning a hagasha." Does anybody know One kid knew, actually. Zakta Gemara. Oh, yeah, you know it. Omer. Ela. Ela ela omer ela like mincha shma me v'chamisha. Perhaps we have this We had the list of 10. Remember the 10 menachos? So, the first five are michas nedava. Minchas solas, machavas, maracheshas, chalisin, and ikarin, five of them. So, perhaps when a person says, "I want to bring you a mincha. I want to bring you a nedava." He should bring all five. Tamar omer me ela. From these. Rotza achas me v'lo, chamisha maybe. Boys, we have a easier sugiya today. It's like nothing difficult. It's just nimuqum shortly nimuqum me ela. From these. You don't have to bring all of these. You could bring some of these, one of these. Rotza achas me v'lo, chamisha maybe. Bring one, you could bring all five. Reb Shimon omer shamincha. If we go back to the pasuk v'haveisa es hamencha asher ye'aseh me ela Hashem. Should bring the mincha. So what do we do with them in her? So she says the rabbis charm in office. Charm in office. What's charm in office today? Charm in office means not not these five minutes but charm in office. Charm in office the minutes fighter. Person who sins has to bring and he doesn't have money so he brings flower. The center one is the Well, usually we use her as a site that but okay, they're using her as a woman. The mincha of a woman and the mincha of a guy. The rabbis charm in office la that all these three they have to take the mincha and touch the corner of the mincha. Perhaps also the two breads of and the 12 breads of that are in the that the guy had to meet every single time of the mailer. Mailer comes to exclude those two the and the mailer. Why do you pick these two to exclude and not to include? All of the minchas you do the coin takes his hand takes part of it three fingers worth like this and puts it on the puts it on the fire on the and my son is still entire and the entire mailer. I see tomorrow so if the deciding factor here is going on the fire not going on the something that goes on the fire you do have got sure. You have to touch them as bad something that doesn't go on the but the talking about the minchas talking about many times it's the mincha that comes together with the mailer. You put it completely on the back. You have to yet to know how got sure according to what you're saying something goes on his back it should be a got sure. How come there isn't any how got sure the mailer. The kriva only this you bring to the to hagasha but not you don't do hagasha on minchas sochim. As the gemara, how can you learn anything from the word vekriva ba'al pikde? All the new guys, guys that just started, we're getting to a mission it's going to be a brand new sugia so just bear with us for a moment. Ba'al pikde. We already used this word vekriva for the sa'ita. Now, from the word vekriva that we could actually learn two things. It could have said vehikriv. The coin should be makriv, lashon zachar normal. Vekriva the extra hey teaches us to to exclude the nesachim. Now we from the same word we're marba the sa'ita. Um mariva um marisa ravasha minachas lo itzi minchas nesachim. How come shai minachas? What's shai minachas? Shai minachas is this, yeah? How come? You're saying that these three do need hagasha but minchas nesachim not. You you could you could choose. You could say vekriva comes to be mema'et these three. Why is vekriva not excluding these three? What Who told you what to exclude from the word vekriva? So for that we have to use a little logic. Marba shai minachas is daf sama chala marba shai minachas she boys below atzma. Shai minachas woman. They come on their own. They don't need a carbon. Um may say any minchas nesachim she boys below atzma. Minchas nesachim comes 90% of the time together with shlamim min oila. So it comes as an addition to something else. So um may say it makes more sense that that doesn't require hagasha. A lot of minchas oila minchas meshiach boys below atzma. Yochol you tune this hagasha. This is goes according to Reb Shimon in the mishna that these two the anything that has to do with a coin the regular coin the coin godol his mincha does not require hagasha. I don't know if you remember we had a whole chart of 10 that they These are included for agasha. But according to Rav Shimon, you don't do agasha on these two. Tamar V'gisha. V'gisha excludes the kayata. As the Gemara lugufos tuna agasha, V'gisha that all these five These five need agasha. How could you exclude something from a word that's necessary to tell us that these five need agasha? Min V'higish V'gisha This is extra hey like we had V'hikrivi Kriva. So we have V'higish V'gisha This is extra hey. Well, my reason Rav Shmuel Ha'Levi says kayata minchas kayata Mashiach. Why did you say that the chaitah Yeah, Sha'ar Minachos with Sha'ar Minachos. Here, Sha'ar Minachos. Sha'ar Yirachos. Sha'ar Minachos These three need agasha. Kayin does not need agasha. Why? Who told you? Mar Rav Ani So, Rav Ani said this is like almost like a a synopsis of everything we learned in one chapter. There are three rules, says the Gemara, according to Rav Shimon. Mar Rav Ani Sha'ar Minachos she'im leishim. These three, the chaitah, ishah, goi They have a k'mitzah. Some of it goes on the mizbei'ach. So, that's why you do hagasha. Ubai's b'goral atzmo. Anything that comes on its own and doesn't come together with a carbon requires agasha. V'yesh min ha'kehanim. And the third thing is that is left over the shirayim for the kayin. And therefore, umai tzanis alecha min lechem ha'panim she'einam leishim. Some things fall have one issue. The what? The two breads from Shavuos and the lechem ha'panim, they have no Nothing goes on the fire. Nothing goes on the mizbei'ach. Uminchas ha'sogim b'goral atzmo. And also, the nisachim don't come on their own. They come because they come with the oil and the shlamim. Uminchas ha'omer b'goral atzmo she'einam min ha'kehanim. The reason the the kayin's mincha because nothing's left over, you don't have the uh the shiyuraim. In other words, it's all to the it's all on the mizbe'ah. The whole thing goes on the mizbe'ah. Next sugiyah. It says in the pasuk "veheirim". Oh, I forgot to check it out cuz it didn't add up this thing. Okay, there's some sort of mistake here, I think, in terms of the pesukim. But anyway, it says "veheirim". "Veheirim mikomein amincha". How does he take from the mincha? So, "yachol bikli". Maybe he should take like one of those spoons that you have in the Take garinim. What What is it called? One of these A scoop. Yeah. "Shikva". Like in a nice scoop. You go like this. A scooper, a scoop. You go like they take with the scooper a scoop of flour and give al it. "Ta'ama deloy imar veheirim me'edam bekumtzoi". You have in pasuk ches, right next to it, two pesukim next to each other. "Veheirim me'edam bekumtzoi". Over here, by the minchas nedava, you take with your hand. You do a kemitzah. "Ma'aramah omer le'alo mekumtzoi af ramah omer kemitzah". They're both with their hand. A ma'aseh. I think Reb Baila said it over at the siyum on Bava Basra. I said it before that also. It's a famous ma'aseh. There was a kid that went into like a store. He was looking around, looking around. So, the owner of the store saw that he's you know needs some help. He says, "Why Why don't you take a a fistful of candy?" So, the kid just looked at him. He said, "No, you take." So, the guy says, "You know what? I'll Well, I'll give you." Takes a bag. Puts it in. So, the kid came home. He told his mother what happened. So, she says, "So, why don't you take what he told you to take?" He said, "Cuz my hand is much smaller than his." >> [laughter] >> So, when you when you daven to the Ribono shel Olam, don't daven with your small musagim. "Ribono shel Olam, give me parnasah $2,000 a month." No. K'she'er asher de'acha. K'she'er asher de'acha. You in the Rebono shel Olam has musagim. A little bit better than ours, a little bit more than ours. And he's called Yakov. So, Rebono shel Olam give us in your musagim. Oh, shalom aleichem guest. What's your name? Avram Colvin? Shalom aleichem. I'm a fakir in Chashmona'im. It's one of the the first one from the first >> [applause] >> Heard of We had a yeshiva here the other day and they didn't clap at all. >> [laughter] >> Shimmy Rakham. Says the holy Mishnah. Yossi was loving it. Are you a talmid of his? How's it work? No, I'm the other unit. He's a grandson. It doesn't go by age, right? So, you could have a 20-year-old pisher like telling you what to do. Your your mefakid is 20 years old. Wow. Anything Eima tzu noys tnufa v'ein tzu noys hagasha. So, we'll just continue the Mishnah is continuing with the the theme. Yesterday we discussed the 10 menachos that need hagasha they don't need tnufa over here. The opposite. What requires tnufa? Tnufa is lifting as we're going to see in the Gemara, up, down, right, left, to all the sides. That's tnufa. Hagasha is touching the the mizbeach on the corner. There are some So, we had four options. Some menachos A mincha is a korban that you bring you made out of flour. Some require both, hagasha and tnufa. Some don't require any, zero, no hagasha no tnufa. Some require just hagasha but not nuva. And some require just nuva not a garshonel. That's what we're talking about right now. Just nuva not a garshonel. It was nuva very good with garshonel. Look shamans of mitsrayim this you didn't see everybody say. A re-done mitsrayim process. The mitsrayim process is very complicated. It There's a lot a lot of steps. And this after you watch this video you're going to remember many many of the steps especially the oil by the ear part. Very important. I I love this this goes by quickly. But look this guy is on his way to the base hamikdash with with everything he needs. Flour oil three different types of carbonas and he's trying to show you the carbona the entire time he's pointing out what carbon. Anyway here we go. That's the nuva and look at the oil how it stays put over there. >> [music] >> You got some finger right there. I don't know why he's painting all the fingers. Side panel on the thumb. As long as the shaman with the oil on the >> [music] >> What's going on in that body? What's on his head? I don't give up. He smiles more than Very good. Yeah. All right. So that oil that you saw on top of the animal You have to do the Nufel. Like you saw, he lifted, he put in the video. You see him doing the Nufel. Let's see the Korum again. What's such a murder video? Show the Korum again. But also I want to ask you a question if there's a problem in this video. Did anybody think that it's the hour tree for a second like from the leaves? You saw it on a massive screen last night. It was so clear. The quality is unbelievable. That's how it should go. See in the bottom it should should take hot sauce. >> [applause] >> This is the Nufel supposed to be in the southwest corner. Remember that's the question I'm asking now. Is that the right place to do the tnuva? So, says the Mishnah, "Bikurim k'didei R' Eliezer ben Yaakov." As the Gemara is going to talk, what does R' Eliezer ben Yaakov say? It's also R' Yehudah says the same thing. "V'eimurei sham Yochid b'chazazis shel haim." I thought I put the emurim in and I forgot to put it in again. I do have the shok and chaza. So, this [snorts] is tnuva. But, also the emurim are the the the skirt steak and the kidneys, etc. "Eich od anashim v'eich anashim." Women also have to do tnuva. "B'isur v'lo b'cheirem." Now, all of a sudden the Mishnah switches. Says, "Well, women have to do it, but not a cheirem. Isur, not a cheirem." So, the Gemara is going to explain what that means. "Shtei aleihem b'shtei kvisos atzaros." The two breads on Shavuos and the two sheep of Shavuos, just as so, you have to do tnuva. Seems like from Rashi, you have to take the two sheep together. The breads are on top according to Rashi. "Keitzad oseiha? Noisin shtei aleihen al gabbei shtei kvasim." According to the Mishnah, the two breads go on top of the sheep. "U'miniyach shtei yadav l'matah." You put your two hands underneath. "Moyil u'meivi maloh u'moreed." You go So, according to Rashi, not here, it's to all sides. That's why with the lulav, we go to all sides. Maloh u'moreed, you go up and down. "Shenemar, "Asher hunaf v'asher huram." Tnuva. Tnuva, you hear this? "Hoseiv b'mizrach." The tnuva was in the east. So, I want to ask you a question. It was in the east. What's the east? Let me just show you what the east is before I ask any questions. There's east and there's west. When you come into the Beis Hamikdash, you're coming in from the east side of the the Azarah, we show it the opposite actually, but okay. The Heichal is the west. The Azarah is on the east. So, it's saying that you could do the tenufa, you should do the tenufa where the red arrow is, not where the green arrow It seems like not where the green arrow is. The green arrow is the southwest corner. Is that a problem with our video? The answer is no. The entire sugia when it says bemizrach means even in the mizrach, certainly on the southwest corner, which is closer to the Heichal, closer to Hashem. So, again, be- bemizrach means it's very important to to realize this. Bemizrach means even in the east. Vahagasha but touching them is bad, it's always on the my always on the southwest corner. Tenufa is called my slagoshis. There are two There are two korbanos, two menachos that you do both. Does anybody remember which one? You do tenufa and hagasha to both the omer and the sotah. So, the tenufa would come before the hagasha. But the Brisker Rav says that this could apply also to if you have a korban that's only hagasha like the whole list that we had yesterday, mincha chavit, all these versus something that's only tenufa. Tenufa comes before. You say, "Hey, wait a minute, you." And you go to him. Minchas omer or minchas knois, what? Yeah. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Oh, we'll see. We'll Oh, yeah, what what's the Yeah, so. Yeah. Right. Why? No, I'm saying he's over here. He's in a different process. He wants to go before you. W- Who said? Why Why should he come before you? Who comes before who? Oh. No, I'm saying if you Yeah. Are you married? Are you married? Say it no animal. On the mincha. On the mincha. Nuf on the mincha. Hagasha on the mincha. >> [snorts] >> Mincha is I'm going to nice. Two nice hagasha with nuf here. This is for I'm and say that. They both get hagasha and nuf. The map on the mincha and say him. The the breads the 12 breads and shabbos look at my map on the mincha and say him and the mincha that comes with the oil. I do this later with nuf. They don't get either. I'm sure I mean slight mean to challenge me to us. There are three things that require three things. However, I'm just going to read it and then I'll show you a chart is very simple. Stein because I have a house. The three things you only take the two myths with for these three things. Which is in but each one gets two out of the three. But two different ones out of the three and neither none of the three get all three. What is this number? They differ from the differ from the table but it's the same. I'll just show you I'll show you rebel Yalkin from the table. He did this rudimentary drawing and he says this is how you should explain this to you. So Yossi did this and then he did this. Let me just show you. It turned into this. Okay, so we have three things in the center. We have the two of them shall we say it's a individual and say more. We know shall we say more means the two the two sheep on shabbos. And then we have three myths with on the top. Smichos Chaim on the right side top, Smufos Chaim and Smufos Shochet. You do Smufos when the animal's dead, Smufos when the animal's alive. So now let's say we take the top center Asham and Tsair he gets two circles. He gets a blue and a green. So in other words, he gets Smicha when it's alive and he gets Smufa when it's alive. Then we go to the right the right on the bottom Shlomi Yochid he gets a blue circle and a red circle. So he gets Smufa when it's dead and Smicha when it's alive. And then Shlomi Tsibur they get the green and the red which is Smufa when it's dead and Smufa when it's alive. Don't don't try to remember it that maybe you could maybe you did. The point is there's three korbanos and there's three mitzvahs and each korban gets two out of the three mitzvahs but something different than the other and neither of them get I don't know is that the right word to say neither on three? None of them get didn't sound well. The right way to say didn't sound right. Wouldn't sound well to say neither. None of them get all three. They all get two. Okay, so it was his way of showing how to do it. Give all of it. Zivchei Shlomi Tsibur inside what? It's okay. You got it now? You can't repeat any of it. You're not going to know if I ask you which one gets which two. No, but okay the idea is there. Zivchei Shlomi Yochid imagine you're a kid in cheder and you have to memorize this Mishnah. >> [clears throat] >> You know, you go to Zichron today, you go to Zilberman, you have to remember this Mishnah about that. Zivchei Shlomi Yochid Tulin Smicha Chaim with Smufa Shochet Vein Bohem Smufa they don't have the third thing Smufa Chaim. Zivchei Shlomi Tsibur the two korbanos you bring on on Shavuos Tulin Smufa Chaim you do Smufa you have to lift it when it's alive U'shochet and also when it's dead. Vein Bohem Smicha you're not you're not I'm sorry not Smicha it's called yeah, Smicha. But Asham and Tsair don't Smicha or Smufa Chaim Vein Bohem Smufa Shochet. Great. Torah Bottom. >> [snorts] >> It says by the metzora the lotion sherman the hainif tnuva milamdish tnuva ke'echad The what? As we saw in the video, the metzora, the guy, after he has tzarat, he has a whole process when he comes to torah, he brings an animal and oil and he does tnuva. We saw it in the video that the oil was about to fall off and then it comes back on. So you have to lift it together with the oil. the hainif oisam tnuva in singular, oisam plural, the animal and the oil, tnuva one lifting. um na'in hainif zevachim zevach tmiyoto It's a very important here to to realize if you don't do tnuva what happens to your carbon? Do you have to bring another carbon? No. It's a few like smicha. You don't do smicha, you don't lean on it. It's a It's a good carbon. So what does it mean over here? um na'in hainif zevachim zevach You didn't do the tnuva in the proper way. You didn't lift them both up together. You did each one individually. Yotza. You don't have to do any of them to be to to to to that the carbon should be chalas. What does yotza mean? Very simple. It means the mitzvah of tnuva. There's a special mitzvah to do tnuva. You should know that if you did each one individually, you're yotza the mitzvah of tnuva. Tamar How do I know? Tamar Vayikra oisoi lo'osham vehainif. Hm? I I I missed the some words. I don't know. Okay. Vayikra lo'osham vehainif. Vehainif it's individual. That's the gemara. Yochil yochil yotza vi'onah. The gemara is asking over here that perhaps you should do three tnuvas. You should do a tnuva like you thought, the two of them together. Put them down and then each one individually. Take the the oil, do a tnuva. Take the animal, do a tnuva, three times. Tamar tnuva v'lo tnuvais. It's the word tnuva is extra. Why is the word Nufah's extra? Cuz it says Vahinif. And then it says Nufah. So the word Nufah, you don't have to say Nufah if it already says Vahinif. Hainif Nufah. So the Nufah's extra. What I learned that it's a one time it's a one time deal. You don't have to do three times. Nufah, singular. Lifnei Hashem, you should do this in front of Hashem Bamizrach. What does Bamizrach mean, Rabbi Yisrael? Very good. Even Bamizrach. Why? Because if you look at the Beis Hamikdash again, Lifnei Hashem is in Maariv. Where's the Heichal? Where's the Kodesh Hakodashim? Inside the Heichal. So Maariv is much closer to Hashem. Which we in Zevachim we kept on saying Lifnei Lifnei Hashem is Maariv Maariv. Ah, and the Gemara's going to bring it up here. But Amris, by Mincha it says Lifnei Hashem Bamizrach. It has to be davka Bamizrach. Amri, Hana Mincha Degrei Chatas. A Mincha the pasuk calls Mincha a Chatas. The Chatas is done on the side. A regular Chatas requires Eitzis. Says Rashi, interesting. Other Rishonim argue on him, but we go with Rashi. Make it simpler. This is the Zichron it's not Ma'akev also, but you take the leftover blood and you pour it on the side. That's on a real Chatas. Since a Mincha's called a Chatas, it doesn't have blood, but it's called a Chatas. So may I I'm going to put it on the same corner as a regular Chatas. The Keren Dromis Mizrach is like the Eitzis. Here, if you look over here on this Mizbei'ach, the red is the base of the Mizbei'ach. Now, there's no red over here and no red over here. This is the east. This is the west. This is the southwest corner. This is the east. There's no you can't There's nothing to do You can't put it over here. Here, I'll show you there's a our artist we have that special Beis Hamikdash guy. All he does all day is Beis Hamikdash. So he did one. You're paying first? The yellow the the green. The the neon green. It shows you that is the side. Whatever doesn't have neon green does not have a base. So may love since we're talking about the Lucas Sherman We're talking about the the material. It doesn't need the side. So may love he could you could do the the the the whole process on the in the measure part also. The two we saw in the video when the the first fruit you bring a basket of fruit. It's unbelievable your voice if you think about it. The a person he plants a tree. He works hard the whole year pesticide um sprinkler system uh employees from uh what are they called over there? From where? Thailand. Oh, they and finally finally it pops out the first one. He's all excited. He wants to eat it. No, that that one you're going to give to who? You give to the client. But the client [clears throat] couldn't care less if it's the first one the second one. But the tires is no. What's important to you might not be important to him, but I want you to be master of it and then what what's kosher I want you to give it to him. So Today I have women. If you just read the these words as is, so the coin puts his hands underneath the hands of the owner and he does Nufa. As twice as how could that work? We have a problem. Katzizza. You know what I just got just you all see? What's the what's twice as kosher? You know why you don't know twice as kosher? Because you concentrated on something else. What are you concentrated on? Tell us. Why? What do you care about sponsors? You should be caring about tomorrow now. He put his No, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no. Your hand, your hand on the your hand, not somebody else's. That we learned before. So he says the mail the shot is that the coin puts it underneath. Underneath means underneath the cleat. And the owner holds over here. So that's why it's called under. Under means on he's lower. The coin is lower than the Israel, but they're not touching. Brings here. Then when it comes to the the site up. We bring the old coin. With less Tyva and he actually his hands are touching according to one he talks about it how it works with the site up. I call my sister no it's a horror there. Oh Zach. Oh, now we do sponsors. I did not I come on from 36 sponsors I missed one. Yeah. Which one? Start start from the beginning. Start again. The anonymous one. The Jacobowski? Yeah, he's the sponsor number two page. Which one? The one underneath Jacobowski. It's going to I've no idea. Tell him what to tell him what to do. Oh, it's here? Anonymous anonymous Oh, I did miss this one. Anonymous. You know why? Because Rosenberg is Mr. Anonymous and he doesn't like this. In honor of Rosenberg from you know who because of you know what. And he's anonymous and he knows that Rosenberg likes to be anonymous. But you know who because of you know what. This is a coterie right now in Eilat. Rebbeside, I just got a message on his phone. What is this? This is in Shalavim? This is unbelievable. People from the community, you know, Chicago has a lot of wealthy people. I'll just knock on doors and I didn't know anything about real estate like that and they What are you showing? Maybe I'll get a Anybody here from Chicago? Oh. What's your name? No way! You're the guy from my door? Get over here. Get over here. Get over here. Get over here. Is your brother? Listen to this story. Okay, we're not going to show the whole story, but anyway. A Dark Global, happy clients all year, not just this month. shadchan.com, please write a shidduch today. Zuck the heilige tomorrow. V'lema nami k'dei Rabbi Yehuda. Why are you telling me this goes according to Rabbi Lozer Yaakov? Rabbi Yehuda says the same exact thing. The sign of Rabbi Yehuda omer. By bikurim it says v'hinachti zutnuva means to do tnuva. Now, the the literal translation v'hinachti means to put it down, to put it down on the floor. A toimes zutnuva in a anacha, maybe means to put it down. Shoimer v'yinecha already says v'yinecha, they should put it down. Harei anacha omer. Umadi mikayeiv v'hinachti? So, what is v'hinachti? Zutnuva. They explain in the the the the the Hebrew Shulchan Aruch in the the Hebrew article explains that v'hinachti he learns the word v'hinachti like it's a loshon of tnuva. It's loshon v'yinocham v' asher nocham what's the v'lo einochem Elokim It's a lotion of okay, fine. They go into that. I can pardon him. You can just learn what? Anchiot. Okay. Omer Rava. I can pardon him with the more skasha. More skasha is why does the mission say it goes according to Rebbe Elazar ben Yakov? Guess what? Rebbe Yehuda says the same exact thing. So just say Rebbe Yehuda, why do you pick Rebbe Elazar ben Yakov? Two answers. Omer Rava, oilam pasul kasher kela. If you look at the pasuk v'lo kacha kohen atah miyadecha and that's what Rebbe Elazar ben Yakov learns from. V'einicho comes afterwards. So we'd rather use the words that come first and say it goes according to Rebbe Elazar ben Yakov uses the first words. Rebbe Nachman bar Yitzchak amar, oilam Rebbe Akiva he was a great man. We know says Rashi that Mishnas Rebbe Akiva Naki we always pass it on to Rebbe Elazar ben Yakov. The Tashbetz says that kav v'naki kav is 102. Kuf is 100. Kav beis is two. 102. 102 times in Shas that the halacha is like Rebbe Elazar ben Yakov. The Belzer was very busy yesterday seeing if this Tashbetz is correct. So he found that the Rebbe Elazar ben Yakov is brought down 300 times in Shas. So he started going through all the 300 times. He got stuck eventually but he was getting very close to figuring out that Tashbetz is right that most of the times that it's brought down they're all doubles. He's going through all the doubles to see how many singular halachas Rebbe Elazar ben Yakov says in Shas but he ran out of time. But he's getting No, 300 is a is is real. The the the the the computer said 300 not a I I I I hear what you say. I got it. No. So very good. It's 100 102 is a lot of halachas. Says the Gemara it says in the Mishna b'imurei Shmuel Yakov because of Shmuel Yakov Rebbe Nachman bar Nachman bar Nachman bar Shmuel bar Nachman pointed out in the Mishna that it's masculine, that b'cheirim, that women should not do t'nufah. My comma, what's going on here? It says that women are chiyuvin t'nufah, and then it says v'lo b'cheirim. My comma. Omer Rebbe Yehudah HaNasi comma. Echad nashim v'echad anashim korban t'nun and t'nufah. Their korban requires t'nufah. Ut'nufah atzma, but who does the t'nufah? B'nei Yisrael v'lo b'nei nashim. Women should not do t'nufah. Tana Rabbanan. B'nei Yisrael minifin v'einam minifin. When it says in the Torah B'nei Yisrael, you have to be the child of Yisrael, so you can't be a to do t'nufah. B'nei Yisrael minifin v'ein anashim minifot. So, what do we do with all the other places that says B'nei Yisrael? So, it's not women. What? B'nei Yisrael came out of Mitzrayim and not women? So, each different places have maybe different ribuyim, but there's actually machlokes Rishonim. We spoke about it in the past. Can women tie tzitzis? Can they work in a tzitzis factory and do tzitzis cuz they're not in the B'nei Yisrael? The barrel B'nei Yisrael was on tzitzis, not women. Machlokes Rishonim, what do you not think could or not? Okay. Akol Panim says B'nei Yisrael minifin v'ein anashim minifot. A woman should not do t'nufah. Omer Rebbe Yishmael ben Elisha Kol Yisrael Achim Yisrael korban korban nashim b'smicha. We see that a woman does not do smicha. What is smicha? Here's the new and improved smicha. I called the Byoshi, I said, "Do you have any normal smicha? Not a smicha that the animal goes flying to the ground." He says, "Yeah, that'll take care of you." I didn't see it. And he he gives me this one. Actually, he did. Okay, good. One of the guys here in the in the shiur, he says, "Wow, a Sefardi guy." He says, "The momish reminds me of how my father does birkas kohanim to me." >> [laughter] >> He's like he's a he's a he's a varm Sefardi. He's like a Moroccan. He's like, "Y'varechecha Adonai, you know, it's my neck." M'lo Yisrael Agalim b'nufah. So, maybe No, maybe say that women don't belong to the partial smicha. You say just like smicha, women don't do smicha, so too when it nuva, a woman shouldn't do nuva at all. There shouldn't be nuva at all on her carbon. Like who does smicha the owner? That's why a woman doesn't do it. So even though it's owned by a woman, the coin will take care of it. So hold on, hold on, hold on, hold on. We still have two more minutes. Let's just get to the bottom of the argument. How do I know that they fit into this? Even though usually does mean okay. Anybody that brings a carbon, he's included maybe it's referring to the coin not the person bringing it. We know that's referring to the owner. So what do we do? So we have a coin, we have a owner, what do we do? Next to so we have a combination of the coin and the Israel that do the nuva. Have a wonderful day at a quarter to 9. Merit the sauce of spreading Torah throughout the world. Sponsor a shear today. mdy.sponsor.com or sponsored.mdydaf.com