Daf Yomi Kesubos Daf 31 by R’ Eli Stefansky

so here we are heir of shabbos say this it's just the two hours before showers is a big oil over here beautiful coming out um i don't expect everybody to be here i don't even know what we're doing immediately i must say this above immediately after the fast is over a coffee and we're going to share right away i realize i have less time than i have taxi's waiting 9 30 fast myer is at 8 45. so we kids i don't know what's going to happen we'll figure it out no what time is my room [Music] really because i read 8 45 maybe it's a mistake okay ah there's plenty of time plenty of time okay so again rabbi said because it's tish above after shabbos so you typically we have a share of matsi shabba so we can't have a shaman the shout outs it's very tish above the entire tissue we don't have a shear so the idea is to give the share now so people could learn now but also hazard tomorrow you're not part of learning on chavez we have to learn every day learn tomorrow and look maybe i'll give a little share here to matteo one-on-one rabbi i'm gonna be in south africa next month and therefore i expect everybody to be there dear rabbi above is the speech this is unbelievable story the man in the center without the beard the shade man with the white shirt in the center his name is simcha firestone he made his first serum at the age of 51 or so it says like this most of it explained i gave a speech tonight most of it explains how why and how i finished three mistakes for the first time in my life what i love about you and the sheer robbie josh brody who's also part of the sh his neighborhood over there is part of the sheer from behind the beam and robbie mordechai yaknes helped put together the mdy boca raton group and we discussed this evening how to leverage the momentum and what the future of mdy boca raton looks like in my speech explain what makes this shirt the best and most exciting that exists i only attached below i'll also attach them thank you for the message i received through the austin brothers your friend and student simplifies many many more i was also at a yankee game says this sadiq his name is moishi both without a last name i was sporting afterwards an unaffiliated jew approached me regarding the slogan as he thought it's a yeshiva or something like that i then went on to explain to him about entire study the greatness of studying entire daily how accessible learn and learn tired nowadays in short i don't know what had ended up happening after i tried inspire i just got this morning from from michael austin jonathan austin's brother from florida he said he's on a flight and the guy next to him said what are you doing and he said doing the daf he says i heard about it what is it so it gets her he gave him the dive showed him the link the guy listened to the entire deaf and more and he says he wants to join he's unaffiliated yvaldik isaac grumbal i started listening to your recently and i'm really enjoying it basically saying what you're saying robert schoenberg so i got to repeat this i want to make a comment on the value of 50 shekel which is equal to 200 zoos i said it's 200 i'm a male 2 is like exuber and it's has a value of at least fifteen hundred dollars i said maybe twenty thousand dollars going through emotion comes to rip schoenberg after shane says no you made a mistake 200 zeus is one thing and this guy also is saying the same exact thing commonly value at 2.2 pounds of silver 536 dollars there's a second 200 it's a cucumber requirement in exuber that has a greater scope that's why i went wrong it's not two hundred so this doesn't scooc him and that's why it's more valuable i haven't i think this guy knows what he's talking about because he's concord mediation group i guess they do mediations supers and stuff like that i don't know anyway the kyle is sponsored second harness at coilov of the month a ten thousand dollar donation to the mdy coiled by abby and rachel kamian for my children second sponsor themselves is jeff rasner excuse my son family lakewood new jersey because toyota is the best segulo he has a trademark under the china's parents rl 149 is this close for my family myself for the tsaddikim of arlatsola number three wow crazy story i'm telling you in the nine days he took his family for a trip in his private plane took off from i forgot the name of that island over there guacamole whatever that took off mackinac matt mackinac island from the pilot himself took off crashed immediately after takeoff one of his grandchildren survived piranha number five dr abram epstein in memory of my precious southern belle wife mother and grandmother rita gay epstein boyce harry go with sheriff chavez thorlos in a rush some people are doing air uh early shabbos you should have all those on zoom how many people are having zoom now wow 76 people on zoom on arab shabbos beautiful guffa top of lamin alef incredible sugis mamish fascinating stuff what happens is the guy is over to his room so going back to the idea of kamalay with the robin if a person is over a major issue at the same time he's kind of a smaller thing he's only higher for the larger one after the smaller one so he stole caleb he stole traif so stealing is one problem caleb is another problem a bigger problem even for the naval over here we have a situation in the sky of the avery why we said for instance according to some under armour if he's manus his own sister he's potter from the canals so why over there if he eats he's hive on the neva what's the difference she quite because they happen at two different times first he picked up the object he did it became his and then a minute later he put it in his mouth and he ate it so they're not connected to two acts and therefore he's kaivan live says the more element of the oven perhaps this comes to argue on ruby oven to america oven okay check this out rabbi so here goes the new technology let's see if you're able to see it oh the yamaha wasn't soggy schmack wasn't sticking to his head okay what you see in this chart is for those who haven't been with us since most of the shop is the very very basic stuff of shabbos the 101 and again shaas cotton we're going through a lot of stuff fast bhagismak khazran one way to be over one of these suriman one of the 39 melakas in chavez is ah to take out an object from arushi from a guy's private domain as you see those houses in his front yard into the public domain we're not going to go into what a public domain is six hundred thousand people sixteen fif amis why does whatever whatever public domain is okay a a large thoroughfare that's one way of being over you also need an akira and hana you have to lift it up and put it down you can't be over on shabbos without an akira and another way to be over this aveiro is by walking for amis irish arabim you can even see he's holding something in his hand that guy and he's walking okay when we learned from cephas ayrevin i didn't have this i just discovered this today it's something like a gif i don't even know what it is no okay i didn't know that i could actually put it on and draw on it and all that schmuck we're going to start using it a little bit more fine i can't what are you laughing yosef has it all the time i just whatever it's new for me we could have used i guess and we might use it a little a little bit more today fine now says the gemara like this okay so you got all the ideas from them walking four rounds and register those are the two ways however there has to be an akira and nanaka you have to lift it up and put it down we're going to see that if you didn't have a mind to put it down when you picked it up it's not even out here now okay hazorek listen to this one lema please eric oh guess what i have another one this is going to be amazing check this out boys okay you might get sick of watching this but there's a shirt there's a piece of silk in the middle he is shooting an arrow four amis on shabbos if you shoot four ammos you you did an akira and hanaha he lifted it and there's a takeoff and there's a touchdown all on shabbos when is he over the israel shabbos one is misa when this first he did akira he shot the bow the arrow and then when it landed he's high of miso you see where it says miso i'm sorry about the you know what let me stop it i could stop it hold on there is a way there was a way not anywhere there is a way okay there's a way when it's in in a different mode not in the this mode yeah maybe you know what let me okay this is better okay what happened was while the arrow was flying through the ear it ripped somebody's clothing said neva he's going to be high of me so what nazek he's magic he he's high of miso in three seconds from now three seconds earlier before the misa he was masking somebody yes a special shirt cost fifty dollars because they're gonna kill him they're going to give him skila tomorrow in bethlehem so he doesn't have to pay for the shirt right now potter why is he potter for the shirt because of the idea of come lay with the rabbit monet he's going to get the death penalty so he doesn't have to pay for the shirt but wait a minute you just said that if it happens at two different times the shirt was at 10 o'clock the landing was 1001. it took 30 seconds to go through by the way we have to say we're learning now there's a tremendous um what do you call it in english there's an operation going on right now the israelis just went into gaza they're bombing gaza so it's going to be a little bit of a balagano narrative so we have to dive in that everybody should be healthy because we're gonna they're going to retaliate now with missiles and everything so the learning should be escrows we're learning now right now as we speak i was just thinking about it the missile going through it sometimes it takes 30 seconds whatever it is but it happened at a different time even if it's a split second it didn't happen at the same time that it hit the shirt says the says gomorrah so we just said that if it happens at a different time you stole and then you ate the hell of you you're hiv on the hill if you don't have kamala over here you say you potter on the shirt because of kham limited rabbini it's a little bit counterintuitive your potter when they happen together you have when they're separate oh so now the gemara says that you saw it the akira is part of the hanako you shoot the arrow because you wanted to land somewhere so it's one misa shooting leaving my hand leaving the arrow and hitting the board or hitting wherever it is is one action and anything that happens in the middle of that action is part of the action of the akira nanaka it's not akira hanaka it's a kiran it's one and the same i'm doing that here i'm shooting the arrow so that it should land somewhere so my melo when i hit my the shirt and i do hezek in the middle of the flight it's all part of it and therefore i'm positive for the shirt i lifted up the kelev and i stole the caleb in order to put it in my mouth it's like an arrow going from over here from my plate into my mouth it's the same thing as an arrow traveling unbelievable there's a question why is tisha above and tisha both tish above should be an asar above when was the base i mean this destroyed on the 10th of of why do we celebrate the 9th of and this year we're celebrating actually the 10th above but it's really but why so they use this gemara right here unbelievable because asia the the fire started on tish above and it continued and that's our above so when did when did the when did it actually happen when the fire started when you shoot the arrow that's when it starts that's the whole the corbin you could yeah the actual building fell on the 10th but when did it start on the ninth fine says the morrow no beautiful tie into the tissue alo thank you the sorry let me see from the beginning this is the difference again we have two cases one is the arrow flying we're saying that the whole flight from beginning to end is one mice and then we have a guy grabbing a piece of caleb off his friend's plate stealing it and we're saying that it's not one mice why not no only way the arrow could go from point a to point b is if you lift it up and you shoot it over here you don't need to lift up the piece of caliper and put in your mouth you could grab the caleb off the floor off the plate with your mouth you don't need to lift it up the boy got involved because rashid says less than three fahren this is shita here the lesson three for him is not considered so if you bend down and you eat the caleb off the floor off the plate so you ate it you're over on this so without even lifting it up so you don't need the lifting up to be part of that maize inaudible once you shoot an arrow you can't take it back over here just because you lifted it up and you stole it doesn't mean that you're going to do the end of the action over here you could stop what you're doing you stole it doesn't mean you're going to necessarily eat it so but when it comes what's a madagascar what's the matter according to them but when it comes to an arrow i want to say that it's one mice it's one action why because once i shoot the arrow i can't take it back so if i can't take it back it shows that it's one myself what's the difference the same action as an arrow but here you're holding it in your hand you're going and you're just robbing and you're cutting stuff as you're going so you could stop it's not an arrow you can stop what you're doing over here in order to to do whatever he's doing he has to pick it up he has to keep on going so it's one mice like but according to the savara that has to do what what's the determining factor whether you could stop your action in the middle over here you can stop your action so it's not connected it stops the mice it's not one whole it's not one long mice because anytime i in the mice i could stop what i'm doing and take it back then it's not one long mice i lifted it up then i went to sleep i went right there and i cut so one thing has nothing to do with the other guffa oh my baby going back to this case hazard last hour if you want to look at the picture one more time how do you save is there a way to make sure that doesn't turn black every second i don't know the program but i'm going to have to walk to try and fix that uh-oh here hold on i'm in this now i stopped one of them the hippopotamus is a different one okay so going back to this myself has already because i believe i have a car show in the ass that i was flying it tore a shirt it was magic somebody else potter why shakira said because when you when the arrow leaves the the bow it's for landing the take-off and landing is one of the same right when you fly a plane you need to take off in order to land so the takeoff and the landing it's one long flight it's one one action but if you could stop in mid-air and pause then we said it's not one action according to that one turrets okay so let's remember if somebody steals a purse he steals a purse on shabbos hishay again from from going from oh yeah two things how great of christmas he's doing two things here he stole something and it's shabbos he he stole the purse it became his so he's got it and then by the time he he made it out the front door of whoever's house he stole that front door turns into which was unraveling now if it was one long miso he lifted it up in order to take it out it's akira so then he shouldn't be high right now real quickly let's say want to be kind of this so the best way to do it really is i lift it up hug him up what if yeah what if i go like this i drag it i pull it to myself that's meshikha sigmara says potter over here we're saying that meshicha is not going to be kinda why because he didn't pull it into his domain his partner so until he gets here just to rob him yeah buddy i want to be kinder with my shirt now we're saying that he's not cutting it yeah it's not this object comes out of the guy's house then he steals it but then it's already too late then he's high of miso for taking out of the guy's house from going to from one domain to another from russia okay it's the same story we said before now that he when he lifted it up on the first part the first part that we said not not on the dragging i said to remember when it says remember how going of kiss if i lift it up i'm in your house i lift up a purse i'm high of a what everybody said why am i i lifted it up in order to take it out of the front door so that's that kira let's go so when i lifted it up it was part of my saw of shabbos it was part of the the misa that i'm getting i can't get it out the front door without me lifting it up so it's like a flight it's like take off and landing i picked it up and i landed outside i'm hyped miso so i shouldn't be high frequent i can't be having the same action [Music] here if his intent was not to take it outside he lifted it up in order to hide it in that guy's house so he wanted to steal it but he did not intend to be over is it a rise over it so the nimblach and then he decided all of a sudden to take it out and this explains it becomes inuakiro okay of why should it be hive for horizon chambers is interesting when it comes to shabbos if i lift the couch in my house all day long i take the couch from one room to another not high of anything so guy who lifted up the couch in order to move it around in his house he spotted if you take out a little needle from the front door into the miso lifting a whole couch and schlepping on shabbos you're not doing anything only when you do the top but he he lifted up the couch in order to move it to the dining room and then he decided no he's going to take it out to the front to the garbage house so he's potter why because when it comes to is a new concept for now i mean those who learned chavez know about this and chavez has to be chavez you have to have in mind you have to have cavanaugh to do that has to be a calculated action so when i lift up the couch i have to have intent to take it out the front door if my intent was to move it to another room so when i lifted it up it was nothing then 25 seconds later i just said okay i'm going to take it out the front door and be over and i saw you not over it's all there's no akira you need a kira and anaka and both of them have to have the right intent of issur i have to say i'm taking it outside so if the intent was to put it to to hide it like the gamer says you shouldn't be over shabbos says are you right 100 right step one is we're going back to what we said before no he had the right intent to be over is it there isa okay so then what what's going on here my skin on kisha ahmad the guy stopped in his footsteps he was walking and then he stopped so when you stop what happens that becomes a hanaka when you stop it's then you start up again now you made another akira so when he stopped the first time what was what what happened he became a ghana he's no long he didn't get to the front door yet he lifted up the guy's purse it's a purse full of my cash a man's purse full of cash or he stole the woman's purse whatever he picked up the purse and he's walking through the office and he hears noise so he stops up that stop is uh he he he's kind of the purse then he then we invite there out the front door and he's over on on isra shabbos so that's why it's too mice him and that's why you only have you on the geneva and the shop is not going to partner you because it happened at two different times two two separate actions okay but wait a minute why did he stop if it's to readjust the package on the shoulder you see this guy right here this guy is carrying something pretty heavy he needs to stop why don't you stop if it's to readjust okay that's normal everybody that has a backpack they're always i think i have another picture here this is a typical in when we're learning about um in aravind this is the cottage this is mama's like he stops puts the his backpack on a stone and readjusts it okay look at it that's normal so it's not if it's normal then what what's the fear ice then it's not a hanoka he's it's not considered stopping it's considered part of your when you're driving you're driving from from here to there and you stop at a stop sign is that stopping no it's part of the drive you didn't take a rest you know you're not resting it's part of driving okay ella boy lovers but if he stopped to take a break that's different says the gemara okay if if that's the case you just might get you made a distinction between lakatif and loveforce between to readjust and to take a nap avocados what are the two cases case number one is i lifted it up some hive case number two sorry harry potter potter because it's one mice case number two is mcgarvey it's a dragging ask the gemara why are you jumping to another type of case to magaya in that reviews case of lifting up i have two cases i don't have to go to another case of dragging within lifting up these two cases when you you stan you stood still to rest because that's not normal so it's two actions avala catif but if you did it in the normal way then your partner we just turned to lemon aloe vera sponsoring which you are not of zach the rock rocklin and lenny lerner cpa and yeah i got going division nba msp and my holy norman honor myself hello moni ben azahi okay we're saying it's been as it what you're always hiv even if you didn't stop the omar mahal koi medomi unbelievable check this out look at this guy if you notice his foot and when you're walking your foot is stationary on the floor it's not moving one foot is not moving yeah when you walk you put your left foot down so you're stationary you pick your right foot up and then you put your right foot down you're not running you're at any given time you're in one place so he claims but as he says if you were to take a hundred steps you did a hundred akira's in an office every time you put your foot down that's a hanaka so therefore what so the he has a toupee so the misa only happens at the end because every time he's doing akira no so when is he high of miso for shabbos when he gets through surrounding but the geneva happened at the first step that he took yeah he's in the guy's house he picks up a purse he picks up whatever it is he takes one step oh you're a ganov because now he's kind of he he brought he brought in his results he was kinda but he's not hive on on a shabbos because he's still in the guy's house he's in a private domain so he has to take 25 steps 25 accuracy in an office which geneva happened 20 steps ago and finally when he gets to the front door and he steps from if so how does a person how's a person over in rochester for ammus how's it possible every time you put your foot down it's another akira another anaka they pick your foot up as another ikea huh so there's no such thing as four hours versus a rabbit says tais is too territory tires number one that's the zeros of kosovo we don't understand it but that's how it is if you're walking which is around forever terrace number two which i never understood so well actually somebody explained it to me a little bit but i don't think that's the patches and dices but terrace number two is that it's this the only way to be either irresistible dalai davis is if the person jumps the full dalaramis so so yeah you have to carry something so i thought my caruso it's impossible most people besides me of course can't jump eight feet so in the middle of the kylo he takes a awesome what are you doing but it was only about six feet there's six seven feet it's no it's not it's not a regular thing now this is a man by the way because it's 100 a man that's why i put it here [Music] i couldn't get the scissors on they're moving too fast the bus and everything fine so you could shut it off already [Music] we're around the rebecca egger asked rebel label egger he's famous that he he left the litvish kite and became a hazard to such a word she asked him he said i don't understand something why can't we shake a lullab on sukkas why don't we blow shay for on roshana shema yavireno dalla maybe you might come to carry four amps or surround them and the only way that you're over is if you jump so how many people are jumping eight feet at a time with the little of an asterisk you would understand the symbol of the mitzvah made me jump okay fine i don't know but it doesn't happen before the death is over that i can tell you something [Music] if you throw the object what happens the geneva and shabbos happen at the same exact moment there's noah this is akira and i know what akira wanna cover both the geneva and the shabbos so therefore what come live with the rabbi monet and therefore your potter for the geneva lifting niffler even this video so then again same question before nav enough camino within one case why do i have to talk about dragging the method if he's walking he's potter from geneva i have a zorrick then you'll be having a neighbor i have a zorrick potter says good morning no i need the case of dragging i don't want to talk about throwing white milan i would think who in the world drags a purse you put the purse on your shoulder you carry it nobody drags a purse commercial on and right when it comes to hilka shabbos everybody knows that if you turn on a light with your elbow it's a shinoi and you're not hydra i say it's urban you archive don't go ahead and doing it but if you do things differently you're not having their eyes so if you're going to drag a purse and the normal way of doing it is to hold it not to drag it and you're not crying there isa that's the gemara bimai what kind of person are we talking about eberravarave if it's a giant purse it's normal to drag it check this out i have a giant purse okay the way to get to move this purse around is by dragging it you can't really lift it right and if it's really small i have a picture of that also if it's really small [Music] it's not the dirt we're gonna put the little person on the ground and drag it it's a medium here we go i got a picture of that also here he's dragging your purse we're exactly in other words so we're teaching us what are you coming to teach us it's normal it's normal for people to drag medium-sized purses by the way i i just realized this exact story like this kid i saw many times in the airport with nick havas there's something about them that they prefer to drag a 400 pound bag through a giant airport than to be caught dead with the bag that has wheels because whales is weird it's a crush of a expensive purse without wheels that's russia but you drag they drag they get wheels no not me no i don't do wheels i do okay fine you never nobody knows what i'm talking about have you seen it no it's not the money it's not the money it's it's a certain it's a status prestige a purse doesn't have wheels imagine a purse with wheels it has to be a hunch of a bag and put a ton of stuff in this managed the way they were okay fine now you'll notice it go to the airport you'll notice no we don't show pictures of those kind of people zarim don't do it i'm not with where exactly is this guy taking moving this stuff if he's thinking out through surrounding when you drag something you're not quitting it you have to pull it into your shoes so you're kind of from bringing from water shows into surabam but not you're not either yet and if you're going from a private rousseau stop another private shows from one should say another private domain you take it from your your friend's house to your house you're not you're not over on shabbos but you are over on geneva let's see so this is what we had over here where's that picture here's see there's just what happened a person puts like bricks uh walls so that the people in the in the public sarabin don't go into his front yard the green is his yard he doesn't want people in there so now you have in between the beams what is that you see it has asphalt but nobody really goes there so is it part of the juicer it's not part it's called see there's rabbits the size is around pokemon and according to each of these if it has the same allocation to rob him is again so we have the same what did you gain exactly the amount of shock if the hello heck leads considerations so i did not dr i can't drag your favorites into this raven be over i'll be over in shabbos but [Music] is if you want to consider between the beams that the the area with the red arrows you want to consider it as a ahead so you weren't over geneva you just went from the grass to somebody else's yacht you're not over since at the end of the day if there's many people let's say this whatever they're going to end up between those beams but also it works on both things it's somewhat versus somewhat of not yakid but more actually calls it a simta i don't know in hebrew they call it a simta i don't know if it's the same thing but it's a place where it's more of a private area in the middle of the surrounding mma law you're kind of there as well when you're making the economy my time at the rabbit at the end of the day works there if i drag it into that area since you don't have a lot of people there it's kind of private so mashikha does work rivashi omar no forget this hole that he dragged it into this punk we're talking about a case where he dragged it into between these beams no that's not what happened he another interesting story what happened was let's say i don't know there's a good idea over here he put his hand this is where she surrounded this table i don't know if you can see me gary this is rishi suraban so he put his hand next to his ram again so within three tv versus so he put his hand over here and it's wrapped into his hand okay now this hand is considered fourth by force because when it comes to the shabbos the only time you're over is if you do where does have to be in a domain in a real domain a domain is only if it's four by fourth focus so i wouldn't be over on shabbos if this computer went into my hand my hand is tiny it's only uh two not four so therefore we have to come on to rava rapha says that your hand has allah four by four so what what are we saying here boys we're saying that over here we have a case that shot shabbos and never happened at the same exact second when i dropped the computer into my hand so first of all i'm over on geneva because i stole it second of all i was over on shabbos at the same exact time so therefore i am potter from geneva because of kim libby the ravenna your whole assumption is wrong i hope that there is mishikha the kingdom of meshicha to drag something you are kind of even in them and how do i know that because i have a diok from a mishnah he says and we're just going to do this what's how exactly do they learn it not a big deal again one-man armor holds that there is no i cannot be cleaning anything by dragging something in order to be kind of something i have to lift it up remember how do you how do you how you kind of an elephant going to safari how are you kind of an elephant anybody how do you lift up an elephant huh up around craig you gotta it has to go up something i i could nope mashika is not working here or he says no meshika does work so what's the what's the raya the travail they both bring away from the same exact mishna they both saw the same mishna the opposite of each other this non it says if a person steals an animal um he was fighting with the animal yeah sometimes animals get scared and he is struggling with the animal he chokes him until the animal dies so if it happened in the domain of the original owner he's potter he bi but if he did hagba oh so you see how it says they're together the gemara wants to he one wants the direction that they're they're one of the same you can learn one from the other but also it could be media if you lift it up or you take it out of there why is he protocols he died in the owner's resources so you see that if i did mashika and i got it out of his domain i'm kaif so what do you see meshikha works to be kinda internal what another source is okay interesting agbo just like when you lift something up you bring it into your own domain so too hoytson rachel or vinoka should you say but each one has a beautiful d hook so what does the other one do with each one's deal says gemara rachel cassio should say which is don't be don't take it literally when i say the owners or shus i don't mean literally what he owns and what he bought and he has a star that says it says what i mean to say as long as it doesn't leave that guy's assurance it doesn't go into your shoes then it's considered his his his domain on this deal to say that he saw just because they're together the words are together to make such a deal we don't make such a deal have a wonderful shabbos have a meaningful fast you skye for coming have a great day you