Daf Yomi Kesubos Daf 21 by R’ Eli Stefansky

good morning boys [Music] cool jeremy shire woods i'm so happy that the eight-minute daf is back i have such a better understanding of that after watching it and for that i'm so appreciative may allah benefit from your work thank you he's a lawyer from i don't know where this is israel goldstein i was working at a golf fundraising event for ezermitzione and i bumped into uncle phil and event organizer simi how do you pronounce it we were there saving lives for ezermition through golf and saving our new shabbos with mdy daft lots of love you stroll goldstein i was having fun in america a vert last night i wanted to tell me them i'm no newman derivative is the best thing is though of last night in booger tongue oh boca raton my wife and i went to vard the daughter of rabbi barack barkhaim barack massotor i was introduced to the father young man on the right i asked the father where are you from he said highland park he said the rabbi of mike and marsha is from there he said who do you do that with the fan scheme my son also does stuff so when i with rabbi so i walked up to amna newman it was like you always described when people from share meet were already brothers i can actually now proudly say i've been with you every day since a few pages before the end of megillah mazatla student and friend simcha firestone boca raton florida ps rabbi brody and i are working on moving the mdy boca raton group forward and this is vandeveld he brings in every day you come to this restaurant you don't leave without a gemara that's how it works over there i forgot it's like next to between lakewood and you have some very good desserts and stuff you saw mayor joselowski hi sro mayor i was inspired by your share when you came to lakewood and i heard that you're looking for someone to spread the sheer i have a jewelry store in a busy shopping plaza in lakewood called eternity jewelers if you need a place to pick up a good bar and sign up for the deaf i can do that for you he happens to be my cousin yankee liba right higher valley schlitz yankee rife i started doing the daf i think it was beta for like four misers then i was on and off with the vomits yeah like many others but hashem been on track since the beginning of subas it's not about the dove it's about the yoyo me i was at bell works and i was that by chestnut when you were giving the share one of the evening uh i love looking around and seeing every type of jew and you share your share is meant for any type of person it's unbelievable when it's built by bell works uh i thought somebody could have been called nikkadesh they eventually called the cottage because the real dude's just seeing single clients all together here is a video attached to my three-year-old teaching my two-year-old how to learn thank you so much for all the hard work i guess i don't have the video oh no this is somebody else this rabbi sai is a classic duty shift dear belly i try my best to recruit my three-year-old sister for mdy and this is all i got [Music] good morning rob boyce no that's a hit ooh our boys are big news very very big news finally made it to the cover of ami magazine but what do i mean this is kashif because more people are going to learn torah nothing to do with guyva nothing they're laughing they're partially laughing i'm not kidding every time i i did one of these interviews many people joined tyra and i'm hoping that many people i have a tremendous occurrence that i've frankfurter the owner and the one who interviewed me tremendous interview um yeah tremendous very very i don't know i he made me feel comfortable i felt great during the interview he's great 180 dollars per signed copyright show this to people that are not doing the lafayette tell them to read the article and don't buy up all the copies leave some for others or advice i leave some for others i am going to sign this one for jonathan stefanski the let's who doubts me so true soldier the boys the month's sponsor is anonymous i don't know but yeah the kyle monspanzer anonymous but it's lu s all the new guys that are joining the daf all the new guys the kylo sponsor for one day by david wright is my father from kalman i don't know i don't have the name correct it's backwards i hope it's reverend cowan bin shmuel but it could be a mixture over here survivor of seven labor camps wow seven seven labor camps for my children the second sponsor is jeff rasner my son is from new jersey lakewood because tire is the best gula a registered trademark of b3 bicycles not sure who tyre is the best school as the altazak but he wants to register let him register our children to be called the safe he'll be happy and no hashem loves them honestly three shraggy pathets is this close from my family myself paris happy birthday to my wife ali chevalier and daughter sarina hama with brahat paris says of our son alter let me see i'll say it again okay we have a very exciting death today a lot of good charts bringing back some characters from ubamus so we're talking about often authenticating staris and the star has two signatures each signee says about his own signature it's mine and i'm going to testify about my friends so it's very interesting if you think we didn't really think about this that much so now we have an opportunity to think about it what exactly are these adam testifying about when they come and they testify they're testifying that these are their signatures or are they testifying that what it says in the star is true what are they testifying it's a big shy law now over here from this lotion and this shita of reby you could see what each one holds what they're testifying is not the star as much as their own signature now you'll figure out that if the star signature is a good star but that's your thing we're testifying about our signatures so therefore each signature very big enough amino e if i'm talking about the star so rouvain is testifying about the star shiman is testifying about the star how many adam do i have for the star too but if i am testifying about my signature so that's one testimony on one signature put it to the side you testify on your signature that's what this one yeah so i don't have to to aid them on any signature i only have one eight per signature therefore says rebbe zelimer's exavio divas i'm also going to testify about my friend and therefore each signature has two a dim savior so great music but what if they don't testify about their friend they don't know about the friend signature they weren't there whatever they didn't see they didn't notice so i justified by myself i'm selfish myself and he about himself so if i were to ask you right now and here and now what does rebbe hold rebbe holds that the testimonies on their edos on the hasima only not on the star and encircle that they're being made on the star itself so if i'm being made understand itself i have two beautiful aiden that are being made on the star reuven and chiming i don't need the third one [Music] and therefore each one could just testify about his own savior that's probably how he thought yesterday before we even saw rebbe and the story says the gomorrah when you look deeply into the suggya lady rebbie so what are they actually testifying they're testifying about their handwriting about the signatures i have to say that when i saw this sheet i was a little taken aback i felt like a loser like somebody doesn't understand because it wasn't so passionate to me like you have to like look deeply into the mishnah kind of figure it out but i guess after you explain it and after you see it again it's posit so there's no need for the gemara to even explain it it's obvious that red beholds that they're testifying on the eden and the the testimonies on the start says mao the same uh le rebbie sapooke i would think that maybe rebbe wasn't so sure exactly how it works because really right testifying but maybe rebbe's little machmer he had a little bit of suffoc [Music] and what's the difference here if he had us so check this out for a second here you have some sort of styrofoam so no i'm fix who's spacing out i just called his name because i wanted to yeah on the phone so whatever i had to call you up advise you you have you'll see kleiner and non-fixed each one by the way if you don't behave i'm going to do one of these to you so non-fix is being made on his signature which is only 25 of the whole start why because yussi klein is also testifying on his signature which is another 25 together you have 50 on that signature then they both testify on the signature above that 25 each 25 each the kids are each one is testifying 50 but you break it down per signature 25 percent out of the 50 that each witness is being this 50 weight to each witness on the star 25 percent goes to the signatures 25 percent goes to the other signature okay so two blues two reds and together you have a hundred percent of the whole star what happens if one of the items goes by by the way if anybody has this character when i was away in america the mice were playing and they took the characters and took them home they belonged to mdy so if anybody has them i know they took them to we still need them so please bring them back they're expensive and we like them and i want to give one to noah so if you have no um it went bye-bye okay that's what i meant by going bye-bye so went by right now we bring in avi avi is going to testify to what's going on here he's going to help because we don't have eight anymore we need another aid what comes out is since yossi klein is also testifying under eidos and avi is just testifying on one eight of those it comes out that we don't have ap edin is that each aid must have 50 weight you can't have an aid that testifies on more than the other aid on 75 what what happens is over here it comes out let's see if i have uh i thought i had a different one okay let's go back jesus no no it says but it has to be divided equally each one that's how we learn from the apostle that each one it's two that combine for one whole thing fifty percent on you 15 but if we're doing it this way oh this is the picture i was looking for yeah it actually says it here yasik line is made on his eighth that's 50 plus twenty five percent on the other one it's like it's barack we're just throwing it out but it comes out that yossi client takes more weight than avi he's doing 75 percent versus twenty-five percent and that is illegal that's not analogically correct so if so it's not going to be enough to have just avi we're going to have to do this we're going to have to bring in dr fafter so now it's evil evenly we don't need to come on to your client for the second second yossi clara will take care of his abi factor in avi uh kamiyansky the reuben and levy though shimon and levi they'll take care of the second section we have 50 50. everything is good so that's the shiloh if abbayo wasn't 100 sure if i buy a a rebbe sorry if rebbe wasn't sure that they're they're testifying on the casimos maybe they're testifying on the star then you're gonna need to bring in reinforcements you're gonna need to bring in two more adam if you're testifying on the hassimo is so one guy avi kamianski is enough if you're being made on the star by the way you say made out of casimo is i made that i signed on a good start but i made america if you made it on the star then you're going to need two guys says the gemara so just say it inside you if one of the adam dies perhaps you need two extra a then like in this chart the mccain because if not then you have a problem that one eight and king cannot nicki river the moment three three quarters of the star apomo the ghatsa you're gonna have this situation where the guy with the shrimp is doing most of the work if you have a guy that's that's dead or not dead both cases are going to go on the rebbe mifshap cheetah being the coolest that's why the gemara has to speak it out and say no rabbi actually holds and he's certain of ashita that even if it means that all you need is one aid like in this case but because they're testifying about the kasima's then one it is enough because he's helping out so you see here's the sheet that says that you need to weigh them to come and reinforce like over here but zoo rebbe lakula and over here rebbe says no you don't need dr factor without activating it's enough however about humor are the ones that hold that you need to aid says the gemara what do you do but what if you don't have a doctor factor the guy the guy had a very good start says somebody owes a million dollars he did what he had to do he has two adam that signed in it and one of them went bye-bye now what he's up a creek he can't he can't he can't he can't use his style what are you going to do says the gemara on incredible it's a villain what you do is if i could get there there you see klein takes his signature puts it on a piece of pottery and then he gives it into the beson he throws it to the best and the person says oh this is jesse klein's signature now i no longer need your client for a signature now i can rely on the piece of pottery and then you'll see klein goes together with avi and now together each one has 50 percent of the other kasim interesting trick i know you're not happy about it no i see you already in your whole no you're about to ask a question tosses into the business so he doesn't come along and testify at all on his own signature vasali and then yossi klein and avi get together and umass and they say testimony on the remaining signature says the gemara with daft you have to use a piece of pottery why aval amiguilte to write it on a piece of paper is a terrible idea that you're going to have a guy that's not very good not a good guy because of a motherboard he's going to take his signature and right on top of it someone so owes me a million dollars i or i'll say i yeah i borrowed all right you have a signature ruling signs and all right i ruvain borrowed a million dollars from ximen signed myself now typical star has two eight of them double stars to aid him this is not a typical star what is this this is a handwritten document from the valdov himself from the buyer himself with his own signature okay it's not as powerful as a regular style which i could go and collect uh collateral and real estate that he sold etc but it's a very good document a lot of times we do that no handwritten star here take my handwriting for myself if you have the guy the borrower's handwriting [Music] there's another way to do it the concern is here a mice and shahaya with the milk a guy came to him with a star so and so owes money they both came to bed looked at it and he saw that the handwriting the the hasimah different inks that he didn't like what he saw so he asked the borrower the so what what happened he says i don't know this guy i never borrowed money from him so he says do you have any swarm at all that you signed your name on he said yeah he says come bring bring this fire he brought and he saw that he signs his name and is in his farm in the middle of the page and then they found the safer that was missing the first page and he put the page in and it matched perfectly and that's what it says over here why didn't i reach the megilto if you write your signature on the top top of the page so nobody could write above it they could write below it but that's not a star and that's also a eta to get out of it the gemara and he brings a good morning bubble bathroom i happened to do hazara in babasha 20 times it wants me to see him on my message 20 times i don't remember a word but i remember this myself you remember to see him it was a pretty good scene no like an eight eight course you got you were also there yeah that's when the show was very well it was before the share what year we had the thursday nights here were you talking about five years ago okay so anyway but i never i didn't tell people at the ceo that i did 20 times that was just later i let everybody know i did a bad number what no i wasn't into this whole thing of bragging in order to encourage other people make fun i don't care should be supposed to my sons yeah okay so so true there's a gevalicon mice in there where a guy that collected taxes he went to abaya he says listen reba you know a lot of times come to me and they say that they're tamid and they say even abbaya says but i can't trust them i don't have i don't have your signature i need to compare your signature with the documents that they're giving me please sign over here sabai took the document and he wanted to sign on the tap and as he's signing on the top the guy starts pulling the document down by his pulling and i told him whatever the lesson over there is in other words i know your trick i learned in the gemara stop pulling the document let me sign on the top where i'm supposed to sign and that's you see what the guy was thinking the guy wanted to buy a signature on the bottom then he write a bios me this and this and that okay so here you have the aside of of what is saying you could read you could put your signature and give it to besdon on a piece of pottery or on top of this comes shmuel and says the famous and here again you have ravi huda who is the talmud of rav and shmuel and he always quotes ravenchamor and over he says like we always thought until today that every aid testifies about his signature inshallah israel what's the what's this you have rebbe who's the individual against a hundred why should rebbe that when rebbe argues with any one of his friends he always wins so i would think and maybe even when he argues against the hundred commas walon shmuel says that is like not like this is where i think breslav got their thing from and these are just abbreviations of the names we're about to learn it didn't help me much i hope it helps you omale here you see that's you have the nun because we have double names here so you they're using one letter from each name you said all you need is one signature wait a minute there's a star that had rebecca he testified on his signature and the other guy's signature um and on the second signature that's shita that you always testified the second one and this all happened where in shmuel's best then and you said shmuel says you don't have to testify about your friend just testify about yourself and what do they say this is called the hempec we say oh we testified that the dionym say it's a great star only i always started the asmav over there it was different over there there are orphans the asylum and we have to be super careful for the asylum is concerned the best and maybe the assailant will go to the wrong president the best in the thinks that the halaq is like rebbe why do they think that love is like rabbi because that is always like ready anytime you are besides mujhavero but in this case happens to be maybe rebbe's has a stronger tightner than hakame and and they decided on their own to pass in like rebbe and require that the aid each a testify about his friend and they look at the star and they say sorry simon we can't give you any money because they only testified about themselves not by their friends the one time thing let me be careful for you simon don't learn anything for this from this but in fact it's like not like that yeah i know i thought about that yeah that's why i stuck in what i stick in for this one time like yeah you say you got to be careful they're always very careful you think mark they're always careful how to act because people are going to learn from the way you act and now people are going to learn okay fine but before should you marry us that we don't pass let's see if we have a thing here oh i just want to show you real quickly if i could zoom forward here okay this is a hem pick empic says that's what it says now going to the small over here okay so you have three dionym that testify and they write a little hemp a little black thing over there with the white letters and they write that we testify we saw in front of us they came and we we verified and we we um i'm looking for the other word where they um they interviewed adam how do you say the interrogated hey they're good they're good ate them no i'm y'all see they're good and then they write a handbag now what happened is the the guy goes with the sempek and he goes to collect what does the mukhotsov do it's a it's a false star yesterday we're in besdon three day on the road at hempic they said it's a good start no i don't want to pay it's a bad start go prove it your whole hymn pick is is false so he goes back to bezel goes back to basin and they're not in session today so the guy with the hamburg or the the end guy the guy with the naftali he goes together with yossi who's the aide and they together they say this star is a good star naftali is going to say rip naftalia hamburg with the frat guy river naftal leader shiva he's going to testify that he wrote a yes he's going to testify that he has eidos but that that it's his signature they're both testifying it's a good start bottom line is the both testified it's a good start well i don't need diana again i don't need to go through the whole process one from here one from here great [Music] i love it it's unbelievable i could take one die in one eight put them together boom now real quickly the martial says over here i don't understand there's a isser to even use those words how can i say about a piece of learning this is great this is unbelievable explains when you say oh that's a beautiful piece you're saying you and you're insinuating that everything you said before that is not good all this cautious in terrorism he said the last three months it garnished it reminds me he said the guy asked him akash and cheer and he tells the guy what you're saying is not even stusm and then five minutes later another guy asks akasha and he goes oh oh that's doosan so when you when rashiva says oh come on now you're saying good that means you're putting him down everything else it's not it's not a nice thing to do rashi brings a pasta noise well i found it fascinating that the schloss says and we might be over on this in our show and then many shows it's awesome for the gabba to get up and say rabbi sai this is the best aliyah ever this is this has this gula to mama and the last year it sold for x amount so what you're saying is that other alias is not are not as hashem and he's saying it's us to do all alias are equal even even the claws exactly it's awesome to stand up very good they say it's awesome it says also to stand up by azir shir as this yoshiro starts you have to be makbid to start out to stand up in the beginning of the aliyah oh seriously a lot of people say oh oh they all stand up it's a problem okay mama's like that because you're showing so fine amri omarova comes robin says my malyuso what are you saying that it's a good thing that he said mighty commas they're not testifying the same thing it's terrible what you're saying you can't take a diane is saying that the black star is good yes he's saying that the white star is good two separate things one is the hampick one is the the the the eidos the signature the star the ma y'all see is tesla again what is yossi testifying on the manager star he's saying the star is a good star there's a there was a the dying has no clue if there was a halva he just knows that we were mckay in the star so that's the time about different things you also wrote me by your testicle who was romy's father haskell omar don't listen to yehuda ravi uda the famous ravi udo that quotes shmuel everywhere over here don't listen to him he doesn't know he's talking about they say that he wasn't as great as his brother rap but he still is his brother he called him yuda so in other words we see from here if you're like your climb kaneowski or like uh you did the kramer so anytime you ask him who was uh raviota's father he knows right away because it says okay it's interesting just to note that the names here you have rava you're ravi yeah then we turn to the file from the base sponsored by moshi horn and honorary team let's get the only river that was actually going to basketball and by yankel cohen the official mby msp and by judy newman in honor of her belly the real greatest jewish basketball player ever lived i found out that hoodie newman is the guy i dunked over during a game in new york lehigh valley never never happened okay ravinoy the brother of abba came to buy sesames yeah throughout sesame was a big thing people are buying very busy with sesames midstarfin the aid like we had a second ago that the roshiva you'll see client they could get together and and talk about uh now just real quickly look at rashi the top rashi like four lines dying down the rainbow douche base rabbi yehuda noila drove i just thought it was fascinating rashid doesn't point the sound but these are all the people that were just talking about all three of them are here in rashi the day that ravi uda died is the day that rava was born the gomorrah says the day somebody dies a lot of times the god was born that day so rob was born on the day they reviewed it was lifter yoim shimae surova on the day the rebels lifted oh so here we have ravage also omar maymar kama malia so anyways they set over the same thing and our main said the same words that we said before what a beautiful hidden a dying and they could get together the image because roman barcoma said it's good you're you're wondering how come on base goes quicker look there's four lines are just names so oh here yeah let's go back a second here we go we have three diagonal like in this picture that are coming to authenticate the edus but one of the three he doesn't know if it's a good a they're not a good he doesn't know he never he never saw any of the signatures so what you do is you take the two a dim that you take the two on him that no they turn into adam and they say to the to the guy without the hamburger and they say look like in the you see the guy with the green arrow you'll see that's his that's his uh signature we recognize it you're here we re we recognize it we here okay good now the adam flip into diana because this is ambassador these are they are you go to bed and you have three day on them so the aiden became dayanam aid nasa diet who who are they them two of the dionym are testifying about the signature of one of the kasim of one of the guys yossi and then they flip in to a dine so it's a shots caught on alert aid nasa it's a scary concept though when you see in the picture it's nothing okay so she has a guy mr the black square if they didn't sign it they could testify on it why because it says in there in a red letter in a red word it says what klausa all three have to know about they how could two of them sign on a document that says all three of us they're know to sign on sunday off you're going to sign all three of us know and they're going to tell they're going to do this on monday that's shecker they can't sign on somebody that says we all three no we recognize the signature when only a few hours later they testified to the third guy and told me about the signature that's called the shakir but once they signed then it's too late as the gemara wait a minute but how do you even write this black document called the hempec how can you write the epic how can you write we three of us know that he dos and then we're going to testify and teach him that it's so that's what we do right we have a blank suba we just fill it in are you allowed to do that it's it's shakier right this this hemp that was written before the whole olympic the whole black document is possible it looks like falsehood says hazakish over in our case also when the two dayanam turned into ate them and they testify after it was written already forget about sign it was written you wrote it falsely ella me right actually it costs when you eat them in front of a house you're right you can't you can't write the black document first first you do the testimony everybody is familiar with the idiom now then you write it in from here we can learn three simple allah's aid nasa diet we just spoke about that that the three dionne and two of them turned into adam they testify about the signature then they go back to becoming a diet so i ate became a diet right without this gemara you you would you would for sure say to yourself it's impossible eight is an eight a dice and a dying you can't mix the two you can't make a witness a diet no you could ushmamino if the those two that know the kasimos naftali and levy they recognize it in other words if all three know and recognize the the adam then there's no need to go ahead and tell them oh by the way these are the signatures of ruben and jim we know it is in our head i don't need you to tell me and also you see over here that the one that doesn't know just because two out of the three no that's not enough each one of the three needs to hear that this is the right aid mask of la vashi suravashi even though he seems to be saying very strong we don't passing like him but he asks very good bishop the first half i'm not going to argue you see straight out black and white that first they testify and then they sit down they put on their dying clothing and they they they're making the stock so eight can become a diet but the second thing i don't believe i don't understand why because it says in the past look what it says in the past to speak it out you can't just have the knowledge in your head you must say maybe at the end of the day what's going on here is that they're saying over the haggadah and the other thing is what's your proof that each and every day must hear it maybe not what's going on over here again is this halacha that they must say it out so they said two set it to one malloy clown you don't have to tell the day on them they know it it's in their head but what they're doing over here is just being making the hero of avagada of saying it over so they use this guy as a carbon but not that this carbon needs to hear it there's a hero in the besan to say it so two set it to one yosemite will come along today said this over oh we see that eight becomes a dime a series after the revival oh look at this case your boy sir you have three ate them that saw the new moon rose lois then but they happened to be tamiya kahame they're best then they usually sit on the best then and now we know in the time of the gemara the time back then they didn't have calendars you got to see the new moon and you had to testify that they saw the new moon and then they say okay so what you have to do is this you take two out of the three and they become the adam then you take two more khrushchev guys you put them together with naftali and they become the dayanam so the aid testifies that they are and then the dayana the three guys in the bottom do what they say what should have been all we need is these three ad nasa diane so take two out of the three and they'll testify to naftali right levy and whatever his name is the guy without the hamburg are going to testify to naftali and then they three they sit down and they go oh my god why do you have to introduce two more folks over here you see that eight loynas died so the two have to testify in front of three who says that the guys on top could transfer into dayanim lomili coulee high why do i need another two laces let the two testify to one and together they'll say finally got around said so don't bring any raya from adidas over there it's the raisa and in the right so we're not going to say eight nine sedan the keem stars there's a lot of coolest throughout the whole sugiya since the whole idea of keemstar is the robot on the mako that aid nasa dayan have a wonderful day you