Daf Yomi Menachos Daf 106 by R' Eli Stefansky

Doctor Epstein, let me hear you. Mazel tov. Good morning, Rabbi Weiss. Rabbi Weiss, I had tremendous tremendous mazel tov. My entire haver, Avi Kamiensky, became a zaida for the first time. Mazel tov. Let's sing again. >> And a tremendous tremendous mazel tov to the great grandfather for the first time, Dr. Epstein. And a vada to the uncle, the uncle villain. Zevy Zevy, the father is also part of our daf, believe it or not. Does the daf Is he still doing? Shaya, the uncle. Shaya Shaya all in the corner. Bobby, the guy's to be spoken. The guy's to be spoken. Wow. Flip over the sand the coil to hour of chulin another five days. See him Menachos in Where is this? In Belgium. In Belgium and in Monsey. Kiryas Joel Monsey Kiryas Joel. Reserve the date a seum for Menachos in Staten Island with the bridge, the Verrazano. What else do we have? The Mana Street. And then we have people who sent in a few things. Not that many. Reboise, you could still win your $2,000, $1,000. This guy was awesome in Hebrew. He's in Hebrew. So we put subtitles. But check this out. A 12-year-old kid Yehuda Michali from Rehovot. You like it? You vote for him? You vote for him. He gets He gets high votes. High votes. Reb Yisrael, I like this one. I like this one because it's natural and he's he's reaching out. Doesn't have a lot of >> Okay, I'm just going to make this a flyer, but since Reb Eli is a fancy guy, he asked that we make videos, I'm making a video. The second schooling starting on May 2nd. If you don't know anything about me, I know you guys have already been seeing a lot of my stuff. I'm a big big big fan of MDY. I'm a big fan of daf yomi cycle. And it's been instrumental to my life and it's been and I'm I know it's been instrumental to other people's lives. To put the my my money where my mouth is, I'm raffling off a pair of AirPods Pro for LA members only who sign up before May 2nd. Get your free Gemara, enter into the raffle. You have a high chances of not a lot of people signing up in in in LA. And I want to incentivize more people. And uh the reason why I'm doing this is because I'm a I've been inspired, let's just say, by the lack of turnout to the satellite locations here. So, I'm doubling down on that thought and encouraging people to stay home with the these AirPods Pros. Let's go sign up. I will send the link. Click the link below, and let's go. Sholom Mordechai and MDY next week. Join the MDY booth at this year's Montreal Jewish Expo this Tuesday, April 28th. Thank you MDY's Isaac Blackman for sponsoring the booth. Shkoyach Gadol. And Sholom Goldstein for arranging it. Big simcha mazel tov to the body checking out at Shimon's Vardin, Lakewood. And those guys all went in there for uh the vart. Now, hold on a second. Oy vey voy. Mark, tell Mark Ashkenazi to put it in. Are you with the Mark? Put in Fishel's uh flyer. I for some I thought I put it in myself. He's not on? Maybe I'll send it to you. Hold on. Very, very important to put it in. Um the last one. I'm sending it to you, Gary, and you put it in. What? You have it? Mark's on? Uh okay, he got it. Mark's doing it. Um Phoenix, Arizona, talking about Mark. Phoenix, Arizona has a satellite location. We've moved. Every day from Sunday through Thursday and Motzei Shabbos, 9:10 live. Right now, it's live cuz right now it's 9:10 p.m. in Arizona. So, you can go. Reboisem, one more. If you follow my way of life, I promise I will change your life. If you come to work out with me, it will change your life. If you try my diet, it will change your life. If you buy my online course, it will change your life. Reb boys, I they're all wasting your time. If you want to change your life, join MDY and start Maseches Chulin this week. I promise it will change your life. If you don't believe me, then maybe this will convince you. Maseches Chulin didn't just change my life, it ended my life. That was me. If you learn Maseches Chulin, it will change your life and you can eat me at the seyum. Learning Daf Yomi has changed my life. Start Maseches Chulin, it will change your life, too. This video is almost as good as mine. For better videos, learn Daf Yomi with MDY. This left, this left. We have a lot of We had a lot of All right. Um do we start here or what? Um Reb boys, there's someone you the felder an avreich in coil in Cleveland. He says that uh what? Onu tasem ain't tasem. Here's another one of him learning He uh he always says like this. I wasn't sure if I should send him the picture because it would be a chill MDY when people will see that I was sitting with the peasants, not in not in business class. But as we always says, don't let the perfect be the enemy of the good. Because I was really learning even though I knew the picture was being taken. Um I would like to clarify my flight is the air with Nachman Selzer yesterday. Maybe the woman in the two of them maybe he's referring to your wife. Is that what you're referring to? Ah, that's the clarification. Reb boys, I one more one last thing before we go into the sponsors is that Fischel once again is putting together uh unbelievable thing. If it's your first time doing Daf Yomi and and you go through his group and you're in America, you have to have a American social security, live in America, you speak English. You could join his WhatsApp. You have to put in he has a few very strict rules. You have to you can't miss a day. You have to put in uh a comment every day about what you saw in the daf. Any comment. And he wants you to do hazara also, but you can do it with only nothing but the daf hazara. And you can get a thousand dollars. And one of the sponsors here was not me. It was my son. I couldn't believe it. He didn't tell me Reb Baruch Stevans because he was inspired by Fishel. He finished a few mesechtas because of Fishel, so he's giving back. Yashar koach Reb Baruch. This shiur is dedicated for a fast of Mordechai ben Nissan shlita. The MWI Coffee Corner Kvod HaTzibur Committee Fishel ben Nissan MWI Shas The mesechta by the Iranian Levy families perek anonymous l'ilui nishmas Nachum Tzvi ben Dovid Schiff I think this is the new Let me see. Yeah, that's the new uh the new mesechta sponsor. This perek sponsor is the new mesechta I believe. Uh daf kuf vov Avraham Tikotsky Reb Zev ben Avraham Yehuda in memory of Reb Zev ben Avraham Yehuda. He's the one that the first day the the first day that we moved out of the Beis Medrash on the first day of COVID. That we implemented COVID rules. A very depressing day. We had a packed Beis Medrash over a hundred people throughout Brachas. And went down to zero. I was in my dining room by myself. Pretty down. Like thinking to myself this is going to end the whole thing. We had a great run. And what's going on? Everybody says bo Shabbos bo Menucha. And here we go. Shabbos daf kuf yud yud gimmel whatever it was. Boom. And there arrives a giant box this big. Avraham Tikotsky sent me a beautiful famous um artist uh painting a beautiful painting by my front door. And uh it lifted me and it you know took weeks to get there. And punk that day it arrived it was a beautiful. The mesechta sponsor Solomon dedicated memory of Mordechai small joke you guys my father Jackie Dallas and forever is the Eli. Anonymous we are so proud of you keep family can be you can be my meaning of life plenty of my and all those in the way to my side of the name of MDY kids innovations Yaffa Chaya. Daily sponsors Sprinting Allen Gross in memory of our aunt Toba Esther Bass great aunt Esther Bass motion Levy. Anonymous of Mayor Shalom Ben Aliza who's having surgery today before Slama daily sponsors to the consortium we see we see you we hear you and we appreciate you the alliance. MDY art before Esther I we are holding in the middle of a now I know because it's towards the end of the there are a bunch of people who today is their very first day so have no fear we are in the middle of a Sugya you can even understand this but if not there's always a new Sugya always a new Mishnah and that's how the rolls. We are holding on the top of the three lines down the hall. So what's going on here? We learned that if somebody says he's going to donate a mincha could be one of these five we are not exactly sure which one he meant so he brings them all. It could be it could be that he meant a mixture you always say it can't go according to the says it does go according to says is the one that says it can actually be a mixture of and again. So that's the case, it can't be the says yeah it could be could be yeah. You make it you say I don't know exactly how many of each. It could be maybe I give five challahs five again. Whatever it is, whatever my is, whatever my obligation is that's what I'm giving. The rest is going to be in a over a a gift So the says but how do you do the went into that. Now the says but wait a minute. With every you have to bring oil. What do you do with the leftover oil? And if you don't know what to do with the leftover oil, you can't bring this at all. What's the problem? The again if in fact you did mean half and half the and again. Then the other one is Then the other one would be take the leftover oil, whatever's left over put into the side not to the into the side. And if you again and if he said By the way, I got to tell you before I one of the last night I was rushing to get to this video. It was such an unbelievable video that I'm going to show you soon. It also I don't know if it qualifies for the $2,000 cuz it's from one of our artists. But it's just top-notch. And I'm I'm excited to tell you about it. We're going to get there in like 10 15 minutes. But you'll you let me know if he qualifies. Probably not cuz he's one of the employees. And I'll explain to you that the for the Hebrew the nuances, the way this guy sits on this table every night and he says the he throws at these words to the whole movie. The guys were on the floor. May you guys also. So the I'm getting you we're going to see we're going to get there we're going to get there. 10 minutes. Teaser. Now the problem is if he said if it's all but if it's half and half, put the rest the the leftover oil, put it into the challah. Equilateral kicking number, but if he said I'm bringing only kicking moisture as him and we have a problem here. What do you do? Do you give the leftover to the kind or do you pour it into the batch? You can't just make something up here. You can't just give it to the kind if you have to pour it into the batch. You can't pour it into the batch. You have to give it to the kind. So it's my answer. It goes like Shimon Shimon ben Judah also Russia tables Russia B. So you Shimon ben Judah Shimon Shimon if it goes like him, we have a good answer. What do you do? Moisture and minkey. This is also like we go coming back. What's minkey? So we had a major like this. A different sheet not a Rashi over here says it's like a test. Rashi says a Rashi says a Rashi increases says it's a X. The Rashi says it's a X and Rashi says it's a G. The Rashi says the K. If you go with most of the sheets it's more like a upside down sideways test. It's just missing the little people say you really meant the just it's like a little you know, a test has a little piece on top. Like that top right corner. Okay, the point is that you write some sort of a letter on the challah. So moisture as him and you have them. So this this idea if we hold like you the no matter what even if it's the challah so it goes to the kind even if it's the the the kicking it goes to the kind so at the end of the day we know what to do with the oil that's not a problem. All the way Rashi. So think about it. These are the five of us that what a person says stop. He doesn't explain what. He says I want to bring a mincha. It could be one of these. Now the question is isn't there other aren't there other minchas? One of the one of the minchas that we spoke about yesterday is called minchas the sochem. Minchas the sochem is a mincha that comes together. It's a little confusing. So towards the end of Maseches, let's let's just figure it out. Let's just discuss it. The Nesachim comes with every single Shlamim and every single Olah. Every time you bring a carbon Olah or a carbon Shlamim, you must bring a Minchas Nesachim. It includes wine, it includes oil, and it includes flour. Depending on the size of the animal, so let's say if we're going to go with the smallest animal, a sheep, so you have you have to bring three log of wine, three log of oil, and one one Issaron of flour. Maybe that's what the guy meant. When the By the way, this is important. You could bring a Nesachim all by itself without an animal. I could say, "Oh, I want to bring the Nesachim that I typically bring with the with the bull. I want to bring the which would which requires more wine. I want to bring the the the the basic one, the one that goes with the sheep." So, that would be three log of each. Three log of Yayin, three log of Shemen Revi'is. That's called a Revi'is. Revi'is a Hin. So, it is. But, maybe Hold on. Oh. Okay, we'll have to remind Olam about the Siyum on Maseches Menachos. It's coming up this Thursday night, Rebbi'im. This Thursday night in Bnei Brak. Promising to be a a very very nice event. Yishkoiach to Rebbi Chaim Kaminetsky who donated a very nice sum erev becoming a grandfather. Um there's going to be music. We didn't get a heter. We went to Rebbi Shaya Wosner. He does couldn't find a heter. It's a good heter. I mean, he said there are, but we're not going to do it. There's going to be vocals. A bunch of professional vocalists. There's going to be a special special demonstration that has to do with Maseches Menachos. And some cool stuff. It's going to be It's going to be really nice. Good food, good times. And a live Shiur in Hebrew cuz it's at night, so it's going to be the live Shiur in Hebrew and we Mom is going to do a Siyum. So, okay. Rebbi'im, say Omar Rebbi Akiva Eiger perhaps this is Maybe when he said a mincha he didn't mean the five minchas that we keep on talking about. Maybe he's talking about the mincha of nisachim which you could bring on its own without an animal. As we learned the other day it's not the other minchas because we a person it's not a problem to give an every single day of your life. So now the Gemara in order to answer the question the Gemara is going to basically teach us the difference the five differences that there are between a a mincha the typical five minchas to the nisachim. There are five differences. And when you know those five differences the Gemara is saying The Gemara is arguing that a person is not going to make a mistake between a mincha that has this difference and that. But it teaches us the differences. So then what are the differences? The what? Number one. We learned that these five minchas you can't bring even the you can't even have a single partner. So certainly it can't be from the whole community. Whereas nisachim can be from the whole community. A person is not going to make a mistake. He's not going to say oh I don't remember is a nisachim that I that I that I can't even have a partner or a nisachim that I could do with everybody. He won't make such a mistake. Another one. He doesn't confuse a mincha that comes all by itself like the five minchas. There's a mincha There's a mincha that can come together with an animal. He'll remember quite well that he donated a mincha that usually goes with with with sheep with bulls it doesn't go by itself. Nisachim does not require levinah. So he's not going to make that mistake. In his mind he knows whether it has levinah or not. Basically the Gemara is just telling us in in a side way all the Nafka Minas, a list of five Nafka Minas. How many when you have a five one of these five Minchas, how much oil is required? One log. And the minimum of an Isachim is how many? Three log. I cannot this I could hear. In his mind he knows exactly he knows if he's going to have to schlepp a huge amount of oil to the Mizbeach it's just one little bottle. Minchas N'sachim does not require a K'miza. Why not? Think about it for a second. Why does Minchas N'sachim not require a K'miza? Anybody? What? It comes with? I okay, but what if you bring it by itself? So I don't answer don't answer. People that learn all day and Sunday don't get to answer. You heard him. Reb Boruch what are you going to do over here? I don't know who's worse. Okay. Anyway, very good. Very What did you say? Say it again. Because It all goes on the Mizbeach. What Why do you do a K'miza? K'miza means you take a little bit of flour in your hand and the rest becomes Shirayim and then you can eat the the Kohain gets to eat it. But the entire thing goes on the Mizbeach like a Minchas N'sachim everything. Where does the wine go on the Mizbeach? In the Shitin. The oil and the and the flour goes on the Mizbeach. So there's no there's no no K'miza over there. A person is not going to confuse himself between a Mincha that has a K'miza and a Mincha that doesn't have a K'miza. That's why N'sachim is out of the question. Huh? I hear. I hear. I hear. Good kosher. So the Gamorah Pirasti we learned in the mission of Pirasti Mincha of Sride him. This was wild mamesh. A guy, he's poor like anything. He doesn't have any money. All he has left is a is a bag of flour in his house. His wife is going to make a little, you know, bread for the week. And he's going to bring this one bag of flour to the Rebboni Shel Olam that the Gamorah said is nefesh. It's mamesh his neshama. And because he messed up, he has to bring 1,830 bags of flour cuz he said the wrong thing and he doesn't know. Pirasti Mincha of Sride him, I said I'm going to bring a Mincha of different Sride him and I don't know what I said. Tana Rabbanan Pirasti Mincha of Sride him any day my Pirasti the Yomi Mincha of Shishim Sride him. The Gamorah say, you know what? Oh. Where? Where? Where are you? I said it. I said it. I did. I just skipped the three words? The Gamorah Mikli Echad? It's not we don't we're not gores that. He's gores it over there? Okay. Tana Rabbanan Pirasti Mincha of Mikli Echad that those words okay Mikli Echad. It's very important because it's it's a little bit it's negiah to this Sugya these words. So maybe they put who put it in? Uh the Bach sticks it in. Okay. That the Bach says basically that the whole Sugya is because Rebbe holds that he said I wanted in one kli. If he wouldn't describe that it's in one kli, then you could put it in 60 different kale. Let me put each kli. One Sride him per kli times 60 and that will get rid of all our problems cuz if he said they want to bring a three Sride him Mincha is three kale. If he said 60 here 60 kale. The problem is that he said I want it in one cle." I want it in one cle. So, perhaps it's 61 cle. Perhaps it's 59 in one cle. So, let's do of chive and one of nedava in one cle. You cannot do that. You cannot mix a nedava with a chive in one cle. So, now you're stuck. Now, you need 60 kelim that each one has a different shear. One has one, the next one has two, three, four, etc. all the way up to 60. According to Rebbe I don't know what I said. I read this. I'm going to read it again. He's going to bring a mincha of 60 isronim only once. One 60-year. Why? Because whatever it is, it'll be in the cle. If I said 20, so 20 out of the 60 should be my mincha that I am chive. The rest, the 40, are going to be another mincha called a minchas nedava. Just for fun. Just to bring a nedava to Hashem Baruch Hu. Divrei Rebbe, divrei chacham. Rebbe omer, what does Rebbe say? Yovi mincha shel isronim echad v'shishim. This is unbelievable. You bring a cle that has one isaron. You bring another cle with two, another cle with three, five, 10, 20, up to 60. Total amount shehain elef ushmanem es shishim. How do you do the math? We're going to do it really quick. You take whatever number it is, you do 1 + 2 + 3 + 4 + 5. So, over here we have to 60. You add a one, so 61. You divide it in two, it's 30. You take that division, whatever number you divided, 30, 30 times the number that you have. 30 * 60 = 1800, but there's a one, so it's 1830. 1830. Pirash'ti v'eini yodea im eini pirash'ti. V'eini yodea kama pirash'ti. Oh, what if I don't even know which one of these five it is? Then I have to do everything times five. So according to you bring 60 in bowl times five. So it's five times 60. How much is that? 300. According to Rebbe that it's 1830. But it could be any one of these. 1830 times five is how much? All pilots can answer. Yeah. Well, it's very simple if you do Three times 18 is how much? No. Six times six times 18 is how much? Wrong. Okay. So now you have to bring five each 60 equals 300. Now you have to do five times 1830. I feel like my mind is gone. Hold on a second. A person who says a person who brings a mincha It's a poor person usually. He brings one thing. Over here he's going to have to bring 9,000 150 which is a tremendous amount of money. It's even It's 15 tons of flour. It's a lot. They all actually can't be another. Here we go. It's It's This is the amount of flour if you just want to see. Oh, you talk about it. You know what I'm talking about. >> 1 through 60 Let me see how it looks. Uh each one I got it. Each one has a different amount times five. Give all of it. Okay. Yeah, I feel like the call my mind call my dad call my mind call my mind call my mind call my mind. Okay. The mic is working. So now we have Uh it's coming up guys. It's coming up. It's coming up. I can't wait. We have five Mahalkem. We have five ways to explain the Sugya. Five ways. Again, what's the Machlokes? If a person doesn't know what he what he donated to the Beis Hamikdash and it could be 1 through 60. One is two is 60 is one. So according to the just bring 60. Bring the highest number. And you make a a condition. You make a and you say Oh, no. You can't leave right before the video on the on the high definition screen. And it don't mean. Oh, if I'm already talking about the the high definition screen, so thank you very much to the the person who donated yesterday these two screens. These two screens are up for donation. And if anybody wants to help me out, that screen is also stick of schlock compared to those. I'm going to be using that one meanwhile. Anyway, these three screens are still available for donation. They're $3,000 each. Three three. So you should go out for the sixer and those are available. Okay. Rebbi says you can't just bring 60 and say, "Oh, I'm making a condition that if I if I meant 50, so 50 out of it is and 10 of it is and all of it doesn't work. And we're going to see why it doesn't work. There's five reasons why according to the Rebbe that doesn't work. Are you allowed to bring into the azara mundane things? Why? Because if you have a bowl, you have a bowl of flour and half of it is my mincha, what's the other half? Cannot be a nedava. Why? Cuz they cannot mix in the same bowl those two things. Hold on a second. You can't mix in those two things. You can't mix in the Can't mix into the bowl two different korbanos. Hello, am I? Half of it is my carbon, half of it is just mundane. But you cannot bring mundane into the Beis Hamikdash. You cannot bring chulin into the azara. No, it doesn't. It never does. It can't. Because No, no, no. Rebbe says you can't. You can't make it nine. Why? Because you cannot bring You cannot First of all, you can't mix. Eh, I'll But if you change it to nedava, now you have you have a nedava and chulin in one kli. You can't do that. You can't have a chulin and nedava in one kli. They can't touch each other. They can't They can't be mixed with each other. Sorry. But it's not a nedava. But a nedava and chulin cannot mix. They cannot mix two korbanos. You could mix chulin with the carbon, but the problem is that now you brought chulin apples into the Beis Hamikdash. You're not going to take the chulin and change it into into a carbon. It's not going to change. It is what it is. But it's chulin. And it's in the azara. So now you have simple apples, simple flour in the azara. Rebbe says ossur l'hachnis chulin l'azara. You're not permitted to bring chulin to the azara. V'Rabbanan savri mutar l'hachnis chulin l'azara. You're not The question are you allowed to bring chulin into the azara, yes or no? Rabbosai, in order to explain this just one more time. I'm not going to show you the whole thing. Don't worry about it. This is Itzik Leibowitz. He's the one that inspired me to ask people to send in their there. Yeah. All right, boys. Here we go. All right, boys. I get it. Maseches Chulin by the Shulchan Aruch family. It's I'm very, very excited about this one. It's getting literally getting better and better. The P'shat is getting better and shorter. This is This has um 40 40 daf and it's thin. It tons of pictures. Mammoth good stuff. Most of the daf in This was I was very very into it from day one that you shouldn't have to turn a lot of pages for P'shat. Most of them only have two pages translation, which we worked really hard to do that. Obviously, if it's a very long daf, but the amount of pictures, the amount of It's just getting better and better. By the time Brochus rolls around, every single every single uh daf B'ezras Hashem will have pictures. We're hiring more people for this. I'm excited about this one. Anyway, it's available. Please do not call my brother. My brother said a few people called him up to find out how to get a Gemara. Call me. Call my wife. >> Anyways, this is available on mdysdaf.com. The You just the first on the first page is on top. Order Gemara, you could order there. You should have got all to all the sponsors. Every daf has a sponsor. Every peric has a sponsor. The mesechta has a sponsor. You should go to the official official edition. All right. I mean Meyer. Meyer, not official, yeah. I'm confused with official. Okay. Zulte Gemara. Um Rav Amar. The Kulyanus also has Kulyanus now. So So there's another mahalach here. Machna one is what shailos could I bring Kulyanus to? No, everybody says says Rav or Rav the Kulyanus also has Kulyanus. Everybody agrees you're not allowed to bring Kulyanus to Azara. Rav Amar Rav Chaim Berlin Rav Doniel Another simple machlokes Can you mix in that same bowl the chulin with the chova in the same bowl? Rav Doniel Berlin Rav Doniel Rav Chaim Berlin Rav Amar So that solves all the problem. I can mix the chova and the nedava two different melachos into one bowl. So maximum all you have to bring is 60. Within the 60 I'm going to have part of it is going to be chova. I'm going to I don't know how many. I make it nine. Whatever it is you know you know how many? It's 18. 18. The rest is going to be nedava. Rav Amar Rav Doniel Rav Chaim Berlin Rav Doniel Since it's ossur to mix the chova and nedava, so maybe I have to bring one of every type. Up to 60. 1830. Rav Amar Rav Doniel Rav Chaim Berlin Rav Doniel Rav Chaim Berlin Rav Amar I'll be in shul at 10:00 a.m. You need to to have two kmitzos. Says the Gemara the comments of other comments. Rav Doniel here I'm just doing a stickle I was thinking to myself Wow. Thinking said myself the whole the Nachis went by and I didn't make a live live mincha here. It's crazy. And back in the day I did with all the AI and everything. But for this sugia I thought maybe this will help a little bit. Oh, wow, wow, wow, wow. It broke on the way. So I don't know do you have a bowl over there? Some sort of bowl? Wow, that's not good. Okay. Fine. Let me put this on. Yeah, that's good enough. Perfect. Perfect. Perfect. It's okay. Doesn't matter. For what? That's coming up in a second. That's so much better but I get what you're saying. But why is it there's not a in sheer? Whoever learned this be in? Ask the questions in the coil. That's the way of saying just Okay, here we go. Where's the Oh, that's the bowl? Okay, here we This is the chiver. This is the nedava, my printer. I I apologize the printer is not working so much dark. Here we go. Oh. Oh, we're going to make a mincha. No, we're not going to make a mincha. We can do a kmitsa at most. Scrape for the bowl. Let's see how this works. I don't know this might get all over your gemara. Move it. Oh. Soles. This is uh 60 siren. Let's pretend. Put it over here. 60 siren. So, I go like this. Stick my hand in. Oh my gosh, this is my mish mishmach. I flip my hand over. And this is kimitzah number one. Kimitzah number one, I'm going to put into this bowl right over here. Now, it's possible that not everything in this bowl is is a chova. Maybe I didn't promise to bring 60. Maybe I promised to bring 30. So, I have to take another kimitzah, says the Gemara, kimitzah kimitzah. Another one for the rest of it, which is mincha number two in this bowl, which is in the nadava mincha. So, I stick my hand again, and do it like this. Turn over. I got to make sure I don't have too much on this side with my pinky like this. Uh uh, here this is my This is my kimitzah. Boom. Dump it in there. Great. So, now I have a chova kimitzah over here and a nadava kimitzah over here. Next, says the Gemara, vaha kimitzah min chova and nadava and nadava chova. When I took my kimitzah out, the very first time I went like this and I put it in here, in this bowl, I have a little bit of my nadava. Cuz this whole thing is a little bit nadava, a little bit chova. In my kimitzah, there's a little part of it that is nadava. Problem. Why? Because my kimitzah needs to be 100% perfect. I can't have too much and I can't have too little. A big part of it is not even a kimitzah. It's not even a chova. Says the Gemara, kimitzah min chova and nadava and nadava the totally bad coin. This guy that donated the whatever he donated, he doesn't say what is what. He says, "You know what? Let the coin decide." When the coin takes it out, whatever he takes it out, the first whatever he takes out first, that should go towards because you don't know which part of the flower is which part is in the flower. It's only decided later. Okay, so the coin decides that the first coin that he took is coin. So, that gets rid of that problem. Well, the side and the second one should be in the door. Back to the market. Ask the Gamora, big problem. How do you make How do you put it on the market? Look at the double duration. So, let's check this out. Let's say I take this this ball and I put this on the market. Okay. Duma Oh, the coin market below. How could I go ahead and put this one on the market? I cannot put the second ball on the market. The coin ball. Why? The coin perhaps all 60 in this guy were all what I promised to bring originally. And then what? So, now it comes out that this 60 is missing how much? This much. One coin that I put in here as in the door is missing off the 60. You cannot bring You cannot bring this guy, coin guy, onto the market if some of this is missing. If an animal comes and eats a little bit out of here, the coin is missing. This is coin left over. An animal comes and eats, I cannot put this on the market. Over here is not an animal, you took this this plastic ball and put a coin in here. You're like an animal. You took some of the coin out and put it over here. You have no right to do that. I can't I don't know what to do. Now, I can't put this on the market. I don't you put the cholev on first. Put this on first. That's also a problem. So, what do you do? So, put the this guy on first. Put this guy on first. Says the Gemara, "No, there will be a problem. How do you put this on the mizbeach?" I need to put this on the mizbeach because perhaps there's nedava in this bowl, the big bowl. And the the nedava needs a kemitzah, and the kemitzah I have to put on the mizbeach, but I can't put this on the mizbeach. Why? Dilma kul cholev again, we're going with assumption that perhaps worst case scenario all of the 60 in this silver thing is all part of my carbon. And therefore what? The cholev u'menalshin, and I already put this on the mizbeach. I put this bowl on the mizbeach. Now you it's ossur, it's issur d'oraisa to put anything else on the mizbeach. Let's say I want to be a big tzaddik. I put this kemitzah on the mizbeach, and then 10 minutes later I go into my bowl, I take another kemitzah, put it on the mizbeach. I was over issur d'oraisa. I am giving Hashem more? No. It says in the possuk, Once there was a fire, once the kemitzah went onto the fire, anything in addition to that is issur d'oraisa about the ketores. Perhaps what's in this plastic bowl, the nedava part, is not nedava. Perhaps it's just part of the the carbon, the cholev carbon. And now I'm sacrificing, I'm being makriv a second time when I'm not allowed to. You're only allowed to be makriv once, not twice. That's it. Okay. So, says the Gemara, the mask u'lshu metzim. You know what you do? This nedava you put on the mizbeach and you say, "If there's a nedava mincha in this in the thing, this should be my kemitzah. But if not, I'm turning this into wood. I'm allowed to turn this into firewood. I need a bird. The mizbeach needs fire. It needs fuel. This is fuel. Here, I'll give an example. We did this back in the day. Your first magde of the chova. First you magde of the chova, then the second and the nedava second second either it's a nedava or it's wood. But it has to you have to go according to Ribbi Elazar in that. Here, we had this back in the day just to remind dialo. You can't burn me. korban You're not allowed to burn all of the korban. Oh. If you flip it in your mind to wood, then you're allowed to put it on the mizbeach. Otherwise, you're not allowed to. Okay. So just like we had it in that sugi, we had in this sugi that what you can take you take this flower right over here, this nedava flower, and you say either it's a nedava, it's a condition, either it's a nedava, but if it's not, let it be wood. You're allowed to put it up on the mizbeach. You can't put it as a carbon. You can put it as wood. Oh. Oh, no, I forgot to show that one. Okay, I'm going to show it. Not going You have to close your eyes for that one. This is the coming up one. A dark global specialist in international financial services crime Mildred before Schlaimel E B Marossi fradellato bass Khanna Here, Rebo say how does a person forget? The whole city is the person forgot what Mincha what Mincha he was supposed to bring. Behold, I pledged a Mincha's sailor. Mr. President, what kind of Mincha did you pledge? I don't remember. He forgot which Mincha. Quick, move. Bring all the options. Move aside, sleepy Joe. I'll show you how it's done properly. Thank you for your attention to this matter. All right. Uh what is this? Who am I? What am I? I told you you didn't listen to me. I told you close your eyes. We did you remember the sin of Israel we had? That's right. We're going to remember it. You're right. So in Israel Fine, you're right. He's not worthy. He's not good. That's right. The the rabbonim Oh. For what? The guy you mentioned makes sense. >> Rebbi say, maybe the is different. Not Not If you lot of be my Arab a with another you not everybody holds you allowed to. So if you allowed to so what's the problem? According to Rebbi just bring 60 and say half of it is in the double half of it is not. This is goofa what we just said. The part that's in the double how do I put it on the back? If I put it on the back it's a problem I'm I'm I'm I'm being macro. On the side that it's not in the double I'm being macro something from the original twice after there was already was already on the once you can't do a second it's show me a lesion. So they argue whether you can do this trick of switching it into what or not. The Rebbi okay. I'm going to lay down with my double so what do you tell me that according to Rebbi you allowed to mix the double into one bowl. And Rebbi doesn't hold the Rebbi laser you can't make it into wood. If you allowed you permitted to mix the two so look what I can do. This bowl I put one in this bowl. This bowl I have 60. And then I touch them on the top like this the flowers touch. What did I gain? I'm going to take the from over here one I'm going to take one from here I save all issues. What was the problem? That I took two from here and the second I'm going to put on the back. I didn't take a second one from here. The second one was from a separate bowl. Just what? This second bowl is going to take care of all the in this bowl how? By touching. You allowed to do ear above. You're allowed to mix. So, I'm going to touch here. Touch this. This is the kamitza for all the dubbin here. This is the kamitza for all the chive in here. But, I'm allowed to bring this on the mizbeach because this is not connected to this at all. It's not the second kamitza from here. It's its own original mincha. Huh? Yeah? No, no, but it's different bowls. Different bowls. No, they they touch. The gabbai they touch. It's not They're not It's in a separate It didn't go bowls. It didn't change bowls. Then it's not 61 in here. It's one in here, 60 in here, and they just touch. It's the touching helps to to that it could be potter the kamitza from here on there. I hear what you're asking. Yeah, there's not 60 anymore. Good point. No, but he took out a kamitza. But, okay, whatever. So, I tell you tomorrow all good cashes. Not None of these cashes they had answers for you. Oh, wow. You don't realize this thing. Of course, not. You're learning be young. No. Where? That That I went back. I went back. Oh. So, why did Rebbe not say this? It's a great answer. Rebbe didn't say cuz he holds you can't mix. Let me just pause for a second. Shalom aleichem to some guests. I saw some guests somewhere. Someone was No, it's not you. Okay. There was a guest over there. Shalom aleichem, what's your name? From? Shalom aleichem, welcome. Welcome. Who else? Ah, Rebbe Fried. Hello, Rebbe. Hello, Rebbe. Okay. You want to come for chulent? Wow. Wow, Rebbe Fried. Reb Omar, another pshat. Another mahalach, again, let's go back. Rebbosai, we have a machlokes, this is for Rabbi Berg. If a person got confused and he made a neder he's going to bring a mincha and he has no clue what he said, how many is rain and could be one is rain and could be up to 60 is rain. So, Rabbi says a wild idea, he has to bring 60 kaylim and each one has a different amount. One, two, three, a total of 1830. Why? Why is 60 not enough? Just bring 60 and say, "If I said 60, great, but if I said less than 60, so whatever I said is the chiyuv and all the rest in that kli should be an nedava." So, another pshat, because the machlokes is in Rabbi Eliezer ben Yaakov. The snah, a feel of mincha of shishim misar no shishim lug. We have a machlokes if I'm another machlokes, how much oil is necessary for 60 is rain mincha. Either 60 lugim or one lug. And mamila that answers the question, what's the answer? Because if in this in this bowl right over here there's a mincha chiyuv and a mincha nedava, so according to one man domer you'd need two lug because it's two separate minchas. According to one man domer you need one. We don't know. It's either one mincha or two minchas. Mamila, that's the shaila, how much oil to bring? Do you bring one lug or two lugim? And since I don't know, you can't bring the mincha. You have to do it all, have to go all the way to 1830. If it's a large mincha of 60, all you need is one lug. So, you either need one lug or two lugim. Show men, Rabbanan savri Reb Amnon shishim lug. B'chol chada chada is lug k'shakin. According to Rabbanan in the 60 >> This one I relate to the most. This is like momish easy. What's my like this? Super easy. Everybody's not going to No one here is going to understand Rebbe. The question is if a person says I want to bring one sort of mincha. Can I bring 60? It's dumb. Why not? I want to be large. I said I'm going to bring one bag of flour. I'm going to bring 60. Rebbe says you're not allowed to do that. That's not your nether. Your nether is one. Stick to your nether. Mamala, mamala, I can't bring a 60 bowl. So for every mincha that I that that it's possible I have to make every single possibility. 60 possibilities. That's it. Because of Rebbe Golog and Rebbe Yaki. He didn't make it this offer of Rebbe Yaki cuz they argue about the same exact thing by a by an animal. I I just think it's a it might be a good a good musar haskel for us. If a person accepts upon himself a kabbalah. He says, "You know what? Starting now, starting chulin, I'm going to learn an extra 10 minutes. I'm going to do chazara." So he does it one day, two days, three days. All of a sudden he says, "You know what? 10 minutes is nothing. Let me a half hour." What happens Rebbe Yisrael? He falls and doesn't do anything. Tafasta merubah. If you do have a nether katan, you stick to your nether katan. Don't go. Don't jump to the nether gadol. Stick to it until you really it's really part of you. Part of you, you add another 10 minutes. I think it's human nature, no? Rabbi Berg. Yeah, yeah, that's nothing. 10 push-ups a day, I can do a thousand. They jump too fast and then Zog to you tomorrow. That's good That's what Because maybe God has Rabbi I'm sorry. Yeah. This exact my question the same two the comma and Rabbi this none. God he he donated. He said he's going to bring a small bull. A small one. A thousand pounder. Rabbi God brought a two thousand pounder. Yotza. Rabbi you believe this? You can't bring larger than you than than you were neither. So what's the difference between a mincha and a bull? At the end of the day it doesn't matter. There's one for a 60 there's one for a one. The what goes on this bear is identical in size. I will also buy animals they that we bring on to them is supposed to bring the goods. The the the the the skirt steak. All these things. As large as the animal is that's how much that's how comparatively speaking they going to be larger. 2000 pound animal is a going to be double. That's why you change your nether. You said you're going to bring 100 pounds of on to this bear and you brought 200 pounds. Maybe in that case that you can't do that. Maybe maybe only said it by an animal because you're literally bringing more on to this bear. But when it comes to a mincha maybe maybe he admits it. Should we Should we do the mission? We can do the mission. This is the only time in by you say that there's a before a mission. I looked it up this morning. In the mission obviously there's no mission. The mission is uh an amaranth kind of thing or maybe a bunch of red, I don't know. Simmons, eight of them lying on the table. Sure, these are all part of a lot of it is for the next mission ice. This mission says eight of them. If a person says I want to bring wood to the bear, he has to bring at least two pieces that uh have to do with the bear. Two pieces. The size of the bear. You know, the size that you bring in the morning. And if he says I'm going to bring frankincense have to have Oh, I never did on the vine. Do me something for them in the sack. Doesn't matter without a thing. You make a block on this stuff here. Oh. Oh, I love this little vine. Hold on. Putting it back. Say to him the vine If a person donates a vine, he means one to meet the light this. Says the mission commission that are in fact five different communities when it comes to the vine. I mean a lot of vine when a person says I'm accepting by myself the vine. He shouldn't give less than one to meet the I'm not the man and any man the five men that we saw the colors are a key king. You all have a man the vine. It should have one to meet the vine. I mean if you take this the vine and you mark it in your house higher. Same thing it would be if you take this to meet you put on the bear for for the not the right reason. What's the two of you guys like? Take a look at this to remind them. I was saying myself that before we learned we weren't all very familiar with the show on. And the bazichin if I if I said bazichin to somebody yes he shiva guy what's bazichin it's bazichin bazichin what's bazichin? It's the two spoons and in each spoon there's one kimetza worth of levaina. Shlaik matan how do I zov a person says I'm going to donate gold like if it's madina zov it shouldn't be less than the minimum small coin of zov. Kasef if he says silver like if it's madina kasef it should be one dinar of kasef. The choshesh do not bring the smallest coin of copper that's not proper. Like if it's mimol kasef. If you rush to bring it to him a person says I don't know what I uh specified you maybe this is a beautiful. You maybe at shiyur maloy at shiyur maloy likach nishkavan keep on giving. And then when it comes to 100,000 2,000 5,000 no that can't be that much. There's a guy real quickly in yeshiva he's he's selling cake and bachum the he sold cakes but when he came he said you know what you could take it on every time he came to give the the cake out you could take it and pay me later. So bachum eventually like when they wanted to do chuva like before they got married after they got married they got a little chosson money they would come to him and say listen I don't know how many cakes I I ate I don't know you know yeah take a 1,000 shekel. So he'd say no I'm not moichel. You want me to be moichel I'm not moichel. What do you mean I'm not moichel? So you had you had to write it down. It's it's your problem. So how much should I pay? Pay until you feel like you paid me like that that's enough. Don't give me this 1,000 shekel stick and try to try to get all those cakes for free. You buy you take cake write it down. Rebbi say have a wonderful day. Merit the zechus of spreading Torah throughout the world. Sponsor a shiur today. mdy.sponsor.com or [email protected]