Daf Yomi Menachos Daf 15 by R' Eli Stefansky

Good morning. Ah, Leu Nishma live from New York. A very snowy New York. Didn't snow quite as much as people anticipated, but I think about a foot where I'm at in different places. A lot of flights canled. Our flight was cancelled. We shall be delayed by a dayem if everything else goes kurro. Uh we have a beautiful video that wraps up our Shabbaton. Let's check it out. [music] The energy, the [music] feeling, the excitement is beyond. This is what's going to bring Mashiach right here. Starting right, it's going to be unbelievable and unforgettable. [music] Here [music] we are at Malt Shabas. We just finished the best Shabas of my life. I have just had the most incredible life-changing Shabas. Whoever wasn't here doesn't understand what it is. Like the >> There's so much as [music] such a beautiful that was made here today. >> Mark your horse. [music] >> Another some events you can't communicate on camera. You have to be it to experience it. It's something that I wish every person would just come, whether [music] you do the DA or you don't, to see a seabboard of K together like this. [music] It's unbelievable. I'm in a different world. I don't know where I am right now. I'm so emotional. [music] Talking with people that you've never met in your life, but it feels like they're your brothers. It's really great. >> Such a shabas. It's incredible to be here. everyone, the family together. This is amazing. Everybody's happy. [music] >> It's beautiful. It's and it's unreal to know that all this comes sitting learning 45 [music] minutes to 60 minutes a day. >> Let's [music] hear the last [laughter] from toare the famous radio personality from Artist. Beautiful. Great job guys. Great job. Shimmy Braun brings the Daft to life and attempts Kamita using the snow in Borart. Yakov Young in Florida stranded in New York due to the snowstorm takes your belly in the DA to 770. The official edition MD by the Iranian Levy families. Peric anonymous in memory of the DA is sponsored by David Salom. Salomon. Uh it's his day today because we just advertised the uh opening of Yeah, I don't know. I don't even know if he caps. This daff is the Monday DAF. He's opening up the Miami location and Nicks together with Nick on Monday today. So I don't know if he decided to coincide that. I don't think so. That's how things work in this world. So he he went to do a mitzvah mitzvah mitzvah. He also was very much involved with the opening of the North Miami Beach location with the renovation. He put in a lot of money to the renovation of the caravan over there, the MDY caravan and location. David the sponsored by David dedicated memory of here we go. MDY Miami Beach, Florida satellite location based on which is Nicks which I learned a lot from Nick. I learned that you could have a withim who don't speak during ding don't speak during kadesh zero talking by nicks base every single day Sunday through Thursday at 7 p.m. at night. Yeah. PM usually means night. Friday, one hour before candle lighting shabas at 10 p.m. one I know on Shabas they throw a wild party so they'll treat the nicely I'm sure sponsors anonymous anonymous for complete refor so proud of you sending family island changed my meaning of life and Only can pay back. You can't get a salary that pays anywhere near the amount of work that these guys do. Simma of and another monthly sponsor. These are all monthly sponsors 10 in a Jamie, an hidden generation anonymous anonymous a verdict that is good and open and revealed way as for everyone in need of anonymous for the merit of success and blessing in all areas of life and growth. for the help with anywhere worldwide daily sponsors big part of the MD extended ben The family heartfelt prayers for speed from here we go by her family. So two of them she should have months [clears throat] we are holding by the Mishna. We have an easier daff than we had yesterday, says the Mishna. I want to remind that we have a product called nothing but the daff nd nothing but the daff. It takes out the sponsorships. It takes out the jokes the muser if you want just daff just tire with the charts. Check that out. It's great for you. We have it in Hebrew. We have it in English. Sure. Lasts about 2530 minutes. Sorry, says the Here we go. Check this out. We're starting off with a piece of art. We know that there's 12, this two rows, there's two durum, each seder, each row contains six. And we also have two spoonfuls of andish of the mice. They walk by, they have a dead mouse on the stretcher, and the dead mouse touches one. What happens to the second row of breads since they weren't touched? Perhaps they're not one of the or a whole row of it. We must burn all the We consider all 12 of them and therefore you should take them out to the place where we burn stuff. There's two places. There's one inside. I'm going to show you the one that's outside. According to we burn it inside because it became inside. The point is there's a pile of stuff that we burn. Ruda holds that if you touch one you touch them all. At the end we're going to say because at the end of the day we cannot divide up the carbon they're all considered one entity one goof one one one one I guess so if you touch one bread all 12 become they say that the row that the the mouse touched that you're right. But the other row not you say no this is all 12 they say no he touched the dead mouse touched the left row the left is the right is so when we're talking about the so we have the go in other words when we we're talking about we're going to be discussing the two breads on that come together with the two schlamim. So over there you have you have the m you have what allows you to eat the bread. Burning the of the upon him allows you to eat the upon him. burning or doing with the blood of the allows you to eat the two breads of soar we have is before the m happened before you did before you were m the frankincense the when it comes to but once you locked it in with the m the it's as you see on the screen whatever you touched is whatever you didn't touch remains. So what would be the then if there's no the is going to take this back but for now says that the is how do we view the tits we know that the tits is a one of the clothing that the wears on his forehead is how we do it but it has powers to remove the concern of that we might have. The question is once you have the SS, can you even eat something that that has an issue with tumor that what? So says Rashi that the accomplishes but you're not allowed to eat the bread. It's a good that's what the tit does that even though there was tum but there was a good in other words the carbon is a good carba but to eat the bread that you cannot do. Why? Because check it out there that says once this food that became there's a carbon that became you're not allowed to eat it. Okay. whole that is good and it makes the carbon good. that sits is cannot accomplish anything and you're not allowed to eat any of the breads even though you're allowed to be m because okay things that go onto the like blood like the go on that's it you're not supposed to put it on this. But if you put it on that sits gives it a ple and it's nevertheless even in that case if one of the two spoons of here one of two spoons became tom here. Check it out. Another case we have the mouse kadisha walk by the person somehow extends his hand and touches one of the spoons. So one is the other not they're both consider and but you continue going on that is why because we don't separate these these items. If you touch one you touch them all. It's as if you touch them all. Nope. The one that's red, the one that's remains. The one that's is another question when it comes to and one of the you have let's say Ruven all of Ruven is Tom. So now somebody from shim is to can he handle the carbon all of Ruven can handle the carbon because if there's a a large the the majority of one sh is it's what about the rest of the so the answer is yes they could all do it into why because when it comes to the herbano of the tib we don't divide them we don't split them up so if one is kosher to do it even so all we cannot break up any of the and ask what does it have to do with regarding the tits like wanted to discuss this has nothing to do with the tits what does it this has nothing to do It says this has just to do with whether or not we we the of we don't split up the we don't split up theatim that's that that's the idea one more question going back to this if one row of kala who how did it happen one row of kala became I was saying before was the left one now it's just the right one okay it doesn't matter they're both considered it's just maybe because I have to start here that's going to be the left. So cute. Boom. Is that both tomate? Send them both to the to the to getburn. And it says because we don't split them up. If you touch one pile, it says if you touched all piles, you divide them up. If it's true or you saying that depend about you should have said he should explain that has to do with no he got this with with tradition from his rebi and his from his that if you you cannot break things up so if what part of the pile one bread becomes to it's as if all the breads became to the We know that if somebody has one or four things occur to him, he crossed the ocean. My father is in the house that I'm at right now and my father and I have a ongoing uh well I only argued with him once about it. I saw they took it seriously. But I'm not a pois or anything, but I just as a pilot, I don't feel comfortable saying go every time I come to only because I understand a little bit better than he does how planes operate, how they work. Um, and yeah, the Gumar says if you cross an ocean, but I don't feel like a plane is crossing the ocean in terms of the waves, in terms of the storms, it it's going around over the ocean. It's not crossing the ocean. So, that was my argument with him. I feel like a commercial plane harbu the the the the chances of an accident on a commercial airline are far far smaller than the chances of getting hurt in a car accident on the way to the airport in a car. And so I don't feel comfortable saying and then I heard that the briskers don't and this one doesn't. Okay, it happens to be that the pilot uh one of the pilots was just on a flight and he he said a beautiful vert because uh there was some turbulence and and this person next to me was getting very nervous and the pilot gets onto the intercom and onto the PA system and makes an announcement and says planes love this kind of turbulence. They live for this. They play in this and it's there's a lot of truth to it. They're designed, I don't know if you know, but that commercial planes are designed to do somersaults. They could do uh, you know, complete uh, what do they call them? Acrobatics. They're designed for that. They could do flips and all that stuff because the wings, it has never happened. And this Nathan Nathan Zooker told me, a pilot from Delta, and I I I said this also before, but I heard it from him. It's never happened that a plane broke up because of turbulence. ever happened that a wing broke that something happened to the plane because of the yeah people inside can get hurt if they don't wear the seat belts but the plane itself is solid anyway alcohol bottom crossing the ocean in the time of the garra in a in a wooden boat you get to other side you say that no question crossing the desert requires a being sick and becoming healthy requires a coming out of a jail requires a go. So our very talented artist Schlommo put all four things together into one video. It's a little long, but it brings out the taido. What happens when you're when you are saved? So you bring a carbon tid one animal. Schlommo went crazy. He brought four because he figured that you have to bring four. I'm not sure that he's right. and a bunch of breads. 40 breads. So, here goes. >> Get them below deck quickly now. One D at a time. One scoop of Earth at a time. Oh, so now he came out of jail and now he's going to cross the desert. So now it's the second thing that he has to give for. Now he's very very sick because he's hot. Can I go to business to get the 40? Yes. Bring a at least one says. So when we have So that's our taida. When a person has a thought of pigle that he's going to eat this taid tomorrow instead of today, you're allowed you're only allowed to eat it today and his thought is to eat it tomorrow. So that automatically does piggle to all the breads. But if the thought was on the breads, then it doesn't transfer that is of pigle to the animal. The bread does not cause to the animal. What's the case? Hecks the thinking in his brain that he's going to eat it outside the allotted time. In other words, tomorrow he's not going to eat it today. He's going to eat it when he's not allowed to eat it tomorrow. Both the animal and the bread become and if you eat from it but if his thought was on the bread he's going to eat the bread tomorrow it's delicious bread and he wants to eat it tomorrow he's going on vacation needs to bring some bread he wasn't thinking about the animal it applies to the bread only the to the app is when you have two two sheep. Oh, let me time out. I don't want to skip that. Very important. As he's shing, he's thinking of doing it in the red clock in the in the place on the animal. So, since he did it on the animal, it transfers. You see how it just transfer jumps from the animal to the bread. But if his thought is that he's going to eat the bread outside the lot of time, so it does not transfer to the animal. Look, there's actually a special invisible shield. The animal is actually laughing at you because he will not become pigle. So now that we have the case of the two breads, if you do pigle on the two sheep, then automatically the two breads become pigle. But if you reverse it and you do the pigle on the bread, it does not cause to the sheep. What's the case? the sheep with the intent to eat them tomorrow. That also applies. It translates to the bread as well. His idea was to do it on the bread. That applies only to the bread and not to the animals. What's the reason that it transfers from the animal to the bread but not from the bread to the animal? Now, maybe because it says in the that that is considered a so you see that the bread is called aid. So if the bread is called aid so if you think about from bread it should transfer from bread to the animal and bread are the same they're both called. So why can't it transfer from bread to animal? It only goes one way. bread is called a taid. So therefore when you think about a taid goes to the bread but you don't call a bread. So therefore if you think about bread it doesn't go to the so how come when it comes to the two sheep it goes from the sheep to the bread but not from the bread of the sheep. your is because bread is called you don't have that when it comes to so says means because of the bread is because of the in other words the is the main thing here the is secondary it's a the and in fact when you the gives to the bread in other words the bread it comes as a I don't know the right word it's on the tip of my tongue it's not second secondary is okay um listenary um okay some English major will send it into me Um like like a that closer. Okay. Whatever. Okay. Great. Next. So therefore says the the bread is because of and the does not is not secondary to the bread. The the bread is secondary to the is the of the two sheep and we need both cases of with the bread and the schlam with the bread. as we're going to see in a second as far as developing when it comes to the you have to do something called you have to lift up the the sheep together with the two breads and you do back forth all to the sides like a lul. Now to describe this, seven and a half years ago, Aiki Kamyansky was bike riding in the hills of the Chamish. You can see in the background I bet you that mountain is full of buildings today and he found an Arab there and he paid the Arab money so that he could demonstrate because the shear is full of visuals >> mountain biking and he I'm here with and uh we're going to try to do Tanufa. This is what Dafomi is all about. Got to do the uh demonstrations. >> We have a Kev here. We have a a and I just happen to have with me and we'll try to get this done. >> Two breads. I think in the mix we should do a little nicer than that. >> Watch your back. >> Okay. Wave it forward. >> That's a heavy sheep. [laughter] >> Sideways. >> It's a little heavy. >> There he is. >> This is for the duffer, guys. Now give him a kiss. >> So that's >> awesome. Excellent. >> And as you saw in the video, thank you. >> Tanufa is done. >> Nufa goes together with the breads. So says the connected so to speak. The breads and the animal are connected because you did together. So I would think that if you do pigle on the bread it should transfer immediately to the to the sheep. Why? Because they are connected. You do together that's why I need both a question. Here we go. As you can see here as he's shifting this animal he'sing the animal and he thinks to himself I am going to eat tomorrow which is outside the allotted time after the time you're not permitted to eat any of the animal or bread. I'm going to eat a half a kazay from the animal and a half a kazay from the bread. Together I have one which is the shear of pigle says I certainly cannot make the animal why we just established that if you do peel 100% on the breads it doesn't transfer to the animal but if you do pigle on the animal it transfer from the breads. So if you do a half a shear from the animal, a half a shear from the bread, of course it's not going to transfer from the bread to the animal. Even if you did a whole shear on the bread, it's not going to transfer to the animal. Of course, it's not going to from it from the bread. The question is, can the bread become pickle like this? Check this out. Can the bread become through a half a z of the meat and half a z of the bread? Can I use a half a zise from an animal in order to make the bread pigle? Now, if I made a hulkise in the bread, of course, it's going to become pigle. But I only have a half and I have from the animal. Can I have a can I have a combination? Can it combine to make? Yes. The bread will come pickle but the animal not I have an interesting what's the which creates pigle in other words take the and you have thoughts that you're going to eat the the animal outside of it it's a lot of time so it creates pigle to the bread it cannot become pigle through the bread. This bread you're trying to make. So you're trying to take a half a z of bread together with the half z of the animal. Of course it shouldn't become pigle. If what's what's the is much stronger than the bread has the power to make the bread pigle yet it itself cannot become pigle through the bread. So the bread which is weak certainly it should not become pigle with a half a shear of the animal does that this doesn't usually work we had a story we know that it's also to plant in a vineyard when there saw It's wheat is we're going to see soon. Couple things. You're not allowed to plant in your vineyard other things. What they're doing right now sewing wheat is comes a guy a random person and decides to utilize the space between the vines for himself and he plants. And we have a concept in you cannot answer something that doesn't belong to you. Now it doesn't always apply but in this case it does. Why? Because it's and it's not just the it's a penalty of Let's just do the sponsor so Mark doesn't have to remind me. Oops. Not this turning of the D by a dark global your one-stop shop for all your financial needs. Isaac Castle in honor of all the daffers in South Florida. anonymous in memory of Moab and Parrot's first yard site of Zen. What didn't they say though? Oh, I didn't say all these sponsored by Joel Family. Okay. Yeah, you're right. I didn't say that. Somebody's paying attention over there. So says the story came from and they said that everything you planted becomes but all the vines are 100% motive say exact just said now the grapes that they cause is they themselves didn't become certainly what you planted these these uh different seeds that you planted They didn't create the grapes. Certainly they themselves shouldn't become why don't bring me right from here. the cannabis I don't know if it means what they call today cannabis something similar from the same family or hemp that's everything else is only this guy that planted where he wasn't supposed to be planting punished him but the guy that owns the vineyard did not penalize him but us why can't you say now interesting story that happened that somebody had a they didn't have a lot of water they were giving out water you know with the the it's called or whatever it was called back then they didn't have water didn't have bread very poor and each person got an aotted amount of water and somebody came by and stuck his hand in somebody's water now you had a question of the water Can he use it for since somebody put his hand in there? So they wanted to say, well, you cannot ask for something that's not yours. The Frank said, no. What if I pour um milk into your into your into your meat? Of course, it becomes when when do you say when you have a like in this case over here. So you cannot be you cannot asser your friend's vineyard with a dabon plant because it's a but anyways he said at the end that he touched the water but the rest of the water is more than it's therefore you're allowed to use it. That's what he said at the end. Now we're going to go really quick because word for word what we just said it's just instead of talking about the we're going to be talking about the two sheep on Same words over somebody the sheep in order to eat a kaz a total half from the sheep and half from the bread certainly you cannot make the sheeple if you had in mind while you're doing a hulk his eyes from bread onto the sheep it doesn't Certainly if it's only half from the bread and half from it, it's not going to work. But the question is, can I use the half from just take this chart and pretend it's it's on? Can I take a half from the sheep and half from the breads and make the breads also? Can I combine the sheep, the meat, the half together with the bread? But here also will say that bread becomes pigle but not the sheep. We should say the same before the sheep who are the ones that do pigle they themselves become pigle. So certainly the bread that that is coming to become pigle and it didn't become pickle certainly shouldn't make the main the strong guy the sheep pickle as we had a story somebody planted in a in a blooming vineyard planted some seeds and over there we said that he gets punished but the owner of the vineyard does not you should say the just said the grapes don't become so the the seedlings in the center they're coming to the grapes certainly they should themselves should not become what's the connection there's only few things in their eyes but other seeds are so the person who planted He did this or he gets punished but the owner of the vineyard doesn't get punished. didn't do anything when it comes to the carbon. So certainly on the sheep of explain it's only because by the sheep of this like he raised lift this that together with the bread. So now we just tie the breasts together with the animal. That's why they're one perhaps. And that's why they're connected. And that's why if you do a I said that's why six times that's why if you think about piggle on the breads maybe it transfers to the sheep because they're one say question like this ask something else if the sheep. Now we're talking about the two sheeps. Okay, these two guys on any sheep to eat from its friend tomorrow. Now what in the world is a friend? We know that I'm sure you have to sh both sheep in order to eat the bread. So each one is a 50% m each one allows you to the bread but only in a 50% capacity. When I say friend, do I mean I'm looking at this guy. The friend I'ming on the right, his friend is on the left. Or perhaps his friend is referring to the bread. Since either I hold that in I can't do pigle on half or I hold you could but it's it's not enough over here I was referring to the bread and becomes pickle We learned one of the sheep in order to eat from itself tomorrow. In other words, the sheep are not connected. And therefore, if I make on one, it doesn't apply to the other. But it says, and says the word friend, and it's referring to guess what? The sheep, not the bread. So that's we're talking about sheep and not bread. What do we see from here? When I say the word friend, I mean the other sheep because if I'm talking about the bread the bread would become says is not a good because maybe over here we're talking about a situation where he actually says not just the word friend but he says friend sheep says the there are two and the where in addition to the actual carbon. You bring a bunch of wine. This is white wine, water. Now, let's talk about the schlamim is easier to understand because you get to eat the actual animal. It's a you get to eat it as we know. It all goes in. So complete once you pour the wine into the vessel so becomes and when I think a bad intent I think while I'ming this that I'm going to eat the schlam in 3 days from now instead of two days I could do pigle this wine in The cup becomes pigle. But if my intent was on the wine, I'm saying this wine should become that doesn't have an effect on the animal. What's the case? I'ming this to eat it tomorrow. Now it could also be referring to the I say I'm going to put the tomorrow who itself let's talk about the itself the animal becomes so too does the wine become but if I say I'm going to put the wine tomorrow I'm going to do it later than I'm allowed to so that actually creates pigle to the actual wine. And if I drink the wine, I'm has no effect on the because you cannot transfer the from the wine to the you could transfer from the to the wines because there's something that has a in order for something to become pigle it has to have a mate that we discussed yesterday. So the all this leftover flour from the kim becomes pigle. Why? Because this small amount of goes on the misb this is the m this is the all for me to eat this. The same thing when it comes to when I sprinkle the blood on the that allows me to eat the at that moment I'm allowed not a moment before. Soim has a matter I can eat a carbon has a matter. The wine also has a matter. When I sprinkle the blood on the then I'm allowed to put the wine on. There's it seems like there's no connection between the carbon animal and the wine. Why? Because I could bring the carbon today and I could bring the wine in 10 days from now, in 20 days from now, in two years from now. There's no limit to when I could bring the wine. So, they're not connected. If they're not connected, I can't I can't make from one to the other. You're right. But in a situation where I do bring the wine today together with the carpet says, but at the last moment I could switch it from animal A to animal B and therefore they're not connected. Once I this animal, then this wine is appointed to this animal. I can't change it to another animal. We're going to do the same exact thing all over again to the bottom of the and then we stop the amount of a of oil. So let's see if we have an updated version. I know that Yoshi wanted to this by the way pouring the wine on his into the Let's see. No, this is wrong. Why is it wrong? Because it's the wrong side of the thumb. It's supposed to be on the nail part. But anyways, just to remind you he's supposed to smear oil on top of the blood and on on his toe and his thumb and on his head on his ear and the rest goes on his head. So now the taught to himself that he's going to use this oil, you know, in another day from now. Now, we'll see that that's not really the case. It's more with with the because the blood of the ash that the brings allows you to bring to to apply the oil on his thumbs on his thumb and on his large toe. What's the connection between the carbon and the oil? The oil can be brought 10 days from now, 100 days from now. I'm referring to oil that comes together that day with you. You can put it and and designated another carbon. Once you then the oil becomes locked in just like the breads of a taid they become locked into that particular taid and therefore you can't change it and therefore they are one if they're one unit one has hash on the other. So if I do piggle on the asham it has an effect on the oil as well. Have a wonderful day. Merit the of spreading Torah throughout the world. Sponsor a shir today. mdysponsor.com or sponsor at mdy.com.