Daf Yomi Menachos Daf 49 by R' Eli Stefansky

Good morning BOYS AND GIRLS. WE'RE HERE VERY SMALL CAMERA. Because of the order of they don't allow us to be together in places and so if we do it in the basement it could be a big problem. Different people come and then we have to tell people to come to leave. Certain people they leave their phones on and then we have to tell them not to come and so comes up comes a matter We're here in Israel and just keep everybody up to date. There are missiles non-stop. Non-stop, sirens non-stop. We happen to be in the best place in Israel for this kind of situation in the shamash. I don't want to tell the enemy but comparatively speaking we we didn't get it as bad as everybody else. We had a we had a siren at 1:40 in the morning and another siren at 6:30 in the morning and different sirens go off on our phone telling us that there are incoming missiles and we don't get the real siren. So there's you might hear a middle of the year ba ba a very loud noise and that's like a warning to the warning. The great news is I shall that himself was killed and will be the beginning of a new era. Beginning that will take over over there and hopefully I mean has his ways and if he wants it to be that way it will be that way. If he wants it to continue it's going to happen that way. It will happen that way but it's a nice for Israel. and nice that's so close to Purim this time. And one of the things that I heard over and over from every single person that came that came into contact with you say but what's going to be with Yossi? That's the client's house now and you know there's a lot of stuff going on and one of the things that's on our hearts is our higher cover our brother Yossi he's in America with Hassan and this is supposed to be Hassan this week and the guy was here in Israel. And besides the fact that you can't make a house in a right now all halls are shut down and all flights are shut down. So besides the fact even if you wasn't in Israel I don't know what they would make a house with 10 people whatever. So our hearts are with Yossi here who's a forest fire last night the alarm came. I'm doing this or you're doing this? I'll do it okay. The heavens from MDY is that what's in the stream now? And who's the one next to him? I can't see this. Oh him yeah. Client forest bill that's Goldstein and PC and checking out and handler ah the camera. You all good. What is Baltimore satellite that you demand demonstrates tying this ah Yeah. Yeah. So he's doing the hands-on. He's bringing a satellite location is is is being hard as a new thing in satellite you can add to the video to the you stop the screen and you do some hands-on more of it. New first weekly Malki Hollywood satellite you all good sponsored by Michael but that's not in there it's not in their location they have a caravan I don't know what's going on here okay. Dear bellies to landscape show me thank you for the wonderful Purim spreading the kids losing and he says on that 38 we spoke about the color of the strings color you don't you said that the color in the go and showed an image of the plan with the caption C16H10N2O2. I mentioned that it was a genetic code. I wanted to point out that I'm a chemist. It's actually a chemical formula of the dye molecule. The letters represent atoms namely C is carbon. There's 16 carbon atoms in the molecule. H is hydrogen, N is nitrogen, O is oxygen, and there are two oxygen atoms in the molecule. You also sent me the the atom bring you know with the the circles and the molecular view. The complete chemical structure is By the way, I don't know. Okay, fine. Dr. Shimon Am Salem Ish Koach. Jason Cutler I'm about to over who flipped out of my 40s and been learning with you since Sanhedrin bet. Your shearim have made learning accessible, interesting, truly communal. I don't even fully understand every word of concept, but the love the survey course Mazel tov. Gishmak. Something you said last week really stuck with me. About how the film of tefillin 150 years ago wouldn't have been as kosher as those that we use today because the technology now allows for more perfect squares. Think about it in the context of AI improved technology gives us better physical tools like filling chemical analysis of tefillin for misses better and get close to Hashem. Okay. It it it messes with me these kind of things. Think about it in the kind of Most people to the beta to say to them More people learning deeper Torah insights to learn one more than the other in the case study of Hashem giving us the chachma the mentors I said yesterday I'll say it again now because I think it's important. I might have said it only in the Hebrew. No, I said it in the English here. That when it comes to um the the five the five who died that does the the eat your nachos eat your nachos So, I pointed out in Ben Chushan he said he liked it. He wanted to know if I I said it myself. He said he he did a two style to Rozner. He just sent me moments right before sheer. And the reason why I said it because you sit here. I'm not a leader, but I give sheer to a lot of people and during sheer I have to make decisions. Do I have to do I have to say something to somebody that's disturbing? So, it comes in somebody this and you know, it's a dilemma by me. I probably I probably could do it in a nicer way whatever, but sometimes you have to say something. Guy that sits in his house and and has no connection to anybody so, he could grow a lot more. He could He could reach in certain ways. He could reach a lot. He's He's not That was just my my mashava and he says he he agrees with it. In other words, the these five people they weren't leaders. The Yuma [clears throat] wasn't a leader. Uh the Yishai uh the David's brother wasn't a leader. David's father wasn't a leader. Moshe Rabbeinu's father wasn't a leader. They were next to leaders. They They were with leaders, but they weren't leaders cuz a leader always not always, but it's very easy for him to mess up and and do Okay. I just had to say what? >> the latter wrote that to either Schlomo Zalman Auerbach or Yeah. or to uh Rav Nachman told me after that. Rav Nachman said, "I just want to sit in my room and do my thing and I'll have better Maybe that's like no. It's when you go out and you go It's easy to be a tzaddik when you're exactly supposed to give up. No, but I was saying in terms of English enough as well. >> Somebody sent me that Norman Lamm said that ain't tzaddik about it's a sheer. We have to ask the tzaddik. Yeah, it's a tzaddik. Tzaddik about it. You can't just be home. You have to be about it out in the world. That's what it happens. Right. >> [clears throat] >> Say that. What? Yeah. You had to decide there's 50 people on Zoom whether you're going to dive in or see where you're going to have to 50 people away. Even the Israeli sheer. I don't remember. And what what was the What was the called up a rabbi and the psak was that there's people where you should do You should not give the sheer. You should not give the sheer. Again, I Oh, I was in Austria in a in a And I was I don't remember. You have to remind me what it was. >> [snorts] >> No. >> [laughter] >> No, it's something I have this dilemma in my head. Now, I know that afterwards I think about it, I could have said it nicer, I could have used this word, that word, but I say, "Look, this guy might be insulted and he might be even embarrassed but I have I have I have a a certain for the sheer I have to get the prayer out there. And there's 40,000 people listening and now you hear this guy making noise. Sometimes I insult you. It's the same And I hope you You're very you're Okay, from the Listen, you come in here There's a there's a thing. You you can't come in if you're not going to be able to take it. Okay, anyway. Um I had I had a nice analogy recently. A few days ago a little kid was standing was sitting next to me making crazy noises in the middle of sheer. Reading this and and Benny asked him a bunch of times and he's completely ignoring completely ignoring the the thing. And at one point I said something to him and he got super insulted and he went home and it was all this and his father called back that this kid was a a kid that was struggling in school and the whole sheer and now the magic sheer said something The kids are to Mr. Anonymous. A beautiful picture. Yes. Ah. Shwaki. And then he wrote I I would think it's Ari Simon, but it's it's uh it's not his lotion. The ultimate duo, the king of music and the king of the daf. A milk What do you mean by a milk here? From the minute a hot shower You probably think you shkoyach gadol. Beautiful. >> Whoever gave it was Yeah, it's you it's a good shot in in this letter that Tell that guy. You're next. All right. All right. Where am I? Uh Jason Cutler, Bergenfield, New Jersey. Almost finished this thing. Do we have time for another Oh, we're already 30 How many minutes are we tacked into it? Okay, we'll just jump. This is a good email, but um we'll show it tomorrow. You know what? I'm not going to show it tomorrow. You know I always forget, so I'll just say it real quickly. Avrohom Yitzchok Fisher. Dear Rabbi Wallerstein, I want to thank you for inspiring me and I do not have a major connection to the daf this year. However, I do enjoy the weekly Ammi article and the video clips that go around from time to time. Last week I went on vacation with my wife outside of the USA. While I learn every night, I did not bring along a Gemara because he doesn't do the daf. He didn't bring the Gemara, it's normal. On the third day in the afternoon, I felt like I wanted to learn. But how? So I thought to myself, let me try Rabbi Steinsaltz. I was in the middle of Maseches Sanhedrin. I couldn't remember the exact daf, either 37 or 38 or 39, somewhere in that area. I decided to and opted for daf 37. A few minutes in, as I'm watching, you're reading an email from somebody that is connected to the daf and is showing a picture of him learning in Punta Cana. Is that how you pronounce it? You guessed it. I was sitting in my hotel room in Punta Cana. The goose bumps are still in my body as I'm writing this to you a week later. The next day we flew home. On the flight home I thought to myself, let's try to learn daf on the plane. I've never done that before. And let alone learn on a plane. Daf 38, a few minutes in, you're reading an email from a man showing a picture of him learning for the very first time on a plane. It sounds like a novel, but this truly happened to me. Baruch Hashem, I'm continuing the shiur with you for Sanhedrin and then I'm sure Hashem will join the daf yomi. Thanks for being such an inspiration worldwide and bringing us all together. Good Shabbos and a freilichen Purim. Avrohom Yitzchok Fisher. Lema'aseh came in for the He came He came in for the statuses and remained for the daf. Well, daf That's how you say it? How do you say it? He came for the statuses in the army article, but he remains for the daf. We got him. I thought we got him. Oh, we have to do sponsors. This way? The mesechta is sponsored by David Solomon dedicated memory of Avi Myerem Shmuel Boruch ben Chaim Tzvi Dovid a friend of Rochel. Mesechta sponsors Joel Gedalis l'ilui nishmas my father Jack Gedalis. Anonymous as bracha to be got the family foundation l'zecher nishmas Rochel going ben The mesivta ilui. And I'm going to say again, if we do chas v'shalom get a siren in the middle of shuir, we will pause. We'll take a break for 3-4 minutes until the your lighting come out and then we'll continue. So, don't go anywhere. Anonymous for Moshe ben Nisa. Anonymous with complete refuah shleima and a refuah shleima to Leah bas Esther. Yisroel Malki to speak to speak to Malki Kessel. We are so proud of you. Yaakov Mordechai keeps shtieging. More mesechta sponsors. Sandy Gross and family. Canvey Island, UK in honor of Bella who changed the meaning of life. And by Ploni Almoni, Yossi, Mark, and Benny and all the mitzvah and the wife of Chorol. Monthly sponsors. Ari Simon refuah shleima Avi Myerem Boruch ben Miriam. Jamie Azulay refuah shleima Esther bas Luna. Anonymous for the merit of ben Sarah and Rochel bas Sarah blessing in all areas of life. There were many people. I don't know the whole list. Many people are coming in from America for this chasana. People that you don't even know of. Like Tzvi Penzel and all Ari Hershkovitz. Uh of course Mark Ashkenazi and that goes without saying but a lot of people and they're not going to be coming in. Tzvi Spiro. A lot of people. Anonymous for the merit of refuah shleima for all of Klal Yisrael who needs refuah shleima. Sol Fishy Fisher in honor [clears throat] of Moishe who's putting on tefillin. sendit.com helping Yidden daven b'tzibur with Papa Miyanum anywhere worldwide l'ilui nishmas Chaim ben Moshe Solomon. Weekly sponsors. Kaufman and Rod families refuah shleima for Tzvi ben Tikva bas Chaya. Official edition MDY shots for boys at the official edition. The new volume is available by the Irani and Levy families, Perik anonymous. I'm not joking. Volume two is a lot better than volume one. And you can see it in the thickness. It's more dappim and it's significantly thinner. In other words, there's less turning of the page, more concise. It's just a better product, more pictures, more color. We get it's it's it's a it's a work in progress, but we're we're getting better and better as we go on. No, it's unbelievable if you think about it. I don't want to compare it to any other shots, but we have two volumes for the entire Menachot, where others are three, four, whatever it is. It it saves in the in the amount of shelf space and the amount of buying. You don't you can you only have to buy two volumes for this. Okay. The official edition MDY shots for the the daf of today, in memory of my father of blessed memory, Reuven ben Reuven Fisher of blessed memory. 1985. Daily sponsors, Gershon Landau, in memory of my father Avraham ben Elazar of blessed memory, anonymous. Thank you, Hashem. Successful in business. For Schliemann of blessed memory, amen. Anonymous, in memory of Leah bas Dveira. Thank you, Hashem. Surgery went well and easy recovery. #MDYmember. Anonymous, thank you, Hashem, for the successful procedure of Nissan ben Sara. Deutsch family, to celebrate the special birthday of Stuart Deutsch. Shmaryahu ben Tzvi on Yud Alef Adar. Mazel tov. MDY art month. For Schliemann of blessed memory, for Schliemann of blessed memory, Daniel Zev and Ayala Esther. MDY art is what makes our sheer so beautiful and popular. And show, we're able to add this week another person. Let's wish him lots of luck. We really hope that it works well for him. He's able to add to what we already have. Okay. Boys, here we go. We're daf mem tes amud aleph. I don't have a clock. I don't know what it's like. Oh, it's over there. Let's go. Go. Let's leave it over there. We're on holding the vent tes amud aleph, two lines from the top. Tony Rabbah Oh, thank you. Tony Rabbah bar bar Chanah came to Rav. Kifsiyos serous she shochtin lishum elam. If you recall, let's just go to the simple um chart that we had. And I'm only bringing it up because we're familiar with it. But on the right side, we have seven sheep and two rams. Two rams and a bull. The coin goes, grabs the bull, the two bulls uh the two rams. Two rams. And he chaps sorry, he chaps the two shlamim. We're talking about the shlamim. So, let's go back to this picture if we could if we have it even over here. Oh, doesn't doesn't work now. It works with the mouse only. No, I don't have it here. Okay. But you know what we're talking about. We're talking about the sosis. We're talking about the two carbonas that we use on Shavuos. What? Oh. Now, instead of grabbing the two sheep that are year old, he goes ahead and he grabs the two rams on the side. Yeah? It's in there. Okay, good. Kifsiyos serous she shochtin lishum elam. >> He He grabs the two sheep and says to himself that it's alum, that it's the It's the two-year-olds. But it's shua's today. And the the rams are also for the shalom. The rams are for the shalom and the sheep are for the shalom. He grabs the sheep and he says in his mind that it's rams. But the rams are oil. And the sheep are shalom. But he grabbed the right thing. He grabbed the right thing. He did the right thing. This is in his mind he switched it to rams. It's okay. But the owners Who who are the owners in this case? The tzimbor. I saw us to bring two more sheep. This is Rav all of all. No, it's good. Why? You grabbed the right thing. It was on the right day. It was the shalom because shalom needs seven sheep, two rams, two two shalom sheep, and a bull. So you did it for the shalom. Just in your mind it's a two-year-old not a one-year-old. Okay. In your mind it's an oil not a not a shalom. But you did it the shalom. I'm off to let me explain something here. So it's a little interesting how he says it. It's what he means. And there's a It's a if he comes to argue he comes to explain. So let's say he comes to explain. I'm off to explain. He thought that they were rams. He reverses it here. In other words, if he thought that it's that that they're that they're rams and he shucked it for the right thing. They They were sheep, and he shucked it for sheep, but in his mind they were rams. In other words, he's trying to do something bad, but he actually did what was good. He He wanted to shuck it for rams, but they are sheep, and he Yeah? He grabbed sheep, but he's trying to flip it in his mind, but he did the right thing. It's It's No, the sugya, the conversation is whether a you could be oiker something. You could uproot something on purpose or by accident. That's the sugya, really. It's not so much In terms of lave, we don't know if this is lave, cuz a lot I think a lot of it has to do with saying it straight out. Yeah. Seems like Yeah, in general, you're shoinem, but over here Yeah. But from this sugya, for the most part, we say that he says it. A lot of times, they point out he said it. I'll go with that with the rav, because sover alem, he thought He thought in his mind that it was the wrong thing, but he real It really was the right thing. Ushkatim lishum fasim, and he shucked it for fasim, and they were fasim. Shai fasim lishum fasim nishkatu. At the end of the day, he shucked the right thing with the right thing. Avukah sover alem lishum alem, but if he In his mind, he He thought it's a oilah, and he shucked it for oilah, but they were sheep. Yeah? If he made a mistake, if he made a real mistake, not that he tried to flip it on purpose, but he made a real mistake. He thought that they were an oilah, and he shucked it for an oilah, but they happened to be sheep. They happened to be the shlamim. Then loy, why? Aker betal shavya akira. If Had he known Had he known what it what it really was, he wouldn't have done it. He would have slaughtered it for sheep. So, the only reason why he slaughtered it as a oil because he made a mistake. It was a mistake, a real honest mistake. Honest mistake says says Rav Chisda in Rav that it's it's a bad it's a it ruins it. An honest mistake ruins it. Rav Amar Kerabitos Lo Ya'av Akirah. So, now until the Mishnah we're just going to be talking about this concept of a Kerabitos. When you uproot something by mistake, is it a real uprooting or not? Over all of our Mishnah Shemitin, and I have a question from what we just learned, what we're going to learn. Hakoyanim Shepiglu Bamikdash. A lot of us had this question, and I don't know if we ever resolved it, but here's a good answer to it. When a Kayan a Kayan, yeah? When he when he takes a carbon and shechts it for the wrong thing, or for the wrong time, let's say. He does pigul in his mind. He says, "I'm going to eat it for four days." Yeah? What do you call it? You're a Kayan. What if you mess up the Shchita on purpose? You don't like your neighbor. Your neighbor shows up with a with a carbon, and he says, "I want to bring a carbon Todah." And you in your mind you say, "Okay, this is an oilah." You mess him up gishmak. And now afterwards you tell him, "By the way, I messed it up. Sorry, yeah? It was an oilah. You have to go bring another Todah." This is the halacha. He has to bring another Todah. So, you cost him 500 bucks. You got him good for 500 bucks. Do you have to pay or not? But, it's grama. Okay. So, it says over here, Hakoyanim Shepiglu Bamikdash. A Kayan who thought he had the wrong intent during the the Shchita that he's going to eat it after three days, Mezid Chayav. If he did on purpose, you're Chayav. You have to push him pay. Ha Shagivtum, seems like if it was by mistake, patur. But, Tanya Allah, Pigul and Pigul. But, the Pigul doesn't work. By mistake, he did it by mistake. He didn't realize that it's an oilah. He he thought it's an oilah. He really thought it's an oilah. He didn't realize it's a it's a toilet. He hired. Oh, showing them with a lot of people and people it really works. If you don't know what's the case. He did the other he become a he knew it was a and purposely he went and he did a meaning he thought himself I'm going to eat this for two days. What is you have to stick this in it's a little bit of a yeah. I'm saying a little bit of a here under my breath. I said it and I'm going to repeat it because I realized it flew over over the radar. When he when he when he when he says when the more says he thought it's a doesn't just mean he thought it's a man. He thought I'm going to eat it for two days cuz that's part of the people. People means instead of eating it for one day as a I'm going to eat it for two days. Okay? It's a little bit what? Yes. Oh, you mean No, but it's not. It's a who's designated you can't change the designation. If I got a guy comes to you can't change it. How are you going to change it? Too bad. Doesn't matter but it is it's a I'm for two days. I'm pretty sure. But anyways, I'm going to go with and say that he didn't even say he says two days. Yeah, I am. It's nice, no? You have to underline that. It's not it's two days. That's what it means here. It's a code name for two days. I show you again. I show you why do you call it you did it on purpose. You went from a deliberately. So it's amazing. And a lot of become a he thought it's a even though it's a it's a real a guy comes in and has a sign it. Famous Yoshi side Amakhatas. And he says in his mind he thought it was a by mistake. And he thought that it was a when he said it was a You can tell that people are people. You see even by mistake you can make something big or Amakira Betos Amakira. So over here we have a a Raya that uprooting something by mistake is a good uproot. It it works. Only a buyer so comes a buyer and says a married guy thing. He says the other Khazisi. I like this Khaz. I don't know why. Says a buyer no. That's not what happened there. I I don't have a Raya that a Kira Betos Amakira that if you uproot something by mistake it's considered a Kira. No, cuz what happened was he knew it was a Khaz. You come a Khaz and And he deliberately says it's a So what are you saying? Ah, he's amazing? No, he's not amazing. Why? Oh, by the way it's Muta. The reason why it's not amazing cuz he his Shregging is that he thought that this is a lucky okay. Almost what the Rebbi Simon did right now. Rebbi Simon thought also that the a coin could take a Khaz. He didn't really think it, but we would push him a little bit more uh on that gun. You know what I'm saying? The Khaz shows up. He says, "You know what? This guy doesn't need a Khaz. I think he really needs he deserves a Shlomo." Like he thought in his mind that he could he could he could maneuver it. That was the mistake. So so you don't have a Raya whether a Kira Bashregging or not because there's no Shregging here. It was deliberate. So it's not an Kira Bashregging. It was a Kira of amazing. Just it's not considered amazing because he thought that it's Muta. I don't know what I'm Muta. Most of Rebbi Zero. I say that when I was saying over this tomorrow last night and these little alarms are going off and you can literally hear bombs exploding. But a lot of bombs I don't I still don't we I can't figure it out. Maybe Gil could help me out. Sometimes the the explosions last for over a minute. It's the splitting up ones. I know just but I don't know. It's so many so many oh I'll tell you what the shot is. The Iron Dome no no maybe the Iron Dome makes it explode in the high up and they explode high up. Now we're not exploding them they're they're they're bursting in midair. Right. No no you get it before it lands and before it it lets it out and then may Allah it's letting it out up there and you hear for over a minute it's crazy. Crazy. No you heard it also? Does it let how long do you think it lasts for real the bombing boom boom boom boom boom boom 30 seconds like it just seems like forever. So anyways in the middle shear you're hearing these sounds last night you're hearing it. My concentration was like in a different place like and they're they're running to the window because here in Bet Shemesh they saw things exploding and a thing on fire just came right down straight down they landed somewhere. And then they saw it from the window what? We didn't have a siren here but the the the blowing up missiles were here maybe you could show you the editor could show the actual thing that fell here in Bet Shemesh how it looks a ball of fire coming out of the sky straight down. What are you showing me? It's a little yeah yeah. But what is it supposed to do on impact oh it's supposed to explode before impact. Yeah. Most of Rabbi Zeira. Rabbi Shimon Oima. Some people wait to say turning of the daf and some people want to say vaiter. >> [laughter] >> Mussar reserve the first mission in our mesechta. But on base, the Gemara elaborates on it, brings a tasefta that elaborates on it. The what? When you bring a mincha, you do the kmitza. Now, you bring flour. If you're new to to mincha, some people just starting now. The flour and some guy said, people start today. Bring a bowl of flour. You stick your hand in there. You do kmitza. The kind of kmitza goes like this. But he in his mind he thought that it's a different There's different types of minchas, right? We have here a whole whole bunch of minchas. Actually, this picture I think made it into the the Gemara probably. Yeah, minchas machashes Oh, no, no. Why do I need this? You also have beautiful stuff here. Let me show you. Check this out. Let's do this. I almost missed this. This is what? This is minchas machashes. Here we go. Into the bigger pile with a lot of oil. What's this? This is a machmas. No, is it machashes? No, machmas. >> [music] >> It's not a big display of oil. Is it minchas? No, this has oil. I should have really looked what it is. Tells me Oh, mincha blula. Is it mincha blula? And this is a mincha chareiva, meaning it doesn't have any oil. So, when you watch these videos, when you watch a person doing this live, you know what he's making. So, when he when he says the wrong words, doesn't really have an effect on on on what's going on here because I see what he's doing. Whereas by a behema, when when you're shechting, every shechitah is the same. So, you don't know what's going on. We don't know what's going on. You can't see from So, it says that's what the Tosefta says. Even if the client said, "Oh, I'm doing a blula." When he's actually doing a chareva, it's good. It has zero effect. The The owner doesn't even have to bring another mincha. If you're doing a a flatter one and you did it which is a deep fry, which has a lot of oil, softer. You can tell what he's doing. It's a different pot, different everything. You can see that it's a it's a flat one. chareva blula And if a guy says, instead of you bring a mincha a sinner doesn't put any oil in it, and he did it blula, it's saying, "Oh, it has a lot of oil." You see that it has no oil. You can say whatever you want. When it comes to carbon, it's different. It's the same shechitah. Now, we have to know how can I know me? Yeah, yeah, I hear what you say. Let's say he did one. Let's say he knows that it's a machvas. But he did it on purpose. He tried to do it like an akira What is it called the opposite of those? Akira be idea? I don't know what the So what? So what if if So what if you see what he's doing? He decided to uproot it. A lot He thought it really is what is it? It really is a the one, or But he decided in his mind that it's the thick one and he said it's a thick one. The tall is a real mistake, honest mistake. The we know that's a mistake. And it's nothing. It's not a It's not a real doesn't It doesn't change the status of this mincha. How about it? You could see the only reason why it's not a real akira is because everybody could tell. But in general when people can't tell, akira have akira, it would uproot it. Only have a buyer. No, no. What happened was he knew for a fact there was a machvas and he did it on purpose. He said, I know it's a machvas but I want to get my neighbor good. I'm going to call it a machvas. Because I'm going to call it a machvas. So what So So if he knew, so what What do I care if everybody else knows he did it When you do it because of the kavana, you do have the power to to uproot it. So what if everybody knows that he's doing it on purpose? No. And over here they say before machshava means dibur. Machshava possible Sorry, machshava means possible. Machshava. When does it work when you change the the status? When nobody else could tell. Machshava means when it's when it's a blatant lie. I look at a at a at a deep fried at a deep fried thing and I say it's flat. It's a blatant lie. It doesn't work. You cannot uproot it. So that's the end of that. So you know what we have we have a much easier now. Last night when I said should we sing a song, so they all said the whole At this point it's the whole we're sitting regular. You have to understand we killed their their their leader. And all they could do is one one missile every six hours. At meeting. I mean it was the the a lot of missiles. There was My phone was going off like crazy at like 7:00 nonstop. What are they doing? Who knows what they did the Mishkan? Anything hit? We know. By the way, if you know any let me know in the middle share. I want to tell the oilam. They want to know. Did anything hit the whole morning? Garners. Losers. I voice I Every single morning we bring a carbon tamid. Like we You think about it. We do the daf in the morning and the daf in the evening. It's tamid tamid tamid. Seven days a week. The tmidim If if you don't have the tamid, you can bring the carbon musaf on shabbos. Shabbos Rosh Chodesh Yom Tov you bring a carbon musaf. One is not dependent on the other. We continue with the theme of parshat tralos. This unbelievable parsha we had such an onus parsha it's so valid. People thought that the whole minachos is like this. Like we forgot where we came from. >> [laughter] >> We did have like two three weeks of mamish agadata. Who knows? Okay. But sham we're going to get back there. But for now no this is easy stuff. This is mamish agadata. So the carbon tamid doesn't hold back the musaf. The musaf doesn't hold back the the We're talking about things that are not ma'akiv. They don't What's the word? I don't even know anymore. Inhibit. They don't inhibit each other. In other words, if you brought the musaf before the tamid you could still bring the tamid. The kids are One is not ma'akiv the Let's say you have a shabbos Rosh Chodesh. So you only have one. You could bring one without the other. What if the kohanim decided not to bring it for whatever reason? We'll see in the gemara has to be dafka b'shogaig. They didn't bring it in the morning. then you could bring one at night. You just continue by the way you're saying. That's in this case. By the time it you're right. Oh. By the time it, you just continue by the way. This we have to understand. If they didn't deliberately and they didn't bring in the morning, don't bring it in the evening. What does it mean don't bring it in the morning evening? Why not? The answer is those Kohanim, we punish them. They can't bring it in the evening. Other Kohanim should. Like the toys by bike here. Oh, it's have a special special surprise here. Cuz we're a limited sheer. This is I spoke about this a lot in sheer. One of the highlights for me on the Shabbaton was when Rebbe Yoel Gold gave a whole speech about the Ktores. Explained how they I'm just going to go over quickly cuz I said it a number of times, how they this guy dug and dug. I think he said 30 years, didn't find anything. You know what it means to dig for 30 years not to find not to give up. Just keep going going and going and going. After 30 years he found a funny substance and he sent it to a lab in the United States and it came back and he brought the documents that it's the 11 they match everything the ingredients in this 11 spices and it point matches 11 spices of the Ktores. And he was able to get his hands on some of the substance. And I was thinking to myself at the time, wow, imagine if I brought it to sheer and I was able to show the Ktores. And then a second later goes and somebody offered me $250,000 for it and I said no, I turned him down. No. But I want to gift this to Eli Stefansky because he represents Klal Yisrael and then I started crying in Shabbos and I looked around there were a few other people that were crying. It was a It was an emotional moment. It was very The way he did it, the way he said it, he's unbelievable. So, I'm going to give a skhod that you know, let you guys actually touch it. I didn't let anybody but you guys a limited amount. Do not open it up. You just look at it, touch it. And it's a sgulah when you when you have it in your hand, it's a sgulah for parnassah. If you think This is what you have to think. It says in the Sifrei Maggidim, you think the skhus the Kli Yisrael that our forefathers brought in the midbar guaranteed guaranteed the Chida says I'm messing with you. It doesn't say that. >> [laughter] >> It could be. >> [laughter] >> But you were falling for it? Yeah. Yes. Don't don't ruin it. Don't ruin it. Really? So, it's now in Texas? Ah, they don't know where it is. >> [snorts] [sighs and gasps] >> Uh I saw him turning something over there. I saw his fingers turning. >> [laughter] >> Uh that would be unbelievable. If What would I do? What would I have to do if Reuven Schwartz opened it up and spilled it on the floor? What would I do? I can taste and taste something and then I can recreate it. I would It was very tempting to smell that. Uh right. Okay. What? chorus was brought twice a day. If they didn't bring the chorus in the morning, you have to do it in the morning. You should do it. Just cuz you messed up in the morning doesn't mean you should mess up in the evening. The biggest side we always mess up. I'm just thinking about it now. We always mess up. Nothing ever goes exactly. But the idea is to pick yourself up and continue in the evening. Just cuz you messed up. You didn't make it to the showers. You didn't make it to the showers. I'm not talking to everybody. I'm talking to Let's say you didn't make it to the showers. You go to Mincha. Just doesn't it Just How's it go? You fall No, but but but Shaya can, but this particular song he doesn't want to sing. >> [laughter] >> I want to tell you Shaya said a line. I've been thinking about the line. It's a great line. Great line. Shaya, maybe you should say it yourself. You want to say it? He says he he start Shaya started coming to this year. He says if the if the sheer changes my life, I'm going to kill Reb Beli. >> [laughter] >> I thought it was such a good line. It's like he has a This thing actually works. Like the guy says, "I'm going to kill the guy." Point it man, at least the fans key. A nickel Reb Beli. Beyond Shishaya he claimed Why did he die? Cuz he changed the guy's life. Beautiful. Hello Vey. I'm going to have to show you guys the grave of Reb Beli. Says Reb Shimon, "No, if you miss it in the evening, you don't just pick yourself up and go back. You make up what you didn't do in the morning. You do two showers. You do showers in the morning together. Why? And he says an interesting lotion here that the Gemara is going to have to explain for us. This beautiful picture of the mizbeach hazahav how did we come how did we inaugurate it? By putting ketores on it. It's not an inaugural you can't just put a mizbeach in the basically say, oh, it's kodesh. You have to make it kodesh. It becomes Has it become Has the kli become kodesh? By putting By using it. So the mailo all the kelim were like that also. The mizbeach oilo, the famous mizbeach oilo that you you shach all the korbanos on you I mean you macro all the korbanos on it. Elo betomcho shacharis. The The first The first korban of the day which is the tamid. They put the tamid on it. Boop. It became mechunocho. You're able to use it now. It has the kedusha. Belo yosam al shulchan lechem haponeem al shabbos. And the shulchan This button works. Yeah. Oh, look at that. Mamma's gishmak. Did I even push the button? >> [laughter] >> This guy's po- posing here for the Who said it's That's the bezichin. So lechem haponeem you put the the lechem haponeem on shabbos it becomes inaugurated on shabbos. Belo yosam menorah elo beshiva derasha. Yeah. Menorah. No, no, no. The first time that they used the menorah it became inaugurated by putting on all the candles. They inaugurated Very good. How do you inaugurate the chasan shas? By learning one volume. You don't need all. Who just told me a chasan just told me that he asked his shver Who was the chasan I just went to He's going to ask his chauffeur for an ArtScroll Shas. I said it's very expensive, but yes, that's the way to go cuz a regular Shas you're not going to be using. Or the yeah, become a member with the the membership of the the the official edition Shas. So this is this is the question that we're going to be dealing with. By the way, I'm a base is very short. See more shine line to them is my question. We're we're going to have to dig into the question. It's not so positive. If you have one of the one of the other, you only have enough for one for carbon tommid or So the first thing that comes to everybody's mind is you only have enough for tommid, you only have enough for or or for musaf, which one should you do? What's the obvious answer? So that cannot be the question then. So what is the question? Why? Now one minute, I'm going to ask you a question. It's not so positive. As the Shabbas. Maybe the maybe the Shabbas overpowers the tommids. The what? The what? That's not THE ANSWER THOUGH. OH, OH, THAT'S the answer. So we have to say with the the is just What does the do? Let's do it here. The is just going through the steps showing you how we got all the steps. Obviously, we know the answers, right? We know the answer. The is is just as smart as us at least. So they're not just wants to the way they they speak it out instead of saying XYZ, they said it in a lot of but they're saying it well here. Saying it with with the back to either between the if you have both and it's the same day. Why? They'll have a good you see that extra word he sticks in there? When you bring a tamid on Shabbos, it's not just a regular tamid. Has kedusha, it's tamid that has kedusha. So, it's tamid shalom tamid is a tamid plus the kedusha. Elo t'mim d'lo machim musafim d'lo einu. Ah, so this is a beautiful shaila. You have the tamid for Sunday, but you're now on Shabbos. So, what do you bring first? Do you bring the sheep as a musaf for Shabbos that has kedusha, but tomorrow you're not going to have a sheep for for for for Sunday, for the tamid on Sunday. So, it's the obvious question that everybody asks here. A male v'ein lo male. A male v'ein lo male is a good kasha. But, it doesn't apply to this case. T'mim d'lo adif sh'chein tamid. On one hand, you have tamid for Sunday morning. I don't musafim d'lo einu mikudash. Or not, cuz the Sunday tamid doesn't have the kedusha of Shabbos. It's a simple tamid. And today's musaf has special kedusha Shabbos. By the way, there's nothing more kodash than Shabbos, right? There's no Yom Tov, there's no nothing that's is as kodash as Shabbos. Not Yom Kippur, not Rosh Hashanah. Shabbos is the top of the top. Omer leish, he says, t'nisua we learn tamid einu machim musafim einu musafim einu machim Our Mishnah we learn that the tamid doesn't it doesn't it doesn't uh uh hold back the musaf and the musaf doesn't hold back the tamid. Let me say machim einu musafim can be machim one another if it's Shabbos and Rosh Hashanah what's the case? Y'lameidenu hakadim. If you have enough sheep for the musaf and the tamid, and the the question is, could you do the musaf before the tamid? Let's say you did the musaf before the tamid, did you ruin anything? B'tanya min acharei d'lo kodem l'tamid tamid d'lo einu You cannot bring anything before the tamid tamid. The tamid always comes number one in the morning, and it's the last korban out at night. It's the sandwich. You cannot do anything before tamid. Not in the morning you can't do anything after the tamid at night. Well, how do I know? It's for sure possible. Oh, I know with the hey. Omeravah oilah rishonah it's the oilah. That from the pasuk in the base. Which means that we have to do the sponsorships. 30 of the daf for other Adar Global have you clients all year, not just this month. Theshadchan.com, please write a shidduch today. I let everyone down. I let everyone was expecting something better from that. I let everyone down. I do it better than you do it. Wow. I love shidduch the leshli. The problem is you don't have enough animals. You have just enough for one of the other, either tamid or musaf. What comes first? In the yom may, in our mishnah, then if it's the same day, the carbon tamid animals of a my, tamid or kodash tamid. Obviously, we're going to go with the carbon tamid because you do this every single day. And we don't have to talk about this. It's poshit. I say this all the time. When you have a daf, you have a kvius. This kvius is above everything else. It's above people's chasanas. It's above uh 100% before uh shalom zachars and uh and varts and everything else. Everything Every It takes precedence over everything. Everything. And I mean everything. Because todder comes first. We're going to shove it. Ela lav de lema'acha. So, we're talking about no, it's we're worried about tomorrow's tamid and versus today. Today, right now, musaf. Liktani, eima kam zeh zeh. Am lo key adininu. So, this answers the question. When you have a musaf today and a tamid for tomorrow and you only have one animal, what do you do? And the answer is whatever you want. It There's no the the they're equal. Am lo abayeyu, no no right. Lo ilom this lo kavin. You have enough for both. And the question is I want to do the musaf first. With the kakashu lo achshav yidaber koidem. We have an official pasuk that nothing comes before tamid. What do you mean? What's your question michlal? How can you do musaf before the tamid? Mitzvah ba'al mahu. This pasuk is telling you what's the best way to do it. First comes tamid, then comes the musaf. What's the idea to ask on a day-to-day basis for us here in this room? Tamid is Shacharit. Musaf is Musaf. So, we have a shaila. Could you daven Musaf on Shabbos before Shacharit? And the answer is, l'mitzva, it's better to daven Shacharit than Musaf. What if you're Elly Stefansky when he's 19 years old learning in the mirror? As Chatan Masquerade, I used to go to the shtiebel. They walk in there and this guy is davening Musaf. This guy is doing Krias Hatorah. You make a real quick calculation. Okay, I'm going to go here Musaf. They're really almost done with Musaf. Let me run a quick Musaf. Then you go over here. This is the best makara for Krias Hatorah. And at the end, you come around the last thing is Shacharit. Yotzei Yotzei. You know what I'm talking about? You ever done it? Yeah. Used to finish early. No. Caught in the mistake. No, I haven't I am. No, I haven't I haven't done it, but when you have this minyan in front of you, you walk in as a how you're Smartest My mother [laughter] should live. Right? Mention that last night. It was I've never seen a makara like that I remember cuz I was big into Krias Hatorah teaching and whatever the whole thing. This 14-year-old Yishai Ami gets up there. The nicest chiyuv chabura said every word clearly with a speed that I've never seen in my life. Never and never since. Knocked out a whole Krias Hatorah in 10 and a half minutes. You heard everything. The the baruchu took longer than that aliya. And you're like, uh, you you get there at 10:15 or 1:15 or whatever it was. Whatever it was. And your suit is starting in 15 minutes. You got to knock out of Musaf, Shacharit, and Krias Hatorah all in one. You talk about Mincha. If you didn't do Musaf, let's say on Krias Hatorah, and you got to the smart Mincha. Yeah, we had that, so yeah. before Musaf. Yeah. After the same reason. Yeah. >> [snorts] >> Just so you should know that every time you you say something here and here you're making a remnant get up out of his seat. You're you're causing a tear cut. Just use the same clip again. >> [sighs and gasps] >> I don't got to over there buy you. Okay, we said this. Tashma. What's the Tashma? So, I want to tell you here. I checked this up. I checked this up. Avi. Oh, you don't even have the the new Gamara. I want Volume one is still good. Still good. You have it. What does it say by Tashma? I've been here proof as to whether that day is Musaf or the next day is time enough. Beautiful. Now, you tell me what it says by you by Tashma. Come in here, bro. What does it say by Tashma? No, he has Hebrew. But it's not the what? That's it. But what? Right for what? Doesn't say. That's what I asked him to do by us. Cuz a person is learning he gets he gets confused. He doesn't know where he is at right now. At this point, most people I'm sorry, most people are not holding cup what the Tashma is for. Beautiful. I'm happy that that's in our Gamara explains what the Tashma is for. All the Gamaras don't have it for some reason. I'm not sure why. And that's what I said to elaborate and they took this Oh, you want me to elaborate? I said, "No, no, on these little things elaborate." You got what I'm saying? It's five words, but it changes the whole thing. I'm saying this for Norm cuz Norm is is is helping us a a lot with the with the with this uh with the new Gamara. Tashma. This is very gishmak. Every single day you have to have at least six sheep that are checked. We're going to see soon. We have to make sure that these sheep don't have a mum. So, you check them out for how long? For four days. And it says over here a loshon and I want to point out the loshon now so it'll be easier later. Kiday lishabis lishnay. What is kiday lishabis? It should say lishabis lishnay yomim toyim lishnay hashana. I need for shabbos, let's say shabbos falls out on shabbos, which it does usually. And on Sunday you have rosh hashana and on Monday you have rosh hashana. So you have three days in a row, shabbos, rosh hashana, rosh hashana. Or if you want to reverse it, you could have th- uh Thursday, Friday, and then shabbos. Because they're a three-day yom tov, which I need to point out that one of the big reasons that my wife and I heard from many people also I'm not I'm not kidding you when I tell you my wife is so into having yom tov in Eretz Yisrael versus the three-day yom tov in America. It's a trauma for women to have a three-day yom tov and the kids and they don't know what to do and they get bored. All zakh, whatever it is. Okay, you know what I'm talking about. I don't have to explain it. But that's one of the big matters of moving to Eretz Yisrael. I push people to move there to Eretz Yisrael. That's good here. Yeah. So appreciate you being here. Maybe uh well I actually we were we were here during COVID. We we weren't able to make it back to America with COVID. So I had to buy all the stuff. I have I have the oven. I have all the stuff. It is what it is. So >> [clears throat] >> um yeah. So that's why I need six. Two for each day. Two for shabbos, two for the first day of rosh hashana, two for the second day of rosh hashana. Yeah, cuz this year it's a three-day yom tov. Talk about shiyur on a three-day yom tov. I don't want Okay. Can't even So says the gemara eikh idamei? Eilu eilu dislei tmidin umusafin umus- dislei tmid dislei If you have enough korbanos for everything tmid umusafin tzu v'havu Think about it. What? Oh, so says the gemara you you're going to have a total you need 22. How do you have 22? You need seven musaf for each day of rosh hashana. So total of 14. Plus the sixth medium is 20, plus Shabbos two Musafs is 22. You need a total of 22 animals. Well, how is six enough for you? And a lab, the last day. Don't worry, he doesn't have enough. How come you chose six? Cuz we care, we're focusing on the medium. Tamid comes before Musaf. This is good. Well, no, no, no, no, no. Well, I don't know the answer, you have enough for Musaf, you have enough for your Tamid. Cuz only for carbon Tamid do you need to check it. Umani, I have a question for you. And this will this will explain that this this this terret. What if you didn't do the four-day checking? You shechted the carbon Tamid, and you got lucky. It's not a mum. Is this a good carbon Tamid or not? The whole point of checking it for four days is to make sure it doesn't have a mum. You didn't. But it happens many times, you shechted an animal and it doesn't have a mum without checking it. Doesn't have a mum. Good or not good? There are those who say not good. Not good. No. No, no, no. Because it's a chiyuv to do bikur. It's not a it's not a like it's a It's a toyva. Oh, we we make sure you have something good. No. Part of the halacha of the Tamid is you have to check it for days. To see if it has a mum or not, but it's part of it. It's not It's not a It's [clears throat] not a um a practical thing to make sure it doesn't have a mum. It's part of the halacha. >> [cough] >> No. Check it for four days. Yes. Each day the the the Rambam says or the there's different shuls that each day you got to go and make a take a check. You don't look at the last day and the first day. Every day you go and check. It's part of the halakha. That's what I'm trying to explain here. This halakha was said, says the Gemara, only by a tamid. This doesn't apply to a musaf. You have to make sure you have a carbonos that are not about mum you can do check in one day. There's a four-day checking now. That's That's exactly what I'm trying to tell you over here. The lishkas hatlaim arba yamim. Kodash shchita. And it's only for tamid. Do money. Then Ben Bag Bag He. You guys know what they're [clears throat] singing Ben Bag Bag? Yeah, yeah, that's coming. >> [singing] >> I learned I learned that by that song that we were singing. What was it? By uh about Torah. And I said that the last words I never knew what they were. I just made it up. And this also, I'm sure there's many people Yeah. Ben Bag Bag. No, one of the one of the kollel guys left me a urgent message. Please don't sing Ben Bag Bag because it's And that's why I sing it. >> [laughter] >> He's like, "Imagine if you said Rav Chaim Kanievsky, Kanievsky, Reb Chaim Kanievsky. Yeah. So once it's a possuk, you see? This is by a talmid. Tishmeru. Like we learned in the possuk it says you should watch this from Mitzrayim. Hakadosh Baruch Hu tells us Klal Yisrael, Moshe Rabbeinu, this sheep should be the mishmeres. Adar Ba'is so you had to take the sheep four days before. So you see it's a possuk. It's a possuk by by talmid. So it tells you this halacha you have to check these animals for four days. I'm going to reveal the Bavli. Hana shisha. Where did you get six? Shiv'a havu. It's actually seven. I forgot to tell you Yoshe to fix it. How you going to have a sheep on Tuesday morning? You're coming off a three day Yom Tov. Where are you going to find that sheep? How are you going to check it? So you need actually one for this Tuesday morning. The tamei'ah money you have you. So he says oh what about you? Lo yikach the panim shav. So what about Erev Shabbos? The last one right before Shabbos. Where are you going to get that one? Holy cow. So what's the answer to the question? He says yeah. I already took that into account. You already shachted the one Erev Shabbos. Now you need at least six. Later on Bob become a friend of mine and become shiv'a havu. You need at least this one for for Tuesday morning. Here. Yoshe did this. Let me see. Here are the tools I didn't show. Oh, this one. I forgot to show this. Hold on. >> [music] >> Rebbe Lee. What is this traffic jam this morning? Such a bad jam. Oh no. I can't be late. I'm just trying to explain why Musaf came before the coming >> have time for this. NO ONE STOPS HOLLY MUSAF. Went from a Tesla to like a Lamborghini or Ferrari. Hey Corbin Tummad. Have fun in traffic. I'm definitely not waiting for you. Goodbye. Okay. What's not we have here? >> [laughter] >> One minute. Dave, I have to ask you a personal question here. When you're up in the booth by yourself, do you also laugh to yourself? I don't cuz we don't get to see it. So here right over here you can see Lishkas um let me do this. I see it's not on there. Yeah. That little arrow shows where that Do we have a little chamber for the Oops. Lishkas at the lion. >> [clears throat] >> Lishkas at the lion over here. Okay. So you need for Shabbos and the first day of Rosh Hashanah and the second day of Rosh Hashanah. So you he put Shabbos on the other way. He put Shabbos that was Because No. It's the first day, not Sunday. It's not Sunday. Sunday one was [clears throat] No, you had to fix You had to fix it. We forgot to fix it. Oh, here it goes. Here goes a thing jumping in there. Cuz the Gamorah says what are you going to do for Tuesday? What are you going to do for Friday afternoon? Yeah, it's a little bit backwards. It's backwards. >> [clears throat] >> No. Exactly. So now it's messed up. So what is it? It's a very interesting this this this chart right here over here is super interesting. Pay attention to this because it's something we didn't think about. How in the world do you have six animals that were checked for 4 days? So the answer is that every day you add animals. You keep [clears throat] on adding. That that's the difference. You put them in different pens. But in pen, if you see there's a there's a pen all the way to the left that has six. The pen right next to it are animals that were checked for 3 days. And the pen the pen next to that is animals that were checked for two and then pen next to that and you keep on At any given time you have six. The mayor has to go there you have to do it from one year to the other. Yeah, one left There's always one left over. It's So okay. I don't know. When we get there we'll discuss that. Oh. Hello, tell me about my coin. This is the Gemara at the end of the day that the our town is not talking about Rosh Hashanah at all. The town was saying in general you need six days six animals that were checked for 4 days. Well, Mike you daily Shabbos Why does it say Shabbos and Rosh Hashanah? See my to remind you that you remember in a year from now we're going to ask you how many sheep do you need you're not going to know if it's six or eight. You'll remember there's a Shabbos and two day Yom Tov. No, the three day Yom Tov. That's when Ellie Stefanski spoke about his wife saying that she loves living in Eretz Yisrael because it's not a three day Yom Tov. Oh, so you need six animals. They can army and I'll prove it to you the Tani Kidei leShabbos. Doesn't say enough for the Shabbos and Rosh Hashanah. It's Kidei as if Shabbos. Look Tani it should say leShabbos uShnei Yom Tov. For Shabbos and two day No, we're not talking about Shabbos and and Rosh Hashanah. It's not a real thing. It's just a siman shma min od that we're talking about in the middle of the year that you need six. Kilo it's Shabbos and to the Rosh Hashanah of boy side. Have a wonderful day and surus toybus be meheira. Merit the schluss of spreading Torah throughout the world. Sponsor a shear today. mdysponsor.com or sponsor at mdydaf.com.