Daf Yomi Eruvin Daf 98 by R’ Eli Stefansky

[Music] good morning rabbi sai we had a little trouble with youtube last few days i don't know hopefully it straightens itself out otherwise we have to figure something out the youtube or the regular the screen it's on an angle but okay it looks better for you great today's sheer sponsor lulunishmas it's great to see the owen schwartz ah that smile from the five pounds sponsored by mordechai sponsorship if you haven't had a chance yet to see the new and improved weekly newsletter said the second edition so more has a positive he's in charge of the he he donated his the the section for children he gives it somewhere else and he gave it to us that whole thing should be a way to get more people to learn torah to to get us closer to one another today's share is sponsored by dr alan listenhouse the memory of jose diana's 83rd yard site iron harrisburg by his grandchildren beverly fink doctor here he goes again remember they're all doctors dr alan estas dr michelle nordlich dr cindy dabrinski is the shaman i just found that was released from the hospital if you look down here from our statistician he says like this today's death according to texas i have a streak going 375 days according to rashford yo bergman only two days on the bottom he says he holds like titus so good we got that sock here but there's an asterisk next to my streak oh so we have a few mills here from khaim kessler from baltimore another baltimorean after we started nate middaf i was wondering lately why my eight-minute commute home from work seemed to be taking so much longer now i can use my productively again keep up the good work haim kessler baltimore doylecon if the wedding's in lakewood you're invited to stay at my house maybe i shouldn't have read that maybe it wasn't meant to be red um from rebellieser from the five towns first rebellio mazda van g's engagement should we invite the good news in their second sorry i didn't come through with this video and third of all ice i i was looking for a better uh translation a taitch better type device he writes here symbolic connection he holds okay they say there since uh youtube cut out right when we're starting the mission we're like one line into the mission so just take it on tap from the beginning of the mishnah and if yeah avada it's one week to see them next sunday go ahead to give in answers by this monday how many people came to see him last time wow 67 people last time at rbs so avi factor is once again hosting in in the uh alley sort of it's an outdoor serum large screen uh projector it's that okay uh the rest of the world the new yorkers i think just fell asleep and uh whatever we'll they'll have to figure it out and muncie no no mutsy's not new york okay don't don't worry about it we're talking about bob park bar park and then the five towns kits are the making of because i'm not doing the night shoe you know how it works zak was sitting on his stoop on this scufa and we're going to see in the gemara whether this is what is it and the safer in those days the safer was something like this it fell out of his hand but he's holding on to it he's still holding on to it in terms of the arizona when we're learning you have to do an akira and you have to lift something up and put something down if you still remain still remains in your hand there's no hanaka so what's the problem here it's only the abundant kind of question since the rest of it fell out of your hand it's rolling on the ground if you bring it back to yourself you might make a mistake next time and bring something back from there just this rooftop he's on the roof same kind of idea but different i just didn't have patience to print another picture so ignore this wall on an angle that gemara is later gonna talk but here's a guy on the rooftop a nice picture he's on the roof he's reading from a safer and it rolls down different idea because the top of the roof is rushed there's no there's no argument at the top of the roof this of the ground you you may bring it back to yourself roll it up bring it back when it reached within 10th falcon of the ground so that there shouldn't be a bazillion to the safer so you show this part you don't let anybody see the inside it's less of a bizarre you see the white man so yeah the picture yesterday even if it's within one needle of the ground you can still have the right to bring it back to you it has to be laying on the ground everything will be explained in the gemara shimino here comes rob shimon even if it's touching the ground you still have the right to roll it up bring it to you why he explains maybe one day you'll come to if we allow you today you might do it tomorrow but when it comes to design of a safer we don't want a hush of a safer to be on the ground nothing about daffodils any safer you do safer it could be navi it can be anything so it's on the ground the design we take away that is rabbana and allow you they didn't make zerus they made it zero and comes to the baseball they didn't make zero when it comes to the safer says the gemara high school dummy what are we talking about if we're talking about that this stoop this guy going back to here if this is a pure meaning it's fourth by fort falcon and it's 10 tall so you'll see why it's like this okay let me show that but if it's a real rush or a problem four by four and ten tall the camera's just arriving right in front is or she's a rabbit going and we're not concerned that it might fall out of your hand you might come to take it pick it up shimini so the first part of the mission so if that's the case if that's the shot the reason why if you're sitting on a stoop and it falls off from it's still in your hand i'm allowed to roll it up because i'm not concerned when it comes to this video so about the second case review is talking about is on a stoop that goes according to a shipment then there's a second case the guy is on the rooftop review that sticks his thing in that it says as long as it's not touching the ground i don't care it could be within a millimeter of the ground you can still roll it up and then you have for a second time around shimano feel about it we'll go to there so even if it's touching the ground you can roll it up versus that doesn't make so much sense of a safer shimmer also the same person shimon is saying the same thing and in between his thing they they they put in them they should say if it's fell off as a stoop and a roof from says why are you telling your shiman a sandwich rip ship in the beginning you're streaming at the end and reviewed in the middle it doesn't work so well this is a question raise your savior in says we have no choice yes okay it's a little bit interesting typically we don't do that it doesn't flow so well that's the shot register for rip shimmin mitzi oso rabbi yehuda so just to make it a little easier maybe we go through the whole serbia in 10 seconds here i'm going to put it on a platter for you the case is guerrilla safer means you're on your stoop you're right in front of your house and it falls off why what are we talking about according to that if this is we don't care because we're talking about kiss fake kaidos according to rabbo we're talking about ischool funny dresses meaning it's in a scufa that people walk by it's a stoop that's right there on 13th avenue and people keep on going back and forth the safer falls out onto the floor people are going to step on it it's a problem it's a special case the third shot is abaya says we're talking about in a scufa that's not as tall as you thought you thought it's tenth no it's a little less than ten for him and therefore it's it's a scufa that's a karmas that's what we're talking about here and in that shadow of abaya we have two them either it's a very long timeless so he's going to remember by the time he gets this house that he's in a caramel or we hold mahalo that is when a person is walking he's actually every time he puts his foot down on the ground he he takes a a stop in slow motion he's stopping and he's standing and that's what's going on here so let's see it inside and everything will be explained just wanted to give a background to what we're talking about here so it's not too confusing so the first shot we just did and that is we're talking about kisfie kaidish so we don't have the zero of the rabban on he might come to carry it rabbah omar what is it two four six eight lines from the top rabbi mahakabi schoof and it dresses we're talking about it's in a place that has many people going by um however when it comes to a roof we don't have this problem there's no there's no people that walk by the roof stoops people walk by this particular stoop people are walking by and there's a special header when it comes to brazilian doesn't like this it says in a bryce and rashi says i have no idea what this price is but this price seems to be very powerful that it changes the way the sugiyo works even if the safer rolls out and it rolls less than four arms onto the ground in other words it keeps on rolling like you know like those rolls of toilet paper to get out of hand it kept on rolling rolling eight feet away from you then if it's less than eight feet less than four hours now think about it the gemara is telling us something new that we didn't think about before here's a concern what's what's the difference if it went four almost less than four hours over here's a new concern not that you might come to carry it you might come to carry it for amazon that's the problem you're going to go to the end of it and pick it up and start bringing it to your stoop that's a different concern so you have concern number one that you might go from raven to say concern number two is you might carry four albums two different concerns it's the same idea they both issued their isa to carry me that this is a foreign of bizarre inquisition we're concerned people going to step on it so who cares what is it that rice is oh i forgot to close this one though okay so this one is also a problem the both problems okay so what is the difference what the pro what the issue is is number one i might carry from through i don't care you know why because it's kissing kaitish i'm not so worried problem number two you might come to carry four almost all of a sudden i'm concerned but it's kissy akaidish i shouldn't be concerned this stoop is less than ten for him tall we have stoops like that only three four steps up you don't have 10 fahrenheit versus arabim or versus if it falls within four hours the nfl might surely rabona what happens if you go ahead and you bring it into your timeless nothing josh however if it goes further away from you now you have another concern so the concern number one that you're going to go from raven through we got rid of we eliminated why because you're not a nurse you happen to be sitting on a caramelist on a stoop that's within 10 of the ground in my mela that's not a it's their iso what's the worst case scenario right now to roll it up is only xero maybe maybe what maybe you'll come to carry from surrounding to the caramelist that's not a problem that's only the rabbana however if it's more than four hours away from you that's is the rights of carrying foreign but wait a minute where's the stoop the stoop leads into your house the house is so you might carry it from it fell onto the ground which is around him you'll pick it up and bring it into your house the caramel is only leading into your house it doesn't stop you from going to your house yeah okay so this particular school happens to be a caramelist but in in three inches from that escufa goes right into your should say after your house you don't have a school for us in the middle of a versus rabbit the schoof is the stoop leading to your house so how come i'm not concerned you might go into your house it's very smart and if you'll tell me even the mafseck is caramel is less limbo you know why because you're going from retrosuraban you stop off in a carmelus and then you're going to go through so the fact that you made a stop and the caramel is you're not over anything in order to be over the riser from going from surrounding yourself perhaps you have to go straight direct you can't do a stopover and since you stop over losing a caramelist maybe you're not over i'll prove to you that that's not true well my robo a my brother cravers look at this you schmuck a picture guy's a trick he's walking rushes to robin but he carries the book above his head now above his head is more than 10 more than 10 him is a mocking tour you could carry in a mocking tour so he's walking above his head what did he do he did in that kira he lifted up the the book in russia's route he placed the book down in this round he did he did uh but in between his forearms sorry he did not kill his right place him but in between that the whole walking was in the himmel it was in the tour but and and he had it passed by above him so may love by us also don't be a tremendous and say oh i'm going to go for mr raven through i'm going to go from the from the from the from the big 13th avenue into my house which is just like but since i'm going through a caramelist and a school for this less than 10 i'm not going to go over anything why because i just went through a mock computer so to speak but only shows no you see that even if you go into making the rice completely says has to be talking about along your issue so in abayo chat number one he says this scufa is a caramelist but we have to explain that it's a caramelist that's very long so what if it's longha so he'll remember that he's carrying in a caramelist it takes a while to get to his house he'll stop that stopping is considered a rest stop that's a real stop it's a real pause in a caramelist and therefore it negates the akira of the rabbit he lifts up and rushes to rabbit and in order to be over there right so he puts it down but since he made a real stop in a caramelist so you no longer have the akira in the mushroom no okay that's a little bit far to say oh we're talking about a very long school no it fell on the floor you're gonna pick it up you're gonna check it out you're gonna look at it you're gonna read from it mma law that's that's a stop so you're not stopping because it's it's longing you remember you're stopping because you have a college degree books you want to you want to look into it maybe he's going to check it out in versus robin but that's the stop in which is rabbit but eventually he's just going to take it and go for mr surrounding so as he's walking past the karmalis he could be walking he could be running it doesn't matter but every time he places his foot and if you think about it you how do you walk you place your foot it doesn't slide it stands still and you lift your toes up but whatever you're doing you made a complete stop your body is not moving your toes hit the ground and they stay there that's staying there yes your knees aren't moving the rest of your body's moving but your foot is on the ground solid on the ground not moving that not moving according to venazzai is a complete hanaha so what you did is you did an akira russian you walked through the karmalis the scufa that's less than 10th falcon you walked yes you were moving but benazi holds it's standing still and then therefore you're not over any director even in case you might be going into your house where you say which you shouldn't but just in case you're not over there isa because you made a complete stop halachic stop in the carmelis says the gemara of the missouri gloom israel maybe i'll take the safer and throw it now we know this gemara already we were born with this gemara to us it's obvious the answer but it's because of this gemara maybe you're going to take the safe and toss it toss the safe and therefore you'll be over so you don't have been as a a pause there's no pausing there's no toes you're throwing that walking is considered pausing all the time he admits that throwing your over it's as if you went from a rabbit here you see here we go ahava is probably a man even though it's a very feminine name we would think and now we learned the other day that ahava was a boy it's not barahava or woman fine joyce marius from here you see you saw it plus it's not a big but you need a gemara to tell us this you don't throw a safer it's not proper to throw swarm all right zogdemar we're talking about you're on a scufa you're on a stoop and you're allowed to roll up the safer why one shot is according to rip shimmy rav you that says the name of shipman special dispensation for kids fake kaidos we're making the whole the whole problem is xavier he might come to carry it might fall completely out of his hand he might pick it up not when it comes to civic critics we're not going to be guided because of the design of this farm second shot is rabbo that we're talking about a special case of these screwfunded dresses it's a stoop that many people walk by there and since they'll be on the ground there's a real reason to be concerned that people will step on the supreme kaidish therefore we allow you to bring it in and abaya finally says we're talking about the scufa which is less than tenth fakhim and it's a caramelist either the shot is that it's long and therefore you'll remember we're not concerned that you might walk right by the cameras and go from you'll remember in between or the shot is even if you don't remember but just walking according to banaza is considered it's as if you stopped still in the cameras since there's a camera between the resources it's as if you stopped there and there's never an issue that arrives at the walk from which was a rabbin when there's a caramel in between so it says in the mishnah he's on the rooftop and where's the picture in the middle of reading and this safer fell out and if it's less than less than if it came within 10 him on the ground he can't bring it back to him he has to flip it over that's the gemara oh me shari you allowed to flip severe tires italia is a cipher he has a big problem all sorry from the you can write a whole secretary in one day so you're writing a safety what do you do when you're done for the day you want to protect it you don't want dust you don't want flies whatever it is touching your ink later yeah do not flip it over that is a bizarre that's not nice to take a safe and flip it upside down ella put yourself lettuce have begged put a nice sheet over it something so how come by us you're flipping flipping is not it's not proper it says says rashi two lines from the bottom of us he simply it's a talking about a case he doesn't have he doesn't have a sheet to go over it taiso says if you look at the small tysons came there's no reason for rashi to say such shot why because for whatever reason you're not allowed to bring your safe attire home and that is the zigzara so how in the world could you take a sheet out of your closet and cover the safety tyra what if it falls out of your hand and you're gonna go grab it the whole reason i can't bring my safety tire back and roll it up is because i might come to grab it if it falls out of my hand so you're gonna introduce a second object and that might fall out of your hand and you might go get it so there's no reason for raj to say he doesn't have a baguette so we're talking about that he cannot bring a beggar for whatever the reason is raj says he doesn't have one so what should i do now well it's not nice to flip a savateur upside down but it's worse to keep it regular and people see it hanging dangling the entire shabbas so mellow you should flip it upside down and from here the famous shach says that when you finish learning you should close your safer and if you don't close your savior he says you'll forget your learning and says yeah you'll forget your learning if you leave it over an extended amount of time not not every you know these people that they get up to go get a safer they ride away clothes are safer okay yesterday maybe says the gemara alexav so you flip it over onto the other side so you see the white part of the part fragrant what is the problem like we said especially if you're with us for shabbos you know these inside out you need to knock kira you need to lift something off the ground and you need to put it back down on the ground but if it's dangling off a roof there's no hanaka it never it never rested anywhere so roll it back to you what's the problem because we're talking about a wall on an angle so there is a hanaka halal let's consider it's resting it's resting on an angle on the angle part but you came to the lemon so you're telling me that it's on an angle aima does how do you explain the rest there's no problem bring it to yourself bring it roll it up even if it's dangling uh one millimeter but at the end of the day if it's thing if it's only one if it's on an angle like like rova says who cares if it's one millimeter off the ground the ground is not important now it's resting on a wall why because the wall is on a on an angle if he let go of it it wouldn't go anywhere let's say you don't even have to come out but it's resting so what are you telling me oh but it's one millimeter off the ground the ground there's nothing here you're right that's not the path in memory of my mother shane don't bat aaron harrison blah blah sponsored by the austin and tobias family grandchildren literature was our bobby this is then you have a budo review but what if it's not on an angle and then in parentheses over here there's aleph you take out the two dots it's not a new sugar sorry it's a continuation review and on that review that says forget the three thumb typically you say love in a second we're going to see he said no there's no water over here it's not on the ground it's not on the ground you could roll it up why the inon review the holds is something physical you can't just say oh it's within three to on the ground and i have love and it says if it's touching the ground no it has to be on a physical ground it has to be literally on something so the gemara says i love this one of the coolest lines in shots you say this people think you're cool so we had this what does it mean question of if something's flying over over the ground could we say that halachically the ground absorbed it it's as if it landed so according to abanon it has to literally land on the ground and robert comes and says so what rava only stated according to review ruby is the one that says that it must be touching the ground ground and threats facing within the ground that the whole tire is full of love and love beloved when it comes to this allah there is no lover so who says this review though we don't really pass him like you be but he never even mentioned that there's an argument in rabbana he said he took it for granted in chavez that if it's within three falcon of the ground there's no clue to commission it's as if it didn't land but that's only ruby huda that says it didn't land others say it doesn't land it did land it's within three two it says anything within three falcons as if it touches what he just said it as if it is if it's on an angle like rover answers then it says if it's resting alpha because but if it's not an angle yet less than three he could roll it up to himself he holds that if it's even one millimeter off the ground we don't say love it when it comes to hanaka and but that's that's really who the fight we're holding by mishnow we got 10 minutes left okay we got to slow down here how are you and remind your own stuff don't be don't be shy shameless welcome to the club how you doing and daddy kornbluth i don't wanna whatever i'm a little upset i don't see your children anymore you're not we gotta get these guys back we gotta get them back what's going on here and hell where are you hello here you're in there just rob you're over there oh that's right i'm sorry you said you said you're doing uh assume in los angeles i should have been paying attention sorry okay he'll see him in los angeles where you have a place there you're gonna hang out by your friend and do it by your friend okay fine say that richer surrounding even though the house itself inside is there we should say okay oh cause here very nice and here this will even emphasize what he's saying more check this out that's part of the window a windowsill that extends outside of the house what is that so since like ellie just said the whole house the outside is like uh but over here this is part of the inside window the ledge the ledge by the way rabbi i might have mentioned this but a tremendous thing i think maybe it's not even called the ledge i shouldn't even say this myself but why not you guys don't know i think it's called in chicago that was what used to be the tallest building in the united states the sears tower that was the wilson tower so a from guy my best friend in those days in chicago mike upstate he built by himself well he didn't screw he built the ledge it's like the stop the sky deck over it's like 90 floors it's very he took me there because he had the keys completely dark building you walk into the wilson towers took me up to the top brought me onto the ledge at night unbelievable the ledge so if you have a ledge sticking out i think it's called the ledge maybe it's called the sky deck i don't whatever let me show you there's a ledge this is that is the ledge of the world i mean the other ones now over a grand canyon whatever but the ledge you have a ledge that comes out of the window it has to be tenth high and four falcon wide like nice and i love the night number shabbos i could take things put it on the ledge i have a a cup put it on the ledge says the gemara um here if you just want to see what a ledge looks like here we're going to use this picture soon but here here's a window here's your ledge it says the gemara oh hi this is the map what's going on here elaine with the mapping lucha sarabin it's over sarabin what's what's going on here enough of what if your object falls off the ledge it's very normal for things to fall off ledges and we have to be geyser hello the map so you have to say no i'm not going to because it's over my backyard sean it's over your backyard was a big deal it goes from your house to your backyard so what's the what's the big dish in the mission of course haley managed to borrow him look at this beautiful picture of yoni if he puts glassware and it's going to fall down and break there's no concern you're not going to go get it look what he did here he put a ladle here i just colored her a little bit because black and white he put a ladle and he there's an x a ladle will be awesome for you to put on the ledge you have to make a distinction if it's something it's not going to break and it'll fall down you'll go get it you can't do that it's a very important insight why based on this aside here's a little bit of a trick question can you think of a reason we said oh we always say if you have a makhan tour you have something that's less than four talking by four mill versus the raven below tenth above three you let it undo your bundle put it on top of a a little beam in the middle you're allowed to use it it's a mockingbirth can you think about a reason why if you have a mocking tour sticking out of your bedroom window you're not allowed to put anything on it it's what's the problem for me to put something on a mock-up but based on this idea that we just said we're very concerned that you're gonna drop something off the ledge rashi says an amazing thing here it's not that if you're gonna drop something off the ledge it's when you're going to drop something off the ledge it's guaranteed you're going to drop something off the ledge and if it's guaranteed they're going to drop something off the ledge it's as if you threw something off the ledge that's what he says major kiddusher so if that's the case let's see what the gemara says that explains the next few lines here this we've learned the very similar brightest that's typical the bright side adds a little bit on the mishnah there's a little ledge in front of the window how you those raven goes over there's just a wrap nice and i love look look at this if you notice the wording here it's all things that are breakable kawaras the kaisai's plates and and and cups all things that are going to break in other words the only items i'm allowed to put on the ledge are breakable because if they do fall mordechai cells are showing him i haven't seen you in three months how you doing so i'm not i'm not concerned um this is check it out if this ledge goes from side to side it continues i could use it even if it's the whole length of the wall and nothing to do with my window unless it goes with intent him to the ground but what if there's two two shelves the guy has two shelves outside a ledge and another ledge two ledges he could use the bottom one like you see in this picture the entire length of the wall ubelian but in the upper one a niche damaged points out here that the the point is just to tell you that don't think that it's difficult to get to look i have to reach over this ledge to get to the battle no you could still use a ledge because if if if there's only one ledge i don't care where it is next to the window below the window as long as it's not within 10 on the ground i can use the ledge so who cares if there's two or one suspicious i would think there's a difference i can't get to it hey look so very interesting if you look closely over here in the blue lines the upper one i'm limited to this area to where the window stops and starts i cannot use the extension whereas the bottom when i use the entire wall and the top one i can't why so mario explains hi zuzidami what are we talking about what kind of ledge it is if it doesn't have fort fachem then it's a making turn as we explained before i don't know if you want to see rashid because we don't have that much time uh i can't even tell you where it is it's like six lines before it gets wide rashi most of them fall most commanders it's as if you're throwing it into resistance that's what ashley says okay let it carry over here according to what rashi said because most of the time it's going to fall and even even breakable objects i can't use why unbreakable objects if it's kashmishi talder i'm always using it even breakable objects are awesome if it sports why because damage why is he limited to the blue line he should be able to carry the entire length of this ledge because the bottom one is very wide it's fourth so you could use the entire length but the upper one doesn't have fourth it has fourth fachem with the actual windowsill that's within the house sorry so therefore connected that's why i could use only the area within the window within the blue line the lino rashi the mark was it's like the holes in a window like we use the lush and higher versions of them like a hole in the wall like that but this part and this part you cannot use why because it doesn't have for him it's not fourth white says the mushroom and we had the submission we're very familiar with this a number of times and move an object in another resource and we're not concerned says rashi that you might come and pick it up and bring it into your shoes and now you're doing a real like bring the resistor i'm not concerned i'll move it there's a kid here look great picture why is he doing it because he wants to bring the pail move it in another his whole body is in versus rabbit he wants to get the kid a toy versus the rabbit in reverse don't move it more than four amos a person should not stand in one and relieve himself hashem i couldn't find the picture in yoni for this but i did find the picture of this of a guy spitting yeah so you can imagine he's standing over here he's spitting into the once you dislodge the spittle in your mouth wow that's a big one so you're walking reaches the robin and you have something going on and you go whatever and you dislodge it now it's like ready to leave your mouth so it's awesome for you to walk four hours because you're carrying within your mouth have a wonderful wonderful day foreign [Music] uh don't hear anybody what's up jay spitzer malaysian from toronto how you doing you're doing well all right st hold that hold on forget forget the day the nightshare hold it out youtube tour anytime you'll get there you'll get there [Music] what's going to be with football ah you guys in toronto don't do football okay fine i'm not crazy though you might okay got it every day one o'clock two o'clock there's a bunch of guys you saw hybrids probably now in florida i don't know where are you stroll in florida here it's one o'clock in the morning what's uh it's not uh uh robbie twersky chicago who else is here yo lily o bergmann if he could do it anybody could do it it's not only y'all by the way you know yo bergman when he wakes up and watches the share his mother has to be right next to him so it's the homispah over there it's a whole family of fear hi old how you doing i'm not going to be there for the scene no these are hashem no it's better to be an architectural first team i promise you you're not the only one you know he but he has the ability mati mati mati he has the ability to make you feel like he's your best friend he has that kayak thank you thank you right i was reading this about uh who was it somebody who's just sniffed her like every person felt their best friend y'all has the kayak in the united states is doesn't have a hard time now with the whole covert like getting into people's houses with them wow so he he must love biden he loves biden biden probably real estate and our trolls going up like crazy now everybody wants to run away wow wow but you know daddy cornbluth daddy called me you gotta tell him even when he has this job he has to pop in once in a while we literally haven't he was the he was the main guy walking around some