Daf Yomi Eruvin Daf 49 by R’ Eli Stefansky

good morning rabbi sci are we live all right still like um 11 15 here in chicago but it's 7 15 are strong again unbelievable in 1922 in spanish you guys know what it is what's wrong with you guys a muslim schmoe rosenberg from honduras nigeria yeshivas you can and raise seven years son with many hundreds of offspring teaching and learning toyota and their destroying america official entirely once again by our great friend yuval kavosh in memory of ferdis kaya bat esteve fischio all right it's heir of yom kippur and i just want to say over from the sky and tie it in in just a few minutes when he gave his y'all y'all again with the water unbelievable again we're stuck at 99 people on over 100. and there might be problems very good okay as we spoke so the says he said at a russia called new dre a very very short russia and a very simple one hold on everybody's in zoom we're having issues with the um with the internet in this building well you watched this year also you're one of those guys very nice okay we have connection so the point is that we have to be mulamite's host wherever we can it's our job that's what the time was trying to tell tequila that's what says the gemara we're holding that from the base towards the bottom today's daf memphis all right real quickly we have this case of three katseroys raboisei rabboisai let's take it down a level let's concentrate here the others i used to have to be we have to give them we have three hot cereals the outer one did the arrow with the inner one the other one here with the inner one but the other ones they're not doing it narrative with each other therefore omar have you heard of zulu very much that the inner guy has access to the outer guys and the other guys to the inner guys but not the outer guys see each other so rob says meshes okay according to rav we have these green arrows rip shimon says there's access from the center to the side from the center to the side from the side to the center but you cannot go all the way around you can't go from the from the sides to each other abacha you could go from the side to the center but not from the center to the side why because it's impossible to be in two places at the same time you can own two different places you either own to the right or you own to the to the left so the center guy he's limited to zero he cannot go to the sides but since the side guys did an area with the center they could go to the side so you see how it is it's red this way it's green this way green this way red this way okay the middle guy cannot go to the sides according to rav nakamura so according to rav in rip shimon you have access from the center to the side from the side to the center just you can't go from side to side and according you're limited in one direction you can go from the center to the side from the side to the center but not from the center to this side why again because the guy in the middle he cannot he cannot make two arrows he has one visa one mocking that he does and that's it either to this way this way since he did to a ruben he can't go either way i could hear you yeah yeah you are mute oh boy we were telling you that people could watch perfectly on call you're jumping up and down and changing stuff we don't care about color shawn we care about youtube avi because that over a thousand people watch it on youtube so what good does color change for me but okay but thank you thanks and also people can watch it on telegram but you know what there's 15 000 people that watch it on whatsapp so we'll talk about that later i understand your sheet though but it's a little whatever shimmy rock okay we'll talk about it later avi it's great anyway in about five seconds you know birdman to get a little closer to you in five seconds that's ravshita now come shimon says something else um in other words according to rashi we're doing a slide down what you thought is in fact that's rip shimon and him are going to go one step even lower so what do we say said that the center guy can't go to the sides but the sides could go to the center that became rib shimon shita a second agora said he has access to them they have access to them now he's limiting according to small no ribs became and they say no one has access to anyone everybody was an oyster on each other it's all lost sir they made a big balaganier and therefore everybody is awesome one two three open to each other this is what you see entrances and here's there's just arriving down here they're all open there's just a wrap it's good so far so good let's do it quickly before it goes off two guys on the side made an arrow with the middle so check this out what does it say here zoo me via this one could carry this way this one could carry this way and there's no mention what the middle guy could do it doesn't say that the middle guy could go either direction doesn't talk about the middle guy why what does that mean to us the middle guy is awesome he can't go anywhere it doesn't mention oh that's not a good idea that you're on that table because you're moving to youtube so you have to go to that table at that table here and you'll show them you'll say show them where you can sit notice i anyway the guy on the side could do whatever he wants he go this way that way that's the guy on the side the guy in the middle has no right to go either direction you see he's all red you can't go in any direction not the middle guy to the side and not the side guy to the middle guy says and this makes a lot of sense name of voice here we go beautiful picture this is from the izbahadar i'm back to printing large format not because i like it just i don't know how to do the small format it barely fits into the screen that's good it's good stuff now this case and this case are almost identical the difference is this is all hatserius one two three and this we have a mother on this side of mavi on this side of the center the idea is the same and this that's why i'll be a very good writer to what we just said do much more constitutional voice if the customer is sandwiched between a lovely on each side if the guy that hudson made an area of it with both my voice that's what we're talking about that if you try to jump on two hasanos you try to make an area with two places neither of them work asura can't you can't carry anywhere lawyer himself but if he didn't make it heir of at all now you have a guy in here in the center of the whole situation that didn't make an error so everybody's awesome let's say this guy used to go to the right this hutzer always used to use this muffin on the right never let's say here in chicago nobody ever uses alleys let's call this an alley this alley nobody likes to use this alley it's very dark and scary so no this is a regular and they're not regular because is that sure gila by also visiting a regular boy motor the one that he's used to going in is also the shiny with the one he's not used to going through regularly so he made a rope to the left he's allowed to the only way how can you carry in a culture like this if he makes one a roof with one of the mothers as soon as he makes two a reuben you can't dance on two hasanos he get he gets nothing so the best idea to make it is that's fine just because he uses it today he decides to make area with the one without use so the one that he uses on the right it's on its own that's let's say these guys on the right they made a an arrow by themselves this is shannon and the guy on the left all the guys in the left did not make an error we asked malaya and the lords in the middle of here so you tell the hutzer you are part of the bad guys the guys that didn't make air if you didn't make it if they didn't make an air you're all in the same category don't ruin the aero that was made on the right side yes i know you'd like to use this mother but for today don't use it what is that called says gemara a major you're saying you described coifin don't be in russia they made it an area if they want to use it you don't need you don't need it right now you pretend you use this model on the left let them be what's quite familiar this time in general if a person doesn't lose out from helping then we force him to help that's the idiot and that's the point i want to make with the prophet we as yidden we should be very proud because we are tremendous tremendous in getting in giving and giving all the organizations and countless countless organizations we give and we give and we give and if we don't want to give when we can give kreifen amida's [Music] the good and clay store where it is and here here's a tremendous very easy to do which other nation gives 10 percent of their income or 20 of their income a claim is a lot of people give just give and besides all the time and the effort that people give and give to others it's unbelievable because look at us and see what we do we're gairing we're all gayrim and yet we uh village all right this idea rebreva said once he he spoke to an accountant that worked for anand a very very wealthy person and he told her he said i understand you earn so much that if you give it won't even cost you anything with all the tax deductions everything you're able to give you won't you won't notice it and she said i only give when i'm forced to give when the irs comes whatever but it's time to give even though not not not something i do no final time if it doesn't cost you we make you do it so in this case so going back tomorrow in this case these guys made an area of this guy that didn't make here we take the center guy and push them to the bad guys and we say don't bother the guys over here let them do their thing on me that's done it's time to be in russia we don't allow take a piece of bread from you from you put in the center and one guy says i don't allow anybody to touch my bread he ruined the ear of eine what's up what does mean it means we're all together in this we put it together and if you're gonna grab if i'm if i don't allow you to be together with me that's not an error error it is a good area of el shanique verdino these are the stingy guys the guys that make a bad name for cholesterol everybody generally large omar have you done well oh i should let that go just to lower the volume okay so halacha number one is remember rabbis divide it down the middle put one half in this drawer another half somewhere else that goes the sanyo as we have before five people that are part of an arab and they put it into two vessels what this guy just did is hero it's not a good air observation if it is a good arrow says the gemara affiliate base that's not very good to say that like we said yesterday that the shot goes according to when everybody knows we passing like distill and everything has to be according to basil oh everything's there go right you guys could see the the nishmas not really i don't see it by me oh you could see it the zoomers don't matter okay fine there's only 111 people on anyway and i don't know officials on even though it doesn't matter as long as official don't tell official okay you'll see it on youtube that's it says this could go according when did they still say it is a good error when you put into them when you try to stuff it into a bag it didn't fit into the bags he took another one are very much the same a person that's macbeth on his and a person that divides his heir into two sweethea if a person says specifically i don't allow him but over here he's not making on the two pieces he divided in half he ruined it he's 50 50. he's not the same thing as 100. but when he's just macbeth the mice he put a whole holiday or a whole pseudo so he says nobody could eat it no it's real that's why i need both cases in a place that you make wine in a winery the bay of zakat um does schmuel actually say that if you divide your ear in half it's not an area of america stop for a second think think about this for a second what would you say if i tell you that we're five guys we're getting together to make air of you all put into my house four suit ice you put into my fifth house and i don't have to i don't have to be part of it why what would you say what's the reason oh who else anybody he says because they're going to eat it in my house anybody else so tomorrow understands i like what you're saying pretty much that's basically the mascara maybe but you understand that the reason is because i have bread in my house it's in a different drawer so i already have it over there you're all going to take your bread put it in drawer number one my bread happens to be drawer number two and therefore you see this idea that the bread doesn't have to be in one place and you wanted to say no it's like a different sparrow my time in the morning it's in my bread drawer i don't have to put i don't take it out of my bread drawer and put it in the drawer of the a-roof that everybody else put it's there no so it's a good ride that it doesn't have to be in the same place no that's not the chat like andrew was saying you don't need bread if you own the house you don't need to be mistaken at all you don't have to provide a meal why because you're providing the house you are there you live there it's like barack love what better thing is i'm over here you order in order for you to be part of my house and be sure that my house you bring a meal to me but i don't have to bring a meal it is my house my time at the cool hockey diary okay you don't need bread everybody comes and lives by me here's a beautiful macholicus what does the heir of accomplish shmuel says eruv meshum we all have ownership in this property how by all putting in a meal we're all part of this a roof so it's a kenyan it's an ownership of so if it's the ownership money is the best way to buy into something so why why is it if so someone gives me a buck he doesn't become part of my a-roof but if he gives me a challah then he becomes part of it isn't money better says can you imagine in those days especially you made a a salary on friday and then you took your money and you bought whatever you need for the whole week so by the time era of time comes around you don't have a you don't have a penny to to put into the push go into there you don't have the money it's not much that people should have the money so may i say do with bread new hair like me but let's say i do have i saved i have i have 25 cents i could i could afford it i'm going to put in there should it work zero sure once i allow you to use cash then people will say oh cash rules cash is king but the other guy won't have the cash but they also deliver a pass and he'll forget that you could do with the bread he'll think oh it makes a lot of sense you need money i don't have money today i'm not making an error voice and people forget about the whole brand thing rabon hey rubens from d-ro no air was not ownership a roof is to reside to live here how do you reside in liver through bread my binayo so what is the difference if i hold that is a kenyan i acquired something now i have ownership or i reside here the difference is if i use a soda you know like arakasana i i pick up a yamaka a handkerchief i go like this kenyan sudar so if i hold the tsukinion i could go like this with a handkerchief but if i hold this to reside nobody lives with a hater you don't consider oh he lives in this house you know why because he has a handkerchief that doesn't if he has a meal here then he resides here so it's a big difference if i hold that it's adira then a handkerchief doesn't work if i hold the king in then it does what instead of what else now if i could afford two meals with less than a pruta so great i have two meals i don't care how much it cost me you could go into the dollar store or whatever and buy like a pretty nice pseudo there i guess i don't know like a lot of candy and that's your sudo it costs you a lot of proof that let's say but you can't necessarily do a kenyan with less than a proto you can't do a kingdom with less and now we're turning the daff and pessimistic sponsored by mark steinberg versus mark are you here right here why is your name mark and not mayor joseph should we do hashem right now and then and sponsored by anonymous aslocko it is for his family to be toro yiddin oh and a cotton smack the other no that's like it's like i'll start the filming tomorrow no no right now we're starting today i met three people yeah i'm gonna i'm gonna join your cheer next when's the next massachusetts no no today me yosef today anyways we caught on and a cotton so cotton could bring a meal from here to there but he can't do a kenyan so therefore there's enough kimono if you didn't catch it we're holding enough and pests on the base on the top we have a problem either way you learn yeah five guys i made a narrow but now they decide they wanna add another concert to the whole mix they wanna they wanna play ball they want the kids to be able to dress up by the other guy the guy on the other side so what do they do when they want to bring it to the next guy one does it for everybody he asks him if i ask one guy should make the kenyan and nobody else whether you hold that a aero is a kenyan how could one guy make a kenyan for everybody else and whether you hold it's to reside how is one guy residing for all his buddies no what's the obvious answer he's a he's just an agent he's not residing for them he he they ask him to do it so he's doing it for them i mean you can make a kenyan for five people for 500 people what's the problem so this is a trick question let's see if you guys know the answer we had to shot them what the mach like is between ribs you could go the the middle guy cannot go to the side but the stock guys could go to the middle or according to the middle guy could go to the side inside go to the middle and so umar now says by the way um which one of these ribs says that the middle guy cannot go to the set to the side guys or the rib shimmer that says the middle guy could go to the sides which doesn't say anything tomorrow it does say in the gemara because it says rav is the one that says this the shemin says you go both ways so according to rav i like this rip shipment says i don't know guy was walking he's trying to get to the city and unfortunately the sun went down on him he knows of a tree he's very familiar with the route and he knows that in the up their head there's a tree so he's gonna say his trick is he's gonna say oh i'm resigned by that tree now from that tree he just hops to the city because that tree is 2000 diamonds away from the city but from where he's at right now this is further than two thousand namus so he won't be able to make it there oh my gloom we're talking about a very large tree 8 ometry 16 feet not so big you know any typical tree here is larger than that the problem is as as we understand from the mishnah there's a way to do it let's just read the next line then we'll understand why this didn't work however if he says if he says he he specifies where he wants to be the problem is that he didn't specify since the trees ate amy's perhaps he meant the adams closest to him of the tree or perhaps he meant the eight armies that are closer to the city so we don't know since we don't know he doesn't get anything if he doesn't get anything we'll see in the gemara what it means exactly let's just say he only gets now four albums he could he's stuck because his arrow meant nothing however if he says specifically i want the bark of the tree i want the actual tree i don't want the shade on the other side of the tree i don't want the shade in this side i want the actual tree oh so now specified so now that's his residence and from there on he can go to the he go to the city two thousand ammo says you guys don't have to go to sleep study what it's only two minutes you know we're gonna skip shift for two minutes you already missed it anyway all right next the series the the perfect arab the most you can get out of here is basically you you what's the word um no i forgot the word you it's right here anyway you did not switch i had it just anyway you take your residence where you are right now and you move it over 2000 ammo in the future by that tree from the tree your 2000 armor starts again but you shift you shift that's what i want that's all i want to say shift you shift your residence you're right here you shifted over here further down the line and then from there you can walk two thousand you're only left two thousand amazon chavez but from where you live and i don't live where i am right now i live under that tree if i could specify a part of that tree then i'm good immediately if you are what we like to call enama rids and you don't know or you don't know the route you know anything about a tree sausage and he says okay so at least where i am should be my mashvisa i'm taking a presence right here thaisis points out on the spot you don't have to say voicemail read the bill i'm here now you'll have to sing for um you just have in mind that this is where you are okay so you take a string you you put a you pitch it exactly where you are you go around a big circle you have two thousand arms and a circle yeah could you see two thousand amis in a circle the blue you guys see the red the pink that i did over here what's the napkin you know because in gemura math which is similar to panovich math the you get 1.4 so if this is 10 amish let's say so from corner to corner it's 14. so what happens is now you have 800 amas extra because you get the corner from the circle to 1800 almost you get 0.4 or more point four is eight hundred dollars right for every thousand you get four hundred amis so now they have two thousand amis you get eight hundred amis so you get from the center to the corner two thousand eight hundred amis we thought you have two thousand almost yes you have two thousand dollars from the guy to the to the flat surface to the to these points is two thousand but to the corner you get an extra eight hundred amis we're gonna beneticular says you only get exactly two thousand elements in all directions in a circle we were boys catavirubas so they can benefit from the corners past the circle now we're going back music and we actually had this word for word allah a poor person meaning someone who doesn't have bread is traveling so he makes an arrow with his feet meaning with his himself he himself is the arab only somebody doesn't have any breath you can have as much food as you want you could say specifically i'm making an error of with myself i don't need bread what better way to make an area than me residing somewhere and saying that's the a-roof room i've been passed why so why do they make bread ella larger somebody could afford it and send the messenger out shalom yatesville viraglov that a guy could send someone his kid out to the desert and say take this role and make my residence over there through the roll but you yourself going out to the desert and putting yourself there it's even better says the gemara just a short little sugar here till the bottom milo when a person says i want to reside under the tree but it doesn't specify what part of the tree the front part of the tree the back part of the tree loyal he didn't accomplish anything oh my rav zero that feels attractive he can't go to any part of the tree in fact he can't go anywhere he cannot move why because he didn't make an error so you can only only has his four hours that a person has why because he didn't if he wouldn't have said anything so he could go where two thousand in every direction but he messed it up he said i want to go over there i'm residing by the tree and the tree doesn't work so you just you also carry me kind of a khan he's bald from both ends he can't move from here because that's not his arrow what he intended to make there by the tree but the tree didn't work because he didn't specify where he gets zero he gets four atoms like any other person attacks okay so it's not as i know you're rushing to sleepless here but hold on a second a boy said what's going on is this follows you got to see this chart it's very important you have a guy little guy over here i don't know if you can see it he's right over here a little guy nah i didn't make the guy i would have made him larger there's a house over here and there's a tree in the center there's 4 000 almost from this guy to the house but exactly exactly four hours from the guide to that and we don't know what part of the tree the the the other side of the tree closer to the house or the part of the tree closer to him says the gemara unbelievable this guy let's say worst case scenario is if he would have made the arrow on the other side of the tree then he has two thousand arms from the red line to the house he can make it there no problem but we don't know that he made the arrow on the red line maybe he made the arrow on the blue line the part of the tree closer to him from that line to the house is more than two thousand armors so what could this guy do he could walk to the house and has to step short five feet in front of his door and he cannot walk in hold on hold on let me just finish it close everybody understands it it's very very important it's a great it's a beautiful sugya let's just say that there's no area in front of his house they can't bring out a bed for him they can't bring out food for him he's stuck in the sun he might be better off to just stay in the in the in by the tree he cannot go home it's awesome to go home he has to stop short the exact distance whatever this tree is five ten feet from his house and that's it why because perhaps his arrow was on the blue line in front of the tree and from in front of the tree to the house is more than 2 000 armors but perhaps his arrow is on the red line and what does that do not going to go home because we have to be cautious that perhaps his arabs on the blue line it ruins it that he cannot go backwards back to his hotel where he started out he can't go this way you see i made a blue line over here there's another blue line he cannot go to this blue line he can't go from the red where he's standing backwards even one inch why because maybe the arrow is on the other side of the tree and from the other side of the tree to where he's at is two thousand almost one step in the opposite direction we started out from going this way to the hotel is more than two thousand hours so he's stuck what is that called i gotta use this picture again because it's the only picture i bought the messenger event hamargamo he's stuck between a a camel and a donkey he can only go from here to here but he can't go back to his hotel this way and he can't go his house that way he's push it stuck let's see it inside and that's it for today you can't get to this house out of the tactics also you go to the bottom of the tree and i'm telling you it even goes to the russia all the way to this house almost five feet before it hasn't stopped and the tree becomes the guy that that leads goes behind the donkey but leads the camel you know he's stuck between a camel and a and a donkey may not suffer if you see in this in this thing it says something over here if he wants to they say no more minadoram you got to measure this way to the from the blue line in other words i cannot get to the house because from the blue line to my house is more than two thousand hours so i'm ahmed okay you know what you want to use the blue line okay i'm going back to my hotel no no no no no no i'm more than one then we'll say no you got to use the red line now and from the red line to the hotel is more than two thousand dollars you gotta stop short where you are you can't go backwards this way rabois you'd filo should be in this cable youtuber should be in this cable have me in mind that i should be able to get back there just for one one day in this coming year and someone's like if anybody has the the the heart for me for my spock and my son should get engaged and and uh remarks son to get engaged and all the the the the girls that i don't have they should all get engaged and we should all hear from rufus and and paranosa in a year of daffy me of toyota every single day tomorrow if you are energized is not for you eric's troll will have a shirt at the regular time at nine o'clock pre-recorded tomorrow morning basically i'm here in chicago 11 15 right here basil will get this internet up and running and uh i'll see you tomorrow because of hashem at 11 15 right here which is the massive daf have a wonderful fast for boys meaningful fast marcus toyota no if you get to this house you let it go wherever you want now that we learned a house is dalaramis doesn't matter how big the house is the whole entire thing is one wondrous turn off youtube okay yeah hold on here just i'll do it joseph is saying tell him