Daf Yomi Eruvin Daf 94 by R’ Eli Stefansky

good morning rabosai how's everybody doing today's share sponsored by mordecai in honor of my wife who encouraged me in parentheses strongly when a man says strongly i think he means strongly to embark on this stuff journey wow kola kavod special with the focus on the yoyo me and the clever i hope it can stay the course valdic we should all honor our wives whether they encouraged us or not but they're a very big part of this reforest land for my brother azaria jonathan schmuel ben leone he needs a liver transplant early has recently been admitted to the icu and reform and the saga continues here's sort of uh hopefully this is the end of it this is by keith reich the attorney the real estate attorney in honor of shalom bias and in parentheses mdy you should be fighting over politics we have two emails today from two guards this is a very special email to me this is from rabbi bernard david from manchester i've been borrowed i've been hashem recruited a new member ex-liverpool rebel lies a wolfson tower daf family shir khaburo so two things the reason why it's so special to me is better than any aged wine and that a renew recruit is the best gift one can give me personally and to the hulk however the fantaira it's amazing but i want to say this also we just discussed one idea one line change the world and a little over two and a half years ago when david he came he saw one of the shoe room i think it was and he asked if he could join the whatsapp group and before we knew it he's saying that he has a chabura in manchester the manchester habura you see from schwartz and different people and at the time we didn't realize we were small growing cheering chamish and he's saying he's a kabura in manchester that joins us every day on youtube and it's possible that he was the original offshoot of mdy and by him saying it and and talking about it it grew to what it is today so again one man's idea you never know where it goes rabbi david and now his son libya every day is in the basement mdy watches the sheer live on the screen because he doesn't have a smartphone or anything with together with nakhla seltzer and avi factor and avigar one of the originals here's another one i don't know if you guys remember although in the beginning of broadcast we had bernie the burn so this is robbie bernard leaptag rebelli i started learning rambam myomi when the cycle began on youtube i do a paragrade today's paragraph is in this paragraph and today's daf irvine it is amazing when when and the the his email is my torah worlds collide it's uh it's a way that kojiboko pats you on the shoulder and says he's doing a great job you're learning here so our boy sai we have an amazing daft today we are holding daft sadik dallad now before i forget the truth is i don't think we have that many i didn't really add so i don't think we have that many aero videos we have a couple and since it's not my idea it's i believe it's norm's idea i think we should help them out otherwise they'll feel really bad so our boys if you what happened to chicago they said they're going to do the air thing i know they have a problem with the with the heckster over there and it's going to be it's politics go ahead joseph do it send it in something somebody somebody else step step up to the plate and send us your video let's make this uh see them better than last year zug daily gemara do it for noam and do it for noam itmar we are holding three lines from the bottom of that side of the gimbal base so we're in the middle of this idea that we just discussed what happens if a wall between two katseras falls down on chavez both sides made their own aero but now they're open to each other do we say that they answer each other like mars says no whatever you start out on that's how it continues through shabbos and now we see there's another sheet it's there's a nice wall between the two hot series and it fell down he doesn't hold up this whole concept that census utter arab shabbas it continues no now it's something new now what are we talking about sriracha goes into this whole explanation we're passing like rip shimon and if you have something in your cutter you have to clean your clutzer you can bring it to another cutter but rav don't forget rav is of the opinion that if you make an arrow you cannot bring it for one you can't move it so we're talking about they made an air over here so you can't bring anything out of your house because you might bring it to another hotzer and the fact is that since right now this wall no longer exists it's nifrat's bimillai so they answer each other so we had a good arrow so everybody could carry within the hotzer now what are we talking about says rashi we're talking about the caleb that are in the cutter [Music] yeah but i'm saying we're going from you can take this to another concert you can take your plea from this hotzer and bring it to another culture that's a kiddush right right i think you're right you are a hundred percent right correct you could carry within the thing but even even caleb let's see rashi inside uh uber claire is commercial we're talking [Music] i thought you said a second ago that you can take it out from you can't go from class to the concert okay i feel okay i'm saying i was talking about the k the clean in the concert fight so the caleb in the house you could take out from the house bring the hot seat the calendar you could always go from one hudson to another concert according to herb shemin the only issue is that if there's an aero according to rav you can't go from you can't take it out from your house but shmuel doesn't hold this whole area of thing there's no difference if there's an arrow or not says the gemara very interesting story vada rav la befereshitma rav never said this mafurish that once sha that we don't care about if shabbos came in with an arab or not in other words rav says that it changes on chavez status could change even though you had an error before shabbos shabbos comes along it changes since the wall fell down on chavez you no longer have a wall what happened the story the ravish moon they were sitting around rav and shimon was sitting in a hot start that had an aero or maybe you should say and the wall fell down on chavez our story tells the tamil go let's hang up a wall in other words go carry schmooze of the pinyin you could carry within the cutter rather than the opinion you can't carry within the cuts or only dollar diamonds so rav wasn't happy with this turned around they didn't want to see how they mahal shabba so to speak carrying in the khatu omarlu shmuel very interesting lotion if rav is upset about this i have an idea him grab rav's belt and use it to tie up this mojito in other words i don't give a hoot about rav i think he's wrong i know what i'm doing this is the way to do it very interesting why did why did he trouble these tell me them to put up a sheet why do you need a sheet why didn't where it was we don't care if the mejitsa fell down he's good says this might that you might have had an issue like how do you build the makitsan chabas to begin with the answer is it's only for privacy or in england they say privacy i think i love that word privacy so melo that's why he put you're right he didn't need a mojito he didn't need the wall to be standing in order for him to carry a sheet you could go all the way up to it but he needed it for privacy virab is fearless so why did rav say so why is ralph playing games and and turning around not looking let him say straight out shamu you're doing the wrong thing you bring muhammad says it's not proper he rules over there you don't tell him that well if it's his community so why is he making him like that people nobody suspects rav or just sitting there quietly thinking about it it would seem like you did the mitusma that you could carry in a situation where the wall fell down on chavez and rav holds no you cannot carry when the mojito so everybody a big happy birthday to seth where is he seth hellman finally we get to see him once in a while when he takes a break from college happy birthday dress i got your email you liked yesterday's cheer took it out to the porch maybe we'll go out to the porch again today says the mishna and as you can see here the wall is missing there's actually a couple stones here the wall fell down this entire wall fell down wide open into a russian rabbit says we have a macholicus now it's more than tanamas or as in this picture it's entire like most of it is gone says here is that this entire hots are tremendous for now for the havamina becomes your sister you see these nice pavers they become part of their surrounding therefore if you were to bring an item an object from somebody else's into this area your either is it the rise of caring from explain to us that we're not really discussing this entire concert we're just talking about the wall area we shall see and everybody discusses why do they change the case they're arguing rebellion but they're talking slightly differently they're not talking about from with inside it to the russian or going from the main thoroughfare into it potter and anybody that was with us during the shabbos anytime it says potter means potter avalosa in other words but your partner you don't have to bring a carbon. harmless this area is considered a caramel so it's a caramelist it's not a rochester album because you don't have 600 000 people walking here you don't have 16 whatever you think of it because it's wide open so it's a caramelise just because it's breached into the rabbit turns your private domain into rasharav how do you explain that it says the gemara in yes if a bunch of if society takes over mob rule they go through your cutter so they make your hats or surround them now our boys listen to this i hope you guys are not like me i i have a very weak memory and i learned the sugi by myself and then later on during the day i learned as i'm learning this i'm like i just saw somewhere in the mesh magazine or somewhere in ami a maison shahaya where arov was walking with this girl and they were going through this field and he said look we the rabbit hopped it and she yelled at him like i couldn't remember which magazine it was anybody remember this if it was mish pakhorami anybody no so i told me i just as a because i figured he probably doesn't read the magazine he said shaita well he didn't really say that but he said baze it's a story in the gemara where rabbi should be says i only lost three fights in my life and one of them was when i walked with a little girl through a field and i said we could walk here and she said no you're a list them you're you're a ganov it's like it was only that it was only 40 days ago it's kilowatt whatever okay fine i'm happy that you guys didn't jump in and say yeah that's fine i'm not the only all right anyways there's a new whatsapp group about hazard it's great gemara look it up again that's a lot of i got to there wow it's good stuff anyway it says the gemara ravi shabiru derek says that if the community walks through somebody's field they do like a land grab that now becomes their thing and we remember we're discussing muncie you walk through the people walk through people's backyards over there it's with permission not whatever but at the end of the day if people walk through he says it's not as simple as you think bomber abdillah of the lamb that's you can't just grab land if there was a path through this hotzer now there's an argument the wall fell down so the community is saying well we get a little bit more into the into the backyard and he's saying no my backyard extends into the surrounding we could use this picture even though it's for a little later the community says that we used to walk over on the blue line and he says no my clutcher goes out to the red line okay so now we have a quake is between the whole community and this individual who wins the community but they they had a reason to fight they were fighting over something that existed beforehand they were able to go through the concert just now they don't know where fight but you can't just go over the guy's backyard and start walking oh we're all here uh we're gonna make a riot and during the riot we're grabbing your land doesn't it doesn't work like that you're going to have to learn derek so maybe that's what happened by us that's exactly maybe that's what happened in other words the machis is in here but that rebellion says the entire qatar becomes a rabbit he says everything the entire qatar is including the blue line and no not the blue light in other words the blue light not inevitable so says not switch the dalai with allamah you misheard it he didn't say ah in other words the entire backyard is just around that's very hard to understand how do you turn somebody's backyard into russian like the gemara has to begin with it's a private domain you can't just the question was that there was a shiloh where exactly the makai mojito was it was blue red okay so over there the rebellion as a whole it turns into versus raven because people started walking there they held it's theirs the owners said it's not theirs but at the end of the day everybody says it becomes versus around because they grabbed it i changed the wrong window i okay i forgot what it was because i was in america too long i closed that one i need to close this one hold up tell me when to stop i can't see my screen [Music] okay we'll try to remember tomorrow much better now you can read keith and this one okay yeah i saw it but i said it's not gonna die to get up in middle shear but if the island is complaining who's the islam is it the aaron price again the yellow bag is my old bag out of the way okay he deserves it okay fine say that he wrote a nice email he gets it for already stopping simon bergens here oh jacob rosa you guys noticed that roseville wasn't on for but now hashem is back he's back says the game everybody says i don't have a good picture of it but the first thing that came to mind was if you drive in the lincoln tunnel in new york so you're driving and all of a sudden you could like you could take like a like a shoulder like a little bit of a shoulder on the side shoulder of a regular highway because that's really part of the highway but what happens is sometimes in the surroundings so many people that's so there's so much traffic that they come they go off to the side and that's the shiloh over here they went off into the side into the blue line over here and is that okay is that considered rishi surviving because typically they have a nice asphalt laying over here and they don't go but once in a while they caught so in mela that's what is see there is the side of the truth a little indentation indirect is that considerations and therefore that's exactly what he says in the mishnah if you carry from the blue into or you'd be very abundant they say no just because once in a while people come off there when there's traffic it doesn't create virtuous wrap as the gemara the lift look see there's so then why do you have to break a guy's wall and make a whole case where the guy's wall fell down just say is silly versus robbing krishna's rabbit nothing to do with the wall falling down says it was just just be a general in macho register nothing to do with the wall falling down have a marina abandoned where's the machine i found the in my head this was but i might be wrong in israel in a lot of places in the world you have these beams for you know anti-terrorist beams but it's more in the middle of this is like on the sidewalk so that the cars can get up here so this might be a better picture you see these blocks that they put next to the wall so that the animals don't break the wall here you have poles here you have blocks so that's now if there are no blacks no poles nothing more delay so maybe would admit terribly that that's considered part of russia's rabbi and why not it's all part of them it's similar maybe to i shouldn't say like like a sidewalk but it's like if all the cars go there and there's no blocks there's no reason for them not to go close to the wall maybe they don't typically they stay to the center but it's still part of the juicer rabbit commerce malone no they still argue and they say see they were just around the sides that are really close to the wall are not part of the surrounding but bottom line is so where's the whole macholic is here the homage like is on this blue line is this versus rabbit is it irish as a rabbit but as the gemara if you look at the lotion of the mishnah it talks about inside the khattar mit in the in the don't say anything about on the blue line on the wall it says inside inside says the gemara i did the umrah born since so we're talking about ah sham alaikum i think yeshua just showed up here and causing your raucous okay he doesn't have we have uh our anucle the watchdog doesn't like when they come in fine so okay where am i okay since rabban used the word and they're talking about from inside and why are they talking about if rabban are arguing honorably they should be talking about the same spot where bless is talking about everybody's talking about the blue line right over here between the wall or somewhere around there between the red and the blue and the city which is rabbin so why are they referring to the mitaka says the gemara so the first stage is the reason why rebel ezra says in the word he's mimicking but using that um so why why are they answering why is the argument something different he's talking about the tedious on the blue line and they they answer him about inside the khattar doesn't make sense says he called earlier abundantly don't you agree that this area over here is if you carry from here your partner wife caramel is it's considered a caramel is white because this is wide open it's very different people are walking around over here so it's like caramelized so therefore they they do argue on the same blue line but what they're trying to emphasize here is that you agree that this area over here is considered careless so what's the difference between the blue line and inside it's all carlos and very bless there what there's a big difference the blue line is right at the edge of research so there's constant traffic on the blue line that's about him so mama becomes part of which survivor don't bring me a riot from inside next to your barbecue where nobody walks there that's not a really that's not a reason [Music] ah what oh yeshua is did you just come to my house just shake your head if yes or no no just uh gotta try to come in okay he ran right back to the basement just sat in the seat so now we can see him okay i left this uh out of control truck that ran the culture yeah my trial i just thought about the chemist mama's just thought about it when i was a teenager i was in kenya airport and out of nowhere a car went nuts like started hitting other cars and sme went right in between people didn't hit anybody but hashem hit a beam and stopped short and i take a look and there's the older hasida shige in complete shock and what happened was his son went in to greet the people that just landed and he told his father stood here his father never drove life and the cop came they said sir move and he went through the through outwards and whatever was when a cop told something he did it without any comments he he put the gear he pushed the gas and went hitzer something like that happened over here a car went through this wall ended up this wall let's just say so now i have two gaps in the concert right over here right over here now how large are these gaps the kumar is going to discuss in a house tornado blew through so now there's a hole on both ends of the house you had the alley and you couldn't carry there until you put your lucky or a cairo and they fell off on shabbos similar to the case that we had we started off with we say ahead there it's a little different because over here structurally it's a different it's something different so since heir of shabbos you had a good lucky and you could carry in the mother so just if it falls off on shabbos you could continue carrying them up so since heir of shabbos you had a good lucky and you could carry in the mother so just if it falls off on shabbos you could continue carrying them up since before shabbos you had proud walls makita surrounding and you were able to carry there so now that they're breached a car went through it doesn't ruin anything the following shop is make sure that you fix the wall make sure you put up the and if it's us or in the future i still like to shabbos and in fact imar is going to say this is what he holds in other words you can't say right now you don't have an arrow so right now you can't carry so it's asur says what is our case exactly how how wide is the breach if it's less than 10 ammos these walls from side to side are let the opening is less than 10 ammo if it was just one opening it's fine it's a doorway right look there's a doorway over here you don't say oh it's a breech it's a doorway so if you have two of them what's the difference you let i have two doors i've removed four doors what's the problem yes your master so you must say that we're discussing a situation where it's more than ten the the gap the breach is more than ten hours then one of them is enough to ruin your concern a very large 10 ammo gap is finished there's even this story right over here here's a 10 am a gap it ruins it you become a vicious rabbit sometimes says is it 10 ammos more than 10 ammos or not says rav loyola ambassador and we're turning to daft sadiq dalat on the base in memory of my mother shane labad iron harris in bracha by your son dr alan listaus also known as the tzadik dr alan estes sponsored by the austin and tobias grandchildren legal instruments are bobby zissel so rav says lori lomba esser the breach is 10. so it's less than 10. and what's going on here what does it mean two walls or beach not like this picture that there's a wall here and a wall here rather what happened was it was two walls that are together in the corner these two walls and since normal individuals don't make openings doorways in the corner so mail is not considered a passage now when i was learning this i was thinking i said wait a minute in america i think in england as well different countries they do have stores on the corner you know those those those uh 24-hour shady stores on the corner and they have a door in the corner so i went to look for a picture look what i found unvalid or voicing yeah the people that do it yeah they do it but the ignorance is normal people don't look at this this is the dope store i'm not kidding you it says we sell dope dope sold here look look there's such a thing there's such a thing as a corner store it's not normal okay i'm not just saying there is a thing there's a thing that maybe today is a little different sensing says okay so now the house is breached on two sides s so we know about the concept of the thicker yoyo if you have we went outside yesterday i can't even go outside because no one made me close my tris but you have a nice flat surface it goes downwards so what's the difference if it's on one side or two sides so you have two breeches so invoke this uh peter iverson twice what's the big deal says [Music] that we we wouldn't dream of such a shot but that's what raf said you know what we're talking about the breach is on the corner not like this picture this picture one breach here one breach here great his bridge is literally on the corner like so these two walls are missing but more than that it's a slanty roof now it was very rare in those days to have these pitch roofs like we have today but it's a slanty roof and so what if it's a slanty roof when do you say pete tikra this is a typical when this is perpendicular to the ground it's nice and flat straight great but you don't say pete tikra we had this we had this by the case remember when the saturn goes like this you cannot say p tigre because then your the wall is going to end up on an angle if you can continue the wall you can't go downwards it's not with the angle of the it's not in the pitch of the roof we don't say p thicker your vesicim when the roof is on an angle okay so that's rav rav says that the breach is less than 10 amis we're talking about the breach is more than 10 ammos if so we have the original question so then why do you have to have two breaches once you have one giant breach of tanamos that's enough to ruin everything says doesn't explain but in a house it's different a house you need two breeches why why is the house different mr why in the house is different if you have two breeches just make an imaginary invisible wall and you're good to go twice question number one so let's remember this question because this is the question we're going to address later again what's the difference if there's two breaches you could say pete ticker or yary version on two breeches what's the problem if you could say p thicker you ever say them on one you could say it on two there's no difference like lava do you say love it only one time you say love it 100 times in a row says the gemara vasu question number two and this question we're going to get rid of we're going to be we'll remain with the first question me is slay the shmuel p ticker yeah every citizen does she won't even agree to this whole concept of pete ever said salah sinis i don't know how he could argue with it so much but it seems like he doesn't even agree that there's such a concept the famous case assad here if you don't remember you have a pergola in middle of nowhere middle of the desert meaning it's not touching any walls it's not up against the house it comes downwards on all four sides so therefore i could carry underneath it um you're stuck you can't go anywhere you could carry dalaran's raven too in other words you can't go anywhere in this song sizzling casual not a good casual from there shmuel argues not on the concept of pity group that you don't see petikra when it's wide open on all four sides like in this picture it's like in a house that there's other walls so if there's a breech and a wall pete dick or you're versatile but the bottom line is i'm i remain with the original question mikhail malcolm cassio so say pitikra twice why is it if there's one breach small says pitaka and if there's two breaches not says the gemara you agreed to me that rav came up with some sort of turrets that you would have never dreamt of it there's no hint in the mishnah to this shadow of wrath that we're talking about a corner and we're talking about a slanty roof he made it up he made it up he heard it from somebody but it's not in the mishnah so may allah aishamal also have the right to come up with a very wild shot and my child is going to be even wilder than yours canary ravish made their aftergone chinese friends by karen zavis vicky with al-aqsa and rav came up with a shot that it's in the corner and and the roof is i'm also going to go with that that's in the corner but much better the kiruyav check this out unbelievable you get you could see it in rashi rashi has a picture if you want here it is in color it's in the corner but look at this there are four pieces missing blue red blue red so we just said shmuel doesn't say pitikra four times he'll say three times two times but not four over here we have to do four peat tikros four peat thickers i don't do according to shmuel explains that it goes in fourth otherwise i guess it's lovable and then it's five two and five twelve and fourth he's trying to get to a larger breach than tenth which everybody asks because at the end of the day you go from here to here you you you take your ruler and you see oh from here there is only seven ammos i don't follow the jagged edges of the broken roof so rashi light duck he didn't really he wasn't he wasn't being specific he was just giving you an example where you could get to 10 amis like this the bottom line is that if you have four there's a wild chat you have four p tickers because they're not straight you can't do pink ticker on an angle in it so maybe i have to do a blue pete thicker red blue and red that you will hold you can do [Music] says the gemara shimola now why if he's going with his wild shot why doesn't he go with rav's wild shot shot number one al-aqsa like tony he doesn't mention anything about slanty roofs i'm assuming because in those days people had flat roofs it was very rare to have a slanty roof so to say that the mishna meant a slanty roof you know how hard it is to make a pitched roof with the right pitch and this and all the rafters it's very difficult so a nice flat roof it's it's not so good against rain stick of problems and the rainy season rains on you a little bit but but it's better i mean that's what they did in those days and how come ralph doesn't come up with this wild idea that there's four pete tickrus ralph doesn't care four five twenty you could say as many p tickers as you want you can't have alexandra that's no different or worse than the pergola in the middle of nowhere you could say peter four times in case you didn't remember this if there's a pergola in the middle of the desert on all four sides so i could do four ptegros i can't say four p tickers lawyer i'm reading peter you're decisive as we explained four times you don't say it but three times yes says the gemara wamp shot is when i have here where's the picture if these walls are less than 10 ammo is cooliama there's no much like this why not because i don't have to come on to pete takero shmuel you're right chemo doesn't say ticker four times but these are not tick these you don't have to say peter these are openings these are doors small agrees that there's a door in the house it's closed door one two three four this is tenth what's wrong with that it's less than 10 ammos keep league but yes or master ah if this is wider from pole to pole more than tanamas raph says pt crush moses says you don't say four times p degree they get army and some say yes if it's more than 10 amis even ravi greasy you cannot say pity crow oh my so now you have a ruin this rune right over here you see it's broken walls but you have a beautiful beam and we had these exact words i know it's not familiar but we had it trust me these words coira arriba mata de horva la el no like uh that's not the gimmel but like i don't remember where oh pay ale if that makes sense pay aleph there's a nice beam across nothing else but a beam you could carry in the dotted line i don't know if you can see the yellow dotted line down here you can carry it right below the beam verb knocking on my rabbit marvel courier i can draw water if this is a lake i could draw water right below the beam money who does that go according to well very simple la collagen diamonds basil please according to the mandala mother that says or the lotion that we just had that there's no mach like in less than 10 this is less than 10 am is right over here and it goes according to everybody but if there is much like it's even in less than ten kira so then this idea of p thicker on four all four sides and see how this beam is literally hanging in the air because it's on these little tiny posts or whatever it is little nails hold it so that's not a so you really have pete thicker on all four sides all four sides is according to the slushion is only rav or according to the fourth slush and there's no macholic is when it's narrower than ten even smaller than greek you say four peticros have a wonderful wonderful day [Music] foreign [Music] foreign are you guys going to mute i don't know how this works exactly david you mustn't what i told you i don't see evidence of it you talk about it i need to see evidence pictures videos aravind for what i saw your dad i started that peeking today i saw him don't think i didn't notice he came in the beginning of this year he came over to your camera i saw i see how you think you think i don't you think i'm not watching you goodalia i'm watching you slowly yeah i know it's it's gonna i try i try to i try to make it through when i swim watching hey seth happy birthday seth how's it going over there you okay i think seriously i think in a few years from now when we go to the hospital casa shalom or whatever it is like you're a dentist that graduated in 2020 no thank you you're a lawyer 2020 lawyer no thank you how about you got married in 2020 i don't know one of those 10 people weddings i don't know anyway yeah so seth you're different you go to school though yeah i'm at school you're at write stuff school i mean but betsy you heard about this that in i think in america they were giving nurses certificates without without tests and stuff like like a simulator it's incredible wow [Music] was that not it's a real store i don't know where it is um emma's store this picture was taken recently [Music] what does it say here it says r what does r99 mean is that like in holland or something that have decided due to the current president situation they're coming here in their house are you serious absolutely yeah i think i think this picture is i think this whole picture is made up if you look closely over here look at this it's fake the awning is fake it's too perfect that's true [Applause] solemn how are you doing i'm here i know you you're one sponsor and i wasn't sure if your name was laker or lacquer thank you thank you thank you so you so you're doing recruiting in modin you know what i have six i'm wondering a hundred percent what do you mean we would love it we would love it maybe send us a video maybe if you send us a video we'll feature it at the seam the modin it's very difficult because a lot of them don't want to get together yeah the whole culvert thing you're saying