Daf Yomi Eruvin Daf 50 by R’ Eli Stefansky

so since um so everybody's gonna have to mute themselves we are live or not live youtube you also have comments check check the youtube situation he said it's live make sure that it's live it says live on it it says it is live it's 22 seconds okay we're live now gabaldic all right so good luck to everybody there's this row if it's not live you still let me know check it out we're good um thank you y'all for irving kipper i got a half a cup of water that's okay it's okay it's it's a myth of the drink you'll fill up later yeah he likes to fill it up a lot he's he cops if he's going to do the whole cup he won't be able to fill it up soon okay now they said somebody just asked i should say over from the time because it didn't come out on the on the youtube basically the khov khan said very very simple and short he said rebuilding shalom if a person is a convert he's a girl and he doesn't have vero nobody has a tying against him nobody says oh what a what a bad guy he didn't learn he said he's mikhail shabas a little bit he he didn't realize that he you can't tell a guy this way in that way or whatever amir lakman doesn't come on he didn't learn all that what about us well we know more we have more of a of the idea than him than the than the convert so the kids are i'm just trying to position this little no it's in the thing okay fine it's not it's a little crooked whatever and then mela what he's trying to say the time is that we have to be melanchos and klay strong there's many golden that did so any any source that we can find any any taina any kind of a malta it's like who are we where am i ritsim i said the end of the day we're american we don't know allah we don't know things we it's always great so why are we different than the girl as it says in the past that we are like the gay rim we are like a garbage that was his var that was the entire jurasha of kalidre there was a person there said i don't understand what does the want like what that's the whole what's the big it took them years to understand the how deep and how and yesterday we're learning the gemara of of clay's role and and kaifa the more i think about it it's unreal to think that every one of us gives meiser regardless of how much we earn we give at least mice or according to the village you have to give 20 percent twenty percent of hamish who gives twenty percent of their income but it's not just the money it's i'm looking at somebody that put it all out for first see them and this guy gives all this and this guy they brought a bottle of wine where do you have that giving that giving the constant just giving use my house for a minion you do this uh and i'm a cavalier and i go and help a guy on the side of the road and and and and 50 of the of the the blood whatever the antibodies in america is from from from from from people and it's just giving and giving and giving kaiser gives and gives and gives so we're born that was that was the point that was the thing okay a quick email here dear rebelli it's just um yeah okay wishing you and your family marcus simatova and a good bench to your this is from arozowski from south africa you've made a massive impact on my limited torah i've managed to keep up since brachas and barkhashan will be able to finish shots with this awesome dafiyami program this has also taught my family the importance of learning torah that's what i said on the first day of brachas that the dafayoimi is guaranteed to change you and to change the way you are a father the way you are a husband the way you are a person people see the family picks up on it everybody picks up on it they see the importance of learning torah every day my sons already know that every morning i need to start my day with the deaf we are currently one hour behind israel so the time works out perfectly i learned the daf and then diamond chakras hashem should bless you and your family with abundance of brahman hoping to meet you soon i'm eternally grateful you see they're getting well actually south africa is is on the radar only because of the when this whole thing is over i got to take my wife again to on a safari and hopefully i'll go with my brother and his wife who bark hashem finish treatment imagine going through a year of treatment and then you want to go on this nice little vacation to celebrate and then you're stuck for another six months at home where you can't even say hello to anybody because of the weak immune system it's terrible anyway hoping to meet you soon i'm internally grateful for all your effort and effort at the mdy team culture of iranzovsky south africa around right so today unreal we're holding the daf nun of irvin no almost halfway through aruban omarabo lilo nishmas it's also today is also sponsored by yossi klein of superior plumbing i don't have a printout yossi klein actually on his own just 100 on his own went out put together an ad for army magazine i don't know what it looks like or where it is and when it's coming out i think it's coming out in the circus issue he insisted on doing a full-page ad or something like that he's driving us crazy he said you know we'll take care of it we'll give you the no no it's not going to happen and today's the last day him and the son against worked a lot and they got i think that it's coming out some sort of ad all right look look around the nami for it omarabo my time another guy that gives and gives and gives omarabo my time of the rav so yesterday we had a very interesting macholicus a guy is standing right over here and he says he needs to get home so what's his trick he says i know that on the way there's a tree somewhere here's the tree he's exactly 4 000 from his house and he says i want to make my arrow by the tree but it doesn't specify where what part of the tree is it the front part of the tree or the back part of the tree is it the blue line or the red line according to rav zero no error of he messed it all up because he didn't specify and according to shmuel he cannot get home but he could get pretty close to home you have five hours away from home we say that there is some sort of arrow here we don't know exactly where we have to be mahmur says shmuel he can't go backwards this way and he can't get to his house but he can walk he could get to the tree that for short to the tree he could even get to five feet away from his house omar abba so rabbit comes along and there's two versions of what rabbi said my time of the rav let me explain to you what rav says now shmuel is kind of understood shmuel says there's an arrow over here there's an arrow i just don't know exactly where it is so let me be mahmur to both directions whatever the hummer is but there's an arrow i can't ignore the fact that he made a narrative raf says the zero why zero we kind of explained it nicely yesterday here it is again my time of the rav at least he didn't specify he didn't specify where exactly is erev is and therefore yatsakirayak mekano makhani's bald from here and there in other words if he wouldn't have said anything and he said the arab is where i am right now that's my makham chavisa great so he'll be able to walk two thousand arms to the tree that's not what he said he said my area was by the tree and the tree is undefined we don't know what the tree is is it the front or the back so he doesn't have a tree and he doesn't have where he is he's mama's nothing zero he's he's a garnish he has four albums and this is going to launch us into a nice sugar and a brand new concept and that's why me every single day there are new concepts especially if you didn't learn that before every day there's a new you saw it a new idea that you didn't know about before today's big idea is this one right here omaraba maitai medirav mushum de kosava he holds kholshaynoi we're going to say this a lot if you cannot do something one after the other then you can't do it together i think your's going to give many examples again it's going to become very clear in other words if you cannot make two a rule of him one after another because you just can't make too a room that's allah right a lot you can only make one a roof i could either i could pick and choose i could go in that direction go in this there i can't i can't make two i can't say oh in the morning i want to go to the right and then even i want to go to the left so since you can't make one after another so you can't make them both together what happened over here he didn't specify is it to the right or to the left and to make to a room you can't do even if together it doesn't it doesn't happen it doesn't apply itself okay so if it sounds a little interesting and not 100 clear as we get through the cases will become more and more clear but it's a new it's a new concept right we didn't have this from beginning of broadcast anu if it doesn't work what's the word consecutively what's the oh no simultaneously is then it doesn't work simultaneously consecutively sequentially sequentially consecutively fine if it doesn't work but zach is there i like zach better sound if it doesn't work one after another if i if i am not allowed to say my ear is to the east and then my ears to the west then i cannot put the east and the west together in one time i'm going to see how that works in many different alakazam myself my subahima so i can't do red and blue together so if red and blue don't work together and you didn't specify so so none of them are five zero if you can't do one after another it can't work simultaneously might be niu what's the difference the tube shot them i i didn't specify where i am or it's not going to be khaled as we're going to discuss that this tree is eight almost wide so if the guy says i don't want all eight i don't want consecutive i want one part of it one for i'm a part i'm just not defining which i'm not telling you i didn't tell you if it's the front part of the trunk or the sec by the way if i say bark or say a funny word in english feel free to correct me okay i'm not insulted by it but i was saying bark yesterday like i'm sugar trunk the trunk of a tree is much better okay so if i didn't specify the front or the the rear the back then but i said four ammos i want four out of the eight so i don't have this problem of bizarre i'm not trying to do something consecutive i'm trying to do something that's perfectly legal which is a four ama domain a four ammo resonance i just didn't specify so if you say mandom from the limits i'm mastering but according to the first shading rabbit like we explained last night he wasn't specific if you're not specific you lose out holy messiah mastery so you didn't gain anything okay he said i want four within eight he's still not being specific he didn't define it you don't define it bye bye no way roof but if you're telling me that the problem the only problem here is that since it doesn't work consecutively so it's not going to work simultaneously but i don't want it to work consecutively all i wanted to work is i want to work 1 4 amis that's it over here we're talking about one area of four albums because he said so himself he said i only want four out of the eight five and now i didn't count exactly but a bunch of nice suggest again a tour through shas sort of of different suggests different ideas how this idea of bizarre works kufa so as we learned if you can't halogically do one after the other then certainly you can't do it in one shot a sway so raboisei as you see here this also this whatever goes to the sheer has to know true muslim maestro's about inside out we're not going to be on maritzim anymore many of us including myself probably a few years ago didn't know a thing about truma and myself my sushini what year am i sir oni it's all going to come together and and it's very scary sometimes tuma tum is also very easy very so anytime we have an opportunity we're going to show this so that becomes ingrained in our heads so of course when you have crop you have 100 apples so you have to take truma give it to the kind how much but it's not apples let's we'll talk apples fine because it's more nugellar mice but the tartar talks about grain you can take one little grain that's worth a fraction of a cent and give it to the client and that's it what we give a two percent let's call it two percent fine so if you have a hundred apples a hundred grand hundred apples you give the kind two apples what are you left with 98. so from the 98 you have to give meister to the lady it's called my servicing 10 percent so 98 you give 9.8 apples to the to the levy and then the lady he takes from his ten percent he just got he takes he takes off ten percent gives that to the client also that's called true muslim fight now in the true magdala the two percent what if a guy wants to be really nice to the kai and give ten percent is that us or no rabbi say i'm telling you yes you guys don't know this ask 95 out of a hundred yeshiva bhagavan they won't know this following allah and that's why i say it's very important it's die it's good eye for them to learn that fear me even if it's like rabbi fine in chicago was telling me that his son and his friends they learned this year i didn't know he says do you know that the latter bunker you could put it on by by the break you could put it on a little quicker one and a half time in 30 minutes you get another daf you can get more musa in in gemara it's unbelievable instead of just being in the entire year you get a little bit extra anyways listen to this you wouldn't believe this if you decided to be large and give the levy more than ten percent no the kind is good if you decide to give the cayenne more than one percent two percent more than one grain no problem why because the third doesn't define how much you should give to him you could give even one grain if you want to give a hundred grain material but if you decide to give to the lady more than 10 percent the tara says 10 and you decide to give 11 terrible it's no good it ruins everything what happens the the extra that you gave the lady is not micer and you didn't take myself from it it's called it's considered tavel and devil's not edible and the devil is mixed in with the other micer and the whole part that you gave the lady is no good now what happens is one minute your fruit is good your 90 whatever apples are okay but everything you get to leave is not okay you made a very big boo-boo would you did anybody know this aloha anybody that if you go extra on the micer it's awesome terrible yeah what are you saying y'all oh matana but he didn't give him a very good you guys hear what y'all's asking kasha why can't he give it as a present as a matano you could but he didn't he gave it as micer and micer is if he would separate it and give it as a present fine but the problem is also terrible if it's the matana is mixed in with the micer and you never took myself from the matano so now you have food that it's not edible in the pile of apples you can't point out which one is what so the lady can't eat anything nobody can eat it you destroy your swell also can eat nicer and you can't eat it now nobody could eat it okay so it says like this because there is mice are in there the meister is there you just don't know where it is the problem is it's not edible because it's mixed it's a mixture of devil and micer but meister is there so your 90 apples are kosher that you gave the mice extra mice or to the honey it's a good shot i don't think so but uh we have to look into it i would i would guess not you're saying well what's the i don't think you can do anything the lady but first of all anybody could eat it it's not just the lady i don't he's asking what's the tikkun i think it's it's messed up stuff that's it i mean you could eat it his fruit is gone so it take take more i don't think there's anything you can do anyway it says like this what doesn't it it's a good child i hear it's a good child but you could ask that on anything i mean even even the two percent should be also it doesn't say the entire two percent it says give true mark it could be one grain so how could i give two percent to the cayenne the akash is even on the two percent you have akasha add too much micer your fruit is okay you could eat the 90 leftover apples umass royce and the micer is no good am i asking this idea that we just said should allow the meister to be okay why because if i give if i give ten percent to the lady and then i give another ten percent to levy the second ten percent doesn't work i can't give consecutive micer so if i give it together question if i can't give it one after another so it shouldn't work at all and that's the tikkun now you're looking at a pile of fruit that doesn't have any mystery to it at all it's not so start over again take it back it didn't work it's not that there's mice or antel in one pile it's nothing it's just fruit that you never took myself from why because if i took ten apples and gave it to the levy and then i took another 10 apples and i gave it to lay v the second 10 apples are no good because it's bizarre it only works once you can only take meister ones so if i took 20 apples and i gave it to the lady why are you telling me it's a problem it should be zero it's as if i didn't give anything says so here's my picture for today one of them you are supposed to give 10 apples to the lady let's just round it out it's not 10 it's 9.8 10 apples and instead you gave 20 ask the gemara but if you gave 10 plus the second ten is no good so if you gave 20 why is it good i'll tell you why it's good because of this one don't think this was easy to make because i'm allowed to give a half an apple to levy so maybe what i did was i gave the levy 20 apples but only 20 halves when i said 20 i meant to say 20 halves which equal 10. 10 is okay i didn't say so but why am i sure enough to give him 20 when i'm only allowed to give 10. so what i meant is 10 20 halves you see i had to go to each apple and color it in black no i just did copy and paste 20 times but uh whatever you see here let me show you closely not bad not bad for for part of its graduate artist fine so anyway but but an area of this doesn't work this idea i can't if we're talking about a roof i i can't say i meant one i'm out of the two atmos four amis out of the eight every other ammo should work that doesn't work in here the if a person said i want half of each grain to be my sir katja it works so amazing it's an interesting idea maybe that's what he meant we're going to answer that that's what he meant he meant to say half of the 20 apples what about this huh you can't get up an animal you can't give an animal so this is my sublime right you have a lot a lot of sheep you let them loose through a door one by one every tenth one that comes out of the barn it's supposed to be one by one not like this picture i couldn't find a better picture this is a ariel in australia they're all running through this way so every tenth one gets a red mark and he's micer and an animal obviously i cannot make a half an animal meister i can't cut animal in half so it's whole animals that we're talking about and the tenth animal goes to the kite the last of that song so what's the problem rabbit says rava says yo see i'm telling you if you you could count hundreds of places where it says rabba and they change it to rav or robin they change it to rabbi some guy in vilnius messed up big time like the uh amarettes that was doing it every time and said i don't know what happened there's a big mess up between rav and robin chasse and uh something happened over there i'm not sure what but they know from whoever said it to who that it can't be rather it was a different gender whatever vamana rabbi yelatsu schneider syrup nassiri if two animals came out simultaneously through the gate as this this is a famous soogie famous mishna two came out and he called them 10th he didn't realize it came out simultaneously you have a 10th and 11th together so what happens they're both kardash one is misor one is shlamim i don't know which one is what but they're very similar there's a very interesting rashi here if you look at the giant rashy words not the largest widest lines the middle section in the middle and rashi says let's call it 10 lines below where the gemara ends in rashi it says sir so the both one islam and one is a miser says you have to lean on the animal you have to bring wine you have to lift up the animal it's it's thai hazard it's not so you know we were learning the sugiya and avi kamiyansky we're mamas like in smacky middle of menaches and i brought flower one day i surprised everybody brought out a whole bowl and i was making a mini middle shear so he tried to up it one like the following day we were learning about nouveau he went out to the to the to the hills with his bike and he found an arab there with uh with it was sheep paid the guy some money and he did nufa he lifted a it's very heavy he put his two hands underneath he's trying to lift the this whole no because the gemara over there was talking about of doing um sukkas when we were talking about circus who's doing uh na nuem with the animal you go this side that way anyway so something like that so it says like this you're supposed to when it comes to you have to do smirk on the sacrum by mistake you you bring something instead of it you have to bring both of them as a car but my ain't giving myself this doesn't apply to mice fine she says but two of them came out of the pen in the same shot is siri gomorrah he doesn't know which one is 10 siri it doesn't know which one is 10 which one is 11. both of them you have to be mahpid and lift it up do the whole nufo what avi did and smith lean on its head which in meister you don't lean but we're going to be i just love this line right over here that's why i read this rash the liby oymer and my heart tells me in other words rasheed never heard this from his rebbe he's saying i have an intuition i have a feeling should not make a bracha la heaven whatever rash he says here i don't care as much as the words he says believe me i love that thing believe me my heart's out usually your ashes doesn't say that he knows he has tradition from his rabbi and everything here rash is saying i'm saying for my own intuition okay so let's continue this famous mishna so what's the shiloh the question is how in the world do both animals become kadaish what if a tenth animal went out of the pen i said kaddish then the 11th one out of the pen i said kaddish it doesn't work what is that called in our language one after the other doesn't work so how come simultaneously you're telling me both of them are called it should be zero neither of them should be called excuse me fine it's because if there's a mistake there's a special allah by meister everything becomes kardosh i don't know what to do here i have to eat something what do you got there what kind of food you have we'll take some sushi in the middle of this year to cover the yum kipper maybe it'll help the situation here you brought sushi the covered erabium keeper because the mistletoe boys i eat eat eat while we're learning it's a mitzvah this naan but by you guys what am i saying eat it's already mushroom cube i forgot what am i talking about fine this naan karalachi if a guy made a mistake passionate mistake he he lost oh he also has mark ashkenazi as a sushi right in front of him you call that sushi what do you what do you think this is sushi oh yeah yeah i'm going to eat it with a fork because i don't want to make a fool out of myself this is the first time i'm eating in sheer in two years we have to it's a mitzvah you didn't learn broccoli no chopsticks a fork what kind of my material are you i said specifically i don't want to make a fool out of myself miss my mitchell it's not all for me i just realized okay i hope you have double triple there you always getting nervous why yo you like sushi he loves it right no y'all doesn't like sushi but he wants to make sure i don't double dip okay he's in charge joel's in charge you all like surim he said he doesn't like sushi but i'll take the survive a triple dip advice i didn't work so maybe i should have more still stuck triple dip all right talk to hillary tomorrow that was gross on the middle of sheer eating sushi have rice in different places it's going to it's going to hit the youtube camera on this siri by the way seriously what i did is awesome you're not supposed to stop learning toyota which is the greatest minnesota to eat whatever it's a myth i said even though it's a mitzvah there's no greater myths in ontario and you don't stop tired for eating however if you guys are i'm just trying to get you guys going what do you say i still got it this is still i'm thinking i'm in the middle right now every every two minutes another piece of rice drops down into the mouth and goes okay it's not going to yes siri you passion mess up you call the ninth one tenth the tenth one ninth with siri and the eleventh one you call ten because you're nine is ten ten is nine and eleven is ten you conf your mama is miss kabob related fine slash all three the big mistakes are quite this so here you have the idea it's not us doing something we're being it's not the mission says when you make a mistake in in meister everything becomes kodesh fine so we're done with that next case vare toido carbon taito something very special happened to somebody somebody came out of a disease who comes out of uh whatever so we do uh a guymo what you're supposed to do and when base comes based on hashem you bring a carbon target you say thanks to him what do you do one of the things you bring is 40 breads 40 breads six go to the cayenne 34 remain i think it is yes six is it four or six four go to the kind four garlic 36 remains by you now the famous vart you know okay we could say we haven't said it in a long time why what are you going to do with 36 breads you can't who could eat 36 breads and the answer is you can't you have to invite your friends and that creates ah and that's part of the thing you make a party for your friends you give oh we give back teaches us how to give byre to the lesbitos you can't there's no concept that if you bring 80 breads that they all all 80 are cottage it's not like mice or you don't have the idea of toast now if i brought 40 breads and then i brought another 40 breads the second 40 are nothing with my if i cannot bring 40 plus 40. it shouldn't zero should be kaddish why does chriskia the rebbe of rebbi say that 40 out of the 80 become kaddish it doesn't fit into this idea of culture and rebirth on his own he says but the question is from the rebbe frisky says 40 out of the 80 are good tita why since you can't do it consecutively so you shouldn't be able to do it simultaneously you're right you shouldn't be able to says my name the country everybody agrees that if somebody says specifically i want 40 out of the 80. is zoom frozen israel it's good they're checking it they're saying it's good only here in this basement because of chicago's internet it's not the whole united states just chicago what would you say i hear somebody talking okay fine how come they make a domain if you say 40. i want 40 out of 80. the kochie it's great to show our boy melon king culture money but if a person specifically i want i i won't do 40 unless all 80 are kudos to everybody agrees there's no in other words this is the concept of culture since i can't do 40 plus 40. so i can't even do 80 together so therefore if a person says i want all 80 to become cautious it doesn't work at all oh so then what is the machole eggs between christian is when a person doesn't specify at all he doesn't say i want 40 out of 80. he doesn't say i want old lady he doesn't say anything he wants a guarantee they say in hebrew he set aside 80 breads because what if what if some of the breads are no good they're crunched they're ripped open they don't look perfect i want 40 perfect bread so i'm going to give 80 and then we're going to choose 40 out of those 80 in case some get lost or whatever the idea is so it may love altenew so it's more of a tonight it's a condition if this doesn't work if some of these are no good then that to my liking i'm going to use the other one so that's why i'm making 80. but not because i want all 80 to be a toy though now we're turning to that base um carbon gradually no there's a problem when a person doesn't specify what he meant is he does he's he doesn't know that he can't that'll tell you this 40 he thinks the toyota is 80. and that's why he said 80. he doesn't specify we don't know i'm a melo that's a problem yeah i'm about to i just want to finish the line don't worry i didn't forget [Music] over here we just turned to the number base sponsored by mark steinberg bazer shem soon will have a shin hashem a shield for his son mayor joseph and by mr anonymous fats you described himself and his horse for his family to be toyora di yiddin says attacked rabb says right we started off the whole suggest with rav that what the guy standing over here he makes an error of somewhere in this tree he doesn't specify where in the tree says rav zero imam is lost out he gets less than a regular human being a regular human being who resides right here gets two thousand dollars in every direction this guy because he decided to be ibrahim and try to get to his house but he didn't specify so now he lost out he has four hours imagine for 24 hours straight you have to be in an 8 foot radius that's it you can't go this way that way going to the bathroom is a different story if he has to go to the bathroom we had to also give fine says mario says if the whole canopy with the trunk of the tree and everything is 12 ammo what's 12 hours 12 ammo is divisible by four you have three four parts three parts that are four amis wide aval be launched mixes basically nick uh okay so i have a picture it's not the greatest i took it off colossal and blew it up very large so at least that we could understand the concept here it's very simple since since there's less than 12 amma underneath the tree then if you take three boxes the center backs the red backs in the center overlaps the other two boxes mma law says abayo this guy is the higher in the center backs so even if he may meant the arab should be closer to him then he's touching the area of closer to him and if he meant that the arab is in the further backs then he's touching the further backs he's touching both boxes so what's the problem what's the question new andrew you're about kitchen what's the question on this i'm not sure the question let's go again if there's less than 12 ammos so then the center guy is touching both boxes it has to be this is less than 12 ohms each box is worth four amis so each blue box that we have here is is four ounces beforehand the center box the red box where we're assuming this guy is he's going to be touching both so what are you what are you concerned you're concerned that maybe his arrow is in this box right over here closer to his house okay he's touching that box he's within that box his arrow no his four elements overlap this box so he's part of that arab and and what's your other thing oh no no maybe he made the arrow on on the box closer to him so the red overlaps him also if it's more than 12 ammos so the center box doesn't overlap anything but if it's less than 12 ammos no rabbi so what's the problem with this is what and therefore what oh so here's the problem maybe that's what you mean think more as who's told you that he's in the middle who told you he's in the middle and he's touching both boxes maybe he's on the blue box over here maybe he decided he should be in the blue box maybe this house should be in this box if if he's on the trunk of the tree you're right but who thought he's in the trunk of the tree you thought he's in the center that's the whole problem in the studio we don't know where no matter what the center backs overlaps the right and the left muscular vulnerability who told you that he's in the middle of that maybe he's in the blue box he's not in the red box let's change it around we're talking about a tree like that's what i mentioned before we're talking about a tree that's eight amex oh so now there's only two boxes there's not we don't have three boxes the whole tree is seven hammers you can only fit two boxes in the tree one to the east one to the south one that's softer wanted whatever you want to call it north and south now that the boxes overlap they overlap because within the tree you only have seven arms and each box is worth four amis so they overlap so no matter what the guy is touching his arrow if you put him in a blue box and the arrow is in the red box so he's touching the red backs great now i could go home and if you want to put him in the red box my toy i can go home and if he wants he could also go back to the hotel because he's touching the blue box so in melee we have to say that the tree is eight arms and the boxes don't overlap that's the story over here the boxes don't overlap fine but if they do overlap so that only works nine and twelve like we said before that only works in seven before we said it's eleven but eleven who told you that he's in the center box maybe he's on the right or the left but what if it's seven then he has to be touching both boxes one of the there's only two bags in the overlap the bigger the tree just keep adding boxes right no you can't so we're at a maximum at three boxes no maximum two boxes if you want to make sure that you can get home we said he can't get home ralph says he can't get home because the tree is larger than two boxes once you're at more than two boxes then you're not touching the area of mimanov shaft there's not a oh you have to be touching there maybe i'm not touching the error maybe i'm on two boxes away from nayroof if there's two boxes then they they definitely overlap two backs is overlapped seven ammos then the two back is overlapped so you want to put him in this box then he's touching this box he's touching his back so then he can go home rav never said is that they can't go home only when there's more than two boxes once there's more than two boxes then maybe he's on the the far backs and the areas on this on the opposite side of him he's not touching it no problem whatsoever no brown so ever of course it's because it's a very large tree and we don't know what part of the tree this side yeah if it's it's a branch if it's a little stick to tree then it's beautiful he said i'm going to that pole that pole is less than four amis then he goes home no problem the problem is we're talking about a giant tree at least 12 almost once it's 12 amis you can't divide the tree you have to divide the tree into four four ammo pieces and twelve almost means it's three pieces so he's not 100 touching zero he might be two boxes away from his room and that is the problem that's why rap says he can't go home but it's really not 12 it's really anything over eight a little bit over eight there's already a third box thank you for saying thank you we have variety to rav that he can't do anything he can't even move from where he's at and we have a right to shmuel that he could go all the way almost home he could use the aerobic use this tree even though he didn't specify the rav okay so this is basically like the mission it's a bryce but it's going to say word for word like what we just learned a person is walking and you know a lot of times the bryson just repeats over the mishnah but adds a little bit so a guy is walking and it got dark i told you this story it happened to me once on shabbos when i was a young kid i was 15 years old on the way to yeshiva and i was being reckless i went during a snowstorm and the bus got stuck and i got off the bus basically in shops happens happens to the best of us i i just had guests just uh a couple months ago they were calling them where are you where are you we got lost this that that the next thing before i know it they parked the car got out of the car i had a walk three four miles i had no idea where they were they told me they're somewhere in betchamesh they told me an approximate place and i started walking and i found them we came home very late and i mean very after i missed my review of the whole thing we actually no we did do a little meyer we found the show we did a but they're schlepping suitcases two babies and suitcases through the streets of bachamesh literally they they must have walked four four five miles yeah anyways it happens so mr khashoggi my he remembers on the way this is some sort of tree he doesn't see it he knows there's a tree there's a fence i want my residents to be let's fast forward over there i'm shifting my residence right that's the word i'm shifting into that street loyal my clown he didn't say anything abalone complaining why again tree is large fence is large we're on the tree we're on the thing but if he says specifically i wanted that part of the trunk that part of the fence the northeast corner of the fence beautiful then just explain what we learned already you go until that place once you get to that corner of the fence you can you can walk it from there you get another two thousand ammo so here comes the bryson ads and let's see if there's a riot to what we learned means a very specific place meaning it has it's a fenced in area okay if you have a fence scenario which is less than two saw two saw is equivalent to five thousand square ammo like in the we learned about you so extensively in the beginning so you're in a valley anyways it's a defined area with a fence it's less than tusso but if you're not in the defined area you don't have fences or it's more than touso en el dollardames now you stuck you only have your four albums because we said up to two saw is considered two dalaramas for you as far as you're concerned you're daladamus now two people are walking together one knows the way well one knows about the trees and the fences one has no clue the one that doesn't know anything says rash he must say specifically you are my agent you are mesh liar you understand where the trees are you do it for me you can't just rely on him he has to tell him straight out okay and the guy says see very good because he's doing it for two people so no making it i did not see it i didn't see it and then pretended that i'm guessing it was just pretty obvious srivisasi is singular but he's doing first second person but complain by the way i mean just uh i didn't have all the time in the world to go over this dive because last night i got home closer to one o'clock in the morning and that's when i started preparing so have rahman is a little bit and i also had to do all this what we didn't finish yet he says i'm doing good they always they always ask me what did the guys say i get i get it at least once a week please repeat what the guy asked so i'm saying right now i don't want to embarrass anybody but when i don't repeat usually because it's cash i don't want to embarrass him so i just answer and like fight again okay when it's finished then i do repeat i have one question what happens when i know the place and i'm designating a fence this offense is gone a storm blew it away yesterday it was a huge storm and when i get there on friday where's my fence but but it's a specific spot so i would say the specific spout is what counts it's a gps location i don't think it's as much as a that's what my own i'm not i'm not a rub i'm not passing what leave you behind here leave your arm i think it's a coordinate it's it's it's a spot now you you you can't make up a spot you can say oh in the middle of the desert it's right over here what do you mean right maybe it's right over there but if you get there and the fence is not there because you see it was uprooted but everybody knows that on this block there's a fence so what's wrong with that it's not the you're not you're not attaching yourself to a fence you're telling yourself to a location and on that location there's a fence now it doesn't it's not there now i think it's still good because you you had in mind that that location the physical locations there the landmark it's landmark yeah i think i don't know it might be wrong a small tree it's gone smells true yeah so it's just the the land i know it was but you you commented that to that land there's a tornado in chicago it took out a whole park okay but so you have to know the exact it has to be within the millimeter you can't just oh i think it's somewhere over here then once again we have that same brownie you didn't specify your residence okay so but all this is not part of the point where's the point avalosium when is all this happening when he defines the four amis he says right over there this man is what we're talking about he defines it but he didn't define a specific area of four amish eight feet long he's worse off than anybody else anybody else has four hours but from the four hours you can go 2 000 on us but this guy messed up like we discussed before since he said my residence is over there by that tree but the tree was uprooted and he has no idea where it is so he just gave up his residence right over here if he didn't give up his red residence where he's at so he has 2000 almost like every normal human being he has four atmos right four amis plus two 000 in every direction he has to pick the but he said i don't want my for my four hours i want my four albums to be where that uh undefined theory is he didn't define it so he just gave up what he has now and he didn't he didn't define an area so melee has zero what does he have he's left with four atoms only and not the two thousand dollars that comes with the four ammos oh let's have it to you you don't have to define in the area we say approximately okay you can't go all the way home but we have to be mahmoud but the area of work says in this case going back to this case again the a-roof could be on the blue line there it could be on the red line he didn't define the area what does rav say he gets zero what does shimon say no it's a great aero we just don't know which line so let's be mahmoud but over here it says if you don't define specifically it's exactly what raph says you have to define the exact line if i could say this line over great but he didn't divide it if you don't define you get one big zero which equals four ammos no that's manage what raf says isn't that a great rioter treyarch what's going on here is he's going to explain the brazo that where am i do i have a picture oh anyway no picture for this hmm okay there's no such thing as over time matam kipper it's museum keeper what do you get is no overtime everybody's such something i'm serious on airbnb coming to learn um i don't know what to do okay there's no 2004 right that's probably the picture no no this is a different case i i guess i forgot to print it me shine it we'll do it without it here you know what let's just use this just to look at this picture yeah but it's a picture i had a good one here we go from where the guy is till over here is 2004 amaz okay 2400 so let's start again a person has four amis go to the edge of your four amis and you start your 2000 ama so in essence a person has 2004 almost what's going on here is that part of the tree this red line is passive 2004 almost so if you define your area outside of the 2004 amis that's already outside you can't even get there that's what the bryce is talking about in the mishnah in this case that we were talking about the whole time it's within your 2000 amis this red line is within 2004 i'm so you're good we're talking about enterprises specifically this very specific case according to shmuel he's going to say that the case is that's beyond the trump so indeed and if you're going to put his residence on the opposite side of the tree on the further part of the further side of the tree come lay lebron it happens to be outside of his trunk if he defines his area then it's good villain so since he didn't define his area then we're going to assume that he went to the to the further part of the tree the first which is outside of the home and that ruins it for him but if he doesn't so he's within the trom says the gemara [Music] okay thank you and now we're going to bring one right to schmuel and that will be it for today a person is an amaritz he doesn't know they can't make more than one arrow so what he does is he thinks in his brain shima irvin he thinks you could make an arrow to two opposite sides in the morning he needs to go visit a swigger to the east in the afternoon he has to go to charlottesville to the west he thinks he can do that he showed my life out of here or he tells us slaves go make me a nerve now he didn't he wasn't smart about it he told two of them to do it so what happens when you tell two people to do something they did two two gosselin golems they both they did two a ruben in two opposite directions and one went to the north valley of the door one to the south mahalo now very positive this is from the colosseum i just added the red line over here to explain a little bit better the bottom line is that the aero one slave put his revere or he did it and one put it over here but there's only a thousand army see i put in a nice red you could see you could read it otherwise it's difficult to read what they did a thousand ammo total 2000 ammo so even if this area of works and only this error works the guy still could go all the way to here from here there's 2000 hours that works so what the second slave put in there of it's all within the air of so the second area of the didn't hurt me so i may like to walk within the arrow within the 2000 ammo here's the house and the guy made an area of a thousand ammo away from the house so this ammo this area of works i could get to a thousand dollars to the other side of the house right no no you're back to the same cash as your last night it doesn't work like that oh but let's say the guy set this arrow it's good it works so it doesn't hurt you you just don't know which one it is if you set them both together fine but this guy said in there this guy's it now you don't know which one came first either way i'm allowed to walk 2000 ammo the second one can't retroactively move on my first one they didn't set it at the same millisecond so the mitsuhalov is at home however if it's the same exact case but rather than the error being a thousand i'm away it's exactly 2 000 i'm away it's over here now this guy is messed up now since we don't know so what happens is he's stuck in his house and he can't leave he doesn't have two thousand dollars in each direction from his house because maybe this is there that works and he can't go this way or maybe this is the area that works so you can't go this way so what do you what does he do he stays right there and then oh says the gemara kashm layman according to rav there's nothing how does he that's that's your kasha basically the heir wasn't defined so if it's not defined how could he walk in either direction says the gemara rav tana so this is the famous concept of the shasta i forgot to look it up i didn't have time to look it up i should say rav was the first amira okay in the way it works there was there was a generation of tanaam and he happened to be the first first amarah but since he lived in that generation of tanayam it didn't just stop it wasn't like uh so melee has the power as a tana to argue on other tanay and he argues you're right so you asked me a cash from a bryce he argues in the bryce he's a tana he could say whatever he wants a boy sai if you're a nazi stroll have a good bench gr a great year and if you're in america and the ones that are right for you should be in the scalpel the ones that are not right not and um it should be a year of more torah more connection barry klein i only had two pieces where's the sushi your