Daf Yomi Gittin Daf 53 by R’ Eli Stefansky

hi we're hearing from our good friend not related to nachman well I've been busy in Camp in the castles I still try my very best to find a few minutes to learn the dive with you I'm not gonna lie but if it's already a few days but thanks to the battle doesn't get me down I say the Monsieur shoe room on Spotify automatically download and went by Israel Hashem I find the time to learn I do that they missed also apologies for the people not getting any YouTube shorts or posts on Twitter since they shut it down no since I have had almost no time to make them and since it's a from Camp I don't have access to any browsers not related by Aaron Schwartz I want to thank Rob yossi whom I met on the airplane to Israel in February this year if y'all see Klein met this individual iron Schwartz on the plane he encouraged me to join the dive and check out Rebellion the daf has changed my life in many ways at 38 years old I finished my first museka it says in parentheses get them I know what that means exactly and I have now learned over a hundred pages of gamara thank you Ruby Austin I learned the last couple of weeks of Nazir with mdy and liked it so much I joined the 5 30 in Daphne mission in town I still wasn't tell me why sure but now as khazaro keep on daffing where boys are running right into the sponsors the coilo huh oh that's what he did no we did 100 pages have to see the picture let's see let's go back to the picture no he's holding volume two times there's a few there's a few shot them maybe went ahead who knows the coiler was sponsored by an atoms from Lakewood and the second Spanish words that I'm able to thank you for everything that I have foreign [Music] by New Jersey and a Hassett NJ NJ not New Jersey NJ and a Hassett our dear son Aaron on his 11th birthday a proud member of mdy kids Gibraltar Cincinnati 11 year old happy birthday I think Benny wants to sing you should Sing Happy Birthday [Music] yeah you you know the 11 year old iron let's go let's go the art of the month sponsored for complete review happy birthday to Arrow happy birthday what it's sad thing he does the deaf every day in Gibraltar [Music] happy birthday to you very first kid or any individual that ever got a happy birthday from this year like that unbelievable huh Mason that's his name you know don't tell me it's you all right we're doing the idea is when a person has a pile of wheat it only becomes when you smooth it out two different types of Fields one is a field that you purchased the one is a field that you get the Arusha different regarding joyville when you could buy a bag when you can't buy it back when a bakar gets two portions he gets double eurusha it doesn't include things that are not in the father's possession at the time of the father's death let's say somebody owes the father money and then he pays him back after the levaya the heart doesn't get two portions famous schwa of Maiden mikhtas we don't have to explain it how might even have a variety we also don't have to explain we don't have to explain should we explain now every kid knows that art of Kaplan that is a new muscle which is a guarantories Arab but he's a kablon he basically he tells the lender don't even go after the life of coming to me first so it's a whole different he's been shot himself on a higher level she booted her right so we learned if a person says I will do X Y and Z for you is he having their eyes just because he says it and we also the famous river Los Angeles usually like when he argues with other people and today we are going to be learning about hezek Shady knicker whether it's May has a national and that is Damages that you cannot tell you can't see whether or not there's damages for instance the bottom of nun base sponsored by yearly Friedman leadership so we're continuing with the theme this whole peric Islam it just happens to be a lot about nizoken and it really belongs a lot of it in babakama and the nazikian over there but we're continuing the theme of chicken Island there's certain alakas that should be one way change that for the better of the world that the to fix the world hamatami a person looks at his friends produce and he says he's going to get his friend hell what's his friend is a Cayenne he takes a rat a dead rat and he touches all the stuff or he himself has taught me he touches his friend's fruit now you can take the fruit put it underneath the microscope but you won't see that stopping nothing changed it's hezekiel you can't really see but Allah it's also for the kind to eat it or as you can see in the gimbara it could be even Cooling and also causes damage to the holy meditame certain people are makbit the prusion we have a soul right next door it's called Prussian prusam our people there's supermarket and they they only eat Hulen of tires they will only eat fruit that's not Tommy you ruined it for this guy now he has to go and and sell it cheaper or whatever it is taking a fruit let's say that's truma and putting it in a pile of fruit that's that that are not true now we don't know which fruit is truma which is not so a Israel can't eat any of the fruit a coin could eat all of it because it's too much so you have to go ahead and sell it now for truma prices which are very low you ruined different you make your friends wine how exactly did you do that either you mixed it up it is or you already took somebody else's wine let's say and you pour it in you take yeah that's already important to your friends important you didn't mean to harm your friend and you didn't cause visible damage your pottery if you do if you're if you ruin your friends produce on purpose no just as a side note there's somebody in my family who's not from and he ate by me and my father was there and he's related to my father as well and my father was all nervous the whole time during kiddish and then this individual gets up he goes let me open up the bottle of wine my father almost had a heart attack it's like no no we're gonna start making up the reasons why he of course he understood it's a big problem it's a big problem that a guided somehow shops before hessia even though he is one of the family it's a problem another issue that I saw and this was like really out there but of course I like to throw things that are really out there are you permitted to give an individual like that wine a glass of wine on Shabbos have to say there he's gonna take it he's gonna make a ineza and that's awesome and now he's drinking ISO it's like the favor the fever very good I'm talking about okay so anybody that has a kid that's off the Dare whatever deal with it I don't know you have to there's a cute story of a guy that was a big circle of wine and he hired a a wagon to take all his wine into the City and during the ride he noticed the the wagon drivers he saw his pouch of money so he stole the money put it between his barrels and it disappeared so the wagon driver took him to the entire and uh what another view of the story you sure okay took him to the Rob I don't remember his name are you talking to the Rob and the Rob said looked at the besides he denied it 100 so the road was a smart man he said okay listen I believe the two of you it's probably not you guys from guys no way but you know what it was a guy it must have been a guy who was his thoughts it's a guy so now all the wine is yeah Nessa you got to throw it out so the soccer started calculating wait a minute there's only 100 bucks in this wallet and there's three thousand dollars worth of wine he said no no it's me it's me okay here here you took it he paid for it okay foreign [Music] he mixed it up foreign didn't see this in a long time means let the stand but they're having a something in front of something that's greater than it in other words if there's ever a situation where you're over on two things simultaneously you only get the greater of the two the punishment the greater the two so if a person was Zara he went like this he's Hive me so they give him skilo he doesn't have to pay for the wine he only gets one out of the two he only has to pay he pays for his life he dies he doesn't wasn't Double Jeopardy well double Germany is different that's like you can't go after him twice it's a little different what does the lawyer say no in America I don't think different things here you should be punished yeah in America they charge for both you get for holding a concealed weapon and a murder and a second degree and ripping the cops clothes the bullet ruined the thing whatever yeah the damages that he caused yep it's this is fine so he says listen you can't say this talking about that he really didn't have a desire because he did have a desire then we wouldn't have the whole case in the mission to begin with you're not high of your friend or rap because we're talking about a situation where he lifted up the barrel of wine first he wasn't he didn't do any of a desire yet but when he lifted it up for genevo at that point he has to return the barrel of wine Mr maybe he lifted up to shake it and and to have a desire maybe he picked it up brought at this house to the to the whatever the church to do whatever desire over there whatever it was but first it was a heel of the payback and now that this other happened later so it's two different times he's crying for both foreign okay it's the same idea Veda who this is a canas why because we're holding that hezek Shane in nickel that's not visible it's not considered a hezek inas said you have to pay you really shouldn't have to pay but they penalize you they say you have to pay well because by trumo it doesn't mean that you'd be high recognized by it's two separate things who says you do learn one from the other so why do you need three cases for only say one case that a person touched his friend's fruit with the object that's Tommy or he's taught me each room what are the K what's the case it's either true he ruined it for a quiet and have I made a mission to come absolutely garment it's the reason why it's only this case because you ruined it completely what's a kind Gonna Do With It very little he could do with it you can feed it to his animal no it wasn't being worth a hundred dollars so it came out worth nothing I was just reading a whole article about feeding to the animal like somebody I think Hillel sent me this thing there's literally a thousand trucks or maybe more a day a fruit and they give the 10 percent 100 trucks go to the zoo it's a lot a lot of fruit when they take terms of measures they take the whole the whole trip advisor to give to the zoo okay so you can give it to the zoo what is it worth regardless or you could use it for for wood for fire yeah it's guard so maybe in that case I would say he's Hive but in other cases you didn't ruin it completely and let's say you're talking about a case not that it's the coins it's not truma it's cooling what does it is Sir to cause Tuma on regular fruit even Hulen in our show it's awesome I would say that that doesn't apply to the case of where you take truma and you mix it in a pile of other fruits yes again you have a pile of nice fruit and somebody takes a piece of Truman throws it in there you don't know which apples too much it's not so the whole thing turns into true that's something that's unfortunately common people who want to stuff their friends out they do that to them they take a fruit of truma throw it into a hundred thousand apples or whatever it is okay you'll say it's bottle but whatever it is where it's not bottle and they ruining it people don't usually look around for rats and then start messing with other people's stuff Emily if you ask me you know why why don't they do it because it's isn't it right so let me see if I have it I I thought maybe no okay it's answered to be my time of the fruit you asked me um and if we had those two cases we just spoke about them there's no no kinds of a community Revenue but a case of wine where is Hive Misa for making it with Zara so I think that it shouldn't pay for the wine itself commercial because every year Mia that this is possible you're right there's a there's a problem of coming with the revenue you don't have to pay but if you do what Ruby has said that the guy that first lifts it up he's kind of the neighbor it becomes his or he's now high for it and then he went and he didn't have a desire to it and then he tried to return it he can't return it why because it's not the same product that he stole he stole perfectly good wine and now it's I'm a desire one okay stop and Shiloh we're talking about the Allah of hezekiel so what is the island guy has a dog and the dog drank from a whole vat of wine the FDA comes along they look at it and they say no I'm gonna get rid of this dog might have rabies I don't know what get rid of it it's actually knicker right what what's the what's that Laffer I think I had to throw out the 20 gallons of wine whatever it is you got to throw it out what happened we're ready to go okay so we're discussing a Shiloh if a person has a dog and the dog drank from a vat of wine or apple juice whatever it is and the the authorities say you have to throw the whole thing out what is that called is does anybody have something to say you want to say something why is it out of the decision occur no no no no but when you're Midtown is somebody when you retirement somebody something it's not knicker how I also took it out of the classroom I touch your fruit and now it comes down with classroom and it's not considered designer huh so what your brother-in-law said is true he said he just you see you you'd be surprised he said he said okay so you should know your brother said that he put bacteria in there but bacteria is visible in a way if you look on their microscope you'll see what it's measurable how's it measurable yeah right if somebody puts in Poison you can't visibly see it it's considered hezek knicker because you changed the what's the word I'm looking for the the composition thank you that's exactly the word I was looking for thank you doc we missed you if you change the composition of whatever this is you could look on their microscope you see the change the poison change so too this okay that they discussed the current discuss this fine the point that sometimes is it's invisible to the naked eye but it's still considered visible hezek because under a migrants you can see it whereas Tomah even under a microscope you can't see it it's not the same thing but with me Israeli talking about no he talks over here comes with the remedy talking about Zelo I mean that's the Gosling we'll get we'll get together in a second let's if you have a shower later then you'll tell me says again tomorrow um says listen everything is good if we go in this order that we did we start off in the Tama we went to medama and then we added is before the third one then what happens it changes the second one in line because ruins the way we did we'll change it up a little bit yes if it only said one case of a person that makes his friends through Tommy you don't have the case of community so I would say that this Mission would not apply to Hawaii I ruin it completely also now the game changes it's sneaking over here a little bit now the gamar before they want to say that when you matama your friend's fruit you ruin it completely another one was saying you didn't ruin completely because you still could use it for your animal but in bait it's the same thing is not having any character saying that when I say when I compare it to something that you run completely mid Tama is not completely before we're comparing it to something that you could everybody could use so my time is rooting completely fine you're causing great laws if I take a fruit and put in a pile of good fruit so now the whole pile becomes truma it's not the greatest loss in the world I could still sell it off vertolero that's amazing so now we're going to mahogics of his exchange whether or not you have a Potter again hezek that's not visible to the naked eye or not you're completely higher even if you do it and Rashi brings this person the famous person here I learned even chuggy I would think if by mistake I ran over my friend's Cat by mistake maybe I should be Potter no pets attackers even by mistake there's no mistakes when it comes to can't say oh I burnt your house down it was my mistake I'm sorry I'm not gonna pay you anything you have to pay my timer has a chance oh so there's two ways to look at it either you're completely shaive and now we have to understand why Bishop your Potter or you can say completely Potter now we have to understand why I've been amazing you're higher so we're saying you completely Hive so I have to understand how come in this case we said by Amazing by shagging you are Pottery it's a very important thing Somebody by mistake sometimes you do mistakes and you run away you don't want people to know you had somebody's car you know back into somebody's car you dentist door you look right and left and unfortunately a lot of people they run away or if they're smarter than that they take out a pen and paper and they write a b c d e f g call one two three four five and they put on the window they run away then they start running away I never did that when I was 15 if I did it and you live in Flatbush on East please be Michael fine there's a lot of people watching and you want to be a mench so you write a note what okay well my time Potter I never license I wasn't supposed to um two doors so you want people to come forward this is this is dangerous stuff give me time in your friends stuff now even though he might not be over the greatest sister in the world it's only he's he's no idea but first of all it's not good you know what come forward and say by the way I happen to be tall man I just came back from a funeral I didn't realize if it was there I touched it all it's all Tommy you gotta get rid of it uh your car you gotta whatever it is if it's true we gotta get rid of it it's cool and whatever but I'm Potter I'm Potter so now I can come clean if I know that I'm partner I can come clean because it's uh it's uh you know it's what's the Shabbos the two brothers a true story two brothers were fighting their entire life in their 70s the Rob decided enough is enough we have to we have to make sure she calls in one of the brothers and he says what's going on here why are you thank you brother he says listen I'm never making trouble with my brother I'll tell you what happened it was poor him I bought an unbelievable tray you're talking about back in the day in your slime I bought him a beautiful tray and I put him we baked and we did we put everything in what does he send back on a tray with horse manure mud the whole thing this is what he sends back to me after we went and we we made the first step this is how he treats us it's nobody the roof goes back to the to the second brother just knew what happened he says you're not gonna believe it it's 40 years ago I'm Purim he sends us a tray mud and this is what mud he sent you a beautiful no it's modern so anyways they they called in the Sun the son of the guy the first song now the guy's already in dog this is listen I'll tell you what happened I was bringing the tray over I tripped fell the whole thing splattered into a puddle of Mud I didn't know I said I just took it put it back and I delivered it it's actually idea sometimes the kid was scared to tell his father what happened you get beat up she didn't say what happened so now they're fighting for 40 years for no reason it's the most high school for all for all the all the mcclages and they're they're basically a lot of times it's a lot of times you ask people why are you fighting they don't even know they don't they're just not in a fight something happened 10 years ago exactly what happened it's not it's not important right now we hate each other we're not in a fight is something tomorrow you want to hear something sad this is sad yeah if a guy goes ahead a Russian he wants to get his neighbor real good he sees the pile there he climbs over the fence he takes a rat and starts chuckling up the entire pile of food with Tuma let him at least because then we'll give an incentive to tell the neighbor that what he did was terrible and he ruined his fruit like this is his neighbor won't won't eat true with tomato es this guy is trying to do to harm him or you do a little more delay he's not going to tell him now it happens to me I saw you know to unlock these things there's a reason why when I go to the restaurant I never ever return my food I don't care how bad it tastes I never I watched one of those movies too many where the guys spit into the food and they know all sorts of worse things and over there they're not being my idea they just do it it happens to me there's a video camera that catches them so I don't know okay the gamara says that when you try to get your friend it's not something that you want to keep in you want to tell them there's a terrible terrible story that I once read where a guy called the authorities on his neighbor what happens I have a neighbor that actually tells me I'm gonna call Authority you better be careful in fact but the guy actually went and called the authorities the guy shows up the picacho's up the uh what do they call them in English the inspector city inspector shows up and he said he starts shutting down the whole thing out comes the neighbor and he says I call them Mouse like that use my dear he called him so the guy that got shut down turned around and cursed him he said you should have died a terrible death like curse the next day the guy that called authorities in bed for for I think for the rest of his life it said because it's a terrible thing to curse somebody Mavish should never ever curse anybody even if they do something like that but certainly do you but stayman his big thing was always just sign sign you tell people like do you say why is Michelle coming I don't know why it's a big thing just sign meaning people want to you know make an addition in their house and they go through the whole process and then the neighbors without a without good reason most of the time sorry jealousy no we're not gonna We're Not Gonna sign just sign let the guy have his extra bedroom whatever that's not the end of the world what do you care if he has another no so five toys [Music] if it's not visible the damage you're completely Potter even maze it completely Potter my timer it's not considered damage so why did they change it so then anybody could just go and ruin your friends he has a million dollars worth of fruit ruin it all and say haha I'm not high of anything sue me I'm partnering with the rice so we will miss second this is ticking Island we need to save the world we need to change things that even though there is a spotter I'm gonna make it higher we got to do another uh it is a shot spigo now if you were with us in kochem this is the most common word but piggle is the idea that if [Music] there's no problems Rika you you shut the animal you receive the blood you walk the blood over to them is back and then you sprinkle on as well if during this Rico the coin only the coin can do this he has intent to mess up the cisral is his neighbor who called the authorities on him so now it is time to get him back so his neighbor the Israel purchased the nice schmuck animal 500 this is the Cayenne Haruna for him just by thinking he thinks in his mind that we're gonna if this animal is eaten for two days a night or three days a night who's this man he's thinking about a machava that ruins the animal the ruins the carbon pigo is a thought that ruins the animal usually you don't have to say it usually you don't have to say it's Shiloh okay some say you have to say okay he thinks it now we're going to see anything more talks about saying that's it if so if this coin ruined the 500 carbon for his friend or his enemy now his friend has to buy another 500 carbon if the coin on purpose why is he high enough is going to bring a bunch of riots whether or not hezek or natural hezek over here is a beautiful ride the what to save the world we say that it's high what does that mean he's Potter only means if you tell me it should say that really when you do it by mistake you're pottery in that case of shaking it should be partnered why we want to we want to save the world that he should he should admit what he did that's the case of tiken island of saving the world that he's partnered not that he's high of hype already according to hiskio the tire tells you that if you do has a chain of knicker invisible damage your hive so it makes no sense to say if a coin did invisible damage you're Hive you know why we have to save the world that's not why because the tire says you're higher and the fact that you're telling me that you're trying to save the world is a Raya that made a rising a Potter just to save the world we said yes it's very simple and you're staring me down that's what I'm saying the most complicated thing okay good Ness yeah you're right that's exactly what it says when he did it on purpose to to mess up his friend but if he did it by mistake he's Potter he thought that this carbon is in for three days it's only even for two days but you are I messed it up I did something wrong in my mind when you brought it that's it you have to bring another one of the laws are okay another another give out the garage if a person does the paraduma yeah I just want to show you a picture that Yoshi did many many seconds ago this is Dr fact is Ritalin these are the clintons are on the cellar you're taking care of the little kids are selling okay the whole mice over there and they painted the fake paraduma okay stop reminding them whoever was here great not not again paraduma comes very very rarely it's worth a ton of money even nowadays there's a guy Upstate New York who had a paraduma and some Hasina from Barbara Park tried to buy from him he wouldn't sell it in for a million dollars he said Michelle is coming what yeah because he's really white they spray you don't see the spray cans on the bottom they spray paint this is a fake part of Duma anyway I don't know whatever they're doing there fine so what Allah is you cannot do any ubad here here's the pasok you can't do any work so if I want to mess up my friend I'll grab his million dollar para Duma and I'll write him I'll start I don't know work him can't do that if you do that you ruin the paradoma it says like this if the water what do you do with the part of the woman you burn the part of doing we take the ashes you mix it with the water and now anybody that's tummy it's my maze you sprinkle him twice on Thursday the seventh day not two times not twice two different days if you ruin his paradum a million dollars into the garbage your Potter you can't bring the guy to court but if you say that invisible damage is considered a complete hezekiel a million dollars in court or myself he asked the question and he's going to answer it we're talking about a different case we're talking about a case so it goes like this if a animal let's say a bird lands on a paraduma's back is that considered work no but let's say the owner says I want the bird to be on his back then it's then you could with your makshava you can make that work you could consider the oil comes a friend that wants to ruin this million dollar gain he's jealous his friend just made a million dollars he comes in he says listen I want you to go over here you little paraduma come a nurse from your mother that's okay also as you're nursing from your mother and your mother is going around in a circle we have this right over here this disha when the the cow just walks around and and tramples the weep and separates the grain that's disho threshing if you intend that the paraduma should do that that's working the paraduma and it's no longer part of Duma so basically he's telling this part of doing to do two things one thing that's mutter one thing that's awesome and it goes in there and does something that saucer should nurse and also do something that's awesome so now that the para it wasn't we don't know he didn't put it in there to thresh he put it in there also to nurse so how do you know that it became awesome and that's no longer paradoma because we in his mind he said it should be for disha also so what is that called that's called another Potter he only there's only it was an indirect indirect has it was in his mind and how did he ruin the mejratos he had a scale and he he used the mechatos he used the leader of or a pound of of water of the to uh and the other side he put fruit he put meat and he was weighing with the water he used the water of the mechatas as a weight and that ruins it it just happens to be I saw that my legs were shining him here when exactly to use the water because once he put in the ashes the rashford says that it doesn't become a possibly more the other is showing the ramen says it does okay fine doesn't matter whatever it is maybe it was plain water before the ashes or water with the ashes the point is he ruined vulnerable foreign I saw it even recently here there used to be a horse and a wagon come through the neighborhood and they used to sell watermelon that's the only thing remember this you guys remember and they had one of those old-fashioned scales and they've put a a fake weight that said five kilo on it it was really two kilo and it shot even five you just look at the guy you know that something's up with this it was Hollow in the back I don't know I'm making that up kids are that's what they do huh no it makes sense no you look at the guy look at the Arabs I don't know what they were terrible people it wasn't even watermelon it was probably just I don't know fine so let's go Sarah says very very good here give me this this is vanilla water okay don't be questioned seriously it's just so could you see these these lines over here on your on your camera that's what we need to see do you see them now yeah yeah [Music] right here no the angle is not so good so now take a your piece of meat and you put it in here it's water displacement so when the line goes up to a certain amount now you know how much how much volume the meat takes up and by the value they know I'm better at how much it weighs they'll sell the meat with volume so now this is this water this ash water this this is ashes that's why it looks differently you see it's not vanilla it's ashes that change the color now you use the actual physical water to weigh something you didn't just put the water on the on the side of a scale you didn't touch the water already touching water actually somebody say that the meat turns colors from I mean the water turns colors from the the blood and the meat or whatever it's not in a plastic bag like in this case but it could be in a plastic bag the point is that it's using the actual water he's a little scared let's get this let's close it quickly oh big fun when using the actual water the physical water to displace for me then you ruin it I'll be connected if you just take it and put it on the other side of the scale you didn't do anything to it and it doesn't ruin it right away and by to heal him eight mintaffs.com what I know but today I'm giving it to him next we got a whole lot to do here it's almost 12 o'clock you know that we're already 50 minutes on this thing look at you big wolf on my circle when you use the actual water you did a action with the actual water and if it's if you pass it that non-visible damage is considered has like we said you should be able to bring this to court because you did something physical and you should be higher no if he wasn't using it for displacement he was just using it for to sell watermelon on that with those scales if somebody has one of those scales he could donate them the wild use it a lot does it comes up in the game a lot those old-fashioned scales or I'll buy one in America what does now what the there is Apostle care for this it better be here here this should be it voices and you you can't be messy of that you can't think about other stuff if you are selling things and doing other things you must see of that like we said about villain you can't wear it filling if you're gonna see if that's now the beautiful story about hezel that's because it's Mata Chavez in the safer shimus shotiro he brings that about rebellious like an incredible way Mama is like better than the Belzer not seriously very very high level so he said because he was never massive Blast from tiger it wasn't myself ever in his life to save that so they asked him these guys it's so annoying he said to me okay so keep on no what does it mean not the Museum of Das how long is that's terrifying if you you read the Bible answer if you know what's going on you you know that it's not it's it's Ms there's a thousand stories I know about reaction there no I heard it's MS he had the key to the Mikvah this is not a nice story but it explains exactly his personality the key to the Mickey Mouse Line and some annoying guys would always like sneak in when he would open it up in the morning then sneak in so he told him listen I have to go learn if you're not going to be out before me I'm gonna have to lock up and he would lock them in there whoever wasn't out before lock there's no I have to go learn every second matters and that's it you want to sneak in sneak in but make sure you out before me there's nicer messages in there but that that one stuck in my head right now tomorrow I've been steals he's a goddess he stole coins and they took it out of circulation it's worthless today trumanism he took truma he stole truma and became Tom and he didn't do it but a dead rat fell off the roof and hit the truma now it's it's worthless he stole Pizza he didn't make Peg peso have made itself I didn't do anything to it I didn't there's no physical thing here it is but if you say it's considered hezek hi Gosling who holds that or not I forgot which one holds what I think let's get my nut holder hi guys [Music] this is again in the pasok I don't know what that's doing there you have to give back exactly what you stole so if hezek Shane and knicker schmeh has it was considered that there's physical damage here then you didn't give back what you gave what you stole but if it has exchange then you gave back here I didn't do anything to it there's no physical thing take it back but over here it's Smash Mouth that you should she should you should have to pay why did they pay so you see that says Exchange in English foreign it's not consideration so why does your mayor says we're going into sugey now this is the soya another exciting jazz do we penalize somebody that does something to show you because of Mason amazing we have to give a penalty we have to give me canas but we should also give a knob you know why because if you don't then people are gonna be they're going to do it on purpose and they're gonna say I was oh mistake I didn't know I by mistake I touched it I'm tall man I touched with my eye I didn't realize that mistake so you say yeah mistake very good but you have to pay so I was kindness sure you got the amazing so now even all the way through tomorrow we're going to be dealing with this shoig automation yeah very simple do we make a class do we say we give a guy a penalty even though he's shaking and he doesn't deserve a penalty but if we don't we have a problem with the amazing part so across the board whether you're amazed or a shaky do it on purpose no matter what the marsal of our mayor holds amazing the reason why shocking amazing are both Hive in our mishnah Yuma time is somebody's fruit bishoyag because amazing um okay very good that makes a lot of sense but we have a problem we're almost reviewed at the review that we're gonna have a contradiction to confuse the Islam we made a beautiful chart a scare a mama scare you okay it's we so first of all we don't have to know anything about everybody but what's very cool about this chart is you could see that the mesod of Ruby mayor the red words on the top line are identical to the red words on the second line of review though and the purple words on the second line of reviews are identical to the purple words that's not a hundred percent it's a Rashi that's that argues with it a little bit but one ratchet says like this one right says like that okay the bottom line is I like to say this all the time let's throw it in again people have to learn okay that being said a guy went ahead and cooked them Chavez this is a we could cook on Travis also I was in somebody's house I saw him cooking in Travis by mistake you didn't know that you can't do this in this with the oven whatever it was a lot of Allah is with the black and the I don't know them very well and I I stay away from it even with a crackpot you put stones on the bottom you miraculate the the thing you just you put your whole thing into like you buy it it might be a big problem you have to put like Silver Falls on people with silver I would think you know if you don't know how long you could be over and Bishop every every child is fine the guy didn't know that Allah his friend comes in and said listen you just cook the whole thing on with the crackpot but you can't use it unfortunately it's a vegetable Shabbos so what do you do so remember holds since you didn't again we have to knock down okay Ramirez says you could eat it right then and there the amazing here's the question what does it mean Rashi and always showing them how old means just right now on Shabbos and after Chavez he could eat it and when I say after Shabbos it means she also as long as it takes to cook up the food so if it takes huh no you're gonna go with this yes now if there's a Rashi not over here but these are actually that says in the art school for some reason goes with this rash I'm not exactly sure why because it doesn't seem like that's how it is and then if it doesn't go with that Rashi the rash it says forever okay but it's also not important to us right now the point is so if we stop right over here we have a big problem what does remainder say if a person inadvertently Cooks some Choppers he doesn't know chab is today or he doesn't know that cooking is awesome or this method of cooking is also yeah a good a good example of cooking and Chavez I'm not saying this is awesome but I saw people now my kids want to do this because they love these uh instant soups you take water out of the you throw it into the soup on Shabbos and people say it's 100 what's the problem I said to me it just seemed like it's not mother and I was looking for reasons why it's not but then it's it could be it's water it could be it's Bishop Collins isn't that but this little there's a lot of ingredients in there maybe those are okay I'm not going into that but let's say let's say that it's awesome so here people they just take the hot water but no it's cliche take the hot water two three yeah and then you throw it into the soup the soup mix and they eat soup panchamas let's say it's awesome and I I find that it's awesome but according to your mayor what do we say ing according to your mayor it should be awesome you made a mistake amazing he says you can't eat it when Mata Shabbos forever whatever it is but makes it why is he making a distinction between amazing you just told me that remainder holds coins him shagging automated if a guy's met Thomas somebody else is Fruit by mistake Ramirez says he's Hive why because Mason and sugar are the same so over here in Chavez make the dragons will be the same that's question number one no no we're not talking about liquor now we're talking about the idea now we're switching suggests why why I hold coins in in everything what's the difference is just go off but 20 minutes of that is the zoom bomber yeah [Music] and if you look around you right on the side of this it says so we're just going to say a reverse virus here Romero says there's a difference a friend's fruit that's the rabbanon people don't care so much about yeah it's just ah just the red bottom I'm going to be that I'm gonna I'm gonna give you a penalty with the wrestle economists people are very scared it says not to do something so they're not going to start cooking on Chavez it says it says the case of and that's it's the riserable honestly no because the Visa is so bad I gave him an extra penalty they do that they really like cash kilikonis when is reviewed and not doing economics if they're a Bono but there is a conus the opposite Mama stops the reward because a person is or even on their eyes I'm going to give him a penalty oh but that's the rise of electronics but is the rest and review the absolutely mayor who holds his knocking us when it comes I don't have to because it's so Commerce of Desire even the worst of the words and I'm gonna bring a contradiction I think I even did a one second no these buttons are not working Gary remind me these buttons are not working here so just stop what is he could eat you don't you don't do amazing okay and now the gamar is going to bring this case how about should we show you which is the mayor says since the Striking we're not going to give you a penalty you can eat now we're gonna see a case of the Eraser person who planned something on shmita which is right sir according to Mayor I give him a penalty you have to uproot the tree well it's not fair how come on child is I don't give him a penalty and give him a penalty if a person plants a tree on Shabbos they'll show you you're allowed to keep it amazing oh and that fits very well with remainder but on shmita the prowess from shmita baby mayor I give him a penalty on shemitah so the question is going to be from Shabbos you don't give him a penalty foreign that itself is a problem you said the difference between Shabbos and shemitah Chavez you you said that according to your mayor you don't give him a penalty what's what's going on because of course you have to come on to the reason over there or remember so what's going to happen is that if I don't make the guy uproot his tree so people are going to say what year fruit is this it's it's after Irma wait a minute when did you plant it oh you planted on shmita oh you let it plant trees on shemitah you're gonna mess people's minds up people are going to think because of you now you're a lot of plans on shemita they're going to start doing calculations go backwards revive the fourth year you're not revise like Meister Cheney if you have a fourth year tree you have to take all the fruit and only eat in your slime and if you can't take all your fruit your slime you can redeem it with money bring the money there's nothing what people are going to do calculations and see that you planted on chemita so you say uprooted and another reason naturally is I don't have to penalize anybody for Shabbos I have to I have to give a penalty on shmita because people are not so good with me hold on let's just do this because I don't understand it so I just want to get over it now I don't want to start tomorrow with this [Laughter] what do you need to know what we just said people you don't need another one is wait a minute some people could count backwards and figure out that you planted it on Jarvis oh what's going on here so in order for something to be our law or not our law it has to be past three years but you don't need three full years mixers so if I get 30 days of of one year before Rosh Hashanah like from it's really six weeks from two Buffs let's just call it 30 days okay not to confuse it 30 days before Ashana from the shallow if I planted before it's going to show then it's it's considered a whole year so what happened was three years later this is the part I understand so well three years later a guy's eating from from the fruit comes his name says isn't that Arlo this is no no it's not Arlo I planted it 30 days before Roshana the guy goes oh that came out on Chavez you see you allowed to plant the tree in Shabbos so I'm not sure how three years later this guy's gonna make a calculation and manage and what if he planted it 31 days before no so it has to be that the guy said the best shot I've seen to just a little bit to understand the guy said no I did it exactly 30 days before and because in those years they were all Geniuses they all knew the the the calendars Inside Out backside forwards so when you're eating today the guy is going to make a quick calculation that 30 days before Rosh Hashanah fell out of the Shabbos huh you mean everybody knew it they're all Planters you're right they're all farmers and they knew that this but but maybe Planet 36 days before and then it's for sure 30 days it was only if he said specifically I did it 30 days yeah yeah fine oh so for that so much again so for that Demar says no nobody's question is nobody's going to plant on shops they might plant them banana Shabbos but boys I have a wonderful wig a wonderful day