Daf Yomi Kesubos Daf 93 by R’ Eli Stefansky

proud father checking my son's status here goes the status the status that's the sun status and then I got it from his son himself him and his commercial just because it's a breaking Shiva doesn't mean break from Torah it's about the way welcome back Avi well you know Michael uh Michael Harbor's flight no gosh you know where were you when I was younger when I was flying around I needed another from Pilot buddy I didn't have it come join me I'm done I'm done I think I'm done for now you know they causing many people because to have a consistent daily learning through businessman this is a big one is my name or otherwise wouldn't have touched the safer think of everything you're doing his with no I'm fixed dear belly thank you for a thousand plus days of adopting this bucker did a thousand plus death of gimbara please give an annual visit to fix a straw game located at 72nd Avenue and Main Street in Kew Garden Hills Queens no I'm did not make him no no I don't care it's all miracles looking forward to many more in the future with appreciation Joseph kenningsburg Washington Heights New York since the beginning of brochus I see a little bit of a problem with that s rig no one likes to send yeah whatever okay I would like to take this I'm kidding it's a perfect day I would like to take this moment and thank you for all this extra time I found in my day on the plane waiting for the doctor waiting for a family member to carve Rosh Hashanah you keep her doing selling Alias look notice he doesn't say he learns there because there's a shot no no no only during Elias that's a big one lunch break driving before kidish after Abdullah unbelievable you taught us that every minute counts and there is always time to learn and make your day so much more meaningful wishing you much still living the multi Shabbos here we attended all right checking out wow you guys over here take it for granted make fun Zach and he's living that one chair is here for David dimbert watching motion keeper about the not so much responsive but how about making some except the stickers like Boy Boy Scout merit badges what did I say no not Scott Boy Scout with the mdy logo imagine cars in Muncie with 40 plus mdy stickers all over the back of the car like it I like it anybody with any good idea let me know I was thinking we should do I saw this is stolen idea but you have like the whole shots and as you finish it you get like a peg you get something to put in you did this and stuff and this and stuff you know you keep count put on the fridge or something the coil was sponsored by no one huh foreign round of treatment yesterday is the sponsor of the month second spans of the month before foreign White Plains New York because I haven't sponsored in a while you hear that Keith Reich why please by the way Donnie you're done with the part you know you're not doing slime Mick right now right there's only 40. that's what I'm saying so you should be paying attention now you got to be paying attention he's right White Plains New York because I haven't sponsored in a while stop I should be sorry to always be able to give generously that's somebody else I should be sorry to always be able to give generously to always be able to give and okay reboise some more names small M Horowitz 18 it's called spiveback huh Canadian dollars oh shmuel I'm Horowitz 18 Canadian dollars it sucks 5 18 Canadian dollars Eleanor benowitz 26 Canadian dollars Benji Vista peister 36 Canadian dollars is here no like him yassi Miller 36 Canadian dollars Stevens over in 18 Canadian dollars and Elvis Elvis is in the house Ginsburg 36 checkout Mordecai Goldberg 36 dollarserman 36 iron Greenspan ten dollars Deborah Zuckerberg Zuckerberg broad Zucker broad 101 dollars behold Selma of 36 dollars made a test of 36 you shy mask was ten back of solar ten Michael Strauss 10. Jonathan stefanski 410 Bush Adventure 10. civil christberg 36 Stephen Stern 200. by the way Jonathan stefanski did not give 410 he's just talking now so I wanted to make sure he's listening but he is sponsoring breakfast in mysoka and we're gonna hit him up big time 4010. Elliott Mattingly ten Joel krimski 10 Martin Hyman 10 Dobby thing 10 Harold Herbst 10 Daniel Rosenberg 10. we're almost done with the list Stephen manten stalbert 52 Avi factor is not in the house so we can just go forever he's not screaming he's the only guy I don't mind is like 36. okay I'm stopping I know I know about it I don't know if he wants he's going to be back tomorrow right after he's gonna be back here he went for I'm very proud to know him they needed a big Crescent and they called him up and he said okay I'm doing it even though it's tremendous tremendous he's going he's coming right back they needed him nobody else wanted to do it besides him okay okay gimmel by the mishnah we did sponsors already where's the mishna guy what's the mission sponsor oh shh guys guys we gotta remove a share here we're not in Middle shots or anything we have a sheer okay sponsor emotions of course for limited could chill down a little bit it'll be very good Tony those like or Chavez I get it listen to this mishnah and tell me what you think about this mishnah is there anything that you can come up with just learning this mission oh my boy say Here We Go we have what's going on here yeah yeah now we know he's married to three women we have dushami lady all the way to the right Rojo what is going on with the screen I don't know what's going on that's you my Towner and we have the burqa lady now this is not going to change throughout the whole mission the first woman he married he only gave her a hundred in herksuba the second marriage woman he gave her 200 and the third woman he gave her 300. so these are the soup is on top is the number 100 20 300 that's not going to change the whole mission what's going to change is how much he left over in assets this is the guy we saw him selling destroy again and this is what happens to him when he doesn't do the Daft that's a show I could have picked anybody I decided to pick him stop I could have picked a guy that doesn't even exist I like doing it let's do it again just just for fun here's no I mean ruvane fine now if there's a super he left over a hundred a hundred that's only left over so what do we do divide it perfectly evenly each person gets a third 33.3 percent let's call it why because the person that that has a soup of a hundred she has the least of everybody she has a full claim on the hundred and so does everybody else so they have equal claims here it's not proportionate so she has a 300 super the one that has a hundred has a full claim to the hundredth and therefore she's no worse than anybody else and she gets equal to everybody else 33 percent no tell us uh sorry let me show you know one has a hundred other 200 300 says Rashi and all these subas were written in the same day because if they were in the same day that's the next mission that says it's obvious whoever's first comes first if she's a hundred and she was first just because he married somebody else two years later doesn't mean she should lose out on 100 she gets the 400th they're all written one day this guy is a real sugar now he got married to three women in one day and he also tried to save in the hospital he's already getting back so anyway let's just knock it out at one time okay there's only one Mana so since this is she Bud on that one mother for each and every woman so now you divide it equally if there's 200 here we go 200 now let's think about this for a second if this 200 what should be the the what what what should really be that Allah so from what I did is this is going to be consistent throughout uh it says 100 and 100 that's from the 200. on top says subba now you take that soup of 200 and you divide into two pieces a hundred on the right a hundred on the left the 100 on the right everybody should have equal claim to including the one the lady all the way to the right ruffle with the chicken coming out of that surfing bag the whole thing that lady get used to these because we're going to need it and sucker oh so the lady on the right she's claiming a hundred she should divide the one part of the Suva the hundred of the xuva in three pieces with all her sorrows right her her uh co-wives the 100 that's left over she has zero claim to she has nothing to do with the hundreds she could only claim as much as Eric super says which is a hundred welcome Levy what's your first name Michael Michael leave you from greeting great night I'm not related to the famous Joey lady okay spell differently so we only have 100 left 100 left you split that with the blue and the green lady the five Town lady and the Burke lady that's the blue and the green so it comes out that each woman the the two women that have a a large Cuba they should get how much 83.3 33 plus 50 83.3 but that's not what the mission says what does the mission say the mission says that the one that claims the hundreds you should get 50. and the other two divide the 50 that's left over into two to 25 and 25. the hundred on the left that the the woman ruffle has no claim to the chicken lady doesn't have a claim to that they'll divide evenly 50 50. so the two women on the left that have a large Suba each one gets 75. and the lady with 100 gets 50. now we have to understand that so the gemara says the truth is on a typical case you get this is how it's going to be in a regular case is how it's going it's a very interesting case what happened there's a special kiddish case not to be so concerned with it I have a question for the Islam should really start off the share with it for those who don't go into the but I have a question what happens that's why I'm asking the question a couple gets married many times most of the time A lot of times one of the two is going to bring more money to the table when they buy an apartment usually it's the girl I have a daughter you you pay you have to pay off when you have a girl so let's say there's a million dollar apartment stop I'm asking a real child a million dollar apartment the girl brings in nine hundred thousand dollars and the guy is a nice guy brings in a hundred thousand dollars the they live here in betchamesh apartment goes up by a million dollars now it's worth two million dollars Unfortunately they get divorced what happens to the million dollar profit does the girl who brought in 90 of the apartment she should get 90 of the profits or not no ever no everybody says no why not she brought in 90 of the life she wouldn't be able to buy in the first place it's no different it's what it's an investment in one thing I could I could quantify this investment I put in 90 investment let's say they won't stop she bought 90 shares of Coca-Cola and he bought 10 shares of Coca they're gonna split everything equally afterwards so you guys are right but that's it's from this Mission over here okay so let's see right there says but what if the tsubo was 200 Shimano the one who brought in a hundred let's go to the Chart the one rock all the way to the right who brought in 100 you see mati she gets 50. we're already in a different song yeah we go about you can't talk it's a military you can't talk 300. each coin golden coin is 25 so 3 times 25 is 75 as you see in the chart the blue gets 50 plus 25 is 75 the green gets 50 plus 25 is 75. the two larger supers get 75 the and that's 150 75 of 75 is 150 and you have 50 left over that goes to the Lady in Red was 300 some money only tells commission okay That Remains the Same the lady who has 100 subah she gets 50 just like let's go to the case before she also got 15 you see 50. now she gets 50. the other 50 would divide with only I think I was gonna have to explain this is not a typical case this is a special kiddish case she divides a 50 with the the lady in the middle let's call her blue the five Towner so the the lady that gets a 200 super she gets a full 100 which shows off six coins of 25 which equals 150. so the the lady the the burka lady she gets you see a hundred plus fifty because let's think about this the lady in the center doesn't have a claim at all against the 300 portion of the tsuba herk sub is only 200 so her claim her shibud is only 200. so the third the 300 the extra 100 at the end is 100 the berkeleys the homophilicus is in the centerpiece so they'll fight over the center they do Yahoo on the milpies the first piece there's no argument the the already divided 50 50. so many law the lady that claims 200. so let's start from the beginning the later that claims 100 gets 50. the lady that claims 200 gets a hundred and the lady that plays 300 gets 150 now the kiss two people slicer three people go into a partnership now this is different than what we just said there is some sort of division but different than what the tsuba is proportionate whatever I put into a business deal that's a much profit I'm gonna share if I'm a one-third of the business deal I get one third of the profit fifty percent fifty percent it goes that we understand it's not like a marriage I want to point out this is something I don't understand that's what I was on the phone coming in here with Rabbi Mendy Newman very very close to Maggie cheer here in town he sent this to me yesterday a number of people sent it to me and told me about this this is uh economics this person Robert uman he won a Nobel Prize so he's not a he's not a jokester you want a Nobel prize in economics and he proves from our mishnah the three cases has a 12-page thing I went to panovic I try to read it it was there's like uh you know he goes through all the cases and he says that to to come up with what the mission came up with took two thousand years for mathematicians to figure out and he proves it and it has a whole thing he even says it's physical you can do it physically you can figure out the mission of physically you have to go to a super math and basically take the the two n numbers and you divide those in it's a bunch of little fights going on a whole Toyota 12 Pages you're welcome to read it I have no idea what it says here just so you should know I'm just saying he proved from the very improving mishna that a certain Theory and he's very happy with how the guitar the mission came out of mascara okay what yeah yeah he did Smith okay the lady who gets who has a soup of 100 she takes 50. that's the gemara that doesn't make any sense if you look at the chart why should she get 50. she should get 33 she is fighting a three-way fight over the hundred so divide the hundred in three ways what happened why is she deserving a 50 of the hundred she has 33.3 percent what happened is the center lady the the French maker from the five towns she said you know what you're never here you only have 100xuba I feel bad for you I'm not gonna I'm not gonna sue you mean you have nothing no no fight I'm gonna take it up with the 300er so therefore the hundred comes along the Hendrick Suba the Lady in Red she said she's not not fighting with the 200 so she gets 50 percent the fight between the burger lady and her okay so they'll divide that says the gamara uh we're gonna we're gonna address that problem also in a second uh I wish if that's the case she said I have nothing to do with you hey be safe we said okay and how do you split this up who goes uh should we go back here the each one of the hierarch supers get 75 75 50 plus 25 50 75 Tama law the 300er should tell the 200 or hosaki snapshot what are you talking about you don't deserve anything it should be like this you said to the lady to Rocco the lady in red with the red super 100 I have nothing to do with you I'm not going to go after you okay so you took yourself out of the hundred you took yourself out of the picture guess what let me green step in and take the rest of it let me take 50. in other words she's telling her you should remain with 50 because you took yourself out of it you want to fight with me on the second hundred okay let's fight I get 50 you get 50. but that's it why do you deserve anything from the first hundred let me step in there and take that first like you yourself said look at my status we're talking about okay so she said I'm gonna be a nice lady I have nothing to do with the first hundred is that what happened says no I didn't take myself out of the first hundred I'm not gonna fight with with you Mrs red Rojo I'm not gonna fight with you but I still have a claim to the first hundred huh oh tell you something it's good that's good good how are you some solutions now let's go to the next case you have 300. so Messiah the one who gets the one who has excluded for 200 Mana she gets a full hundred 50 plus 50. 50 from the first hundred fifty from the second hundred and nothing from the third hundred so she's left the blue gets 100. she should get 75 why see if we have it here oh 75 why because she has zero from the from the last hundred right she has no claim from the third 300. she's only her super says 200 she can't claim against 300. so she has nothing to do with the last hundred she has nothing to do with the first 50. of the red super yeah all the way to the right the first 50 she says anything I'm not gonna fight you no so so what's her fight her fight is with the second 50 of the first hundred right you have the first hundred on the right the red part she was Mojo Michael the second part she's gonna fight with the with the with the burger lady so she fights with her she's gonna get 50 of 50 which is 25. and she's also fighting about the hundred in the center she's gonna get 50 of that which is 50. 50 plus 25 and 75. why do you say that she gets a hundred she shouldn't get 100 she should get 75. other small because it's another Michaela going on here the third lady the burger lady is saying to the second lady because the burka lady removed herself completely from the first hundred you removed herself completely from the first hundred now you just have the red and the blue fighting over the first hundredth and we split it down the middle 50 50. then the blue and the green fight over the second hundred so we split that down the middle so what does the the blue get at the end the five counter she gets a hundred that's how she gets 100 because so what's going on is very interesting if there's no Michaela going on like a regular normal case 2020 2022 what year are we in tough champagne gimmel thank you I thought we're in here ready usually nobody's my home I mean we're not talking about something so then each the the two ladies the 200 and 300 we wouldn't be doing this there's no Michaela going on that we would split the first hundred into three and my Melo to get 83.3 and 183.3 whatever okay foreign let's see if we have it here oh what happened was Chartwell those two times that the ladies grabbed stuff right she says we're talking about Metallica an interesting case super Metallica okay fight the husband set aside cash flow similar like I guess they do that today also be cash there's 75 that the women grab 75 they all grabbed so if they all grab it and they all have equal claim to the 75 to 75 because the the minimum Super Bowl there is a hundred so she for sure has a claim against the 75. so you divide the 75 into three pieces each one gets 25. okay now now we have 125 left we're talking about super of 200. so now the last from the 75 that is here you divide that again okay so let's go like this there's two grabbings 75 split that three great guess what happens here because there's two grabbings and it was only 75 it's a very cool case in 75 the Martin said they grabbed 100 the grab 75 why because now all three players are still in the game we didn't get rid of the Rojo lady she's still there you didn't satisfy her because if there was a a claim against the hundred and you gave her whatever you gave her 33 of that she's gone she's out of the story but you only gave her a third of 75. so she says wait a minute I still deserve money she comes back she comes back for 7 . no okay fine okay so that's right okay right she comes back for 25. so she's coming back and she's having a claim against the next assembly now the cop 125 they have another 125 she's coming back pay me up 75 25. so we split it up we give her 25 and giving woman 25. what do you have left from that now 50. so the 50 split in half so she's not part of it she didn't know she doesn't have a claim on the last 50. because she only has a claim for no she only has a 25 claim she has a 25 claim and and therefore you have to take 75 and give her 25 and give each one 25. if you're going to give her 25 to give each 125 I have to be fair no she has a claim on 75. on the next 75 she has a claim I hear what you say I hear I hear we kind of use what you're saying you're smart and a little bit what would happen if she grabbed if they all grab 200 let's say you wouldn't have this problem right then we would then that's the first case okay fine um safer there's a little bit more interesting mistakes and again there's again two grabbings again 75 and 225. two grabbings so from the 75 we give her 25. again we do another 75 we take the 75 we give her 25. now you're left with the second lady only has a claim now on a hundred because in the beginning when we did 75 and she got 25 her claim was what on 175. what when we get take the second lady her claim is 200 but we already gave her all the way in the beginning we gave her 25. so her new claim is what 175. so now now we're using a Jonathan to say I'm not exactly sure over here that we we take the 75 and with that 75 we kind of get rid of her get rid of 75 of herxuba because we're taking 75 and dividing in three ways and now our claim only remains a hundred that's what you were saying before now our claim remains a hundred so for a hundred we divide 100 in half 50 50. and now we're only left with 50 total and the the last 50 the the burger lady gets yes we do that again oh that's what I I'm not 100 sure why is the 75 the second 75 treated differently than the first 75 I don't know I don't know but in the beginning because the first 75 she gets 25 and they say her claim is 175 I'm missing a little piece here I know no no the way the way I understand it is the first 75 you split three ways 25. what does the second lady have left yeah Jonathan stay with me for a second the first 75 first 75 and then we have a second 75 because the first lady's claiming against it yeah the first lady is claiming her 25. she's again so we we split that 75 and that 75 the second time gets rid of 75 from the second Lady and now her claim is only a hundred and I can claim a hundred we split that in half and mamela look at all the blues 25 plus 25 plus 50 equals 100. look at all the greens 25 plus 25 plus 50 is 100. plus 50 is 150. then you take 175 yeah yeah you have 175 now what 175 and and who's going against 175 all three you have 75 right totals okay 225 yeah and then that 175 . you take off you take you take off 25 25. so now you so that 75 comes off to her 175. that 75 comes off for 175. and now you bring her down to 100. but you didn't do that in the first 75. no you said she has a claim for 175. that means he only took off 25 from her why why the first time you only take 25 over a claim and the second time you use the whole 75 take it over claim I'm not sure about that piece what now a new claim is 100. yes no but her claim started off at 200. okay so so we go by what what she got we we go with what she got okay so go with what you got now what 175. right now it's 175 right [Music] the 175 is left this is 225. there's 225 left and our claim is 175. correct okay no the second hundredth yes it's still still the no the first one is still claiming from the second hundred the first one is still alive error in the game she still is claiming content from this from the second part you received you're talking about the second part okay so let's talk about a second part let's talk about it afterwards we'll try to figure it out later okay invite the youngest ready oh we have a lot to do here wow wow wow sorry Nelson everybody has a Shiba there and everybody collects equally now I got to tell you a story real quickly you you might know the answer amazing there's a rebe from Amazon who went to buy a lottery ticket in those days the library cost four and a half shekel and he only had four shekel on him so he sees another rep if I'm sorry to walk by and he says do me a favor you have a half a shackle yeah you know that in the story he gives him the half a shekel and he wins three million shekels in those days three million shekels is 10 Apartments literally 10 apartments 3 million shots so the the rabbit the second rabbit from Sawyer says okay give me five Apartments give me one and a half million check though she got says what are you talking about you give me a half a shekel the the ticket was four and a half I put in four you put in half who wins you guys you guys said already the second guy because without the half a shekel of the second guy there's no he can't buy the ticket at all it doesn't make sense to you right it doesn't make sense to you against it [Music] oh so you're saying you shouldn't get anything no it's the way he said it okay so he said he said can't be my shoulder can't be my shoulder you have to say he said it's a beautiful day tomorrow the kiss what happened oh he's saying that what I have you tell them what to do little kids he's about to jump off the thing we don't have a mic here we have two people investing in uh in a business 100 and 200. this is the little Olive there this is this is the sack for this lottery ticket in honor of my uncle Rebel Khan and president is to continue being able to support tairo and finish shots with your belly then the story is a very sad story the guy that put in the four shekel he uh he he helped his kids do what she puts here she puts there before he knew it he had zero money left the message people that win lottery is the other guy was a little bit more of a Savvy investor and uh whatever he left he's not a rebbe anymore I just made up that whole ending but whatever you know what I'm saying hey look go online the guy that won 350 million dollars his daughter his two daughters became drug addicts he was shot in the head he this he had no the kid so he died penniless and he was killed and it's every one of these guys these NFL players you know what I'm talking about okay you have to know how to do it Palmer rabbit says the gemara there's two kinds of things there's an investment imagine an ax me you buy an ax I put in two thirds you put in a third and you want to chop off you know a third of the animal just imagine our ax trying to plow field just you know my front legs it's not gonna work we're we're in a partnership here together we bought this ticket together Charlotte Harrison ment not to be to make it less confusing this is if I sell the meat right Benny I take the meat I could chop it up into any way I want to chop it I get one third of the animal and you get two-thirds great it's a beautiful Division I could do that but the gamar is adding to that even more what if we went into the business to a business that you cannot divide it's a karisha business you can't divide two-thirds in a third but then it ended up even I could have just said it simple karisha but I'm saying even if I started off as a harisha business and it flipped into a it came time to to kill the animals getting old or the prices of meat went up whatever the reason is we decided to shut it now we can divide it equally I could flip my business the outcome instead of it being 50 50 I'm gonna go two-thirds in the third because that's how that's how we put the money in um even if they start out the business not like that you always go down the middle fun that's the story with uh that's why we pass in also with the Dira that she brings in 90 and he brings in 10 the end of the day we split it down the middle amazing but how does it fit with what we said little kiss two people put into one packet uh another was into business them aside one brings a hundred dollars you split it down the middle my lab is we're talking about even a case where they start her off where you couldn't divide it and then you were able to divide it with yufta the rabbit we're talking about a simple case that you can't divide it but you admit to me that if you started out where you can't divide it and then it flipped into a case that you could divide it because you're shifting it is so then you could split the money as they put the money in whatever the percentage that they put in that's the percentage they take out of the profits I think more if that's the case I find it safe a lot because let's say one board very strong animals one bought very weak animals been in cerebral and they got mixed up and now you don't know what's what zenith you tell me a funny story going to another kind of story literally literally though that's the typical classic Emoji question if you're admitting that in this case is XYZ then why don't we just say two cases that are very similar [Music] it's the case that I bought an ax to plow and it we sold it plowing and therefore I can't divide it based on what I put in I could only divide it down the middle but if I started off thinking that it's going to play out boy but at the end of the day we sold it as meat Zenith myself why do you have to tell me a funny story I bought strong animals you bought weak animals they got mixed up we didn't know and then each person tell me a much simpler just be consistent in the story you're right that's exactly what we meant to say and that's what it says here remember it's one story but if I bought it in a way that I cannot divide it up but then it came it turned into something I could divide it up NASA kimisha look it's then it's similar to another story it's as if I bought the strong animals you bought the weak animals in the server and they got mixed up it's a case of that we could split based on the investment now three people put into one packet into one one investment zero if there was there's uh it went up it went down they they they they they split it they divided equally my love because it's because I'm Amish you're learning that it means that it really went down in value hey seriously managed they made a profit and what does it say look at the top top words of this almond um the river you do in the middle that is small foreign so this is it Captain Hook him was whatever they put in right and schmole says Captain Hook him whatever they put in and Schwann says 50 50. you split it down the middle so takasha says tomorrow the top two words what's going on here is his follows there's there's money right we're using money and it says on you know it says a a quarter 25 cents whatever it is it says one dinner but there's old money new money the difference in the old money the new money is that the new money is easier to get rid of people like it they take it even BMA you know if you give somebody a no not so much that really has no value let's say a dollar bill that's really all you know if a guy gives you change or whatever you give a guy and show it gives you a bill that's all you know you said no give me that one it's easier to get rid of it's easier to deal with see what it says what happened was that they were doing the business and their coins got better not the value they didn't didn't really have more more value just easier to deal with what are you going to do with the older coin this is Mario oh I have a perfect thing what to do with it this like I think I got this from Yoni this is from Chavis literally they would take these old coins and they use it as medicine it could heal your foot because it has rust it has like uh moisture in it rust and it has it's very strong and it has even Demar learns that the the the depiction on the coin also heals for however reason so that's what they were using the old coins for so you use that you take your coins you do that I do mine show my ISRO the boys like what's the Shabbos we're gonna just make it a little earlier 9 15 to make happy [Applause] have a wonderful day a wonderful service you spent all the guests wow