Daf Yomi Eruvin Daf 67 by R’ Eli Stefansky

don't say if you'll just cut and paste youtube good morning everybody how's everybody doing there's a stroll malaysian we're here live from chicago a very special guest david brand is from southman indiana oh my gosh this is unbelievable this is what happens gary he muted me and muted me one more time for the third time we are live from chicago good morning energy stroll uh yeah yeah okay so you probably already heard for the third time that david brandes showed up all the way from south bend took him three hours to get here and he's going to two two he's gonna be back home about three in the morning he says three in the morning so tremendous for coming out he came with his child moshe who's starting gemara next week real quickly um today's share is being sponsored by menachem seawalled david ben malko the reformer shlema there's one another sponsor andrew fuchs lili nishmas his grandmother raiso basically levy on a yard site may should be a melissa's youtuber for all of us and all of claudia's role on maine yesterday's sponsors which i didn't print out were the clifton a year there's avi gurwitz we're going to put this up in memory of yoni cone from chicago big belts duck about the stories a guy shows up in edison he he started at salah two shoals he he started a big hail me bought the house across the street from the hospital all these things ellie dykman knows about all this great it just and and it's this guy that's staying by me avi camiller he came at shivan he told the family that you know he started two shoals and big hailum and the family had no idea all these things besides her never wanted his name on anything unbelievable all right real quickly uh a few emails we're sticking late we have a nice daf ahead of us i asked that people should uh check in so thank you for checking in there rebelli just checking in to say aye from your hometown ramapanchamish i couldn't imagine life without daffy me especially yours brother hashem have been learning for a long time went to a real religious school spent three years after high school on terrorism and continued learning ever since we made aliyah four years ago and until january 2020 i wasn't able to find the gemara street i fit in my schedule and style that i was looking for i got inspired from the sema shots and decided to take the daffan i didn't find your shirt straight away maybe two weeks into brachas i found it that's uh that's what happened to uh beyond schwarz as well all right maybe two weeks in the brother family of course i'm still with you and hooked just cannot wait to come back to the center nothing beats the live share safe travels back home warren carlos this is from david address i just want to thank you for the best call of my trip ever coming out 12 15 a.m in the morning to do that fly with you and the khabar was hands down the best call of my trip ever i don't know if there's a picture we got to get a picture ellie got a picture of of uh of an address with his yell he came with the whole gear the whole covert gear it's not my stick the bala mahabharata it's all about the yami one last one here from mordekaiser posnick i want to thank raveli schlitz for the chart of the three cases of shmuel of asura marvin dave samar i don't know it was last minute he's talking about this chart right over here but i guess it gave him some clarkite i love all the charges and pictures because i myself am very into photoshop i put out a weekly photographic kids and photoshop pictures on it and i'm attaching the vatara so you can see it and show it to the islam i hope to be able to hear many more shirum from my valley in many more years to come your talmud morgan from flatbush new york here's his here's what he does all the stuff he's got we can use his help actually all right so today is dave samach zain and we're holding actually on the top of that summit seine and we're holding three lines down so we're discussing this case right over here where there's two katsera is next to each other there's the inner and outer cutter they place the aerov this red that over here in the inner cotter everybody's mustache with the area of besides one guy from the inner hot the inner hot road i missed you man you know i just found out josh rosen listen to this year you know uh a bunch of people but where's ben c friedman lewis cole where all these guys should come out show a little support but i understand it's 11 15 in the morning all right well we missed you we saw you on zoom but you're here already you're ready up you're ready doing the share you might as well come i hear the cigar part is probably what tipped it over all right so i i know avi it's lost in ikea trust me he understood i understood there's no reason i'll be kamiyansky for you okay very good so one of these guys one of these dudes in the in the inner clutch oh here we got a picture of of of david address here if you look at ellie dykman's screen you'll see the dress and the yellow suit send it to us put on the put it on i know by the way when the first time i met him i'm going to say this again again i met him first time it's as if i knew the guy for 30 years as if he i grew up with him this zoom thing is not a joke i'm serious you see the same people the same faces same smiles you hear the voice i saw okay no oh what i we never met before no we never met he saw goats and all these guys every single one unbelievable anyway fine let's get to the sugar so the guy the guy forgot the arab over here so what do we have yesterday we had that what would it help us if he is mavato's reshus his own friends his own guys that are in this cluster it doesn't help anything because what about these guys on the outside or it can be waters resource to the guys on the outside but he can't because you cannot beam a battle from one hutter to another hutter says the gemara asked the gemara oh male 1 review four lines down up if one of the guys in the inside didn't do the the arrow in the suros what is the problem is liberty let him at least do a bittle to the guys inside to his friends and what did we say so how does it help the guys on the outside of the distributor about daiyu look he made an arrow they're all in this together the inner hudson the outer cuts are there one so as long as he has an arab and he's without his friends inside it shall work why so we continue on come on so what are you asking me you're asking me kyra be a lesbian this will explain his question you're only basing your question on one cheetah called rebellizer that says that you're not to be do bittle on each and every person in all the hat series still general beetle so that explains why it doesn't work to do bitter just for yourself and your buddies in your cutter is not enough because you didn't do a bittle for the outer guys his question was maybe you don't need it maybe it's enough to do one bittle and that works he says no that works yes according to italy azer it doesn't work according to rabona and that is the problem so what's the bottom line like we had yesterday we're going to see a little bit more of it on in the ions bottom line is you how do you do how could you do beetle do bitter when you have a huts within a hotzer hotel from hotzer and we said very interesting since the inner hearts are quite slammed the door shut they use the air for themselves and they have to come on to the beetle of the other hotzer according to urbankiva great zogtigimara rav krishna ravshesh's this is agatha arriving style you know like a story ahugavra and then it goes right into ireland so but we got a little bit of a little bit of a got to enjoy it while it lasts it's about three words you have the famous refrigerator and the famous representations when they would bump into each other refrigerator martin's lips would start trembling from all the bryces that are sheishas knew and basically when he met refrigerator he would try to figure out what these prices mean so he would he would say refresdo how do you explain the contradiction between this breast and this brain refrista wasn't holding in the amount of knowledge that rafa's had he started trembling on the flip side rafhizdo was the lambdan he knew how to learn he was very deep not only his lips his entire body would tremble so who's that like now we already learned that if you have somebody that knows a sinai kaharim the one that knows that has more knowledge be passing like him so that would be between the two here it is right here but it gives us more background who's refrigerator who's rafa's what will his friends his friends rob his father-in-law we we build a picture of his now it's this turn to ascription this is where rashesha starts trembling his whole body batting bishop if you have two houses on two sides versus rob there's this and create and build a mojito between them here's two little gallium just nicely they just don't i guess to eat them without yama goes built the mojito right here here's the surround going right through build the middle of building this picture is showing you in progress as a matter of fact there's a toolbox here if you look closely toolbox hammer he's banging in the nail and he has a couple pieces of board he's almost done okay so now you have two houses and a hutzer in between they created the hutzer when on shabbos mao now obviously rashi points out immediately that if a mojito was created on shabbos or on the weekday or bashagi bemidji it's always a majita we don't care when that was created on chavez mao means can one be me battle there is just the other can you relinquish your resource your property and say hey you could have mine so that you could walk in the surround between us now going back to this machlagas that we had yesterday you have two hat series side by side and you have an opening between them but the two characters here at least two people live here two people total four people let's say can i relinquish my results to you and we had the mclegs yesterday says no according to the manual it says you cannot do so why like we here you need oyster marvin you need to do so so this what happened yesterday well okay let's let's just see here you need oystering you need two things in order to do beetle with vacuum there's only one case we said one case that shabby starts out that they're they answer each other every time you have more than one person in a clutzer you cannot use the cutter unless you make an error that's the whole point of arab that we're all in this together and that you're able to do a roof over here you weren't able to do an error of because it was a rabbit in a case where if they wanted to do an area of before shop as they could have ambrose ain't you schmuel beethoven they cannot do any bittle even in the case here here's the case you have two hot series next to each other could they make an area before shops absolutely but they chose not to they forgot so because i forgot to do the arrow what's my next my next option let me do bitto let me just give you my property now there's a sole owner now we can carry you cannot do so such more but i had a way out of it er shabbos i could have made it a roof so in our case it's like a cava climber and now okay in our case if they wanted to make it a roof in middle versus arabim no way what changed that the guy in there decided to put up some sort of mris in the middle of ocean parkway okay but i didn't have the adoption of shabbos like college gaines shouldn't work you don't have to the two conditions when it says that i could do beetle in this case when there's a side to side hot or hostilely boiler roof maybe it's only in this case that you could do bitter why because i could have done a matter of shabbos but so therefore i have the option to do bitter since i could have done an arrow i forgot so i'm going to let you do bittle but in this case where they built the mercitsa on chabez i didn't have the option to make an area of air shabbos so maybe i don't have the option to do beetle today beetle is just if i forgot i don't have a choice i'm stuck great but that's only because i could have done a heir of maybe that's his kasha avalok surrounding you couldn't do an i'm allowed to error beforehand so therefore there's no there's no option of bitter i don't know maybe britain says they're not connected i could do bitter whenever you could do bitter dubital nothing to do with the fact that you could have done an arrow where you couldn't you couldn't do a narrative on malaysia answers in other words the the genius the the bigger london so to speak the the more horrif people he asked for serious cash revisions typically trembles flashes answered him ain't nevadlin why because you need the two conditions so yeah you can just ask it so what happens if you have a guy in your cutter if he's in your cutter so we had a case yesterday that guy showed up on chavez could you rent it on shop it's not over here the guy was there the entire time he's there on heir of chavez from friday he lives there and of course if you have a person that's not part of the erupt it ruins the whole a roof the whole point of the era is that everybody's in this together one guy that forgets or one guy ruins it what happened is mace knocker shabbos the guy died now there's no person there that's going to create a problem he's not there even if a guy leaves town on vacation he's not a problem certainly over here he left toilet ms he's not a problem let me see is this very hard it's a good cup it's a good cup i couldn't tell feels cold but it's hot this chicago for you no slurpees no nothing they have uh wine wine andrew glass is the wine guy you should have seen you got me like brilliance it's delicious andrew glass is delicious very good but you know what that's not nice because the natural you can't get it i don't think and uh it's not available oh it's a non-kosher winery okay he's giving me the whole thing it's not kosher winery it's special you can't get it fine so yesterday what was the what do we have yesterday the day before i don't even remember anymore certainly we had it yesterday we started the day before the idea to rent from the guy on shabbos yeah we had it we started if you did you ran from the guy and once you run from the guy you have to do bittel on chavez everybody does beetle who does the work for no one really only that one guy that you're mavato too the guy that gains everybody's property he's the guy that gains from the whole idea okay he's the one making a kiddish let's say so he needs this more than anybody else he's going to make a bris whatever it is so you're almost him he could carry in and out but you have to do two things you have to do heroes you have to rent it from the guy once you're done renting it from him if he gives you the permission they have to do bittle and then we discuss you rent from his worker you could rent it and you could afterwards do step number two which is then certainly there's no question that the guy disappeared is not a question hashtag and if you can do two things first skirus and then step number two bitter mabaya so over here you only need one thing what do you need over here bittle you don't need serious you're not renting him from a dead man what about his relatives they're not here they might exist but they're not coming into the movie even if he has somebody to inherit him this is how i understood it it doesn't matter so what if it's owned now by johnny so he lives in california he's not going to be he's not going to ruin it the shabbos so what do we need we need bitto so of course if you're working on holds you could do bitter because you could if you could do two things you could do one according to the matter it says you cannot rent from the guy tarte who delay of dino now in that case because you couldn't can't run from the guy or maybe there's no difference on malay again answering now where was the guy was there from before shabbos so they could have rented from him they had the option to so mello you explains rashi um mma law amendment very good since they didn't rent from the guy they didn't rent from the guy they could have but they didn't so male of the area went to work didn't work bitter doesn't work in in place of a nerve omar it's very interesting i just noticed this now also rav yehuda says the name is we have this all through shas review the one of shmuel's famous tell me the rav's talmud also why am i saying this because we're going to see at the end yesterday we had i noticed all the way at the end yesterday we had that ravioli forgot his learning and he said i never heard this but he was saying over allah i mentioned it yesterday like under my breath because revisive was a talmud of review of the talmud of shemo but he should have known this because it's his rebbe's rebbe and here you have ravihuda the talmud allah this is very interesting to me you have a mother and you have one chevron guy called one guy in case they they're listening to it so they call him you have one guy that's ruining you for everybody the shop is going he ruins it for everybody because he's not part of the roof but he's in mobile he could go out like everybody get out but he has a secret passage a small four by fourth falcon it's pretty small i personally wouldn't want to go through that passageway it's kind of small narrow but he has a a way out that's how he that's how he goes even if it's four by four paschal it's open to a very wide open area even if he brings his camels and his wagons right through the movie like the jew you know he doesn't ruin it for them because of that secret passageway called secret is it he has a way out he doesn't need to use everybody else's opening my diamond piece why did he make that opening because he likes to sneak out through that opening so i have two pictures i like this picture a lot because a lot of action here there's camels and it's showing you the part of the camels but it's not really showing you the hiding is so here this is from the other here's the way he has out you see right over here i did a little red so you could see uh right over here it's not so schmuck but the problem with this picture this picture explains the sookie better i think there's no camels in this picture and here's a tiny little opening to a biker so you see the bike a lot but i think that's the main part of the sugar the big the problem is that his hole is so the opening is so small you don't even see it in the picture you guys see it something right over here i even highlighted it with a red marker but okay anyway so between the two you get the idea here even though the camel's coming in and out from the main opening into the mother the guy doesn't ruin the mother but typically he ruins it since he has a way out through the back he has a back door back entrance into the bicker he uses that that's his favorite way to go in and out he boy luke now rashid points out also he has a lot of room it's a bicker he could take care of his stuff he brings his pickup truck with the wide wheels with the wide loads he likes it over there that's where he doesn't want to go through the marvel and push with all the people okay so today we're going to discuss a lot about this kharfaff here's a karafe a car fav we had it many times it's a place that is enclosed with mkhitaryan's but it's not much of ladies people don't live here what do they do they store wood it's in vavanam beautiful picture from colorado a lot of wood lumber stones whatever it is and if you look very closely with the microscope you could see that there's a tiny little opening between the the hutzer and the kaaf i'm going to explain a little more in a few lines what is this chiropractor what a kaifa is compared to compared to the cameras very interesting lotion don't remember really i didn't do a search but she says upon means that he heard it from his rebbe who heard it from his rebbe pono he heard it from his reviewer from arabi we're turning to daft samosa base sponsored by mark steinberg who's not here tonight for you [Music] so even though so what's the what's the idea if the guy has an opening and it leads into a car fought but it's walled somebody's gonna have to climb over the wall open the door yes he likes to go into the kairofa he could do his business there nobody sees nobody he has his room he likes it over there since he likes it over there then he doesn't go through the mavoi and ruin it for the israelis the yehudim who live in the mavi that has a karfav basal oyster yoyos so we had this base aside so simon's 2 saw basically it's 50 by like the hotzer lag in the basement 50 by 100 so if it's small it's only 50 by 100 ammo 100 by 200 feet for whatever reason that's not large enough room so if it's not large enough for him say robin raviosif then the guy is going to start using the regular marvel using the regular mavoy he answers it on clay stroll on the israelim under you did him on the jews if it's yo oh that's already large enough for the guy then aydah oyster then he starts going out through his little door in the back and he doesn't go through the maverick and it's not us it's kilo the guy doesn't live there all we have is a bunch of jews all the jews made an era of great but when it comes to a jew who forgot to make a roof in a marvel then the reverse is true the israel based on hey sir if it's small he won't use the mother he'll use the opening and go through the the smaller place why goes on shabbos he doesn't have such packages that he needs such a large place now it becomes a caramelist once it's more than two saw it becomes what we call a carmelis mma law he wouldn't be able to carry there because it's a carmelus he'd have to use the mother and once you use the mother now you have a guy that's part of the mother and he wasn't mistaken from the mother he didn't he didn't contribute to the roof may law he has the ability to answer let's stop here for a second and discuss real quickly we have arush is tenth high like this table ten twelve high and four by fourth fachem that's then you have what's called a carmelus caramel is is it and it's anything wide open that doesn't fit into the category versus it doesn't fit into the category which is a rabbit like an ocean like a desert like a giant bika it's not a restaurable people don't go through there you don't have 600 000 people going to rashi or whatever the the criterious versions are happening but it's neither of us so abundance said you know what people might get confused they'll say oh if you could walk through if you could carry in a desert so you might carry from the desert you might carry from surrounding they said it's all awesome the whole camera is us then we have something called the karafev chiropractor is similar to carmelus but it has walls around it has walls around it midori raiso what is this what's a kaifa midi raiser because it has walls around it surrounded by walls what's the but since it's not hook of ladiero since you don't live there you know it's not a residence this is more for lumber let's meet mahmur on it say you can't you can't carry from one to the other you can't carry in it so let's see so this is not anything new this is basically the same exact question we had a second ago like what if the backyard is opened at karfaf malay omar lay hariyamu the same answer we had before you asked the same question that we just asked we just answered if it's less than two saw from tucson down then he's going to use it joseph saw saying any oyster great omarou kharpav joyce beso scientially hook up lediro you have a karfaf you have this giant enclosure more than two so affilo coor even if it's 30 saw vaphilo qurayim or 60 saw huge comes if you throw a ball you see this guy throwing an object a green ball here's the green ball i don't know if you could see you guys see it over there if you're standing in rochester robin and throw something into the carafe i don't care how large it is more than two saw it's as if you took something from and threw it at the end of the day surrounding it is the urine okay so it's used for lumber but because it doesn't have the urine it's not a residential place so they said it has like a caramelist but may they rise to forget it for a second before came along it's a regular it has walls all around it they said let's be makhmir make it into a carmelus but at the end of the day you can't take their homura and make it into a kula and say you're not us you're not high of miso they warned you they said if you're going to throw it from into that wall into that enclosed area you're going to be high of miso poof and he throws it in cash what if you have iraq a little island in the middle of the ocean which is why because it's and it's fourteen wide so you have a stone 10 high fourth wide and here's the ocean so this is the caramelist this is going from the cables is that allowed no see now i go from one to the other pakis what if it's shorter than tenth mid totally [Music] so we have two parts of this bryce one that it's taller and you cannot go from the yam to it and one that it's shorter you could go from the caramelist to the stoneway it's shorter than 10 fahrenheit mellow what is the stone another caramelist so i go from kind of the caramel there's no problem all day long so again the ratio is taller than tenth i cannot carry from tolerance and falcon to the yam to the cameras i can't go from the cameras but if it's shorter than the 10th falcon i'm going from a constant camera that's okay then all of a sudden the brightest says at kamo at basal sine so it could be talking about the ratio that it's taller at common basis side or the shorter it can't be the same thing more explains so here's the picture if the stone is the size up till two two saw two so up to if it's 50 by 100 this looks a lot larger up to the size so saying then what a higher element say for that it's very short and it's considered a carmelus but if it's two thousand ammo i cannot go from one to other why not base assignment if it's it's a short little rock two it's protruding from the ocean but it's five saw who cares vomit cameras like caramel at the end of the day the stone is a caramelist the ocean is a caramelist who cares what it is so that can't be the shot ending actually stays with this even though we're going to have two two other shot them but it's all within this ratio this is only be up to two saw is going on the first part karma let's see why why is it if it's more than two saw i could carry from the stone to the ocean because it's kind of like caramelized so you have to derive your canon now just as uh so you understand a little bit better this stone is tenth falcon high so does this don't have walls gnome says yes and he's right this stone has walls why does it have walls because it has tenth height and we have 10 height good asic those are the walls the walls are its height yes you don't have a mercits in the middle of the ocean but the stone itself is its walls as that if you have a kaifaf isn't this the same story why is this different than this this rebirth said if i take a ball and i throw it into here this is this also has walls here's the walls here these walls go up we always said an entire aravind if you have a mound of dirt those are the walls here's the mound here's a cella you have the walls so if i throw i shouldn't be able to carry from here to here why are you telling me this is considered a caramel is this considered that person who doesn't know how to answer up contradictions and prices to you if the massively in we're saying no of course this is and of course you can't go from this guy into the ocean you can't go from this this is a yakid so what does it mean at basal sign a base assign when am i when can i when do i have to stop carrying period if i'm stuck on this island avada i can't go from the island to the ocean this is but not only that if this stone if this island is more than two thousand ammo two thousand i'm sorry to saw sausayim a hundred by fifty ammo i can't even carry there at all i can't carry i can't walk on shabbos from here to there with something in my hand [Music] why because it's it's it's gonna you can't carry on something so large it's like it's just a rabbit um okay so may rebecca is right of course there's and i can't go from there to there and therefore if i throw a ball in the car you'll have miso rabashi omar loyola we're talking about the ratio we're talking about a stone that's more than but he looks at it it looks at it differently that yes same thing it's good this is but we're not talking about like rava carrying over here we're actually continuing with the same theme could you carry from the to the cameras oh but you're not going to carry from the you could sometimes you could why haha removed there is sir who invented the issue of karmalis in this case you could why rashford allah they're the ones that invented this sir they're the ones that are going to remove this sir hey mom recovered from you shall look they're the ones that said that a fav that's more than two saw yeah rebecca's case of throwing the ball into the toilets you have to treat electricity you can only carry four atmos and they also said they made a second answer hey mom remember tell them and you cannot go from a stone to the to the ocean you can't go from there they're the ones that invented this sister saying this and if it's less than two saw i could carry in the entire island and say you now go from the ocean to the stone and vice versa is considered so that fits in beautifully with revlon but if it's more than two saw listen to this it's mamesh counter-intuitive if it's less than two saw i'm stuck but if it's more than two saw the other that do will be cool a it's awesome now it's a two-saw so i cannot carry my island at all [Applause] no isn't this counterintuitive i'm not i carry here in anything but i'm allowed to go from the island into the water why they had to do so they had to remove that issue because if if you're not allowed to go from the island to the water people are going to say oh that's and what's step two if they say it's oh then you let it carry in it but you're not carrying it but wait a minute why can't i carry on it because this is the rabona so i'm trying to save that isn't the rabbit on again if i allow you to carry if i say you cannot carry from the island into the water you might think it's a rishi why can't i carry from the out you're going to come to carry on the island but the carry on the island is only is it rabbana and to go from the island too the water is also always to the rabbanum so i allow israel bond to go from the island to the water so that people won't do and this is the rabona to carry on the island how does that make sense oh that's the gemara's question um what's the difference between the two eastern why would i um whatever the word is why would it be matter one is or not to do another so when both of these two are made up on again just so i say i see people are looking at me a little uh what's going on here again this is the carry on the island is there about banana because it's more than two saw there's also a rabbanan to carry from the island into the water because the island is the water is the caramels but kama's on the rabbana i'm gonna allow you to carry from the island into the water so that people don't get confused and think that the island is and if they do get confused what's going to happen they might carry on the island huh but it's only is that they're abandoning the island so i'm going to take away is there a button to carry from the island to the water and also the united staring on the island to carry on the island is something that happens very common and therefore what what's the next step you might come to carry universal rabbit that's that's very important to remember you might come to carriages or rabbit i don't want you to carry yourself it's very big it's white people say oh it's like versus [Applause] i'll allow something that barely ever happens let's stop here our boys once again you scrape david for traveling all the way out here he struck all the people in new york a few people traveled i don't know if that i don't know if they got home at three well ellie dyker needs to get home every morning two two two thirty but describe to all those people that traveled came out she got everybody here actually it's already after 12 a.m and you guys are here so uh thank you very much shira maloys have a wonderful day rabbi signing [Music] foreign is [Music] my