Daf Yomi Eruvin Daf 76 by R’ Eli Stefansky

right good morning rabosai how's everybody doing a good nerf chavez we are uh at it's like uh 20 minutes to four in the afternoon in chicago which means it's 20 to five in new york and we still have people in new york today's share lili nishmas basmarkai and by the very famous khalman of the five towns in schools of menachem endo ben simcha reforest leima to pinchas ben ritzel and family he and his family are very sick with covet he's in the hospital you should have a fool shleima this is a tremendous gift from kalman to me also welcoming my friend and minion kabura dr dan kaufman from woodmere was officially joined our mdy family i convinced him to try it last week and now he's hooked like the rest of us so welcome dr dan kaufman ishikaya kalman it's a tremendous gift any any additional guy is the gift her boy sai last night i didn't know what i was getting myself into i said we're going to do a sheer and people saying maybe should do at 11 o'clock so i stayed up after [ __ ] to 3 a.m and then i realized i need a clear head for that so i went to sleep then i worked all the way just got done now there's a lot of stuff going on there's a lot of gemara math that we already had basically all the concepts kismaka stuff so let's jump right into it we're holding the ayan hey omud base oh um no no emails no writer we'll go right there we're holding two four six eight nine lines from the bottom omar you don't smoke a so chart number one we have 10 houses in a row how exactly i don't know if you could see they are split 10 in a row here's the hotzer and the only way to get to the hutzer from over here is to go crawl through people's houses until you get to the end who makes an a roof now there's a concept called that we learned earlier the concept of base char shower is a vestibule a lobby of some sort right over here coming into the culture it's not permitted to place your a-roof in a base shower so what are these houses considered now the gemara understands that all of these are base shire they're all base sharing why because they provide access to the hutter to some of the guys especially the guy in the back he has nine base showers the guy in the front he has one base shot so where do you place the arab exactly listen to this says the gemara panimi noise what you do is you place the arrow of by the red guy all the way in the back because he's not a base shower he's not going through nobody goes through him so you go to in the in the last number 10 he gets the arrow everybody else will be yikes with that heir so all he he's the only guy that has to put the hero on even the outer ones the more understands even this guy right over here number one says the gemara but he's he you can't even place there over there forget about he's not high of an era he's a he's just a vestibule everybody goes right through him we're talking about the outer one of the most inner one in other words the most inner one is number ten so the one that's outer to the inner one number nine so blue rubbing says in addition to putting the arrow in number 10 also number nine needs to put an a roof why does number nine need a roof why is nine worse off than number eight eight doesn't need a heir of so why does nine either here says the question is if a shar that one person goes through it is that considered a vestibule the only guy that goes through number nine is number ten um says just because number ten goes through him that's not enough of a reason to consider him a vestibule and therefore he's also in a roof so these two guys blue and red nine and ten i'm here the rest are potter because they're all based shire end of the story another concerning so we have a situation you have three houses one two three a cutter on this side and a hutter on that side hotter meaning every hotter has two houses if you notice they put another house here there's two caterers open there's two bathroom open to this one hotzer two bottom open to this hot but these middle guys what do we do with them says the gemara an amazing these guys in the center don't have to make an arrow at all why based on dialogue that we just said a base shar if you have a vestibule you don't put an arrow if you don't you know so the guys at the end seth hellman shaw malayhim it's great to see you once in a blue moon how's college doing so the guys on the side their base sharim because the way you access this hudson the way the middle guy acts as the hutter is through this house so this house right over here base shot this house right over at bay shower these two guys are not higher than anything so where are they going to place the area in the center well the place the house you place the a-roof also doesn't need an a roof why the whole point of an a-roof is we live together we're in one house well i provided my house we live in my house great you don't need to place bread in my house my house is in my house so no one is javanese three houses in the center this guy goes right through places this area of in the center visible thereof and so does the guy on the left goes to the center we're holding the points out each one becomes the bashar prayer i probably made a mistake by saying it before each one becomes a bashar to the hotter if i said differently correction not to be sharp you don't become a big shower to the house this becomes the vestibule to this hutter okay just notice the top rashy bay charlotte okay becomes a vestibule the point is it becomes a vestibule to what to the cutter this guy to this halter and the guy in the center doesn't need a arrow i'm sorry i have a base the middle guy becomes a house that that's where you place the arrow the house that you place in a row then sorry you don't have to put bread in the house that you place the ear so therefore all three houses are potter says wanted to check if the tamim are paying attention if the schluff in arab shabbos before shab is thinking about the child oy we have to go to shul soon or they were paying attention so what did he say he gave them a little test he said okay where's that there we go got two houses one and two two houses and each house has a cutter clutzer as we've explained before requires two houses in itself so here's the other house not important to our story there's two guys in the middle the story is says rakhava i went this way maybe i should have gone this way let me shown it the guy takes his arrow from over here goes through the house and places it in his buddy's house on the other side of the fence this guy in return goes through his own house places it in the other house so let's just take one example follow this arrow he's going from his hot so he goes through his house what is this house considered is the house considered a base shower it's a vestibule i'm just using it to get to another place and i'm placing my area or it's a house well it's a very big problem a base shower if you consider both of these houses the same because they're acting the same exact way whatever this guy in the left does the guy on the right does so let's think about it what is what are these houses the base shower you can't place an area in a base shower base shower doesn't need an arrow zero a roof so you're gonna tell me they're houses well that's a major problem because where did this guy place his arrow on the other side what is this house number two called i have sick it's a katsitsa so to speak in order for him this guy in this concert to get to the other to the other house he has to step through his own house that's problematic you can't go through a house on choppers you can't carry through somebody else's house and shoppers without an a roof so what is it it's a house or it's a it's a base shower how are you going to view it if it's a house where you want to place an area because that's the only way to place in there it's a base shower you can there's nothing to talk about a vestibule you can't put an arrow in a vestibule element it's a house so if it's a house it makes it have sick it makes the cacito what do you do you want to dance on two hassan let's call it a house slash bashar you want to do that i don't know if you can do that let's see this guy walks through his own house this guy walks through his own house and places there in the other house uh there's there haven't represented the opposite guy does the same thing but in the opposite way he goes through his own house and places the arrow in the other guy's house khan here is there a nerve me the high bias could i dance on two hassanas call each house a bashar slash a house well the guy with a high base shower somebody's unmuted so please mute well he got me the high bay shower they got behind me could i call each house a base shower depending for me it's a big shower for you it's a house and for you it's a house you mean to be shy so the talmidam wake up and they say we're paying attention review there's no way there's no area over here why this we already had oh yeah i shouldn't be throwing these on the floor the person places is is a bashar al-sadr is a gazebo a little no good you can't put your air over there so my melo we cannot consider these two houses a big shot even though they act as we're going back hold on one second let me just okay i just want to make sure i need to put it on do not disturb okay sorry okay i am back sorry about that air of shabbos without gary with the clever ah one day i made a brock already don't worry it's ogden so we're smacking middle over here before my tired brother called me to wish me good jobs so we can't consider the bay shower because if we consider it a big shower you can't place an area of innovation ebay is monstrously but if you consider it a house commentator is how do where did i place my aero in my friend's house how do i want to carry on shops i want to go through their own shop as a cat but i'm carrying through my own house where i don't have an arrow says the gemara and the and these guys don't want to make a nav with each other they have nothing to do with each other ask the gemara beautiful question a soogie that we're familiar with especially if you learned the shabbos with us look at this i had a lot of knowledge from this one special from today one guy makes two a reuven for two his friends two of his friends said you're you're a rabbi make an error for us okay so he goes ahead and makes one area at 5 30. see the sun is shining it's way above the horizon 5 30. the second guy he makes his arrow at six o'clock bana smashes benash moshe's we don't know what it is is it daytime is it nighttime we don't know but what happened is very interesting at six o'clock when he made a roof number two heir of number one was eaten by a cat okay no more came ate there this is a piece of bread ate the ayrov now here's the shiloh you hear what's going on it's beautiful in order for an earth to be in order for an earth to be it has to be before shabbos and if the air was eaten before shabbos no good so we're going to say that both of these aruvum are perfect why because area of number one was done when it was still daytime and when was it eaten after dark so if so how does the area of number two work he made area of number two at the same exact time no area number two was how during daytime oh so here's the situation i'm dancing i'm too casanas when it comes to area number two i'm saying it was daytime finish mushrooms equals day when it comes to my cat eating my aero venash mushrooms equals nighttime rabbi said there's somebody that's unmuted so please everybody please be mac with amudo you can hear later on thank you everybody's muted now all right see here what we're saying we're dancing on two haasanas how could you dance on two casinos so let's dance on two casinos by us let's call this house a bass shower slash a bias just like i could call shikiya or banishmashes daytime for when i created the aero and nighttime at the same time the same person did this it's not even two people doing the same error it was one guy did two a ruben we're gonna say the one area that he did it was daytime and the other area that he did even though it's the same exact moment is considered night time see dancing in two hasimas for one of them he did there and the second one he did at six o'clock is ribbon they were both eaten the guy that he made there of during the daytime we're going to say that his era was eaten banash mushrooms and in other words it was eaten after shabbat started so the area was bizarre and the one who he did the arab venus it's considered not a good comparison to banish mushrooms ha some sufficient mama sufficiently mink when it comes to banished mushrooms nobody knows anything we don't know right today you're going to tell me it's been ashwas day night i don't know anything i don't know if it's neither day so mama doesn't become a joke don't become a joke to klaus israel to but everybody you're going to tell you're going to point out to this house this is a house is it a house or it's not a house oh it's both what's going to happen the the kaifern guys the guys that like to poke fun at the gemara they'll say oh look i think why doesn't i was talking about here the guy with the high base shot high name so if you look at rashi the last last words in the peric he says we don't want the koi from a lot of times like we were learning gemara in aveda zara and said the snake was so smart it tipped over the water it it it wanted to drink from the wine it had a whole trick so a guy sends me a guy that has you know questions in the moon he sends me there's a website that brings this gemara and says look at these rabbata and they're so silly they say funny things about snakes it it opens up a door for kayframe if you don't understand what's going on you don't understand the the the style of the gemara it could lead to firo and with that it's also not a coincidence that today kalman sponsored once again and when we started the parrot he also sponsored he said he has a daughter named tadar i don't know if you recall so we finish off with kauman like the way we started beautiful i guess we could take this thing hello this is not easy to make you know that right especially a guy like me from pontovec a window opening basically not a window we're not talking about anderson windows with crankshafts and a window in the gemara is just a opening wide opening you could it never closes so this we had many times already a human being could fit through a four by four in order for it to be a substantial window opening it has to be four by four [ __ ] y'all save mac we gotta get muted everybody gotta get muted sorry everybody's used to coming on and there's an automatic mute they don't have that today's friday it's a little different okay so our ball our bob is sorrow now the window must be below 10 we're going to see that it doesn't have to be the entire window some of the window has to be within 10th falcon of the ground if that's the case if you have a window that's 4x4 so let's see if we have a picture here we actually do here's a window in a wall here's the wall between hutzer beautiful there's a fireplace there's a table with some stuff on it great here's the window it's a little bit with intense falcon we're going to see here's tenth falcon from the ground here's the line this red line is a tenth falcon line so we have a an opening fine so my arvin schnein you can make either a native on both sides of the wall to a room they have nothing to do with each other vimratsu and because there's an opening this access from one customer to the other you can make one arrow and both of them could carry from one place to the other you could pass it through the window pass it above the wall pass it in a hole whatever you want to do is but if the opening is less than four or lamala sorrow or it's completely all above tenth fuchem i'm just going to mute it for boise since you don't have the axis you don't have the the the width that you need or the or the height the window is too high it's above 10th volcan so you could only do two a room one for one hotzer one for the other you cannot combine the two khat series together says the gemara um lemon non-stomach verb shimmering emily remember we had a number of times already the the concept of beloved we all know what love it is lava is that you could take if something is not more than three apart from each other let's say in these modern circus that we have today you take a string and they have this this floppy wall so what they do is they take a taut string and they put it within three [ __ ] of the next string and the ground so we say allah glee it's all filled in gamaliel is of the opinion even up the fourth [ __ ] so perhaps our mission is rupturing he says the opening has to be at least fourth fachem why because if it's less than fourth fachim shut halachically it's all closed we're not talking about love it here i feel the temperament even who say that love it is three talking please opinion that in order to make an opening to have a proper opening it needs to be at least for him has nothing to do with the halacha messina of love wood and it's closed not closed this has to do with allah of opening can a human being fit through this hole or not is it a normal opening remember now i remember we had the sugy of the guy that lives next to bika and he had a little opening how big was his opening four by fourth [ __ ] that's that's the concept of opening pakistan we're getting there a bus we're getting to the to the math in a second and it's it's easy and fun says shito it says in the mishnah that the opening has to be fort falcon so anybody with a little logic knows that if it's less than four falcon it's not good so why does the mission have to repeat itself it also said in the mission has to be above 10 it has to be below 10th welcome if it's above 10th welcome it's not good so why do you have to tell me the same thing twice we're not alone we're not american anymore says i would think that if the entire window's above 10 then it's no good i wouldn't know this idea that if part of it was within 10 that it's okay i would think the entire thing has to be below 10 and if the entire thing is above 10 great and even if some of it is below above 10 it's no good but what if part of it is below 10. it's a good window bottom line is you need some of it we're going to see soon how much you need some of the window to be within ten vimratsu so it's their choice they could either say this is a wall it's a proper wall and let's not be friends you make your own area i make my own area we have nothing to do with each other or because this entire perak is discussing when two khaters are next to each other when they could be won when they're not considered one and we've seen our mishna you have two khaters next to each other here you could do whatever you want that's a very interesting thing on the one hand i could say let's be partners let's partner up because we have access to each other on the other hand it's not a real wide opening there is a wall so we can also say we don't want to be partners says and we in fact see this over here doesn't mean literally all of it it means most of it is now this we need to understand what is the what does it have to say almost 90 percent of it is below 10th falcon which is great and a little bit above 10 fahrenheit is also good i already said that if it's mostly above 10 fahrenheit which is apostle area and just a little bottom part is inside the tenth of almost okay so certainly if 90 percent is below 10 and 10 is above 10 it should also be okay right you if you want if you want you could combine the two or not it's considered as if it's below 10. so if 90 is below 10 of course it's okay we had the same idea last night or yesterday in the morning i should say inaudible the kinds of lawyers who absorb tony we start off easy and we build up the kiddush we say that above i'm sorry if 90 percent is within tenth falchem it's okay and not only that even if ninety percent is above tenth of him as long as ten percent is within the bone it's also okay and here we go circles circles and squares gemara style um now how big is a window have to be fourth [ __ ] by fourth [ __ ] how do you translate that into a circle for him and it's a major that in order for a circle to have this the the ability to contain a square that's four by fourth facet the circumference of the circle needs to be 24. see if we have a picture here not that we need one i guess i didn't think it was important okay we're gonna see um uh so if a circle is 24 so the diameter is eight why as we're going to see in a second in gemara math you times the diameter by three so whatever the diameter is of a circle times three that's the circumference of the circle so if a circle is 8 divided by 3 i'm sorry if the circumference of the circle is 24 divided by 3 8 right 8 times 3 24. so if it's eight if your circle is eight and you wanna place a square in the circle so that means a square is four by four that means you have two [ __ ] above the square and two [ __ ] below the square for a total of eight fahren so mela your circle the the the window has to be tutvaham above two above the bottom of the circle so the the the round circle has to be i'll show you a picture you'll understand better um maybe not do i not have a picture of this this i needed a picture um okay so pretend that this square is a circle here's your line your tenth [ __ ] line so you need you need at least at most two for him that go below the line why because you need to contain a full square of four by four square by the by the tenth fuchem line and like we explained the circumference is the the height of the circle of this window must be eight fahren so it you have to have two on the top and two on the bottom although make sure that from this 24 or i should say the eighth diameter to the bottom two fahrenheit are within fahrenheit of the that if you want to make a square within that circle some of that square should be close to the ground tenth [ __ ] so based on this idea that if the diameter is one tepha the circumference is three how do we get the 24 has to go tomorrow in order to have fort falcon i mean we're just going step by step here the answer is obvious but let's let's assume we're starting from scratch we have a square that's four by four so the diameter is four so in order to make a circumference for a circle of fourth falcon if the diameter of a circle is fourth falcon times three equals twelve where did you get the 24 well it's the obvious answer that's the circumference that's the diameter of a square not of a circle we should be enough and we should the circle yeah am i making sense now yes no if we're taking the the the first of all here if you have a tether from side to side the diameter that means that the round is three two times it by three if so if from here to here is fourth fahrenheit because that's the size of the square so you go around times three equals twelve so the circle should be twelve before we say the avi's answer returning the daf in memory of my mother shane dolbat aaron hirsch and bracha by your son dr alan listaus aka the tzadik also sponsored by the austin and the tobias grandchildren leader nishmasa our bobby bass who's nifter on gimmel marchman to see five generations of soybean toyo mixes so returning honeymily says the gomorrah great the fighting beings had a meal that's in a circle i would be rebua being in faye you can't you can't uh do the diameter of a square and times that by three we're talking about a circle here not a square okay great so what's the next step miri this is all gemara math miri how much is a square larger than a circle if you take a square and put it around the circle how much larger is it rivia it's 25 more okay so add 25 to your 12 that we have before three times four is 12. we're at 16. again where did you get the 24. says if we're dealing with a square that's inside a circle so what do we have to deal with we have to deal with the diagonal line from here to here that's the side to side the diameter of the circle the diagonal line of a square oh how much is a diagonal line of a square so that's another gemara math that we always have throughout shots every if you have one alma this way that equals one and two-fifths on a diagonal if your square is one by one so the diagonal from corner to corner is one and two-fifths so we're dealing with the diagonal because the square fits into the circle so the the circumference the diameter of the circle is the diagonal of the square it's they're equal here you have a circle it's going to hit these two points oh and now the gemara does the math the shifts are 17 minus two-fifths is enough very very simple look at this here i did the math for you this is gemara math and i'm going to explain what i mean in a second we have fourt [ __ ] our window is fourth [ __ ] not one amma fourth [ __ ] so how much is the diagonal of fourth [ __ ] four times uh two fifths one and two fifths how much is four times one and two fifths five and three fifths or five point six so if you take a calculator and you do five point six times three that equals 16.8 and that's what the mars says 17 minus 2 eighths two fifths so mela the gemara comes up with 16.8 so why do i need [Music] says yeah so again if the diameter of the circle is five point six because i need to fit in a four tepha square into the circle so then the diameter for me is 5.6 that means that the amount of [ __ ] in the circumference is 16.8 and not 24. where did you come up with 24. says rebecca has different math than us if you have a circle inside a square you're right it's only a quarter less reboot so he says like this if the square is inside of a circle and that's what we want to do that's important to us we want to get a four by four square into a circle so we take off or we add 50 percent pow go 50 so we have to add 50 so 16 how much is half of 16 8 that's the 50 percent we're talking about so add 8 to 16 you come up with 24 fahrenheit now tyson asks but it's not math it doesn't fit into what we know in terms of math so there are some that say the village actually has a nice shot on the side and the villain says we're talking about the square that's on top of the circle which equals 22.6 fahrenheit which is very close to 24. you makhmir a little that's how he wants the same shot otherwise others say that yes the the dayanam of kisari they knew math they weren't showing them that uh i learned the ponovich i don't know math they're not going to make such a a gross mistake in math but what they said is that if you want to put a circle if you want to use a window that's a circle and not a square don't start playing calculator games with me and say what equals a square i'm going to tell you i'm going to throw out a number and you have to stick with it it has to be an easy number for everybody to remember and that there shouldn't be any mistakes and you shouldn't make it less yeah 24 in circumference that's how they say the shot is but anyway twice wants to say that they meant they didn't understand them well et cetera all right so that's the end of the suggest of the math says so the mission says that you have a window that's four by four you can combine the two kha teres le but if it's between two houses it's completely different we don't care what the height is the height could be more than 10 fahrenheit maitaima beso okay because the house is as if it's full what does that mean exactly is it allah ugly full and that we don't consider height at all height doesn't matter it does or the shot is it's easy to climb up to that window because you have a couch up against the window you have a table up against the window so that's gumbar asks over here aceve ravel or even athlete what's going on here we have a bryce that says i don't care if it's a window between two katseros that's our case of our mission let's see we have pictures here this one was easier because it has all the cases in one shot it's a i forgot what it's called not a side view a a cutaway of a house so if you look closely you have this is our case a window between the hudson hutzer a window between two houses a window between ceilings a window in the attic and a window in the on the roof okay windows everywhere and the browser says it's not enough to mean what the window is where the window is how the window is they're all the same now i just wanted to show you how the color lashon does the window beautiful just because of the beauty i printed this out it has nothing to do with the shot just to enjoy a little bit here's a beautiful house with a nice gesundo wall on top on the roof this is the window with each case he made his own picture i didn't have patience for that and a window in the roof but look at this he has he has a pot over here has a broom and then hay and it's just to give all the oven here oven there flowers growing out of the window he went all out this guy see that okay fine but what's the bottom line is between the attic in the rooftop between two bedrooms there's no difference between a cutter and a house rav nachman just said there's a difference between a hudson house and a hotzer it has to be below 10 fahrenheit but in a house because of the sparrow of the whole house is considered full it has there's no air whatever you look like there's no height there's no height limit it could be even above 10 seconds so you have to explain that when he says over here in this price that says they're all the same no it's only talking about the the one allah that there's no difference what height in the khatsu i'm sorry that there is a difference in the height only only in the difference in the height but at the end of the day it says they're all the same all these cases are the same this one this one they're all echoed that they're all in the same category so there's two parts of this bryce this is the part that the window could be four by four that they're all the same aloha four by four is the measurement there's another on the brass height height there's no enough when it comes to house there's no height when it comes to a attic no height when it comes to hot zero because it's outdoors then we have to consider tenth [ __ ] so the tenth welcome limit is only on the khattar not on the house what's that that's if you have this is the cutaway of the house you have an opening like a fire in the firehouse you got this little hole in the floor they used to use that a lot and you have a ladder over here that go up there so lula batuach a ladder has the ability to break down a wall we said if you have a wall you have a ladder it's as if you could go from side to side how are you doing it's great to see you i didn't notice you so it's great to see you it's been a while all the way from baltimore do you need a permanent ladder and say so what's going on here two guys on this one guy lives in the top floor that's his residence that's where he lives it's his guy in the bottom now if i want to consider them one do i need a ladder that's kavuwa says what's the shield here i'm in the base okay when i say that a house is full honeymilimi natsad now what's the problem we have a window but guess what the window is very high up and a high up window above 10 falcon doesn't count as a window but it's inside a house but maybe we're only talking about vertical windows not horizontal windows this is a skylight this is a flat window this is a window that's between floors in other words it's not standing up it's a flat window maybe that rule doesn't apply why not what's the logic when do i say this concept that the whole house is considered it's full mma law even a skylight will be considered as if it's with intense vacuum even the ceiling is within that only works on the side but if it's in middle of a ceiling no idea malaysia why because you could say that afghanistan if you say that a house is full because physically there's a couch that i could climb up any window is within my reach that's physical and that's on the side of the house but not in the center not in the not in the roof it's very difficult to climb into a window that's in your ceiling just because you have a couch but if you say how logically your house is considered full there's no air there's nothing in the house it's all one horologically so what do i care where the window is it could be flat on the ceiling it could be standing up on a wall there's no there's no height at all within a within a house there's the house is full it's a concept and therefore you don't need a ladder at all you don't need a ladder that's permanent in the house sovereign meanwhile so he thought sun kavo then it started he thought okay you don't need a permanent one right but you need some sort of temporary ladder it's not true um you don't need any sort of ladder at all halal we are within the tenth fuchem of a window that's in the ceiling even though it's a hundred fahm above the ground but logically my entire dining room is full with invisible material and it puts me by the window let's do this mishna we can repeat it tomorrow as well but we'll do it just to get to the to the gemara to get to say that we did today's easy mishno if you have a wall now i just want to show you real quickly i like this picture a lot it's a it's a picture from the ais vahader in my gemara and it shows you a solid serious wall and there's fruit on top of the wall and that's what the mission is going to be discussing but i want to show you how yoni drew drew it and i i like his better just it doesn't have color [Applause] now we know throughout the shabbos anything that's sent for him fourth [ __ ] wide is what is before it's its own rashos so what do you do there's a tremendous separation between the hudson khatta there's no window there's nothing so mama this guy makes his own error if this guy makes his own error how you burroy should perish what if there's a nice smack a meal on top what do i do i don't have an area with you you don't have any with me but guess what it's its own properties its own domain let me show you yoni that's why i like yoni's it gives us a better schmuck understanding what's going on here these two guys in other words yoni's showing you that where do you eat the fruit only on the wall i don't have the right to take the fruit off the wall and bring it into my hutter because that i don't have an arrow from the wall through the hot tub i have an aero for within my shoes so what do you do if you want to take a nice gishmaka snack you stand there you eat like that and he shows you a roof over here air of over here it's a beautiful it has a lot of detail this picture anyway next beautiful picture from carla shawn i'm going back because there's a picture i'm taking the best of the best over here this wall got destroyed so now i don't know if you can see you see right over here so there's an opening from hots at the hutter well it depends and this we had in the beginning is also 10 amos is the limit my iron then it's considered one open giant hotter vim tremendous there was a wall here and you could see there was a wall here so if they want it you don't say oh it's one hotter no it's actually two cats areas with a nice opening a nice doorway so therefore they have the they have the they have the option they could say i want to do it as one cutter so it's one area of or they could say no we have nothing to do with each other to a reuven it's considered a doorway not a blown open wall but if the the opening from side to side is more than 10 almost more than 20 feet approximately then you can no longer say that it's two separate series look there's absolutely nothing separating the hutzer therefore you make to a reuven uh one arrow of sorry have a wonderful shabbos and if you're in new york and chicago and the rest of the world in baltimore and have a wonderful week if you're watching this energy stroll the show not be shall i invasive hashem i'm hoping next week to get out of here if i can marty i need some advice because i heard from a surgeon i'm not going to say where a certain surgeon that lives in a certain city a certain block next to yours and he says if i get a bunch of tests and they're all negative then i don't have to be so much bit on the 14-day quarantine i know you're gonna go crazy on that i know it i see your face even what is oh oh hold on sorry okay now what do you say what the the different the different types of uh good job it's john where are you where are you jonathan oh my daughter is there now in the house in miami go say you're the hello that's doing all that yeah it's your fault my creative ambassador